key: cord-0839568-fx22vtll
authors: Hero, Mario; Rožmarić, Gloria; Šukunda, Ena; Papić, Eliša; Rački, Valentino; Vuletić, Vladimira
title: Effect of the coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic on people with Parkinson's disease: experience from a Croatian regional center
date: 2022-02-03
journal: Croat Med J
DOI: 10.3325/cmj.2022.63.62
sha: 88a4e56b8a75b22765f6f567b8cbf22f268dc650
doc_id: 839568
cord_uid: fx22vtll

AIM: To assess the effect of social isolation due to the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic on physical and mental health of Parkinson’s disease patients treated at the University Hospital Center Rijeka. METHODS: This cross-sectional telephone study involved Parkinson’s disease patients who had at least one control examination at University Hospital Center Rijeka in 2020 and were Croatian citizens. A questionnaire was used to obtain data on the socio-demographic characteristics and the severity of motor, anxiety, depression, and non-motor symptoms. RESULTS: The final sample included 87 patients. Most patients reported subjective worsening of motor symptoms. Patients who lived alone had worse motor scores than those not living alone. The majority of patients reported worsening of anxiety symptoms. Significant worsening of anxiety symptoms was found in patients who lived alone, had a longer disease duration, and had avoided check-ups. Fewer patients had depression symptoms than motor and anxiety symptoms. Significantly higher Hamilton Depression Rating Scale scores were observed in patients with a longer disease duration. Significant worsening of non-motor symptoms was identified in patients who lived alone, were less educated, had a longer disease duration, and had a higher Charlson comorbidity index. CONCLUSION: Patients who live alone, have longer disease duration, are less educated, avoid check-ups, and have more comorbidities are more vulnerable to the negative effects of social isolation.

To assess the effect of social isolation due to the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic on physical and mental health of Parkinson's disease patients treated at the University Hospital Center Rijeka.

Methods This cross-sectional telephone study involved Parkinson's disease patients who had at least one control examination at University Hospital Center Rijeka in 2020 and were Croatian citizens. A questionnaire was used to obtain data on the socio-demographic characteristics and the severity of motor, anxiety, depression, and non-motor symptoms.

The final sample included 87 patients. Most patients reported subjective worsening of motor symptoms. Patients who lived alone had worse motor scores than those not living alone. The majority of patients reported worsening of anxiety symptoms. Significant worsening of anxiety symptoms was found in patients who lived alone, had a longer disease duration, and had avoided check-ups. Fewer patients had depression symptoms than motor and anxiety symptoms. Significantly higher Hamilton Depression Rating Scale scores were observed in patients with a longer disease duration. Significant worsening of non-motor symptoms was identified in patients who lived alone, were less educated, had a longer disease duration, and had a higher Charlson comorbidity index.

Conclusion Patients who live alone, have longer disease duration, are less educated, avoid check-ups, and have more comorbidities are more vulnerable to the negative effects of social isolation.

The coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic has thoroughly changed many aspects of human daily life (1) . From December 31, 2019 to February 21, 2021, there were 112 348 223 COVID-19 cases worldwide and 36 607 500 in Europe. In Croatia, 240 017 people were infected and 5449 died (1). Poorer outcomes and higher mortality rates have been reported in older adults and people with comorbidities such as cardiovascular disease, diabetes, hypertension, chronic obstructive pulmonary disorder, and chronic kidney disease (2). Recent studies suggest that people with Parkinson's disease have an increased death rate (3, 4) .

During the pandemic, people belonging to risk groups were forced to limit their social life and reduce the number of contacts. Any change in behavior that greatly alters a person's life requires the flexibility to adapt to new circumstances. This cognitive process depends on dopaminergic function (5) . A deficient dopamine-dependent adaptation can lead to feelings of helplessness and increased psychological stress (5) . Higher levels of psychological stress can worsen motor and non-motor symptoms of Parkinson's disease, but also trigger psychiatric comorbidities such as depression and anxiety (6) . Physical activity can alleviate the progression of Parkinson's disease symptoms, so a lack of activity often worsens motor symptoms (5, 7) . A further significant problem during the COVID-19 pandemic is avoidance of follow-up examinations (4, 5, 8, 9) . Delaying or avoiding medical care may increase the risk of morbidity and mortality associated with otherwise treatable or preventable diseases (9) .

The main aim of this study was to assess the effect of social isolation due to the COVID-19 pandemic on physical and mental health in Parkinson's disease patients treated at the Clinic of Neurology of University Hospital Center Rijeka. The specific aims were to assess the effect of social isolation on 1) non-motor symptoms, 2) the occurrence of depression, 3) the occurrence of anxiety, and 4) avoiding check-ups, in people with Parkinson's disease.

This cross-sectional study enrolled 170 patients from the outpatient subspecialist clinic. The inclusion criteria were a clinical diagnosis of Parkinson's disease based on the UK Parkinson's Disease Society Brain Bank Diagnostic Criteria; at least one control examination at the Clinic of Neurology of the University Hospital Center Rijeka in 2020; and Croatian citizenship ( Figure 1 ). The patients' telephone numbers were obtained from the hospital electronic records system, and the patients were attempted to be contacted up to three times on three different days. The telephone questionnaire was conducted from November 15, 2020 to February 15, 2021. The participants gave oral informed consent at the start of the interview, while the written informed consent was obtained later on a control visit or via mail. The study was approved by the Ethics Committee of the University Hospital Center Rijeka.

The questionnaire consisted of 75 questions divided into five categories (Supplementary material). The first category consisted of 10 questions (questions 1-10) on age, sex, duration of illness (in years), education level (primary, secondary, upper secondary, and tertiary education), relationship status, living status (alone or partnered/with family). settlement size (rural regions 0-10,000; semiurban regions 10 000-100,000, large cities >100 000 inhabitants), employment status, presence of comorbidities, COVID-19 positivity (necessary positive test for COVID- 19) , and avoidance of check-ups (yes/no). The Charlson comorbidity index score is a validated method of classifying comorbidities based on their severity with an aim to estimate short-term and long-term mortality. The second category consisted of four questions (questions 11-14) related to a subjective assessment of the worsening of motor symptoms since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic. The third category was dedicated to subjective anxiety assessment with the Hamilton Anxiety Rating Scale (HAM-A) (questions 15-28) (10) . The fourth category involved a subjective assessment of depression with the Hamilton Depression Rating Scale (HAM-D) (questions 29-45) (11) . The fifth category involved the assessment of the symptoms with the modified Non-Motor Symptom Assessment Scale for Parkinson's Disease (NMSS) (questions 46-75). The patients answered with yes or No. If the patients answered with yes, they were also asked about the worsening of the listed symptoms on a scale of 1-4 (12) .

Normality of distribution was assessed with the Shapiro-Wilk and Kolmogorov-Smirnov test. The Mann-Whitney test was used for single comparisons, while the Kruskal-Wallis test was used for multiple comparisons. The Spearman's rank-order correlation was performed to assess the correlation between four parts of the questionnaire. Statistical significance level was set at P ≤ 0.05. The results are presented as medians (interquartile ranges) with corresponding Z-or U-values, where applicable. Statistical analysis was performed with Graphpad Prism 9 (Graph-Pad Software, San Diego, CA, USA). Table 1 summarizes the socio-demographic data. There were 51 women (58.6%) in the final sample. The mean age was 72.9 years, and the mean duration of the disease was 9.6 years. The majority of respondents were married or partnered (71.3%), lived with their spouse or partner (71.3%), and had completed secondary education (90.8%). (Table 2) . However, patients who lived alone, as opposed to those living with a partner/family, had significant worsening of motor symptoms (P = 0.016) ( Figure 3B ).

The majority of our patients reported more frequent and severe anxiety symptoms (65.35%), while fewer pa- tients reported problems with depression (45.88%). Nonmotor symptoms were not significantly associated with sex (P = 0.676), age (U = 827.5; P = 0.239), settlement size (Z = 3.232; P = 0.198), and check-ups avoidance (U = 402.5; P = 0.119) ( Table 2) . However, non-motor symptoms significantly worsened in patients who lived alone (P = 0.046) ( Figure 4B ), and had longer disease duration (Z = 6.076; P = 0.048) (Figure 4C) . Patients with secondary education had significantly higher anxiety scores than those with upper secondary education (Z-value 2.906; P = 0.0037) ( Figure 3C ). Although the majority of our patients (n = 73) did not avoid checkups, the patients who avoided them had significant worsening of anxiety symptoms (U = 327; P = 0.019) ( Figure 4B ). No significant findings were found in other categories.

Compared with motor and anxiety symptoms, patients less frequently reported depression symptom presence or worsening (Table 2) . Depression symptoms were not significantly associated with sex (P = 0.338), age (P = 0.468), living 

This study had several important findings. First, most of our patients reported worsening of motor symptoms since the beginning of the pandemic. Patients who lived alone reported significantly greater worsening than those living with a partner. Second, the majority of our patients had anxiety problems. Higher HAM-A scores were observed in patients who lived alone, were less educated, had a longer disease duration, and avoided checkups. Third, compared with motor and anxiety symptoms, fewer patients had problems with depression. Patients with longer duration of disease had significantly higher HAM-D scores. Fourth, many patients reported the wors-ening of non-motor symptoms. Higher NMSS scores were observed in patients who lived alone, were less educated, had a longer disease duration, and had higher Charlson comorbidity index.

The majority of our patients reported worsening of both motor and non-motor symptoms. The main cause for this could be a reduced opportunity to engage in physical activities due to the COVID-19 pandemic (8). Croatia had several lockdowns and implemented numerous restrictive measures, all of which drastically limited the everyday activities and the possibility to perform physical activity. Physical activity in PD patients is linked with improved quality of life and mood, better cognitive performance in several domains, and less motor and non-motor disturbances (13) (14) (15) . Thus, less physical activity could be a risk factor for motor and non-motor symptoms worsening. The effect of the COVID-19 pandemic on exercise in PD patients has already been linked with subjective increase of motor and nonmotor symptoms (15) .

Non-motor symptoms are a significant burden in advanced Parkinson's disease, as they lead to significant disability, frequent hospital admissions, poor quality of life, and a shorter life duration (16) . Home confinement during the pandemic was associated with new-onset or worsening of sleep disturbances in Parkinson's disease patients, which can deteriorate the disease symptoms and reduce the quality of life (17) . Our results suggest that living alone, lower education, longer disease duration, and higher Charlson comorbidity index are risk factors for NMS worsening. Patients who live alone, as opposed to patients living with a spouse or partner, showed a greater worsening of both motor and non-motor symptoms, such as anxiety. Social isolation due to the protective measures against the COVID-19 pandemic, made it even harder for these patients to maintain healthy social contacts. Fewer social contacts and living alone could eventually evoke the feeling of loneliness, which can be associated with a lower quality of life in Parkinson's disease patients (18) . Loneliness, social isolation, and living alone increased the likelihood of death, after taking into consideration multiple covariates, by 26%, 29%, and 32%, respectively (19) .

Anxiety and depression negatively affect the quality of life in patients with Parkinson's disease (20) . These patients had a higher incidence of anxiety and depression during the pandemic (21) . The higher incidence could be due to social isolation, fear of contracting COVID-19, or limited access to health care services. We found significantly higher anxiety scores in patients who lived alone, were less educated, had longer disease duration, and had avoided check-ups, while depression scores mostly depended on disease duration. The effect of disease duration on anxiety and depression could be explained by progressive deterioration of motor symptoms due to dopaminergic neuron loss. Motor symptoms in Parkinson's disease patients become more severe over the years, causing a higher degree of disability and requiring higher doses of medications, which positively correlates with anxiety and depression (22) . Furthermore, because of impaired dopamine-dependent adaptation, patients with PD are susceptible to increased levels of psychological stress, which can worsen motor and non-motor symptoms of the disease, but also trigger psychiatric conditions such as depression and anxiety (8, 9) .

The psychological effect of the COVID-19 pandemic has resulted in more frequent avoidance of follow-up examinations. In the USA, 41% respondents avoided or delayed medical care due to COVID-19 concerns (9) . Avoidance of follow-up examinations delays a timely recognition of symptoms worsening and an early treatment. Additionally, social restrictions interrupted routine treatment of neurological diseases. In a study by Zipprich et al (6), 31.3% of patients reported a loss in mobility due to restrictions, partly because of discontinuation of routine therapies. An Ital- ian study (18) reported the greatest worsening in chronic neurological diseases requiring complex clinical treatment and frequent hospital controls, often by a multidisciplinary team (18) .

Although the epidemiological situation in many countries calmed and vaccines have been introduced, many people still fear going to the hospital. This presents a great challenge in the treatment of not only Parkinson's disease patients, but of all chronic patients. Increased levels of cognitive stress, less physical activity, and poor disease control, due to examination avoidance or treatment interruption, create a fertile ground for worsening of Parkinson's disease symptoms and their negative effect on the quality of life.

The limitations of this study are the lack of a control group and the cross-sectional design. For this reason, we could not determine if social isolation affected Parkinson's patients more than it affected the general population. Therefore, we only analyzed people with Parkinson's based on certain characteristics that might be more affected by social isolation.

Based on our results, we can recommend the following: 1) patients who live alone during the pandemic and their families need to receive special care and consultation; 2) greater care should be given to patients who tend to avoid check-ups and they should be offered counseling due to increased anxiety prevalence; and 3) greater focus should be directed to non-motor symptoms as they positively correlate with motor symptoms.

The current pandemic has changed our society in ways that could pose a risk for patients with Parkinson's disease. Further longitudinal studies are warranted to assess the effect of social isolation on the physical and mental health of people with Parkinson's disease and to identify the risk factors for disease exacerbation. These studies need to determine the areas where we should direct our care in Parkinson's disease patients during stressful times in order to achieve timely intervention and better disease control.

Funding None.

Ethical approval was given by the Ethics Committee of Clinical Hospital Center Rijeka (003-05/20-1/141).

declaration of authorship VV and MH conceived and designed the study; MH, GR, EŠ, and EP acquired the data; VR analyzed and interpreted the data; MH and VR drafted the manuscript; GR, EŠ, EP, and VV critically revised the manuscript for important intellectual content; all authors gave approval of the version to be submitted; all authors agree to be accountable for all aspects of the work.

Changes in motor, cognitive, and behavioral symptoms in Parkinson's disease and mild cognitive impairment during the

CoVid-19 lockdown. Front Psychiatry

CoVid-19 and older adults: what we know

CoVid-19 in Parkinson's disease patients living in lombardy, italy

Coronavirus disease 2019 case fatality and Parkinson's disease

the impact of the CoVid-19 pandemic on Parkinson's disease: hidden sorrows and emerging opportunities

Knowledge, attitudes, practices, and burden during the CoVid-19 pandemic in people with Parkinson's disease in Germany

Effect of high-intensity treadmill exercise on motor symptoms in patients with de novo Parkinson disease a phase 2 randomized clinical trial

outcome of Parkinson's disease patients affected by CoVid -19

delay or avoidance of medical care because of CoVid-19-related concerns -united states

the Hamilton anxiety scale: reliability, validity and sensitivity to change in anxiety and depressive disorders

appendix: the Hamilton Rating scale for depression. the Ethical treatment of depression

the metric properties of a novel non-motor symptoms scale for Parkinson's disease: Results from an international pilot study

Physical exercise improves quality of life, depressive symptoms, and cognition across chronic brain disorders

Physical activity changes and correlate effects in patients with Parkinson's disease during CoVid-19 lockdown

the changes of exercise pattern and clinical symptoms in patients with

Parkinson's disease in the era of CoVid-19 pandemic

non-motor symptoms of Parkinson's disease: dopaminergic pathophysiology and treatment

impact of home confinement during CoVid-19 pandemic on sleep parameters in Parkinson's disease

italian neurology outpatient clinic facing saRs-CoV-2 pandemic: data from 2,167 patients. Front

Harris t, stephenson d. loneliness and social isolation as Risk Factors for Mortality

Prevalence of depression and anxiety in parkinson disease and impact on quality of life: a community-based study in spain

Romagnolo a, et al. anxiety, depression, and worries in advanced Parkinson disease during CoVid-19 pandemic

Gamea a. depression and anxiety among patients with Parkinson's disease: frequency, risk factors, and impact on quality of life

Competing interests All authors have completed the Unified Competing Interest form at www.icmje.org/coi_disclosure.pdf (available on request from the corresponding author) and declare: no support from any organization for the submitted work; no financial relationships with any organizations that might have an interest in the submitted work in the previous 3 years; no other relationships or activities that could appear to have influenced the submitted work.