key: cord-0759913-lec8qepj
authors: Abdelhamid, Kenzy; ElHawary, Hassan; Gorgy, Andrew; Alexander, Noah
title: Mentorship Resuscitation During the COVID‐19 Pandemic
date: 2020-09-26
journal: AEM Educ Train
DOI: 10.1002/aet2.10538
sha: f3a91e74d21f659231a1767a1d7fd81e0ac91c9b
doc_id: 759913
cord_uid: lec8qepj

In the current ever‐changing state of the COVID‐19 pandemic, it is clear that one of the casualties has been medical education across all academic levels. While clinical teaching has either been suspended or significantly modified, academic teaching is slowly recovering with the aid of online platforms. Though faculty and educators are working tirelessly to adapt curricula and ensure that students meet requirements to graduate without delay, there is still incredible uncertainty as to how medical training will coexist and evolve within the pandemic.

either been suspended or significantly modified, academic teaching is slowly recovering with the aid of online platforms. Though faculty and educators are working tirelessly to adapt curricula and ensure that students meet requirements to graduate without delay, there is still incredible uncertainty as to how medical training will coexist and evolve within the pandemic. Inevitably, medical students feel adrift; with the current disconnection and the high levels of anxiety, these times of transition can be difficult to navigate. Thus, the reassurance and guidance of mentormentee relationships has never been more critical.

He who was once the student will become the teacher -this concept is fundamental in apprenticeship and medical education. The core of medical training is not in the classroom, it is at the side of a clinical mentor. Mentorship may take place on the internal medicine wards, under the bright lights of an operating room, in the office of a family physician, or on shift with an emergentologist. In addition to this structured clinical mentorship there is formal and informal mentorship that often take credit for the "hidden" curriculum and raising physicians from laypersons. 1 To that end, this viewpoint discusses mentorship as a fluid-construct, highlighting the dual-role of the medical trainee, as both a mentee seeking guidance and as a mentor supporting their junior colleagues. The authors aim to provide tools to help life-long learners build effective mentoring relationships, whether as a mentor or apprentice during the COVID-19

pandemic.

In seeking a mentor, first the mentee must understand menteeship; like any relationship, finding the right 'match' is the key. 2 To do so, mentees must define and list their needs and the

This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved type of relationship sought. Similar to personal relationships, mentoring relationships can be categorized. The first layer to explore is the time frame: while some mentors are committed to their apprentices longitudinally, others address a one-time need. 3 and finally, The Connector, or master networker, that can use their social and political capital to empower their novices by connecting them with others that can help them as well. With their needs identified, students can target a suitable mentor, maximizing the yield of the relationship. 3 Table 1 details the role each mentor can play in helping a medical student advance to become a post-graduate resident trainee.

Once the student has chosen their ideal mentor, they must approach them appropriately and use their mentor's time wisely. 2 While a good mentee seeks the right mentor, a good mentor will also choose their protégé carefully. 9 Indeed, as a result of their high success and recognition of the commitment required for mentoring, great mentors are often busy. 3 A good mentee is one who shows commitment, is curious, motivated, organized, efficient, responsible and engaged. By managing expectations, setting actionable goals, and planning appropriate methods for communication, the mentee can efficiently utilize their mentors' valuable time. Once a first meeting is set-up, it is worthwhile to go the extra step and ask the mentor for their preferences in communication (where and how often), as well as their own expectations from the mentoring relationship. 5 With a clearly established goal, as well as consensus regarding frequency and method of communication, the signing of a mentoring agreement can reinforce the set of objectives/ expectations agreed upon. 5 For success, it's important that professional standards are set and that both mentee and mentor are disciplined in keeping with the scheduled meetings. 9 Finally, as is true of any relationship, misunderstandings and disagreements are inevitable and should be openly addressed.

Because of this seemingly intimidating process of seeking a mentor, novice medical trainees (junior students, residents, or staff) may find it easier to contact their senior colleagues for mentorship. 8 In following with the fundamental concept of apprenticeship, the senior trainee/staff becomes the teacher to their junior counterpart and naturally takes on the role of a

This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved mentor. This form of near-peer mentorship is beneficial because the mentees find it easier to relate to those who have recently "been there." 8 However, in medical education while trainees are encouraged to mentor and teach juniors, little training is received on how to be a good mentor. Alongside personal satisfaction, the benefits in becoming a mentor include, becoming recognized as an expert and leader in the field, gaining exposure to new ideas and skills, reflecting on own goals to further advance career, and developing leadership and communication skills. 6 Indeed, mentorship is a commensal relationship, where the mentor can also benefit from mentoring relationships. In valuing this form of reverse-mentoring (the reciprocity of the relationship), 7 senior trainees can be motivated to become mentors, and apprentices can appreciate their role, acknowledge their relevance in the relationship and approach their rolemodels more confidently.

Given the heterogeneity in medical trainees' interests and experiences, there may be a wide variety of advice offered by peers to each other. As such, there is a role for team mentorship. Team mentorship can compensate for the inexperience of mentors, allowing for comentors to share the responsibility of an apprentice. 9 This is also an opportunity for mentors to improve on their mentorship skills, which requires them to seek and welcome constructive criticism. 9 This is likely easier to obtain in a near-peer mentoring relationship. While the advantage to peer mentorship is that there is a small power differential, a good mentor must always be conscious of the vulnerability of their mentee, and avoid "mentorship malpractice" at all costs. 9, 10 In honoring this fluid form of mentorship, mentors should prepare their mentees for the transition to becoming a mentor. 9 The COVID-19 pandemic has resulted in unprecedented changes to medical education and the path to professional development. While entering mentoring relationships during the COVID-19 pandemic may seem more difficult because of social distancing and less opportunity for face-to-face contact, it is necessary for students to persist in finding a mentor(s). Virtual forms of connectivity should be considered. In fact, technology can collapse the time and space between mentors and mentees, allowing for relationships that are not geographically bound.

Online platforms can be utilized for not only written communication, but also the invaluable face-to-face interactions. The mentee must take initiative and seek out their mentor without pursuing the "perfect opportunity" in person, which can be indefinitely delayed during these times. It is crucial that learners and educators adapt and make the most out of the mentor-mentee

This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved relationships. Through mentorship education and utilization of novel mentoring models, the postpandemic medical community can be further connected through stronger relationships. Accepted Article

Mentoring program design and implementation in new medical schools

The four golden rules of effective menteeship

Will You Be My Mentor?-Four Archetypes to Help Mentees Succeed in Academic Medicine

Melting the Plastic Ceiling: Overcoming Obstacles to Foster Leadership in Women Plastic Surgeons

The Unwritten Rules of Mentorship: Facilitators of and Barriers to Effective Mentorship in Pediatric Hospital Medicine

Mentorship in the health professions: a review

Why Reverse Mentoring Works and How to Do It Right

A systematic review of the literature describing the outcomes of near-peer mentoring programs for first year medical students

Things Every Mentor Should Do