key: cord-0775524-509p6use authors: Smith, Everett Clinton; Denison, Mark R. title: Coronaviruses as DNA Wannabes: A New Model for the Regulation of RNA Virus Replication Fidelity date: 2013-12-05 journal: PLoS Pathog DOI: 10.1371/journal.ppat.1003760 sha: c0cf1c6377c3115aa80ff787332120d4ba1cd386 doc_id: 775524 cord_uid: 509p6use nan RNA viruses rely primarily on low-fidelity replication by RNAdependent RNA polymerases (RdRps) to facilitate viral adaptation to complex host environments [4] . Because of the lack of proofreading and repair functions, the average mutation rate of RNA viruses is estimated to be around one mutation per genome per round of replication [5, 6] . Much beyond this rate, RNA viruses risk crossing an ''error threshold,'' or the point at which there are too many deleterious mutations for the viral population to reproduce faithfully [4] . Thus, while allowing for enormous population diversity, the low-fidelity of RdRp-mediated replication imposes constraints on both viral genome size and maintenance of genomic integrity, theoretically limiting the size of RNA virus genomes to around ,15 kb (reviewed in [4] ). RNA viruses have evolved several mechanisms to partially circumvent these constraints, including large population sizes, rapid replication cycles, robustness to mutations, recombination, and compact genomes [7, 8] . In addition to these mechanisms, CoVs encode several additional RNA-processing functions within their 16 nonstructural proteins (nsp1-16), including a 39-to-59 exoribonuclease (nsp14-ExoN; Figure 1 ). Many of these enzymatic functions likely have facilitated the expansion of the CoV genome beyond the ,15 kb upper limit. CoV nsp14-ExoN contains four conserved DE-D-D acidic residues ( Figure 1B ; [9] ), which are the hallmark of the DEDDh superfamily of DNA and RNA exonucleases. Many of these DEDDh exonucleases are involved in proofreading [10] . Alanine substitutions at the CoV DE-D-D residues significantly reduces or abolishes the nucleolytic activity of nsp14-ExoN in vitro [9] and results in CoVs with up to 20-fold reduced fidelity (increased mutation rate) in vitro [11, 12] and in vivo [13] . A recent biochemical study demonstrated that nsp14-ExoN is capable of removing single 39 mismatched nucleotides and that this activity is stimulated by the non-enzymatic protein nsp10 [14] . Thus, all biochemical and genetic studies indicate that CoV nsp14-ExoN performs a proofreading function during CoV replication. Is nsp14-ExoN the Proofreading Component of a Multi-Subunit Polymerase Complex Containing nsp10 and nsp12-RdRp? The identification of a proofreading exoribonuclease distinct from the CoV RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (nsp12-RdRp) suggests that CoVs might use a multi-protein complex for RNA synthesis and regulation of fidelity. A possible analogy would be the E. coli DNA polymerase III (pol III) core (aeh), which contains a polymerase (a subunit), a DEDDh exonuclease (e subunit), and an exonuclease stimulatory protein (h subunit) [15] . Is there evidence to support or to even suggest the possibility that CoVs contain a DNA pol III-like multi-subunit polymerase complex? Several lines of evidence support the hypothesis that regulation of CoV fidelity involves, at minimum, three nsps: nsp12-RdRp, nsp14-ExoN, and nsp10 ( Figure 1C ). The presence of nsp12-RdRp would be critical as nsp14-ExoN has not been demonstrated to possess polymerase activity, and thus error recognition, removal, and repair would require interactions between nsp14-ExoN and nsp12-RdRp on elongating RNA. Several studies with poliovirus, chikungunya virus, and Coxsackievirus have demonstrated that point mutations within the viral RdRp can decrease or increase fidelity [16] [17] [18] [19] . While the fidelity of nucleoside triphosphate (NTP) incorporation for nsp12-RdRp has not been determined, CoV nsp12-RdRp would provide essential polymerase activity and likely function to regulate fidelity primarily through NTP discrimination. The CoV nsp10 is a ,130 amino acid protein with no identified enzymatic function that has been demonstrated to bind and enhance nsp14-ExoN activity in vitro by up to 35-fold [14] . While the precise mechanism and function of this stimulation during virus replication remain unknown, nsp10 also plays a critical yet undefined role in viral polyprotein processing and RNA synthesis [20, 21] . Unlike prototypical members of the DEDDh exonuclease superfamily, nsp14-ExoN contains a zinc-finger (ZnF) domain that is likely critical for associating with viral RNA, though the affinity of nsp14 for RNA has not been determined ( Figure 1B) . Nsp10 also has two ZnF domains [22] . Thus, nsp10 might increase the affinity of nsp14 for RNA, or directly affect ExoN activity through allosteric mechanisms. Extending our analogy of CoV nsp10 to the theta (h) subunit of the E. coli pol III core, theta is a ,76 amino acid protein with no known enzymatic function that has been shown to both bind and stabilize the pol III e subunit and stimulate e-mediated removal of terminal mismatches [23, 24] . Thus, nsp10 could act to increase nsp14-ExoN stability, or possibly alter the capacity or preference of nsp14 to remove certain types of mismatches. Why CoVs encode an enhancer of ExoN activity remains unknown. However, the presence of such a complex might allow for greater control, and potentially active regulation, of replication fidelity. CoVs Encode Primase, Single-Strand RNA Binding, and Helicase Activities within nsps 8, 9 and 13 Might other CoV nonstructural proteins be associated with this putative multi-subunit polymerase? And how would such a complex be assembled? Again using E. coli pol III as a model, in addition to the aeh core, the pol III holoenzyme requires additional subunits including a processivity factor (b sliding clamp), single-strand DNA-binding proteins (SSB), and a helicase (DnaB; reviewed in [15] ). Remarkably, ssRNA-binding, helicase, and NTPase (e.g., ATPase) functions have been identified within the CoV replicase. SARS-CoV nsp9 dimerizes and binds both ssDNA and ssRNA in a sequence-independent manner [25] . The capacity of nucleic acid to be bound by multiple nsp9 dimers strongly suggests that nsp9 could function as an SSB-like molecule, thus protecting the CoV genome from degradation during replication ( Figure 1C ). NTPase and helicase activity have been identified within nsp13 of human coronavirus 229E [26, 27] . Because dsRNA is likely an abundant replicative intermediate, nsp13 could function ahead of the polymerase complex and unwind the dsRNA, which would then be subsequently bound by nsp9. More recent work has shown that SARS-CoV nsp8 has noncanonical RdRp activity and likely functions as a primase [28] . Additionally, two distinct folds of nsp8, named I and II, participate in a hexadecameric nsp7-nsp8 supercomplex capable of primer extension and binding RNA, likely due to the presence of a ,30 Å central channel lined with positively charged amino acids ( Figure 1C ) [29, 30] . Combined, these studies suggest that the nsp7-nsp8 supercomplex could be analogous to the b sliding clamp within the pol III holoenzyme, which increases both the processivity and speed of the a subunit [15] . Ribavirin (RBV) and 5-fluorouracil (5-FU) have been shown to be mutagenic for many RNA viruses (reviewed in [31] ). Nucleoside analogs, including both mutagens and chain terminators, have been tested or are used to treat many RNA and DNA viruses, including herpesviruses, HIV, hepatitis C virus, and hepatitis B virus. However, in vitro and in vivo studies demonstrate the limited antiviral activity and variable effectiveness of RBV against SARS-CoV infection [32, 33] . Our recent study shows that nsp14-ExoN is responsible for CoV resistance to RNA mutagens. SARS-CoV and murine hepatitis virus (MHV) lacking ExoN activity (ExoN2) demonstrate 160-to 300-fold increased sensitivity to 5-FU [34] . While 5-FU treatment significantly increases the number of mutations present within both wild-type (ExoN+) and ExoN2 viruses, almost 4,000 mutations were present in the ExoN2 population following a single round of replication ( Figure 2 ). This suggests that small-molecule inhibitors of ExoN could reproduce this genetic defect, and render CoVs vulnerable to treatment with RNA mutagens and obligate or non-obligate chain-terminating nucleoside analogs. The complete conservation of the ExoN2 genotype and phenotype in CoVs studied to date [11] [12] [13] , and the lack of redundancy or complementation of ExoN activity, further suggests that ExoN inhibition is a broadly applicable approach to therapeutically target CoVs. Furthermore, ExoN2 viruses are highly attenuated in vivo, suggesting that smallmolecule inhibition of ExoN activity would also significantly impact virus infection and virulence [13] . Finally, the probability that fidelity is regulated by a multi-protein complex involving nsp12-RdRp, nsp14-ExoN, and nsp10 suggests that interference with fidelity could be achieved through the disruption of multiple enzymatic activities and/or protein-protein interactions. The opportunity to disrupt the process of CoV fidelity regulation through the simultaneous targeting of multiple proteins, instead of a single protein or enzymatic function, has the potential for broad applicability and for potentially thwarting the emergence of resistance, particularly in combination with mutagens or other nucleoside analogs. Coronaviruses encode a proofreading exoribonuclease that is responsible for genome expansion, increased robustness to mutations, and resistance to mis-incorporations during RNA synthesis, as well as being required for virulence. The stability of the ExoN2 genotype and phenotype provides a powerful model for the study of additional CoV fidelity determinants and of the effects of altered fidelity on virus replication, fitness, host-species range, and response to environmental changes. Experiments testing the proposed multi-subunit fidelity complex will yield exciting new insights into how CoVs ignore the RNA virus playbook and instead seem to play by their own rules while dancing on the edge of genetic disaster. Identification of a novel coronavirus in patients with severe acute respiratory syndrome A novel coronavirus associated with severe acute respiratory syndrome Isolation of a novel coronavirus from a man with pneumonia in Saudi Arabia Viral quasispecies evolution The rate and character of spontaneous mutation in an RNA virus Mutation rates among RNA viruses Mutational robustness of an RNA virus influences sensitivity to lethal mutagenesis The role of mutational robustness in RNA virus evolution Discovery of an RNA virus 39R59 exoribonuclease that is critically involved in coronavirus RNA synthesis Exoribonuclease superfamilies: structural analysis and phylogenetic distribution Infidelity of SARS-CoV Nsp14-exonuclease mutant virus replication is revealed by complete genome sequencing High fidelity of murine hepatitis virus replication is decreased in nsp14 exoribonuclease mutants A live, impaired-fidelity coronavirus vaccine protects in an aged, immunocompromised mouse model of lethal disease RNA 39-end mismatch excision by the severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus nonstructural protein nsp10/nsp14 exoribonuclease complex Cellular DNA replicases: components and dynamics at the replication fork Coxsackievirus B3 mutator strains are attenuated in vivo Arbovirus high fidelity variant loses fitness in mosquitoes and mice Quasispecies diversity determines pathogenesis through cooperative interactions in a viral population A single mutation in poliovirus RNAdependent RNA polymerase confers resistance to mutagenic nucleotide analogs via increased fidelity Murine hepatitis virus replicase protein nsp10 is a critical regulator of viral RNA synthesis Analysis of murine hepatitis virus strain A59 temperature-sensitive mutant TS-LA6 suggests that nsp10 plays a critical role in polyprotein processing Crystal structure of nonstructural protein 10 from the severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus reveals a novel fold with two zinc-binding motifs DNA polymerase III accessory proteins. V. Theta encoded by holE The theta subunit of Escherichia coli DNA polymerase III: a role in stabilizing the epsilon proofreading subunit The severe acute respiratory syndrome-coronavirus replicative protein nsp9 is a single-stranded RNA-binding subunit unique in the RNA virus world The human coronavirus 229E superfamily 1 helicase has RNA and DNA duplex-unwinding activities with 59-to-39 polarity Guanosine triphosphatase activity of the human coronavirus helicase A second, non-canonical RNA-dependent RNA polymerase in SARS coronavirus Insights into SARS-CoV transcription and replication from the structure of the nsp7-nsp8 hexadecamer The SARS-coronavirus nsp7+nsp8 complex is a unique multimeric RNA polymerase capable of both de novo initiation and primer extension Lethal mutagenesis of viruses SARS: systematic review of treatment effects Enhancement of the infectivity of SARS-CoV in BALB/c mice by IMP dehydrogenase inhibitors, including ribavirin Coronaviruses lacking exoribonuclease activity are susceptible to lethal mutagenesis: evidence for proofreading and potential therapeutics Space limitations did not allow for citing the important work of all of our colleagues, for which we apologize.