key: cord-0785243-tahiuco3 authors: Abe, Makiko; Tabei, Ken-ichi; Satoh, Masayuki title: The Assessments of Music Therapy for Dementia Based on the Cochrane Review date: 2022-01-21 journal: Dement Geriatr Cogn Dis Extra DOI: 10.1159/000521231 sha: f35339d615dd0fd53fd7886cad6bee1b1058371e doc_id: 785243 cord_uid: tahiuco3 BACKGROUND: Research on music therapy for dementia has taken a variety of measures and has been slow to consolidate evidence. Examining the outcomes that are currently being investigated and the measures that have been used can be useful for future research on music therapy for dementia. OBJECTIVES: This study used cited original papers from a review in the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews to determine if there are items that should be measured or scales that should be used in conducting research on music therapy for dementia. The rating scales used and the outcomes examined were extracted. METHOD: We used Dodd's criteria to identify (1) the outcome domains examined in music therapy for dementia, (2) the measures used, and (3) the measures capable of detecting significant intervention effects. RESULT: A search for reviews was conducted, and 7 systematic reviews (78 articles) were identified. Among them, 30 articles met the inclusion criteria. The 30 articles examined 18 of the 38 items in Dodd's outcome categories, while 20 items were not examined, and 78 different survey methods were used. The items most frequently surveyed in the studies were psychiatric outcomes, cognitive functioning, and global quality of life general outcomes. CONCLUSIONS: We found that many studies investigated cognitive function, behavioral and psychological symptoms of dementia (BPSD), and quality of life; compared to BPSD, various types of rating scales were used for cognitive function. By standardizing the rating scales, we can contribute to the accumulation of evidence for music therapy for dementia. The treatment of dementia involves a combination of pharmacological and nonpharmacological therapies. Nonpharmacological therapies may be prioritized, especially for behavioral and psychological symptoms of dementia (BPSD) [1, 2] . However, the status of the recommended grade for implementation of nonpharmacological therapies in Japan, including music therapy for dementia, is weak, and the overall evidence is considered inconclusive. Despite various studies on the therapeutic effects of music therapy, conclusive evidence for its use in treating dementia has not been established. Kelly et al. [3] collected more than 4,200 responses from approximately 1,500 participants on the question, "What should be investigated in future research on dementia"? and published the top 10 responses in rank or-der. "Establishing evidence for pharmacological and nonpharmacological therapies to manage BPSD" was ranked fourth, and establishing evidence for music therapy was found to be desired [3] . However, some studies on music therapy for dementia do not have sufficient data to support the conclusions discussed in the articles [4] , making the issue of evidence and quality of research on music therapy for dementia an urgent matter to be addressed. A core outcome set (COS) helps to establish evidence in clinical research. A COS is a consensus-derived, standardized, and parsimonious collection of outcomes to be reported at minimum in all studies of a particular condition ("what" to measure) [5] [6] [7] [8] . A COS for music therapy for dementia would facilitate the aggregation of the effects of music therapy interventions for dementia, leading to the establishment of evidence. However, there is no COS for music therapy for dementia currently, and the outcomes have not been classified. If the researchers used different batteries to assess the intervention effects, we cannot compare the results between them, and it may prevent from establishing the evidence. The present study examined the outcomes and measures investigated in music therapy for dementia, found in the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (CDSR), as a preliminary step in the development of a COS. These outcomes and measures were categorized based on an outcome taxonomy created by Dodd et al. [9] that can be used in general medical clinical research. It consists of 38 items comprising mortality, physiological and clinical, impact on life, resource utilization, and adverse events. This is used in both clinical [10, 11] and basic research using animal experiments such as mice [12] . The collection of outcomes for the COS is essentially a systematic review in the CDSR. However, there were only a few reviews of music therapy for dementia in the CDSR; hence, we used the articles in the reviews, extracted the rating scales used, and the outcomes examined. Dodd's criteria were used to identify (1) outcome domains examined in music therapy for dementia, (2) measures used, and (3) scales able to detect significant intervention effects, to determine whether there were any items to be measured and any scales to be used in conducting research on music therapy for dementia. The following words were used to search the CDSR: "dementia," "music," and "therapy," in studies registered on or before September 1, 2020. The inclusion criteria were as follows: (1) articles reporting results of studies using music therapy, music intervention, or music stimulation, (2) articles were written in English, and (3) the target disease was dementia. The exclusion criteria were as follows: (1) articles reporting results of a study that did not use music therapy, music intervention, or music stimulation; (2) articles written in languages other than English; and (3) the subject of the study was not dementia. Only articles that met the inclusion criteria were included in the study. The items and scales examined in each article were extracted. The extracted items and scales were classified according to Dodd et al.'s [9] outcome taxonomy. All authors participated in the exclusion of articles, extraction of items, scales examined, and assignment to Dodd's classification; decisions were made by consensus in cases of differences. The following methods were used to conduct the analysis: (1) identifying the items examined by each research article, categorized according to Dodd et al.'s [9] criteria, and identifying the applicable and nonapplicable outcome domains and (2) frequency of use of the measures used in each outcome domain and frequency of detection of significant differences. It was approved by the Research Safety and Ethics Committee of the Advanced Institute of Industrial Technology (No. 19009). Seven reviews [4, [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] used 76 articles, and 30 met the inclusion criteria (Table 1 ). The 30 articles examined 18 of the 38 items in Dodd's outcome categories, while 20 items were not examined, and 78 different survey methods were used. The items most frequently surveyed in the studies were psychiatric outcomes, cognitive functioning, and global quality of life general outcomes (Table 2 ). The frequency of use of the scales used in each outcome domain and the frequency of detecting significant differences are shown in Table 3 . Many of the general outcomes were items examined as demographic data, and most studies examined age, gender, and education. Since this present review focused on studies of music therapy, music intervention, or music stimulation for dementia and not on subtypes of dementia (e.g., Alzheimer's disease [AD], dementia with Lewy bodies, and cerebrovascular dementia ), age, gender, and education were not included in the demographic data. In some studies, the classification of dementia type was also included in the demographic data. The cognitive outcome revealed the use of a variety of measures of cognitive function in addition to general intelligence, including the Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE). In dementia, multiple cognitive functions are impaired, reflecting the areas of functional decline in each disease. The main areas of cognitive decline include attention, executive function, memory, language, visuospatial cognition, action, and social cognition [49] . It was inferred that the wide range of symptoms expressed by patients of different subtypes of dementia led to the use of many scales to assess each of them. Särkämö et al. [41] used 9 cognitive function tests, the most used, in an attempt to assess overall cerebral function. While it is important to use scales according to the functions to be assessed, the burden on the target dementia patients must be considered. It is therefore necessary to reorganize the scales to assess the patients' conditions with the least possible number of assessment method. The most frequently rated psychiatric outcome reflected the BPSD rating in dementia. According to previous reports, music therapy and other music interventions for dementia have been shown to improve BPSD, with effects on anxiety and depression reported by Ueda et al. [50] and those for agitation reported by Vink et al. [38, 42] and Lin et al. [31] . Many studies included in this review were concerned with BPSD, and many of them used the Cohen-Mansfield Agitation Inventory, a rating scale for agitation, although there were differences in the shortened or Chinese versions. Others used a rating scale for depression, a rating scale for anxiety, and a rating scale that can evaluate several BPSDs together. The Neuropsychiatric Inventory (NPI) evaluates the occurrence, frequency, and severity of BPSD, and there are various versions, such as that for clinicians and nursing homes. The NPI also assesses the burden of care for each item, and some studies have partially used the NPI to assess care burden. While many studies have assessed BPSD, the method of assessment has remained constant compared to that for other items. Moreover, the use of these rating scales in studies of music therapy and music intervention for dementia has been thought to be useful in accumulating evidence. There is a wide variety of quality of life (QOL) scales for AD, and the present review revealed that many scales have been used in traditional music therapy and music intervention research. QOL assessment scales follow Lowton's QOL model and have a variety of response formats, including those that require responses to caregivers [51] . Further, there are QOL scales for the elderly that are not limited to AD [52] . The QOL scale itself is under review, and it is anticipated that an optimal scale will be found in order to accumulate evidence for music therapy and music intervention in dementia. Finally, 20 categories were not investigated in the articles included in the survey. The outcome classifications developed by Dodd et al. [9] are a classification table that can be applied in general clinical research, and some categories were not applicable to dementia (e.g., congenital, familial, and hereditary outcomes; pregnancy and perinatal outcomes). However, economic outcomes have been examined in several previous studies [53, 54] , and in particular, music therapy for BPSD in dementia has been found to be more economical and more effective than pharmacotherapy. Importantly, while the studies reviewed were intervention studies, adverse events were not reported. Further, although singing was used in the intervention, respiratory outcomes were not assessed, suggesting that there are several issues that need to be clarified in future intervention studies using music therapy and music for dementia. Consequently, we extracted articles used in a systematic review in CDSR. In a normal review study, it is desirable to extract and analyze the data according to the PRIS-MA guidelines, but the content of this study did not meet the PRISMA guidelines. Therefore, we decided to proceed with the study in an exploratory manner. This is a limitation of this study. In conclusion, we investigated the effects of music therapy on dementia from articles used in a systematic review housed in the CDSR. As a result, we found that many studies investigated cognitive function, BPSD, and quality of life; compared to BPSD, various types of rating scales were used for cognitive function. By standardizing the rating scales, we can contribute to the accumulation of evidence for music therapy for dementia. This study protocol was reviewed and approved by Committee of the Advanced Institute of Industrial Technology, approval number 19009. Using the Delphi technique to determine which outcomes to measure in clinical trials: recommendations for the future based on a systematic review of existing studies Developing core outcome sets for clinical trials: issues to consider Driving up the quality and relevance of research through the use of agreed core outcomes A taxonomy has been developed for outcomes in medical research to help improve knowledge discovery Outcomes evaluated in controlled clinical trials on the management of COVID-19: a methodological systematic review Systematic review of outcome domains and instruments used in designs of clinical trials for interventions that seek to restore bilateral and binaural hearing in adults with unilateral severe to profound sensorineural hearing loss ("single-sided deafness") Can harmonisation of outcomes bridge the translation gap for pre-clinical research? A systematic review of outcomes measured in mouse models of type 2 diabetes Snoezelen for dementia Nonpharmacological interventions for wandering of people with dementia in the domestic setting. Cochrane Database Syst Rev Cognitive stimulation to improve cognitive functioning in people with dementia. Cochrane Database Syst Rev Reminiscence therapy for dementia Simulated presence therapy for dementia Cognitive training interventions for dementia and mild cognitive impairment in Parkinson's disease. Cochrane Database Syst Rev Effects of music on Alzheimer patients Management of verbally disruptive behaviors in nursing home residents Use of music to decrease aggressive behaviors in people with dementia Effects of cholinergic drugs and cognitive training on dementia Music therapy in moderate and severe dementia of Alzheimer's type: a case-control study A comparison of two treatments of agitated behavior in nursing home residents with dementia: simulated family presence and preferred music Effect of music therapy on anxiety and depression in patients with Alzheimer's type dementia: randomised, controlled study A randomized controlled trial exploring the effect of music on quality of life and depression in older people with dementia A randomized controlled trial exploring the effect of music on agitated behaviours and anxiety in older people with dementia Development of a music intervention protocol and its effect on participant engagement: experiences from a randomised controlled trial with older people with dementia Efficacy of music therapy treatment based on cycles of sessions: a randomised controlled trial Effects of music therapy on psychological symptoms and heart rate variability in patients with dementia. A pilot study Effectiveness of group music intervention against agitated behavior in elderly persons with dementia Conducting randomized controlled trials with older people with dementia in long-term care: challenges and lessons learnt STAM protocol in dementia: a multicenter, single-blind, randomized, and controlled trial Addendum to "Efficacy of music therapy treatment based on cycles of sessions: a randomised controlled trial A group music intervention using percussion instruments with familiar music to reduce anxiety and agitation of institutionalized older adults with dementia Individual music therapy for agitation in dementia: an exploratory randomized controlled trial Comparing the effects of different individualized music interventions for elderly individuals with severe dementia The effect of music therapy compared with general recreational activities in reducing agitation in people with dementia: a randomised controlled trial The impact of group music therapy on depression and cognition in elderly persons with dementia: a randomized controlled study Efficacy of musical interventions in dementia: evidence from a randomized controlled trial Cognitive, emotional, and social benefits of regular musical activities in early dementia: randomized controlled study Effect of music therapy versus recreational activities on neuropsychiatric symptoms in elderly adults with dementia: an exploratory randomized controlled trial Individual music therapy for managing neuropsychiatric symptoms for people with dementia and their carers: a cluster randomised controlled feasibility study Effect of active music therapy and individualized listening to music on dementia: a multicenter randomized controlled trial Efficacy of musical interventions in dementia: methodological requirements of nonpharmacological trials Music therapy in patients with dementia and behavioral disturbance on an inpatient psychiatry unit: results from a pilot randomized controlled study The effects of music therapy-singing group on quality of life and affect of persons with dementia: a randomized controlled trial The effects of music therapy on cognition, psychiatric symptoms, and activities of daily living in patients with Alzheimer's disease Classifying neurocognitive disorders: the DSM-5 approach Effects of music therapy on behavioral and psychological symptoms of dementia: a systematic review and meta-analysis Quality of life measures for dementia. Health Qual Life Outcomes Which measure of quality of life performs best in older age? A comparison of the OPQOL, CASP-19 and WHOQOL-OLD Music interventions against agitated behaviour in elderly persons with dementia: a cost-effective perspective A systematic review of the clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of sensory, psychological and behavioural interventions for managing agitation in older adults with dementia The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare.