key: cord-0770154-9nt6sa8t authors: Akaba, Godwin; Dirisu, Osasuyi; Okunade, Kehinde; Adams, Eseoghene; Ohioghame, Jane; Obikeze, Obioma; Izuka, Emmanuel; Sulieman, Maryam; Edeh, Michael title: Impact of COVID-19 on utilization of maternal, newborn and child health services in Nigeria: protocol for a country-level mixed-methods study date: 2021-08-18 journal: F1000Res DOI: 10.12688/f1000research.26283.2 sha: d000326a0dac372bebdc7b8b29816153a5d0846b doc_id: 770154 cord_uid: 9nt6sa8t Background: Battling with COVID-19 and providing essential services along the continuum of care could be challenging. This study will evaluate the impact of COVID-19 on utilization of maternal, newborn and child health (MNCH) services in Nigeria and explore the barriers being experienced by women and their families in getting access to MNCH services, as well as other contextual factors that may have shaped the utilization of MNCH services during the COVID-19 pandemic. Methods and analysis: The study will adopt an observational mixed-methods study design involving 18 health care facilities delivering MNCH services in six selected states across six geopolitical zones of Nigeria. We will retrieve longitudinal data on MNCH services from all selected hospitals six months before and after the first recorded case of COVID-19 in Nigeria. Qualitative data will be collected using in-depth interviews conducted via mobile phones or ZOOM meeting platforms among stakeholder participants (users of MNCH services, health workers and policymakers) to ascertain their perceptions on how COVID-19 has shaped the utilization of MNCH services. We will triangulate quantitative and qualitative data to better understand the impact of COVID-19 on the utilization of MNCH services in Nigeria. Ethics and dissemination: Ethics approvals have been obtained from the Health Research Ethics Committee of the tertiary hospitals involved in the study. Our findings will provide the first evidence from an African setting on the impact of COVID-19 on the utilization of MNCH services using a mixed-methods study design for policy formulation towards sustained MNCH service delivery. The Sustainable Development Goals agenda is part of the global efforts to improve maternal, new-born and child health (MNCH) by challenging countries to make efforts to reduce the global burden of maternal, new-born and child mortality 1 . However, despite these efforts, global maternal mortality remains unacceptably high with about 303,000 women dying each year from pregnancy-related complications 2 , for which sub-Saharan Africa and Southern Asia accounts for about 86% of such deaths 1 . According to the World Health Organization (WHO) report, an estimated 5.3 million under-5 deaths and 2.5 million neonatal deaths were reported in 2020, which are equivalent to an under-5 mortality rate of 39 per 1,000 live births and neonatal mortality rate of 18 per 1,000 live births, while the maternal mortality rate is 211 per 100,000 live births 3 . In Nigeria, MNCH outcomes have improved over the last decade. However, these outcomes are still rated as being among the worst in the world 4 . The under-5 mortality rate is 132 deaths per 1,000 live births while the infant mortality rate is 67 deaths per 1,000 live births 4 . On the other hand, the maternal mortality ratio in Nigeria is 512 per 100,000 live births and some of the main causes of maternal deaths include obstetric haemorrhage, infection, obstructed labour, unsafe abortion, preeclampsia/ eclampsia, malaria, anaemia, and contributory factors such as lack of awareness about complications in pregnancy, inability to seek timely medical intervention, lack of utilization of health care services, lack of transportation and inability to pay for services 4,5 . With these indices, Nigeria is the second largest contributor to maternal mortality worldwide accounting for more than 10% of all cases 2, 5 . In order to improve child survival and maternal health, the continuum of care for MNCH was designed and this has gained so much attention because it is expected to reduce the burden of maternal deaths, neonatal deaths and deaths among under-5 children particularly in lower and middle-income countries 6, 7 . The continuum of care includes healthcare services for mothers and children from pre-pregnancy to delivery, postnatal and childhood 6, 8 . Furthermore, this depicts the link between maternal and child health, particularly as they seem to be affected by the same variables. Therefore, this makes it important that at every specific point in the continuum of care, every mother/child pair should receive the full package to attain maximum satisfaction 6 . Towards a positive impact on overall MNCH indicators, every woman is expected to continuously receive antenatal care (ANC), skilled birth attendance at delivery and postnatal care (PNC). The WHO recommends that every pregnant woman is expected to have a minimum of eight ANC contacts before delivery 9 . This is because ANC helps to identify pregnancy risks, provide appropriate care for women who might be at risk of potentially fatal conditions, provide opportunities for counselling these women and give access to health-promoting services (weight measurement, blood pressure measurement etc), and it also helps to increase subsequent use of maternal and child health services 7, 10 . Even though the majority of maternal and neonatal deaths occur in the postpartum period, in Nigeria, only about 42% of mothers utilize PNC services within the first two days after delivery. Similar trends are seen in the utilization of ANC, the number of deliveries attended by skilled birth attendants and uptake of immunization and family planning services. According to the Nigerian Demographic and Health Survey 2018, only 57% of women had at least four ANC visits, deliveries by skilled birth attendants were 43%, immunization coverage for age-appropriate vaccinations was 21%, and modern contraceptive prevalence rate among currently married women was 12% 4 . Low utilization of MNCH services can be categorized into two major factors, which are the user factor and the health system factor. The user factor includes distance to a health facility, cultural beliefs and practices, economic factors and many other factors within the community and respective households. On the other hand, the health system factor includes the capacity of health staff, attitude of care providers, infrastructure and other forms of interactions that take place within the healthcare system 1 . With the recent COVID-19 pandemic, the resilience of health systems' and countries' emergency preparedness and response have been tested. According to the WHO, over 200 countries, areas and territories have been affected and as such health systems have been critically affected 11 . As of May 17, 2020, there have been 4,534,731 cases of COVID-19 and over 307,537 deaths globally. In Africa, about 58,663 cases and 1,710 deaths have been recorded. On the other hand, in Nigeria, 5,621 cases and 176 deaths have been recorded 12 . COVID-19 pandemic and its devastating impact on the health systems, livelihood and economies of Nations have been likened to a "war" situation. Health care for women and children are usually disproportionally and negatively impacted at times of war and conflicts. Battling with COVID-19 and providing essential services along the continuum of care is critical and challenging 4 . To avert deaths, it is important to ensure that appropriate care is available to every woman and every child during the pandemic. We, therefore, hypothesized that COVID-19 pandemic in Nigeria may have further worsened the already poor maternal and child health services utilization in Nigeria. Thus, this study is designed to evaluate the impact of COVID-19 on the utilization of MNCH services in Nigeria using a mixed-method approach. The quantitative part of the study will involve the collection of longitudinal data on maternal and newborn health services, while the qualitative component will explore the barriers being experienced by women and their families in getting access to MNCH services as well as other contextual factors that may We have now increased the proposed time frame of the study from 3 months before and after the first case of COVID-19 in Nigeria to 6 months before and after as recommended by the reviewer. We also added the definition of service users to include those who have not visited the hospital during the pandemic but had utilized services in the facility prior to the pandemic. Any further responses from the reviewers can be found at the end of the article REVISED have shaped the utilization of MNCH services during the COVID-19 pandemic. It would also explore the level of preparedness of the Nigeria health system in responding to such pandemics and examine the available policies and action plans that are currently in place. Findings from this study will be beneficial in providing key stakeholders at all levels of the health care system with the necessary information that will provide new direction and policy for the country towards mitigating the negative impact of COVID-19 on the already fragile health system, and thus help in sustaining previous efforts towards attaining the third sustainable development goal of "achieving good health and well-being for all" in Nigeria. The study aims to assess the rate of utilization of maternal and newborn child health (MNCH) services before and during the COVID 19 pandemic as well as to critically examine the various barriers and facilitators associated with accessing MNCH services during the COVID-19 pandemic in Nigeria. Specific objectives are to: 1. Ascertain the trend in the utilization of MNCH services before and during COVID-19 pandemic. 2. Determine the barriers and facilitating factors associated with access to MNCH services during the COVID-19 pandemic. 3. Identify gaps in the MNCH continuum of care and the most affected level of care during the COVID-19 pandemic. 4. Explore contextual factors that may have shaped the utilization of MNCH services during the COVID-19 pandemic This study will be conducted in six states across the six geopolitical zones of the country. The states were purposively selected during the proposal development and categorized according to the number of reported COVID-19 cases as "highburden states (high number of cases) and low-burden states (low number of cases)". For this study, any state with at least 56 confirmed cases of COVID-19 as at May 17, 2020 (equivalent to approximately 1% of total cases of COVID-19 at that time) will be regarded as a high-burden state, while those with less than 56 confirmed cases will be classified as low-burden states. The high-burden states include Lagos in the South-west (n=2,373), Kano in the North-west (n=825) and Abuja FCT in the North-central (n=397), while the low-burden states are Enugu in the South-east (n=11), Taraba in the North-east (n=17) and Bayelsa in the South-south (n=6). The participating states and health facilities are shown in Table 1 . The study will use a mixed-methods design to evaluate the impact of the novel COVID-19 pandemic on the utilization of MNCH across six selected states of Nigeria. The quantitative part of the study will involve the collection of longitudinal data from hospitals in the participating States on maternal and newborn health services (antenatal clinic attendance, hospital deliveries, postnatal clinic attendance, family planning services and immunization uptakes) six months before (September 1, 2019, to February 28, 2020) and after (March 1 to August 31, 2020) the first recorded case of COVID-19 in Nigeria. The data from the three high-burden states (Abuja FCT, Lagos, Kano) will be compared with that of the three low-burden states (Enugu, Taraba and Bayelsa). The qualitative arm will assess the perceptions of users of healthcare facilities, health workers, and policymakers on how COVID-19 has shaped the utilization of MNCH services in their locality as well as other contextual factors contributing to the projected views. Participants for the qualitative survey will be identified, screened for eligibility, and selected by purposive sampling method by the study coordinator in each of the selected states. The participants will include policymakers, service providers and service users from each of the participating states. Research collaborators in the six states who are all healthcare practitioners working in the tertiary health facilities will support the recruitment of policymakers and service providers in the states. The service providers will help in the recruitment of the service users who presented for MNCH services during the study period. Inclusion and exclusion criteria for stakeholder enrolment are the same across all participating states. Eligible participants are those aged at least 18 years with adequate physical, mental, and cognitive capacity who give informed consent to participate in the study. • Policymaker -a healthcare professional who has been working within the health system for at least one year and is involved in defining policy on MNCH services. • Service provider -a healthcare professional who has been working within the health system for at least one year and involved in the direct provision of MNCH services in any of the study facility before and during the current COVID-19 pandemic. • Service user -someone who has accessed MNCH services before or during the COVID-19 pandemic. Qualitative data will be collected by in-depth interviews (IDIs) from the three stakeholder groups comprising of one policymaker, health care worker and service user related to MNCH services from each of the three levels of the healthcare system in the six selected states. The interviews will be conducted using mobile phones or ZOOM application platforms depending on the choice of the respondents due to the social distancing regulations in Nigeria. Nationally, a total of fifty-four (54) IDIs will be conducted (comprising of 18 IDIs for each of the stakeholder groups). Before the IDIs, the interviewers will be required to check if the participants meet the inclusion criteria. Stakeholders who failed to meet the inclusion criteria or those who declined consent will be excluded from participating in the study. The list of stakeholders to be interviewed and their distribution across the six participating states is as shown in Table 2 . Theoretical frameworks Several theoretical frameworks have been developed that may have relevance to exploring and understanding barriers to the utilization of health care services. We will use a hybrid of the social-ecological model (SEM) and the three delays model to investigate and explore how COVID-19 has impacted on utilization of MNCH services in Nigeria. The SEM provides a theory-based approach to understanding the complex interaction between individual, interpersonal, community, institutional and policy factors that influence behaviour and practice 13 . The delay model recognizes three phases (delay in deciding to seek care, delay in reaching healthcare facility and delay in receiving adequate care at the health facility) as contributing to women's ability to receive care towards averting poor outcomes. These delays are shaped by several complex factors operating at the same or different levels of delays [14] [15] [16] . Figure 1 shows the theoretical frameworks to be used for this study. Quantitative data: Data for the three months preceding the first confirmed case of COVID-19 in Nigeria (December 1, 2019, to February 28, 2020) and the three months after (March 1 to May 31, 2020) will be collected from one facility each at the three different levels of the Nigerian healthcare system (primary, secondary and tertiary facilities) in each of the six selected states. The facilities are also to be spread across three different Local Government Areas in each of the participating states. Monthly data to be collected includes: total antenatal care (ANC) attendance, total facility deliveries, total postnatal clinic (PNC) attendance, total family planning services rendered, and the total number of babies who received immunization. These data will be used to evaluate the trends in the utilization of MNCH services in these states. Qualitative data: The state study coordinators will schedule and confirm the dates and time of the planned IDIs with the study participants after obtaining informed written consent. The participants will also be informed that the interview will be recorded during the informed consent process. Interviews will then be facilitated by a trained interviewer over the phone or via ZOOM. The interviewers have expertise in the conduct of IDIs and will be working with members of the core research team to schedule interviews with the respondents while determining the best time for the interview to take place. The study participants will be informed about the purpose of the study and are invited to participate in the interview, which will last for approximately 20 to 30 minutes. The interviews will be conducted using an IDI guide designed specifically for each of the stakeholder groups. After the interview, the audio recordings would be transcribed verbatim. The transcripts will be compared with the audio recordings to ensure completeness Table 2 . Stakeholders to be interviewed. 3 3 3 3 3 3 18 Health care worker 3 3 3 3 3 3 18 MNCH service user 3 3 3 3 3 3 18 Total 9 9 9 9 9 9 54 and are then analysed and utilized to develop the study report. Table 3 shows examples of some of the question that will be asked for each of the stakeholder groups. Quantitative data: This data will be entered into a computer and analysed using SPSS version 20.0 for Windows (Armonk, NY: IBM Corp.) to show the trends of the utilization of MNCH services over the six months review period. The differences in MNCH services utilization between the study period (before and during the COVID era) and COVID-19 infection burden (high-and low-burden states) within and across the different levels of the healthcare system will be tested using the independent sample t-test. The level of significance will be reported at P<0.05. Qualitative data: Audio recorded interviews will be transcribed verbatim and transcripts will be anonymized with pseudonyms. Data analysis will begin with the reading of transcripts repeatedly to achieve immersion and derive codes by identifying words in the text that capture key concepts. Initial codes will be discussed by the study team and sorted into categories based on linkages between key concepts. The themes that represent key issues with MNCH services will be developed for initial coding and inductive analysis. The data will then be entered into NVivo software version 12 for organization and analysis. Each transcript will be coded by two members of the research team independently to reduce inter-coder variability. Data protection: On completion of this study, transcripts will be stored in password-protected computers/laptops and only the core research team will have access to the data. All members of the team will sign a confidentiality agreement. All study participants will be assigned an identification code, which will be delinked from their identity at the data entry point. Audio recordings will be destroyed at the end of the project. Transcripts will be stored for a minimum of 5 years after the project ends and will only be destroyed afterwards if necessary. Ethics approvals have been obtained from the Health Research Ethics Committee of the participating tertiary hospitals involved in the study: University of Abuja Teaching Hospital (UATH/HREC/PR/2020/001), Lagos University Teaching How can these challenges/barriers be mitigated? What is the available standard protocol for attending to women who access MNCH services in the ongoing pandemic? What are the challenges/barriers you experienced accessing MNCH services during this period? Do you think this facility is well equipped to provide MNCH services during this pandemic? (Give reasons) Were there referrals this period? Kindly explain some of the coping/adaptive mechanisms that has helped you while providing services. What are the challenges/barriers this facility has experienced in providing MNCH services during this period? (How can they . Social approval and permission will be sought from the primary and secondary facilities selected for the study. The ethical review undertaken by all project investigators will ensure standard processes (dignity, autonomy, informed consent, confidentiality, anonymity, ability to adhere to protocol) and data security are maintained. Voluntary and informed participation, confidentiality and safety of participants will constitute key principles of researcher-respondent interaction. Written consent will be obtained from service users, service providers and policymakers prior to their enrolment in the study. The study will be conducted according to the Helsinki declarations on ethical principles for medical research involving human subjects. The development of the research question was based on experiences of patients narrated in the media, as well as during medical consultations at the obstetric emergency services of the University of Abuja Teaching Hospital, Abuja. Their inputs were sought in designing the qualitative component of the study proposal. Findings from this study will be disseminated by delivering presentations at national and international conferences, organization of study dissemination meetings involving relevant stakeholders in Nigeria and publishing articles in peer-reviewed journals. Additionally, all participating institutions and patients will be notified of the key findings from the study. Data resulting from this study will be deposited in a data repository (Mendeley Data) and can be assessed by the public. The study is currently collecting both longitudinal data and qualitative data. This paper reports a protocol for an observational mixedmethods study design aimed at collecting quantitative data showing the trend of utilization of MNCH services during the three months preceding and during the COVID-19 pandemic, and qualitative data from key stakeholders across the health systems in the six geopolitical zones in Nigeria to determine the barriers and facilitators associated with access to MNCH services during the COVID-19 pandemic. Additionally, the study will explore other contextual issues that have shaped service delivery along the MNCH continuum of care during the COVID-19 pandemic. The study findings will provide a timely contribution to the ongoing debate on the magnitude of impact on access and utilization of MNCH services across the different levels of the Nigeria health system following the COVID-19 outbreak and also help in identifying strategies that will assist Nigeria and other African countries in maintaining focus towards the realization of the third sustainable development goal of "ensuring good health and well-being for all" amidst the COVID-19 pandemic. The identification of the state of MNCH continuum of care and the most affected components of care during the COVID-19 pandemic in Nigeria could lead to multiple benefits for service users, service providers, policymakers and other relevant stakeholders towards effective planning for the strengthening of national health systems during the COVID-19 pandemic. No data are associated with this article. Under Data management (Qualitative); Do you intend to code before entering the transcript into NVivo or import the transcript and code in NVivo? Under Data Management (Quantitative); Use of t-test for proportions? Consider Chi-square test for proportion. Under Data Protection; Audiotapes destroyed immediately after the project could be risky. Keeping in a safe place for 6 months before destruction may be safer. Thank you. Is the rationale for, and objectives of, the study clearly described? Yes Are the datasets clearly presented in a useable and accessible format? Not applicable The benefits of publishing with F1000Research: Your article is published within days, with no editorial bias • You can publish traditional articles, null/negative results, case reports, data notes and more • The peer review process is transparent and collaborative • Your article is indexed in PubMed after passing peer review • Dedicated customer support at every stage • For pre-submission enquiries, contact research@f1000.com Persistent barriers to the use of maternal, newborn and child health services in Garissa sub-county, Kenya: a qualitative study PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text | Free Full Text 3. WHO: World health statistics 2020: monitoring health for the SDGs, sustainable development goals Reference Source 4. National Population Commission (NPC) [Nigeria], ICF: Nigeria Demographic and Health Survey Improving maternal and child health policymaking processes in Nigeria: an assessment of policymakers' needs, barriers and facilitators of evidence-informed policymaking Patterns and determinants of dropout from maternity care continuum in Nigeria Barriers for pregnant women living in rural, agricultural villages to accessing antenatal care in Cambodia: A community-based cross-sectional study combined with a geographic information system World Health Organization: WHO recommendations on antenatal care for a positive pregnancy experience Northern Nigeria Maternal, Newborn and Child Health Programme: Selected analyses from population-based baseline survey Violence against women: An integrated, ecological framework Too far to walk: maternal mortality in context Piecing together the maternal death puzzle through narratives: the three delays model revisited Factors associated with maternal mortality in Malawi: application of the three delays model The authors wish to acknowledge the management staff of the participating hospitals for approving the conduct of the study in their institutions, and also the patients who made inputs in the design of the qualitative study. addressing users of services, health care providers and policymakers. The proposed timeframe of 3 months before and e months after the first covid case seems short and probably does not allow the current status following the initial 'covid-19 shock'. The voices missing are the women that do not attend the MCH services anymore; they should be included in FGDs.○ Is the rationale for, and objectives of, the study clearly described? Yes Are the datasets clearly presented in a useable and accessible format? Yes Thank you for your comments. I wish to respond that our study received ethical approvals in the first and second weeks of June 2020 at which time Nigeria was only about 3 months into the COVID -19 pandemic and we commenced data collection on 22nd June 2020 to 30th September 2020. The objective of our study was to investigate the effect of lockdown due to the COVID-19 pandemic on the utilization of MNCH services in Nigeria. This protocol was first submitted to this Journal (F1000 Research) on 20th August 2020 at which time the authors had declared that we were already collecting both longitudinal and qualitative data which describes fully the situation of COVID-19 in Nigeria at that time during which Nigeria was still in lockdown. We believe that if this research protocol was reviewed at that time the comment may not have been made since the data were collected within 4-6 months of the COVID-19 pandemic in Nigeria. Thank you for the invitation to review this article at its proposal stage. This article seeks to evaluate the impact on utilization of maternal, newborn and child health (MNCH) services in Nigeria by the COVID-19 pandemic as battling with COVID-19 and providing essential health care services can be a real challenge. The study will adopt a mixed-methods study design involving 18 health care facilities delivering MNCH services at the 3 levels of care in six selected states across the six geopolitical zones of Nigeria over a six month period (pre and post first recorded case of COVID-19 in Nigeria). The findings from this study will aid policy formulation towards sustained MNCH services during the COVID-19 pandemic and beyond. An interesting and well thought-out study. Three months before and during COVID-19 pandemic may not give the entire picture of MNCH services but to avoid recall bias, the duration covered is appropriate. In terms of use of the term 'rates' the duration is not up to a year, as such projections may be considered. We have few suggestions;Grammar: Many conjunctions are used erroneously. 'However' and 'on the other hand' should be used for divergent views and not for views with similar flow of information.1.Some sentences are too long Paragraph 3, lines 9 -13; also rephrase Paragraph 2; lines 3-7. Paragraph 3, line 3; low income countries not lower. 3.Use of past and future tenses need to be checked. A continuous check throughout the write up is required. This is a protocol but some events have taken place and some will take place in the future. Maternal, newborn and child health (MNCH) -What of the period of infancy? Infancy should be included because of the peculiarity of this disease that affects infants and their caregivers (usually mothers) during that period. Paragraph 3, line 13; The sentence, 'Even though the majority of maternal and neonatal deaths occur in the postpartum period in Nigeria, only about 42% of mothers....' is contentious. Is majority of maternal death really postpartum or peri-partum? Give a reference for the 42%. Rate of utilization -rate is usually with an annual denominator (time), yours is over 6 months or are you projecting? Protocol: Under Study design, specify the type of study. This is a cross sectional study using a mixedmethods approach.1.Under Study design, can the authors specify how the longitudinal data will be collected from hospitals in the participating states. Will the data be sampled or will data of all patients that access MNCH services in those states be collated? Is it in retrospect? We believe this should be addressed to make the article scientifically sound. What approach will you be using for the qualitative study? -phenomenological? 4.Under Methods of data collection (qualitative), check this sentence; 'The interview will be recorded during informed consent---' wording can be simply put as audio recording of informed consent. In-depth interview for 20 minutes is regarded as short, about 30 minutes; or 30-40 minutes is preferable. Was the IDI guide tested and if yes, where and among which stakeholders? 7.Under Patient and public involvement and dissemination; dissemination to participants and other stakeholders should come first before disseminating to national and international conferences, because the activity serves as both a dissemination and verification exercise when it is among participants of a study. Competing Interests: No competing interests were disclosed.Reviewer Expertise: Fetomaternal medicine, infertility and assisted conception, reproductive health.We confirm that we have read this submission and believe that we have an appropriate level of expertise to confirm that it is of an acceptable scientific standard.