key: cord-0837068-24y5sc48
authors: Abbasi‐Shavazi, Mohammad Jalal
title: COVID‐19, economic recession, and the Refugee situation
date: 2021-02-14
journal: Int Migr
DOI: 10.1111/imig.12820
sha: f1443e2f9125c20e31c3911421e04c7d390c4c93
doc_id: 837068
cord_uid: 24y5sc48

nan

to protect their refugee populations. Take for instance, Pakistan and Iran that have been hosting close to 90 per cent of Afghan refugees over the last four decades. Iran has hosted between three to four million Afghan refugees and migrants over the past four decades. About 980,000 Afghans have refugee cards (UNHCR, 2020b) , 500,000 reside in Iran on work visas, a limited number have student visas, while a significant proportion reside in Iran without residency permits. Like in many other host countries, those who reside without a legal permit are usually denied access to public and welfare services, including having an ID card, and are consequently unable to have the privileges of banking services and internet access.

The unilateral sanctions imposed on Iran have affected its economy, resulting in unmet demand of jobs by the large cohort of the young and educated population were not met. Estimates show that the amount of investment in Iran's economy in 2018 amounted to less than 65 per cent of the volume of investment in 2011. Also, during the last 7-year period, more than 520,000 people, mostly university graduates, have joined the labour market annually; around 55,000 of whom are classified unemployed (Ministry of Cooperatives, Labour & Social Welfare, 2019). Despite a slight recovery under the 'resilient economy programs' during early 2019 (Abdullahi, 2020), the economic downturn followed by the complexities introduced by the pandemic has led to a rise in unemployment and loss of around 1.6 million jobs for the Iranian population (Ministry of Cooperatives, Labour & Social Welfare, 2020). Consequently, the situation of a large number of Afghan refugees and migrants who are mainly employed in entry-level jobs deteriorated, reducing their remittances and leading to the return of some to their home country.

The situation in Afghanistan is no better. The deteriorating socio-economic and political situation in Afghanistan, compounded by COVID-19, is increasing the pressure on returnees to re-migrate in search of greater safety as well as more stable employment to sustain themselves and their families, resulting in increased demand for smuggler services along the Iran-Afghanistan border (Mixed Migration Centre, 2020b). Already, diminishing access of refugees and migrants to local services and economic opportunities has triggered irregular movements towards other destinations such as Turkey that has been a host country and transit hub for Afghan and Syrian ref- The impact of recession shocks on the lives of refugees, who are already among the lower and middle classes of society, is significant. Most work in low-skill and low-pay jobs which are temporary in nature. These unfavourable job conditions force those already living in poverty to look for work and rely on public transport for daily commute. Such exposure makes them more susceptible to coronavirus and related risks. Based on data from eight hosting countries prior to the onset of COVID-19, refugees are 60 per cent more likely than host populations to be working in highly impacted sectors such as construction and food services, manufacturing and retail (Dempster et al., 2020) . As a result, COVID-19 will likely lead to a widespread loss of livelihoods and increase in poverty among refugee populations. Most do not have unemployment and retirement insurance and are considered vulnerable groups.

With the lockdown and closure of many factories, offices and economic centres due to the COVID-19 crisis, many migrants and refugees have lost their job opportunities alongside locals and are facing many economic difficulties. Whilst locals have minimal access to government support measures such as subsidies and livelihood packages, refugees and migrants are denied such assistance. As refugees and migrants have limited capital and savings, rising debt and drawing down of individual savings will be extra challenges leading to their anxiety and stress. Child deprivation is likely to exacerbate, especially among boys, as they are forced to leave education to work and support the family. This is evident in many low-income refugee families whose first strategy in such critical situations is to make up for the lost sources of income.

Another major problem facing refugees is continuing access to educational services. After the launch of online education systems many refugee families, especially on the outskirts of cities, have missed out, mainly due to the lack of access or inability to source smartphones, the inability of parents to set up this system, and inadequate coverage of communication services in the group's neighbourhoods. Women and girls are usually more | 291 COVID-19, ECONOMIC RECESSION, AND THE REFUGEE SITUATION disadvantaged due to the relative increase in the physical and psychological vulnerability of refugee women during pandemic.

At times when societies face a crisis of recession and unemployment, some may think that refugees are the cause of unemployment and these difficult conditions (Goldstein & Peters, 2014) , and this may lead to xenophobia and discriminatory discourse against refugees. The social effects of this discourse, or possible discriminatory treatment of immigrants and refugees, can in some ways be more dangerous than coronavirus itself.

The negative economic consequences of the pandemic are immense, and recovery from it will take time. The timeline of overcoming the pandemic, its total impacts on employment and loss of jobs are all uncertain. Undoubtedly, the conditions created by the outbreak of the coronavirus will lead to changes in immigration laws, and governments may revise their priorities regarding migration and refugees under the current economic circumstances.

Future direction of policies and programs should include short, medium and long-term plans. Modelling the post-COVID era, taking into account the conditions of refugees and their numbers in the future of the global economy, is a planning necessity for any country. Special attention is to be given to vulnerable groups during and postpandemic. Equitable management of resources and distribution of services is imperative both in the absence of a vaccine and in the rollout phase. In the long run, the resilience of societies must be considered so that in situations like these, individuals and families possess the necessary social safety nets to withstand hardships and difficulties. Supporting host countries must be on the agenda of international organisations and donor agencies enabling them to continue their services to refugees who are disproportionally disadvantaged during and after COVID-19.

In the absence of government support, utilising social potential and strengthening the sense of togetherness and social trust through public awareness campaigns can improve the wellbeing of vulnerable populations and refugees. When public support for refugees is known to fall during economic downturns, policymakers' role in advocating for social and economic inclusion of the needy as well as refugees is vital. Refugees and forced migrants are under-researched in the international migration literature due to limited data availability (Abbasi-Shavazi & Kraly, 2018) . Understanding the situation of these vulnerable groups and designing new protection policies warrants further data collection.

The peer review history for this article is available at https://publo ns.com/publo n/10.1111/IMIG.12820.

The opinions expressed in this Commentary are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Editors, Editorial Board, International Organization for Migration nor John Wiley & Sons. 

Nativism or economic threat: attitudes towards immigrants during the great recession. International Interactions: Empirical and Theoretical Research in International Relations

The Demography of Refugee and Forced Migration. The Netherlands: Springer. Ministry of Cooperatives, Labour and Social Welfare (2019) Achievements of government employment programs for women

Predicting the labour market situation and identifying the driver businesses in the face of sanctions

Mixed Migration Centre. (2020a) Destination Unknown Afghans on the move in Turkey

Mixed Migration Centre. (2020b) The Impact of COVID-19 on the Smuggling of Refugees and Migrants from Afghanistan

Commentary: How is COVID-19 Reshaping Labour Migration?

4a04/force d-displ aceme nt-passe s-80-milli on-mid-2020-covid -19-tests -refug ee-prote ction.html United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR). (2020b) Global Trends of Forced Displacement in 2019