key: cord-0823606-umlxwnid authors: Searle, T.; Ali, F. R.; Al‐Niaimi, F. title: Surgical plume in dermatology: an insidious and often overlooked hazard date: 2020-08-11 journal: Clin Exp Dermatol DOI: 10.1111/ced.14350 sha: 80a94d53b2eb4b75d3ccf5900e58480a71c628e4 doc_id: 823606 cord_uid: umlxwnid Dermatologists performing surgical procedures face occupational and health hazards when exposed to surgical plume released during electrosurgical and ablative laser procedures. These hazardous fumes have toxic, infectious and carcinogenic effects. Understanding this risk is of particular importance during the COVID‐19 pandemic as the understanding of the transmissibility and infectious nature of the virus is still evolving rapidly. In this article, we present the hazards from laser and surgical plumes, and discuss possible preventative measures aimed at reducing these risks. Dermatologists frequently undertake procedures using electrosurgical and ablative laser devices, generating a cloud of surgical smoke known as plume, which can pose harm to both patients and staff. Surgical plume is made up of 95% water and 5% particulate matter with toxic, carcinogenic and infectious potential. 1 Despite this occupational hazard, the risks posed to dermatologists from particulate matter released in surgical plume have received little attention. We discuss the potential hazards of surgical plume and the protective measures that can be taken to mitigate these risks, which we believe are particularly important in the COVID-19 era. The primary hazard of surgical smoke is its propensity to cause harm following inhalation. Airborne spread and diffusivity of particulate matter is dependent on its size, with smaller particles having greater diffusivity than larger ones. Particles < 5 lm in diameter can travel down the lower respiratory tract (including the bronchioles and alveoli) and are generally referred to as 'aerosols', whereas larger particles (> 5 lm) are referred to as 'droplets' and can reach the upper respiratory tract (including the pharynx, trachea and bronchi). 2 The mean particle size produced in the plumes of electrosurgical and ablative laser devices (such as the CO 2 laser) is predominantly < 1 lm. 3, 4 There is currently some confusion in the literature as the terms 'airborne' and 'aerosols' are occasionally used interchangeably. For the purposes of this article, we have adhered to the Public Health England definition of 'aerosols' as particles of < 5 lm in diameter. 5 Electrocautery and ablative lasers generate plumes with aerosols (small particle diameter) and as such are defined as 'aerosol-generating procedures'. the most egregious risk (Table 1) . 6 Hydrogen cyanide, acetylene and 1,3-butadiene ethyl-benzene-styrene, carbon disulphide, methyl propane and toluene have also been identified in variable concentrations. 7, 8 Of note, the latter two components have been found in higher concentrations in surgical plume than in both cigarette smoke and city air. 9 The pathogenic potential of each component upon inhalation is unknown (Fig. 1) . Hazardous components of laser plume include acetonitrile, acrolein, ammonia, benzene, ethylene and toluene 10 ( Table 2 ). Various factors affect the composition of surgical plume. These relate to the type of procedure performed, the instrument and parameters used and the tissue being treated. 11 The instrument and parameters used affect the nature of the particulate matter. 5 Bipolar and ultrasonic instruments have been shown to produce less plume (measured as 'visibility') than unipolar/monopolar devices. 12 In addition, more plume appears to be generated with greater energy settings: during tonsillectomies with monopolar electrocautery, particle concentrations were 9.5 times higher when the power was set to 20 W vs. 12 W. 13 Tissue-related particulate composition studies have shown that thermal decomposition of adipose tissue released more aldehydes and lower concentrations of toluene in the smoke, whereas ablation of epidermal tissue produced greater levels of toluene, ethyl benzene and xylene. 14 Acrylonitrile is a volatile chemical that releases hydrogen cyanide and is absorbed by the skin and lungs. Short-term exposure has been linked to headaches, eye irritation, vomiting, sneezing and dizziness, while long-term exposure has been associated with cancer in humans. 15 Benzene released in electrocautery plume has been linked with haematological cancers, can affect the central nervous system (CNS) and is an irritant. 15 Toluene is highly pungent, may depress the CNS and can act as an irritant. Other common components of surgical plume (including ethyl benzene, xylene, styrene, formaldehyde) are variously carcinogenic, irritant, cause respiratory disease and may cause haematological problems. Although human studies have not been reported, there is evidence from animal models that pulmonary damage (including emphysematous change) can be Ample evidence exists to suggest that inhalation of plumes is carcinogenic to humans, due to both the toxic metabolites and to underlying carcinogenic viruses that may be contained in the plume. Tomita et al. found that the amount of smoke condensates produced from 1 g of tissue using a CO 2 laser and electrocautery was equivalent to that of three and six cigarettes, respectively. 17 Another study reported that daily plume generated from monopolar electrocautery on human and porcine muscle tissue was equivalent to 27-30 cigarettes. 18 The carcinogenic risk from polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) generated from electrocautery plume is estimated to be 20-30 times higher than that posed by the risk from environmental pollution. A study reported the 70-year lifetime cancer risk of surgeons exposed to PAHs in electrocautery smoke was 117 times greater than that of a person exposed to the safe level of 1 9 10 À6 advised by the World Health Organization. 11, 19 Infectious risk Surgical plume harbours viable particulate pathogens with the potential of transmission and infection. These pathogens may originate from the skin, mucocutaneous surfaces and body fluids. 1, 15 Lower-temperature plumes (such as CO 2 laser plumes) are associated with higher infectivity. 20 Coagulase-negative Staphylococci were identified in the plume of 5 of 13 patients undergoing ablative laser treatment, with 1 case each of Corynebacterium and Neisseria also reported. 21 A study looking at concentrations of human papillomavirus (HPV) DNA from treated plantar warts in both ablative laser and electrocautery plume found the virus in 62% and 57%, respectively. 22 Another study compared the incidence of warts in CO 2 laser surgeons and population-based controls. The incidence of plantar, nasopharyngeal and genital/perianal warts was significantly greater among the CO 2 laser surgeons, suggesting that treated tissue containing HPV viruses can be inhaled and eventuate in the upper airway of operators via the laser plume. 23 The risk of viral particle inhalation is supported by two cases of laryngeal papillomatosis secondary to plume inhalation from CO 2 laser and electrocautery in healthcare professionals involved in the treatment of HPV papillomas. 24, 25 A DNA analysis of HPV subtyping in one case confirmed the identical subtypes 6 and 11 in the operator. 24 HPV virus particles are estimated to be about 55 nm in diameter and their small size makes them inhalable during aerosol-generating procedures, 24 which is particularly concerning as they are associated with oropharyngeal cancer. Evidence exists on the presence of blood and bloodborne viruses in surgical plume. Hepatitis B virus (HBV) has been found in 91% of surgical plumes generated by laparoscopic surgery of affected patients. 26, 27 An in vitro study of tissue samples infected with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) treated with CO 2 laser found HIV antigens detectable in 3 of 12 tube segments after 1 week of culture and in 1 of 12 after 2 weeks. PCR analysis of the sterile tubing through which vaporized debris from the laser CO 2 passed was positive for proviral HIV DNA upon immediate sampling and on day 14 in culture. 28 Although there are no reported cases of COVID-19 transmission via surgical plumes, the small size of coronavirus virions (50-200 nm) 29 and their presence outside the respiratory tract in bodily fluids (including in blood, peritoneal fluid and faeces) 30, 31 and their high transmissibility makes the presence of the virus in inhaled surgical plume highly plausible. 32 Decreasing the volume of plume, with a consequent reduction in the risk of viable viral particles present, can be attempted by using lower power settings and considering the use of bipolar cautery. Given the fact that ablative lasers generate greater concentrations of particles of greater infectious potential, it is highly recommended that ablative lasers are only used in patients confirmed as COVID-19free, with the maximum protection used such as filtering face piece (FFP)3 masks with appropriate filters, and plume extraction. 33, 34 Protective measures Appropriate precautious measures for surgical plume include appropriate masks and eyewear, smoke evacuation, ventilation and suction. Standard surgical masks do not adequately filter particulate matter < 5 lm (including most toxic metabolites and viral particles) from inhalation. However, they might impede larger droplets or splashes perioperatively. 32 If applied correctly, FFP2 and FFP3 masks can filter up to 94% and 99%, respectively, of particles from entering the respiratory tract. 35 Masks should be properly fitted to reduce air leaks, covering both the nose and mouth, and staff should have annual fit testing. Protective eyewear should be encouraged to prevent ocular irritation and possible contamination. 36 General ventilation dilutes the contaminated air before levels reach hazardous concentrations and is recommended. 37 Smoke evacuation is necessary to trap contaminants close to the source andin addition to aiding in clear visibilitycan prevent the diffusion of particulate matter to the atmosphere, thus reducing exposure to both the patient and staff. In a study investigating the plume released during laser hair removal, when the smoke extractor was turned off for 30 s the particulate matter content increased by 26 times compared with baseline environmental levels. 37 Although laser hair removal is not an ablative procedure, plume is generated from hair shaft vaporization. The most common form of plume evacuation is through dispersion, in which there is suctioning of the generated smoke into a central vacuum. 11 Other techniques include smoke evacuation using filters. These can be attached to suction devices to prevent components of the plume diffusing into the environment. Evacuators can be built into electrocautery devices. Filters tend to use both suction and mechanical filtering, such as a combination of highefficiency particulate air (HEPA) filters, which can filter particles ≥ 0.3 lm in size, and ultra-low particulate air (ULPA) filters, which can filter 99.99% of particles ≥ 0.12 lm. 11 Filters must be replaced frequently, and care is needed to prevent the release of any particulate matter that has accumulated, and to prevent the growth of microorganisms. 11 The UK Health and Safety Executive recommend routine use of extractors for surgical plume. 38 However, only 66% of UK plastic surgery units were reported to use smoke extractor devices, highlighting the potential occupational hazards. 18 Conclusion Surgical plumes potentially have toxic, carcinogenic and infectious capacity. Surgical masks confer little protection to the respiratory tract against aerosols generated during surgery or CO 2 laser procedures. To reduce the quantity of plume generated, operators should consider using bipolar (as opposed to unipolar or monopolar) cautery at the lowest power settings. Mechanisms to remove the generated plumes through vacuum extraction should be implemented, as well as the use of appropriate personal protective equipment. ª 2020 British Association of Dermatologists • Surgical plume is a risk that dermatologists may face when carrying out common surgical procedures such as electrocautery and laser. • The potential infectious risk of surgical plumes including reports of HPV transmission. • The risk of carcinogenicity of surgical smoke caused by its toxic components. • Bipolar cautery and lower power settings generate lower concentrations of surgical plume. • Viruses and bacteria can be transmitted via surgical plume. • There are no reports of COVID-19 transmission via surgical plume; however, this is physically possible and may represent a hazard to operators. • There remains a need for plume extraction and appropriate masks during plume-generating procedures. Surgical smoke and the dermatologist Recognition of aerosol transmission of infectious agents: a commentary The hazards of surgical smoke Health risks associated with exposure to surgical smoke for surgeons and operation room personnel COVID-19: infection prevention and control (IPC) Chemical composition of smoke produced by high-frequency electrosurgery in a closed gaseous environment Composition of volatile organic compounds in diathermy plume as detected by selected ion flow tube mass spectrometry Chemical composition and potential hazards of electrocautery smoke Respirable particles in the excimer laser plume A single-blind controlled study of electrocautery and ultrasonic scalpel smoke plumes in laparoscopic surgery Surgical smoke exposure in operating room personnel: a review Analysis of surgical smoke produced by various energy-based instruments and effect on laparoscopic visibility Effect of electrocautery settings on particulate concentrations in surgical plume during tonsillectomy Chemical composition of smoke produced by highfrequency electrosurgery Awareness of surgical smoke hazards and enhancement of surgical smoke prevention among the gynecologists Effect of plume produced by the Nd:YAG laser and electrocautery on the respiratory system Mutagenicity of smoke condensates induced by CO2-laser irradiation and electrocauterization Surgical smoke -a health hazard in the operating theatre: a study to quantify exposure and a survey of the use of smoke extractor systems in UK plastic surgery units Cancer risk of incremental exposure to polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in electrocautery smoke for mastectomy personnel Surgical smoke and infection control Microbiologic activity in laser resurfacing plume and debris Infectious papillomavirus in the vapor of warts treated with carbon dioxide laser or electrocoagulation: detection and protection Risk of acquiring human papillomavirus from the plume produced by the carbon dioxide laser in the treatment of warts Laryngeal papillomatosis with human papillomavirus DNA contracted by a laser surgeon Laryngeal papillomatosis -first recognition in Germany as an occupational disease in an operating room nurse Floating aerial blood mists in the operating room Detecting hepatitis B virus in surgical smoke emitted during laparoscopic surgery Presence of human immunodeficiency virus DNA in laser smoke Respiratory virus shedding in exhaled breath and efficacy of face masks SARS-CoV-2 is present in peritoneal fluid in COVID-19 patients Prolonged presence of SARS-CoV-2 viral RNA in faecal samples Epidemiological and clinical characteristics of 99 cases of 2019 novel coronavirus pneumonia in Wuhan, China: a descriptive study Safe management of surgical smoke in the age of COVID-19 COVID-19 pandemic: effects and evidence-based recommendations for otolaryngology and head and neck surgery practice Medical masks and respirators for the protection of healthcare workers from SARS-CoV-2 and other viruses Surgical smoke: risk assessment and mitigation strategies Gaseous and particulate content of laser hair removal plume Evidence for Exposure and Harmful Effects of Diathermy Plumes (Surgical Smoke) To gain up-to-date knowledge on the hazards associated with surgical plume. Which of these infectious particles has not currently been found to be transmissible by studies investigating surgical plume? (a) Human papillomavirus 6. What is the safe level for polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, according to the World Health Organization (WHO)?(a) 1 9 10 À6 (b) 1 9 10 À9 (c) 1 9 10 À12 (d) 1 9 10 6 (e) 1 9 10 9 Infection with human papillomavirus can cause the development of which of these cancers? Once the test is passed, you will receive a certificate and the learning activity can be added to your RCP CPD diary as a self-certified entry.This activity will be available for CPD credit for 2 years following its publication date. At that time, it will be reviewed and potentially updated and extended for an additional period.