key: cord-0727994-t8ugtlem
authors: Yi, Stella S.; Ðoàn, Lan N.; Choi, Juliet K.; Wong, Jennifer A.; Russo, Rienna; Chin, Matthew; Islam, Nadia S.; Taher, MD; Wyatt, Laura; Chong, Stella K.; Trinh-Shevrin, Chau; Kwon, Simona C.
title: With No Data, There's No Equity: Addressing the Lack of Data on COVID-19 for Asian American Communities
date: 2021-10-23
journal: EClinicalMedicine
DOI: 10.1016/j.eclinm.2021.101165
sha: a4854b70b1f2c087452ace33490bb746c0a54946
doc_id: 727994
cord_uid: t8ugtlem

nan

1) Invest in improved, standardized data collection and reporting practices by race/ethnicity. COVID-19 has exposed our flawed data systems. At the federal level, 36% of COVID-19 deaths and 17% of COVID-19 cases are missing race/ethnicity [8] and poor quality racial/ethnic classifications is differential by race/ethnicity À with Asian Americans, Hispanics and American Indian/Alaska Natives more likely to be misclassified in administrative data [9] . Moreover, datasets routinely and indiscriminately aggregate individuals into arbitrary 'race/ethnicity' categories (e.g., no distinctions between Chinese, Filipino), limiting the ability to describe and/or intervene on specific concerns for different groups. In addition to focusing on prospective data collection, it is important to improve the quality of race/ethnicity data in existing administrative data retrospectively through the use of race/ethnicity classification algorithms. Datasets including longitudinal health outcomes could be made available efficiently in electronic health record data for example, with such strategies. 2) Place equal weight on community stories and published qualitative/quantitative literature. To create educational materials, programs and policies that meaningfully reflect community experiences, community voices need to be heard [10] . 'Community engagement' is a phrase often used, but how does it actually get operationalized? What emerged from our experience was that there was a demand for data driven approaches and community partnerships, yet the definition of data was narrowly defined as published literature or quantitative survey data À which essentially deprioritized the community narratives by design. We recommend that a redefinition of 'data' occurs, where information gathered from community listening sessions be considered equivalent À or in some cases more valuable than quantitative data. 3) Address systems-level implicit and explicit Asian American bias. Our experience also revealed that even when data are available that demonstrate disparities in Asian Americans, the data are interpreted through a lens of 'Asian American' exceptionalism. For example, even if a health outcome appears graded by race/ethnicity, as being lowest in Whites, higher in Asian Americans, and highest in Latinx and Black communities, the Asian American data are interpreted as similar to Whites as opposed to on a spectrum of risk and/or similar to the other communities of color. Asian Americans are perpetually cast as a population that does not experience health disparities in the same way that other communities of color do. Education and training are needed to mitigate the deeply embedded bias related to the 'model minority' in U.S. policy, education, and public health. One's biases play a large role in how data are interpreted or reported.

Data with poor quality race/ethnicity classifications are being used to drive funding decisions, policymaking, and resource allocation. A failure to address basic issues like accurate collection of race/ ethnicity will further limit the utility of healthcare innovations À such as artificial intelligence or machine learning, that are developed and validated in non-diverse populations, and that are devoid of community narratives. Forging Partnerships has strengthened partnerships and infrastructure, particularly around data collection and reporting, provided education on best practices in being inclusive of Asian Americans in data collection and reporting leveraging the experiences and knowledge of our multisector partners Àsmall steps towards more equitable health practices during the pandemic and beyond. 

The authors have nothing to declare.

Trends in Clinical Research Including Asian American, Native Hawaiian, and Pacific Islander Participants Funded by the US National Institutes of Health

A national health agenda for Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders

COVID's Outsize Impact on Asian Americans Is Being Ignored

Asian American Subgroups And The COVID-19 Experience: What We Know And Still Don't Know

Disaggregating Asian Race Reveals COVID-19 Disparities among Asian Americans at New York City's Public Hospital System

Death Toll of COVID-19 on Asian Americans: Disparities Revealed

Excess Deaths Associated with COVID-19, by Age and Race and Ethnicity -United States

Beyond Black and White: Mapping Misclassification of Medicare Beneficiaries Race and Ethnicity

Using Narrative Evidence to Convey Health Information on Social Media: The Case of COVID-19