key: cord-0775689-uyjnmqid
authors: de Araújo, Leonardo José Tadeu; Gonzalez, Lorenzo Lang; Buss, Lewis Fletcher; Guerra, Juliana Mariotti; Gomez, David Salas; Ferreira, Camila Santos da Silva; Cirqueira, Cinthya Santos; Ghillardi, Fábio; Witkin, Steven S.; Sabino, Ester Cerdeira
title: Surveillance of hemorrhagic fever and/or neuroinvasive disease: challenges of diagnosis
date: 2021-06-17
journal: Revista de saude publica
DOI: 10.11606/s1518-8787.2021055003068
sha: defb1cd667de7008b358cefd752b437f4edd2159
doc_id: 775689
cord_uid: uyjnmqid

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the performance of post mortem laboratory analysis in identifying the causes of hemorrhagic fever and/or neuroinvasive disease in deaths by arbovirus infection. METHODS: Retrospective cross-sectional study based on the differential analysis and final outcome obtained in patients whose samples underwent laboratory testing for arboviruses at the Pathology Center of the Adolfo Lutz Institute, in São Paulo, Brazil. RESULTS: Of the 1355 adults clinically diagnosed with hemorrhagic fever and/or neuroinvasive disease, the most commonly attributed cause of death and the most common final outcome was dengue fever. Almost half of the samples tested negative on all laboratory tests conducted. CONCLUSION: The failure to identify the causative agent in a great number of cases highlights a gap in the diagnosis of deaths of unknown etiology. Additional immunohistochemical and molecular assessments need to be added to the post-mortem protocol if all laboratory evaluations performed fail to identify a causative agent. While part of our findings may be due to technical issues related to sample fixation, better information availability when making the initial diagnosis is crucial. Including molecular approaches might lead to a significant advancement in diagnostic accuracy.

The Brazilian National Health System (SUS) surveillance system is responsible for investigating causes of death related to infectious diseases in the state of São Paulo 1 . When a diagnosis of the cause of death is uncertain, the system performs a post-mortem analysis encompassing all available clinical, laboratory and epidemiological evidence to assess possible etiological agents. This represents the final opportunity to establish the most likely diagnosis and subsequently alert public health officials to initiate improved surveillance measures.

Arboviruses (ARthropod-BOrne virus) are responsible for a large number of different infections with similar clinical manifestations, ranging from mild to severe febrile illnesses, hemorrhagic fever, and neuroinvasive diseases 2 . Several outbreaks have occurred in Brazil due to newly introduced or re-emerging arboviruses 3, 4 , each representing a serious public health issue due to difficulties in containment, differential diagnosis and treatment. When caused by non-Arbovirus diseases, laboratory analysis play a pivotal role in the differential diagnosis of hemorrhagic fever (leptospirosis, spotted fever, hantavirus 5 ) and neuroinvasive diseases (such as meningitis, herpes, rabies 6 ).

This study evaluates the performance of post-mortem laboratory analysis in identifying the causes of deaths associated with hemorrhagic fever and/or neuroinvasive disease of unknown etiology in the state of São Paulo from 2009 to 2019.

This is a retrospective cross-sectional study conducted at the Pathology Center of the Adolfo Lutz Institute between January 2009 and February 2019. Patient records and laboratory results were accessed in the laboratory management systems (GAL and SIGH).

According to recommendations from the Ministry of Health, all suspected deaths must be investigated following the São Paulo State Protocol for the Investigation of Severe Cases and Deaths by Urban Arbovirus 1 , in which samples follow a designated laboratory flow chart (Figure 1 ). For the purpose of this study, we grouped the cases according to their initial proposed diagnosis, which was based on clinical, laboratory, epidemiological, and necroscopic information -typical basis for post-mortem laboratory analysis. After a multi-organ histopathological analysis, a second possible diagnosis may become evident, which then required further assessment of the immunohistochemistry findings ( Figure 1 ).

Our study included patients whose samples underwent laboratory testing for any arbovirus, based on suspected cause of death. Samples were referred for laboratory confirmation if they were related to:

• an urban arbovirus infection outbreak by clinical (regardless of disease progression or the duration of its acute phase) and epidemiological evidence 7 .

• presumed non-arbovirus pathogens, not confirmed by laboratory testing, in which multi-organ histopathological analysis showed findings suggestive of arbovirus infection.

For real-time PCR (qPCR), blood and multi-organ samples (Table 1) were collected during the necroscopic examination, immediately frozen, and sent to the Adolfo Lutz Institute.

Multi-organ tissue fragments (Table 1) 

(Gather information to elaborate the initial diagnose hypothesis, which requires specific analysis to be assessed) (May raise a secondary diagnose hypothesis, which require new analysis to be assessed)

From the initial 1405 cases, we excluded those involving stillbirths and children under one, resulting in 1355 cases for analysis. Most cases (847, 62%) involved males, with a median (range) age of 40 (26-55) years. (2) a Percentages from the 1355 cases included in the dataset. Most cases received more than one differential diagnosis, resulting in the percentages totaling more than 100%. Table 2 shows the most common diagnostic hypotheses related to the cause of death in these patients. Most samples were tested for dengue (76%), followed by leptospirosis (47%), yellow fever (29%), rickettsia (28%), hantavirus (24%), influenza (16%), chikungunya (4%) and zika virus (2%), with immunohistochemistry being the most frequently employed detection method (Table 3) . Note: Percentages are out of the total in column 1 -e.g., 94% of cases in which dengue were the initial diagnoses were tested for dengue. Table 4 presents the set of differential diagnostic tests employed. Even the high number of tests performed in these sets was insufficient to elucidate most cases, since almost half (48%) tested negative in all laboratory tests conducted, having to rely only on clinical and epidemiological findings for a resolution. Among those with a definitive final diagnosis, 145 (11%) tested positive for dengue, 140 (10%) for yellow fever, 89 (7%) for influenza and 79 (6%) for rickettsia (Table 5 ). Figure 2 shows the variation between the number of cases according to initial and final diagnosis, depicting the increase in the number of suspected and confirmed cases in specific years, as occurred for dengue, yellow fever and rickettsia outbreaks. The annual seasonal pattern of influenza outbreaks is also evident.

Green line -number of deaths linked to a given differential diagnosis. Blue line -number of cases that received that final diagnosis (e.g., from the top left panel is the number of cases that received a final dengue diagnosis). In the "All ddx" panel (bottom left) the black line refers to all cases of suspected arboviral infection (whole dataset) and the blue line those cases that received a final diagnosis. The temporal aggregation is on a seasonal level. The set of diagnostic tests employed as part of the post-mortem protocol may therefore require additional immunohistochemical and/or molecular evaluation if all laboratory results fail to identify a causative agent. As a result of the post-mortem investigation, about 10% of the final diagnoses differed from the initial diagnoses. Diseases such as bacterial/fungal infection, viral hepatitis, adenovirus, enterovirus, herpes, neoplasms, and heart attacks would have remained undiagnosed if it were not for the histopathological post-mortem investigation procedures. Moreover, the set of diagnostic tests performed on fresh tissue is different from that performed on FFPE tissue. Ideally, both tissue specimens would be collected 17 , but sometimes only one of them is available. In our cohort, some of the FFPE samples lacked a corresponding fresh aliquot available and therefore relied only on immunohistochemical and anatomopathological analysis for diagnosis.

We also have a clear logistics limitation depending on the distance from the collection point to the reference center, along with transport conditions. Although the qPCR assay is able to provide information on the presence of infectious agents at the molecular level, being a very high specific analysis 18 , it is performed only on fresh frozen tissue in public surveillance laboratories. Despite its technical limitations 19, 20 , FFPE analysis provides valuable support to immunohistochemical 21, 22 and anatomopathological evidence. Cytological architecture is preserved and the samples can be used to perform molecular tests, such as conventional 23 or quantitative reverse transcriptase PCR 19, 20 . It is important to consider, however, that although immunohistochemistry may reveal the presence of viral antigens within the tissue sample, its specificity may be limited due to the cross-reactivity observed in commercially available antibodies 20, [24] [25] [26] This reinforces the need to use molecular methods as a complementary tool for FFPE.

Despite all efforts to identify an etiological agent, almost half of the cases investigated at the Pathology Center during the study did not receive a final laboratory diagnosis, thus relying solely on clinical and epidemiological information for a tentative conclusion 1 . This is consistent with prior studies reporting that conventional laboratory assays failed to detect a causative agent in approximately 40% of gastroenteritis 27 cases and 60% of encephalitis 28 cases. Part of our findings could be attributed to technical issues related to sample fixation 20-21 , but we also highlight the importance of better information availability when making the initial diagnosis, and having these data available to the reference laboratories (via online laboratory management systems). Lack of clinical data may limit implementing additional laboratory approaches. The more complete and accurate the investigation, the better will be the quality of laboratory surveillance, not only reducing the waiting time for a result, but also limiting the number of unnecessary tests and consequently easing the financial burden on Public Health.

As identified, many other common non-infectious diseases/pathologies (e.g., neoplasms, hepatopathies, vasculitis, hematologic diseases) can mimic arbovirus infections and even hemorrhagic fevers, misleading the diagnostic hypothesis. Another point to consider is that even when laboratory reports are negative for all tested pathogens, the undetected causative agent may be a known species that was simply not included in the laboratory's testing algorithm. Alternatively, it might involve a truly novel pathogen 29 . Surveillance laboratories must be constantly prepared to identify new pathogens, because their rapid detection is necessary to initiate public health measures.

A potential way to improve laboratory surveillance would be to perform PCR on FFPE samples 30,31 , using specific kits or protocols. Pathogen non-specific molecular methods, such as metagenomic approaches, could have even greater efficacy. Metagenomic sequencing can be used to detect any pathogen without the need for sequence-specific amplification. These sequence data can then be used to predict antibiotic resistance phenotypes 32 , detect co-infections 33 , identify infectious disease outbreaks of unknown causes, and diagnose patients with suspected infections but negative results in conventional tests 34 . This could be a powerful new tool for post-mortem analysis for surveillance purposes. As next-generation sequencing technologies continue to improve and its costs reduced, metagenomic approaches may become increasingly common in public health laboratories. Depending on the clinical and epidemiological information available, a syndromic laboratory approach could be useful for diagnosing hemorrhagic fever deaths of unknown etiology. Multiplex molecular diagnostic assays are able to simultaneously detect and identify the most frequent infectious causes of a single clinical syndrome. They are more accurate, faster and convenient than most techniques previously used in the laboratory 35, 36 .

Thus, using a syndromic panel applied to hemorrhagic fever deaths of unknown etiology could contribute to improved surveillance, as has been shown in the diagnosis of respiratory, gastrointestinal, and central nervous system infections 35, 36 . Monitoring spatial-temporal trends to identify clusters of negative cases can be used to facilitate early detection of silent infectious disease outbreaks 37 or even overcome logistical issues affecting sample quality and results, which can occur in non-random yet clustered distributions.

Importantly, the SARS-CoV-2 virus, cause of the COVID-19 acute respiratory disease, was detected in Wuhan, China, by monitoring the emergence of severe cases of "pneumonia of unknown etiology" 38, 39 . This underlines the importance of surveillance systems for fatal infectious diseases of unknown etiology to help recognize the emergence of a new outbreak.

Our findings highlight the relevance of a post-mortem laboratory investigation for the accurate diagnosis of arbovirus infections, revealing a gap in the surveillance of deaths from hemorrhagic fever and/or neuroinvasive disease caused by arbovirus infection in the state of São Paulo. The availability of more comprehensive patient data to reference laboratories could improve the quality of laboratory testing. In the future, metagenomic and syndromic laboratory approaches might lead to a significant advance in diagnostic accuracy, thus directly contributing to solving these death causes.

Diretrizes para prevenção e controle das arboviroses urbanas no Estado de São Paulo

Potential role of dengue virus, chikungunya virus and Zika virus in neurological diseases

Emerging arboviruses and public health challenges in Brazil

Características gerais e epidemiologia dos arbovírus emergentes no Brasil

Febres hemorrágicas

Secretaria de Vigilância em Saúde, Coordenação Geral de Desenvolvimento. Guia de vigilância em saúde. 3

Serotype-specific detection of dengue viruses in a fourplex real-time reverse transcriptase PCR assay

Advanced yellow fever virus genome detection in point-of-care facilities and reference laboratories

Chikungunya virus in US travelers returning from India

Genetic and serologic properties of Zika virus associated with an epidemic, Yap State, Micronesia

Síndrome pulmonar e cardiovascular por hantavírus

Diagnóstico molecular das leishmanioses: contribuição ao Programa de Vigilância e Controle da LVA no Estado de São Paulo

Aseptic meningitis caused by Leptospira spp diagnosed by polymerase chain reaction

Evolution of bacterial meningitis diagnosis in São Paulo State-Brazil and future challenges

Rickettsia species infecting Amblyomma cooperi ticks from an area in the State of São Paulo, Brazil, where Brazilian spotted fever is endemic

Secretaria de Vigilância em Saúde, Departamento de Vigilância Epidemiológica. Guia de vigilância epidemiológica

Molecular amplification assays for the detection of flaviviruses

Succesfully overcoming the challenges of working with FFPE samples. Madison, WI: Promega Corporation

Against all odds: RNA extraction from different protocols adapted to formalin-fixed paraffinembedded tissue

When tissue antigens and antibodies get along: revisiting the technical aspects of immunohistochemistry: the red, brown, and blue technique

Archived formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) blocks: a valuable underexploited resource for extraction of DNA, RNA, and protein

Culture cell block controls as a tool to the biomolecular diagnosis of infectious diseases

Histologic, viral, and molecular correlates of dengue fever infection of the liver using highly sensitive immunohistochemistry

Immunohistochemical characterization of a new monoclonal antibody reactive with dengue virus-infected cells in frozen tissue using immunoperoxidase technique

Retrospective study on dengue fatal cases

Metagenomic analysis of human diarrhea: viral detection and discovery

Diagnostic strategy used to establish etiologies of encephalitis in a prospective cohort of patients in England

Metagenomics for pathogen detection in public health

Molecular detection and typing of dengue viruses from archived tissues of fatal cases by RT-PCR and sequencing: diagnostic and epidemiologic implications

One-step multiplex real-time RT-PCR for molecular detection and typing of dengue virus infection from paraffin-embedded tissues during the Brazilian 2019 outbreak

Genomics and outbreak investigation: from sequence to consequence

Coinfections of Zika and chikungunya viruses in Bahia, Brazil, identified by metagenomic next-generation sequencing

Validation of metagenomic next-generation sequencing tests for universal pathogen detection

Direct-from-specimen pathogen identification: evolution of syndromic panels

Multiplexed molecular diagnostics for respiratory, gastrointestinal, and central nervous system infections

Spatial and temporal aberration detection methods for disease outbreaks in syndromic surveillance systems

A review of coronavirus disease-2019 (COVID-19)

SARS-CoV-2: a storm is raging