key: cord-0739538-ew04zzh6
authors: Khambhati, Khushal; Bhattacharjee, Gargi; Singh, Vijai
title: Current progress in CRISPR‐based diagnostic platforms
date: 2018-10-26
journal: J Cell Biochem
DOI: 10.1002/jcb.27690
sha: 687afdf2850584621107d98c6ac6de7df3facd87
doc_id: 739538
cord_uid: ew04zzh6

The CRISPR‐Cas system is a key technology for genome editing and regulation in a wide range of organisms and cell types. Recently, CRISPR‐Cas–based diagnostic platform has shown idealistic properties for pathogen detection. Integrating the CRISPR‐Cas platform along with lateral flow system allows rapid, sensitive, specific, cheap, and reliable diagnostic. It has the potential to be in frontline for not only pathogen detection during the epidemic outbreak, but also cancer, and genetic diseases.

A constant need arises to develop an ideal diagnostic platform for a rapid, sensitive, specific, and cost-effective detection of a wide range of pathogens and diseases. It should be user-friendly and able to give instrument-free readouts for early detection of pathogens. 1 This desperate need was experienced during the Ebola 2014-2016 outbreaks. 2 The second annual review released by World Health Organization (WHO) in February 2018 emphasized on the urgent need for the development of better and improved diagnostic tools for prioritizing the epidemic diseases. The detection of Ebola, Zika, Marburg virus, Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV) and many more have been prioritized. 3 Recently, CRISPR-based diagnostic (CRISPR-Dx) tool for nucleic acid sequence recognition has productively delineated its potential to fulfill the requirements of an ideal diagnostic tool for pathogens, single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), and cancer detection. 4 CRISPR-Cas system found in bacterial system is amongst the many protective strategies that the cell utilizes for the eradication of extracellular genome or to resist the phage infection. Being an adaptive immune response, CRISPR-Cas systems have the ability to memories, adapt and lyse the nucleic acid sequences that have been previously or newly encountered. 5, 6 The endonuclease proteins (eg, spCas9, Cpf1) found during the interference event of CRISPR-Cas that are programmed using the mature cr-RNA (commonly known as guide RNA) to target the desired sequence present in cell. 7, 8 This has proved to be advantageous for genome editing since it is convenient, rapid, simple, cost-effective, and offers lower chances of off-targeting as compared with alternative tools including zinc finger nucleases and transcription activator-like effector nucleases. 9 2 | SHERLOCK'S VENTURE

Cas13a (C2c2) is a programmable RNAse found in CRISPR type-VI class 2 systems. In the presence of a specific guide RNA, it recognizes its target RNA and executes its nonspecific RNA degradation activity. 10 East-Seletsky et al 10 have taken the advantage and demonstrated the use of Cas13 for the detection of 0.01 nM of λRNA with high specificity, using the signals generated from fluorophore-quencher based reporter RNA molecule ( Figure 1 ). In a recent issue of Science, two articles reported the development of a CRISPR-based highsensitive diagnostic platform. 11, 12 Gootenberg et al 4 have developed a cost-effective (0.61$ per test) platform for in vitro detection of nucleic acid sequences, which could detect up to attomolar (aM) concentrations without compromising the specificity. This platform has been termed as Specific High Sensitivity Enzymatic Reporter UnLOCKing (SHERLOCK). In SHERLOCK, the target sequence is amplified with recombinase polymerase amplification for DNA detection (RPA) or reverse transcriptase-recombinase polymerase amplification for RNA detection (RT-RPA), an isothermal, nucleic acid amplification technique that eliminates the use of thermal cycler. The resultant amplified DNA sequence is then subjected to in vitro T7 transcription, and produced RNA molecule is detected by Cas13-guided reporter assay. The fluorescence signal is monitored using the spectroscopy 4 ( Figure 2 ). SHERLOCK has the potential to specifically detect lentiviral particles at a concentration of 2 aM, which harbors Zika and Dengue virus's nucleic acid fragments. It has also the ability to detect Zika virus directly from clinical isolates from serum, urine, and saliva, having a titer as sensitive as 3.2 aM, and through RNA extraction from the same material, a more sensitive detection up to 2.1 aM has been achieved. SHERLOCK is a powerful tool that allows us to distinguish between Escherichia coli and Pseudomonas aeruginosa; as well as can efficiently figure-out the clinical isolates of Klebsiella pneumoniae carrying antibiotic resistance genes. 4 Furthermore, by addition of single mismatch to its synthetic guide-RNA molecule, SHERLOCK can potentially detect SNPs with high specificity, and is also able to detect a clinically relevant range of low-frequency cancer mutations. 4 3 | SHER" LOCK" IS THE "KEY"

SHERLOCK's second version (SHERLOCKv2) has been developed and optimized. 11 In this study, Gootenberg et al 11 have unveiled the potential of SHERLOCK for the multiplexed detection of targeted nucleic acid sequences in a single reaction chamber at aM range. The multiplexed detection is achieved by optimizing the cleavage preferences of different Cas13 orthologues towards different sequences of the reporter molecule. In a system containing a pool of different Cas13 orthologues and its guide RNA, a particular target sequence could be recognized by a specific orthologue of Cas13. Cas13 orthologue would prefer to cleave a particular RNA reporter molecule, generating a specific range of fluorescence signals. 11 For improved multiplexed detection, Cas12a has been used along with Cas13 RNAse. 11 F I G U R E 1 Schematic representation of CRISPR-based diagnostic tool, in the presence of the appropriate gRNA, Cas13 recognizes the target RNA sequence that is complementary. On-target recognition, Cas13 activates its nonspecific RNAse activity that can cleave any nearby RNA sequences. In the presence of the fluorescence-quencher RNA-based reporter molecule, the catalytically activated Cas13 could cleave the reporter molecule, resultant emission of fluorescence that can be detected by spectroscopy. 10 gRNA, guide RNA Multiplexing highly specific detection of Zika and Dengue virus was achieved with synthetic doublestranded DNA and single-stranded RNA (ssRNA) molecules. 11 It has also explored for detection of P. aeruginosa and Staphylococcus aureus. The detection of target ssRNA molecules to the zetomolar (8 zM) range through scaleup of preamplification steps through RPA was also demonstrated. 11 

Amplified fluorescence signal can be obtained after the target recognition using Csm6 nuclease of CRISPR type III. Csm6 nuclease gets activated in the presence of linear adenine homopolymer with 2ʹ3ʹ-cyclic phosphate. 11 It is the nonspecific cleavage via Cas13 RNAse that leads to the formation of 2ʹ3ʹ-cyclic phosphate. 11 Csm6 being nonspecific RNAse upon activation, 13 could help to amply the fluorescence signal via homoadenine 2ʹ3ʹ-cyclic phosphate that was generated by Cas13 on target recognition. Combining this with SHERLOCK has facilitated an easy-to-use lateral flow assay that have shown an instrument free readout in the presence or absence of target sequences at concentrations as low as 2 aM within less than 90 minutes. The details of lateral flow assay have been meticulously described by Bahadır and Sezginturk. 14 Figures 3 and 4 represent an explanatory version of lateral flow assay which has been used by Gootenberg et al. 11 A combination of SHERLOCK with a paper strip lateral flow assay is able to detect non-small cell lung cancer with mutations in the epidermal growth factor receptor. As an added advantage, Csm6 in combination with SHERLOCKbased lateral flow assay gave a strong signal readout. 11 

By combining the Heating Un-extracted Diagnostic Samples to Obligate Nuclease (HUDSON) with SHER-LOCK, it is possible to detect viral nucleic acid without the extraction steps. 12 HUDSON is a protocol that uses heat treatment to inactivate the nuclease and lyse the viral particle from the body fluids. It could open a new F I G U R E 2 Schematic representation of SHERLOCK; In the presence of appropriate RPA primers, the target sequence that needs to be identified is subjected to amplification through the isothermal RPA or RT-RPA. The amplified DNA sequence obtained that is subjected to in vitro T7-transcription. The produced RNA molecule can be recognized via fluorescence signals that are generated by the reporter molecule upon target recognition by the Cas13 RNAse. 4 The cleaved reporter molecule can also be detected in the form of bands through a lateral flow assay. The inclusion of Csm6 could improve the amplification of the output signal 11 avenue for paper and fluorescence-based readouts directly from the body fluids, hosting the Zika virus at aM concentration limits and that too within less than 2 hours. 12 Additionally, this system could facilitate the detection of Dengue virus directly from the patient's blood or saliva. 12 SHERLOCK alone is capable of discriminating the different types of Dengue virus serotypes and closely related flaviviral species with less than 3.2% and 0.22% off-target fluorescence, respectively. However, Myhrvold et al 12 presented an experimental design, which is rapid and could detect the recently found SNP S139N in the Zika virus from patient samples of a 2015-2016 pandemic with paper-based readouts. 12 6 | SHERLOCK AN ATTENTION

Currently, the available nucleic acid-based diagnostic platform is sensitive but involves expensive machinery and extensive sample processing. While the antigen-based diagnostic platforms are rapid with minimal demands, 12 it comes with a set of challenges such as poor sample quality and difficulty for analyzing complex data. However, antigenbased diagnostic platforms have often found to be less sensitive and selective. 12 Identification of the causative agent of the infection either bacteria or virus is important, and if it is bacteria, then it is necessary to know its (multi)drugresistance profile. 15 SHERLOCK is a powerful, ultrasensitive and cost-effective (0.61$ per test) platform without the needs of instrument that is able to discriminate between closely related genetically and antigenically similar flaviviruses as well as serotypes of Dengue virus. 12 It is also able to sort F I G U R E 3 Schematic representation of lateral flow test strip.

Once the sample is treated with the SHERLOCK reaction mixture, the solution obtained is put on the sample pad of the lateral flow strip. The flow direction would be in the following order; sample pad, antibody conjugated gold nanoparticles (gold NP-antibody), streptavidin line, antibody capture line, and absorption pad. Antibody conjugated gold nanoparticle could bind against florescence molecule. Streptavidin forms a complex with biotin labeled reporter molecule. Antibody capture line traps conjugated antibody complex at a particular position. 11 Absorption pad helps to stop the back flow of the sample 14 F I G U R E 4 Mechanism, analysis, and interpretation of lateral flow test in the presence and absence of target sequences. 11 A, In the absence of target sequence in the sample, the reporter molecule would remain intact (1) . The intact reporter molecule would form complex with antibody-conjugated nanoparticles as well as with streptavidin (2, 3) . The formed complex cannot move further with flow as streptavidin attached to substratum restricts the flow of the complex (3). Therefore, a red colored band would appear at the streptavidin line due to nanoeffects (4) . B, In the presence of the target sequence in the sample, the reporter molecule would no longer remain intact (1) . The fluorescent molecules of lysed reporter could form complex with antibody-conjugated nanoparticles (2) while biotin would form complex with streptavidin. The antibody-conjugated nanoparticle-fluorescent molecule complex would move further and get trapped in the antibody-capture line (3). Therefore, a red colored band would appear at the antibody-capture line due to nanoeffects (4) 11 different bacteria and differentiate their antibiotic-resistant strains with exceptional sensitivity and selectivity. 4 SHER-LOCK can also detect SNPs and cancer mutations and have shown its adaptability for rapid and reliable development of new tests for recently detected Zika virus. 4, 12 So far, SHERLOCK with HUDSON has shown impressive and versatile qualities, it could definitely act as an attentionseeking tool for reliable and cheap diagnostics for infections and genetic disorders.

Overall, SHERLOCK can be further extended to have paper-based single or multiplexed readouts for detection of not just pathogens and cancers, but also genetic disorders, and many other debilitating diseases or infections. In the near future, SHERLOCK may play a vital role for early detection and diagnosis of infection during any epidemic outbreak worldwide.

This study was supported by The Puri Foundation for Education in India. Authors thank Darren Braddick, Nisarg Gohil, Happy Panchasara and Shreya Patel who have given their comments and suggestions to improve the quality of the manuscript. The authors also appreciate the anonymous reviewers of the journal for their valuable comments and suggestions to improve the quality of the manuscript.

Tropical infectious diseases: diagnostics for the developing world

Evaluating novel diagnostics in an outbreak setting: lessons learned from Ebola

List of blueprint priority diseases

Nucleic acid detection with CRISPR-Cas13a/C2c2

A programmable dual-RNA-guided DNA endonuclease in adaptive bacterial immunity

Biology and applications of CRISPR systems: harnessing nature's toolbox for genome engineering

Recent advances in CRISPR-Cas9 genome editing technology for biological and biomedical investigations

Cpf1 is a single RNA-guided endonuclease of a class 2 CRISPR-Cas system

Expanding the genetic editing tool kit: ZFNs, TALENs, and CRISPR-Cas9

Two distinct RNase activities of CRISPR-C2c2 enable guide-RNA processing and RNA detection

Multiplexed and portable nucleic acid detection platform with Cas13, Cas12a, and Csm6

Field-deployable viral diagnostics using CRISPR-Cas13

Bacterial physiology: it's never too late for CRISPR RNases

Lateral flow assays: principles, designs and labels

Novel diagnostic technologies for clinical and frontline use: advanced diagnostics based on molecular markers and analysis technologies has been improving diagnosis across a wide range of diseases

The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest.

http://orcid.org/0000-0002-6394-4370