key: cord-0801944-p06ki0rq authors: Mamun, Mohammed A. title: The first COVID‐19 triadic (homicide!)‐suicide pact: Do economic distress, disability, sickness, and treatment negligence matter? date: 2020-11-25 journal: Perspect Psychiatr Care DOI: 10.1111/ppc.12686 sha: 09d4413d97db7631d74612aba8f7a310329529a3 doc_id: 801944 cord_uid: p06ki0rq INTRODUCTION: Dyadic suicide‐pact is rare but possible incidence in the COVID‐19 time. No prior evidences available on triadic suicide‐pact, which is presented herein for the first‐time. CASE PRESENTATION: An Indian family consisting of three members, committed suicide. There is no evidence of homicide‐suicide, which suggests the cases to be mutual suicide‐pact. However, the suicide risk factors can be evidently noted as (i) economic distress, (ii) feeling burden of disability and sick people, and (iii) being stubborn as of not getting hospital treatment. Poisoning is reported for the suicide method; besides, the victims left a suicide note. PRACTICAL IMPLICATIONS: The present case highlights the possibilities of further suicide‐pacts in economically unprivileged family, whereas having disabled and/or sick people may add extra burdens in taking such extreme decision. observed a total six global couple suicidality pacts from Bangladesh, India, Malaysia, and the United States. The suicide-pact causalities were reported to be (i) fear of infection, (ii) financial distress, (iii) social boycott, (iv) being unable to return home from abroad among the couple. 15 An unusual suicide-pact case (considering the victim and preparators' relationship, that is, among mother-adult son) was also reported as of online schooling-related quarrel leading family conflict in Bangladesh. 16 Besides, another exceptional case relating to infanticide suicide pact of a 30-year-old Indian woman and her 6-month-old infant was reported in Saudi Arabia. 17 The woman's husband was recently retrenched from his job and was infected with COVID-19 before 4 days of the incident. However, the probable fear of COVID-19 infection of the infant along with ongoing familiar economic crisis, the infant was deliberately killed before the woman committing suicide. 17 Dyadic suicide cases are reported in the COVID-19 context although, there is lack of evidence on triadic suicide pact. And, thus, the present report tries to document a rare (but possible) suicide pact of three persons from South Kolkata, India. The case is presented based on the press media reports, 18 a well-established retrospective suicide method that is widely used in the non-COVID-19 19, 20 and COVID-19 12, 13, 21, 22 periods. On June 9, three people of the same family living in Satyanarayana Palli, Thakurpukur police station area of South Kolkata, committed suicide. According to the press media and police source, the triadic suicide-pact victims were an 80-year-old man named Govinda Karmakar, his 70-year-old sick wife Ranu Karmakar and 47-year-old disabled son Bula Karmakar Debashis. 23 Debashis was crippled since birth, with paralyzed lower back and was supposed to perform everything by other's help, especially his mother, Ranu. The woman had a cerebral stroke a month ago. Due to financial constraints, she was treated by the support of her father in Hugli. They returned home 2 days back committing suicide from Hugli. That returning day, the old-man went out to the neighborhood and swept off his feet. Neighbors grabbed him and brought him home. Then, he went out again and fall down. As of 2-day uneaten, the old-man became heavily debilitated. Then, the locals called the police, and they were taken to Vidyasagar Hospital for the probable COVID-19 test. The doctors informed that the old man was having high body temperature and suggested that he should be taken to other hospitals. He was taken to Bangur Hospital, then, Medical Hospital, and later on, Nilratan Government Hospital; but as of not getting him admitted, the police dropped them in their home. 23 According to Mr. Karmakar's suicide note, it seemed that without him, his wife and son would be in a tragic situation, whereas he wanted to save them. The experience of walking from hospital to hospital might have made him even more stubborn. And the result of that zeal was to leave the world together with everyone. The locals could not accept the fact and felt that the hospital admission could have saved their lives. However, Debashis and his mother were lying dead on the bed, while Govinda was lying on the floor with his head toward the door. On the cement floor, 'all three of us are dead' was written, and near to the cup with a paper found to be noted as "no one will touch the cup, there is poison." 23 When two persons' deaths occur because of either (i) killing one by a perpetrator and committing suicide himself, or (ii) committing suicide on mutual understanding at the same given time and place is referred as dyadic deaths. 24, 25 The examples of dyadic deaths can be noted as murder-suicide or homicide-suicide, child homicide-suicide, suicide pact, and so forth. 15, 24, 26 Usually these suicides occur in the family context, and account for a very minor portion of the total suicide rate. However, the homicide-suicide rate is reported to be yearly 0.06 per 100,000 persons in England and Wales, whereas 0.11 in Australia, 0.38 in Japan, 0.07 in New Zealand, 0.21 in the United States, and so forth. 26 Being married, socially isolated, having a serious health suffering in one or both partners are the accountable risk mediators of couple suicide pact. 25, 26 Besides, premarriage relationship complexities, being unable to have children, financial difficulty, and so forth, can also be reasons for suicide pact. 25, 26 For the child-homicide suicide, there are two aspects leading the incidence occurrence; (i) motivational sources (i.e., altruistic, acutely psychotic, unwanted child, accidental, and spouse revenge) and (ii) origin of the stimulus (i.e., battering mothers, mentally ill mothers, retaliating mothers, unwanted children, and mercy killing). 27 Issues like frequent depression, psychosis, and suicidal behaviors, prior mental health treatment, and so forth, along with chronic physical sufferings, unhealthy familiar environments consisting with violence, abuse, and so forth, aggravate the child-homicide suicide incidence. 27, 28 The COVID-19 recession, is a major global financial recession, which began with the great lockdown across the entire world. It was first manifested by the 2020 stock market crash on February 20, of that 2 months back, the first-ever COVID-19 case was reported in China. 29 To suppress the infection rate, extreme social movement restriction measures like lockdown was placed in almost all countries. 2 [30] [31] [32] In the extreme cases, people do commit suicide. A recent systematic review observing a total 38 papers found that economic distress and suicide rate was significantly correlated with 31 studies. 31 Thus, the financial crisis and distress related to the COVID-19 pandemic is taking up people's lives. For instance, Bangladesh reported all but one suicide because of economic constriction. 13 Similarly, it was the first suicide causality in Pakistan, 11 whereas the Indian reported it to be the second most prominent suicide factor during the COVID-19 outbreak. 12 Consistent with the general people suicide, the present suicide pact also reports economic sufferings. As mentioned before, COVID-19 turns excessive fear and worries among the people. 1, 3 In extreme psychological cases, people commit suicides. 33 Fear of COVID-19 infection was reported as the foremost suicide risk factor in India, 12 whereas it was second in Pakistan. 11 The fear also leads some avoidance behaviors among those who deal with public service during the pandemic. For instance, Mamun et al. 34 reported Bangladeshi healthcare professionals were in excessive fear, which turned themselves to forbid treatment of a patient who was suspectedto be infected with the virus, even they also advised other patients for not getting touched with that patient. The treatment negligence and avoidance behaviors were so extreme that the patient had no option to commit suicide. 34, 35 This may be an incidence herein the present case, although the press reports do not clearly indicate anything if the victims are refused for treatment by fearing them to be infected with the virus. However, being stubborn as of not getting admitted in the hospital probably makes the old-man egotistic, which ultimately leads them to commit suicide. However, considering the homicide-victim and preparators' relationship, homicide-suicide is more common among the couples or person in a close relationship, which is also supported by the previous COVID-19 suicide pact findings. For instance, out of a total eight suicidality pacts, six cases occurred in couple, 15 whereas mother-infant 17 and mother-son 16 are the rest two cases. However, the present finding provides a new insight on triadic suicide pact victims' relationship (i.e., father-mother-son) with the probable mutual suicide-pact incidence. The present triadic suicide pact is very uncommon case as far as The fear of COVID-19 scale: development and initial validation Epub ahead of print Depression and anxiety among university students during the COVID-19 pandemic in Bangladesh: a web-based cross-sectional survey Psychometric validation of the bangla fear of COVID-19 scale: confirmatory factor analysis and Rasch analysis Social and electronic media exposure and generalized anxiety disorder among people during COVID-19 outbreak in Bangladesh: a preliminary observation Exploring COVID-19 stress and its factors in Bangladesh: a perception-based study The mental health impact of the COVID-19 pandemic across different cohorts Epub ahead of print COVID 19 fear, stress, anxiety, and substance use among Russian and Belarusian university students Depression and suicidal behaviors among Bangladeshi mothers of children with Autistic Spectrum Disorder: a comparative study A rare case of Bangladeshi student suicide by gunshot due to unusual multiple causalities PTSD-related suicide six years after the Rana Plaza collapse in Bangladesh COVID-19 suicides in Pakistan, dying off not COVID-19 fear but poverty?-The forthcoming economic challenges for a developing country Aggregated COVID-19 suicide incidences in India: fear of COVID-19 infection is the prominent causative factor COVID-19-related suicides in Bangladesh due to lockdown and economic factors: Case study evidence from media reports Epub ahead of print Indian celebrity suicides before and during the COVID-19 pandemic and their associated risk factors: evidence from media reports COVID-19 suicidal behavior among couples and suicide pacts: case study evidence from press reports Mother and son suicide pact due to COVID-19-related online learning issues in Bangladesh: an unusual case report The first COVID-19 infanticide-suicide case: financial crisis and fear of COVID-19 infection are the causative factors Mandatory Junior School Certificate exams and young teenage suicides in Bangladesh: a response to Arafat (2020) Suicide of Bangladeshi medical students: Risk factor trends based on Bangladeshi press reports Student suicide risk and gender: a retrospective study from Bangladeshi press reports. Int J Ment Health Addict. 2020f. Epub ahead of print COVID-19 suicide among adolescents and youths during the lockdown: an exploratory study based on media reports Nationwide suicides owing to alcohol withdrawal symptoms during COVID-19 pandemic: a review of cases from media reports Sick wife, old man commits suicide with lame son! (in Bangla) [WWW Document] Dyadic death: a typology Suicide pacts: six cases and literature review Homicide-suicide and other violent deaths: an international comparison Victim, perpetrator, and offense characteristics in filicide and filicide-suicide Child murder by mothers: patterns and prevention Financial threat, hardship and distress predict depression, anxiety and stress among the unemployed youths: a Bangladeshi multi-city study Systematic review of suicide in economic recession Psychological implications of unemployment among Bangladesh Civil Service job seekers: a pilot study First COVID-19 suicide case in Bangladesh due to fear of COVID-19 and xenophobia: possible suicide prevention strategies Hospital suicide due to non-treatment by healthcare staff fearing COVID-19 infection in Bangladesh? COVID-19 infection risk in Pakistani health-care workers: the cost-effective safety measures for developing countries How to cite this article: Mamun MA. The first COVID-19 triadic (homicide!)-suicide pact: Do economic distress, disability, sickness, and treatment negligence matter?