key: cord-0858285-lgb1r7se
authors: Sarai Racey, C.; Donken, Robine; Porter, Imogen; Albert, Arianne; Bettinger, Julie A.; Mark, Jennifer; Bonifacio, Lizl; Dawar, Meena; Gagel, Mike; Kling, Rakel; Mema, Silvina; Mitchell, Hana; Roe, Ian; Ogilvie, Gina; Sadarangani, Manish
title: Intentions of Public School Teachers in British Columbia, Canada to Receive a COVID-19 Vaccine
date: 2021-06-29
journal: Vaccine X
DOI: 10.1016/j.jvacx.2021.100106
sha: 8099ceb2c13822e4407a27721e68fcd617693b0c
doc_id: 858285
cord_uid: lgb1r7se

BACKGROUND: To control the COVID-19 pandemic high vaccine acceptability and uptake will be needed. Teachers represent a priority population to minimize social disruption and ensure continuity in education, which is vital for the well-being and healthy development of youth during the pandemic. The objective of this analysis was to measure public school teachers’ intentions to receive a COVID-19 vaccine in British Columbia (BC), Canada. METHODS: A population-wide cross-sectional online survey from August to November 2020 asked all BC public school teachers with an available email address how likely they were to receive a COVID-19 vaccine. Two multivariable logistic regression models explored separately sociodemographic and vaccine hesitancy predictors for intention to receive a COVID-19 vaccine. RESULTS: A total of 5,076 teachers participated. The majority, 89.6%, reported they were likely or very likely to accept a COVID-19 vaccine. In multivariable regression, sociodemographic predictors of intention to be vaccinated included being male, having an educational background in science or engineering, and using reliable information sources on vaccination such as public health and health care providers. Teachers who reported lower levels of vaccine hesitancy, higher general vaccine knowledge, and belief that COVID-19 was a serious illness were more likely to intend to receive a COVID-19 vaccine. CONCLUSION: A high proportion of public-school teachers in BC intend to receive a COVID-19 vaccine. Continued monitoring of vaccine intentions will be important to inform public health vaccine implementation.

Deployment of safe and effective vaccines will ultimately be required to control the pandemic.

Initial approvals of COVID-19 vaccines were granted by regulatory bodies 1 in December 2020, with multiple additional vaccine candidates under evaluation 3 . The impact of vaccination to protect both individuals and communities, and allow social and economic activities to return, will only be possible with a comprehensive vaccine delivery program and high vaccine acceptance. Initial priority for COVID-19 vaccination programs have focused on high-risk populations to minimize mortality and serious illness from COVID-19, with a secondary goal of limiting societal disruption as a result of the pandemic, while ensuring efficient, effective, and equitable allocation of vaccine 4 .

The initial phase of COVID-19 vaccine rollout has focused predominantly on residents and staff of long-term care homes and health-care workers 5 . In BC, the mass general population COVID-19 immunization program will be conducted largely based on age cohorts from oldest to youngest 5 .

With the goal of minimizing societal disruption and reducing inequities as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic, educators, specifically teachers, are a distinct population, given the role school structure plays in the well-being of youth and the economy 6 . School closures and the transition to distance learning during the initial wave of the pandemic had significant negative impacts on income, mental health and learning for families and youth 7 , disproportionately impacting low-income families, and those requiring essential supports coordinated through the public-school system 6, 8, 9 . Despite many public schools in Canada remaining open during the second wave of the pandemic, exposure events and quarantine guidelines have continued to be disruptive for teachers, students, and families. High acceptance of a COVID-19 vaccine among teachers will be important to minimizing disruptions to schooling, and ensure the safety of teachers, especially those at high-risk for severe illness due to COVID-19. A focus on the uptake in teachers is also important given that COVID-19 vaccines have not yet been approved for children, and given vaccine roll-out to date, children may be the last to receive a vaccine against COVID-19.

The objective of this analysis was to measure BC teachers' intentions to accept a COVID-19 vaccine, and factors associated with acceptance, to inform COVID-19 vaccination programs.

All elementary and secondary public school teachers in BC with an available public email address on a school district website from June -July, 2020 were invited to participate in an online survey through individual email invitations from August 20th to November 3rd, 2020.

Administrative and non-teacher support staff were excluded, based on school website information. Respondents provided informed consent, and were invited to participate in a draw for gift cards. A maximum of two reminder invitations were sent one week apart to nonresponders.

Survey items were developed using available literature and previous surveys, in addition to elicitation from experts on vaccine hesitancy and acceptability (MS, GO, JAB, HM).

Sociodemographic items included sex, gender, and geographical location based on postal code.

Educational training background was assessed based on the selection of one or more broad discipline categories. Indigenous ancestry and visible minority categories were based on the Statistics Canada 2016 census. Vaccine hesitancy was measured using the validated 9-item Vaccine Hesitancy Scale (VHS), which was developed by the WHO's Strategic Advisory Group of Experts (SAGE) Working Group on vaccine hesitancy 10, 11 . The VHS is focused on general childhood vaccines and assesses vaccine hesitancy based on two separate factors: lack of confidence in and perceived risks of vaccines. Respondents were asked about past vaccination experience, sources for general vaccine information (e.g. public health, government websites, school district or BC teacher's union, general news sources, social media, friends or colleagues), and general vaccine knowledge was measured using a modified scale 12 . The primary outcome of intention to receive a future COVID-19 vaccine was measured on a 5-point Likert-scale from very unlikely to very likely in response to the question: "If a safe and effective COVID-19 vaccine were to become available to the public, and recommended for you, how likely are you to receive it?". At the time of survey administration, vaccine product characteristics were not available. Respondents were also asked if they believed COVID-19 was a serious illness. Survey invitation and items included in this analysis appear in appendix 1 and 2.

The survey was piloted tested with four current public-school teachers and members of the study team for face validity, length, and navigational ease. The survey was administered using the secure web-based software platform REDCap 13 . Ethics approval was received from the University of British Columbia's Research Ethics Board (H20-01820).

A minimum sample size of 2,400 was needed to achieve an 80% power to estimate a population proportion of 0.5 (with 95%CI) for intent to vaccinate, with a 2% margin of error. We invited all public school teachers in BC with a publicly available email to participate. Completed surveys were those that were submitted as complete by the respondent. Partial surveys were those that initiated the survey but did not submit the survey as complete. Email addresses that were auto-returned as undeliverable, or no longer active, were considered invalid. Response rate (%) was the sum of completed surveys plus partial surveys, divided by the number of invitations send to respondents with valid email addresses, as per the American Association for Public Opinion Research guidelines 14 .

Representativeness of respondents was examined through comparison to the reported distribution of male/female and age cohorts of teachers in BC 15 , and based on population distribution among the five geographical provincial health authorities 16 .

The primary outcome of 'intention to accept a future COVID-19 vaccine' was dichotomized from the 5-point Likert scale to focus on those who intend to vaccinate.

Participants responding likely and very likely to receive a COVID-19 vaccine were categorized as 'yes, intend to accept a COVID-19 vaccine' compared to those who reported neutral, unlikely and very unlikely to accept a COVID-19 vaccine. The dichotomization was done to focus on those with intent to vaccinate, and neutrals were assigned to bias results to the null.

Vaccine hesitancy was calculated as mean scores (range of 1 to 5) for both factors of the VHS, which included the 7-item lack of confidence in vaccines factor (reverse scored) and the 2-item risk of vaccines factor 14 . Scale item reliability was assessed using Cronbach's α (>0.6 good agreement) for the VHS factors. General vaccine knowledge scale was measured as a grand score to 5-items (true/false, for a range of 0-5) that achieved >0.6 on the Kuder -Richardson formula (KR20) for reliability. More than one visible minority identity was allowed, and so each visible minority group was summarized separately. A separate dichotomized variable (visible minority yes/no) was included in the analysis, which included anyone who selected one or more visible minorities or identified as Indigenous.

Only surveys submitted as complete were included. Missing data was assessed and complete case analysis was conducted due to less than <10% missing.

All statistical analyses were completed in R v.4.0.2. 17 . Factors associated with intention to accept a future COVID-19 vaccine were explored using Fisher's Exact Tests for categorical variables and Kruskal-Wallis tests for continuous variables, using case-wise deletion for missing data. Two multivariable logistic regression models explored predictors for intention to accept a COVID-19 vaccine. The first model explored socio-demographic and behavioural predictors of vaccine intention that could be applied in public health practice (a priori variables included age, sex, identifying as a visible minority, educational training background, prior vaccine delay or refusal, and the use of reliable sources for vaccine information). The second model explored intention to receive a COVID-19 vaccine based the psychological measures of general vaccine hesitancy, belief COVID-19 was a serious illness, and general vaccine knowledge. For both models, a priori variables for predictors of positive vaccine acceptance that reached p<0.10 in bivariable analysis were included.

A total of 29,184 email addresses were identified on public school board websites for the estimated 45,000 BC public school teachers 18 . All identified teachers were sent email invitations, of which 1,072 were deemed invalid due to automated undeliverable or inactive accounts. Of the 28, 112 teachers with valid email addresses, we received 5,725 responses (20.4%), of which 5,095 (88.9%) submitted a complete survey. Almost all completed surveys (5,076, 99.6%) reported how likely they are to receive COVID-19 vaccine. Respondents were representative of the overall BC teaching population, which were comparable based on comparable distribution of sex and age to the current workforce 15, 19 (Supplementary Table A) , and population distribution among the five geographical health regions 16 . Two of the school districts did not display public email address, and we had respondents recorded from 58/60 public school boards across the province.

The majority of respondents, 89.7% (4,551/5,076), reported they were likely or very likely to accept a COVID-19 vaccine (Figure 1) , and 89.2% reported never having delayed or refused any vaccination in the past ( Table 1 ). The majority of respondents reporting seeking general vaccine information from reliable information sources: public health (78.1%), government websites (63.6%), and health care providers (57.3%). 40.7% of respondents reported professional organizations such as school boards or the teacher's union as a source of vaccine information. Few respondents reported seeking general information about vaccines from social media (4.4%).

In bivariable analysis, factors associated with intent to accept a COVID-19 vaccine included being male; never having personally delayed or refused a vaccine, and having reported an educational background in science or engineering. Those who reported seeking vaccine information from reliable sources such as public health, health care providers, and the school board or teachers' union, were more likely to intend to accept COVID-19 vaccination. There was no significant association between vaccine intention and age or visible minority status.

Respondents who intended to accept a COVID-19 vaccine had lower scores on the VHS factors (i.e. were less vaccine hesitant), had higher general vaccine knowledge, and were more likely to report COVID-19 being a serious illness ( When looking at predictors of intention to accept a COVID-19 vaccine based on the psychological measures (Table 3) , for vaccine hesitancy, as the lack of confidence in vaccines increased there was an association with decreased vaccine intention (OR=0.5, 95% CI 0.44-0.58), which was similar to perceived risk of vaccination, in which an increase in perceived risk of vaccines was associated with a decreased vaccine intention (OR=0.36, 95% CI 0.31-0.42).

Predictors of intent to vaccinate included an increase in general vaccine knowledge (OR=1.58, 95% CI 1.38-1.80) and belief that COVID-19 was a serious illness (OR=5.79, 95% CI 4.09-

Assessing intention to be vaccinated is a vital step towards ensuring optimal implementation of COVID-19 vaccines. Our analysis found the majority (89.7%) of public school teachers in BC intend to accept a COVID-19 vaccine that is safe, effective, and recommended for them, with 69.5% (95%CI 68.2% -70.8%) reporting they would be very likely to get a COVID-19 vaccine.

Vaccine intention in teachers was higher compared to recent national data, which found only 55.5% (95%CI 49.2 -61.6%) of the general BC population reported being very likely to receive a COVID-19 vaccine 20 .

Females comprise approximately 72% of the teaching workforce in BC 15 , and despite our finding that females are less likely to accept a COVID-19 vaccine, overall intention for teachers to accept a COVID-19 vaccine remained >85%. Being male has been previously reported as a positive predictor for COVID-19 vaccine intentions 21, 22 , where as being female has been a identified as a predictor of vaccine hesitancy for the COVID-19 vaccine 23 . Sex differences in vaccine intention may be related to the initial COVID-19 clinical characteristic reports identifying males as more likely to experience severe COVID-19 illness and death 24, 25 .

In addition, participants who are pregnant, or intend to become pregnant, maybe less likely to accept a COVID-19 vaccine, given the lack of available information at the time of the survey regarding vaccine characterization in pregnancy.

In this highly educated population, having formal education in science or engineering was found to be an independent significant predictor of vaccine intention. In BC, registered teachers are required to have a bachelor in education degree, with many obtaining a prior bachelor degree in another discipline. Those with an educational background in science or engineering were analyzed together compared to those without educational training in a scientific discipline, as globally, science education has been observed to be an important factor for both confidence in vaccines and uptake 26 .

Using reliable sources of information such as public health, health care providers, and school boards or teachers' union were found to be predictors of vaccine intent. Having a direct recommendation from a health care provider has been previously found to be a key mediator in vaccine acceptance 27, 28 , and may improve COVID-19 vaccine uptake. 29 Public health and health care providers should be key communicators about COVID-19 vaccines, and the risk of COVID-19. However, we also observed information from professional organizations, such as the school board or teachers' union, may be another communication avenue for targeting public health messaging for teachers.

Those who measured as more vaccine hesitant, regarding confidence in vaccines or perceived risks of vaccines, as well as reporting a previous delay or refusal of a vaccine, were less likely to intend to accept a COVID-19 vaccine. Having an increased perceived risk of vaccines was strongly associated with not intending to receive a COVID-19 vaccine, indicating that communication about COVID-19 vaccines should focus on the safety profile and contextualize vaccine risk. Being transparent about the vaccine development, approval processes and safety monitoring may help address concerns for those individuals that are specifically hesitant towards new vaccines 30 . It is important to note that the VHS has a focus on known childhood vaccines, specifically the factor related to vaccine confidence. Given the COVID-19 vaccine at the time of the study was an unknown and new vaccine, it is understandable that vaccine intention was more strongly associated with perceived risk of new vaccines.

As with any survey, our findings may be impacted by non-response bias; however, we had over 5,000 respondents from a population-wide survey, which exceeded our minimum sample size, and were representative of the BC teaching population based on sex 15 , and population distribution between the five geographical health regions in BC 16 . Given the study was conducted by a research institute that promotes the benefits of vaccination, there is the potential that those who refused participation in the study were more vaccine hesitant, or were vaccine deniers. The potential for a selective sample of those who are more supportive of vaccination, may have led to an overestimation of vaccine intention amongst BC teachers, resulting in the predictors of vaccine intention being valid only for those who are more likely to support vaccination. However, ardent vaccine deniers are estimated to be a small minority of the population 31 , it is doubtful that non-response from this small sub-population would greatly influence our findings.

Vaccine intention was measured at a single time point before the second wave and prior to vaccine approval or availability of vaccine product information. Intention to vaccinate may change in response to the dynamic nature of the pandemic, and so continued monitoring of vaccine acceptance will be important to ensure vaccination programs are responsive to any changes in vaccine intention 32 .

This analysis contributes to our understanding of vaccination intention towards a COVID-19 vaccine in teachers, with over 85% of school teachers in BC intending to accept a COVID-19

vaccine. Continuing to communicate about vaccines, vaccine safety, transmission rates and severity of COVID-19, will be important in the planning and continued roll out of vaccine programs, and should include targeted communication through teachers' professional organizations and school districts. Understanding intentions and monitoring of vaccine uptake in the initial phases of vaccine rollout, will set the stage and tone for wide-scale vaccination role out as supply meets demand.

The study was supported by the BC Immunization Committee. We wish to thank Kim Marty and Caitlyn Southey for assistance with study and data management. Notes: * Cronbach's α for VHS Lack of confidence in vaccines, α = 0.94; ** Cronbach's α for VHS vaccine risk α = 0.67; *** General vaccine knowledge 5-items Kuder -Richardson formula (KR20) = 0.63. 

Regulatory Decision Summary -Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 Vaccine -Health Canada. Health Canada

Draft Landscape of COVID-19 Candidate Vaccines

Safety and Efficacy of the BNT162b2 mRNA Covid-19 Vaccine

BC's plan for vaccine distribution as of

Mental health effects of school closures during COVID-19

British Columbia Centre for Disease Control and BC Children's Hospital. Impact of School Closures on Learning , Child and Family Well-Being During the COVID-19 Pandemic

Mitigating the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic response on At-risk children

COVID-19, school closures, and child poverty: a social crisis in the making

The vaccine hesitancy scale: Psychometric properties and validation. Vaccine

Measuring vaccine hesitancy: The development of a survey tool

Measuring people's knowledge about vaccination: Developing a onedimensional scale

Research electronic data capture (REDCap)-A metadata-driven methodology and workflow process for providing translational research informatics support

Standard Definitions Final Dispositions of Case Codes and Outcome Rates for Surveys

British Columbia Teachers' Federation. Percentage of Female Teachers in BC over Time School Year.; 2004. 16. Government of British Columbia. British Columbia Population Estimates. BCStats

The R Project for Statistical Computing

British Columbia Teachers' Federation. 19. DataBC. British Columbia Public School Teacher Statistics

Canadians ' willingness to get a COVID-19 vaccine : Group differences and reasons for vaccine hesitancy

Vaccine hesitancy: the next challenge in the fight against COVID-19

Acceptance of covid-19 vaccination during the covid-19 pandemic in china

Psychological characteristics associated with COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy and resistance in Ireland and the United Kingdom

Clinical features of patients infected with 2019 novel coronavirus in Wuhan

Case-Fatality Rate and Characteristics of Patients Dying in Relation to COVID-19 in Italy

Mapping global trends in vaccine confidence and investigating barriers to vaccine uptake: a large-scale retrospective temporal modelling study

Provider recommendation mediates the relationship between parental human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccine awareness and HPV vaccine initiation and completion among 13-to 17-year-old US adolescent children

A population-based evaluation of a publicly funded, school-based HPV vaccine program in British Columbia, Canada: Parental factors associated with HPV vaccine receipt

A National Survey Assessing SARS-CoV-2 Vaccination Intentions: Implications for Future Public Health Communication Efforts

Public Health Agency of Canada. Vaccine Coverage in Canadian Children: Results from the

Intention to vaccinate against COVID-19 in Australia

Prefer not to answer/missing 95 1.87 The study is being conducted by the Vaccine Evaluation Center of the BC Children's Hospital and has been approved by the Research Ethics Board at the University of British Columbia.As a teacher in British Columbia, you play an important role in the lives and well-being of your students and their families.We wish to learn more about the knowledge, attitudes, and beliefs of BC teachers towards immunizations and their experience with the BC school-based immunization program.You are invited to participate in an online survey as part of a research study entitled: An exploration of the confidence, knowledge, attitudes and practices of British Columbian teachers towards immunization. This study is one of the first to investigate this important topic.This survey is being sent to all teachers in British Columbia with publicly identifiable professional email addresses. Your email address was obtained from the school district or school website.This survey will take about 10 -15 minutes to complete.Before you begin the survey, you will be provided with additional information about the study and asked to provide consent.We are offering a raffle for 20 $100 gift cards. If you would like to be considered for the raffle you can provide your email address at the end of this survey.If you would like more information about the Vaccine Evaluation Center of the BC Children's Hospital please visit: https://www.bcchr.ca/vecWe thank you for your consideration and contribution to this important research! Sincerely, The next questions will ask you about your knowledge of immunizations and the school-based immunization program. There are no right or wrong answers, please answer to the best of your knowledge.

All questions in this section answered as either "TRUE" or "FALSE". a. Immunizations are effective at preventing diseases b. It is safer to get immunized than to get a disease c.