key: cord-0726815-5vrk5650
authors: Khan, Aleena; Kurmi, Om; Lowrie, Richard; Khanal, Saval; Paudyal, Vibhu
title: Medicines prescribing for homeless persons: analysis of prescription data from specialist homelessness general practices
date: 2022-05-23
journal: Int J Clin Pharm
DOI: 10.1007/s11096-022-01399-3
sha: 33787860bcce09c273f746d3ba6f70294f2f2951
doc_id: 726815
cord_uid: 5vrk5650

BACKGROUND: Specialist homelessness practices remain the main primary care access point for many persons experiencing homelessness. Prescribing practices are poorly understood in this population. OBJECTIVE: This study aims to investigate prescribing of medicines to homeless persons who present to specialist homelessness primary care practices and compares the data with the general population. SETTING: Analyses of publicly available prescribing and demographics data pertaining to primary care in England. METHODS: Prescribing data from 15 specialist homelessness practices in England were extracted for the period 04/2019-03/2020 and compared with data from (a) general populations, (b) the most deprived populations, and (c) the least deprived populations in England. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Prescribing rates, measured as the number of items/1000 population in key disease areas. RESULTS: Data corresponding to 20,572 homeless persons was included. Marked disparity were observed in regards to prescribing rates of drugs for Central Nervous System disorders. For example, prescribing rates were 83-fold (mean (SD) 1296.7(1447.6) vs. 15.7(9.2) p = 0.033) items), and 12-fold (p = 0.018) higher amongst homeless populations for opioid dependence and psychosis disorders respectively compared to the general populations. Differences with populations in the least deprived populations were even higher. Prescribing medicines for other long-term conditions other than mental health and substance misuse was lower in the homeless than in the general population. CONCLUSIONS: Most of the prescribing activities in the homeless population relate to mental health conditions and substance misuse. It is possible that other long-term conditions that overlap with homelessness are under-diagnosed and under-managed. Wide variations in data across practices needs investigation. SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s11096-022-01399-3.

An estimated 280,000 people in England are known to be experiencing some form of homelessness [1] . Homelessness includes rooflessness (without a shelter of any kind, sleeping rough); houselessness (with a place to sleep but temporary in institutions or shelter); living in insecure housing (threatened with severe exclusion due to insecure tenancies, eviction, domestic violence); and living in inadequate housing (in caravans on illegal campsites, in unfit housing, in extreme overcrowding) [2] . In addition, in 2019 (i.e. prior to the COVID-19 pandemic), approximately 5,000 people slept rough on any given night in England [1] . During the first phase of the COVID-19 pandemic, an estimated 20,000 households became homeless in England [3] . However, those sleeping rough have been offered temporary accommodations such as emergency shelters and hotels during the pandemic. Findings from published literature suggest that persons experiencing homelessness (PEH) face extreme health inequalities [4] and 12 times higher mortality rates than the general population [5] . In England, males and females PEH are known to die at an average age of approximately 46 years and 43 years, respectively [6] . The majority of higher mortality is contributed by opioid overdose, accidents, heart failures and infectious diseases.

Historically, identifying healthcare and treatment needs amongst PEH has been difficult due to their secluded and unstable locations. Current epidemiological studies on the health status of PEH in the UK have tended to utilise local epidemiological datasets specific to a city, a region or a particular homelessness practice [4, 7] . The emergence of specialist primary care services has enabled accessibility of routine healthcare for PEH across the UK. At least one specialist homelessness general practice or healthcare centre currently operates in most UK cities, providing services exclusively for PEH [8] . Healthcare can also be accessed at general practices with homeless drop-in services, mobile homeless health teams, and volunteer organised healthcare days at local hostels and centres.

Currently, little is understood in regards to the prescribing of medicines to PEH in primary care. Analysis of prescribing data allows understanding of patient access to treatments and enables the development and strengthening of relevant primary care and public health prevention programmes to prevent ill health. One recently published study analysed prescribing medicines to PEH registered in mainstream general practices [9] . Medicines for mental health condition was identified to be the most frequently prescribed items. However, this study only included data of 43 patients registered with mainstream general practices. Two other studies [10, 11] ) reported prescribing activities undertaken by pharmacist independent prescribers in specialist homeless out to compare the data across a) homelessness practices, c) general populations and c) practices in the most deprived and d) least deprived CCGs using a t-test for the continuous variables. All values are reported as the number of items prescribed per 1000 population. All analyses were carried out in Stata version 16, and figures were drawn using a Microsoft Excel sheet. drugs used for ADHD, non-opioid analgesics and compound preparations, opioid analgesics, alcohol dependence, nicotine dependence and opioid dependence) and four other major BNF chapters (gastro-intestinal system, cardiovascular system, respiratory system and endocrine system). Populations and demographic data specific to each CCG were extracted from the Office of National Statistics and NHS digital databases [14, 16] . Data were extracted by one author (AK) and checked for accuracy by a second author (VP). Heterogeneity test for prescription items was carried Provides GP and Nursing clinics for homeless people, residents of hostels, asylum seekers and women working in prostitution over two practices. Additional services include a visiting ophthalmic optician, midwife appointments and a practice therapist for common mental health problems [18] .

Brighton Arch Healthcare

Provides a full range of medical service for homeless or temporary housed people, including a drug and alcohol nurse and needle exchange. The practice provides an in-reach service to local hospitals to aid the discharge and follow up care of homeless patients [17] .

A multi-disciplinary team providing care to homeless, vulnerably housed and refugees. Services also include mental health crisis service and recovery service [19] .

Oxford

A practice providing a full range of primary care services for homeless and vulnerably housed people. Services include contraception advice, screening for Hepatitis B, C and HIV, assessment/ management of mental health, alcohol detoxification, smoking cessation, and leg ulcer management. Additional services include hepatitis B vaccinations, social practitioner assistance, dental, podiatry and psychiatry clinics and acupuncture appointments [20] .

Chester St Werburgh's Practice for the Homeless Provides diagnostic and screen procedures, the treatment of disease, disorder, or injury for homeless people. It also provides smoking cessation, immunisations, and sexual health services [21] .

Cambridge Cambridge Access Surgery

Provides primary health services for homeless people and those at risk of homelessness. The practice also run drug and alcohol clinics twice weekly [17] .

Exeter

Provide healthcare services for homeless and vulnerably housed people. The practice within a wellbeing hub brings together a range of services offering help and support. This includes mental health workers, addiction treatment workers, training, and adult education [22] .

Camden Health Improvement Practice

A practice that provides primary healthcare for homeless and temporary housed people. Also provides services to people with poor mental health, alcohol, and drug addictions. Services include hepatitis and HIV screening, sexual health screening, contraception, alcohol and drug advice and food vouchers [17, 23] .

The Greenhouse Walk-in Provides healthcare service and housing and welfare advice for homeless people and those at risk of homelessness [17] .

London, Newham

Newham Transitional Practice

Delivers comprehensive primary care service to residents who have experienced difficulties registering locally with GP, including homeless people. They provide a special homeless service with several outreach nursing clinics held across Newham [24].

London, Tower Hamlets

The practice aims to provide effective and efficient healthcare service to homeless people through daily walk-in clinics. It also offers home visits, family planning, alcohol services, substance misuse and mental health clinics [25] .

Great Chapel street medical centre A flexible service combing medical care and social care by escorting patients to services for specialist interventions. Services included mental health assessment and support, family planning, vaccinations, women's and men's health [17, 26] . database, and three services had incomplete datasets and hence were excluded. A total of 15 specialist general practices were included (Table 1 ) [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] [25] [26] in this study,

The search identified 25 specialist general practices, of which seven practices were not accessible in the Openprescribing Table 3 Number of items prescribed per thousand patients per year (Non-CNS chapters). Table represents 3) < 0.001 * p-value denotes heterogeneity between means of A and B; **p-value denotes heterogeneity between means of A and C; ***p-value denotes heterogeneity between means of A and D Respiratory corticosteroids datasets were extracted (Fig. 1) . Prescriptions in specialist practices for the homeless were approximately 20% higher than in mainstream practices (Table 3 , Electronic supplement 1).

Endocrine system. Datasets for antidiabetic drugs and thyroid hormones were extracted (Fig. 1) . Fewer rates of antidiabetic medicines (x = 710.8 vs. 749.2 p = 0.826) and thyroid hormones (x = 191.3 vs. 602.2, p < 0.001) were prescribed in the PEH populations when compared to the general populations (Table 3 , Electronic supplement 1).

Infections.

The prescribing frequency of anti-infectives was higher in the PEH population than mainstream general practices (x = 313.1 vs. 267.3 p = 0.319) and compared to the practices in the most and least deprived areas of England (Table 3 , Electronic supplement 1).

This study aimed to investigate trends of medicine prescribing to PEH populations in England. Datasets from 15 specialist general practices were retrieved and analysed, representing over 20,000 patients. Results demonstrate significantly higher prescribing rates for substance misuse and mental health conditions in the PEH than in the general population. However, fewer items aimed at other long-term health conditions, including cardiovascular and endocrine conditions, were prescribed to PEH compared to the general populations, suggesting that long-term conditions amongst PEH may be underdiagnosed and/or undertreated. Undiagnosed and under-treated long-term health conditions could explain the early and higher mortality rates observed in the PEH populations [6].

There were large variations in the rates of prescribing across the specialist homelessness general practices. Differences were most notably identified for mental health conditions, where some specialist general practices prescribed specific medicines categories approximately ten times more items than other specialist practices. Local commissioning arrangements in the services, discrepancies in local guidelines and formularies such as prescription thresholds and referral to mental health teams may have influenced such variations.

The datasets represent a large sample of PEH from over 15 specialist general practices located in major urban areas representing 20,572 PEH registrants. Nearly three-quarters of all registrants were males (n = 14,642, 73%).

Prescribing data.

Central Nervous system (CNS). Specialist practices for PEH consistently showed higher rates of prescriptions for the ten CNS drug paragraphs extracted ( Table 2 ). The least deprived regions showed the lowest volume of prescribing. The most commonly prescribed items in the PEH populations were antidepressant drugs, with 4594 items per 1000 population per year. The rate was 3-fold higher than the general populations (p = 0.019) and 3 times higher than the least deprived general populations in England (p = 0.003) ( Table 2) .

Data concerning drugs related to opioid dependence showed the highest difference in prescribing rates across the PEH and the general population. The rate in the PEH (x = 1296.7 items per 1000 population) was approximately 83-fold higher compared to the general populations ( Table 2 ). Higher prescribing rates were observed for drugs for alcohol dependence (x = 50.2 vs. 2.6 per 1000 population, p = 0.161)) in PEH compared to the general population. Other BNF paragraphs which represented markedly higher prescribing rates in the PEH populations when compared to the general populations were related to drugs used in psychoses and related disorders (x = 2632.4 vs. 218.7 per 1000 population, p = 0.018), selective serotonin re-uptake inhibitors (x = 1633.9 vs. 738.5 per 1000 population, p = 0.040), and nicotine dependence (x = 114.5 vs. 13.0 per 1000 population, p = 0.051). While rates of prescribing opioid analgesics were approximately two-fold higher in the PEH population than the general population, prescribing non-opioid analgesics was similar across the two groups (Table 2) .

Cardiovascular system. Datasets were extracted for beta-blockers, calcium channel blockers (CCB), renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system (RAAS), antiplatelets and lipid-regulating drugs (Table 3 , Electronic supplement 1). Fewer items were prescribed of RAAS drugs (x = 760.5 vs. 1186.3 per 1000 population, p = 0.005), antiplatelet drugs (x = 442.7 vs. 599.2 per 1000 population, p = 0.085), lipid-regulating drugs (x = 1043.9 vs. 1378.8 per 1000 population, p = 0.086) in PEH population compared to the general populations. The rates of prescribing these drugs in PEH populations were even lower when compared to the most deprived populations in England (Table 3 , Electronic supplement 1). Gastro-Intestinal system. Prescribing data for proton pump inhibitors (PPIs) were extracted (Table 3 , Electronic supplement 1). Significantly more items per 1000 population were prescribed to the PEH population than the general population (x = 1870.2 vs. 1145.5 per 1000 populations, p = 0.019).

Respiratory system. opportunity, and they believe such care to be important [36] . In relation to acute conditions, higher prescribing rates were observed with antibiotics demonstrating their vulnerability to injuries, infections and lack of opportunity to undertake self-care [37] . In addition, poor nutrition and stress increase the risk of exposure to a range of respiratory tract infections, viruses, and diseases.

Higher rates of prescribing of medicines for substance misuse and mental health demonstrate patient and/or prescriber priorities about their healthcare needs. Optimisation of prescribed medicines is important to ensure optimal outcomes from their treatment [38] . Introduction of prescribing pharmacists and nurses and outreach-based services conducted by the primary care team are likely to promote medicines optimisation and engagement with care [39, 40] . There is a need to develop and evaluate innovative service models to encourage access to services and treatments. Innovative service models are important also in the light of the recent COVID-19 pandemic, which has led to disruption in routine care provision [41] [42] [43] and is likely to widen inequality in access to service provisions. While our study demonstrated high prescribing rates in substance misuse and mental health, promoting adherence to prescribed medicines is key to optimal treatment outcomes. Patients with a dual diagnosis of mental health and substance misuse are most vulnerable to facing homelessness [44] , and hence primary health and social care services should offer tailored services to prevent key causes and consequences of homelessness. Many PEH are excluded from primary care due to various factors such as lack of ability to navigate services, perceived stigma and discrimination in healthcare settings and wrong application of registration criteria in mainstream practices [17] . It is imperative to capture the health status of those who do not have access to any primary care services. This study used aggregated dataset at practice level and future studies should consider exploring the extent of disparity using patient level data.

Currently, most of the prescribing activities in PEH relates to mental health conditions and substance misuse. It is possible that other long-term health conditions, such as diabetes and cardiovascular diseases, may be under-diagnosed and undermanaged. Primary healthcare professionals should offer targeted and opportunistic screening and treatment for other health conditions that overlap with poverty and across England, and the general population dataset provided a robust comparison. Given the large population size and completeness of Openprescribing dataset [12] , any possibility of missing data is likely to be small and balanced across the comparison groups. Prescribing data in this study relied on registrants accessing healthcare exclusively from their specialist primary organisation. It is important to note that not all PEH have access to specialist homelessness health services, and some PEH may also be receiving services in mainstream general practices. However, previous studies have demonstrated PEH exclusion from mainstream services due to complexity in navigating services, inability to keep up appointments and perceived stigma and discrimination in practices by other patients and healthcare professionals [27] [28] [29] . These factors lead to PEH preferring to use specialist practices for their health services use. PEH are also frequent users of emergency departments and may often be excluded altogether from primary care [30] . Prescribing data was collected at a practice level, and therefore due to lack of access to patient-level data, it is important to undertake careful consideration. Large variations in prescribing rates were observed amongst specialist practices demonstrating the impact of local policies, practice level demographics, small sample size of the practices and unknown factors.

Epidemiological studies have demonstrated a high prevalence of mental health conditions and substance misuse problems [4, 7] . Causal and consequential relationships between mental health conditions, homelessness and substance misuse have been established [31, 32] . A recent systematic review showed that PEH are more likely to have a 3-fold higher risk of cardiovascular disease (OR 2.96) and 138% higher hypertension (OR 1.38) than general populations [33] . Literature suggests approximately 70% higher mortality rates in PEH due to all cardiovascular-related causes compared to the general population [34, 35] . Prescribing rates of cardiovascular drugs was observed to be lower in specialist homelessness practices in the current study compared to the general population suggesting potential under-diagnosis and under-treatment. Factors contributing to under-diagnoses and treatment can include prioritising treatment of substance misuse and mental health from patients and prescriber perspectives, asymptomatic nature of other long term health conditions, lack of holistic screening of health conditions and time constraints. In addition, long-term health and mortality compete with more immediate needs, such as obtaining adequate food and shelter. However, the literature suggests that PEH are willing to accept healthcare for chronic conditions if given the deprivation. Optimisation of prescribed treatments and promoting adherence is key to achieving favourable health outcomes.

Data statement: Openprescribing datasets are developed and maintained by the University of Oxford EM DataLab [12] . It claims to cover anonymised data about the drugs prescribed by all general practices in England. However, it is likely that some general practices may be missing in the databases, particularly the specialist homelessness practices as reported in the results section of this paper. Data are shown per 1000 populations and are adjusted for England's mid-year population size every year. The data are also normalised by drug name and classification and therefore, when drugs change their name or move across BNF chapters, it does not interfere with the analysis [45] .

The online version contains supplementary material available at https://doi.org/10.1007/s11096-022-01399-3.

Funding This study received no external funding.

Availability of data and materials All data generated or analysed during this study are included in this published article (and the supplemental materials).

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons. org/licenses/by/4.0/.

Multimorbidity and emergency department visits by a homeless population: a database study in specialist general practice

Morbidity and mortality in homeless individuals, prisoners, sex workers, and individuals with substance use disorders in high-income countries: a systematic review and meta-analysis. The Lancet

disadvantage, and patient engagement within a specialist homeless health service in the UK: an in-depth study of general practice data. BJGP Open

Mapping of specialist primary health care services in England for people who are homeless

Representation of homeless persons and coding of homelessness in mainstream general practices: a descriptive evaluation using healthcare utilisation data. BJGP (Open)

Collaborative engagement for long term conditions by clinical pharmacists for people who are homeless in

A descriptive study of a novel pharmacist led health outreach service for those experiencing homelessness

Ministry of Housing. Communities & Local Government. File 13: clinical commissioning group summaries

Clinical commissioning group population estimates (National Statistics

uk/data-and-information/data-tools-and-services/data-services/general-practice-data-hub/quality-outcomes-frameworkqof

Patients Registered at a GP Practice

Search homelessness services in England

Inclusion healthcare. Homeless GP service

European typology of homelessness ethos and housing exclusion

Homelessness in Britain is about to get much worse

Mortality among residents of shelters, rooming houses, and hotels in Canada: 11 year follow-up study

Cardiovascular disease and homelessness

Factors Associated With the Health Care Utilization of Homeless Persons

If I die, I die, I don't care about my health': perspectives on self-care of people experiencing homelessness

Current status of opioid epidemic in the United Kingdom and strategies for treatment optimisation in chronic pain chronic non-malignant pain: A systematic review

Pharmacist led Homeless Outreach Engagement and Non-Medical Independent 1 prescribing (Rx) (PHOENIx) intervention for people experiencing homelessness: a non-2 randomised feasibility study

Clinical pharmacy intervention for persons experiencing homelessness: evaluation of patient perspectives in service design and development. Pharmacy

Cancer Services During the COVID-19 Pandemic: Systematic Review of Patient's and Caregiver's Experiences

Provision of clinical pharmacy services during the COVID-19 pandemic: experiences of pharmacists from 16 European countries. Res Social Administrative Pharm

Provision of services to persons experiencing homelessness during the COVID-19 pandemic: a qualitative study on the perspectives of homelessness service providers. Health and Social Care in the Community

Scope, quality and inclusivity of international clinical guidelines on mental health and substance misuse in relation to dual diagnosis, social and community outcomes: a systematic review

Available: https://digital.nhs.uk/data-and-information/data-tools-and-services/dataservices/general-practice-data-hub/practice-level-prescribing

Publisher's Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations

Southampton Directory. Homeless Health Care Team

St Werburgh's Practice for the Homeless

Clock Tower Surgery takes residence in exciting new wellbeing hub

CHIP -Camden Health Improvement Practice

Health E1 Homeless Medical Centre. Health E1 Homeless Medical Centre

Perspectives of homeless individuals on the provision and accessibility of primary healthcare services: A qualitative study

When you are homeless, you are not thinking about your medication, but your food, shelter or heat for the night': behavioural determinants of the homeless population adherence to prescribed medicines

Relocating patients from a specialist homeless healthcare centre to general practices: a multi-perspective study

Clinical characteristics, attendance outcomes and deaths of homeless persons in the emergency department: implications for primary healthcare and community prevention programmes. Public Health

Homelessness and substance abuse: which comes first? Australian Social Work

The unhealthy state of homelessness. Health audit results

Cardiovascular disease in the homeless: a systematic review of observational and interventional studies