key: cord-0751566-im5uom28
authors: Jones, Elizabeth A. K.; Mitra, Amal K.; Bhuiyan, Azad R.
title: Impact of COVID-19 on Mental Health in Adolescents: A Systematic Review
date: 2021-03-03
journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health
DOI: 10.3390/ijerph18052470
sha: 0132557f4725ac014db045951939fcc4996e3f03
doc_id: 751566
cord_uid: im5uom28

Due to lack of sufficient data on the psychological toll of the COVID-19 pandemic on adolescent mental health, this systematic analysis aims to evaluate the impact of the pandemic on adolescent mental health. This study follows the PRISMA guidelines for systematic reviews of 16 quantitative studies conducted in 2019–2021 with 40,076 participants. Globally, adolescents of varying backgrounds experience higher rates of anxiety, depression, and stress due to the pandemic. Secondly, adolescents also have a higher frequency of using alcohol and cannabis during the COVID-19 pandemic. However, social support, positive coping skills, home quarantining, and parent–child discussions seem to positively impact adolescent mental health during this period of crisis. Whether in the United States or abroad, the COVID-19 pandemic has impacted adolescent mental health. Therefore, it is important to seek and to use all of the available resources and therapies to help adolescents mediate the adjustments caused by the pandemic.

The COVID-19 pandemic has created a havoc across the world, which has resulted in over 2 million deaths, globally and forced billions into isolation due to stay at home orders [1] . As a result of social isolation, and the constant concern of infectivity, mental health consequences that are associated with the COVID-19 crisis are monumental [2, 3] . However, researchers are focusing more on the mental health impact of this rapidly evolving global crisis in the elderly population [4] . There has been very little attention to the psychological toll of COVID-19 on adolescent mental health [5] .

The psychological toll of COVID-19 among adolescents should be a focal point in COVID-19 research due to the severe and enduring impact of mental health, which leads to poor mental health outcomes and to poor physical health outcomes, such as the development of cardiovascular diseases [6, 7] . The mental toll of this impact serves as a greater challenge for adolescents because this age range (characterized as young people between the ages of 13-17) lack the psychological capabilities of resilience and coping and the physiological development of adults [6, 8] . The mental health challenges of adolescents are even greater among adolescents with pre-existing mental health conditions during periods of crisis, which may be a result of isolation, feelings of uncertainty, lack of daily routines, lack of access to health services provided through schools, and lack of advanced emotional development [9, 10] .

Globally, 10-20% of adolescents suffer from mental health conditions [11] . This statistic is likely to be affected by the vulnerability of adolescents during the COVID-19 pandemic [12] . Due to the negative outcomes associated with poor mental health statuses among adolescents, such as suicide, behavior problems, and emotional distress and the need for quality research to build resilience and to reduce anxiety among adolescents, it is imperative to review the impact of COVID-19 on adolescent health in the United States and abroad in order to understand the global state of adolescent mental health and to provide strategies that prevent poor mental health outcomes, such as anxiety and depression, presently and in the future [13] .

The aim of this systematic review is to assess the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on adolescent mental health. Distinctively, the objectives of this review are: (1) To identity the state of adolescent mental health, globally; and (2) To provide quality research that will provide insight into strategies that can be used to address poor mental health outcomes of adolescents.

The systematic review included studies by following the PRISMA guidelines [11] . The study focused on published original quantitative studies on mental health issues in adolescents due to COVID-19. The inclusion and exclusion of the review are mentioned in Table 1 . 

The primary search engines that were used to identify articles included EBSCOhost, MEDLINE, APA PsychoInfo, APA Psych articles, Socindex, and CINAHL. All the investigators were involved in the search process. The studies were chosen for the review based on inclusion criteria, such as (1) articles being written in English; (2) being quantitative studies; (3) being scholarly papers; (4) using human participants between the ages of 13-17; (5) being associated with mental health illnesses; and (6) being associated with COVID-19. The search was performed on 27 January 2021. The time limit for the studies was from 2019-2021. The search string is mentioned in Table 2 . 

The Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis (PRISMA) guidelines (2009) was used as a guide to record the review process [14] . Selected abstracts were reviewed to ensure their eligibility for inclusion. Full text articles of eligible abstracts were retrieved and assessed on whether they answered the research questions and fulfilled the inclusion criteria. Studies were included if consensus was reached by the three researchers.

Research Information System (RIS) formatted references were exported from the databases, where studies were automatically screened based on the inclusion criteria and then imported into CADIMA. The 46 studies that were imported in CADIMA were accessed based on title and abstracts. The researchers (Jones, Mitra and Bhuiyan) accessed the studies two times before discussing if the studies should be chosen for full text review. Conflicts were managed by group discussions between all three of the researchers of this study. After the initial discussion, all of the researchers agreed that 46 studies should be selected for further screening using the inclusion criteria. During this second phase of screening for having articles with full text and for excluding review articles, the three researchers again screened the 46 articles two times independently. Conflicts were managed by group discussions. After discussion, 30 more articles were excluded because they did not meet the inclusion criteria, and 16 articles were selected to be included in the systematic review. The PRISMA flow chart ( Figure 1 ) exhibits the search and inclusion process for the systematic review. 

Studies were appraised for quality using CADIMA. Through CADIMA, standards for the critical appraisal and the rating scale of the studies were defined. We followed the critical appraisal tools for systematic reviews developed by the University of Adelaide, South Australia [15] . A rating scale from 0 to 4 was based on the following criteria: (1) Study design-cross-sectional, case-control, or cohort study = 1, otherwise = 0; (2) Sample size-large = 1, small = 0; (3) Use of standardized instrument(s) for data collection, such as assessment of mental health by using Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9) or Diagnostic Manual of Mental Disorders-IV (DSM-IV) = 1, not specific = 0; and (4) Selection of participants-random selection or lack of bias = 1, non-random sample or convenience sample or presence of bias = 0 point. Based on the above-mentioned criteria, the three researchers rated each of the 16 studies independently from a range of 0 to 4. Due to having no major inter-observer variations in the evaluation of the quality of the studies, an average of the three scores was presented in Table 3 . 

A summary of the methodology, characteristics of findings, impact of COVID-19 on mental health in adolescents, quality appraisal and the countries of the studies are presented in Table 3 . Of the 16 studies reviewed, 7 were conducted in China, 2 in the United States, 2 in Canada, and 1 each in Denmark, Germany, Japan, the Philippines, and the United Kingdom. All of the 16 studies utilized a quantitative methodology [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] [25] [26] [27] [28] [29] [30] [31] . Among the studies, 12 (75%) were conducted online and 4 (25%) did not clearly report the study format. The studies were conducted from February 2020-May 2020, with six studies not reporting the date of data collection. Ten studies (62.5%) were conducted among adolescents only, three studies (18.8%) were conducted among children and adolescents, one study (6.3%) was conducted among adolescents and parents, and two studies (12.5%) were conducted among adults, young adults, and adolescents. In this study, we evaluated the data of adolescents only.

The total sample size used in the studies varied from 102 to 9554, having a median sample size of 1054 (1st Quartile = 693 and 3rd Quartile = 3254); 10 out of 16 (63%) had sample sizes of more than 1000. In terms of standardized tools, nine studies (56%) utilized standardized tools, and seven studies (44%) did not use standardized tools.

An average score of 4 out of 4, meant excellent in seven (44%), 2-3, meant moderate in seven (44%), and 0-1, meant poor in two (12%) studies.

Of the studies that addressed the impact of COVID-19 related anxiety for non-special populations, several studies established an association between the COVID-19 pandemic and rates of anxiety among adolescents [16] [17] [18] 24, 28, 30] . One study in China [28] identified that low support (Odds Ratio [OR] = 3.18, 95% Confidence Intervals [CI]: 2.54 to 3.98) and medium support (OR = 2.19, 95% CI: 1.94 to 2.48) increased the likelihood of anxiety. However, Chen et al. [19] did not identify a significant correlation between the COVID-19 and anxiety among adolescents.

Five studies (31%) addressed depression among non-special populations and identified an association between the pandemic and depression [17, 25, 27, 28, 30] . One study in China conducted by Duan et al. [17] identified an association between depression and COVID-19 related addiction in using social media, such as smartphone addiction (OR = 1.844, 95% CI: 1.29 to 2.811), and internet addiction (OR = 3.107, 95% CI: 1.252 to 7.708). Guo et al. [23] identified an association between COVID-19 related stress and depression (β = 0.33, t = 11.49, p < 0.001). However, the study conducted by Chen et al. in China [19] failed to establish a significant correlation between depression and COVID-19 related factors.

Of the studies, several considered various other forms of psychological disorders and other forms of psychological distress, such as burdensomeness, belongingness, psychological distress, stress and trauma, and drug abuse. One study in the United States [16] revealed that specific motivation to practice social distancing led to burdensomeness and belongingness among adolescents. Another study in the Philippines [27] identified that 16.3% of respondents experienced psychological impairments as moderate or severe due to the pandemic. A Chinese study by Zhang et al. [30] found that negative coping skills are risk factors for stress and trauma among junior high and high school students. A Canadian study [31] recognized the increased frequency of drug usage, such as alcohol and cannabis among adolescents during the pandemic.

Special populations among adolescents were assessed in several studies. These special population included Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, and Queer (LGBTQ) adolescents, adolescents diagnosed with anorexia nervosa, pre-pandemic maltreated adolescents, seniors, females, and adolescents diagnosed with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). Through 31 synchronous text-based chats, LGBTQ adolescents expressed difficulty maintaining mental health wellness due to being forced to stay at home with unsupportive family members, and due to the lack of socialization that helps with identity [22] . Adolescents diagnosed with anorexia nervosa reported 70% increases in poor eating habits and increases in thoughts associated with eating disorders [21] . Pre-pandemic maltreated adolescents experienced higher rates of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) (effect size beta = 0.16~0.27) and higher rates of anxiety (effect size beta = 0.32~0.47) [23] . Of the two studies [24, 26] that specifically evaluated seniors, both studies established associations between poor mental health outcomes, such as psychological issues and anxiety, and factors related to the COVID-19 pandemic. Both studies that discussed gender-related data [26, 27] established higher rates of COVID-19 related anxiety among females. The study [29] that evaluated various groups of youth, including adolescents that were diagnosed with OCD, established a worsening of symptoms (44.6%) for patients, who completed primary treatment and for patients, who were currently in psychiatric treatment.

Of the 16 studies in this review, one study in China [24] identified both a negative and a positive impact between COVID-19 related factors, such as home quarantining and parent-child discussions with mental health outcomes. The positive benefits were related with coming in closer and having more family discussions between parents and their children during home quarantining.

In this systematic review, there was conclusive evidence to support the potential negative impact of the pandemic on adolescent mental health. The stressors and motivations to practice social distancing due to the COVID-19 pandemic seem to be difficult for adolescents to process, which results in poor mental health outcomes [16] . The inefficient ability to process difficult circumstances, such as the pandemic are due to negative coping skills, which are risk factors for depression, stress and trauma among various ages of adolescents [30] . The lack of positive coping skills among adolescents is not unusual because adolescent must be provided with the tools to cope in order to be resilient and mentally well during periods of adjustments. However, the exposure to and practice of positive coping skills can lead to mentally well adolescents, who can easily adjust to rapid changes.

Social support was another major factor identified in this review in determining the mental sustainability of adolescents during periods of crisis, such as the pandemic. Adolescents had perceived high rates of low to moderate social support during the pandemic, which contributed to increases in anxiety and depression [28] . Despite the concept of social support being expressed from the point of view of adolescents, which may or may not be bias, adolescents are still experiencing authentic forms of psychological challenges, such as anxiety and depression associated with the lack of social support and the pandemic. Due to these challenges, it is imperative that support be greatly implemented in homes. Studies have shown that the implementation of social support leads to positive mental health outcomes [28] .

Addiction is another concern for adolescent mental health during the pandemic. Due to stay-at home orders, school closures, or new at home learning methods, students are seeking ways to connect and to socialize in manners that may not be productive for optimal health. The result of these behaviors are smartphone addiction and internet addiction. Both forms of addiction lead to poor mental health outcomes for adolescents.

Despite being forced to remain at home, adolescents were identified as still engaging in drug use during the pandemic. Rather adolescents were increasing their use of alcohol and cannabis during the pandemic with 49.3% engaging in drug use alone [30] . An earlier study [32] showed the link between the lack of positive coping skills and the possible neurobiological pathways that may associate stress with the craving for drug use.

As the non-special populations of adolescents experience mental health challenges, the special populations are experiencing a worsening of conditions, or experiences during the pandemic, which are a result of physical and psychologically COVID-19 related factors. These adolescents are forced to deal with unsupportive families due to sexual orientation, with the lack of social and medical support in connection to various pre-pandemic disorders, with an added stress concerning their futures, and with dealing with new and old stress from previous traumas [21] [22] [23] 26, 29, 33] . These groups of adolescents have always experienced more challenges, but the pandemic has significantly affected the quality of life of these adolescents.

Whether in the U.S. or abroad, the COVID-19 pandemic has impacted adolescent mental health. Stressful life events, extended home confinement, worry, overuse of the internet and social media are factors that could influence the mental health of adolescents during this pandemic. Adolescents from across the world face mental challenges due to COVID-19. Despite the uncertainty of the current crisis, it is important that adolescents receive the physical and mental care that they need to develop, to grow, and to thrive. Therefore, it is important to seek and to use all of the available resources and therapies to help adolescents mediate the adjustments caused by the pandemic. More research is needed on the improvement of adolescent mental health during COVID-19 and similar disasters. Among many interventions, more emphasis may be suggested on the global implementation of telemedicine to address the psychological needs of adolescents [34] . 

The authors declare no conflict of interest.

World Health Organization. WHO Coronavirus Disease (COVID-19) Dashboard. 2020

Pandemic fear" and COVID-19: Mental health burden and strategies

The Impact of COVID-19 Epidemic Declaration on Psychological Consequences: A Study on Active Weibo Users

COVID-19, Mental Health and Aging: A Need for New Knowledge to Bridge Science and Service

Risk and Protective Factors for Prospective Changes in Adolescent Mental Health during the COVID-19 Pandemic

Mental health and the COVID-19 pandemic

Mental Health and Cardiovascular Disease

World Health Organization. Adolescent Health

How Are Children Different from Adults? CDC

Mental health effects of school closures during COVID-19

COVID-19 and child and adolescent psychiatry: An unexpected blessing for part of our population? Eur

Available online: https:// www.who.Int/activities/improving-the-mental-and-brain-health-of-children-and-adolescents

Research in Mental Health During the COVID-19 Pandemic

Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement

Adolescents' Motivations to Engage in Social Distancing During the COVID-19 Pandemic: Associations with Mental and Social Health

An investigation of mental health status of children and adolescents in china during the outbreak of COVID-19

Demographic and health factors associated with pandemic anxiety in the context of COVID-19

Depression and anxiety among adolescents during COVID-19: A cross-sectional study

Do suicide rates in children and adolescents change during school closure in Japan? The acute effect of the first wave of COVID-19 pandemic on child and adolescent mental health

Eating disorders in times of the COVID -19 pandemic-Results from an online survey of patients with anorexia nervosa

I'm Kinda Stuck at Home with Unsupportive Parents Right Now": LGBTQ Youths' Experiences With COVID-19 and the Importance of Online Support

Is the psychological impact of exposure to COVID-19 stronger in adolescents with pre-pandemic maltreatment experiences? A survey of rural Chinese adolescents

Mental health and its correlates among children and adolescents during COVID-19 school closure: The importance of parent-child discussion

Physically isolated but socially connected: Psychological adjustment and stress among adolescents during the initial COVID-19 crisis

Prevalence of anxiety and associated factors for Chinese adolescents during the COVID -19 outbreak

Psychological impact of COVID-19 pandemic in the Philippines

The Effect of Social Support on Mental Health in Chinese Adolescents During the Outbreak of COVID-19

The immediate effect of COVID-19 pandemic on children and adolescents with obsessive compulsive disorder

The Psychological Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Teenagers in China

What Does Adolescent Substance Use Look Like During the COVID-19 Pandemic? Examining Changes in Frequency, Social Contexts, and Pandemic-Related Predictors

Chronic Stress, Drug Use, and Vulnerability to Addiction

Adding stress to the stressed: Senior high school students' mental health amidst the COVID-19 nationwide lockdown in Greece

The relevance of digital mental healthcare during COVID-19: Need for innovations