key: cord-0741697-zd2wsxxe
authors: Dondi, Arianna; Lenzi, Jacopo; Candela, Egidio; Sureshkumar, Sugitha; Morigi, Francesca; Biagi, Carlotta; Lanari, Marcello
title: Social Determinants of Health and Distance Learning in Italy in the Era of the SARS-CoV-2 Pandemic
date: 2022-05-09
journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health
DOI: 10.3390/ijerph19095741
sha: b6c0acf0c6ef4bc587f5e8d94cc35d121e3914de
doc_id: 741697
cord_uid: zd2wsxxe

Objectives: To investigate the experiences by distance learning (DL) method during the first wave of the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic in Italy, and to search for correlations with purported experiences and respective levels of social determinants of health (SDH). Study design and methods: Cross-sectional online survey, investigating various SDH and parents’ attitude towards DL, proposed 6 months after the beginning of the pandemic to a sample population of parents with school-aged children throughout Italy. Results: A total of 3791 questionnaires were analyzed. Non-Italian parents complained more frequently of difficulties in providing support to their children in DL due to poor digital skills (p = 0.01), lack of good-quality digital equipment (p = 0.01), problems with the Italian language (p < 0.001), and a lower level of education (p < 0.001). When parents lived apart, greater difficulties in concentration in children using DL (p = 0.05) and a lower parental capacity to support DL (p = 0.002) were reported. Adequate digital structures appeared related to living in owned compared to rented property, higher levels of parental education, and better familial financial situations. Conclusions: Students from families with financial difficulties and low levels of parental education, or even those living in houses for rent or having separated parents, may be disadvantaged in an educational context since the introduction of DL.

Social determinants of health (SDH) are the set of conditions in which people are born, grow, live, work, and age, that affect their state of health [1] . Overall, SDH include political systems, economic systems, development programs, and can be grouped mainly into six fields: economic stability; place of residence; type of diet; presence or absence of a community/network of support; health care; and level of education [2] . From the beginning of 2020, the COVID-19 pandemic has exacerbated and amplified social and health inequalities in various nations of the world [3] [4] [5] [6] . Social vulnerability has proven to be a relevant risk factor for severe manifestations of COVID-19, even in children, reaffirming the notion that some SDH contribute to premature death more than the quality of healthcare received [7, 8] .

Due to the need to limit the spread of the SARS-CoV-2 infection, distance learning (DL) became the prevailing schooling modality during the first months of the pandemic. (Italy, from 8th March 2020, was the first country in Europe to implement a nationwide lockdown) [9] and is still utilized in cases of quarantine for groups of children in countries including Italy. DL (also known as e-learning, distance education, or online learning), is characterized by a physical separation between the students and teachers during the process of education [10] , thus representing a viable alternative to the conventional lessons where presence is required. It reshaped the education service, but also provided a possible further factor of social inequity [11, 12] .

The aim of the present study was to investigate the experiences encountered by families with children utilizing the DL method during the months of the first wave and nationwide lockdown due to the COVID-19 pandemic in Italy, namely from March to May 2020, and to search for correlations with purported experiences and respective levels of SDH.

From 1 September to 15 October 2020, a cross-sectional online survey of 78 questions was proposed to a sample population of parents with children up to the age of 18 years and domiciled throughout the Italian national territory. The survey was developed on the online platform Qualtrics and distributed through dissemination of a link and a QR code in a tertiary care pediatric hospital and in the waiting rooms of the pediatricians' offices, and through social networks with a snowball sampling technique. It queried the demographic variables of families, various SDH (housing, level of parental education, employment, hunger, stress), topics related to children's behavior during lockdown (sleep, tics, changes in eating patterns), and parents' attitude and opinions towards DL. The methods and the questionnaire have already been described in detail elsewhere [13] . Here we examined the questions about DL and measured the degree of interrelation of these questions to the available information on SDH. The parents' level of education was measured according to the Italian school system division: secondary school normally lasts from 11 to 13 years old, while high school lasts between 14 and 19 years old.

Numerical variables were summarized as mean ± standard deviation; categorical variables were summarized as counts (percentages). Comparisons between groups were performed with Fisher's exact test, Mann-Whitney U test and Kruskal-Wallis test, where appropriate. Although the purpose of this analysis is mainly exploratory [14] , all p values were corrected using the Simes-Benjamini-Hochberg method for false discovery rate control [15] [16] [17] , which has the advantageous property that the power to detect an effect of a given size does not tend to zero as the number of comparisons increases, in contrast to the case with most other multiple-test procedures [18] . All data were analyzed using Stata version 15 (StataCorp. 2017. Stata Statistical Software: Release 15. College Station, TX, USA: StataCorp LP). The significance level was set at 5%.

The present study was approved by the Ethics Committee of the IRCCS Azienda Ospedaliero-Universitaria di Bologna, Policlinico Sant'Orsola (Bologna, Italy) (Institutional Reviewer Board approval number 762/2020/Oss/AOUBo).

Overall, 4031 parents of school-age children filled in the survey. After excluding incomplete answers about SDH and DL responses (country of origin, digital skills, major barriers to DL, feelings of inadequacy, and family bonds), 3791 questionnaires (94.0%) were included in the analysis.

One hundred nineteen parents (3.1%) were not of Italian origin: 88 (73.9%) came from other European countries, 13 (10.9%) from Latin America, 6 (5.0%) from Northern America, 6 (5.0%) from Asia, and 5 (4.2%) from Africa, while 1 was of unspecified origins. A total of 88.2% of these subjects had lived in Italy for at least 5 years (n = 105) and 37.0% had Italian citizenship (n = 44).

As shown in Table 1 , we observed a significant difference between the non-Italian parents who felt they did not have enough digital skills to follow their children in DL and the Italian population with the same concern (20.2% vs. 10.3%, p = 0.01). Similarly, non-Italian parents complained more frequently of a lack of good-quality digital equipment (12.6% vs. 5.5%, p = 0.01) and reported an overall lower number of personal computers (p = 0.04). As compared with Italians, non-Italian parents had more difficulties with the Italian language (11.8% vs. 0.1%, p < 0.001), and reported an insufficient level of education to support the school commitments of their children (17.6% vs. 5.7%, p < 0.001). 

Among families with parents living apart, children were reported to have greater difficulties in concentrating during DL (60.6% vs. 55.1% of the children of parents living together, p = 0.05) and parents referred to a lower capacity for commitment in support of DL (11.4% vs. 6.8%, p = 0.002) ( Table 2 ). 

We observed a greater propensity to declare insufficient parental digital skills, lower availability of good-quality digital devices, and greater sense of inadequacy in providing adequate digital tools in families living in houses for rent, compared to those who lived in owned property (19.9% vs. 9.5%, p < 0.001, 13.7% vs. 4.7%, p < 0.001, and 8.3% vs. 3.8%, p < 0.001, respectively) ( Table 3) . 

Parental level of education (i.e., the highest level of education successfully completed according to the Italian school system) exhibited a large number of significant associations with perceived impairment in DL (Table 4 ). The number of computers and tablets owned by the family increased progressively with the level of education acquired by the parent (personal computer: secondary school 1.5 ± 0.8 SD, high school 1.8 ± 1.0 SD, university degree 2.2 ± 1.1 SD, p < 0.001). As reported in Table 4 , the barriers for children's DL (e.g., problems in connecting to the Internet, insufficient digital facilities) increased as the parental level of education decreased; parents with lower levels of education felt more incapable of supporting their children with DL, but, on the other hand, the concomitance of DL with parental working represented a major problem for children from families with higher levels of education. In this group, parents also reported more difficulties in controlling their children's anxiety, due to the scarcity of time spent with them.

The economic status of the family was assessed based on the personal perception of the family's economic situation (well-off, average, difficult) ( Table 5) . Parents with a better financial situation seemed to offer more support by providing adequate digital structures to their children, both in terms of the number of devices owned by the family, and in terms of the ability to be connected to the Internet. A more prosperous family environment, in general, was associated with higher parental self-confidence in supporting children and keeping their anxieties under control. Finally, this group of parents reported better agreement with partners concerning the management of their children. 

At the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic, the abrupt schooling transition to DL represented one of the greatest disruptions to youths' lives [19, 20] , and a great challenge for parents and caregivers, who were suddenly required to support their children in DL in different ways, according to their offspring age, as well as for teachers, who were often technologically unprepared and used to didactic methods suitable for lessons in presence. This study strived to identify the effects and impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on SDH and DL in Italy. Numerous studies have analyzed the mental and emotional health of children and adolescents during the pandemic [21, 22] . Other studies have focused on the students' opinion about DL, mostly in post-secondary education [23] [24] [25] .

After a thorough search on the PubMed database, we identified 12 studies investigating the relationship between SDH and DL at school age (primary to higher secondary grades) in different countries worldwide, although the age of schoolers and the considered parameters are highly variable. Papers evaluating this relationship are reported in Table 6 . In general, a lower socioeconomic status and lower parental education are burdened by more impediments to DL in terms of lower digital devices' availability, problems with internet connection, and parental difficulties in supporting their children's DL. The included realities are both high-, middle-, and low-income countries; however, no information is reported about the situation in Italy. Our study highlighted the differences in access to digital devices in relation to SDH in a wide population sample distributed all over the Italian territory. The lack of adequate equipment seems to correlate with parents being of non-Italian origin, parents not having reached a higher level of education, families not living in owned housing, and parents perceiving their economic situation as difficult. In 2018, a survey in American colleges reported that about 20% of students had issues in accessing essential technology for DL (laptops and high-speed Internet) [38] . In the same study it was shown that students of lower socioeconomic status experienced disproportionate difficulties and a correlation between malfunctioning laptops and lower grade averages. In another study based on an analysis of the Facebook posts of a population of parents, the technological barrier also appeared to be the most common limitation in supporting e-learning [39] . The first step to successful DL is reliable technology and the infrastructure to ensure the online delivery of lessons.

According to a report by the Italian National Institute of Statistics (ISTAT), relating to the period 2018-2019, 33.8% of families in Italy do not have computers or tablets at home; this rate decreases to 14.3% among families with at least a minor. Only 22.2% of families have a PC or tablet available for each family member. In Southern Italy, 41.6% of families have no computer at home (compared to an average of about 30% in other areas of the country), and only 14.1% have at least one computer for each family member [40] . In 2020, the EU Kids Online Survey mapped the internet access, online practices, skills, online risks, and opportunities for children aged 9-16 in 19 European countries (including Italy) [41] . In Italy, 84% of participants are reported to go online primarily from their smartphones. In a recent UNICEF discussion paper, 15 studies were reviewed about how children log on to the Internet. The researchers reported great difficulty in finding high-quality studies about access inequalities among children, most of all because the majority part of these reports provide only descriptive statistics, and the socioeconomic status or other SDH was hard to measure in a way that is consistent across different countries [42] .

The economic state of a family is a fundamental SDH, showing that families of better economic standing were able to offer superior global digital support to their children.

Although not new, this fact should further emphasize that adequate access to the web has been shown to affect the health of people and communities [43] . On the other hand, it has long been known that use of digital technology is a key driver of change and can underpin the realization of the Sustainable Development Goals promoted by the United Nations [44] . The COVID-19 pandemic has exposed how the lack of internet access could affect most of the six domains of the SDH defined by the American Medical Association [2] .

In our study, several factors (migration, financial instability, house property, knowledge of the Italian language, separation of parents, level of education) included in common SDH frameworks appeared to influence the ability of parents to support their children in DL during the lockdown period. A multicenter study based on an online self-report questionnaire explored adolescents' emotional reactions during lockdown in a sample of 2105 secondary school students (aged [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] in Italy, Croatia, and Romania. It highlighted how the students who believed that family support was relevant to overcome this period (73.4% of the Italian interviewees) were less likely to report both boredom/emptiness and anxiety compared to those who had not recognized such an important role of the family [45] .

The findings determining DL among children from families not living together coincides with research showing lower scores and measures of academic achievement in children of single-parent households, when compared to children in two-parent households. Moreover, high rates of family fragmentation, worldwide, account for multiple socio-economic consequences, compromising economies, hindering innovation, as well as competition and growth.

Although a child's home environment, stability, and surroundings superseded home ownership in the achievement of improved social child outcomes, it was found that subsidized home ownership led to improved outcomes, in so far as the child maintained a suitable residing environment [46] . The findings of this study, in this respect, correlate to existing work on childhood home stability. The very apparent correlations to parental levels of education and being economically viable enough to be in possession of more digital devices and being more able to assist with school exercises, are seen. Indeed, those households with higher levels of parental levels of education have ensuing resource and employment opportunities that influence cognition and social outcomes but may have significant effects on children's behavior and receptiveness.

According to our results, in general a more prosperous family economic context seems to favor DL in several respects. This concurs with the studies that highlight strong evidence of associations between income factors and COVID-19 pandemic outcomes [47] [48] [49] . Furthermore, according to the latest report from ISTAT, Italy has one of the highest school dropout rates in Europe (about 13.1%) [50] , which is measured by the number of 18-to 24-year-olds who have, at most, a lower secondary qualification, and are outside the training and education system (Early Leavers from Education and Training, ELET). One of the benchmarks of the Strategy EUROPE 2020 is to reach a common European target of ELET below 9% by 2031 [51] . The report does not exclude the hypothesis that the various barriers to DL may have further worsened the Italian rates of school dropout.

The present study has several limitations. This survey was spread predominantly by social media. We, therefore, do not know the true response rate. The study design could limit the ability to reach groups of the population that do not have access to the Internet and who were probably not able to follow DL in a beneficial way; indeed, the foreign-born population in Italy is estimated at around 10% by the National Institute of Statistics (accessible via web-page http://dati.istat.it/, last accessed on 24 April 2022), a value much higher than the percentage of people with an immigration background observed in our study sample (3.1%). Moreover, we did not include all parameters of SDH, but we focused on the ones that we believed to be most relevant to this pandemic. Lastly, we only obtained parental point-of-views about DL. Despite its limitations, our work confirms and analyzes the difficulties in DL and its correlation to SDH during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Despite the disruption in the school system brought about by the COVID-19 pandemic, it brought opportunities for innovation and resilience in education. However, unequal access to DL poses barriers to education among disadvantaged groups. From a parental point of view, during the COVID-19 pandemic, SDH seemed to have had great impacts on DL, both in terms of accessibility (digital devices availability, adequate Internet connection), and parental ability to effectively support their children. School closures affected all children, but not all in the same way: students from families with financial difficulties and low levels of parental education, or even those living in houses for rent or having separated parents, may be disadvantaged in a school setting since the introduction of DL. When remote learning cannot be avoided due to public health requirements, institutions should be aware of those groups who may experience augmented impairment of effective learning and take measures to avoid the increase in social inequities. Moreover, obstacles in DL might likely lead to disproportionate learning losses and, finally, to long lasting inequalities with consequences in adult life, reflecting both at an individual and societal level. Thus, all stakeholders, including governmental, national, and local authorities, should take action to minimize these gaps and ensure the right of education for everyone. Informed Consent Statement: Informed online consent was obtained from all subjects involved in the study.

The data presented in this study are available on request from the corresponding author. The data are not publicly available due to the accordance with the Ethics Committee policy.

Closing the Gap in a Generation

Addressing Social Determinants of Health (SDOH): Beyond the Clinic Walls

COVID-19: Exposing and amplifying inequalities

COVID-19 exacerbating inequalities in the US

Social determinants of health and inequalities in COVID-19

COVID-19: Facts, cultural considerations, and risk of stigmatization

Social vulnerability as a risk factor for death due to severe paediatric COVID-19

The trouble with trust: Time-series analysis of social capital, income inequality, and COVID-19 deaths in 84 countries

Differences between traditional and distance education academic performances: A meta-analytic

Online learning and COVID-19: A meta-synthesis analysis

Are college students prepared for a technology-rich learning environment

Parents' perception of food insecurity and of its effects on their children in italy six months after the COVID-19 pandemic outbreak

Correction for multiple testing: Is there a resolution? Chest

An improved Bonferroni procedure for multiple tests of significance

Resampling-based false discovery rate controlling multiple test procedures for correlated test statistics

Selective inference in complex research

Operating characteristics and extensions of the false discovery rate procedure

Advocating for children during the COVID-19 school closures

Remote learning during COVID-19: Examining school practices, service continuation, and difficulties for adolescents with and without attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder

Adolescents' health in times of COVID-19: A scoping review

Sleep disorders reveal distress among children and adolescents during the Covid-19 first wave: Results of a large web-based Italian survey

Student's perspective on distance learning during COVID-19 pandemic: A case study of Western Michigan University, United States

Factors affecting attitudes of nursing students towards distance education during the COVID-19 pandemic: A web-based cross-sectional survey

Self-Brown, S. COVID-19 and distance learning: Effects on Georgia State University School of Public Health Students. Front. Public Health

Socio-demographic determinants of children home learning experiences during COVID 19 school closure

Who gets to learn in a pandemic? Exploring the digital divide in remote learning during the COVID-19 pandemic in Nigeria

The impact of lockdown on the learning gap: Family and school divisions in times of crisis

Experiences with online teaching and psychological adjustment of high-school students at the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic in Croatia

Sharp increase in inequality in education in times of the COVID-19-pandemic

Disrupted education trajectories: Exploring the effects of COVID-19 on adolescent learning and priorities for "building back better" education systems in Ethiopia

The impact of COVID-19 pandemic outbreak on education and mental health of Chinese children aged 7-15 years: An online survey

What could we do differently next time? Australian parents' experiences of the short-term and long-term impacts of home schooling during the COVID-19 pandemic

Loss of childcare and classroom teaching during the COVID-19-related lockdown in spring 2020: A longitudinal study on consequences on leisure behavior and schoolwork at home

A two-sided lockdown? Social class variations in the implementation of homeschooling during the COVID-19 lockdown

The first wave of the COVID-19 pandemic in primary schools in the Czech Republic: Parental perspectives

Carrying the burden into the pandemic-Effects of social disparities on elementary students' parents' perception of supporting abilities and emotional stress during the COVID-19 lockdown

Technology problems and student achievement gaps: A validation and extension of the technology maintenance construct

Barriers to distance learning during the COVID-19 outbreak: A qualitative review from parents' perspective. Heliyon 2020, 6, e05482

Investigating Risks and Opportunities for Children in a Digital World: A Rapid Review of the Evidence on Children's Internet Use and Outcomes Media and Communications

Broadband internet access is a social determinant of health!

The 17 Goals

My life during the lockdown": Emotional experiences of European adolescents during the COVID-19 crisis

The Impact of Homeownership on Child Outcomes Low-Income Homeownership Working Paper Series. The Impact of Homeownership on Child Outcomes

Vitamin D and COVID-19 infection and mortality in UK Biobank

Risk factors for SARS-CoV-2 among patients in the Oxford Royal College of General Practitioners Research and Surveillance Centre primary care network: A cross-sectional study

Disparities in outcomes among COVID-19 patients in a large health care system in California

Ciclo di Audizioni sul Tema della Dispersione Scolastica

Council Resolution on a Strategic Framework for Europen Cooperation in Education and Training towards the European Education Area and Beyond

We thank all the families who completed the survey. We thank Gabriele Pizzi from the Department of Management of the University of Bologna for allowing us to conduct the survey on the Qualtrics platform. We thank Francesco Bianchi from the Press Office of Sant'Orsola Hospital, Bologna, for his precious help in distributing the survey. Finally, we thank the Associazione Ospedali Pediatrici Italiani (AOPI) and the Autorità Garante per l'Infanzia e l'Adolescenza (AGIA) for patronage and support of our initiative.

The authors declare no conflict of interest.