key: cord-0784953-64ocuzrp authors: van Daalen, Kim Robin; Bajnoczki, Csongor; Chowdhury, Maisoon; Dada, Sara; Khorsand, Parnian; Socha, Anna; Lal, Arush; Jung, Laura; Alqodmani, Lujain; Torres, Irene; Ouedraogo, Samiratou; Mahmud, Amina Jama; Dhatt, Roopa; Phelan, Alexandra; Rajan, Dheepa title: Symptoms of a broken system: the gender gaps in COVID-19 decision-making date: 2020-10-01 journal: BMJ Glob Health DOI: 10.1136/bmjgh-2020-003549 sha: aae933b9e6943fe791999a9b417118c15fadccd2 doc_id: 784953 cord_uid: 64ocuzrp nan A growing chorus of voices are questioning the glaring lack of women in COVID-19 decision-making bodies. Men dominating leadership positions in global health has long been the default mode of governing. This is a symptom of a broken system where governance is not inclusive of any type of diversity, be it gender, geography, sexual orientation, race, socio-economic status or disciplines within and beyond health -excluding those who offer unique perspectives, expertise and lived realities. This not only reinforces inequitable power structures but undermines an effective COVID-19 response -ultimately costing lives. By providing quantitative data, we critically assess the gender gap in task forces organised to prevent, monitor and mitigate COVID-19, and emphasise the paramount exclusion of gender-diverse voices. The global community was unprepared as COVID-19 struck. As a result, countries swiftly established expert and decision-making structures through traditional processes: reaching out to government ministry directors, prominent experts and heads of well-known institutions. Most of these positions are typically held by men, as evidenced by our analysis of 115 expert and decision-making COVID-19 task forces from 87 countries: 85.2% of identified national task forces (n=115) contain mostly men, only 11.4% contain predominantly women and a mere 3.5% exhibit gender parity.* Similarly, 81 .2% (n=65) of these task forces were headed by men (table 1) . Men were overrepresented in global task forces to a similar extent to that of national task forces (table 2) . For instance, the WHO's first, second and third International Health Regulations Emergency committees consisted of 23.8%, 23.8% and 37.5% women, respectively. Expert groups, compared with decision-making committees, more frequently had higher proportions of women or gender parity, reflecting potential societal biases and stereotypes in terms of gender Summary box ► Despite numerous global and national commitments to gender-inclusive global health governance, COVID-19 followed the usual modus operandi -excluding women's voices. A mere 3.5% of 115 identified COVID-19 decision-making and expert task forces have gender parity in their membership while 85.2% are majority men. ► With 87 countries included in this analysis, information regarding task force composition and membership criteria was not easily publicly accessible for the majority of United Nations Member States, impeding the ability to hold countries accountable to previously made commitments. ► Lack of representation is one symptom of a broken system where governance is not inclusive of gender, geography, sexual orientation, race, socio-economic status or disciplines within and beyond health -ultimately excluding those who offer unique perspectives and expertise. ► Functional health systems require radical and systemic change that ensures gender-responsive and intersectional practices are the norm -rather than the exception. ► Open, inclusive and transparent communication and decision-making must be prioritised over closeddoor or traditional forms of governance. ► Data collection and governance policies must include sex and gender data, and strive for an intersectionality approach that includes going beyond binary representation in order to produce results that are inclusive of the full gender spectrum. This analysis was based on a large-scale effort collecting data on COVID-19 global and national decision-making and expert bodies for 193 UN Member States through a crowdsourcing effort, targeted grey literature searches, and outreach to national governments or World Health Organization (WHO) country offices. Data collection was completed June 2020. Gender was determined based on prefixes, pronouns and online bibliographies (table 3) . Most information pertaining to task force construction, leadership and membership criteria (eg, expertise) was not easily accessible nor publicly available, impeding research and, ultimately, the ability to hold countries accountable to previously made commitments. While current evidence suggests direct COVID-19 severity and mortality is higher for men, women are disproportionately burdened by compounded social and economic impacts. 1 2 Decision-making bodies which are neither inclusive nor diverse can easily overlook the reality that COVID-19 acts as a multiplier of pre-existing gender-based inequities. Many governments established COVID-19 response measures which disregarded women's higher levels of income loss, expanded and unpaid family care responsibilities, and gendered poverty rates. Ignorance of these implications exacerbates (lifetime) poverty and hunger. 3 Response measures often do not account for women's increased exposure to domestic and sexual violence or their loss of access to essential health services. Furthermore, many lockdown policies do not consider maternal and reproductive health service as essential care. [4] [5] [6] Experiences from Ebola and Zika demonstrated rises in maternal morbidity and mortality, unwanted pregnancies and unsafe abortions. 3 Despite being publicly praised with hollow applause, the majority of COVID-19 frontline health and social workforce are women who are underpaid, unpaid or are not recognised as essential at all. Failure to adequately provide resources and personal protective equipment exacerbates disease transmission and disproportionately harms workers in the health and social care sectors, which are predominated by women. 7 The situation is even more dire for marginalised individuals, such as those identifying as non-binary, transgender or genderqueer, as they are forced to navigate the discriminatory impacts of gender-based quarantine guidelines, which authorise specific days when women or men are allowed in public. As seen in Panama, this often led to harassment, abuse, arrest and fines of transgender people who were wrongfully profiled. 8 The exclusion of women and gender minorities stems from a host of factors including inherent conscious and unconscious biases, discrimination, workplace culture and gendered expectations. Unfortunately, this is not new. Although women comprise 70% of the global health workforce, they hold only 25% of senior decisionmaking roles. Women from the Global South are particularly underrepresented at global level holding less than 5% of senior leadership roles. This exclusion creates a vicious cycle where perspectives and knowledge of large segments of the population continue to be excluded. 11 12 One cannot expect a different result by replicating this same broken cycle over and over again. A 'new default' mode of diverse and intersectional governance is sorely needed to face future crises head-on and guide a healthy and equitable COVID-19 recovery. Reaching a critical mass of women in leadership -even as result of intentional selection or quotas -benefits governance processes through the disruption of groupthink, the introduction of novel viewpoints, a higher quality of monitoring and management, more effective risk management and robust deliberation. 13 Interestingly, countries with women leaders have been associated with implementing particularly effective COVID-19 responses and have been better at reducing COVID-19 negative impacts (fewer deaths per capita, a lower peak in daily deaths and lower excess mortality). A recent study indicated that countries with women in positions of leadership suffered six times fewer deaths from COVID-19 as countries with governments led by men. 14 Recognising the effectiveness of countries led by women may help in understanding the underlying prerequisites of effective leadership. Societies who elect female leaders may share a different set of values and perspectives, including gender equality, than more traditional societies. 15 Countries where women lead seem to have political institutions and cultures that have prepared for inclusive governance being practised prior to COVID-19, influencing their COVID-19 response. Gender quotas can establish a standard to redress inequalities in the public realm and enable more effective decision-making through gender parity. Increasing women's representation is a key step towards addressing inequalities-but it cannot stop there. 16 17 More women in leadership positions does not necessarily lead to changes in social norms nor does it guarantee the genderresponsive, gender-mainstreamed policies needed to mitigate the gendered vulnerabilities of pandemics. Women are not automatically gender-inclusive advocates, nor are men inevitably gender-exclusive. 17 18 Furthermore, gender intersects with additional factors that act as significant barriers to healthcare access and participation. This requires recognising inequities across ability, race, income, ethnicity, class, religion and geography, and intentionally prioritising programmes and resources 20 Claiming to not find any qualified women in global health is ultimately an unjustifiably poor excuse for excluding diverse perspectives. Systemic and cultural change must address traditional norms and attitudes, and embrace holistic gender-mainstreaming practices. This deep-rooted change is critical to ensure that health services and policies mitigate the adverse socio-economic impacts of COVID-19 and adequately meet the needs and safety of all populations. 17 21 GOING FURTHER THAN GENDER BINARIES Despite employing colloquial binary terms such as 'men' and 'women' to denote gender, we reiterate that gender is non-binary, socially produced, self-identified and complex. In a non-pandemic scenario, we would have sought to conduct a survey to self-identify gender, with appropriate ethics review, privacy and data protections in place. By relying on binary definitions of "gender," research initiatives (such as this one) and governance, emphasise the inability of current data to produce results that include the full gender spectrum. This means an entire segment of the population is misrepresented and side-lined from policy decisions that affect them. Promoting and integrating mechanisms that ensure inclusive intersectional data collection is one of the systemic changes needed for fair governance. Our data exhibit what has become a disturbingly accepted pattern in global health governance. Collective efforts in policy-making continue to overlook opportunities to create inclusive and comprehensive decisionmaking, echoing gender inequalities in other areas such as academia and the sciences. 22 The COVID-19 pandemic response requires inclusion of diverse perspectives, experiences and expertise in global health leadership. First, international and national task forces need to ensure diversity, particularly across gender, but also in terms of ethnic, racial, cultural, geographic and disability groups in decision-making and expert advisory bodies. Increasing representation and gender parity is a first step, but functional health systems require radical and systemic change that ensures gender-inclusive and intersectional practices are the norm -rather than the exception. Second, quick action in emergency scenarios is repeatedly used as a justification to sidestep transparency and restrict communication in the name of health security. Crises are precisely when transparent procedures and clear communication are required the most. Rather than relying on closed-door governance, open and transparent communication and decision-making should become the norm. Third, data collection and governance policies need to go beyond binary representation in order to produce results that are inclusive of the full gender spectrum. A future with resilient health systems depends on radical action to establish decision-making groups that reflect the populations they represent, in the time of COVID-19 and beyond. Leaving these voices unheard today sets a precedent for continued silence in the years to come. Gender differences in patients with COVID-19: focus on severity and mortality Early estimates of the indirect effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on maternal and child mortality in low-income and middle-income countries: a modelling study Women are most affected by pandemics -lessons from past outbreaks As domestic abuse rises, UK failings leave victims in peril: the New York Times Abortion during the Covid-19 pandemic -ensuring access to an essential health service Avoiding indirect effects of COVID-19 on maternal and child health PPE is made for a 6ft 3in rugby player': The Guardian Panama: set transgender-sensitive quarantine guidelines Panama: government takes step to end quarantine gender discrimination How transgender and non-binary communities around the world are being impacted by COVID-19 Gender equality in science, medicine, and global health: where are we at and why does it matter? Gender equality in the global health workplace: learning from a Somaliland-UK paired institutional partnership Challenging boardroom homogeneity: corporate law, governance, and diversity Women in power: female leadership and public health outcomes during the COVID-19 pandemic The spirit level: why more equal societies almost always do better Introduction: quotas -add women and stir? Why it must be a feminist global health agenda Transnational networks and policy diffusion: the case of gender mainstreaming COVID-19 sex-disaggregated data tracker OPERATION 50/50: Women's perspectives save lives Off the back burner: diverse and gender-inclusive decision-making for COVID-19 response and recovery Challenges for the female academic during the COVID-19 pandemic Kalo: Hapja të mos kalojë në shqyerje, qytetarët të respektojnë masat Euronews Albania 84% D9% 84% D8% AC% D9% 86% D8% A9-% D8% A7% D9% 84% D9% 88% D8% B7% D9% 86% D9% 8A% D8% A9-% D9% 84% D8% B1% D8% B5% D8% AF-% D9% 88% D9% 85% D8% AA% D8% A7% D8% A8% D8% B9% D8% A9-% D8% A7% D9% Quién es quién en el comité de expertos que asesora a Alberto Fernández El Presidente se reunió con el comité de expertos médicos y científicos 27 Government of Armenia. ՏՏ հայ մասնագետների խումբը կմոդելավորի կորոնավիրուսի հնարավոր տարածումը Հայաստանում National Center for Disease Control. Ստեղծվել է միջգերատեսչական հանձնաժողով. Available: https:// ncdc. am/% D5% BD% D5% BF% D5% A5% D5% B2% D5% AE% D5% BE% D5% A5% D5% AC-% D5% A7-% D5% B4% D5% AB% D5% BB% D5% A3% D5% A5% D6% 80% D5% A1% D5% BF% D5% A5% D5% BD% D5% B9% D5% A1% D5% AF% D5% A1% D5% B6-% D5% B0% D5% A1% D5% B6% D5% B1% D5% B6% D5% A1% D5% AA% D5% B8 29 Government of Australia. National COVID-19 coordination commissioners and key staff Announcement of the National COVID-19 coordination Commission (NCCC Australian Health Protection Principal Committee (AHPPC) Two women on the National COVID-19 Coordination Commission. Is it enough? : Women's Agenda Coronavirus -Taskforce: Federal Ministry for Social Affairs, Health, Care and Consumer Protection of Austria Bahamas appoints National Coordination Committee on COVID-19: magnetic media Nat'l committee for COVID-19 formed: The Nassau Guardian 37 Government of the People's Republic of Bangladesh. National preparedness and response plan for COVID-19 COVID-19 : une gestion de crise collégiale et complexe Que font les autorités? : Le service public fédéral (SPF) Santé publique, Sécurité de la Chaîne alimentaire et Environnement Coronavirus-point des mesures prises PAR Le gouvernement National preparedness and response plan for outbreak of novel coronavirus (COVID-19) Agradezco a los miembros del Consejo Científico Asesor que, de modo generoso, me acompañan con recomendaciones para luchar Contra el coronavirus te los presento para que vos también puedas conocerlos Instagram Meet the all-men COVID-19 Task Force team: the Voice newspaper Botswana Secretaria de Informação Legislativa Brasil. Decreto N° 10.211, de 30 de Janeiro de Secretaria de Informação Legislativa Brasil. Decreto N° 10.238, de 11 de Fevereiro de Decreto N° 10.277, de 16 de Marco de Comissão de Vigilância em Saúde debate situação do novo coronavírus Governo federal institui comitê de crise para tratar do coronavírus Diretor-presidente da anvisa é diagnosticado com covid-19 Кой кой е в медицинския "мозъчен тръст": Dnevnik Organigramme de Comité de Coordonnateur national de la réponse la pandémie de COVID-19 Prime Minister creates committee on COVID-19 Special advisory committee on COVID-19 COVID-19): Canada's response Council of chief medical officers of health (CCMOH) statement on cannabis extracts, edibles and topical products Presidente Piñera se reúne con Consejo Asesor del Minsal por COVID-19 Beijing pins hopes on 'guy with the emperor's sword' to restore order in coronavirus-hit Hubei The State Council -The People's Republic of China. Vice-premier inspects epidemic prevention work in Hubei Plan de contingencia para responder ante la emerhencia por COVID-19 Decret N 20-055/PR: Portant nomination des membres du Comité National de Coordination, du "Cadre de Gestion et de Coordination de la Crise du Covid-19 Du 27 Mars 2020 Portant création, attributions et organisation de la coordination nationale de gestion de la pandémie de coronavirus (COVID-19 La composition du comité scientifique entre alertas y buenas noticias: Presidencia Republíca de Cuba Una semana sin fallecidos la epidemia en Cuba está bajo control: Granma The Council of Ministers affirms launching of second phase of easing of restrictions with minor modifications Presidency of the Republic of Cyprus. Members of the Council of Ministers General: Council of Ministers Republic of Cyprus Un sacks top officials for "corruption" in meeting on coronavirus Three officials likely promoted to full members of North Korea's Politburo Prévention contre le COVID-19: le Conseil des Ministres extraordinaire se tient ce mardi Les membres du Comité multisectoriel de crise autour du PM ILUNKAMBA pour contrer la pandémie de coronavirus (COVID-19) en RDC Coordination/FNSCC: le Révérend Dominique Mukanya prend la place de Fridolin Ambongo Décret N° 2020-066/PRE portant mise en place d'un cadre institutionnel de gestion de crise liée la pandémie du COVID-19 La composition du Conseil des Ministres Comité Emergencia y Gestión Sanitaria conforma Consejo Internacional de Asesores para combatir COVID-19 en RD Lineamientos para el Diagnostico y Manejo de COVID-19 en el Ecuador Dirección del Seguro General de Salud individual y familiar KKK? fbclid= IwAR3eHAjWg2RPZjBQ_ Nq461jPdTAQQ-7dTekfyDO5P5Z68o2Gw0-JisYzEMw 88 Government of the Kingdom of Eswatini. National emergency management coordination structures Ethiopia steps up preparedness for potential coronavirus outbreak Ministry of Health Ethiopia. National comprehensive COVID19 management handbook Working group on essential work-related travel and other traffic appointed to assess the need for workers' entry into country in the state of emergency Working group to examine realisation of children's rights in aftermath of coronavirus Coronavirus : qui sont les onze membres du Conseil scientifique qui conseille le gouvernement: France Inter Qui compose le Conseil scientifique Covid-19 créé pour aider le gouvernement face la crise Didier Raoult claque la porte du Conseil scientifique de Macron Covid-19: qu'est-ce que le care ce nouveau comité de scientifiques qui conseille Macron Coronavirus: les scientifiques gabonais se jettent dans la bataille contre le dangereux virus Ghana coronavirus (COVID-19) situation report Inter-Ministerial Coordinating Committee on Decentralisation (IMCCoD) Ghana. IMCC members: Ghana, Inter-Ministerial Coordinating Committee on Decentralisation Αυτοί είναι οι 26 επιστήμονες της ελληνικής ομάδας «κρούσης» -Σε εξέλιξη η συνεδρίαση. Available: www. iefimerida. gr% 2Fellada% 2Fkoronoios-i-epistimoniki-omadakroysis-elladas COVID-19 update by Minister for health, social security and international business Information Service of Grenada. Ministry of health press conference on Information Service of Grenada. Ministry of health press conference on Guinée: alpha condé meuble le Conseil scientifique de riposte au COVID-19 Arrête A/2020/1038/PM/CAB/SGG portant attributions et composition du Comité Interministériel de lutte contre l'épidémie de Coronavirus-19 Decret D/2020/080/PRG/SGG Portant nomination des Membres du Conseil Scientifique de riposte contre la pandemie de la maladie a coronavirus (Covid-19) République de Guinee Inside PM Modi's COVID-19 task force COVID-19 outbreak in Iraq and the official outbreak response Minutes and agendas from meetings of the National Public Health Emergency Team: COVID-19 (coronavirus) Who SITS on the National public health emergency team and what do they do Statement from the national public health emergency team -first meeting of the expert advisory group takes place Coronavirus vertice alla Protezione Civile con iil Presidente Conte: Governo Italiano, Presidenza del Consiglio dei Ministri Borrelli nomina Comitato tecnico scientifico per l'emergenza coronavirus Cosa FA E dA chi è composto IL comitato tecnicoscientifico per l'emergenza Task force tech anti Covid-19 ecco i 74 esperti del governo (un po' troppi?) COVID-19 economic recovery Task Force established: Jamaica Information Service Prime Minister of Japan and his Cabinet. 新型コロナウイルス感染 症対策本部の設置について Uhuru forms taskforce to fight coronavirus Executive Order No. 2 of 2020 -National Emergency Response Committee on Coronavirus The Laotian Times. The national taskforce committee for Covid-19 prevention and control Koronaviruso krizės valdymą perima Skvernelio vadovaujamas komitetas: Lithuanian radio and television (LRT) Potvarkis del Valstybes Lygio Ekstrmaliosios Situacijos Valstybes Operaciju Vadovo Paskyrimo Prime Minister's first exchange with the ad hoc group to accompany the measures decided as part of the fight against COVID-19 Statement on coronavirus outbreak (COVID-19) 2020-000282/MSAS-SG du 25 Fev 2020 portant création du comité de crise pour la gestion des épidémies de coronavirus et de Crimée Congo portant nomination des membres du comité scientifique et technique de l'institut national de santé publique (INSP): République du Mali Disaster management reference Handbook: the center for excellence in disaster management and humanitarian assistance COVID-19 emergency response committee holds first coord meeting: The Republic of the Union of Myanmar, Ministry of Information Outbreak management team (OMT): Netherlands, Ministry of Health, Welfare and Sport Epidemic response Fixant les missions, la composition et le fonctionnement des structures d'appui auprès du Comité Interministériel de lutte contre la pandémie Coronavirus COVID-19: Buhari names 12-member presidential task force to control spread: the punch Plan de Respuesta Nacional al eventual Ingreso del coronavirus (COVID-19) v1.0, 2020. 139 Government of the Philippines. Philippines' National Task Force (NTF) COVID19 Atualização da Task Force para a operacionalização e a implementação de medidas para prevenção e controlo da infeção por novo Coronavírus -COVID-19 previstas no plano de contingência Direção-Geral da Saúde Quem São OS conselheiros da ministra da Saúde? Правни основ за доношење Закључка о образовању Кризног штаба за сузбијање заразне болести COVID-19 Multi-ministry taskforce on Wuhan coronavirus; terms of reference (TORS) and composition What South Africa's COVID-19 Ministerial Advisory Committee did and didn't advise on: Bhekisisa health journalism centre Republican order for the formation of a high level Task Force Committee to take extra precautionary measures in combating the spread of coronavirus disease (COVID-19 Se constituye oficialmente el Comité Científico Técnico COVID-19: España, Ministerio de Sanidad El Gobierno constituye oficialmente el Comité Científico Técnico Covid-19 President establishes task force to revive economy and eradicate poverty post COVID-19 Presidential task force on economic revival and poverty eradication established Swiss National Covid-19 Science Task Force. Organisation und wissenschaftliche Arbeitsfelder der task force Nouveau coronavirus: mesures et ordonnance: Switzerland Les membres du Conseil Fédéral: Switzerland Ministry of Public Health Thailand. National committee for controlling the spread of COVID-19 Thailan Coronavirus : de nouvelles têtes désignées pour la gestion de la crise: Le Nouveau Reporter Coronavirus: mise sur pied de la cellule de gestion PM appoints 22-member team for COVID-19 road to recovery The 15-member team managing the donations made towards COVID-19 fight New and emerging respiratory virus threats advisory group Advisory committee on dangerous pathogens Vice president Pence and secretary Azar add key administration officials to the coronavirus task force What we know about the White House coronavirus task force now that Mike Pence is in charge Severe outcomes among patients with coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) -United States Créase el Comité de Expertos Científicos en Gestión de la crisis Ministry of Health Vietnam contact. Composition of national steering committee for COVID-19 prevention and control List of proposed members and advisers to international health regulations (IHR) emergency Committee for pneumonia due to the novel coronavirus 2019-nCoV Report of the WHO-China joint mission on coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) Available: https://www. who. int/ news-room/ detail/ 30-01-2020-statement-on-the-second-meeting-of-theinternational-health-regulations-( 2005)-emergency-committeeregarding-the-outbreak-of-novel-coronavirus-( 2019-ncov List of members and advisers to international health regulations (IHR) 3rd emergency committee for COVID-19 -teleconference session European Commission's coronavirus response team Available: https:// ec. europa. eu/ transparency/ regexpert/ index. cfm? do= groupDetail. groupDetail& groupID= 3719& news= 1& new_ groups= 1& month= 03& year= 2020 Africa Centres for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)