key: cord-0730207-dqjm8ju3
authors: Krassanairawiwong, Tares; Suvannit, Chartchay; Pongpirul, Krit; Tungsanga, Kriang
title: Roles of subdistrict health office personnel and village health volunteers in Thailand during the COVID-19 pandemic
date: 2021-09-14
journal: BMJ Case Rep
DOI: 10.1136/bcr-2021-244765
sha: a689f526b781d463f913bc66901408746f832a6f
doc_id: 730207
cord_uid: dqjm8ju3

In Thailand, 40 000 subdistrict health centre (SDHC) personnel and >1 million village health volunteers (VHVs) are responsible for primary healthcare of 23 million households in 75 032 villages. They were trained, made household visits, gave hygiene advice, participated in the ‘Big Cleaning Day’ campaign, produced cloth face masks, proactively identified high-risk visitors and monitored quarantined cases. 7.4 million Thais received basic education on hygiene, 1.3 million villagers joined the campaign and 3.6 million handmade cloth face masks were produced. In March 2020, 3.9 million households were visited, and 40 000 high-risk cases were detected. The intensity of proactive case findings increased to 12.6 million home visits and 834 000 cases were detected in April 2020. Almost 800 000 cases complied with the 14-day mandatory home quarantine, of which 3.6% developed symptoms suspected of respiratory tract infection. VHVs and SDHC personnel could efficiently contribute to the prevention and control of COVID-19 in Thailand.

COVID-19 infection has rapidly spread across continents and became pandemic. 1 It is a group of emerging infectious diseases caused by RNA coronavirus and can infect both humans and other wild animals. 2 3 The novel SARS-CoV-2 causing lower respiratory tract disease was detected in humans in Wuhan, China in December 2020. [4] [5] [6] The virus has molecular similarities with SARS and the Middle East respiratory syndrome. 7 As of 1 February 2021, there were 103.69 million cases in 219 countries and territories, with 2 241 378 deaths. 8 In the absence of specific antiviral drugs or vaccines, proper preventive measures, both at an individual as well as from a societal aspect, are the prime key success factors to fight against the virus.

The first case of COVID-19 infection in Thailand, and also the first case of COVID-19 infection imported from China, was reported in January 2020. 9 10 Thailand initially ranked first among countries outside China in the number of COVID-19-infected cases. 11 It had been predicted that without proper stringent measures implemented, the number of COVID-19 infected cases in Thailand could have been as high as 400 000 cases by the end of 2021. 12 Interestingly, 1 year and a month after the country outbreak, the current number of COVID-19-infected cases in Thailand was only 19 618 cases with 77 deaths. 13 Thailand now ranks the 116th country concerning a total number of infected cases. 8 This is in contrast to many other developed and developing countries where the number of COVID-19-infected cases has been climbing up exponentially. The success in controlling COVID-19 infection in Thailand could be due to several mechanisms driven by government agencies, health authorities, academic institutes and the public.

Thailand is an upper-middle-income country in the Southeast Asian region. As of December 2019, the household income per capita was US$ 3707. The unemployment rates were between 0.75% and 0.83% during 2017-2020. With a population of 66 million and the size of the country as large as France, Thailand has a hierarchically structured healthcare system from the ministerial (national) level to the village level. Each of the 76 provinces of Thailand exclusive of Bangkok Metropolitan, has one tertiary-care provincial hospital, one secondarycare district hospital at each of 10-15 districts of each province and 1-2 subdistrict health centres (SDHCs) at each of 10-15 subdistricts of each district. The tertiary and secondary care has been provided by 1300 hospital facilities, 80% of which are government-owned. Tertiary care is provided by provincial hospitals, some of which are regarded as regional (referral) hospitals that could provide a higher level of care. Secondary care is provided by approximately 740 community hospitals that are categorised based on the number of beds (10, 30, 60, 90 and 120 or above).

In each SDHC, there are one to two community nurses, one to two public health officers, one dental care personnel and other assistants. Each SDHC is responsible for primary healthcare of 10-15 villages according to the size of the district. Each village consists of 50-100 households. There are >1 million village health volunteers (VHVs) all over the country, each of whom is responsible for primary healthcare of 10-15 households. The joint responsibility of SDHC personnel in collaboration with VHVs covers maternal and child health, vaccination programme, drug abuse, common infectious diseases like dengue haemorrhagic fever, leptospirosis, malaria, HIV, as well as non-communicable diseases including diabetes mellitus, hypertension, stroke, cardiovascular diseases and chronic kidney diseases.

Thailand has established a well-structured primary healthcare system. There were about 40 000 healthcare workers across the country (table 1), responsible for providing primary healthcare for a population of 3000-6000 on average. In addition to the healthcare workers, 1 039 729 VHVs have been proactively responsible for the primary healthcare of >23 million households locating in 75 032 villages. The VHV programme is managed and financed under the Primary Healthcare Division, Department of Health Service Support (DHSS), Ministry of Public Health. They are common villagers who volunteer to be paramedical personnel, taking care of 22.8 households per VHV. The ratios of households to that of SDHC personnel and VHVs were 621:1 and 22.8:1, respectively. The male-to-female ratio was 1:4 and the majority of them were aged 40-60 years (about one-fifth were older than 60 years). This system has been established in Thailand for more than four decades. 14 The role and achievement of VHV and SDHC personnel have been described elsewhere. 15 In brief, VHVs act as a connecting point between villagers and healthcare personnel at SDHC or district hospitals and are involved in providing primary care to each household. SDHC personnel and VHVs have been proven to be a very effective tool for grassroot primary healthcare approach on dengue haemorrhagic fever, 16 17 leptospirosis, 18 tuberculosis, 19 infant mortality, diabetes, 20 hypertension 20 and chronic kidney disease. The purpose of the report is to describe the activities of SDHC personnel and VHVs during the COVID-19 crisis in Thailand.

Since the beginning of the COVID-2019 outbreak in January 2020, DHSS has prepared the SDHC personnel and VHVs as such to be ready for controlling the spread of the infection. Owing to the presence of high-risk factors among VHVs, only 591 058 VHVs actively joined the COVID-19 prevention programme. They were assigned to make home-visit and give advice to villagers about maintaining good personal and public hygiene. They also received training on making cloth face masks and were instructed to organise public campaigns on cleanliness. The 'Big Cleaning Day' rallies were organised in the public area of each community across the country. A special registry programme was added to the DHSS's website ( www. thaiphc. net) for online registration of the assigned activities by SDHC personnel and VHVs.

The second phase occurred in early March 2020 when the number of COVID-19-infected cases in Thailand started to increase. 'Door-knocking' and 'case identification' campaigns were launched. The SDHC personnel and VHVs visited each household and advised on lifestyle changes to prevent COVID-19 infection, including eating hot food, using personal utensils during meals, frequent handwashing with soap or alcohol gel, wearing face masks, avoid smoking and alcohol drinking, and physical distancing. Also, they were assigned to identify high-risk individuals who were coming into their villages, based on the following operative criteria: (1) anyone with a fever, sore throat, persistent cough or breathing difficulty; (2) travellers from countries with confirmed COVID-19 cases (China, Hong Kong, and Macao SARs, Korea, Italy and Iran) and high-risk countries (Denmark, France, Germany, Japan, Netherland, Norway, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, UK and the USA) and (3) Thai migrant workers who had returned home from those high-risk countries during the COVID-19 pandemic period. VHVs, in collaboration with the local civil administrative body, were assigned to monitor these high-risk cases at home at least twice a week for two consecutive weeks.

The third phase was in late March 2020 when the total number of COVID-19-infected cases in Thailand had surpassed 100 

and it climbed up exponentially to reach 900 within 10 days. 21 This worsening situation prompted the Thai government to declare an emergency decree on the COVID-19 situation, being effective from 26 March until 30 April 2020. 22 A partial-yetstringent lockdown policy was implemented nationwide. During this period, the SDHC personnel and VHVs were assigned to make more comprehensive identification of the high-risk cases who entering their villages, collaborate with the village chiefs to arrange a place for self-quarantine, monitor the cases under quarantine in the villages for 14 consecutive days and report about those who were suspected of symptomatic COVID-19 infection to the village chiefs and above.

During the first phase, >7.4 million Thais (12.5% of the Thai population outside Bangkok) had received basic education on personal and household hygiene (table 1). More than 1.3 million villagers joined the Big Cleaning Day event whereas 3.6 million handmade cloth face masks were produced by the VHVs.

During the second phase, a massive exodus of labour forces from within and outside the country back to their hometown was observed. The SDHC personnel and VHVs had made about 3.9 million household visits (table 1) and detected 40 000 highrisk cases who entered their villages: individuals with a fever or respiratory tract symptoms (10 810 cases), travellers from highrisk countries (16 010 cases) and Thai migrant workers from high-risk countries (13 400 cases).

During the third phase, about 12.6 million home visits were made (table 1) , and >834 000 cases were detected: 576 972 (70%) workers who had returned home from Bangkok or other provinces, 191 436 (22%) villagers with a history of exposure to the high-risk population and 66 467 (8%) Thai migrant workers or other travellers from high-risk countries. It was by law that all newcomers into the villages must have home quarantined for 14 days. Indeed, 799 894 cases (96%) had completed these processes. About 3.6% of the surveillance cases developed symptoms suspected of respiratory tract infection and were referred to district hospitals for further investigation.

► COVID-19 pandemic has affected many low-income and middle-income countries including Thailand. ► The primary healthcare system at the community level has been well-established in many countries and could be beneficial for the prevention and control of the COVID-19 pandemic; however, research evidence and lessons learnt have been scarce. ► VHVs and SDHC personnel have a good understanding of local community dynamics and can efficiently contribute to the prevention and control of COVID-19 in Thailand.

This case stresses the importance of primary healthcare, defined as 'a system-wide approach to designing health services based on primary care, which is regarded as a means to help reduce medical expenditures and provide more effective and equitable care to populations'. 23 24 The collaborative works of SDHC personnel and VHVs simultaneously reflected at least three main primary healthcare attributes-coordination, community orientation and professional personnel. 25 Given no specific antiviral drugs or vaccines for the COVID-19 infection, maintaining good personal and public hygiene, early identification, mandatory quarantine and self-isolation of the suspected case were crucial for preventing the virus from spreading in the communities. These activities have been carried out by the SDHC personnel and VHVs in Thailand during the COVID-19 pandemic. Despite relatively limited medical knowledge, the VHVs have a good understanding of the local community dynamics. They have been proven to be effective and efficient tools in dealing with many communicable and non-communicable diseases including the current COVID-19 pandemic.

To keep the VHVs proactive, several incentives have been offered. Though at the beginning the VHVs worked for free, they had been offered a monthly salary of 600 baht (US$20) which was recently raised to 1000 baht (US$30). The VHVs usually received social recognition from the local community. Some VHVs are nominated for provincial and regional competitions; nationally recognised VHVs are entitled to prestigious awards, especially from the Thai Royal Family. Also, several leisure activities, parties and field trips sponsored by local health and non-health authorities are other types of incentives. Nevertheless, some of these incentives might be changed as a consequence of the pandemic.

Several challenges and solutions should be noted. First, the majority of VHVs received primary education, similar to the other villagers. Hence, the messages were designed to be short and poem-like in the Thai language: Kin Ron-Chon Klang-Yoo Hang-Lang Mue-Sai Nakak which means eat hot food, use a separate utensil, keep physical distance, wash hand and wear a mask, respectively. Second, face masks and alcohol gel were the basic yet essential protective equipment to be provided but they were considered scarce resources during the crisis. The face mask production skills of the VHVs would have been useless without the fabric material donated by the public in such a large quantity. Moreover, >1 million bottles of alcohol gel were donated to the VHVs and SDHC personnel by one of the largest beverage companies in Thailand. The use of face masks and alcohol gel by the VHVs not only conveyed the importance of personal and societal protection to the villagers but also promoted the selfesteem of the VHVs as role models. Third, although the Thai merits of giving had surpassed the fear of pandemic uncertainty, a special fund of 10 million baht donated by a philanthropist and another 1 million baht donated by the Bank for Agriculture and Agricultural Cooperatives was used for potential medical expenses that might incur to the VHVs who got infected from the fieldwork.

► Village health volunteers and subdistrict health centre personnel have a good understanding of local community dynamics and can efficiently contribute to the prevention and control of COVID-19 in Thailand. ► Village health volunteers could be trained to provide basic hygiene education to the villagers, produce face masks and personal protective equipment, proactively identify cases, monitor the migration in and out of the community, as well as ensure compliance to the mandatory quarantine. ► Rapid and effective implementation of prevention and control of infectious disease pandemics at a national scale is possible if the basic infrastructure has been made available.

Naming the coronavirus disease (covid-19) and the virus that causes it

Review of bats and SARS

Isolation and characterization of a bat SARS-like coronavirus that uses the ACE2 receptor

A novel coronavirus from patients with pneumonia in China

Clinical features of patients infected with 2019 novel coronavirus in Wuhan, China

The outbreak of COVID-19: an overview

Emerging coronaviruses: genome structure, replication, and pathogenesis

COVID-19 coronavirus pandemic

National community health worker programs: descriptions from Afghanistan to Zimbabwe

World Health Organization. Novel coronavirus (2019-ncov) situation report -1

World Health Organization. Novel coronavirus (2019-ncov) situation report -10

At least 400,000 infections expected

Covid-19 situation reports

Evolution of primary health care in Thailand: what policies worked?

Primary Health Care Division. The four-decade development of primary health care in Thailand

The knowledge, perception on dengue hemorrhagic fever, disease prevention control behaviors of public health volunteers

Factors related to participation of village health volunteers on dengue hemorrhagic fever prevention and control in AO luek district, krabi Province

Factors affecting leptospirosis primary preventive performance of village health volunteers (vhvs) in risk areas, roi-ei Province

The development of health volunteers' competency for tuberculosis screening in community in nam pat district, uttaradit province

Role performance about diabetes of village health volunteers: a health promoting hospital in samutprakan

World Health Organization

Ministry of Foreign Affairs. Emergency decree on public administration in emergency situation due to the outbreak of the coronavirus 2019

Contribution of primary care to health systems and health

Policy relevant determinants of health: an international perspective

Policy characteristics facilitating primary health care in Thailand: a pilot study in transitional country

Acknowledgements We and the Thais thank the subdistrict health center personnel, village health volunteers and healthcare providers at all levels for their tireless contribution to the prevention, control and management of COVID-19 in Thailand.

Contributors TK and CS conceived of the idea, collected the data. KT and KP drafted the manuscript and analysed the data. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.Funding The authors have not declared a specific grant for this research from any funding agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors.Competing interests None declared.

Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.This article is made freely available for use in accordance with BMJ's website terms and conditions for the duration of the covid-19 pandemic or until otherwise determined by BMJ. You may use, download and print the article for any lawful, non-commercial purpose (including text and data mining) provided that all copyright notices and trade marks are retained.

Krit Pongpirul http:// orcid. org/ 0000-0003-3818-9761