key: cord-0751571-ez603qc5
authors: Lidbury, Brett A.
title: Ross River Virus Immune Evasion Strategies and the Relevance to Post-viral Fatigue, and Myalgic Encephalomyelitis Onset
date: 2021-03-24
journal: Front Med (Lausanne)
DOI: 10.3389/fmed.2021.662513
sha: b68dd86cdd4b57f40ad2dfde4695a05b5f5b4907
doc_id: 751571
cord_uid: ez603qc5

Ross River virus (RRV) is an endemic Australian arbovirus, and member of the Alphavirus family that also includes Chikungunya virus (CHIK). RRV is responsible for the highest prevalence of human disease cases associated with mosquito-borne transmission in Australia, and has long been a leading suspect in cases of post-viral fatigue syndromes, with extrapolation of this link to Myalgic Encephalomyelitis (ME). Research into RRV pathogenesis has revealed a number of immune evasion strategies, impressive for a virus with a genome size of 12 kb (plus strand RNA), which resonate with insights into viral pathogenesis broadly. Drawing from observations on RRV immune evasion, mechanisms of relevance to long term idiopathic fatigue are featured as a perspective on infection and eventual ME symptoms, which include considerations of; (1) selective pro-inflammatory gene suppression post antibody-dependent enhancement (ADE) of RRV infection, (2) Evidence from other virus families of immune disruption and evasion post-ADE, and (3) how virally-driven immune evasion may impact on mitochondrial function via target of rapamycin (TOR) complexes. In light of these RRV measures to counter the host immune - inflammatory responses, links to recent discoveries explaining cellular, immune and metabolomic markers of ME will be explored and discussed, with the implications for long-COVID post SARS-CoV-2 also considered. Compelling issues on the connections between virally-induced alterations in cytokine expression, for example, will be of particular interest in light of energy pathways, and how these perturbations manifest clinically.

The history of Myalgic Encephalomyelitis (ME) features outbreaks as defining events, suggesting an infectious etiology behind the cluster of symptoms experienced by affected individuals (1, 2) . Outbreak examples include Akureyri disease (Iceland -1940s), Royal-Free Hospital London (UK -1950s), "Tapanui Flu" (New Zealand -1980s), and Lake Tahoe (USA -1980s), with the description of "flu-like" symptoms common among patients (3, 4) . While respiratory viruses were obvious candidates given this history, other virus families have been linked to ME (5) , as well as the intra-cellular bacterial agent of Q-Fever, Coxiella burnetti (6, 7) .

Viruses rely upon the host-cell machinery to replicate, and knowledge of these processes for diverse virus families is well-established (8) . Appreciation of the manipulation of host-immunity by viruses has emerged during the previous three decades (9, 10) , with early insights gained from large genome DNA viruses, for example poxviruses and herpesviruses, which often involved cytokine ligand or receptor mimicry to evade host-immune responses (11) (12) (13) (14) (15) . RNA viruses also have evolved ingenious strategies for immune evasion (16, 17) , with examples including members of the flavivirus and coronavirus families (18) (19) (20) (21) that are responsible for disease on a global scale. From an evolutionary perspective, the author has previously theorized that RNA viruses rely upon "erroneous replication" strategies to avoid destruction by the host, but at the potential cost to the virus of killing the host and impeding the propagation of viral progeny (16) .

The perspective presented here centers on the endemic Australian virus, Ross River (RRV), a positive-strand RNA (12 kb) Old World Alphavirus. RRV is transmitted by mosquitos and responsible for Ross River virus disease (RRVD), which is defined by lethargy, myalgia, rash and polyarthritis, as well as post-viral syndrome (22, 23) . RRV is suspected of being a microbial precursor to Australian ME cases, along with Epstein-Barr Virus (EBV) and C. burnetti (7) .

How infection leads to ME is the subject of the perspective presented herein, with RRV as the primary ME-linked virus example. Of particular interest are the observations on the dysregulation of cytokine expression in macrophages post RRV-ADE (antibody-dependent enhancement) infection, and thus inflammatory responses by the host, as well as the impact on mitochondrial function. A perspective on how these interacting features result in the ultimate clinical manifestations of long-term fatigue, post-exertional malaise and other symptom clusters (2) is presented herein.

Consideration of these questions has contemporary urgency due to the emergence of "long-COVID, " which for some patients resembles ME once recovered from the acute SARS-CoV-2 infection (24) .

The concepts investigated to formulate the perspective presented are of particular contemporary importance, since at the time of writing, the world is confronting the SARS-CoV-2 (COVID- 19) pandemic that has raised issues related to:

(a) Vaccine safety in the context of antibody-dependent enhancement (ADE) of virus infection, and (b) The emergence of cases of "long-(haul)-COVID, " which in some present symptoms identical to ME.

Vaccines are not the primary focus here, but understanding ADE as an avenue of immune evasion, and thereafter manipulation of host immune -inflammatory responses by the virus, raise pertinent questions linked to the eventual development of idiopathic fatigue in some individuals postacute virus infection. The concept of "cytokine storm" is wellrecognized for COVID-19 and other diseases, but in other cases impacts of immune manipulation are maybe subtler? And what do these events mean for the regulation mitochondrial function and energy production if the virus is assisted by ADE?

Hawkes first reported ADE of virus infection in 1964, observed for members of the Togavirus Family as classified at the time (25) . The studies focussed on Class A and B Togaviruses, with Getah (Togavirus -Alphaviridae) Murray Valley Encephalitis, West Nile and "Japanese Encephalitis viruses" (Flaviruses -Flaviridae) displaying up to 12-fold growth enhancement in chick embryo fibroblast (CEF) cultures, and on chorioallantoic membranes, with the effect only seen with antibodies raised in "domestic fowls, " not from other species. Further investigations revealed that the enhancing properties were specific to the IgG fraction of the anti-serum that enhanced virus growth (26) .

Presciently, once antibody was identified as the enhancing factor, the authors stated; Another possibility that should be considered is that the enhancing antibody is taken into the cell along with the virus and influences subsequent intracellular events. These problems can only be answered by further studies of the interactions between complexes of virus and antibody and susceptible cells (26) .

Subsequent studies conducted over the 1970s−80s established in vitro ADE for the global pathogen Dengue virus (DEN), as well as identified the role for Fc-Receptor (Fc-R) engagement in ADE via studies with other flaviviruses (27) (28) (29) . By the 1990s, ADE was recognized as a factor in severe DEN disease (Haemorrhagic Fever, Shock Syndrome), on subsequent infection with a DEN serotype different to the original case (30) , which has also frustrated attempts to develop a DEN vaccine (31) . Many virus families have been observed as displaying enhanced in vitro growth post-infection due to ADE, but the impact in vivo and on disease manifestation are not currently well-understood (32) (33) (34) .

While ADE was observed for the close RRV relative, Getah virus, during Hawkes's original ADE observations in 1964, RRV-ADE was not reported until the 1990s (35) . As found for earlier examples, RRV-ADE was demonstrated in vitro for monocytes and macrophages, including the macrophage cell line RAW 264.7, which was later central to the elucidation of molecular mechanisms post-ADE entry.

While enhanced virus uptake helped explain ADE mechanism (28), the ". . . subsequent intracellular events . . . " suggested by Hawkes and Lafferty were eventually revealed by in vitro models of RRV infection using RAW 264.7 macrophages. The important intracellular events were linked to the regulation of pro-and anti-inflammatory cytokines, at the level of the transcriptional machinery. While the impact on early virus growth is clear, it must be assumed that the dysregulation of cytokines during an innate response also has implications for longer term immunity, and perhaps the vigor of subsequent inflammation that follows infection.

The RRV in vitro models showed a clear disruption of expression for TNF, NOS2, IFN-β, IP-10 that involved the temporary post-ADE ablation of STAT-1 (ISGF3 and AAF), IRF-1 and NK-κB transcriptional complexes, which occurred at the same time as enhanced RRV growth. As well as the downregulation of proinflammatory -antiviral gene expression, IL-10 expression was significantly increased, as was the transcription factor Sp1 (36, 37) . Similar patterns were also detected in a flavivirus (DEN) (38) (39) (40) (41) (42) and an arterivirus (PRRSV) (43) (44) (45) (46) . Post-ADE IL-12 and IFN-γ suppression was also observed for DEN, as well as concomitant impacts on the associated transcription factors (e.g., STAT, IRF), while IL-10 expression was similarly unaffected or increased ( Table 1) .

Knowledge of intracellular events post-ADE has been assisted through understanding the biology of Fc-gamma-Receptors (FcγR), including the identity of FcγR classes, the affinity of IgG (or complex) receptor binding and linked intracellular activating (e.g., FcγRIIa ITAM) or inhibitory (FcγRIIb ITIM) pathways (55) . For the inhibitory action of FcγRIIb, phosphatases are recruited to the ITIM domain post receptor cross-linking (SRC family kinases), and ultimately leads from PIP 3 to PIP 2 conversion via hydrolysis. PIP 3 is a cell surface receptor linked second messenger synthesized from PI3K isoforms, involved in a range of cellular functions post ligand engagement. Of potential relevance to the role of ADE-mediated suppression of inflammatory pathways after FcγRIIb interaction, mouse models of disease have demonstrated that the inhibition of PI3Ks diminishes the severity of inflammation (56) .

DEN has provided a strong focus into the intracellular consequences post-ADE infection, describing other intracellular mechanisms beyond those originally identified by RRV. These extend to type I IFN restriction via autophagy, SOCS3 and Syk-regulated pathways ( Table 1) . DEN-ADE and cytokine expression changes have been also reported for mast cells (48) . Ebola virus ADE showed interesting FcγRIIa signaling pathways, without details on cytokine expression (49-51), although Ebola has been shown to alter cytokine expression without ADE via secreted viral glycoprotein (57) .

SARS-CoV is an ADE virus, but with a difference ( Table 1) . While ADE for FcR bearing cells was observed, longer term infection was abortive, and the post-ADE mRNA expression profiles for IFN-α/β, MCP-1, IP-10, TNF, MIP-1 were not altered (52) (53) (54) . Whether ADE is a factor in SARS-CoV pathology, or poses a threat post-vaccination, are currently being debated and assessed (58, 59) . However, there is broad consensus that "cytokine storm, " which can be understood as a gross dysregulation of appropriate cytokine responses leading to hyperinflammation, is a factor in disease (e.g., acute respiratory distress symptom). The link of SARS-CoV to ME is the recognition of "long-COVID, " which shares symptoms such as long-term unexplained fatigue, "brain fog, " pain and so on (24, 60) , and as such provides a connection between an acute virus infection and long-term sequelae, as has been suspected in ME for decades. Definitive cytokine profiles for long-COVID have not been determined as yet, and drawing from the ME experience of establishing cytokine profiles for long term illness is not helpful due to the lack of consistency and validation by larger studies, although TGF-β has attracted some interest (61, 62) .

The core ME symptoms of long-term fatigue and post-exertional malaise (PEM) logically point to bioenergetic pathways, metabolomics and mitochondrial function, which have attracted biomedical research attention over the previous 10-15 years (63) (64) (65) (66) . Very recently, studies by Missailidis et al. (67, 68) have investigated mitochondrial function in immortalized ex vivo lymphoblasts collected from ME patients. Among a number of observations, Complex V rate of ATP synthesis was significantly reduced compared to healthy control lymphoblasts, with a statistical difference also found for lymphocyte death rate, and with chronic TORC I (TOR-Complex I) hyperactivation in ME lymphoblasts observed (suggesting compensatory activity via the upregulation of proteins required for oxidative phosphorylation and general mitochondrial function). TORC signaling is critical for stress sensing, cell growth and energetics, hence important to homeostasis and life span in general, with implications for disease if altered (69, 70) .

Infection and the virally-induced disruption of cytokine signaling impacts homeostasis, and evidence exists to support mTOR -STAT signaling interactions in the context of immunity, including IL-10 expression (71) . Therefore, chronically upregulated TORC signaling, as recently observed (67), may be linked to upsets in STAT, or vice versa. Inflammation impacts TOR function, and of relevance to the disruption to cytokine expression in macrophages post RRV-ADE, mTORC2 regulation is necessary for IFN-stimulated genes (ISGs) (37, 71) .

The disturbance of homeostasis is an obvious result of infection, with the advent in some patients of severe illness due to cytokine storm, which represents a serious disequilibrium outcome due to the compromise of normal inflammation regulation processes. In discussing pathology, it is often forgotten that immune responses are also required for cellular and tissue repair, which involve the pleiotropic nature of some cytokines that are normally associated with inflammation, like TNF (72, 73) , in addition to other cytokine families with primary roles in healing, for example, the transforming growth factor (TGF) family. In fact, a member of the TGF super family, Activin B, has been identified in serum from ME patients as significantly different when compared to healthy volunteers (74) . Activin proteins have many physiological roles, including repair, pro-, and anti-inflammatory functions (75) .

In answering questions on why some individuals develop severe symptoms post-infection, and then in a proportion of cases intractable ME or long-COVID, while others display no short or long terms health impacts, surely is connected to individual differences in the regulation of the interactions discussed above. And within this milieu, the TOR family of proteins sit at the interface between the regulation of inflammation -immunity post-infection, and energy regulation both at the mitochondrial level, and associated pathways required for carbohydrate, lipid and amino acid catabolism.

While ADE is not the primary focus here, past investigations of ADE mechanism have identified a range of cellular pathways manipulated by viruses that may alter future cellular function, potentially leading to a long-term disturbance of homeostasis, which can lead to chronic alterations in mitochondrial function and energy regulation, ultimately manifesting as multisystem disease. By linking patterns of post-infection cytokine dysregulation with observations on chronically increased TOR protein activity in cells from ME patients, the interface of TOR and inflammatory pathways is recommended as a topic for deeper investigation. Delving into these cellular processes will contribute insights into the mystery of why a virus infection can lead to a chronic health condition like ME in some individuals (estimated to be 11% in Australia) (7) . The emergence of long-COVID brings a new urgency to these questions.

Of course, viruses do not need ADE entry to manipulate host immune-inflammatory responses to infection [(5) -includes explanations of virus-associated disruption of mitochondrial function, impact on immune cells, and discussion of infection and ME pathogenesis], but the impact associated with the expansion of cellular range to Fc-Receptor (FcR) or Complement-Receptor (CR) bearing cells, not normally permissive to infection, requires consideration. The strong disruption, and at times ablation of antiviral and inflammatory pathways, must have downstream impacts on later innate immune functions and the formation of adaptive immunity, particularly with the higher viral load allowing more FcR and CR cells to become infected, and their functions similarly impacted.

The history of ME features regular "outbreaks, " which have been associated with virus infections. At the time of writing, the COVID (SARS-CoV-2) pandemic has revealed a sub-population of recovered patients who have developed long-term symptoms that resemble classic ME. Therefore, a perspective is presented herein that aims to link the viral manipulation of host antiviral and inflammatory-immune responses to mitochondrial function, with TOR proteins as the critical interface between deranged cytokine expression and energy regulation. Established for many virus families (Table 1) , ADE post-infection is the particular perspective focus. ADE currently has renewed interest in relation to potential COVID vaccine safety, but in a more general context also raises questions on ME pathogenesis due to the dramatic consequences for immediate antiviral defenses, later innate immune responses, and thereafter guidance from ADEimpacted cells (e.g., antigen-presenting cells) for the formation of an appropriate adaptive immune response to support long term homeostasis.

The unraveling of the interactions between the viral manipulation of cells, bioenergetics and mitochondrial function will reveal the differences, at a cellular level, to explain why some individuals go on to develop chronic long-term health challenges like ME or long-COVID, while others do not.

The conception, research, analyses, and writing of this manuscript were all conducted by BAL.

Many thanks to ME-RESEARCH-UK (Scotland) and the J. J. Mason Foundation (Australia) for recent funding to support our research into ME and CFS.

Myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome: a comprehensive review

Myalgic encephalomyelitis: international consensus criteria

On chronic fatigue syndrome and nosological categories

Chronic fatigue syndromes: relationship to chronic viral infections

Chronic viral infections in myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS)

Multi-omics examination of Q fever fatigue syndrome identifies similarities with chronic fatigue syndrome

Post-infective and chronic fatigue syndromes precipitated by viral and non-viral pathogens: prospective cohort study

Editors-in-chief) Field's Virology

Viral subversion of the immune system

Viral strategies for evading antiviral cellular immune responses of the host

Encoding of a homolog of the IFN-gamma receptor by Myxoma virus

A soluble receptor for interieukin-1β encoded by vaccinia virus: A novel mechanism of virus modulation of the host response to infection

Homology of cytokine synthesis inhibitory factor (IL-10) to the Epstein-Banvirus gene BCRFI

Glycoprotein C of herpes simplex virus, type I prevents complementmediated cell lysis and virus neutralisation

Was exposure to directly antiviral cytokines during primary infection an important selective pressure in the evolution of unique immune evasion strategies by viruses?

Genetic "budget" of viruses and the cost to the infected host: a theory on the relationship between the genetic capacity of viruses, immune evasion, persistence and disease

The viral manipulation of the host cellular and immune environments to enhance propagation and survival: a focus on RNA viruses

Zika virus inhibits IFN-α response by human plasmacytoid dendritic cells and induces NS1-dependent triggering of CD303 (BDCA-2) signaling

Immune evasion strategies of flaviviruses

Innate immune evasion by SARS-CoV-2: Comparison with SARS-CoV

Covid-19: perspectives on innate immune evasion

Ross river virus transmission, infection, and disease: a cross-disciplinary review

Arthritogenic alphaviruses-an overview

Long COVID: let patients help define long-lasting COVID symptoms

Enhancement of the infectivity of arboviruses by specific antisera produced in domestic fowls

The enhancement of virus infectivity by antibody

Dengue viruses and mononuclear phagocytes. I Infection enhancement by non-neutralizing antibody

Monoclonal anti-Fc receptor IgG blocks antibody enhancement of viral replication in macrophages

17D yellow fever virus infection of P388D1 cells mediated by monoclonal antibodies: properties of the macrophage Fc receptor

Antibody-dependent enhancement of dengue virus growth in human monocytes as a risk factor for dengue haemorrhagic fever

Dengue and Zika virus infections are enhanced by live attenuated dengue vaccine but not by recombinant DSV4 vaccine candidate in mouse models

Fc receptors in antibody-dependent enhancement of viral infections

Antibody-dependent enhancement of virus infection and disease

Antibody-dependent enhancement of viral infectivity

Antibody-dependent enhancement and persistence in macrophages of an arbovirus associated with arthritis

Specific ablation of antiviral gene expression in macrophages by antibody-dependent enhancement of Ross River virus infection

Suppression of lipopolysaccharide-induced antiviral transcription factor (STAT-1 and NF-kappa B) complexes by antibody-dependent enhancement of macrophage infection by Ross River virus

Dengue virus (DENV) antibody-dependent enhancement of infection upregulates the production of anti-inflammatory cytokines, but suppresses anti-DENV free radical and proinflammatory cytokine production, in THP-1 cells

Spleen tyrosine kinase (Syk) mediates IL-1β induction by primary human monocytes during antibody-enhanced dengue virus infection

Antibody-dependent enhancement of dengue virus infection inhibits RLR-mediated Type-I IFNindependent signalling through upregulation of cellular autophagy

An emerging role for the anti-inflammatory cytokine interleukin-10 in dengue virus infection

Antibody-dependent enhancement infection facilitates dengue virusregulated signalling of IL-10 production in monocytes

Antibody-mediated porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus infection downregulates the production of interferon-α and tumor necrosis factor-α in porcine alveolar macrophages via Fc gamma receptor I and III

Monoclonal antibody analysis of porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus epitopes associated with antibody-dependent enhancement and neutralization of virus infection

Antibodydependent enhancement of PRRSV infection down-modulates TNF-α and IFN-β transcription in macrophages

Porcine FcγRIIb mediates enhancement of porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV) infection

How dengue virus circumvents innate immunity

Release of vasoactive cytokines by antibody-enhanced dengue virus infection of a human mast cell/basophil line

A complement component C1q-mediated mechanism of antibody-dependent enhancement of Ebola virus infection

Fcγ-receptor IIa-mediated Src signaling pathway Is essential for the antibody-dependent enhancement of Ebola virus infection

Epitopes required for antibody-dependent enhancement of Ebola virus infection

Antibodydependent enhancement of SARS coronavirus infection and its role in the pathogenesis of SARS

Antibodydependent infection of human macrophages by severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus

Anti-severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus spike antibodies trigger infection of human immune cells via a pH-and cysteine protease-independent FcγR pathway

The role of IgG Fc receptors in antibody-dependent enhancement

PI3K signalling in inflammation

Ebola virus secreted glycoprotein decreases the anti-viral immunity of macrophages in early inflammatory responses

ADE and hyperinflammation in SARS-CoV2 infection -comparison with dengue hemorrhagic fever and feline infectious peritonitis

Warp Speed" needs mind melds, not warped minds

Long-COVID: An evolving problem with an extensive impact

The clinical value of cytokines in chronic fatigue syndrome

Chronic fatigue syndrome and circulating cytokines: a systematic review

Chronic fatigue syndrome and mitochondrial dysfunction

Cellular bioenergetics is impaired in patients with chronic fatigue syndrome

NMR metabolic profiling of serum identifies amino acid disturbances in chronic fatigue syndrome

Metabolism in chronic fatigue syndrome

An isolated complex V inefficiency and dysregulated mitochondrial function in immortalized lymphocytes from ME/CFS patients

Cell-based blood biomarkers for myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome

Target of rapamycin (TOR) in nutrient signaling and growth control

mTOR as regulator of lifespan, aging, and cellular senescence: a mini-review

Intersection of mTOR and STAT signaling in immunity

Epithelial TNF receptor signaling promotes mucosal repair in inflammatory bowel disease

Transmembrane TNF and partially TNFR1 regulate TNFR2 expression and control inflammation in mycobacterial-induced pleurisy

Activin B is a novel biomarker for chronic fatigue syndrome/myalgic encephalomyelitis (CFS/ME) diagnosis: a cross sectional study

The roles of activin A and its binding protein, follistatin, in inflammation and tissue repair

With thanks to Professor Paul Fisher (La Trobe University) for his guidance and advice on mitochondrial function and ME.

The author declares that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.Copyright © 2021 Lidbury. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.