key: cord-0857861-yh50yxg0
authors: Mthembu, Thobeka P.; Zishiri, Oliver T.; El Zowalaty, Mohamed E.
title: Genomic Characterization of Antimicrobial Resistance in Food Chain and Livestock-Associated Salmonella Species
date: 2021-03-18
journal: Animals (Basel)
DOI: 10.3390/ani11030872
sha: eecec564ba772f2c8c74fb54d16c89b2b2031c78
doc_id: 857861
cord_uid: yh50yxg0

SIMPLE SUMMARY: In the era of the COVID-19 global pandemic, antimicrobial resistance is looming as an imminent threat and challenge to human public health. Antimicrobial resistance is a major global threat of increasing concern to human and animal health. It also has implications for both food safety and food security and the economic well-being of millions of humans. Among other zoonotic infectious diseases, antimicrobial resistance in food chain and livestock-associated pathogens such as Salmonella is of great concern. In the present study, the genomic characterization of antimicrobial resistance in food chain and livestock-associated Salmonella was summarized. Several antimicrobial resistance determinants were reported in Salmonella isolated from food chain animals and livestock. Monitoring of antimicrobial resistance in Salmonella in livestock and food chain animals through genomic characterization is significant to control and protect humans from the threat of antimicrobial resistance. Salmonella, a foodborne zoonotic enterobacterium species can transmit antimicrobial resistance from the microbiome of animals to humans. This study summarizes the genomic characterization of antimicrobial resistance in Salmonella species with special focus on resistance against carbapenems and colistin which are the last resort antibiotics used against infections caused by multidrug resistant bacteria. The present review aims to draw attention to prudent use of antibiotics, a good example of the One Health concept. ABSTRACT: The rising trend of antimicrobial resistance (AMR) by foodborne bacteria is a public health concern as these pathogens are easily transmitted to humans through the food chain. Non-typhoid Salmonella spp. is one of the leading foodborne pathogens which infect humans worldwide and is associated with food and livestock. Due to the lack of discovery of new antibiotics and the pressure exerted by antimicrobial resistance in the pharmaceutical industry, this review aimed to address the issue of antibiotic use in livestock which leads to AMR in Salmonella. Much attention was given to resistance to carbapenems and colistin which are the last-line antibiotics used in cases of multi drug resistant bacterial infections. In the present review, we highlighted data published on antimicrobial resistant Salmonella species and serovars associated with livestock and food chain animals. The importance of genomic characterization of carbapenem and colistin resistant Salmonella in determining the relationship between human clinical isolates and food animal isolates was also discussed in this review. Plasmids, transposons, and insertion sequence elements mediate dissemination of not only AMR genes but also genes for resistance to heavy metals and disinfectants, thus limiting the therapeutic options for treatment and control of Salmonella. Genes for resistance to colistin (mcr-1 to mcr-9) and carbapenem (blaVIM-1, blaDNM-1, and blaNDM-5) have been detected from poultry, pig, and human Salmonella isolates, indicating food animal-associated AMR which is a threat to human public health. Genotyping, plasmid characterization, and phylogenetic analysis is important in understanding the epidemiology of livestock-related Salmonella so that measures of preventing foodborne threats to humans can be improved.

Simple Summary: In the era of the COVID-19 global pandemic, antimicrobial resistance is looming as an imminent threat and challenge to human public health. Antimicrobial resistance is a major global threat of increasing concern to human and animal health. It also has implications for both food safety and food security and the economic well-being of millions of humans. Among other zoonotic infectious diseases, antimicrobial resistance in food chain and livestock-associated pathogens such as Salmonella is of great concern. In the present study, the genomic characterization of antimicrobial resistance in food chain and livestock-associated Salmonella was summarized. Several antimicrobial resistance determinants were reported in Salmonella isolated from food chain animals and livestock. Monitoring of antimicrobial resistance in Salmonella in livestock and food chain animals through genomic characterization is significant to control and protect humans from the threat of antimicrobial resistance. Salmonella, a foodborne zoonotic enterobacterium species can transmit antimicrobial resistance from the microbiome of animals to humans. This study summarizes the genomic characterization of antimicrobial resistance in Salmonella species with special focus on resistance against carbapenems and colistin which are the last resort antibiotics used against infections caused by multidrug resistant bacteria. The present review aims to draw attention to prudent use of antibiotics, a good example of the One Health concept.

The rising trend of antimicrobial resistance (AMR) by foodborne bacteria is a public health concern as these pathogens are easily transmitted to humans through the food chain. Non-typhoid Salmonella spp. is one of the leading foodborne pathogens which infect humans worldwide and is associated with food and livestock. Due to the lack of discovery of new antibiotics and the pressure exerted by antimicrobial resistance in the pharmaceutical industry, this review aimed to address the issue of antibiotic use in livestock which leads to AMR in Salmonella. Much attention was given to resistance to carbapenems and colistin which are the last-line antibiotics used in cases of multi drug resistant bacterial infections. In the present review, we highlighted data published on antimicrobial resistant Salmonella species and serovars associated with livestock and food chain animals. The importance of genomic characterization of carbapenem and colistin resistant Salmonella in determining the relationship between human clinical isolates and food animal isolates was also discussed in this review. Plasmids, transposons, and insertion sequence elements mediate dissemination of not only AMR genes but also genes for resistance to heavy metals and disinfectants, thus limiting the therapeutic options for treatment and control of Salmonella. Genes for resistance to colistin (mcr-1 to mcr-9) and carbapenem (blaVIM-1, blaDNM-1, and blaNDM-5) have been detected from poultry, pig, and human Salmonella isolates, indicating food animal-associated AMR which is a threat to human public health. Genotyping, plasmid characterization, and phylogenetic analysis is important in understanding the epidemiology of livestock-related Salmonella so that measures of preventing foodborne threats to humans can be improved.

Antimicrobial resistance continues to be a challenge to public health due to the everrising trends of multi-drug resistant bacterial isolates in clinical settings. Antimicrobial resistance is propagated by the improper administration of antibiotics in human medicine however, the agricultural sector, through animal husbandry, is the origin of antimicrobial resistance and the major contributor of antimicrobial resistance pathogens to humans. Overuse of antimicrobial agents in livestock led to the emergence of drug resistant bacteria which constitute part of the gut microbiota. Antibiotic administration should be based on susceptibility results of the causative bacteria. The food chain is the main route in which foodborne pathogens such as non-typhoidal Salmonella spp. are transmitted from animals to humans.

Colistin and carbapenems are critical antibiotics in human medicine which are used to treat multiple drug resistant (MDR) bacterial infections. Due to reported resistance to these antibiotics in the clinical settings, this study reviewed the reports of carbapenem and colistin resistant Salmonella in food animals with an aim of determining if there is a relationship between carbapenem and colistin resistant Salmonella isolated from humans and animals. Another aim of this review is to emphasize the role played by genomic characterization of livestock-associated and antimicrobial resistant pathogens in creating references for foodborne diseases outbreak tracing. Covered in this review are the genetic determinants of colistin and carbapenem resistance in Salmonella spp., the role played by the mobile genetic elements in mobilizing colistin and carbapenem resistance genes and the importance of genomic approaches in characterizing and monitoring the dissemination of antimicrobial resistance genetic determinants.

The livestock is a significant source of protein for humans through the consumption of animal origin meat, eggs, and dairy products [1] . Monogastric animals and ruminants can convert the high fiber found in vegetation into protein [2] . Humans rely on livestock for meat and income generated from livestock by-products for the greater part of their livelihood.

The wellbeing of animals lies in the cautious practice of animal husbandry by the farmers. The well reared and healthy livestock produce meat, milk, and eggs that are nutritious to humans and reasonable income for the farmer [3] . Shelter, water availability, nutritious feed, disease prevention, and treatment measures must be considered by the farmers to ensure proper animal growth [3, 4] . For disease treatment, antibiotics are supplied to animals in therapeutic doses for a short duration while for disease prevention, sub-therapeutic doses of antibiotics are added to water or feed for a longer duration in cases of suspected risk of infection [5] . Farmers also use antibiotics for growth promotion [6] . Prophylactic use of antibiotics is sometimes confused with growth promotion purposes, leading to a continuous supply of antibiotics to healthy animals [7] . As early as 2006, the European Union has banned the use of antibiotics for growth promotion. According to the WHO, healthy animals should only receive antibiotics to prevent disease if the disease has been diagnosed in other animals in the same flock or herd. Although antibiotic use has some benefits in livestock production, it also leads to the occurrence of antimicrobial-resistant bacteria. The practice of using antibiotics as growth promotion in agricultural should be prohibited and banned immediately to avoid exacerbation of the antimicrobial resistance challenge. 

The world faces the horrendous challenge of the emergence of multidrug resistant foodborne pathogens, which render antimicrobials ineffective in combating diseases [8, 9] . Antimicrobial resistance is a public health concern as the world is slowly going back to the era before the discovery of penicillin [10] . Before Alexander Fleming discovered penicillin, even a minor injury was difficult to treat and would lead to death due to bacterial infection [10] . Injudicious use of antibiotics in agriculture and human medicine is the driving force behind antimicrobial resistance [6] . In livestock, antibiotics were registered for disease treatment, but they have been exploited for growth support and prophylaxis [10] .

The guts of eukaryotic organisms harbor many Gram-negative microorganisms that form the natural microflora, which aid in food degradation and digestion [11, 12] . Some of the enteric bacteria are opportunistic pathogens and are induced by factors such as stress and antibiotics [13, 14] . Due to short generation time, bacteria evolve faster than other organisms in the ecosystem [13, 15] . Microorganisms have responded to evolution and acquired diverse mobilizable defensive and metabolic mechanisms against foreign attacks, including antibiotics [16] . Therefore, overuse of antibiotics in animal husbandry turns livestock into carriers of antimicrobial resistant enteric pathogens which become a problem for humans.

Rapid population growth results in the demand of meat, milk, and eggs, thus pressuring the livestock production industry [1, 17] . The high demand tends to encourage swift and extensive farming using antibiotics [17] . According to Chattopadhyay, adding antibiotics to animal feed improves the feed conversion efficiency and growth rate of the animals, it also reduces the expenditure as the animals consume less feed than the animals that consume the feed that is not supplemented with antibiotics [6] . Some of the antimicrobials that are used for animal growth promotion and prophylaxis are closely related to therapeutics used in humans, which renders them ineffective due to resistance by bacteria [18] . One of the problematic antimicrobial-resistant pathogens is Salmonella spp. which causes gastroenteritis, enteric fever, and bacteremia [19] .

Salmonellosis is a burden to both developing and developed countries worldwide [20, 21] . Global studies reported that Africa is leading with the prevalence of non-typhoidal Salmonella [21, 22] . A global study by Ao et al. reported that 57% of invasive non-typhoidal Salmonella illnesses and deaths occurred in Africa in 2010 [20] . The high prevalence of lethal salmonellosis in Africa is associated with poor or primitive health care, human immunodeficiency virus, malnutrition, malaria, and antibiotic resistance [23] . Non-typhoidal Salmonella spp. has a broad host range and infect both humans and animals [24] . Animals are known to be the carriers of non-typhoidal Salmonella spp. as part of their natural microbiota [25] . Phylogenetic studies have revealed an evolutionary relationship between Salmonella spp. isolates from animals, the environment, and humans [26] [27] [28] . Djeffal et al. reported the clustering of 7 S. Heidelberg strains isolated from avian species and human isolates [26] . Eguale et al. reported the clustering of fluoroquinolone-resistant S. Kentucky strains isolated from poultry, cattle, and humans [27] . A study by Pornksukarom et al. unpacked the relatedness between the genomes of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium, Salmonella enterica serovar Derby and Salmonella enterica serovar Schwarzengrund isolated from chicken, the environment, swine, and humans [28] . Another study by Ekwanzala et al. reported that in South Africa, farm settings share a significant number of antimicrobial resistance genes with clinical and environmental settings compared to clinical vs. environmental settings [29] . The previously cited studies concluded that animals are the reservoirs of Salmonella spp. and a source of human and environmental contamination.

Global dissemination of Salmonella spp. is facilitated by travelers, imports, and exports of livestock and livestock products [30] . Some Salmonella enterica strains are restricted to Animals 2021, 11, 872 4 of 16 a particular geographical area, such as invasive Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium Sequence Type (ST) 313 and the recently discovered African Salmonella enterica serovar Enteritidis strains [23, 30] . Cases of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium ST313 strains in the United Kingdom were however reported [30] . During an investigation of the African Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium ST313 isolated from humans, a dog, and an unspecified food source led to the conclusion that the emergence of this strain in the UK was associated with travel to Sub-Saharan Africa [30] . A study by Parsons et al. on Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium ST313 revealed a possibility of pseudogenes degradation linked to higher virulence in the African strain than the strains in advanced settings [31] . Feasey et al. reported two Salmonella enterica serovar Enteritidis strains that are restricted to Africa and noted that these strains differed from the S. Enteritidis strains circulating worldwide by possessing diverse virulence determinants and multidrug resistance [23] .

The burden of antibiotic resistance originates in animals but is disseminated by the occurrence of traces of antibiotics in the environment and inappropriate use of antibiotics in human medicine. The use of antibiotics in the agricultural sector has led to the traces of antibiotics being left in soil and water resulting in resistance by the environmental bacterial isolates [32, 33] . Soil fertilization using animal fecal matter spreads pathogens and traces of antibiotics in soil and results in contamination of plants and the surrounding environment during watering. Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium and Salmonella enterica serovar Enteritidis are the main non-typhoidal Salmonella serovars that have been isolated from the stools of patients [20] . As stated previously, several epidemiology studies have focused on characterizing Salmonella isolates from humans, the environment, and animals to trace the origin of isolates that are found in clinical settings [27, 29] . Antibiotic resistance genetic determinants that are carried by the Salmonella spp. have also been characterized by nucleic acid-based approaches such as polymerase chain reaction and whole-genome sequencing. Similar genetic determinants for resistance to beta-lactams, aminoglycosides, tetracyclines, and fluoroquinolones have been detected in Salmonella isolates from livestock and humans [27, 34, 35] . This led to the conclusion that livestock animals are carriers of antimicrobial-resistant Salmonella spp. moreover, food, and environmental contamination are the sources of transmission to humans [34] .

Following resistance to traditional antibiotics, macrolides, higher generation cephalosporins, and extended spectrum beta-lactams have been the imperative antibiotics against Salmonella [36] . The rising trends of multidrug resistance and resistance to fluoroquinolones and 3rd generation cephalosporins in clinical isolates led to the introduction of carbapenems and colistin as critical antibiotics of last resort [36] .

Beta-lactam antibiotics contain the lactam ring which weakens the bacterial cell wall by disrupting transpeptidase activity during cell wall synthesis [37] . Bacteria developed resistance to beta-lactams by producing beta-lactamase enzymes which degrade the lactam ring through hydrolysis. Extended spectrum antibiotics including cephalosporins, which are resistant to lactamases were then introduced to broaden the activity of betalactam antibiotics [38] . However, extended spectrum beta-lactamase enzymes encoded by blaCMY2, blaSHV, and blaTEM emerged thus reducing the efficacy of cephalosporins [37] . Carbapenems are a broader class of extended-spectrum beta-lactams that are resistant to lactamases produced by bacteria [39] . The in vivo activity of carbapenem antibiotics was reported by Capoor et al. and were accepted for treatment of multidrug-resistant Gram-negative pathogens, including Salmonella [40] .

As a result of quick adaptation and evolution, bacteria have developed resistance to carbapenems by producing carbapenemase enzymes that hydrolyze carbapenems [37, 41] . Carbapenemase enzymes are classified into two groups based on the amino acid content on their active site i.e., serine beta-lactamases and metallo beta-lactamases [39] . The former contains serine while the later contains zinc ions at their active sites [39] . Additionally, a mutation on bacterial ompR enabled Gram-negative bacteria to lose porin channels, which are an entry of carbapenems resulting in less intake of the antibiotic [37, 41] . In attempts to preserve their effectiveness, the use of carbapenems in livestock is prohibited worldwide [42] . Carbapenem resistance was first reported in Klebsiella pneumonia and Escherichia coli clinical isolates and was later described to be plasmid-mediated in Gram-negative bacteria [41, 43] . Emergence of resistance towards these antibiotics in human medicine signifies improper use of antibiotics at the clinical settings as pivotal in propagating antimicrobial resistance.

Surprisingly, carbapenem resistance has also been reported and metallo-beta lactamase genetic determinants such as New Delhi Metallo-β-lactamase (NDM) and Verona integron encoded Metallo-β-lactamase (VIM) have been detected in bacteria isolated from pigs and poultry [44] [45] [46] . Furthermore, blaVIM-1 gene was detected in a Salmonella isolate from a wild bird in Germany [33] . The blaVIM-1 and blaNDM-5 genes were reported to be responsible for resistance to 3rd generation cephalosporins, which are used in animal husbandry; these same genes confer resistance to carbapenems and have been detected in Salmonella from food animals [47, 48] . Findings from the previous studies support the idea of co-resistance. Carbapenem resistance genes have been recently isolated in different Salmonella serovars from different hosts, including food animals as shown in Table 1 , signifying their distribution. Wild bird blaNDM-1 carrying IncA/C type Germany [33] These genetic determinants are located in the plasmids, which facilitates their transmission between even unrelated bacterial species (Table 1) . Although the clinical setting is the major contributor to carbapenem resistance, the presence of the carbapenem resistance genetic determinants in food animals is an issue of concern since transmission of these genetic determinants to humans is highly feasible.

Colistin (polymyxin E) is an antibiotic under the class of polymyxins, which is listed as one of the critically important antibiotics by the WHO [36] . Colistin was first used for veterinary purposes only; however, due to the decreasing efficacy of available drugs in human medicine and the increasing burden of multidrug-resistant bacteria, colistin was recommended as an antibiotic of last resort in human medicine [51] . Colistin disrupts the negative charge of the outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria resulting in leaking of cytoplasmic contents and cell death [52] . Prescription of colistin for both human and veterinary use has led to the emergence of mobilized colistin resistance (mcr) genes, which encode phosphoethanolamine transferase in Enterobacteriaceae [51, 53] . As a mechanism of resistance Gram-negative bacteria produce phosphoethanolamine transferase, which adds the positively charged phosphoethanolamine to the lipid A of the outer membrane, thus reducing the binding site for colistin [52] . The first report of the mcr gene was from China in Escherichia coli isolated from pigs [51] . Thus far, 9 variants of mcr genes have been detected in Salmonella isolated from humans and animals [53] [54] [55] . The mcr genes are carried by the conjugative plasmids, which facilitate their transfer between bacterial species [51] . The detection of mcr genes in bacteria isolated from food-animals and humans in different countries places colistin at risk of reduced efficacy against Enterobacteria. In South Africa, colsitin mcr gene resistance have been detected in bacteria isolated from hospitalized patients, while in countries like Taiwan, China, England, and Germany, variants of mcr genes have also been reported in bacteria isolated from pig, cattle, and poultry (Table 2 ). 

Genome-based approaches such as polymerase chain reaction (PCR), pulse-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE), multi-locus sequence typing (MLST), single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) genotyping, and whole-genome sequencing (WGS) are an accurate way of typing pathogens. These methods enable scientists to draw more clear conclusions on identification and relatedness of AMR pathogens isolated from animals, food, and humans [73] . The high level of discrimination between even related species obtained by genomic approaches generates thorough results which are helpful during outbreak tracing.

PFGE revealed genetic relatedness between mcr-1 carrying Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium isolated from humans, pigs, and chicken in Taiwan [59] . WGS was used to reveal high similarity between mcr-1 carrying plasmid recovered in S. Typhimurium isolated from pigs (Great Britain) and a reference mcr-1 carrying plasmid recovered in Escherichia coli isolated from a pig in China [56] . WGS with SNP-based phylogeny analysis uncovered the association between S. Infantis isolated from broiler chickens and Salmonella enterica serovar Infantis infecting humans in Italy [58] . PFGE, MLST, and PCR-based plasmidtyping clustered mcr-1 carrying Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium ST34 recovered from a duck and pigs from diverse geological sites into one group [61] . From the findings of the authors, there is a relationship between bacteria isolated from animals and humans. Moreover, some studies reported that similar plasmids, such as IncI2, IncX4, and IncHI2 like mcr carrying plasmids recovered from Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium, were detected from humans and food-animals [59] [60] [61] 64] . Genomic methods are valuable tools for tracing pathogens and their associated AMR genes therefore, for proper monitoring and surveillance of Salmonella, it is vital to include such methods.

PFGE generates DNA fingerprints by using enzyme restriction which recognizes the specific site and digests DNA into fragments of different length. Bacterial strains are then grouped into clones which show similar restriction patterns. This method has been the "gold standard" for typing pathogens due to its proven high level of genetic discrimination of bacteria of the same species. PFGE is used in outbreak tracing and epidemiology studies by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention [74] . Molecular analysis studies which included subtyping Salmonella enterica serovar Poona, Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium, and Salmonella enterica serovar Enteritidis isolated from different sources in diverse geological areas reported PFGE to provide the highest discriminatory power among other genotyping methods tested [46, 73, 75] . Furthermore, PFGE provided results that were in accordance with WGS in subtyping S. Poona [73] . On the contrary, other studies reported that PFGE was less powerful in subtyping Salmonella enterica serovar Heildeberg and Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium [76, 77] .

This approach is based on sequencing of housekeeping genes for a bacterial species. The traditional MLST approach is based on PCR amplification, followed by sequencing, and identification of allele variations in seven housekeeping genes for S. enterica [78] . Advanced MLST approaches are based on sequencing and identification of core genome loci variations (cgMLST) and pan genome or whole genome (wgMLST) variations in a bacterial species [79] . Whole genome MSLT and cgMLST provide higher resolution than PCR-based MLST as many genes are involved in the former approaches [80] . Furthermore, advanced MLST approaches are more accurate than PCR-based MLST because they are less laborious, resulting in minimum risk of errors. Even though PCR-based MLST is more laborious than the advanced MLST methods, it is a more economic and easily accessibly method in developing settings [80] . PCR-based MLST was used to successfully identify known S. enterica isolates with the results correlating to the traditional serotyping method [80] .

Comparative studies which revealed the power of MLST over other molecular genotyping approaches in subtyping Salmonella include separating outbreak S. Heidelberg isolates into four distinct phylogenetic clusters, which were indistinguishable by PFGE [77] . In another study, MLST was able to predict serovars for 42/46 Salmonella isolates, providing better results than PFGE, rep-PCR, and ribotyping [76] . Further genotyping investigations which utilized MLST revealed human and food animal Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium ST19, Salmonella enterica serovar Kentucky ST198, and Salmonella enterica serovar Enteritidis ST43 isolates which were indistinguishable, reinforcing circulation of pathogens between food animals and humans [81, 82] . Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium ST19 and ST34 are strains which are associated with MDR, including carbapenem and colistin resistance, and are circulating between humans and food animals [48, 49, 71, 72, 82] .

SNPs are conservative single nucleotide base changes in the genome, which can be synonymous or non-synonymous [83] . The polymorphisms may result in mutations which are responsible for antimicrobial resistance. In pathogen typing, SNPs are used to cluster bacterial strains into clades or haplotypes. PCR-based SNP genotyping detects single base polymorphisms in the targeted loci of interest while whole genome SNP analysis detects polymorphisms throughout the sequenced genome. Comparative studies have shown SNP analysis to be another valuable and powerful approach for typing closely related strains of Salmonella [84] [85] [86] [87] . The discriminatory power of PCR-based SNP typing was evidenced in subtyping S. Enteritidis PFGE type XAI.0003 into eight different clades and phage type PT8 into seven clades in Salmonella isolates from various sources including food and poultry in Canada [86] . In another study, SNP analysis detected polymorphisms which resulted in different amino acid sequences in the alleles of housekeeping genes in clinical and food Salmonella enterica serovar Saintpaul isolates [84] . Although the results were congruent with PFGE, SNP analysis provided further discriminatory power among the clones [84] . In a WGS-based SNP analysis where clinical and pork isolates of S. Derby were subtyped in Germany, this method proved to be of high discriminatory power and an appropriate tool for strains with partial epidemiological data [87] .

WGS is the most accurate discriminating approach among the genotyping methods however, its worldwide use is limited due to high costs, lack of resources, and expertise in some developing settings [87, 88] . Furthermore, WGS requires extensive computing and storage for data generated, adding to the cost of the method [87] . For these reasons, detection of marker sequences by PCR is the most applied approach in research. PFGE and MLST provide more in-depth discrimination between even strains of the same bacterial species. Moreover, approaches such as PFGE, MLST, SNP genotyping can be used to trace and relate pathogens of different geographical areas and hosts. The accuracy of discrimination of molecular genotyping methods differs with bacterial species and strains. There is no one genotyping method that is better than the other. Additionally, one approach can be powerful in discriminating a certain bacterial species and be less accurate in another species.

AMR genes are often carried by mobile genetic elements that integrate into plasmids or the bacterial chromosome. Insertion elements and transposons have been found to be responsible for disseminating gene cassettes that confer resistance to antibiotics [56, 57] . AMR genes are frequently flanked by the insertion elements or carried along with composite transposons [69, 89, 90] . These elements have been identified in plasmids that have been isolated from Salmonella in humans, food, and animals. The role of IS26 and ISCR1 in mobilizing carbapenem resistance genes was highlighted [50, 90] .

Since plasmids mediate lateral transfer of AMR genes to different hosts and between bacterial species, it is crucial to characterize the plasmids that are carried by pathogens. The plasmids which carry AMR genes are frequently conjugative, as shown by several studies [50, 67, 71] . Although some plasmids are host restricted, some can be transferred and replicated in different hosts. Similar plasmids have previously been isolated from different hosts and different Salmonella serovars, e.g., IncI2 mcr-1 carrying plasmid, which has been identified from S. Typhimurium and S. Indiana from poultry, pigs, and humans in China [59, 90] . A blaNDM-5 carrying IncX3 plasmid with 99% identity to a blaNDM-5 carrying plasmid in India was isolated from a pig in China, implying cross-contamination between humans and food animals and broad dissemination of AMR genes by pathogens [48] .

Plasmid characterization does not only detect the specific genes of interest, but also other antibiotic and heavy metal resistance genes carried by plasmids. For biosecurity, disinfectants are frequently used in meat and poultry production systems. These include quaternary ammonium compounds, heavy metals, phenolic compounds, and alcohols [34] . Due to their moderate toxicity and prominent antimicrobial activity, quaternary ammonium compounds are the commonly used disinfectants [34] . Besides disinfection, heavy metals are also used as growth promoters especially in poultry production. Zinc, copper, organic arsenicals, and silver nanoparticles are added in feed lots and water for animals while mercury is a disinfectant in farms and meat production environments [34, 91] . Since high concentrations of heavy metals are toxic to bacteria prolonged exposure to such substances resulted in defense mechanisms by bacteria. Stress response proteins which result in Efflux pumps, heavy metal and disinfectant resistance genes have been identified in livestockassociated bacteria including Salmonella [47, [92] [93] [94] . The same mechanisms for resistance to heavy metals could result in cross-resistance to some antibiotic compounds [91] . Genes that encode mercury, silver, arsenate, and cobalt resistance were detected in a blaVIM-1 carrying InHI2 plasmid isolated from Salmonella enterica in pigs as shown in Figure 1 [47] . Detection of resistance by microbiological culturing or PCR alone is not enough to conclude the source of AMR. Further characterization of plasmids coupled with bioinformatics and epidemiology enables determination of the geographical spread of the plasmid.

anisms for resistance to heavy metals could result in cross-resistance to some antibiotic compounds [91] . Genes that encode mercury, silver, arsenate, and cobalt resistance were detected in a blaVIM-1 carrying InHI2 plasmid isolated from Salmonella enterica in pigs as shown in Figure 1 [47] . Detection of resistance by microbiological culturing or PCR alone is not enough to conclude the source of AMR. Further characterization of plasmids coupled with bioinformatics and epidemiology enables determination of the geographical spread of the plasmid. Figure 1 . Comparative plasmid maps of pRH-R27 from Salmonella enterica and pRH-R178 from Escherichia coli. Deleted regions (1-3) are indicated on the map and pRH-R27 was used as reference. All sequences show >95% DNA sequence identity. Coloured regions represent functions and features indicated in the figure legend. The IncHI2 plasmid harbored by S. Infantis (pRH-R27) isolated from a livestock farm in Germany carries antibiotic resistance genes (blaVIM-1, aacA4, aadA1, sul1, blaACC-1, strA/strB, and catA1), disinfectant resistance (qacEΔ1) and heavy metal resistance (ter-, mer-, sil-, ars-, rcn-, and pco). The figure was reproduced with permission from [47] . Plasmid dissemination is mediated by the presence of tra genes which encode all the proteins that are needed for the conjugation process [47, 89] . Helper plasmids mediate the transfer process in the absence of tra genes, such case was reported in the non-conjugative ColE plasmid [95] . Epidemiological studies have shown that Salmonella spp. acquire colistin and carbapenem resistance genes mostly from Escherichia coli through conjugation [50, 67, 71, 95] . (1) (2) (3) are indicated on the map and pRH-R27 was used as reference. All sequences show >95% DNA sequence identity. Coloured regions represent functions and features indicated in the figure legend. The IncHI2 plasmid harbored by S. Infantis (pRH-R27) isolated from a livestock farm in Germany carries antibiotic resistance genes (blaVIM-1, aacA4, aadA1, sul1, blaACC-1, strA/strB, and catA1), disinfectant resistance (qacE∆1) and heavy metal resistance (ter-, mer-, sil-, ars-, rcn-, and pco). The figure was reproduced with permission from [47] .

Plasmid dissemination is mediated by the presence of tra genes which encode all the proteins that are needed for the conjugation process [47, 89] . Helper plasmids mediate the transfer process in the absence of tra genes, such case was reported in the non-conjugative ColE plasmid [95] . Epidemiological studies have shown that Salmonella spp. acquire colistin and carbapenem resistance genes mostly from Escherichia coli through conjugation [50, 67, 71, 95] .

Foodborne diseases affect both developing and developed countries, but the burden is higher in the developing settings. On the other hand, the developing countries primarily lack proper resources for genotyping AMR pathogens or little consideration is given to agriculture-related AMR, leading to paucity of data on the issue.

In Africa, food animals and farm environments harbor diverse Salmonella Salmonella enterica serovars including S. Kentucky, S. Newport, S. Hadar, S. Enteritidis, S. Infantis, and S. Typhimurium [96] . The leading disease causing Salmonella serovars S. Typhimurium and S. Enteritidis have been reported in lower prevalence than S. Kentucky, S. Hadar, and S. Newport in food animals in Africa, however, the host species might have an impact on this low prevalence [32, 97, 98] . Furthermore, like in other continents, extensive distribution of S. Enteritidis and S. Typhimurium has been reported in Africa [96] . According to the cited literature in Africa, poultry, pigs, and cattle are the main reservoirs of the problematic Salmonella serovars. Moreover, isolation of multidrug resistant S. Kentucky from food animals is of concern since this serovar has also been isolated from humans [32, 97] . Although outbreaks caused by S. Kentucky have not been reported, this serovar is still a threat to humans as it can transfer the AMR genes to other disease-causing pathogens.

Despite the inaccessibility to proper genotyping resources in Africa, data on genotype profiling of non-typhoid Salmonella is accumulating, however, only a few studies have been carried on animal isolates (Table 3) . From the genotyping results of Salmonella, WGS distinguished outbreak from non-outbreak S. Enteritidis isolates which belonged to common subtypes by PFGE [85] . In another study, subtyping by PFGE clustered isolates S. Newport, S. Mbandaka, and S. Aberdeen from different farms and different districts into pulsotypes PT(H), PT(N), and PT(F), respectively [98] . On the other hand, seven S. Hadar isolates were discriminated into four different pulsotypes and belonged to four farms in two districts [98] . In a study by Fashae et al. MLST showed that humans and cattle share S. Colindale ST584 and S. Kentucky isolates, however, SNP analysis revealed that there was no cluster between human and cattle isolates [97] . MLST detected the global circulating multidrug resistant S. Typhimurium ST19 in isolates from Morocco and PFGE differentiated 9 serovars into 32 pulsotypes, some of which showed up to 5 variations within the same serovar [99] . Salmonella has been detected in livestock and poultry from many sub-Saharan African countries including South Africa however, there is still a lack of in-depth knowledge about the multidrug resistant clinically important serovars which are circulating in food chain animals. Data on the predominant serovars are based only on few studies, therefore, more genotyping studies are required in African livestock to understand the epidemiology of Salmonella in this continent.

There are rising trends of resistance to carbapenems and colistin in Salmonella isolated from food chain animals. Antimicrobial resistant in livestock associated Salmonella is an increasing public health concern since carbapenems and colistin are the last-line antibiotics. Of note is that AMR genes which have been isolated from Salmonella in animals originated from clinically problematic pathogens such as K. pneumonia and Escherichia coli [43, 51] . Although agriculture, food animals and livestock production systems are significant sources of antimicrobial resistance [5, [101] [102] [103] , genetic transfer of AMR through plasmid and mobile genetic elements are the major contributor to the dissemination of AMR genes. More attention should be brought into monitoring the last line antibiotics in animal husbandry, and genomic characterization of the drivers of AMR should be part of the surveillance programs. Antimicrobial resistance is a complex multifactorial challenge requiring a One Health approach of coordinated multidisciplinary efforts to tackle it. It is important to highlight that non-prudent use of antimicrobial agents in human medicine significantly contributes to the development of antimicrobial resistance, underlining the importance of One Health. Active surveillance of foodborne pathogens should be practiced by every country to protect human health and prevent possible outbreaks by emphasizing stringent hygiene measures, especially in food animals.

Another point of concern is the worldwide dissemination of S. Typhimurium ST34, which carries gene cassettes for MDR, including genes for resistance to carbapenems and Colistin. Particular attention should be given to this serovar as it is found in food animals and responsible for causing diseases in humans. Pigs and poultry are the major reservoirs of carbapenem and colistin resistant Salmonella, therefore more stringent surveillance is urgently required in livestock. Although genomic characterization of livestock-associated Salmonella has been done in Africa, there is still some lack of information with regards to investigating resistance to the last-line antibiotics and other antibiotics of high clinical importance as listed by the WHO. In addition, disinfectant resistance and heavy metal resistance is an emerging concern in livestock production as it disrupts pathogen control measures.

Successful surveillance and strict monitoring of colistin and carbapenem resistance in livestock can be achieved by microbiological, genomic analysis, and phylogenetic studies to early detect trends and emergence of resistance which will eventually mitigate antibiotics use in livestock and create Salmonella references to be used during disease outbreak tracing. Resistance plasmids offer survival advantages to pathogens by conferring resistance to antibiotics, heavy metals, and disinfectants therefore, plasmid typing in livestock-associated pathogens is important in detecting food related threats to humans. The use of antibiotics in livestock varies with geographical locations therefore different Salmonella serovars which carry distinct AMR genes dominate diverse geographical locations. This brings out the need to constantly monitor antimicrobial resistance and genetically characterize AMR pathogens in both livestock and humans. As reported in literature, Africa is leading with foodborne infections, yet it still lacks proper monitoring of foodborne pathogens. Hence, improved surveillance needs to be performed in this continent to reduce transmission of livestock-associated AMR pathogens to humans.

Sustainability of the South African Livestock Sector towards 2050 Part 2: Challenges, changes and required implementations

A South African perspective on livestock production in relation to greenhouse gases and water usage

Interventions and Package of Practices needed to Enhance Farmer's Income through Livestock

Pig Welfare at Different Production Systems

Agriculture and food animals as a source of antimicrobial-resistant bacteria

Use of antibiotics as feed additives: A burning question

Antibiotics usage in food-producing animals in South Africa and impact on human: Antibiotic resistance

The antimicrobial resistance crisis: Causes, consequences, and management. Front

Antibiotic resistance is the quintessential One Health issue

Antimicrobial resistance: A global emerging threat to public health systems

The role of the gut microbiota in nutrition and health

Gut microbiota-generated metabolites in animal health and disease

Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium strategies for host adaptation

The innate growth bistability and fitness landscapes of antibiotic-resistant bacteria

Prevalence and antibiotic susceptibility patterns of Shigella and Salmonella causing Diarrhoea in children below 5 years at Thika level five district hospital

A brief history of the antibiotic era: Lessons learned and challenges for the future

Global trends in antimicrobial use in food animals

Antimicrobial resistance in human populations: Challenges and opportunities

European food poisoning outbreaks involving meat and meat-based products

Global burden of invasive nontyphoidal Salmonella disease

A perspective on invasive Salmonella disease in Africa

The global burden and epidemiology of invasive non-typhoidal Salmonella infections. Hum. Vaccines Immunother

Animals 2021

Distinct Salmonella Enteritidis lineages associated with enterocolitis in high-income settings and invasive disease in low-income settings

Same species, different diseases: How and why typhoidal and non-typhoidal Salmonella enterica serovars differ

The role of antibiotics and antibiotic resistance in nature

Prevalence and clonal relationship of ESBL-producing Salmonella strains from humans and poultry in northeastern Algeria

Genetic markers associated with resistance to beta-lactam and quinolone antimicrobials in non-typhoidal Salmonella isolates from humans and animals in central Ethiopia

Whole genome sequencing analysis of multiple Salmonella serovars provides insights into phylogenetic relatedness, antimicrobial resistance, and virulence markers across humans, food animals and agriculture environmental sources

Systematic review in South Africa reveals antibiotic resistance genes shared between clinical and environmental settings

Public health surveillance in the UK revolutionises our understanding of the invasive Salmonella Typhimurium epidemic in Africa

Invasive non-typhoidal Salmonella Typhimurium ST313 are not host-restricted and have an invasive phenotype in experimentally infected chickens

Potential sources and transmission of Salmonella and antimicrobial resistance in Kampala

NDM-1 carbapenemase-producing Salmonella enterica subsp. enterica serovar Corvallis isolated from a wild bird in Germany

Antibiotic resistance in Salmonella from retail foods of animal origin and its association with disinfectant and heavy metal resistance

Genotypic resistance to quinolone and tetracycline in Salmonella Dublin strains isolated from humans and animals in Brazil

World Health Organization. Critically important antimicrobials for human medicine: Ranking of antimicrobial agents for risk management of antimicrobial resistance due to non-human use

Epidemiology and diagnostics of carbapenem resistance in Gram-negative bacteria

Recent updates of carbapenem antibiotics

Diversity and proliferation of metallo-β-lactamases: A clarion call for clinically effective metallo-β-lactamase inhibitors

Minimum inhibitory concentration of carbapenems and tigecycline against Salmonella spp

Characterization of a new metallo-betalactamase gene, bla(NDM-1), and a novel erythromycin esterase gene carried on a unique genetic structure in Klebsiella pneumoniae sequence type 14 from India

Carbapenemaseproducing Enterobacteriaceae recovered from the environment of a swine farrow-to-finish operation in the United States

Plasmid-mediated transfer of the bla NDM-1 gene in Gram-negative rods

Detection of VIM-1-producing enterobacter cloacae and Salmonella enterica serovars Infantis and Goldcoast at a breeding pig farm in Germany in 2017 and their molecular relationship to former VIM-1-Producing S. infantis isolates in german livestock production

Complete genetic analysis of a Salmonella enterica serovar Indiana isolate accompanying four plasmids carrying mcr-1, ESBL and other resistance genes in China

Animals 2021

Characterization of Salmonella enterica isolates from diseased poultry in northern China between

Comparative genome analysis of IncHI2 VIM-1 carbapenemase-encoding plasmids of Escherichia coli and Salmonella enterica isolated from a livestock farm in Germany

Plasmid-Encoded blaNDM-5 Gene That Confers High-Level Carbapenem Resistance in Salmonella Typhimurium of Pork Origin

First detection of NDM-5-positive Salmonella enterica serovar typhimurium isolated from retail pork in China

Characterisation of a cointegrate plasmid harbouring blaNDM-1 in a clinical Salmonella Lomita strain

Emergence of plasmidmediated colistin resistance mechanism MCR-1 in animals and human beings in China: A microbiological and molecular biological study

Towards understanding MCR-like colistin resistance

Identification of novel mobilized colistin resistance gene mcr-9 in a multidrug-resistant, colistin-susceptible Salmonella enterica serotype Typhimurium isolate

Development of a novel mcr-6 to mcr-9 multiplex PCR and assessment of mcr-1 to mcr-9 occurrence in colistin-resistant Salmonella enterica isolates from environment, feed, animals and food

Multiplex PCR for detection of plasmid-mediated colistin resistance determinants, mcr-1, mcr-2, mcr-3, mcr-4 and mcr-5 for surveillance purposes

Colistin resistance in Salmonella and Escherichia coli isolates from a pig farm in Great Britain

Characterization of mcr-5-harboring Salmonella enterica subsp. enterica serovar Typhimurium isolates from animal and food origin in Germany

Colistin resistance mediated by mcr-1 in ESBL-producing, multidrug resistant Salmonella Infantis in broiler chicken industry

Dissemination of mcr-1-carrying plasmids among colistin-resistant Salmonella strains from humans and food-producing animals in Taiwan

Detection of the plasmid-mediated mcr-1 gene conferring colistin resistance in human and food isolates of Salmonella enterica and Escherichia coli in England and Wales

Clonal spread of mcr-1 in PMQR-carrying ST34 Salmonella isolates from animals in China

First report of mcr-1-harboring Salmonella enterica serovar Schwarzengrund isolated from poultry meat in Brazil

Genomic characterization of an extensivelydrug resistance Salmonella enterica serotype Indiana strain harboring blaNDM-1 gene isolated from a chicken carcass in China

mcr-1− Harboring Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium sequence type 34 in pigs

MCR-1 in multidrug-resistant and copper-tolerant clinically relevant Salmonella 1, 4

Comparative analysis of an mcr-4 Salmonella enterica subsp. enterica monophasic variant of human and animal origin

Plasmid-borne colistin resistance gene mcr-3 in Salmonella isolates from human infections

Detection of mcr-4 positive Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium in clinical isolates of human origin

Salmonella enterica mcr-1 positive from food in Brazil: Detection and characterization

Epidemiologic and genomic insights on mcr-1-harbouring Salmonella from diarrhoeal outpatients in

12: I:-sequence type 34 carrying the mcr-3.1 gene on the IncHI2 plasmid recovered from a human

Genomic characterization of mcr-1-carrying Salmonella enterica serovar 4

Laboratory investigation of Salmonella enterica serovar Poona outbreak in California: Comparison of pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) and whole genome sequencing (WGS) results

Salmonella serotypes, Shigella sonnei and Shigella flexneri

Comparison of four molecular methods to type Salmonella Enteritidis strains

Comparison of typing methods with a new procedure based on sequence characterization for Salmonella serovar prediction

Comparison of advanced whole genome sequence-based methods to distinguish strains of Salmonella enterica serovar Heidelberg involved in foodborne outbreaks in Québec

MOST: A modified MLST typing tool based on short read sequencing

Multilevel genome typing: Genomics-guided scalable resolution typing of microbial pathogens

Salmonella enterica multilocus sequence typing and its correlation with serotypes

Poultry as a possible source of non-typhoidal Salmonella enterica serovars in humans in Bangladesh

Antimicrobial resistance, plasmid, virulence, multilocus sequence typing and pulsed-field gel electrophoresis profiles of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium clinical and environmental isolates from India

The TaqMan method for SNP genotyping

Genetic and resistance phenotypic subtyping of Salmonella Saintpaul isolates from various food sources and humans: Phylogenetic concordance in combinatory analyses

Comparison of conventional molecular and whole-genome sequencing methods for subtyping Salmonella enterica serovar Enteritidis strains from Tunisia

Development of a new molecular subtyping tool for Salmonella enterica serovar Enteritidis based on single nucleotide polymorphism genotyping using PCR

Evaluation of WGS based approaches for investigating a food-borne outbreak caused by Salmonella enterica serovar Derby in Germany

Next generation microbiological risk assessment: Opportunities of whole genome sequencing (WGS) for foodborne pathogen surveillance, source tracking and risk assessment

Prevalence and molecular characterization of mcr-1-positive Salmonella strains recovered from clinical specimens in China

Genomic characterization of a large plasmid containing a bla NDM-1 gene carried on Salmonella enterica serovar Indiana C629 isolate from China

Comparative genomics and phenotypic investigations into antibiotic, heavy metal, and disinfectant susceptibilities of Salmonella enterica strains isolated in Australia

Salmonella genomic island 3 is an integrative and conjugative element and contributes to copper and arsenic tolerance of Salmonella enterica

Dyall-Smith, M. pSTM6-275, a conjugative IncHI2 plasmid of Salmonella enterica that confers antibiotic and heavy-metal resistance under changing physiological conditions

Presence of heavy metal resistance genes in Escherichia coli and Salmonella isolates and analysis of resistance gene structure in E. coli E308

Novel plasmid-mediated colistin resistance mcr-4 gene in Salmonella and Escherichia coli

Worldwide epidemiology of Salmonella serovars in animal-based foods: A meta-analysis

Phenotypic and genotypic comparison of Salmonellae from diarrhoeic and healthy humans and cattle

Diversity and antimicrobial resistance genotypes in non-typhoidal Salmonella isolates from poultry farms in Uganda

Antibiotic resistance determinants and genetic analysis of Salmonella enterica isolated from food in Morocco

Genome sequences of two Salmonella enterica strains (MEZSAL74 and MEZSAL81) harbouring multiple antimicrobial resistance genes isolated from livestock in South Africa

The animal-human interface and infectious disease in industrial food animal production: Rethinking biosecurity and biocontainment

Antibiotic resistance genes from livestock waste: Occurrence, dissemination, and treatment

Antimicrobial resistance in livestock: Advances and alternatives to antibiotics