key: cord-0808842-56jge1ys authors: Sahoo, Swapnajeet; Padhy, Susanta Kumar; Ipsita, Jigyansa; Mehra, Aseem; Grover, Sandeep title: Demystifying the myths about COVID-19 infection and its societal importance date: 2020-06-18 journal: Asian J Psychiatr DOI: 10.1016/j.ajp.2020.102244 sha: 860e0ccee58d766f458b6cd25c0a2023d210bf9f doc_id: 808842 cord_uid: 56jge1ys nan Myth is commonly considered as a folklore genre consisting of narratives/stories that play a fundamental role in human beings' everyday lives. These are often endorsed by leaders/rulers/religious preachers and explain to a great extent the functioning society and shape the beliefs of people. There is a potential role J o u r n a l P r e -p r o o f of cultural and religious beliefs/traditions/customs/rituals, which add a flavor to the public's mindset in a particular region/country and influence the propagation or acceptance of a myth (Morales, 2013) . Myths related to various infections have been prevalent from time to time, and it takes a long battle to demystify the existing myths by providing a realistic evidence-based approach. In recent times, some of the common infections, which are have been associated with myths, include Leprosy, Tuberculosis, and Flu (CDC, 2018; Haldimand-Norfolk Health and Social Sciences, 2018; World Health Organisation, 2019) . In recent times, the World is facing COVID-19 infection, which has created havoc in the entire World and has affected all aspects of human lives. With the exponential rise in the number of confirmed cases and deaths per day across the World, the health care system has been affected the most. With no potential medication or vaccine developed (to date) against the virus, it is expected that the morbidity and mortality associated with COVID-19 infection is going to increase in the near future. Despite creating awareness and providing adequate information to the general public through telecommunication (radio, television advertisements, public health messages by prominent celebrities and national leaders) and distributing pamphlets/signboards at public places about infection control measures and mode of spread of the infection, still, there are a large number of myths associated with the spread and cure/treatment of COVID-19 infection in the society. These myths are traveling from one person to the other, through social media platforms. These myths can be very dangerous, as these can lead to overcomplacency and lead to a reduction in actually needed practices, or following some of these myths can lead to other health hazards. In this regard, the various health authorities [World Health Organization While the healthcare systems are unable to find a solution/cure to the COVID-19 infection, various facts have emerged, which have low validity and are gradually turning into potential myths related to COVID-19 (Boston, 2020; Carbone et al., 2020; "Myth busters," n.d.) . We need to understand that, when we consider something as useful or efficacious in managing or preventing a health condition, the intervention, should undergo a well-designed, adequately powered double-blind randomized controlled trial (DB-RCT). Further, as per the levels of evidence even a cohort or case-control study or any degree of evidence based on case series/case reports or expert opinions can be considered to be a trial to render an intervention to be propagated as justifiable or for the need to be tested (Burns et al., 2011; "CEBM- The Centre for Evidence Based Medicine," 2020; Sackett, 1989) . Till the time any intervention has been unequivocally proved to be efficacious by any of the above-mentioned types of studies, the same should not be claimed as efficacious. In this background, if we look at the various claims made for improving the immunity and resultant prevention of COVID-19, many of these have not been subjected to the rigorous evaluation. Hence, all such claims can be questioned. However, if these are propagated as efficacious or useful, these will also boarder on to be labeled as myths. Currently, prevailing myths related to COVID-19 infection can be categorized into those related to the spread of infection, source of spread of infection, preventive measures, and cure. Some of the commonly prevalent myths related to COVID-19 infection are listed in Table-1. J o u r n a l P r e -p r o o f No evidence that regularly gargling has protected people from COVID-19 infection. While this strategy may help soothe a sore throat due to any flu-like infection, however, this practice will not prevent anybody from developing COVID-19 infection if exposed to the same. Drinking warm water and getting enough sunlight are effective in preventing COVID-19. Heat or warm fluids kill the virus. No evidence that the nCoV-SARS virus can be killed at higher temperatures. Drinking warm water and getting enough sunlight may have other health benefits. Sunlight is good to get Vitamin D, which has a role in modulating the innate and adaptive immune responses. But too much exposure to sunlight may also lead to sunburn. Taking a hot bath can prevent COVID-19 disease. Heat kills the virus. Taking a hot bath will not prevent you from contracting COVID-19. Taking a hot bath with extremely hot water can be harmful, as it can cause burns to the body. The COVID-19 infection cannot be transmitted in areas with hot and humid climates. Spraying alcohol or chlorine all over your body can kill the COVID-19 virus. Since alcohol is used in sanitizers and chlorine is used in hypochlorite solutions, it can be used to kill the virus from the body by applying it all over. Spraying alcohol or chlorine all over your body will not kill viruses that have already entered the body. Spraying such substances can be harmful to clothes or mucous membranes (i.e., eyes, mouth). Both are used to disinfect surfaces, but they need to be used in appropriate proportion/quantities under appropriate recommendations 8. Sniffing/inhaling alcohol can protect from developing the COVID-19 infection. Alcohol can kill any virus which has entered the respiratory tract. No evidence for the protective effect of alcohol inhalation against COVID-19 infection 9. Vaccines against pneumonia can protect you against the COVID-19 infection. Vaccines against pneumonia, such as pneumococcal vaccine and Haemophilus influenza Type B vaccine, do not protect against the novel coronavirus. Researchers across the world are trying to develop a vaccine against COVID-19. Wearing a mask or N95 mask can only prevent the transmission of COVID-19. There is evidence that masks can prevent an asymptomatic patient of COVID-19 from unwittingly spreading the virus. Only masks won't help, but proper and adequate infection control measures, social distancing, appropriate use of masks, and hand hygiene is the best possible solution to prevent getting infected. Drinking alcohol can cure COVID-19. Alcohol is present in alcohol sanitizers which Using cow dung and cow's urine can cure the virus. Cow's urine is the most sacred thing on Earth, and it can purify one's body from all types of infection. No stream of medicine acknowledges the efficacy of cow's urine in the treatment or prevention of COVID-19. Religious chants can protect us from the virus/ Clapping hands creates vibrations that destroy the coronavirus Clapping hands creates sound waves, and the sound produced is sensed through the vibrations of our eardrums, which then creates oscillations in the fluid in our inner ear and increases our ability to fight with the virus. No evidence regarding this. The vibration created by chanting would not even be sensed by something as small as a virus. Chanting and religious discourses with clapping hands can be an effective coping skill to combat stress and anxiety related to COVID-19. It boosts up the mood and calms the mind. The new coronavirus can be transmitted through mosquito bite. -No evidence that mosquitoes can transmit the COVID-19 infection. No need to worry about the relationship between mosquito bites and developing the COVID-19 infection. Pets at Ordering or buying products shipped from overseas will make a person sick. As per the WHO, the likelihood of becoming infected with COVID-19 from a commercial package is low since it has likely traveled over several days and had been exposed to different temperatures and conditions during transit. The potential risk of getting infected from overseas products is minimal /negligible. Newspapers, milk packets, and vegetables can transmit the infection. The public needs to be reassured that pregnancy and childbirth are safe, and the same precautions are to be taken by pregnant women as the general population. Pregnant women with suspected or confirmed COVID-19 need to give birth by cesarean section (CS) only. Virus can spread through normal vaginal delivery. The WHO clearly advises that CS should only be performed when medically indicated/ justified. The mode of birth should be individualized and based on a woman's preferences alongside obstetric indications. CS should not be asked unless indicated by the treating obstetrician. If pregnancy occurs, there is a high risk of miscarriage, abortion, or congenital malformations due to COVID-19. Pregnancy is risky during COVID times. There is currently no evidence to support that acquiring COVID-19 predisposes to a heightened risk of miscarriage. There is also no reported evidence to suggest that the virus will cause any problem with fetal It is very unlikely that breastfeeding can spread the virus. Breast milk in all settings improves survival and provides lifelong advantages to newborns. Following delivery, the WHO recommends that the baby needs to be provided with skinto-skin care, including kangaroo care with adequate respiratory hygiene and hand hygiene measures and breastfeeding the baby. All health care workers (HCWs) are a potential source of COVID-19 infection. HCWs are exposed to patients with COVID-19 infection. HCWs are regarded as the front line warriors for tackling with COVID-19 infection. They are wellequipped with personal protective equipments (PPEs), which protect them against contracting COVID-19 infection. There is an urgent need to create awareness in the general public that HCWs take all safety measures to protect themselves from getting infected. There is no need to worry or to panic when they come near any HCWs. Someone without symptoms cannot spread the infection. Respiratory symptoms are mandatory to be present to spread the virus. measures to be taken when dealing with a suspected COVID-19 person. 14. All those who been quarantined because of travel history had developed the COVID-19 infection. Foreigners or Indians who had recently returned from abroad had spread the COVID-19 infection. The COVID-19 infection gradually spread across the World since its outbreak in China to almost all countries. However, it is not true that anyone who has a positive travel history to abroad is harboring COVID-19 infection. Quarantine means under observation. Therefore, those who had returned from abroad are kept under quarantine to check for any development of symptoms to detect for COVID-19. This does not mean that they are already infected with COVID-19. Someone who has recovered from COVID-19 infection can still spread the infection. Once a COVID-19 patient always a patient, i.e., a patient carries the virus even if recovered. Once recovered or tested negative as per WHO (RT-PCR) viral testing, the person is declared recovered i.e., he/she is immune to the infection and has developed immunity or antibodies against the COVID-19 and therefore, they are absolutely safe, and they cannot transmit the infection. The public should be made aware that those recovered do not carry the virus potential for infection and must be accepted back in the community with due respect. Unprotected sexual intercourse can lead to spreading of COVID-19 infection. People who get the coronavirus/COVID-19 will die. Nature is trying to revive, and COVID-19 is Nature's or God's way to reduce population. About 80-90% of persons infected with COVID-19 are asymptomatic or have milder flu symptoms, and the death rate is below 2%. Not to panic or get afraid if you are infected with COVID-19. In most of instances, it will be a milder form of flu-like illness. The health care workers will take appropriate measures if the condition worsens (which is seen in 8-10% cases), mostly in those with pre-existing chronic medical illnesses. The Indian Immune system is better than the West, and thus, Indians will survive Covid-19 infection better. Indians have a good diet and more robust and hardworking so COVID-19 can't affect us. No such comparative data on the immune system of Indians Vs. West is available. Need to consider that people of all ages, of all races and ethnicity, are equally prone to contract the COVID-19 infection 4. COVID-19 can be treated by colloidal silver, vitamins, teas, and essential oils. These materials have antibactericidal and anti-viral properties. No evidence for any special role for colloidal silver, vitamins, teas, and essential oils in dealing with COVID-19. Not to follow/believe any such procedures or unless approved by the National and International Health authorities. Having had malaria makes one immune. Chloroquine or Hydroxy Chloroquine is being used to treat COVID-19, which is an anti-malarial drug. No evidence yet in this regard. If this was true, then considering India to be the Malaria capital of People should take adequate measures to remain protected from getting infected by malaria as well as COVID-19. the World should have low caseload, which is untrue. Anti-bacterial drugs are effective for therapy of COVID-19 -COVID-19 is a viral infection; therefore antibacterial agents are not effective for treating COVID-19 but are useful for treating secondary bacterial infections. No need to stock/ pile antibiotics and always use antibiotics rationally and only when advised by a medical practitioner. Hand sanitizers are better than soap and water. Alcohol-based sanitizers are the most potent disinfectants. Hand hygiene measures by either alcohol sanitizers or soap and water are equally effective in protecting one from getting infected. No need to buy hand sanitizers or hoard sanitizers. Simple soap and water is an equally effective strategy that can be followed. Thermal scanners can detect COVID-19 -Thermal scanners can only detect fever, which is one of the usual symptoms of COVID-19, but a person infected with COVID-19 may take 2-10 days after infection to develop fever. Not 100% effective screening method. If the public water supply is contaminated with COVID-19, the entire community will be infected. --No evidence that the virus can spread through the water supply. In fact, the treatment in water facilities/ having a good shower can protect from getting infected. No need to believe in this myth. Those immunized with BCG are more likely not to get COVID-19 infection BCG vaccine improves immunity against all infections. There is no evidence that the BCG vaccine protects people against infection with COVID-19. WHO to date has not recommended BCG vaccination for prevention of COVID-19, BCG Vaccination prevents severe forms of TB. In the absence of evidence regarding any efficacy of BCG in COVID-19, people should refrain from believing the BCG vaccine is protective against J o u r n a l P r e -p r o o f few trials are underway though. COVID-19. It can engender a false sense of security and hence should not be believed unless proved. No vaccine can be developed against COVID-19 infection. God has sent COVID-19 as a declaration suggesting the end of the human race. Researchers are actively engaged in developing a vaccine against COVID-19. However, clinical trials on a vaccine for COVID-19 may take a long time (months) to reach definite results. The public needs to keep patience and to wait until any news about the vaccine is published by trustworthy websites/news or declared by the WHO. Refrain from believing on any random news about the vaccine being discovered DB RCT -Double blind Randomised controlled trial. The myths listed in the table have been discussed so as to disseminate knowledge and information with regard to COVID-19 (Tandon, 2020) as these are being circulated on various social media platforms and can be regarded as a potential source of anxiety related to COVID-19. Those myths related to spreading/transmission of COVID-19 have been bothering the public to think twice before using newspapers/vegetables etc. and many are avoiding non-vegetarian foods with the fear of being infected. Further, many have hoarded or stockpiled antibiotics, essential oils, Vitamin C tablets, masks, sanitizers, etc. to protect themselves from running out of stock of these commodities. These myths can also lead to a false sense of security of being immune to the infection and resultant exposure to high-risk situations. Harboring such myths can be detrimental to society as all these create a hue and cry and chaos among the people. People need to understand that spreading such information can be punishable. In this regard, the Cyber Police/Cyber cell has been active ("WhatsApp Admin Warned For Fake Coronavirus Post," n.d.) and have traced all those persons circulating wrong messages and tried to demystify many myths through telecommunication awareness programs (DelhiMarch 20 et al., n.d.) . There have been instances of persons being heavily fined or being arrested when found to be spreading false claims of treating/curing COVID-19 (S. Bhandari, 2020). If we compare the myths related to COVID-19 with myths related to leprosy, TB and Flu, there are some commonalities about the major themes of myths, i.e., the myths mainly prevail around the causation, disease transmission, and cure. However, the COVID-19 infection has emerged very recently and affected almost all the countries of the World in a short span of time. Accordingly, the myths related to its spread, transmission are much more. This is complicated because there is social media's availability to almost everyone in the World. Hence, these myths spread very fast and extensively across the globe. Further, lack of any potential medicine/cure/vaccine has also led to the emergence of multiple claims about the various aspects of COVID-19 infection. Some of the facts that are not yet clear, but there is some evidence to support the same. Accordingly, these facts cannot be labeled as myths. Emerging evidence suggests that there could be the faeco-oral transmission of COVID-19 infection or SARS-nCoV-2. Recent studies indicate that prolonged viral shedding in feces is seen in symptomatic patients with COVID-19 as well as in those recovered from COVID-19 (more so in children) (Wu et al., 2020; Xu et al., 2020; Yeo et al., 2020) . Therefore, as the research evidence is growing at a faster rate about J o u r n a l P r e -p r o o f different aspects of COVID-19, we need to be aware of the potential facts about the illness and not to believe in any facts which have no authentic evidence or not claimed by any International Health body (like WHO). The very nature of the myth is that it gets publicized widely in a very short time, and people tend to follow a myth without questioning its authenticity or evidence for/against a myth. Moreover, during a pandemic, crowd psychology plays a major driving force in believing and practicing a ritual/procedure to find a solution. Certain acts/beliefs can enhance public stigma related to COVID-19. Both myths and public stigma get combined, shaping society's behavior toward disease and those infected by the same. Many myths related to the spread of infection are compounded with the stigma associated with patients recovered from COVID-19 infection and the health care workers (HCWs), working in COVID-19 wards/hospitals. These are leading to a social boycott of people such as debarring HCWs to stay in the same housing society (H. "COVID-19," n.d.) , asking them to stay away from the public, avoiding interaction with the persons recovered from COVID-19 infection or those suspected of having COVID-19 infection, etc. Therefore, a proper and planned awareness program taking into account all the stakeholders is the need of the hour, which can help change society's outlook from following the unhealthy/unacceptable norms/myths to acceptable/healthy evidence-based norms. The Government and the media have a significant role in dealing with the prevailing and emerging myths related to COVID-19 infection. One of the main responsibilities of the GovernmentGovernment and the health care authorities is to deal with the widely prevalent and rapidly spreading new misconceptions/myths related to COVID-19. If these are not curtailed, then these can be very detrimental. Leaders/health officials should look at the evidence before endorsing anything related to spreading, prevention and treatment of COVID-19 infection, and leaders/health officials should look at the evidence, rather than blindly supporting the same. Additionally, if something is found to be of use, for example, some of the things, which are claimed to improve the immunity, and then the leaders/health officials should clearly state that the evidence of generic nature, rather than specific for COVID-19 and the strategy has not been evaluated specifically for COVID-19. Further, they should say that these strategies are not a substitute for the proven hand hygiene measures, use of masks, and maintaining physical distancing. More awareness activities and messages should be delivered through all possible means (Telecommunication/advertisements /distributing pamphlets/ holding public webinars etc.) to counter the emerging myths. Additionally, strict legal action needs to be taken against people spreading fake news/making false claims during the pandemic. More and more stringent action and punishments must be declared by the Judiciary system to control the spread of myths/fake claims. The mainstream media should also be very cautious in presenting the different information about the COVID-19 infection. Media, in its enthusiasm, should not try to discuss the studies evaluating the scientific evidence for various issues related to COVID-19 infection, until and unless these have some public message and have been proved unequivocally. The public should be made aware that they should always follow authentic websites such as WHO website, CDC website or Ministry of Health and Family Welfare website of India (mohfw.in) to gain knowledge and stay updated regarding COVID-19. The public should be made aware of questioning the authenticity or level of evidence of a publicized treatment or strategy being circulated or advocated by any person or group of persons before believing any fact blindly. Further, awareness should be raised to follow the evidence-based preventive measures such as hand hygiene, social distancing, and infection control measures to safeguard against getting infected. Myths have been widely prevalent about various diseases since time immemorial. Myths have a cultural influence and can have a varying degree of impact over the society. Many myths have been related to other infections (Leprosy, Tuberculosis, Flu/Influenza), but with time and evidence-based approaches, these have proved to be wrong. The current COVID-19 pandemic and its uncertainty had given rise to various myths. Some of these myths are leading to widespread stigma in society. Additionally, these myths have the potential of making people over-complacent and resultantly more at risk of developing the infection. All these myths are having a widespread impact on public viewpoint and disease transmission. Therefore, possible and prompt steps should be taken by appropriate authorities to demystify the myths in due time. Considering the current status of COVID-19 infection to be so dynamic, people should evaluate things properly, before considering them to be useful. Doctor harassed by his Dwarka housing society Corona wale Baba": Godman claims to cure Coronavirus, arrested [WWW Document Myths vs Facts The Levels of Evidence and their role in Evidence-Based Medicine Coronaviruses: Facts, Myths, and Hypotheses CDC, 2020. Coronavirus Disease World Leprosy Day Control Prev Centre for Evidence Based Medicine COVID-19: Doctors, beaten and harassed, plan silent protest across India Myths Associated with Tuberculosis. Ministry of AYUSH [WWW Document Myth and the construction of meaning in mediated culture Rules of evidence and clinical recommendations on the use of antithrombotic agents The COVID-19 pandemic, personal reflections on editorial responsibility WhatsApp Admin Warned For Fake Coronavirus Post: Police [WWW Document Prolonged presence of SARS-CoV-2 viral RNA in faecal samples Characteristics of pediatric SARS-CoV-2 infection and potential evidence for persistent fecal viral shedding Enteric involvement of coronaviruses: is faecal-oral transmission of SARS-CoV-2 possible? The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest. We have no financial disclosure to make. None