key: cord-0843934-ncfqvb1q
authors: Al-Mandhari, Ahmed Salim; Brennan, Richard J; Abubakar, Abdinasir; Hajjeh, Rana
title: Tackling COVID-19 in the Eastern Mediterranean Region
date: 2020-11-19
journal: Lancet
DOI: 10.1016/s0140-6736(20)32349-7
sha: f99fb9c6424e66d5a897e5eb0c91600bd8bf3e6f
doc_id: 843934
cord_uid: ncfqvb1q

nan

COVID-19 has substantially impacted the Eastern Mediterranean Region (EMR), home to nearly 700 million people across 22 diverse countries. Since the first reported confirmed case in January, 2020, 3 611 352 confirmed COVID-19 cases and 91 738 deaths were reported in the region as of Nov 17, 2020. 1 Most countries saw fairly slow transmission of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) during the early months of the pandemic but in May, as social measures, such as restrictions and partial or full lockdowns, were relaxed during the holy month of Ramadan, disease transmission accelerated. 2,3 After a small reduction in the summer, cases increased in late August as disease surged in countries, such as Jordan and Tunisia, where transmission had been low earlier in the year and resurged in other countries, such as Bahrain and Oman. 3 Several factors can explain the regional COVID-19 trends and inform more effective disease control. First, the early implementation of public health and social measures, starting mid-March, proved effective, including nonpharmaceutical individual and societal interventions to control COVID-19. 4 All countries closed schools and non-essential businesses, imposed travel restrictions, and partial or full lockdowns, 5 and community mobility decreased substantially. 6 But as these measures were eased, community mobility resumed and was only 19% below pre-COVID-19 levels by mid-July. 6 Second, restrictions on mass gatherings and pilgrimages had an important role. In Iran, cases initially occurred in Qom, a destination for religious pilgrimages, which soon became an epicentre, and within 15 days all 31 provinces in Iran reported cases. By early April, 12 EMR countries reported SARS-CoV-2 transmission associated with mass gatherings and pilgrimages. In response, new measures were taken including the closures of mosques and the suspension of Friday and church prayers and Tackling COVID-19 in the Eastern Mediterranean Region children's development-good health, adequate nutrition, safety and security, learning opportunities, and responsive and supportive interactions with adults. The abilities of families to sustain nurturing care under economic and other stresses are being stretched. The likely worsening impact of continued income cuts and parental mental distress on the healthy developmental trajectory of many children will only reliably be estimated with available data on ECD.

Within just a decade, ECD measurement and monitoring have started to be mainstreamed. However, to achieve a universal picture of how young children are faring, as well as progress and setbacks to improve their lives and their futures, we need more countries, including HICs, to adopt and prioritise the measurement of internationally comparable ECD indi cators. Much more work is needed to advance ECD, never more so than now, when young children in all countries face threats to their survival, health, and development resulting from or exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic. 8 LMR, SNN, CC, and NP contributed to the development, design, and production of the ECD country profiles discussed in this Comment and supporting material. CC and NP led the development and testing of the revised ECD Index 2030 discussed in this Comment and the preparation of supporting material. We declare no other competing interests. The preparation of the country profiles was led by UNICEF and was made possible through core funding to the organisation. Other funders include the Conrad N Hilton Foundation and the the Umrah. 7 Third, migrant workers drove SARS-CoV-2 transmission during the early months of the pandemic in those countries where they constitute a large proportion of the population. The Gulf countries, which have the highest testing rates, also have the highest COVID-19 regional attack rates; in these countries, 62-90% of COVID-19 cases occurred among migrant workers early on, 8 attributed partly to overcrowded living conditions. 9 Finally, among the eight EMR countries affected by conflict and humanitarian emergencies-Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, the occupied Palestinian territory, Somalia, Sudan, Syria, and Yemen-COVID-19 attack rates are substantially lower than in other countries in the region (median 73 cases per 100 000 population vs 1343 cases per 100 000). 10 This lower attack rate might be due to restricted international arrivals limiting virus introduction, reduced internal mobility, the demographics of these countries, 11 and fewer tests in conflict-affected countries than in other EMR countries (median 291 tests per 100 000 vs 15 279 per 100 000). 12 Observations from community and health facilities in conflict-affected countries suggest that laboratory testing capacity or under-reporting of cases is unlikely to solely explain these lower attack rates.

The main challenges to the COVID-19 response in the EMR include information sharing, expanding public health measures, protecting health workers, achieving behaviour change, ensuring continuity of essential health services, and establishing reliable supply chains. Although the effectiveness of country-specific COVID-19 responses varies, certain best practices in the region have been important. Decisive leadership and whole-of-government and whole-of-society approaches are central to an effective response. 13 Most countries established highlevel national multisectoral coordination mechanisms and developed national plans that covered the nine pillars of the WHO COVID-19 Strategic Preparedness and Response Plan (panel). 14 For surveillance, countries leveraged existing systems, including routine influenza surveillance and polio infrastructure. Nonetheless, reporting of epidemiological data to WHO as per the International Health Regulations (2005) and application of the WHO case definition have often been unreliable and incomplete. Although all 22 countries can test for SARS-CoV-2, laboratory capacities, testing strategies, and testing rates vary widely-eg, from 33 to 146 343 tests per 100 000 popu lation in EMR countries. Contact tracing is generally insufficient and not yet scaled up. All EMR countries have designated health facilities to manage COVID-19 cases, mostly of severe disease. Treatment protocols vary from supportive treatment to complex regimens, including compassionate drug use outside of clinical trials. 15 Health workers accounted for 7-10% of COVID-19 cases during the 3 months of the pandemic in the EMR and outbreaks among these workers con tributed to acceleration of the pandemic. 16 Inadequate infection prevention and control (IPC) programmes and poor IPC compliance are important contributing factors, especially considering that ten countries had no preexisting national IPC structures. On the basis of WHO recommendations, all EMR countries subsequently prioritised and invested more in IPC practices through training, monitoring, and provision of personal protective equipment. 17 As the pandemic evolved, risk communications and community engagement faced challenges, such as widespread so-called pandemic fatigue. 18 COVID-19 knowledge and risk perception vary across the region; use of masks ranges from 6% to 83% across EMR countries. [19] [20] [21] The socioeconomic impacts of COVID-19 response measures have been substantial, with gross domestic product projected to decline by 4·7% across the EMR in 2020 and by 13% in conflictaffected countries. 22 WHO recommends risk assessment before the easing of COVID-19 response measures, but some countries struggled to make such assessments while mitigating economic impacts, and often decisions were not adequately informed by public health data. 23 The COVID-19 pandemic has compromised delivery of essential health services (EHS) in the region, as countries repurposed health systems to respond. About 75% of EHS had some level of disruption in 13 countries, mostly affecting routine immunisations, dental services,

• Country-level coordination, planning, and monitoring • Risk communication and community engagement • Surveillance, rapid response teams, and case investigation • Points of entry, international travel, and transport • National laboratories • Infection prevention and control • Case management • Operational support and logistics • Maintaining essential health services and systems rehabilitation services, and family planning. 24 Countries are now increasingly prioritising continuity of EHS, using WHO's operational guidance. 25 In addition, the pandemic has exposed the fragility of the medical supply chain; there have been shortages of personal protec tive equipment, ventilators, and diagnostics in all EMR countries. WHO and partners established the COVID-19 Supply Chain System that managed distribution of supplies to more than 160 countries. WHO's EMR logistics hub in Dubai, central to this system, had managed 376 shipments to 109 countries by Nov 17, 2020. In conflict-affected countries there are insufficient resources for an effective response, with inadequate planning, limited public health and hospital capacity, and difficulties with implementing phy sical distancing and hand and per sonal hygiene in overcrowded settlements for displaced persons. 26 The most pressing challenges remain balancing the easing of COVID-19 control measures while maintaining suppression of SARS-CoV-2 transmission, scaling up public health measures, tackling COVID-19 fatigue, and establishing a platform for distribution of eventual COVID-19 vaccines. Countries in the EMR must heed the advice of the independent Global Preparedness Monitoring Board: show responsible leadership, engage citizens, build strong systems for health security, and ensure sustained investment and strong governance of preparedness for health emergencies. 27 ASA-M is the WHO Regional Director for the Eastern Mediterranean. We declare no competing interests.

World Health Organization Regional Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

COVID-19 situation in the region-total reports

The impact of COVID-19 and strategies for mitigation and suppression in low-and middle-income countries

COVID-19) situation report-102 and 163

Considerations for implementing and adjusting public health and social measures in the context of COVID-19. Interim guidance

Government Measures Database

Google COVID-19 community mobility report

Ministry of Hajj and Umrah: Hajj 1441H is decided to take place this year with limited number of pilgrims from all nationalities residing in Saudi Arabia

2 Mideast countries have highest confirmed virus rates

Coronavirus exposes vulnerabilities of world's migrant workers. The Straits Times

Country comparison: median age. CIA World Factbook

Mediterranean Regional Office COVID-19 dashboard

Decisive leadership is a necessity in the COVID-19 response

COVID-19 Strategic Preparedness and Response Plan-operational planning guidelines to support country preparedness and response

The current understanding and potential therapeutic options to combat COVID-19

Egypt orders enquiry into doctor's death as separate wards open for medics. The National

Knowledge, attitude, practice and perceived barriers among healthcare professionals regarding COVID-19: a cross-sectional survey from Pakistan

Virus-weary Saudis at risk of succumbing to "pandemic fatigue

Knowledge, attitudes, risk perceptions, and practices of adults toward COVID-19: a population and field-based study from Iran

Knowledge, attitude and practice toward COVID-19 among the public in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia: a cross-sectional study

Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation. Mask use in WHO regions

Five charts that illustrate COVID-19's impact on the Middle East and Central Asia

Considerations in adjusting public health and social measures in the context of COVID-19. Interim guidance

90% of countries report disruptions to essential health services since COVID-19 pandemic

Essential health services

Guidance for the prevention of COVID-19 infections among highrisk individuals in camps and camp-like settings

Global Preparedness Monitoring Board. A world at risk: annual report on global preparedness for health emergencies