key: cord-0781690-gzgx6zmk
authors: Devakumar, Delan; Bhopal, Sunil S; Shannon, Geordan
title: COVID-19: the great unequaliser
date: 2020-06-10
journal: J R Soc Med
DOI: 10.1177/0141076820925434
sha: 9b32a8a2c590ee4d9c08f9e8bdec9f8dd59f440c
doc_id: 781690
cord_uid: gzgx6zmk

nan

tory status, receive much less attention. The risk of contracting COVID-19, the severity of the illness and the risk of poor health related to the policies and actions responding to the pandemic are all increased in Black, Asian and minority ethnic and migrant groups. These amount to a form of structural violence, placing Black, Asian and minority ethnic people and migrants at greater risk.

First, Black, Asian and minority ethnic and migrant groups have a greater risk of contracting COVID-19 infection, as they are more likely to live in poor and overcrowded housing and do precarious forms of work or work in the gig economy. For many, stopping work is not just an inconvenience, it is impossible. This increases the chance of getting an infection and then it can more easily spread to family members in crowded and high-density dwellings. This is not to mention the 44% of the NHS medical workforce of Black, Asian and minority ethnic backgrounds, who are on the frontline treating patients with limited protection. 5 Second, Black, Asian and minority ethnic groups are more likely to get a severe form of infection. The evidence to date shows that having a non-communicable disease increases the risk of hospitalisation from COVID-19. 6 These diseases, such as diabetes or cardiovascular disease, tend to be more common in Black, Asian and minority ethnic groups. Data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in the USA show that 33% of hospitalised patients were Black, compared to 18% in the population. 7 Another important issue is that many migrant groups, especially those without documents, are less likely to seek help, or may seek help later, with more advanced disease. 8 The introduction of the UK Government's 'hostile environment' policy, including barriers to accessing the health service, such as upfront charging and the sharing of data with the Home Office, has led to migrants avoiding healthcare. 9 Infectious diseases are exempt from hospital charges but the rules are complicated and many people fear going to hospital in the first place.

Third, it is likely that the UK, and the world more generally, will enter one of the deepest recessions in a lifetime. This is in addition to the financial crisis of 2008 and subsequent decade of 'austerity' which has eroded national health and social safety nets, as well as the anticipated years of uncertainty and trade negotiations related to Brexit. The poorest, with insecure employment, and most vulnerable in terms of health are then at risk for other stress-mediated health problems, especially mental health issues, that increase in times of recession.

In the longer term, we also need to be careful to ensure that current emergency policies are maintained only as far as they are required to combat COVID-19. While technology, for example contact tracing apps for surveillance, may prove to be useful, it can also easily infringe on human rights afterwards, with minority and marginalised groups being affected disproportionately. 10 Infectious diseases have long been associated with 'othering' and minority groups are often blamed. Economic hardship is a fertile ground for populist movements to thrive and sadly, many world leaders have used the COVID-19 outbreak, mixing public health actions with divisive policies to further their own agendas. Minority and marginalised groups bear the brunt of this. Migrants are unfairly targeted as bringing infections into a country, when it is mostly business and frequent flying travellers and tourists. Take Victor Orban 11 or Matteo Salvini, 12 for example, who have linked COVID infections to illegal migrants coming into Hungary or Italy. Or Donald Trump's reassertion that a wall with Mexico might help. 3 In spite of mass suffering and death, why miss an opportunity to drive home your message? But policies that foster fear and division do not help anyone.

To successfully combat a pandemic, health protection measures rely on well-prepared and wellfunctioning health services that treat and support everyone, ensuring those most at risk are protected. Global health responses are not, however, limited to health service provision, but must be active in ensuring safe, inclusive and just social and structural conditions for everyone. Public health principles based around equity should be firmly at the core of the world's response.

Competing Interests: None declared.

Funding: None declared.

Ethics approval: Not applicable.

Contributorship: DD conceived the work and wrote the first draft. GS and SSB interpreted and critically revised the draft.

Racism and discrimination in COVID-19 responses

Anti-Asian racism during coronavirus: how the language of disease produces hate and violence. The Conversation

China outraged after Brazil minister suggests Covid-19 is part of 'plan for world domination

Clinical characteristics of Coronavirus Disease 2019 in China

Hospitalization rates and characteristics of patients hospitalized with laboratory-confirmed Coronavirus Disease 2019 -COVID-NET, 14 States

Charging undocumented migrant children for NHS healthcare: implications for child health

The negative health effects of hostile environment policies on migrants: A cross-sectional service evaluation of humanitarian healthcare provision in the UK

The Disparate Impact of Surveillance

Orban uses coronavirus as excuse to suspend asylum rights in Hungary

Salvini attacks Italy PM over coronavirus and links to rescue ship. The Guardian