key: cord-0709377-896uzyvv
authors: Yar, Denis Dekugmen
title: Bacterial Contaminants and Antibiogram of Ghana Paper Currency Notes in Circulation and Their Associated Health Risks in Asante-Mampong, Ghana
date: 2020-10-08
journal: Int J Microbiol
DOI: 10.1155/2020/8833757
sha: 1910c88b8ccadaea5a54cc307dd2b6696bf23acc
doc_id: 709377
cord_uid: 896uzyvv

Transmission of pathogens through currency notes has become very relevant in today's world due to COVID-19 pandemic. This study profiled microbial flora and their antibiotic activities from Ghana paper currency (GH¢) notes in circulation in Mampong Municipal of Ashanti Region, Ghana. The study employed a cross-sectional design to assess bacterial contaminants and their antibiotic activities from January to May 2019. A total of 70 GH¢ notes consisting of 15 each of GH¢1, GH¢2, and GH¢5; 10 each of GH¢10 and GH¢20; and 5 of GH¢50 were randomly sampled from persons at different shops, canteens, and commercial drivers. The surfaces of each GH¢ note were gently swabbed, and tenfold serial dilutions made were inoculated on plate count agar (PCA), MacConkey agar, mannitol salt agar, and deoxycholate citrate agar. The study used appropriate laboratory and biochemical tests for bacterial identification. SPSS-IBM version 16.0 was used to analyze the data. Of the 70 GH¢ notes studied, 97.1% were contaminated with one or more bacterial isolates. Mean counts on PCA ranged between 3.2 cfu/ml × 10(5) and 4.7 cfu/ml × 10(5) on GH¢ notes. Of 124 bacteria isolated, 34 (27.4%), 30 (24.2%), 22 (17.7%), 17 (13.7%), 13 (10.5%), and 8 (6.5%) were from GH¢1, GH¢2, GH¢10, GH¢5, GH¢20, and GH¢50, respectively (p < 0.05). Bacterial isolates were Escherichia coli (28.23%), Staphylococcus aureus (16.94%), coagulase-negative Staphylococcus (16.13%), Klebsiella species (11.29%), Salmonella species (9.68%), Shigella species (8.87%), Pseudomonas aeruginosa (5.65%), and Proteus species (3.23%). GH¢ notes had 25.81%, 20.16%, 19.35%, 17.74%, and 16.94% from meat shops, commercial drivers, canteens, grocery shops, and vegetable shops, respectively. All bacteria were 100% resistant to erythromycin, 87.5% to tetracycline, chloramphenicol, and cotrimoxazole, 75% to vancomycin, while 87.50% sensitive to amikacin. The GH¢ notes were heavily colonized with potential pathogens, which are resistant to most commonly used antibiotics and could pose a health threat to users during commercial transactions.

Globally, paper currency notes are widely used to exchange for goods and services [1] [2] [3] . Users often contaminate these notes with several microflora including viruses, fungi, protozoan, and bacteria via unhygienic conditions and habits [1, [4] [5] [6] . Some of these practices and habits include nose-picking, coughing and sneezing on palms, applying saliva on fingers to aid notes counting, improper hand washing after using toilets, and storage of paper notes on contaminated surfaces [3, 7] .

Historically, money was strongly linked to fatal infections like the "Black Death" or bubonic and pneumonic plague pandemics [8] [9] [10] . Currency notes, therefore, serve as fomites and vehicles for the transfer of microflora from one user to another [11] [12] [13] . Infection with pathogens through contact with fomites is widespread and more serious in the era of COVID-19 pandemic. Individuals get infected by touching objects or surfaces contaminated with pathogenic microbes while touching the eyes, nose, or mouth [14] .

Infections caused by microflorae on currency notes are largely bacterial and many of them defied treatment with antibiotics [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] . Resistance to antibiotic treatment by some of these bacteria had claimed millions of lives despite huge investments and efforts to decrease the predicaments [20, 21] . is has a dire global health consequence and is incumbent to check the disease transmission and antibiotic resistance via fomites [12, 22] . Global surveillance showed there is a widespread antibiotics resistance [18, 23, 24] including drug-resistant Streptococcus pneumoniae, vancomycin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus, methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus, and multidrug-resistant Pseudomonas aeruginosa [17, 25, 26] .

In Ghana, Mobile money (M-money) and Electronic commerce (E-commerce) payments for goods and services in the informal sector is very low [27, 28] . ere is, however, a gradual use (4.8%) of M-money and E-commerce due to some perceived risk issues and service charges [29] . Other studies showed that the majority of participants preferred cash instead of M-money to pay for goods and services [30, 31] . e Ghana paper currency (GH¢) notes are constantly passed on from one user to another with dirty hands, squeezed, mutilated, and kept on contaminated surfaces [32] .

Earlier studies also reported that the GH¢ notes were heavily colonized by microflorae [1, 33] , with some being pathogenic [32] . ese notes, therefore, carried pathogenic bacteria that can infect handlers [34] and are resistant to antibiotics [35] . In Ghana, money is the most often and widely passed item from one user to another for commercial transactions. Meanwhile, pathogenic bacteria colonized our hands although adherence to effective hand washing is not observed by most Ghanaians [36] . Adherence to COVID-19 protocols among Ghanaians was found to be difficult. e mantra "to wash your hands regularly with soap and water or clean with alcohol-based hand rub" cannot be overemphasized [14] .

Infections with pathogens via fecal-oral route from fomites are rampant [37] . ere is, however, poor adherence to effective hand washing among many food vendors in Ghana [38] although cooked food is sometimes served with bare hands [39] , thus putting customers at risk of foodborne infections [40] .

ere are several studies conducted on microbial contamination on GH¢ notes mainly in major cities in Ghana. ere is, however, paucity of empirical data on bacteria and their antibiotic profile on GH¢ notes in periurban Ghana. is study examined the microbial flora and their antibiotic activities from the Ghana paper currency notes.

e study area was in the Mampong Municipal of Ashanti Region, Ghana. It is one of the twentyseven administrative districts located north of the region and shares boundaries with Atebubu-Amantin Municipal, Sekyere East, Afigya-Sekyere, and Ejura-Sekyeredumase to the north, east, south, and west [41] . e municipal is within longitudes 0.05 degrees and 1.30 degrees west and latitudes 6.55 degrees and 7.30 degrees north, covering a total land area of 2346 km 2 . e municipal capital Mampong is about 57 km from the regional capital Kumasi.

e municipal population is about 88,051, out of which 42,653 are males and 45,398 are females. Agriculture is the main economic activity within the municipal and employs about 67.3% of the entire labor force. e climate and topography of the area are conducive for agriculture [42, 43] .

is study employed a descriptive crosssectional design to assess microflora contamination on Ghana paper currency (GH¢) notes and their antibiotic activities in Mampong Municipal from January to May 2019.

e currency notes included GH¢1, GH¢2, GH¢5, GH¢10, GH¢20, and GH¢50, which are the most widely circulated denominations. A total of 70 GH¢ notes made up of 15 GH¢1, 15 GH¢2, 15 GH¢5, 10 GH ¢ 10 GH¢20, and 5 GH¢50 were randomly sampled from different sources in the Mampong township.

is study sampled only GH¢ introduced by the Bank of Ghana in 2007. e numbers of each GH¢ note were sampled based on the frequency of usage and volume in circulation.

e study used aseptic techniques to collect each GH¢ note into a separate plastic envelope bag and sealed. ese notes were collected from grocery shops, canteens, commercial drivers, butchers outlets, and vegetable shops. e notes were obtained either by exchanging fresh banknotes for old notes or through a commercial activity. e study used a week to sample each denomination to improve efficiency.

e media used were the products of Oxoid Limited, Basingstoke Hampshire, England. e study adopted the Oxoid standard protocol for media preparation except for selenite F broth. e media included plate count agar (PCA), MacConkey agar (MCA), mannitol salt agar (MSA) and deoxycholate citrate agar (DCA), Simmons citrate agar, triple sugar iron agar (TSI), selenite broth, and peptone water. Reagents were Kovacs and Remel BactiDrop Oxidase. PCA, MCA, DCA, and MSA were the media used for the total viable count, Gram-negative bacteria, Salmonella-Shigella, and Staphylococcus isolation in that order. Mueller-Hinton agar (MHA) was the medium used for the antimicrobial susceptibility test.

Processing. Each GH¢ note was given a unique identifier. Both surfaces of the note were gently swabbed with sterile cotton moistened with sterile buffered peptone water (BPW). e swabs in their respective tubes with 1 ml sterile BPW was then vortexed to get a uniform suspension. e study made tenfold serial dilutions of each suspension for cultivation and identification of microbial contaminants. e GH¢ notes swabbed for the study were later cleaned with MAK SWAB (alcohol swab).

International Journal of Microbiology

e study used 0.1 ml of each dilution, and each dilution was inoculated into the right media and incubated at 37°C for 12-48 hours. e culture plates were then examined for growth and morphologic characteristics based on standard microbiological methods. Discrete colonies were subcultured on Nutrient Agar for biochemical analysis and Gram's staining technique [44] . Electronic colony counter was then used to count the total viable colonies, and the average counts were expressed in cfu/ml [44] .

e study identified bacterial isolates using standard microbiological methods [45] . Gram's staining, colony morphology, and suitable biochemical tests were the methods used to identify bacterial isolates. For Gram-positive cocci bacteria with purple round shapes, catalase and coagulase tests differentiated staphylococci (catalase-positive) from streptococci (catalase-negative). Isolates of Gram-negative rods on MCA were further grouped into lactose and nonlactose fermenters. ese isolates were then inoculated into TSI, and indole test, citrate test, etc., were performed to aid identification [44] .

(1) Salmonella and Shigella species. Colonies from samples pre-enriched in Selenite F Broth (DifcoTM) plated onto DCA with pale or colourless colonies with or without a black spot in the middle was suggestive of Salmonella, while colonies with pink zone indicates Shigella [44] .

(2) Staphylococcus species. Colonies on MSA plates with yellow colonies with halo zone and colonies with pink with reddish-purple zones indicated Staphylococcus aureus and Staphylococcus epidermidis. Coagulase test differentiates between Staphylococcus aureus (coagulase-positive) and Staphylococcus epidermidis (coagulase-negative Staphylococcus (CNS)) [44] .

(3) Other Gram-negative isolates. All Gram-negative bacteria from MCA were subsequently inoculated in TSI and were incubated. Growth with acidic butt, acidic slant, and gas production without hydrogen sulphide (H₂S) indicated either E. coli or Klebsiella species. e two isolates were further identified by indole and citrate tests. Red ring formation on the surface of indole indicates E. coli. Blue colour change of citrate after incubation confirms Klebsiella species. An acidic butt, acidic slant, and gas production with H 2 S indicates Proteus spp. Alkaline butt, alkaline slant, no gas, and H 2 S production indicates Pseudomonas aeruginosa [44] .

Agar diffusion technique on Mueller-Hinton agar (Kirby-Bauer modified disc diffusion technique) according to CLSI guidelines [46, 47] determined the antibiotic susceptibility. e inhibition zone standards for antimicrobial susceptibility were from tables of interpretative zone diameters of Clinical and Laboratory Standards Institute [48] . e study tested 10 antibiotic discs of the most commonly used drugs to treat human and animal infections caused by bacteria. ese included erythromycin (ERY) (5 µg), ciprofloxacin (CIP) (5 µg), gentamycin (GEN) e analysis compared sources of currency notes using t-test at 95% confidence interval (p ≤ 0.05 and p ≥ 0.05), and comparison of means was done using Tukey-Kramer (Tukey's W) multiple comparison analysis.

Formal permission was sought from the municipal authorities in Mampong. is study did not collect personal data from study participants. e study, therefore, obtained only verbal consent and approval from participants before sample collection.

is study assumed that canteens, vegetable shops, butchers outlets, grocery shops, and commercial drivers were avenues in which currency notes are often exchanged and passed on from one user to another on daily basis.

3.1. Results. Out of 70 GH¢ notes examined, 68 (97.1%) had bacteria contaminants. Table 1 shows mean total bacterial counts from different denominations on different media. Mean counts ranged from 3.2 cfu/ml × 10 5 to 4.7 cfu/ ml × 10 5 on PCA, 1.7 cfu/ml × 10 4 to 8.2 cfu/ml × 10 4 on DCA, 1.2 cfu/ml × 10 5 to 2.4 cfu/ml × 10 5 on MCA, and 1.2 cfu/ml × 10 5 to 2.7 cfu/ml × 10 5 on MSA. (10.5) , and 8 (6.5%) were from GH¢1, GH¢2, GH¢10, GH¢5, GH¢20, and GH¢50, respectively (p < 0.05). Table 4 shows antimicrobial susceptibility patterns of bacteria isolated. All bacteria were 100% resistant to erythromycin, 87.5% to tetracycline, chloramphenicol, and cotrimoxazole, 75% resistant to vancomycin, 62.5% to ciprofloxacin and ampicillin, 50.0% to amoxicillin and ampicillin, while 87.50% sensitive to amikacin. 

In this study, nearly all GH¢ notes sampled had bacterial contaminants. is finding was very similar to earlier studies conducted in Ghana [51, 52] , Saudi Arabia [53] , and the United States of America [54] . Similar findings were also recorded on Iraqi currency [55] , South African banknotes [56] , Nepal banknotes [57] , and Nigerian banknotes [58] . GH¢ notes are largely used to exchange for goods and services on cash basis in the country [30, 31] with limited use of M-money and E-commence [27, 28] . e low usage of M-money and E-commence could contribute to the high microbial contamination of the GH¢ notes. is study reported high mean bacteria loads on GH¢ notes than similar studies conducted in Ghana [35, 52] and akin to earlier studies in Nigeria [15, 58, 59] . Other studies elsewhere reported high microbial loads on different currency notes that agreed with the finding in this study [60] [61] [62] . is study also reported mean counts for coliforms, Staphylococcus species, and Shigella-Salmonella species on GH¢ notes much higher than those in a similar study on the Nigerian naira [59] and other currencies [60] [61] [62] . e high bacterial load in this study could be linked to the rampant abused of the GH¢ notes especially the lower denominations which are often squeezed, mutilated, mishandled, and kept in unhygienic surfaces. e findings in this study further revealed that GH¢ notes of lower denominations were significantly more contaminated than higher notes, confirming earlier studies in Ghana and Nigeria [35, 63, 64] . Ghanaians are notorious at abusing and mishandling GH¢ notes with careless abundance and impunity. ere seems to be little regard for the lower denominations, and this may be linked to the high bacterial loads on the lower GH¢ notes. Moreover, lower GH ¢ notes are frequently passed on from one user to another in diverse economic and social activities with unclean hands, further contributing to the high contaminations [64] . Meanwhile, higher GH¢ notes are often saved in banks, more respected, and less frequently handled.

is study also reported eight different bacterial species, of which S. aureus was predominant on GH¢ notes. Previous studies recovered similar microbes from GH¢ notes, of which CNS was most prevalent [35, 63, 64] . Money is the most handled and circulated item among the public making it prone to microbial contamination with a potential to cause diseases to handlers. In this study, Escherichia coli, Salmonella spp., and Shigella spp. were pathogens recovered from GH¢ [65] . ese fecal bacteria on GH¢ are an indication of lack of effective hand washing after using washrooms [36, 66] and unhygienic practices among users [67] .

In this study, there was no link between sources of GH¢ notes and microbial contamination. GH¢ notes collected from meat shops, commercial drivers, and canteens recorded the highest numbers of bacterial isolates. GH¢ notes from meat shops were likely to be contaminated with blood, which is a good medium for bacterial growth [44, 64] . Commercial drivers often exchanged notes with passengers with unclean hands increasing the rate of contamination [1, 4, 5, 39] . Canteens are often patronized by many people where GH¢ notes are exchanged in minutes from one user to another with dirty hands [68] . GH¢ notes from canteens had all species of bacteria isolated, an indication that food vendors' hands possibly carried fecal coliforms and could lead to foodborne illnesses [39, 69, 70] . Customers with unclean hands could further increase their risk of contracting food-related diseases [71] . e prevalence of bacterial contamination was least on GH¢ notes collected from vegetable shops although vegetables are known to carry microbes [72, 73] .

is study revealed that most bacteria isolated from the GH¢ notes were resistant to the widely used antibiotics [18, 74] .

is has public health implications since these bacteria are pathogens that could easily infect users and would fail treatment with these antibiotics [75] . Moreover, many of these isolates were resistant to multiple antibiotics, which is a threat to public health in Ghana [76] . However, amikacin was the most effective antibiotic against these bacterial isolates on the GH¢ notes. An earlier study reported similar findings in Ghana [51] and other parts of the world [77] . ere is an increasing threat of antibiotic resistance due to excessive usage without prescriptions from a pharmacist [78, 79] .

is study has demonstrated that the GH¢ notes are heavily contaminated with potential bacterial isolates that are highly resistant to the most widely used antibiotics and are a threat to public health. e GH¢ notes are overly abused with dirty and unhygienic hands contaminating them with pathogenic bacteria with the potential of infecting handlers. It is highly recommended that E-commerce and M-money should be strongly promoted to save the GH¢ notes from abuse and deterioration and the users from harm. e wake of COVID-19 is a testimony for the need to limit or avoid directly handling currency notes for the public good.

e study met some difficulties obtaining GH¢ notes from the sources. e research assistants bought goods from shops to get the required denominations for the study. Some sources also suspected the team of fraud and trading in fake currencies and were very reluctant.

is study has demonstrated that the GH¢ notes are heavily contaminated with potentially pathogenic bacteria that are highly resistant to the most widely used antibiotics and are a threat to public health. e use of E-commerce and M-money is commendable to use for goods and services to minimize the abuse and deterioration of the GH¢ notes.

All data have been included in the manuscript. Disclosure e author is solely responsible for the content and does not represent the official views of the Faculty of Science and Environment Education, University of Education, Winneba.

International Journal of Microbiology 5 Conflicts of Interest e author has no potential conflicts of interest.

Microbial contamination of currency notes and coins in circulation: a potential public health hazard

Evaluation of the microbial contamination of Bangladesh paper currency notes (Taka) in circulation

A literature review on microbial contamination of paper currency

Microbial and parasitic contamination on circulating Pakistani currency

Bacterial contamination of Pakistani currency notes from hospital and community sources

Isolation and identification of microbial contamination of paper currecncy collected from local night markets in Shah Alam

Assessment of microbial contamination of Indian currency notes in Mathura City, India: a cross-sectional study

Survival of epidemic strains of nosocomial-and community-acquired methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus on coins

An assessment of oral health risk associated with handling of currency notes

Evaluating the risk of bacterial infections associated with the most handled Iraqi notes in Kalar

Microbial contamination of Nigerian currency: a potential health risk to handlers

Microbial contamination on different paper currency in

Contamination of Ethiopian paper currency notes from various food handlers with E. coli

Information about COVID-19-World Health Organization-WHO

Prevalence and antimicrobial resistance pattern of microorganisms isolated from Naira notes in Ogbomoso North, Nigeria

Coliform contamination on different paper currency in Ajmer

Multidrug resistance of isolates of methicillin resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) in paper currency notes from restaurants and hotels in Lusaka in Zambia

Bacterial contamination of Iranian paper currency and their antibiotic resistance patterns

Bacterial contamination of Nigerian currency notes circulating within selected markets in Kaduna Metropolis

e antibiotic resistance crisis: part 1: causes and threats

Contamination of currency notes with Kanamycin Resistant Shigella Flexneri

Global contributors to antibiotic resistance

Isolation and Identification of causative agents from some Iraqi Banknote currency

Emergence of global antibiotic resistance

Multidrug resistance of isolates of methicillin resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) in paper currency notes from meat sellers in

Assessment of microbial contamination of indian currency notes in circulation-an in vitro study

Mobile Money Services Adoption and Customer Behavioral Intentions in Ghana

Customer behavioural intentions towards mobile money services adoption in Ghana

Small-scale individual entrepreneurs (SIEs) and the usage of mobile money (M-money) and mobile commerce (M-commerce) in 6 International Journal of Microbiology facilitating business growth in Ghana

Assessing the Impact and Challenges of Mobile Money A Case Study of University of Ghana

Mobile money adoption and spending behaviour: the case of students in Ghana

Street foods in Accra, Ghana: how safe are they?

A study of bacterial contamination of Ghanaian currency notes in circulation

International perspectives: microbial contamination in 20-peso banknotes in

Bacterial load on Ghanaian currency notes

Hand hygiene habits of Ghanaian youths in Accra

Billetes como fómites de bacterias con potencial patógeno para el hombre

Hand hygiene practices among street food vendors

Antibiotic resistance in India: drivers and opportunities for action

Knowledge on food safety and foodhandling practices of street food vendors in ejisu-juaben municipality of Ghana

Population &Housing Census National Analytical Report of Ghana

District Laboratory Practice in Tropical Countries

Consensus statement on the adherence to clinical and laboratory standards Institute (CLSI) antimicrobial susceptibility testing guidelines (CLSI-2010 and CLSI-2010-update) for enterobacteriaceae in clinical microbiology laboratories in Taiwan

e continued value of disk diffusion for assessing antimicrobial susceptibility in clinical laboratories: report from the clinical and laboratory standards institute methods development and standardization working group

Analysis and presentation of cumulative antibiograms: a new consensus guideline from the clinical and laboratory standards institute

Antibodies: a laboratory_manual

Multicenter evaluation of colistin broth disk elution and colistin agar test: a report from the Clinical and Laboratory Standards Institute

Antibiotic resistant bacterial contamination of the Ghanaian currency note: a potential health problem

Antimicrobial resistance and molecular detection of extended spectrum β-lactamase producing Escherichia coli isolates from raw meat in Greater Accra region

Bacterial and fungal contamination of Saudi Arabian paper currency and cell phones

Bacterial contamination of paper currency

Bacterial contamination of Iranian paper currency

Microbiological analysis of banknotes circulating in the Venda region of Limpopo province, South Africa

Risk of handling paper currency in circulation chances of potential bacterial transmittance

Prevalence and public health implications of the microbial load of abused naira notes

Plasmid carriage and antibiotics susceptibility of cultivable bacteria isolated from hospital wastewater

Bacterial load and contamination of Indian currency note: isolation and Transferability studies of multi-drug resistant bacteria

Assessment of bacterial contamination of paper currency notes in Bangladesh

Microbial load and safety of paper currencies from some food vendors in Jimma Town, Southwest Ethiopia

Microbiological evaluation of naira notes handled by fish

Antibiotic susceptibility pattern of enterobacteriaceae isolated from raw meat and Ghanaian coin currencies at Cape Coast metropolis, Ghana: the public health implication

Bacterial contamination of Indian paper currency and coins

Hand washing practices among school children in Ghana

Public health implications of contamination of Franc CFA (XAF) circulating in Buea (Cameroon) with drug resistant pathogens

Food safety knowledge, attitudes and self-reported practices of food handlers in institutional foodservice in

Hygienic practices among food vendors in educational institutions in Ghana: the case of Konongo

Antibiotic resistance in foodborne bacteria

Childhood diarrheal morbidity in the Accra Metropolitan Area, Ghana: socio-economic, environmental and behavioral risk determinants

Microbial contamination, an increasing threat to the consumption of fresh fruits and vegetables in today's world

Fresh vegetables and ready-to-eat salads: sources of parasitic zoonoses in mampong-Ashanti, Ghana

Colonization, fomites, and virulence: rethinking the pathogenesis of community-associated methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus infection

Antibiotic resistance: from the bench to patients

Clinical and economic impact of antibiotic resistance in developing countries: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Antibiotic resistance and public health perspective of bacterial contamination of Nigerian currency

e threat of antimicrobial resistance in developing countries: causes and control strategies

A review on antibiotic resistance: alarm bells are ringing

Acknowledgments e author thanks Nyarko Simon who helped in the sample collection and laboratory analysis together with Mr. Kwame Adepa, the department laboratory technician, and Mr. Albert Baffour Awuah, a teaching assistant at the Department of Science Education.is laboratory analysis was supported by the Faculty of Science and Environment Education.