key: cord-0753213-wlda4x8w authors: Zeitoun, Mark; Sittah, Ghassan Abu; Shomar, Reem; el Ach, Nassim title: AMR and Covid-19 on the Frontline: A Call to Rethink War, WASH, and Public Health date: 2021-02-24 journal: Annals of global health DOI: 10.5334/aogh.3140 sha: 9a4122d5dd158b8d68a19897b29e7b50a8666f27 doc_id: 753213 cord_uid: wlda4x8w This Viewpoint calls for a greater understanding of the role that water plays in the transmission of anti-microbial resistance and covid-19 in protracted urban armed conflict, in order to develop a ‘pathogen-safe’ practice. It argues that dealing with the twin threats is difficult enough in the best of circumstances, and is so little understood in war zones that surgeons and water engineers now question if their practice does more harm than good. Experience suggests that the known transmission routes are complicated by a great number of factors, including the entry of heavy metals through bullets in patients’ wounds, hospital over-crowding, mutation in treated water or wastewater, and other threats which endure long after the bombing has stopped. The skeleton research agenda proposes greater sewage surveillance, testing of phages and monitoring of treatment designed to dispel or substantiate these assertions. If covid-19 is indeed accelerating the perils of anti-microbial resistance (AMR) in the US and UK, [1] it has surely sent them beyond warp-speed in the war zones of the Middle East. The challenges that we, water engineers and surgeons, face on the frontline were daunting enough before the dawn of covid-19. Now, we suspect that the drugs which we prescribe and the water we treat may actually be harming rather than helping. The rampant virus and the mutating bacteria must force a change to the traditional public health response of agencies that are active in humanitarian contexts. This obliges no less than a reconception of practice, and can come only after development of the knowledge and policy base. The 'antibiotics apocalypse' has already claimed hundreds of thousands especially in low and middle-income countries [2] . Responses which have been developed to deal with covid-19 can learn a lot from our stumbling in the dark with AMR from Aleppo to Tripoli, through Gaza and Aden. Here, resistant bacteria can come in on a sniper's bullet [3] , mutate via surgical instruments that are disinfected in contaminated water [4] , and be carried back to the community through the hospital's wastewater pipes [5] . We lose pan-drug resistant patients every day when the fighting is most intense, and every week between the bouts of violence, as these continue to be shaped by ongoing tensions and economic sanctions. Consider the eight-year-old girl from Aleppo who came in February 2020 with bilateral above-knee amputations and burns, and who died of infections despite the tetracycline and colistin we gave her. Or the hundreds of teenagers shot in the knees who overwhelmed hospitals in Gaza in March 2018 [6] . Many of those wounds have been re-infected three times since then, despite repeated doses of antibiotics. Covid-19 amplifies the manslaughter when the family that cannot be kept out of the wards returns to care for their injured, and even more antibiotics are dispensed to covid-19 patients [7] . We know that standard drinking water and wastewater treatment may get the virus [8] , but not the bug [9] . Of the bigger picture, we do not know a whole lot more. The World Health Organization (WHO) Global Strategy for Containment of AMR is strong on Health Care Facilities (HCF), for instance, but makes almost no mention of water sanitation and hygiene (WASH). Status updates on WASH in HCF miss out on AMR [10] , while reports on WASH and AMR omit hospitals [11] . The breadth of the interdisciplinary One Health, WASH in Health Care Facilities and similar initiatives stand out amidst this field, and have suggested numerous transmission route diagrams, as in Figure 1 [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] . Gaining a better understanding of these pathways is of crucial importance in most 'normal' contexts, even refugee camps [17] . But the known pathways are less relevant where the backdrop sees heavy metals on shrapnel rip into flesh, economic sanctions pervert access to pharmaceutical markets, and pathogens define an entire define a 'biosphere' of endless armed conflict -as in Figure 2 [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] . In the disastrous 'ecology of war' which characterizes protracted conflicts, the impact of sanctions goes well beyond the blast zone, and endures long after the dust settles [23, 24] . We have to guess if the persistent infections stem from the water used to disinfect the scalpel, or the soap used to wash our hands [25, 26] . After all, they may just as well be a result of the fact that we run out of drugs [27] , or have to prescribe drugs which are counterfeit [28, 29] , or which have been kindly donated but do not meet WHO guidelines (like the near-expiry Carbapenems dumped in Gaza in 2018) [30] . In these contexts, patients are exposed in equal measure to viruses, superbugs, cephalosporins [31] , and missiles exploding in the rooms they have come for consultation. Hospitals become petri-dishes; carers become carriers. 'Clean' water infects, soap kills. Zeitoun How covid-19 is accelerating the threat of antimicrobial resistance Attributable deaths and disability-adjusted life-years caused by infections with antibiotic-resistant bacteria in the EU and the European Economic Area population-level modelling analysis. The Lancet Infectious Diseases Heavy Metal Toxicity in Armed Conflicts Potentiates AMR in A. baumannii by Selecting for Antibiotic and Heavy Metal Co-resistance Mechanisms Water Safety for Public Health Status Joint Report. Gaza: Palestinian Water Authority Hospital Wastewater Releases of Carbapenem-Resistance Pathogens and Genes in Urban India Humanitarian Bulletin (occupied Palestinian territory) -May 2019. Ramallah: UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs The Misuse of Prescribed Drugs During the Syrian Crisis: A Crosssectional Study Drinking water very well protected against all viruses, including coronavirus. KWR News Contribution of Hopsital Wastewater to the Spread of Antibiotic Resistance in Comparsion to Non-Health Institution Water, sanitation and hygiene in health care facilities: Satus in low-and middle-income countries and way forward. ISBN 978 92 4 150847 6. Geneva: World Health Organization Briefing Note: Antimicrobial Resistance: An Emerging Water, Sanitaion and Hygiene Issue. WHO/FWC/WSH/147. Geneva: World Health Organization Global progress report on water, sanitation and hygiene in health care facilities: Fundamentals first. Geneva: World Health Organization, UNICEF Licence: CC BY-NC-SA 3.0 IGO One Health approach to tackle antimicrobial resistance in South East Asia No Time to Wait: Securing the Future from Drug-Resistant Infections (Report to the Secretary-General of the United Nations) The BMJ Christmas 2019 appeal: A health centre is not a health centre if it doesn't have clean water Medical Approach to Refugees: Importance of the Caring Physician Healthcare Service Access and Utilization among Syrian Refugees in Turkey Changing therapeutic geographies of the Iraqi and Syrian wars Gaza now has a toxic 'biosphere of war' that no one can escape. The Conversation Ecology of War, Health Research and Knowledge Subjugation: Insights from the Middle East and North Africa Region. Annals of Global Health Coronavirus 2019 and health systems affected by protracted conflict: The case of Syria The impact of explosive weapons on urban services: Direct and reverberating effects across space and time The Epidemiological Challenge to the Conduct of Just War: Confronting Indirect Civilian Casualties of War Microbiological Quality of Soaps and Efficacy of Antiseptics and Disinfectants Used in Hospitals in Gaza -Palestine. Islamic University Gaza Comparative Identification of Bacterial Quality in liquid Soap between Nasser and European Gaza Hospitals, Khanyounis Governorate Health conditions in the occupied Palestinian territory, including east Jerusalem, and in the occupied Syrian Golan: Report by the Director General. A72/33. New York: Seventy-second World Health Assembly -Provisional agenda item 14 Challenges Providing Pharmaceutical Products to Syrian Refugees. Regulatory Focus: Regulatory Affairs Professionals Society Drug Counterfeiting: The Situation in the Gaza Strip Medical donations are not always free: An assessment of compliance of medicine and medical device donations with World Health Organization guidelines Antimicrobial Resistance of Acinetobacter spp. isolated from Pus Specimens from Al-Shifa Hospital UNRWA) Presence of SARS-Coronavirus-2 RNA in Sewage and Correlation with Reported COVID-19 Prevalence in the Early Stage of the Epidemic in The Netherlands Anti-Microbial Resistant Bacteria in Health Care Facilities in Gaza: exploring links with WASH. Final Report of a pilot study conducted under the GCRF/UK Academy of Medical Sciences Networking Grant Networking Grant GCRFNGR4\1490 Faeces and vaccines could be the key to tackling antimicrobial resistance Antibiotic resistance in drinking water systems: Occurrence, removal, and human health risks Global Humanitarian Overview 2019: UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA)