key: cord-0789048-i2i1md4u
authors: da Silva, Tércia Moreira Ribeiro; de Sá, Ana Carolina Micheletti Gomide Nogueira; Vieira, Ed Wilson Rodrigues; Prates, Elton Junio Sady; Beinner, Mark Anthony; Matozinhos, Fernanda Penido
title: Number of doses of Measles-Mumps-Rubella vaccine applied in Brazil before and during the COVID-19 pandemic
date: 2021-12-09
journal: BMC Infect Dis
DOI: 10.1186/s12879-021-06927-6
sha: 632ec8c582d13012f8ff38682658bc727f626dc7
doc_id: 789048
cord_uid: i2i1md4u

BACKGROUND: Due to the social isolation measures adopted in an attempt to mitigate the risk of transmission of SARS-CoV-2, there has been a reduction in vaccination coverage of children and adolescents in several countries and regions of the world. OBJECTIVE: Analyze the number of doses of vaccine against Measles-Mumps-Rubella (MMR) applied before and after the beginning of mitigation measures due to COVID-19 pandemic in Brazil. METHODS: The data collected refer to the number of doses of the MMR vaccine applied monthly to the target population residing in Brazil: cahildren, aged 12 months (first dose) and children, aged 9 years (second dose), from April 2019 to December 2020. Differences in MMR vaccine doses from April 2019 to March 2020 (before the start of mitigation measures) and April 2020 to September 2020 (after the start of the mitigation measures) were evaluated. Spatial analysis identified clusters with a high percentage of reduction in the median of applied doses no Brazil. RESULTS: There was a reduction in the median of doses applied in the Regions North (− 33.03%), Northeast (− 43.49%) and South (− 39.01%) e nos Estados Acre (− 48.46%), Amazonas (− 28.96%), Roraima (− 61.91%), Paraíba (− 41.58%), Sergipe (− 47.52%), Rio de Janeiro (-59.31%) and Santa Catarina (− 49.32) (p < 0.05). High-high type spatial clusters (reduction between 34.00 and 90.00%) were formed in the five regions of Brazil (Moran’s I = 0.055; p = 0.01). CONCLUSION: A reduction in the number of MMR vaccine doses was evidenced as a possible effect by the restrictive actions of COVID-19 in Brazil.

During the COVID-19 pandemic, national and international health agencies recommended that immunization services to continue, uninterrupted, their activities, due to the possibility of a return of vaccine-preventable diseases, controlled or eliminated, in response to low vaccination coverage [1] . However, studies have shown that, due to the social isolation measures adopted in an attempt to mitigate the risk of transmission of SARS-CoV-2, the etiological agent of COVID-19 [2, 3] , there has been a reduction in vaccination coverage of children and adolescents in several countries and regions of the world [4, 5] .

The impact on vaccine coverage was not an exclusive event of the COVID-19 pandemic. Studies conducted after catastrophes and epidemics that occurred in Open Access da Silva et al. BMC Infectious Diseases (2021) 21:1237 human history also pointed to a decline in vaccination coverage as a response to the reduction in the population's supply and access to health services [6] .

Difficult access to immunization services and child malnutrition are factors that act synergistically, placing communities living in a situation of social vulnerability more susceptible to the development of severe forms and death as a result of measles [7] . Even with the widespread diffusion of the Measles-Mumps-Rubella vaccine (MMR vaccine) in 2019, the world's measles rates reached their highest level over the last two decades [7, 8] . In fact, it is estimated that in 2018, more than 140,000 people died from measles, with the majority of deaths reported in underdeveloped countries, affecting primarilarly malnourished children [8] . In this sense, health strategies and policies aimed at improving MMR vaccine coverage indicators are needed, especially in low-and middle-income countries [7] .

The MMR vaccine, produced from live attenuated measles, rubella and mumps viruses, is available free of charge in Brazil and recommended for routine vaccination at 12 months and 9 years of age [9] . Even with the freely available vaccine distributed throughout the national territory, in 2018, two years after receiving measles-free certification for the elimination of virus in the Americas [10] , 10,346 cases of the disease were confirmed in Brazil, resulting in the loss of certification as a "measles virus-free country" [11] . The recently reported cases of measles can be explained by the progressive drop in the coverage of the MMR vaccine in Brazil over the last decade and by the formation of clusters of susceptible individuals in the States of Acre, Amazonas, Pará, Amapá, located in the North region, and in the State of Maranhão, located in the Northeast region of the country [12] .

Considering that the historical reduction in MMR vaccine coverage rates in Brazil [13, 14] may have been compromised by the sanitary measures adopted due to the COVID-19 pandemic and that in Brazil the distribution of health services and the allocation of health resources are heterogeneous [15] , this study aimed to analyze the number of doses of the MMR vaccine applied before and after the beginning of social distancing measures in response to the COVID-19 pandemic that took effect in the municipalities, states and regions of Brazil. Brazil ranked third among the countries with the highest number of confirmed cases of COVID-19 (more than 22 million on September 30, 2020, according to the WHO) [16] , in addition to the absence of a comprehensive national plan to combat the pandemic and to adequately secure the reduction of mortality from the highly contagious disease [17] . In addition, this study also aimed to identify, through spatial analysis, clusters formed by municipalities with a high contingent of individuals susceptible to measles.

This was an ecological study, with data taken from the Brazilian National Immunization Information Program System (SI-PNI), available at http:// sipni. datas us. gov. br/. The SI-PNI provides the number of monthly doses of vaccines applied throughout the country.

The data collected refer to the number of doses of the MMR vaccine administered in the period from April 2019 to September 2020. Data extraction was performed by the number of monthly doses applied to the target population over the period: children, aged 12 months (first dose) and 9-year-old children (second dose).

The independent variable was the number of doses applied. The independent variables were geographical, including the five regions of the country (North, Northeast, Central, Southeast and South), the 27 States of the Federation, which are comprised of 5568 Brazilian municipalities.

First, the doses of the MMR vaccine applied before (April 2019-March 2020) and after the beginning of social distancing measures in Brazil (April-September 2020) in the 27 states were added. Next, the differences between the median number of doses applied before and after social distancing measures were evaluated using the Mann-Whitney U test and the significance level was established at 5%. The percentage of variation of the median doses applied was estimated using the following equation:

These analyzes were processed using the Statistical Package for Social Sciences software (IBM-SPSS, v.19, IBM, Chicago, IL).

For the general spatial analysis, the percentage variation of the median doses of the MMR vaccine was considered before and after the beginning of social distancing measures in Brazil for each Brazilian municipality. The percentage variation of the median of applied doses was estimated using the equation previously mentioned.

Techniques for spatial analysis of area data were used considering the digital grids of the Brazilian municipalities, using two Geographic Information System (GIS) programs. To examine the existence of a spatial correlation of the median reduction of doses of the MMR-Triple Viral vaccine, the Global Moran's Index (I) was calculated, which ranges from − 1 to + 1, with positive values (between 0 and + 1) indicating direct correlation and negative values, between 0 and − 1 (an inverse correlation). Spatial correlation is interpreted according to the I and can translate to weak (I < 0.3), moderate (I ≥ 0.3; < 0.7) or strong (I > 0.7) [18] .

From the cartographic base of the Brazilian municipalities acquired on the IBGE website, cartograms were created for the presentation of clusters with statistical significance (p < 0.05). The Moran Eigenvector Maps (MEM) show the high-high spatial clusters (red color) resulting in statistical significance, formed by municipalities with a high percentage reduction in the median of applied doses of the MMR vaccine and surrounded by municipalities with the same trend. Municipalities that failed to present significant spatial correlation (p > 0.05) or that formed low-low, low-high or high-low type spatial clusters, were excluded from the map. The regions of the country, namely: North, Northeast, Central, Southeast and South, are represented on the cartogram with different shades of gray.

In this study, the 95% of Global Moran I level of significance was considered after 999 permutations [18] , that is to say, the areas with statistically significant spatial correlation were those whose p-value was less than or equal to 0.05 after 999 random permutations. For these spatial analyses, the following software was used: Spatial Analysis Laboratory, University of Illinois, Urbana Champaign, United States (GeoDa 0.9.9.10) and TerraView, version 4.1.0.

Due to the nature of this study of using freely accessible data, it was not necessary to submit the present study to the Research Ethics Committee, in accordance with Resolution 466/2012 of the National Brazilian Health Council [19] .

From April 2019 to September 2020, 25,717,742 doses of the MMR vaccine were applied throughout Brazil (46.55% at beginning of the social distancing measures). In the period before measurements, the median number of doses applied was 1,645,527. During this period, the median dropped to 934,991, equivalent to a reduction of 43.17%.

Of the five regions in the country, the North, Northeast and South showed a statistically significant reduction in the median number of doses applied while the the public health emergency measures were in place. Among the states, seven demonstrated a statistically significant reduction, ranging from 47.52% in Sergipe, to 64.91% in Roraima (Table 1) .

Weak spatial autocorrelation (I = 0.055; p = 0.01) and the presence of High-High spatial clusters were identified, formed by 262 municipalities that presented a reduction in the median of applied doses between 34 and 90%, 88 of which were located in the North Region, 107 in the Northeast region, 41 in the Southeast region, and 26 in the South region (Fig. 1 ).

The COVID-19 pandemic resulted in a reduction in the number of applied doses of the MMR vaccine as a possible effect of the restrictive actions of COVID-19. The North, Northeast and South regions and the States of Acre, Amazona, Roraima, Paraiba, Sergipe, Rio de Janeiro, and Santa Catarina showed a significant reduction in the median of MMR vaccine doses applied during the period that recommendations for social distancing were instituted in Brazil. High-High spatial clusters were formed by municipalities located mostly in the Northeast and North regions of the country.

National and international studies attributed a reduction of the population's demand for health services, with a consequent drop in vaccination coverage, due to the restrictive mitigation measures adopted during the COVID-19 pandemic [1, 5, 20, 21] . However, there has been an observed trend in a decline in vaccine doses applied in Brazil over the last two decades [21] , especially those immunobiologicals recommended during early childhood [12, 22] . Contextual and individual factors, cited in recent studies [21, 23] , have attributed the decline based on vaccination coverage including a lack of planning by the Brazilian National Universal Healthcare System (SUS), social and cultural aspects effecting vaccination acceptance, logistical difficulties cited by the PNI in offering several routine vaccines as part of the national vaccine schedule, anti-vaccination movements, and inconsistencies in the availability of immunobiologicals offered by Primary Healthcare services [24] [25] [26] [27] .

The results of the present study demonstrate that the number of MMR vaccine doses applied between April 2020 and September 2020 was considerably lower than in the period from April 2019 to March 2020. This result does not rule out evidence that contextual factors and individuals have acted synergistically, contributing to the reduction in the number of applied MMR vaccine doses [12, 25, 27, 28] , but highlights that social isolation, triggered by the COVID-19 pandemic, greatly contributed to the reduction in the number of applied MMR vaccine doses. This fact was evidenced by the sudden change in the behavior of the absolute numbers between the evaluated periods and confirmed by statistical analyses.

Also in this study, three of the five Brazilian regions demonstrated a statistically significant reduction in the median of applied MMR vaccine doses during the period of social distancing measures. This scenario, added to the drop in vaccination coverage rates in recent years, point to a problem for collective immunity and the risk of outbreaks resulting from the measles virus [22, 29] . Furthermore, it is worth noting that the regional inequalities in vaccination coverage in Brazil has favored the formation of pockets of susceptible individuals [12, 22, 30] .

Between 2015 and October 2018, Brazil experienced a significant drop in MMR vaccine coverage, from 96.1 to 86.7%, and only after the national vaccination campaign, in September 2018, did it reach the 95% target [13, 31] . These low vaccination coverage indicators, added to measles cases, imported from Venezuela, triggered an 21:1237 epidemic of the disease that affected several Brazilian states, mainly states in the Northern regions [32] .

The findings of present study showed that, added to the historical reduction in the coverage of the MMR vaccine, as highlighted in the literature [33] , there was a sharp drop in the number of doses of the MMR vaccine applied during the first six months, when compared to the previous period of the COVID-19 pandemic. A study that evaluated the availability of the MMR vaccine in Brazil, from 2013 to 2014, reported that the immunization services, located in the Northern region, possessed inadequate infrastructure for undertaking immunization actions which resulted in a lower frequency of vaccine availability [23] . The lack of vaccine in the Northern region, even during a short period of time, incurs a lost opportunity for vaccination and can compromise the achievement of vaccination coverage goals, increasing the number of susceptible individuals from that region [23] .

The lower frequency of availability of the MMR vaccine, on top of the logistical and infrastructure problems of the primary healthcare services in the Northern region, may have contributed to the formation of clusters with a higher percentage reduction in the coverage of the MMR vaccine in this region. In this study, by using spatial analysis, we identified cities that showed a reduction in the number of applied MMR vaccine doses and that were close to neighboring cities demonstrating a similar behavior of forming a cluster. The concentration of individuals who are not adequately immunized with the MMR vaccine compromises collective immunity, increases the risk of circulating disease such as measles, rubella and mumps, and therefore, the identification of these areas is essential to fast track public health policies and health strategies for improvement of immunization indicators [33] .

In the North and Northeast regions of the country, we identified a greater number of clusters that showed a reduction in the number of applied MMR vaccine doses. Regional inequalities in vaccine coverage in Brazil [12, 29] can be attributed, in part, to differences in investments in the health sector in the North and Northeast regions when compared to other Brazilian regions, which culminated in the precariousness of the nationally mandated Primary Healthcare Services (Atenção Primaria-AB), responsible for offering free immunization through the National Immunization Program (PNI) [23] .

Furthermore, it is noteworthy that measles is one of the most contagious infectious diseases known [34] , requiring the adoption of emergency strategy actions for vaccinating communities that formed clusters with a significant reduction in immunization coverage during the COVID-19 pandemic period. This strategy aims to reduce the chances of overlapping cases of measles and COVID-19, which could favor the collapse of healthcare services in these regions.

The collapse of health services in some states in the North and Northeast regions, due to the increasing demand for hospital beds for patients with COVID-19, may have contributed to the reduction in the population's demand for immunization services in these regions [35, 36] , resulting in the formation of clusters with higher percentages of reduction in the applied MMR vaccine doses in these regions.

Strategies to contain the pandemic in states and regions of Brazil were also not uniform, which may explain the percentage variations in the median of applied MMR vaccine doses, from 47.52%, in the State of Sergipe (p = 0.04), to 64.91% in the State of Roraima (p = 0.00). While in some locations, the response to the epidemic phase of acceleration of the number of reported cases and deaths from COVID-19 was using mitigation practices through social distancing. Other locations resorted to the strategy of total confinement, that is, suspending all non-essential activities and limiting the circulation of people [37, 38] .

In Brazil, more than a year after the first case of COVID-19, the country continues to lag behind many developing countries in an effort to immunize its population against COVID-19 [39] and many public health officials agree that long-term social isolation strategies will continue for several years to come [40] . Under this scenario, it is vital to adopt health strategies and policies that ensure the population's universal access to immunization programs. The consequences of a lack of access would mean living with the overlapping cases and deaths from COVID-19 with other infectious diseases, such as measles, rubella and mumps.

One of the weaknesses of the present study was in relation to the intrinsic limitations of studies that use secondary data, in addition to the fact that the available data were not specifically collected to answer the questions proposed in this research. Another point that deserves to be highlighted was the possible influences related to the standardization and quality of filling in the SI-PNI records, which may be subject to information bias. The SI-PNI is considered a powerful tool as a source of data on immunizations for the Brazilian population, and even with some weaknesses, as pointed out, it has solid bases, with more than 40 years of existence, contributing to support monitoring and decision-making in the country [32, 33] . The SI-PNI is useful in the fulfillment of its mission, decisive both in the control and enabling the identification of groups susceptible to vaccine-preventable diseases through individualized data and the management of actions throughout the Brazilian territories [34] . A study that evaluated the SI-PNI revealed that it is a system that maintains sensitive criteria, managing to capture a satisfactory percentage of vaccination of the population [34] . In addition, the SI-PNI is coordinated by the Ministry of Health [32] and possesses strict regulations for control, adherence and standard fulfillment targets [34] . In this way, the data presented here are recognized and very close to the reality in Brazil. In this study, the SI-PNI registered population data was used during the study period, and the generalization of these results is relatively safe for national estimates. Also, to control biases, methodological rigor was taken into account during all of the stages of the study execution.

The COVID-19 pandemic resulted in a reduction in the number of applied MMR vaccine doses as a possible effect from the restrictive actions against COVID-19.

In Brazil, few studies have evaluated the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the vaccination of children and adolescents, and this is the first study in the country to consider the MMR vaccine. The results of this work may support public health policies to guarantee immunization strategies against measles, rubella and mumps in the country, even during the current epidemic phase, which continues to result in increased numbers of reported cases and deaths from COVID-19 in Brazil. In this sense, this work may highlight priority areas for which public health policies and health strategies should be adopted to improve immunization indicators, in order to prevent the spread of potentially vaccine-preventable infectious diseases. 

Routine vaccination during covid-19 pandemic response

Social distancing measures in the fight against covid-19 in brazil: description and epidemiological analysis by state

Portaria N o 1.565, de 18 de junho de 2020. Brasil: Publicado em: 19/06/2020 | Edição: 116 | Seção: 1 | Página: 64

Impact of COVID-19 pandemic response on uptake of routine immunizations in Sindh, Pakistan: an analysis of provincial electronic immunization registry data

Impact of COVID-19 pandemic on the utilization of routine immunization services in Lebanon

The impact of a prolonged ebola outbreak on measles elimination activities in Guinea

Measles & Rubella Initiative. Measles and Rubella Strategic Framework 2021-2030

The colliding epidemics of COVID-19, Ebola, and measles in the Democratic Republic of the Congo

Prevalence of measles antibodies in

Measles and rubella elimination in the WHO Region for Europe: progress and challenges

Monitoramento dos casos de arboviroses urbanas causados por vírus transmitidos pelo mosquito Aedes (dengue, chikungunya e zika), semanas epidemiológicas 1 a 16

Areas with declining vaccination coverage for BCG, poliomyelitis, and MMR in Brazil

Trends and spatial distribution of MMR vaccine coverage in Brazil during

Measles epidemic in Brazil in the post-elimination period: coordinated response and containment strategies

Acesso e acessibilidade na atenção primária à saúde no Brasil

COVID-19) Dashboard With Vaccination Data | WHO Coronavirus (COVID-19) Dashboard With Vaccination Data

The Brazilian Government's mistakes in responding to the COVID-19 pandemic

Local indicators of spatial association-LISA

What changes in research ethics in Brazil: resolution no

Pandemic and vaccine coverage: challenges of returning to schools

Covid-19 and its impact on immunization programs: reflections from Brazil

Vaccine coverage within the first year of life and associated factors with incomplete immunization in a Brazilian birth cohort

21:1237 • fast, convenient online submission • thorough peer review by experienced researchers in your field • rapid publication on acceptance • support for research data, including large and complex data types • gold Open Access which fosters wider collaboration and increased citations maximum visibility for your research: over 100M website views per year • At BMC, research is always in progress. Learn more biomedcentral.com/submissions Ready to submit your research Ready to submit your research ? Choose BMC

Estrutura e localização dos serviços de vacinação influenciam a disponibilidade da tríplice viral no Brasil

Areas with declining vaccination coverage for BCG, poliomyelitis, and MMR in Brazil (2006-2016): maps of regional heterogeneity

National immunization program: computerized system as a tool for new challenges

Incomplete childhood vaccination and associated factors among children aged 12-23 months in Gondar city administration

Factors associated with incomplete or delayed vaccination across countries: a systematic review

Structure and location of vaccination services influence the availability of the triple viral in Brazil

Longitudinal profiling of the vaccination coverage in Brazil reveals a recent change in the patterns hallmarked by differential reduction across regions

Vaccine uptake and associated factors in an irregular urban settlement in northeastern Brazil: a cross-sectional study

Conquistas do SUS no enfrentamento das doenças transmissíveis

In the eye of the storm: infectious disease challenges for border countries receiving Venezuelan migrants

Áreas com queda da cobertura vacinal para BCG, poliomielite e tríplice viral no Brasil (2006-2016): mapas da heterogeneidade regional

The basic reproduction number (R0) of measles: a systematic review

Health system collapse 45 days after the detection of COVID-19 in Ceará, Northeast Brazil: a preliminary analysis

The COVID-19 pandemic in Brazil: analysis of supply and demand of hospital and ICU beds and mechanical ventilators under different scenarios

Brazil's actions and reactions in the fight against COVID-19 from

Medidas de contenção de tipo lockdown para prevenção e controle da COVID-19: estudo ecológico descritivo, com dados da África do Sul, Alemanha, Brasil, Espanha, Estados Unidos, Itália e Nova Zelândia, fevereiro a agosto de 2020. Epidemiol e Serv Saude Rev Do Sist Unico Saude Do Bras

Coronavirus (COVID-19) Vaccinations-Statistics and Research-Our World in Data 2021

Primary healthcare in times of COVID-19: what to do. Cad Saude Publica

Publisher's Note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations

We would like to thank NUPESV-Center for Studies and Research in Vaccination-for their support in carrying out this study and to the National Immunization Program for providing the data.

Authors' contributions TMRS: conception, worked on study design, analysis and interpretation of data, co-wrote this manuscript, critical content review and approval of the final version. ACMGNS: worked on study design, analysis and interpretation of data, co-wrote this manuscript, critical content review and approval of the final version. EJSP: interpretation of data, co-wrote this manuscript, critical content review and approval of the final version. EWRV: data interpretation, co-wrote this manuscript, critical content review and approval of the final version. MAB: data interpretation, co-wrote this manuscript, critical review of content and approval of the final version. FPM: data interpretation, co-wrote