key: cord-0868707-nsucycdn
authors: Levit, Michael; Levit, Leah
title: Infection Risk of COVID-19 in Dentistry Remains Unknown: A Preliminary Systematic Review
date: 2020-09-14
journal: Infect Dis Clin Pract (Baltim Md)
DOI: 10.1097/ipc.0000000000000939
sha: 1178cde9cd9b3a54aa17f1c3d1ac3b6fa28fd0ad
doc_id: 868707
cord_uid: nsucycdn

COVID-19 is a novel viral respiratory disease caused by a member of the coronavirus family, SARS-CoV-2, and has been declared as a pandemic on March 2020. Dental practitioners are routinely exposed to infectious bodily excretions, for example, saliva, blood, and respiratory excretions. Therefore, they are in the first line of SARS-CoV-2 infection-prone health care providers. The purposes of the current review are to trace documented cases of COVID-19 transmission inside dental settings worldwide and to explore the clinical management of these cases. METHODS: We searched MEDLINE and Google Scholar for all possible reported cases of COVID-19 transmission in dental practice as of December 1, 2019, until May 13, 2020. Multiple terms and combinations were used, including “coronavirus,” “COVID-19,” “SARS-CoV-2,” “dental,” “dentistry,” “transmission,” and “nosocomial.” Articles that were not written in English were excluded. RESULTS: A total of 78 articles were found from December 29, 2019, until May 13, 2020. Of these, 31 articles discussed the risks related to dental practice and recommended infection management protocols for dental health care personnel. Of these articles, only 1 had reported data on transmission of COVID-19 in dental practice. Two possible transmissions of COVID-19 to dental personnel were reported in China before its recognition as an epidemic. CONCLUSIONS: Although it seems that there are almost no reported cases of infection by SARS-CoV-2 during dental treatments, occupational or nosocomial transmission could not be ruled out. Hence, further prospective assessment of COVID-19 transmission is urgently required, and careful and protective measurements are necessary to avoid infection during dental practice.

a member of the coronavirus family that originated in Wuhan, Hubei, China, in December 2019. 1 This infectious agent was first named 2019-nCoV and then officially SARS-CoV-2 by the World Health Organization. Over the past few months, the infection has spread to 188 countries and regions worldwide. On March 11, 2020 , the World Health Organization has declared COVID-19 as a pandemic because the number of cases reached more than 118,000. 2 As of May 13, 2020, there have been 4,291,081 laboratory-confirmed cases of COVID-19 worldwide, with 293,157 global deaths and 1,507,598 global recoveries. 3 Given the widespread transmission of SARS-CoV-2 and the reports of its spread to health care providers, 4 dental health care personnel (DHCP) are at most risk for nosocomial infection and can become potential carriers of the disease. 5, 6 SARS-CoV-2 effectively uses angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 receptor for cell invasion. 7 Angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 receptor was found to be expressed in the epithelium of the rhino-respiratory and parts of gastrointestinal tracts, as well as the bladder, myocardial cells, oral mucosa, gingival tissue, and salivary glands. 8, 9 Because salivary gland epithelial cells share the angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 receptor, saliva might potentially become a major source of the virus. 10 Even after patient recovery, recurrence during the convalescence period was reported. 11 This is plausible because the presence of some virus strains in saliva for as long as 29 days has been reported in the literature. 12, 13 The viral loads of SARS-CoV-2 in various human specimens were reported as following: anterior nasal mucosa, 6.1 log 10 copies/mL 14 ; oropharynx, 5.2 log 10 copies/mL 15 ; nasopharynx, 5.4 log 10 copies/mL 16 ; and saliva, 4.1 log 10 copies/mL. 16 The minimum infectious dose for SARS-CoV-2 is yet unknown but guessed to be a few hundreds of virions. 17 Human-to-human transmission of COVID-19 is now believed to be mainly via saliva-associated respiratory droplets and contact transmission. Saliva droplets are generated when breathing, talking, coughing, or sneezing and are formed as particles of moisture and droplet nuclei of microorganisms. 18 Large droplets and splatter (diameter >50-60 μm) tend to fall ballistically to the ground, so the risk of pathogen transmission is limited to individuals in close proximity to the infector (1-2 m). 19, 20 Small droplets (diameter ≤50 μm) are likely to evaporate into droplet nuclei (diameter <10 μm), which sustain in the air for protracted periods, and then become potentially transmitted by air flow over a longer distance as aerosol. 18, 21 After being suspended in the air, the droplets and aerosol continue to pose a risk by settlement on environmental surfaces. 8 COVID-19 might be disseminated by many routes, most of which are, unfortunately, very common in the daily dental practice. Dental and oral surgery drills, as well as ultrasonic devices and the triple syringe, form aerosol and splatter, which are commonly contaminated with bacteria, viruses, fungi, and blood. [22] [23] [24] [25] Moreover, as validated by numerous studies, strong evidence indicates that the severe acute respiratory syndrome virus (SARS) spreads through aerosol transmission. 26 Although not completely understood at this stage, aerosol and fomite transmission of SARS-CoV-2 is plausible as the virus can remain viable and infectious in aerosols for at least 3 hours and on surfaces for days. 27, 28 There is an increasing body of evidence to suggest that human-to-human transmission rate from asymptomatic patients (4.1%) is statistically similar to that from symptomatic patients (6.3%). 29 Alarmingly, emerging data from European countries and the United States point to very high proportions of asymptomatic COVID-19 carriers, estimated to range from 25% to 50% of all confirmed cases. Therefore, asymptomatic and presymptomatic patients are both major sources of SARS-CoV-2 transmission, as they are covert and show no warning signs to health care workers or laypersons at the time of contact. 30 The high airborne infectiveness of SARS-CoV-2 was demonstrated by COVID-19 outbreak on March 2020 in Skagit country, Washington, United States. After a 2.5-hour choir practice attended by 61 persons, 1 minimally symptomatic choir member transmitted SARS-CoV-2 to as many as 52 other choir members even though most of the people were at least 2 m apart. 31 There are currently no data available to validate the level of risk of SARS-CoV-2 transmission during dental practice, nor literature to support whether DHCP are adequately protected by current proposed protective equipment. 5 Necessarily, the purposes of the current article are to review documented transmission of COVID-19 in dental settings and to review the reported risks of COVID-19 transmission to DHCP and to visitors of dental facilities.

We conducted a comprehensive literature search, using MEDLINE and Google Scholar, to find all possible reported cases of any form of COVID-19 transmission in dental practice. The search covered the period from December 1, 2019, until May 13, 2020. We used a combination of the following search terms: (coronavirus or COVID-19 or SARS-CoV-2) with (dentistry or dental) with (transmission or nosocomial). Because the available clinical data on COVID-19 transmission in dental settings are scarce, all articles that matched the search terms were full-text retrieved. The terms "transmission" and "nosocomial" as well as "contract," "contagion," "infect," and "case" were sought in the text of each article with the purpose of identifying documented cases of COVID-19 transmission in dentistry. Moreover, each article was sought for any other appropriate relevancy. Efforts were made to exclude from Google Scholar articles that were already retrieved by MEDLINE, to avoid an overlap between results. Non-English written articles were excluded; however, their abstracts were examined for relevancy.

A total of 78 articles matched the search terms and were included in the current review ( Fig. 1 ). Ten articles were not relevant to dentistry. These irrelevant articles incidentally appeared on search because of inclusion of the word "dentistry" in the affiliation of their authors or because "dentistry" or "dental" were encountered for some other reasons. There were 62 articles that were relevant to either dentistry or oral surgery fields and were full-text retrieved and further analyzed and traced for reports on COVID-19 transmission. Only 1 article had an actual report on COVID-19 transmission in dental practice. All possible relevant data on COVID-19 transmission that were retrieved from all the analyzed articles are summarized in Table 1 .

The current article has systematically reviewed literature available on COVID-19 transmission in dental settings and found no reported cases of transmission since its declaration as a pandemic. Also, no experimental or epidemiological studies considering dental occupational COVID-19 transmission were found. Meng et al anecdotally reported 9 cases of COVID-19 transmissions to DHCP who were using standard precautions in China, before quarantine on Wuhan region was imposed. 32 Of these 9 cases, only 2 could not be excluded to be caused by occupational 33 reported the measures of COVID-19 prevention in Italy; however, they could not conclude whether these measures were efficient enough to prevent COVID-19 transmission. Also, they did not report if any transmission had actually occurred. These findings are surprising, knowing that health care workers were highly infected with COVID-19, as documented in numerous studies. [34] [35] [36] The absence of documented cases of COVID-19 transmission in dental practice since its recognition as a pandemic should be interpreted with great caution, as dental practitioners appear on worldwide reports of deaths from COVID-19. As of May 12, 2020, Medscape honored 1012 health workers who have already died of COVID-19, regardless whether they were practicing and whether infection control tracing was done. 37 Of them, 22 were DHCP: 20 dentists, 1 dental nurse, and 1 dental technician; 13 dentists were from Italy and 7 were aged 48 to 78 years (with an average of 66 years) (the age of the other 6 dentists was not reported). As of March 2019, most dentists in Italy were aged 20 to 60 years (88.88%). 38, 39 The mortality rate in this age group from COVID-19 is much lower (0.1%-2.7%) than in the general population of Italy (13.7%). 40 This may explain why only 13 dentists were reported to die of COVID-19, but this may also lead to an alarming possibility that a much higher number of dentists were infected but not reported, despite very high level of personal protective equipment (PPE) adopted in Italy (Table 1) . Although Medscape's report includes cases of death not directly resulting of COVID-19, still, these data strongly suggest that at least several dentists might have contracted COVID-19 during dental practice. However, in the clinical setting of a dental practice, droplet exposure is so prevalent that the number of deaths might have been underreported.

Past evidence has shown that most of SARS-CoV and MERS-CoV cases were associated with nosocomial transmission in hospitals, resulting, partly, from use of aerosol-generating procedures performed on patients with respiratory diseases. 41 Interestingly, it is reassuring that, to date, there have been no documented cases of SARS transmission in dental settings. This can result from several factors, unique for SARS and MERS, but absent in COVID-19; first, SARS and MERS transmission has not been Second, it is unlikely that patients with SARS or MERS would visit a dentist for an elective treatment while they were in the acute phase of the disease, because of high fever and other, rather debilitating, attendant symptoms. 42 Third, based on current epidemiological data, COVID-19 has higher transmissibility than SARS-CoV and MERS-CoV, 11 with up to 44% of COVID-19 transmissions occurring at the presymptomatic stage. 43 Hence, it is plausible that COVID-19 transmission would occur in dental settings, unlike past evidence with SARS and MERS. Several techniques are aimed at preventing COVID-19 transmission in dental settings. These techniques include the use of best possible PPE, allowing fresh air in between patients, meticulous hand hygiene, and sterilization procedures aimed at inactivating, destroying, or removing pathogens from any surface or instruments. 20 Because small particles in aerosol might remain suspended in indoor environments for 3 to 4 hours, a good ventilation or air conditioning system in dental offices may be as important as PPE. In addition, COVID-19 screening questionnaires are completed and patient's body temperature is measured before any dental visit. In cases other than emergencies, all patients with any symptom consistent with COVID-19, positive testing, or potential previous exposure are deferred for at least 2 weeks. 4 Previsit screening of COVID-19 by nasal swab or antibody analysis was also suggested. 44 Control of fomite transmission of SARS-CoV-2 presents a tremendous challenge in dentistry because of a combination of high variety of materials commonly used in dental routine, with a prolonged and variable temporal decay of the viral inoculum (Table 2) . 23, 24, 45, 46 Inadequate disinfection of surfaces or unnoticeable contamination of dental supply (ie, secretions, aerosol) presents an additional unexpected threat of COVID-19 transmission. However, the existing data on surface persistence are based on experimental conditions only and do not necessarily reflect all clinical situations, particularly in dentistry.

To date, the most common strategy to manage suspected COVID-19 transmission in dental practice was to quarantine the potentially infected persons for as long as 14 days and to report health authorities. This may also be referred to as the "watch and see" strategy, unlike very dedicated guidelines of assessment and prevention in cases of exposure to other well-known infectious agents, like HIV. 47 A more dedicated risk assessment should be adopted, based on clinical experience and evidence of COVID-19 transmission. Therefore, an urgent need for systematic collection, analysis, and publication of the exact occurrence of COVID-19 transmission in dentistry is required. Similar demand on analysis and publication of COVID-19 transmission and death cases in other health care workforces was already highlighted. 35 For this reason, we propose a tentative prospective protocol for tracing COVID-19 transmission in dental settings (Fig. 2) .

The risk of a dental practitioner being positive for COVID-19 and potentially infecting patients, accompanies, and other DHCPs should not be underestimated. The theoretical risk of SARS-CoV-2 transmission in dentistry is significant and justifies fairly stringent airborne precautions. A constant source of COVID-19 infection in dental settings might create a micro epicenter with many potential infectees, until the source is traced through epidemiological investigation. According to the current available evidence, the potential risk to DHCP from occupational exposures has not been adequately assessed by epidemiologic studies in health care setting and should be further investigated.

China coronavirus: WHO declares international emergency as death toll exceeds 200

World Health Organization. WHO director-general's opening remarks at the media briefing on COVID-19

Coronavirus disease 19 (COVID-19): implications for clinical dental care

Guidance for dental settings

The New York Times. The workers who face the greatest coronavirus risk

A pneumonia outbreak associated with a new coronavirus of probable bat origin

Saliva: potential diagnostic value and transmission of 2019-nCoV

High expression of ACE2 receptor of 2019-nCoVon the epithelial cells of oral mucosa

Epithelial cells lining salivary gland ducts are early target cells of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus infection in the upper respiratory tracts of rhesus macaques

Recurrence of positive SARS-CoV-2 RNA in COVID-19: a case report

Infection dynamics in a traveller with persistent shedding of Zika virus RNA in semen for six months after returning from Haiti to Italy

Postnatal identification of Zika virus peptides from saliva

Detection of SARS-CoV-2 in different types of clinical specimens

Temporal profiles of viral load in posterior oropharyngeal saliva samples and serum antibody responses during infection by SARS-CoV-2: an observational cohort study

Comparison of SARS-CoV-2 detection in nasopharyngeal swab and saliva

It's not whether you were exposed to the virus. It's how much

Guidelines for infection control in dental health-care settings-2003

Factors involved in the aerosol transmission of infection and control of ventilation in healthcare premises

The severe acute respiratory syndrome Coronavirus-2 (SARS CoV-2) in dentistry. Management of biological risk in dental practice

Characterization of infectious aerosols in health care facilities: an aid to effective engineering controls and preventive strategies

Dental bioaerosol as an occupational hazard in a dentist's workplace

High incidence of blood exposure due to imperceptible contaminated splatters during oral surgery

Detection of visually imperceptible blood contamination in the oral surgical clinic using forensic luminol blood detection agent

Dentistry and coronavirus (COVID-19)-moral decision-making

Aerosol transmission of infectious disease

Stability of SARS-CoV-2 in different environmental conditions

Aerosol and surface stability of SARS-CoV-2 as compared with SARS-CoV-1

Epidemiological characteristics of infection in COVID-19 close contacts in Ningbo city

Dental care and oral health under the clouds of COVID-19

High SARS-CoV-2 attack rate following exposure at a choir practice

Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19): emerging and future challenges for dental and oral medicine

COVID-19 transmission in dental practice: brief review of preventive measures in Italy

Protecting our health care workers while protecting our communities during the COVID-19 pandemic: a comparison of approaches and 294 early outcomes in two Italian regions

Deaths in healthcare workers due to COVID-19: the need for robust data and analysis

COVID-19: protecting health-care workers

memoriam: healthcare workers who have died of COVID-19. 2020. Available at

Number of male dentists in Italy in 2019, by age groups

Number of female dentists in Italy in 2019, by age groups

COVID-19) death rate in Italy as of

Transmission characteristics of MERS and SARS in the healthcare setting: a comparative study

Severe acute respiratory syndrome and dentistry: a retrospective view

Temporal dynamics in viral shedding and transmissibility of COVID-19

Rapid detection of SARS-CoV-2 in saliva: can an endodontist take the lead in point-of-care COVID-19 testing?

Persistence of coronaviruses on inanimate surfaces and their inactivation with biocidal agents

Human coronavirus 229E remains infectious on common touch surface materials

Updated U.S. public health service guidelines for the management of occupational exposures to HIV and recommendations for postexposure prophylaxis

Infection Risk of COVID-19 in Dentistry