key: cord-0770346-ba7fxmnj
authors: Hao, Er-wei; Su, Zi-xia; Gong, Yan-ling; Du, Zheng-cai; Yang, Xue; Huang, Chun-tao; Hou, Xiao-tao; Deng, Jia-gang
title: Analysis on application law of dampness-removing chinese medicine in treatment of coronavirus disease 2019
date: 2021-10-01
journal: Chin Herb Med
DOI: 10.1016/j.chmed.2021.09.011
sha: 2c79b5cebfce9b12f15d130189fd7cdbd69234ee
doc_id: 770346
cord_uid: ba7fxmnj

OBJECTIVE: Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) has been diagnosed as an epidemic disease characterized by cold and dampness pathogens in TCM clinic. Due to many Chinese medicines with different functions were used in the treatment of COVID-19, it is very important to find the law of application of damp-removing Chinese medicine with high frequency application, with view to providing a reference for the use and research of Chinese medicine to further control the pandemic. METHODS: The publicly released diagnosis and treatment programs issued by the National Health Commission and Health Commission of provinces, autonomous regions and municipalities, and Chinese herbs prescription information in these were collected, a database was established, and Excel and Graphpad 8.0 software were used to analyze the frequency of use of various Chinese medicines, the frequency and property characters including five flavors (bitter, pungent, sweet, sour, and salty) and four qi (warm, hot, cool, and cold) and channel tropisms of Chinese medicine for removing dampness. RESULTS: A total of 137 prescriptions of Chinese medicine for treating COVID-19 were collected, including 178 TCMs showing functions of resolving phlegm, relieving cough and asthma, resolving dampness, clearing damp and inducing dieresis, clearing heat, tonifying deficiency, and relieving exterior syndrome, in which the TCMs with the first four functions that we called the removing-dampness TCMs, accounted for 35.78%. Also a number of TCMs in the rest functions showed removing-dampness. The first four functions were divided into subfunctions including aromatic resolving dampness, clearing heat and drying dampness, drying dampness and tonifying spleen qi, drying dampness and removing phlegm, inducing diuresis and relieving swelling, inducing diuresis and relieving exterior syndrome. Among them, the most frequently used TCMs was Ephedrae Herba, followed by Citri Reticulatae Pericarpium, Pogostemonis Herba, Pinelliae Rhizoma, Poria, Scutellariae Radix, and Atractylodis Rhizoma. The property character analysis in the removing-dampness TCMs showed that bitter and pungent were largely present and sour and astringent were absent, warm and hot were dominant; And the lung, spleen, stomach, large intestine, bladder were main channel tropisms. CONCLUSION: This study may provide meaningful and useful information on further research to investigate the effective compounds from the dampness-removing Chinese medicine with high frequency application, and also provide a reference for the clinical treatment of COVID-19 accurately against dampness evil with dampness-removing Chinese medicine.

Coronavirus disease 2019 was with the characteristics of strong infectivity, rapid development and general susceptibilities, and seriously endangering people's lives and health around the world. In the fight against the COVID-19, traditional Chinese medicines (TCMs) were used in the early stage and participated in the whole process. As of March 23 th , 2020, 74,187, or 91 .5%, of the confirmed cases of COVID-19 nationwide used TCM, including 61,449, or 90.6%, in Hubei Province, China , and studies had confirmed that the combination of TCM could improve symptoms such as fever, cough, and weakness more quickly, shorten the number of days of hospitalization, improve the rate of nucleic acid conversion, and effectively reduce the number of light and the development of common type to heavy type and heavy type to critical type, improve the cure rate and reduce the death rate of disease (Huang, 2011) . TCMs has made an important contribution to the comprehensive prevention and control of COVID-19, highlighting the unique advantages over the past thousands of years to prevent and control plague.

COVID-19 which caused infectious pneumonia and spread rapidly belongs to the category of "epidemic" in TCM. The records of epidemic diseases in TCM can be traced back to Yellow Emperor's Internal Classic more than 2250 years, and there are more than 320 large-scale plagues in China . TCM has accumulated a lot of experience in the prevention and treatment of epidemic diseases, and has created many prescriptions for prevention and treatment of epidemic diseases. In this process, many classic TCM books have also been produced, such as Treatise on Febrile and Miscellaneous Disease, On Plague Theory, Detailed Analysis of Epidemic Warm Disease, and so on. In 2004, a clinical study including 524 patients with severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) showed that the duration of major symptoms in the group of patients treated by integrated Chinese and western medicines was signifcantly shorter than those in the group treated by western medicine alone (Luo et al., 2020) . During the process of fighting against COVID-19, the national and provincial health commissions had issued diagnosis and treatment plans, and provided Chinese medicine treatment prescriptions. Due to many TCMs with different functions were used in the treatment of COVID-19, it is very necessary to research the application law of TCM. According to the research and diagnosis by academician Xiao-lin Tong, the COVID-19 is a cold-damp epidemic, which is caused by the epidemic of cold-dampness . Therefore, it is very importance to research the law of application of TCMs from the aspect of damp-removing Chinese medicine.

The dampness-removing TCMs refer to a class of herbs that can remove dampness. According to TCM theory, dampness, water and phlegm are homogeneous and heterogeneous, with dampness as the basis, dampness floods as water and gathers dampness into phlegm. Therefore, TCMs for removing dampness do not only refer to the damp-resolving medicines in the TCM efficacy classification, but all herbs that can facilitate water and phlegm can be classified as Chinese medicine for removing dampness. According to the pathogenesis of COVID-19, the basic pathogenesis can be summarized as follows: external invasion of epidemic virus, evil in the lung meridian, and deficiency of positive energy. The pathological nature involves dampness, heat, toxicity, deficiency, and stasis . Clinical findings showed that the tongue of patients with COVID-19 mostly shows signs of greasy moss, suggesting that the evil of the disease is closely related to dampness. If the moss is white and greasy, it is cold-damp; if the moss is yellow and greasy, it is damp-heat; if the moss is greasy and dry, it is damp-heat and dryness . It indicates that dampness is the primary factor in COVID-19, and resolving dampness is the primary task in the treatment of COVID-19. Therefore, the application of TCMs for removing dampness is a natural choice for prescription medication. In this paper, we collected 137 prescriptions of formula for the treatment of COVID-19 from January 20 th , 2020 to March 23 th , 2020, and applied frequency analysis and other methods to analyze and study the frequency of the classification of TCMs for removing dampness, the characteristics of the pharmacological properties of TCMs for removing dampness, the characteristics of the combination application of TCMs for removing dampness, and other medication patterns, in order to provide a useful reference for the precise use of clinical treatment of COVID-19 and the development of innovative drugs. This study was conducted to provide useful reference for the precise use of drugs and the development of innovative drugs in the clinical treatment of COVID-19. Program 2 treatment programs publicly released by medical institutions in Wuhan, Hubei Province.

The information of prescriptions for treatment in each program was included, among which preventive prescriptions and proprietary Chinese medicines were not included, and the same prescriptions were combined. A total of 137 effective prescriptions are included, such as clearing lung and detoxifying soup, dispelling dampness, and declaring lung and detoxifying formula, involving 178 kinds of herbs, among which 58 kinds of herbs have the effect of treating dampness. A database was established, including the name of the prescription, the name of the drug, the classification of therapeutic effect, the nature and taste of the medicine, the efficacy and main treatment, the treatment methods and rules, and the By using software such as EXCEL and Graphpad 8.0, statistical analysis was performed on the frequency of use of various types of TCMs, the frequency of classification of removing-dampness TCMs, and the medicinal property characteristics of removing-dampness TCMs.

In the traditional Chinese medicine prescriptions for the treatment of COVID-19, according to the classification of the efficacy of modern TCM, 17 categories of TCM were used, including heat-clearing, supplementing, phlegm-dissolving, cough and panting-relieving, among which six categories of heat-clearing medicines, supplementing medicines, phlegm-dissolving, cough and panting-relieving medicines, exterior-releasing medicines, damp-resolving medicines, and damp-draining diuretic medicines were mainly used, among these six categories, phlegm-dissolving, cough and panting-relieving medicines, damp-resolving medicines and damp-draining diuretic medicines accounted for 35.78% of the total frequency of use, while among the heat-clearing medicines, supplementing medicines and exterior-releasing medicines, a considerable number of herbs also had damp-relieving effects, the Chinese medicine for removing dampness used accounted for 52.27% of the total frequency of use, it can be seen that the use of TCMs for removing dampness is the primary choice of TCM formulas (Table 1) . 

In each prescription, a total of 61 TCMs for removing dampness were used, and the top 20 drugs are shown in Table 2 .

Among them, Ephedrae Herba induces sweating to release the exterior, diffuse the lung and relieve panting, promote urination and relieve swelling; Citri Reticulatae Pericarpium rectifies qi and fortify the spleen, dries dampness and dissolves phlegm; Pogostemonis Herba has the functions of resolving dampness, clearing summer-heat, and arresting vomitng; Pinelliae Rhizoma dries dampness and dissolves phlegm, directs counterflow downward and arrests vomiting, disperses spleen and dissipates masses; Poria promotes diuresis to drain dampness, invigorates the spleen, and sedates the mind; Scutellariae Radix clears heat and dries damp, reduces fire to remove toxin, stops bleeding, clams the fetus;

Atractylodis Rhizoma dries dampness, dispells wind-damp, releases exterior; Tsaoko Fructus dries dampness and dissipate cold, dispels phlegm and prevents attack of malaria; Descurainiae Semen Lepidii Semen drains the lung and relieves panting, moves water and diminishes swelling; Coicis Semen promotes urination and drains dampness, invigorates spleen to relieve diarrhea, clears heat and expels pus, eliminates impediment, which were mainly used to remove dampness. 

According to the mechanism of removing dampness by TCMs for removing dampness, TCMs for removing dampness were classified and analyzed, and the results showed that the treatment of COVID-19 mainly involved the categories of damp-draining diuretic medicines, damp-resolving medicines, dry-dampness medicines, phlegm-dissloving medicines, and exterior-releasing overcome damp medicines. According to the effect of dampness medicine, a step-by-step analysis was carried out, and the damp-draining diuretic medicines include edema-alleviating diuretic medicines, heat-clearing and damp-excreting medicines, exterior-releasing promote urination medicines, supplement qi promote urination medicines, digestion-promoting and promote urination medicines, purgative and damp-excreting medicines, stranguria-relieving diuretic medicines, damp-excreting anti-icteric medicines, phlegm-dissloving promote urination medicines, and blood-cooling and promote urination medicines; damp-resolving medicines include aromatic damp-resolving medicines, invigorating spleen damp-resolving medicines, and heat-clearing and damp-resolving medicines; dry-dampness medicines include dry-dampness dissipate phlegm medicines, dry-dampness invigorating spleen medicines, and heat-clearing and dry-dampness medicines. These were the main types of dampness management drugs used: edema-alleviating diuretic medicines, exterior-releasing promote urination medicines, heat-clearing and damp-excreting medicines, aromatic damp-resolving medicines, heat-clearing and dry-dampness medicines, dry-dampness invigorating spleen medicines, and dry-dampness dissipate phlegm medicines (Table 3) . 

The five flavors involved in the treatment of COVID-19 used in the management of TCMs for removing dampness are bitter, pungent, sweet, light and salty, without sour and astringent tastes; among them, bitter and pungent medicines are predominate; among the four qi, warm, cold and neutral are all present, but warm-heat medicines are predominate, accounting for 56%; the meridians involve the lung, large intestine, spleen, stomach, heart, small intestine, bladder, kidney, liver and gallbladder, with the meridians of the lung, spleen, stomach, large intestine and bladder predominating (Figs. 1−2) . Warm Diseases records that warm disease is an epidemic of hostile gas, mostly seen as filth, and it is like this in every family, as if it is a servant. The Treatise on Timeless Diseases records that warm is also warm heat, plague is also plague, its sound is the same but its disease is different. The diagnosis and treatment protocol of COVID-19 of the National Health

Care Commission clearly indicates that COVID-19 belongs to the category of epidemic in Chinese medicine, and the cause of the disease is the feeling of epidemic and hostile qi. The theoretical understanding of COVID-19 has not been fully unified in the academic community of Chinese medicine. For example, Yong-yan Wang et al (Fan, et al., 2020) considered it to be cold epidemic, Xiao-lin Tong (2020) and Bo-shou Xue (2020) considered it to be cold-damp epidemic, Bo-li Zhang , Qing-quan Liu (He et al., 2020) and Zhong-de Zhang considered it to be damp poison epidemic, Zhong-ying Zhou (Ye et al., 2020) considered it to be plague poison upstream, Ji-bai Xiong considered it to be warm-heat turbid poison, and so on. Although there are different opinions on the etiology and pathogenesis of this epidemic, there is a consensus on the importance of dampness as a cause and its pathogenic characteristics. Therefore, digging and analyzing the application pattern of dampness medicine can provide important reference for further prevention and treatment.

According to the results of the data analysis in this paper, the salient features of the medication used in TCM for the treatment of COVID-19 can be summarized. Firstly, large proportion of dampness-regulating herbs were used. In the TCM prescriptions for the treatment of COVID-19, six major classes of drugs, including heat-clearing medicines, supplementing medicines, phlegm-dissolving, cough and panting-relieving medicines, exterior-releasing medicines, damp-resolving medicines, and damp-draining diuretic medicines were the main drugs used; among these six major categories, phlegm-dissolving, cough and panting-relieving medicines, damp-resolving medicines, and damp-draining diuretic medicines together accounted for 35.78% of the total frequency of use, while among the heat-clearing medicines, supplementing medicines and exterior-releasing medicines, there were also a considerable number of TCMs that also had damp-removing effects; the frequency of TCMs for removing dampness used accounted for 52.27% of the total frequency of use. The use of Chinese medicine for removing dampness is the primary choice of TCM formulations. The pathological nature of COVID-19 involves dampness, heat, toxicity, deficiency, and stasis, but dampness is in the first place, and the large proportion of Chinese medicine for removing dampness used also confirms the objective judgment that the core pathological mechanism of this epidemic is focused on dampness.

Secondly, High frequency application of aromatic dampness, pungent warmth to win dampness and bitter warmth to dry dampness type of dampness management herbs. The epidemic is caused by the invasion of cold and dampness with hostile qi into the population, either by attacking the surface of the body, resulting in fever, cold, headache, body pain and other superficial symptoms; or by entering through the mouth and nose, attacking the lungs, resulting in cough, asthma, chest tightness and other respiratory symptoms; or when cold and dampness directly hit the spleen and stomach, resulting in the failure of transportation and transformation, resulting in vomiting, nausea, diarrhea and other gastrointestinal symptoms . Cold dampness as a problem, the main warm medicine is in order to warm the water dampness; such as the Inner Classic records, dampness in the internal, the treatment should be bitter heat, with acid and light, with bitter dry; damp-resolving medicinal, among which Pogostemonis Herba also has pharmacological effects in terms of anti-pathogenic microorganisms, anti-inflammatory, antipyretic, phlegmolytic and immune system regulation (Xu et al., 2020) .

Thirdly, a variety of different and effective dampness management herbs are used in combination with each other. The results of the analysis showed that the proportion of damp-draining diuretic medicines used was high, amounting to 39.52%;

the damp-draining diuretic medicines with different concurrent effects were involved, including 10 different subclasses of damp-draining diuretic medicines such as edema-alleviating diuretic medicines, heat-clearing and damp-excreting medicines, exterior-releasing promote urination medicines, supplement qi promote urination medicines, digestion-promoting and promote urination medicines, purgative and damp-excreting medicines and so on, this is a specific application of academic idea of Zhong-jing Zhang for treating dampness without facilitating urination is not it's cure, which is one of the rules of treating dampness established in The Essentials of Jin Kui, in this treatment of COVID-19, which can help improve the effect of treating epidemic by facilitating the flow of water so that dampness can have a way to go.

Fourthly, the clearing of heat and drying dampness or cold, sweet and light dampness-liberating class of dampness-regulating herbs are frequently used. Dampness is a yin evil, the cause of the disease is insidious, with other evil qi mixed and become poisonous, rapid transmission, can enter the internal heat. If dampness enters the lung from the surface, dampness suppresses the lung guard and is seen as low fever, dry cough, tiredness and weakness, and soreness and heaviness of the limbs; if dampness and heat are combined, dampness suppresses the heat, so the body is hot and does not rise, the mouth is dry and not thirsty, the tongue is red and the coating is yellow and greasy; if dampness and heat are concentrated in Shao Yang, it is seen as cold and heat rising and falling, vomiting, bitterness in the mouth, distress in the heart, and fullness in the chest (Ye et al., 2020) . The results of the pharmacological analysis showed that cold and cool herbs also accounted for a certain number of comparative cases in the dampness management herbs used, amounting to 34%;

clearing heat and drying dampness or cold, sweet and light dampness class dampness management herbs were frequently used. Such as Coptidis Rhizoma, Scutellariae Radix and other heat-clearing and dry-dampness medicines, and cold or sweet and light water-liquid-permeating type of dampness-regulating drugs such as Mori Cortex, Descurainiae Semen Lepidii Semen, Coicis Semen, Phragmitis Rhizoma, Lophatheri Herba have a high frequency of use. This also suggests that in addition to the consideration of both efficacy, the anti-sexual combination is one of the key issues to be considered when using rheumatic drugs for the treatment of COVID-19. were used more frequently, accounting for 19.64% of the frequency of use of all dampness tonics. In the causative factors of COVID-19, dampness is closely related to the spleen's function of transporting water and dampness in TCMs. The spleen prefers dryness rather than dampness, so external dampness will inevitably lead to internal dampness, causing the spleen to malfunction in transporting water and dampness, and most patients have digestive symptoms such as poor appetite and diarrhea. The application of herbs for strengthening the spleen and tonifying qi to regulate dampness is through the direct effect of dispelling dampness, or dry or beneficial to remove dampness from the body, on the other hand, through the effect of strengthening the spleen, so that the spleen and stomach can increase the function of transporting water and dampness, the source of internal dampness is reduced, and the existing dampness can be easily dispelled.

At present, the international epidemic is still spreading, the risk of importing foreign cases and domestic outbreaks again is high, and the epidemic prevention situation is still very serious. The use of TCMs for the treatment of COVID-19 should focus on the application of TCMs for the management of dampness, which is essential for the prevention and treatment of COVID-19, in particular, aromatic dampness, pungent-warm and bitter-warm dampness herbs, dampness herbs with different effects, dampness herbs with clearing heat and drying dampness or cold, sweet and light dampness herbs, dampness herbs with spleen strengthening and qi tonifying effects, and other dampness herbs are used in different stages, and scientific formulas are made by combining the antagonistic combination, five flavors and meridians of dampness herbs.

The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.

What role does Chinese medicine play in the prevention and treatment of neocrown pneumonia? The State New Office conference in Wuhan delivered these information cloth

The combination of peace and war to promote the development of Chinese medicine

TCM diagnosis, treatment and research of Coronavirus Disease

Treatment efficacy analysis of traditional Chinese medicine for novel coronavirus pneumonia (COVID-19): an empirical study from Wuhan

Strategies for the prevention and treatment of novel coronavirus pneumonia (COVID-19) in Chinese medicine from the perspective of "cold-damp epidemic

Manual of Chinese medicine treatment for novel coronavirus pneumonia

Wet Epidemic and Tongue -Chinese Medicine Treatment of New Coronary Pneumonia

Experimental treatment of novel coronavirus pneumonia from the theory of cold and epidemic

Analysis of Chinese medicine theory on the rapid and effective treatment of novel coronavirus pneumonia with "lung clearing and detoxification soup

Reflections on the role of combined traditional Chinese and Western medicine in the treatment of novel coronavirus pneumonia

Exploration of medical cases of novel coronavirus pneumonia from the theory of wet toxicity and epidemic

Chinese medical understanding and reflection on novel coronavirus pneumonia

Interpretation of the Chinese medicine treatment plan for novel coronavirus pneumonia by professor Zhou Zhongying

Strategies for the identification and treatment of novel coronavirus pneumonia by Xiong Jibai, a master of national medicine

Progress of research on the pharmacological effects and mechanisms of patchouli

Authors thank for the support of the science foundation projects: a. Sino-Singapore Cooperation for Evaluating the