key: cord-0702902-20nozop1
authors: Galán, Miguel; Vigón, Lorena; Fuertes, Daniel; Murciano-Antón, María Aránzazu; Casado-Fernández, Guiomar; Domínguez-Mateos, Susana; Mateos, Elena; Ramos-Martín, Fernando; Planelles, Vicente; Torres, Montserrat; Rodríguez-Mora, Sara; López-Huertas, María Rosa; Coiras, Mayte
title: Persistent Overactive Cytotoxic Immune Response in a Spanish Cohort of Individuals With Long-COVID: Identification of Diagnostic Biomarkers
date: 2022-03-25
journal: Front Immunol
DOI: 10.3389/fimmu.2022.848886
sha: 28a7fc8ebb6419a1b70fbab480a7df3092525157
doc_id: 702902
cord_uid: 20nozop1

Long-COVID is a new emerging syndrome worldwide that is characterized by the persistence of unresolved signs and symptoms of COVID-19 more than 4 weeks after the infection and even after more than 12 weeks. The underlying mechanisms for Long-COVID are still undefined, but a sustained inflammatory response caused by the persistence of SARS-CoV-2 in organ and tissue sanctuaries or resemblance with an autoimmune disease are within the most considered hypotheses. In this study, we analyzed the usefulness of several demographic, clinical, and immunological parameters as diagnostic biomarkers of Long-COVID in one cohort of Spanish individuals who presented signs and symptoms of this syndrome after 49 weeks post-infection, in comparison with individuals who recovered completely in the first 12 weeks after the infection. We determined that individuals with Long-COVID showed significantly increased levels of functional memory cells with high antiviral cytotoxic activity such as CD8(+) TEMRA cells, CD8(±)TCRγδ(+) cells, and NK cells with CD56(+)CD57(+)NKG2C(+) phenotype. The persistence of these long-lasting cytotoxic populations was supported by enhanced levels of CD4(+) Tregs and the expression of the exhaustion marker PD-1 on the surface of CD3(+) T lymphocytes. With the use of these immune parameters and significant clinical features such as lethargy, pleuritic chest pain, and dermatological injuries, as well as demographic factors such as female gender and O(+) blood type, a Random Forest algorithm predicted the assignment of the participants in the Long-COVID group with 100% accuracy. The definition of the most accurate diagnostic biomarkers could be helpful to detect the development of Long-COVID and to improve the clinical management of these patients.

The emergent virus named severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) is responsible for the coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic , which has caused 281 million infections worldwide and more than 5.4 million deaths to date (1) . These numbers are rapidly increasing due to new emergent variants such as Omicron (2) .

The clinical outcome of COVID-19 is highly variable, ranging from asymptomatic or mild to a fatal disease. This variability is mostly dependent on how the immune system reacts during the primary infection, due to an exacerbated systemic inflammatory response that has been described in the most severe and critical forms of the disease that may lead to multiple organ dysfunction syndromes (3) (4) (5) . Those patients who develop severe or critical COVID-19 usually present bilateral pneumonia, respiratory failure with low blood oxygenation, and acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) (6) . Other organs may also be compromised, leading to nervous and cardiac system injuries that cause severe complications such as ataxia, acute cerebrovascular disease, olfactory dysfunction, blood hypercoagulability, or cardiomyopathy (7) . The median hospital length of stay for patients with severe forms of COVID-19 ranges from less than 1 week to nearly 2 months, whereas the median stay at the intensive care unit (ICU) for those patients with critical COVID-19 varies from 1 to 3 weeks, being shorter for those patients who die from the disease (8) . Those hospitalized patients who recover from the most severe forms of the disease may suffer permanent sequelae (9, 10) .

The duration of the clinical signs and symptoms may also be very variable among those patients who do not require hospitalization due to asymptomatic or mild COVID-19. In the case of short or acute COVID-19, all signs and symptoms usually disappear from 10 days to 4 weeks after diagnosis (11) . However, there is an increasing proportion of patients with mild COVID-19 in which the symptoms do not resolve completely after 4 weeks and may last up to 12 weeks after the clinical onset, then termed Ongoing Symptomatic COVID-19, or even more than 12 weeks, then termed Post-COVID- 19 Syndrome (12) . These new forms of the disease have been grouped under the term Long-COVID (13, 14) , which describes those cases in which the signs and symptoms that continue or develop after acute COVID−19 last from 4 to more than 12 weeks (12) . Long-COVID may be developed by 1 in 10 patients who passed COVID-19 (15) , and it includes both general and neuropsychiatric persistent symptoms such as cough, fatigue, muscle, and joint pains, insomnia, breathlessness, myalgia, or diarrhea. Other relevant symptoms may compromise the cardiopulmonary system, such as dyspnea, pericarditis, or heart failure (13, 16, 17) . Long-COVID may be developed not only by patients who were admitted at the ICU due to critical COVID-19 and now present long-term respiratory sequelae but also by patients with mild COVID-19 who did not require hospitalization.

The causes of Long-COVID are still uncertain, and in most cases, no clear evidence of organ damage is usually found (17) . However, some host factors such as gender and age have been related to a higher susceptibility to develop this prolonged syndrome. Women under 50 years of age seem to be more susceptible to present unresolved COVID-19 (18) , which indicates a potential role of sex hormones in Long-COVID (19) . Another plausible hypothesis could be viral persistence. Although the SARS-CoV-2 viral cycle is different, viral persistence is known to occur in other RNA viruses such as the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) or hepatitis C virus (HCV), which may produce chronic infection with sustained activation of the immune system (20) . Accordingly, prolonged viral shedding has been found in feces from patients with acute COVID-19 after negative PCR in respiratory specimens, suggesting that not only RNA of SARS-CoV-2 but also virions may persist in cells from the gastrointestinal tract (21, 22) , likely in enterocytes and small vessels, as was described for the first SARS-CoV (23) . The presence of SARS-CoV-2 in the intestinal mucosa could cause intestinal damage that, along with systemic inflammation, may increase bacterial translocation, which would play an essential role in the sustained immune activation and cytokine release syndrome characteristic of COVID-19 (24) . On the other hand, several symptoms described in individuals with Long-COVID are quite similar to those developed during autoimmune diseases such as fibromyalgia or chronic fatigue syndrome, which are also linked to persistent inflammation and exacerbated immune responses (25) . Individuals with COVID-19 may develop autoantibodies against tissue-associated antigens and immunomodulatory proteins, both soluble such as interferon (IFN) type I or bound to the surface of the immune cells, which would also promote the persistence of the symptoms (26, 27) .

In summary, the recovery from COVID-19 seems to be beyond hospital discharge or testing negative for SARS-CoV-2 (28), but the causes for the subsequent perpetuation of the symptoms are still undetermined. To define the clinical guidelines for the prevention, diagnosis, follow-up, and rehabilitation of these individuals, it is necessary to gain a better understanding of the underlying mechanisms of Long-COVID. Our group previously determined that an inefficient cytotoxic response is a reliable biomarker for COVID-19 severity (4) . Consequently, in this study, we evaluated the relative importance of this impaired cellular immune response, along with several demographic and clinical features, to develop the persistence of the symptoms and the evolution to Long-COVID by using a Random Forest algorithm.

Blood samples from 50 individuals who had passed mild, symptomatic COVID-19 during the first pandemic peak in Madrid (Spain) (March-April 2020) were collected in the Primary Healthcare Center Doctor Pedro Laıń Entralgo (Madrid, Spain). The inclusion criteria were as follows: over 18 years old, have a positive RT-qPCR assay for SARS-CoV-2 in nasopharyngeal smear or positive titers of virus-specific IgG, and did not require hospitalization while with COVID-19. The subjects were subsequently classified into Long-COVID (n = 30) and Recovered (n = 20). The Long-COVID group included those individuals who had passed mild COVID-19 and referred the presence of at least 8 clinical signs and symptoms compatible with Ongoing Symptomatic COVID-19 or Post-COVID- 19 Syndrome according to the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) guideline (12) for at least 4 to 12 weeks or more than 12 weeks after the clinical diagnosis of COVID-19. Individuals with Long-COVID were recruited in collaboration with the non-profit Spanish Association of Patients with Long-COVID (Long-COVID-ACTS, Madrid, Spain). The Recovered group included those individuals who had passed acute COVID-19, were homebound until medical discharge, and had the resolution of all signs and symptoms 2 to 4 weeks after the clinical diagnosis. Re-infection or vaccination previous to sampling was not reported by any participant. The most relevant clinical data of all participants with Long-COVID or completely recovered are described in Supplementary Tables 1, 2, respectively.

The individuals participating in this study were recruited at the Primary Healthcare Center Doctor Pedro Lain Entralgo (Alcorcón, Madrid, Spain). All participants gave informed written consent to participate, and their anonymity was ensured by the current Spanish and European Data Protection Law. This study was conducted following the Declaration of Helsinki, and it was approved by the Ethical Committee of Instituto de Salud Carlos III (IRB IORG0006384) (CEI PI 07_2021) and the Central Research Commission from the Health Counseling (Comunidad de Madrid, Spain) (favorable report 20210008).

Peripheral blood lymphocytes (peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs)) and plasma were isolated from blood samples by centrifugation through Ficoll-Hypaque gradient (Pharmacia Corporation, North Peapack, NJ, USA) and cryopreserved until the moment of analysis. Due to the low quantity of samples, not all the parameters could be determined in all participants. K562 cell line (ECACC 89121407) was kindly provided by Dr Cristina Eguizabal (Basque Centre Transfusions and Human Tissue, Álava, Spain), and Vero E6 (African green monkey kidney) cell line (ECACC 85020206) was kindly provided by Dr. Antonio Alcami (CBM Severo Ochoa, Madrid). For intracellular staining of IFNg, TNFa and granzyme B (GZB) in CD3 + CD8 + T cells, PBMCs were treated for 4 h at 37°C with PepMix ™ SARS-CoV-2 (NCAP) (JPT Peptide Technologies, Berlin, Germany), which contains 102 peptides derived from the Nucleoprotein of SARS-CoV-2, to stimulate the cytotoxic activity of CD8 + T cells, in the presence of brefeldin A (BD Biosciences). Cells were then stained with anti-CD3-APC and anti-CD8-PercP. After fixation and permeabilization with IntraPrep Permeabilization Reagent (Beckman Coulter, Brea, CA, USA), cells were stained with antibodies against IFNg-PE, TNFa-PE, and GZB-FITC (BD Biosciences) and then acquired and analyzed in a BD LSRFortessa X-20 flow cytometer (BD Biosciences) using FACS Diva (BD Biosciences) and FlowJo_V10 software (TreeStar).

Viral RNA was extracted from the blood samples of all participants of the Long-COVID group using the QIAamp MinElute Virus Kit (Qiagen Iberia, Madrid, Spain). The presence of RNA of SARS-CoV-2 was determined in the blood of all participants in this study following the protocol previously described (29) , which is part of the Interim Guidance of the WHO for the diagnostic testing of SARS-CoV-2 (30). encoding G614 SARS-CoV-2 S glycoprotein (QHU36824.1) without the last 19 amino acids (32) was cloned into pcDNA3.1 expression vector (4) . A mutant clone introducing D614G change was generated by site-directed mutagenesis due to D614 viruses being the majority of the earliest variants detected in Spain within clade 19B (33) . A monolayer of Vero E6 was infected with identical amounts of both D614 and G614 pseudoviruses (100 ng p24/Gag per p48 well). After 48 h of incubation, Vero cells were cocultured for 1 h with PBMCs isolated from the blood of individuals from our cohort (1:2). Caspase-3 activity was measured in the monolayer as an indicator of cellular cytotoxicity by using the Caspase-Glo 3/7 Assay system (Promega, Madison, WI, USA).

K562 cells that do not express the Major Histocompatibility Complex (MHC) class I molecules on the cell surface (missing self) were used as classical targets of NK cells to evaluate their cytotoxic activity as previously described (4) . Briefly, K562 cells were stained with PKH Red Fluorescence Cell Linker kit (Sigma-Aldrich Merck, Darmstadt, Germany) and then cocultured with PBMCs (1:2). After 1 h, they were collected and stained with Annexin V conjugated with fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC) (Thermo Fisher, Waltham, MA, USA) to quantify early apoptosis by measuring the expression of phosphatidylserine on the cell surface by flow cytometry. BD LSRFortessa X-20 flow cytometer and FACS Diva software were used for data acquisition, and FlowJo_V10 software was used for data analysis.

A Random Forest algorithm (34) was applied to evaluate the accuracy of those demographic, clinical, and immunological parameters that showed significant differences (p < 0.05) in the comparison with the Recovered group to predict the predisposition to develop Long-COVID. The selected parameters were as follows: demographic factors: female gender and O + blood type; clinical factors: lethargy, pleuritic chest pain, dermatological injuries, mean body temperature, dyspnea, diarrhea, conjunctivitis, previous autoimmune diseases, and treatments during COVID-19 such as corticosteroids, antibiotics, and/or vitamin D; immune response factors: total NK cells (CD56 + ), CD3 − CD56 + CD16 + , CD56 + NKG2A − NKG2C + , and CD56 + CD57 + NKG2C + subpopulations; CD3 + PD-1 + ; total CD8 + T cells, CD8 + TEMRA, and CD8 ± TCRgd + subpopulations; CD4 + Tregs; and cytotoxic activity against NK target cells K562 and/or SARS-CoV-2 infected Vero E6 cells. A nested 5-fold cross-validation procedure for each competing algorithm was performed in order to avoid bias in the selection of training, testing, and validation sets, as previously described (35, 36) . The relative importance for each feature in the categorization of patients was calculated by using the Gini Variable Importance Measure (VIM) method (37) .

Statistical analysis was performed using Graph Pad Prism 8.0 (Graph Pad Software Inc., San Diego, CA, USA). Quantitative variables were represented as the mean and standard error of the mean (SEM), and significance was analyzed using the unpaired, non-parametric Mann-Whitney test to compare between both Long-COVID and Recovered groups. Qualitative variables were represented as percentages, and significance was analyzed using Fisher's exact test. p-Values (p) <0.05 were considered statistically significant in all comparisons.

Fifty individuals who passed natural infection by SARS-CoV-2 previous to vaccination were recruited for this study. They were assigned to the Long-COVID group if they showed persistent clinical signs and symptoms from 4 to more than 12 weeks after diagnosis (n = 30), or to the Recovered group if they had resolved all signs and symptoms of COVID-19 in the first 4 weeks after diagnosis. The main demographic and clinical characteristics of all participants are summarized in Tables 1, 2 and detailed in  Supplementary Tables 1, 2 . Most individuals in the Long-COVID group (86.6%) were female, whereas 55% of the participants in the Recovered group were female (p = 0.0205). Median age at SARS-CoV-2 acute infection in the Long-COVID and Recovered groups was 42 (interquartile range (IQR) 37-46) and 45 years (IQR 28-57), respectively. Median time from the clinical onset to sampling was 49.7 weeks or 348 days (IQR 150-369 days) in the Long-COVID group versus 11.8 weeks or 83 days (IQR 73-99 days) in the Recovered group. Median length with signs and symptoms compatible with Long-COVID at sampling was 49.7 weeks or 348 days (IQR 150-369 days) and 1.8 weeks or 13 days (IQR 0-49 days), respectively. The most frequent Rh blood group was A + in both cohorts, whereas O + was present in 36.6% of the individuals from the Long-COVID-19 group and 5% from the Recovered group (p = 0.0160). During COVID-19, individuals from the Long-COVID group reported 38.2°C (± 0.66) of recurrent peaks of fever, in comparison with 37.7°C (± 0.18) of peak fever during the first 10 days postinfection in participants from the Recovered group (p = 0.0156). Dyspnea was developed by the majority of participants from the Long-COVID group (86.6%) and 35% of individuals from the Recovered group (p = 0.0002), whereas pleuritic chest pain was present in 76.6% and 25% of the individuals, respectively (p = 0.0005). Additional signs and symptoms with statistical significance reported by individuals from the Long-COVID group, in comparison with individuals from the Recovered group, were lethargy (80%, p < 0.0001), diarrhea (73.3%, p = 0.0037), dermatological injuries (63.3%, p = 0.0003), and conjunctivitis (30%, p = 0.0073). Most participants from the Recovered group did not receive any drug for the treatment of COVID-19, whereas individuals from the Long-COVID group mostly received antibiotics (70%, p = 0.0012), corticosteroids (50%, p < 0.0001), and/or cholecalciferol/vitamin D (40%, p < 0.0001). The most prevalent comorbidities in the group of Long-COVID were autoimmune diseases (30%, p = 0.0366), including psoriasis, rheumatoid arthritis, Hashimoto's thyroiditis, mixed connective tissue disease (MCTD), and Raynaud's disease, versus 

We did not find differences in the levels of total peripheral CD4 + T cells ( Figure 1A ) or the composition of CD4 + memory subpopulations between both Long-COVID and Recovered groups ( Figure 1B) . The total level of lymphocytes (CD3 + ) expressing the immune exhaustion marker PD-1 on the cell surface was increased 1.5-fold in the Long-COVID group, and this difference nearly reached statistical significance (p = 0.0506) ( Figure 1C) . The level of regulatory T cells (Tregs) (CD4 + CD25 + CD127 low ) was significantly increased 2.5-fold in the individuals from the Long-COVID group (p = 0.0007), in comparison with the Recovered group ( Figure 1D ). The flow cytometry gating strategy is shown in Supplementary Figure 1 .

Total levels of CD8 + T cells were increased 1.5-fold in the Long-COVID group, in comparison with the Recovered group (p = 0.0005) (Figure 2A) . We also observed changes in the Figure 2B ). Regarding the highly cytotoxic CD3 + T cells with TCRgd, both CD8 + TCRgd + and CD8 − TCRgd + populations were increased 2.0-fold (p = 0.049) and 2.2-fold (p = 0.005), respectively, in the Long-COVID group in comparison with the Recovered group ( Figure 2C ). Stimulation of PBMCs with a pool of nucleoprotein peptides from SARS-CoV-2 showed no significant differences in the capacity of CD8 + T cells to release pro-inflammatory cytokines such as IFNg and TNFa, as well as the serine protease GZB, between individuals with Long-COVID and the Recovered participants ( Figure 2D ). The flow cytometry gating strategy is shown in Supplementary Figure 2 .

The total levels of NK cells, characterized by the expression of the activation marker CD56, were increased 1.7-fold (p = 0.0005) in the Long-COVID group, in comparison with the Recovered group ( Figure 3A) . No significant differences were found in the expression of the immune exhaustion marker PD-1 in NK cells between both groups ( Figure 3B ). The population of NK cells expressing CD16 marker on the surface (CD3 − CD56 + CD16 + ) was increased 1.7-fold (p = 0.032) in the Long-COVID group ( Figure 3C , left graph), but no significant differences were found regarding the expression of the degranulation marker CD107a + in this population ( Figure 3C , right graph). There were no statistically significant differences either between both groups in NK cells not expressing CD16 marker ( Figure 3D ) or in NKT cell populations ( Figures 3E, F) . The flow cytometry gating strategy is shown in Supplementary Figure 3 .

NK cell subpopulation expressing the activation marker NKG2C (CD56 + NKG2A − NKG2C + ) was increased 1.4-fold (p = 0.0149) in the Long-COVID group, in comparison with the Recovered group ( Figure 4A , left graph), whereas no significant differences were found between both groups in the NK subpopulation with the inhibitory markers NKG2A (CD56 + NKG2A + NKG2C − ) ( Figure 4A , middle graph) or KIR2DL5/CD158f ( Figure 4A , right graph). There were no differences in the total levels of NK cells with the memory marker CD57 between both groups ( Figure 4B , left graph), but the population of activated memory NK cells (CD56 + CD57 + NKG2C + ) was increased 1.5fold (p = 0.044) in the Long-COVID group, in comparison with the Recovered group ( Figure 4B , right graph). The flow cytometry gating strategy is shown in Supplementary Figure 4 .

The cytotoxic activity of PBMCs from the individuals of the Long-COVID group against the classical target of NK cells K562 was increased 2.3-fold (p < 0.0001), in comparison with the Recovered group ( Figure 5A) . The cytotoxic activity of PBMCs was also tested against Vero E6 cells infected with pseudotyped SARS-CoV-2. The activation of caspase-3 was increased 1.7-fold (p = 0.0092) in the monolayer when they were cocultured with PBMCs from individuals of the Long-COVID group, in comparison with the Recovered group ( Figure 5B ).

All individuals from the Long-COVID group showed an absence of detection of RNA from SAR-CoV-2 in blood, except for one individual (Patient ID 26; see Supplementary Table 1 ) (3.33%) who showed amplification of RNA in blood at cycle threshold (CT) 32.97 (data not shown).

An accuracy of 94% ± 4.90% was obtained for the 5 iterations of the outer loop of the nested K-fold cross validation for each competing algorithm ( Figure 6A) . As a result, all 30 patients (100%) in the Long-COVID group were correctly assigned to this group, whereas 17 individuals of 20 (85%) were correctly assigned to the Recovered group ( Figure 6B) . The Gini VIM method determined that clinical parameters such as lethargy, pleuritic chest pain, dermatological injuries, treatment with corticosteroids, immune factors (such as enhanced total levels of NK cells, CD8 + T lymphocytes, and Tregs), and increased cytotoxic activity were the most important variables to assign the individuals to the Long-COVID group ( Figure 6C) , whereas demographic parameters such as female gender and O + blood type, or previous history of autoimmune disease, were within the variables with less importance.

Long-COVID is emerging as a new relevant syndrome worldwide that is characterized by the maintenance of longterm signs and symptoms of COVID-19 that are not resolved in the first 4 weeks after the infection (12) . Several host and viral factors may be involved in the development of Long-COVID, although the underlying basic mechanisms are still unknown. To determine the most important host factors that could be used as diagnostic parameters to evaluate the development of Long-COVID, we collected and analyzed essential demographic, clinical, and immunological characteristics in a Spanish cohort of individuals with signs and symptoms compatible with Long-COVID in comparison with individuals who recovered completely before 4 weeks after the infection. A Random Forest algorithm was applied to identify the most important variables to predict the susceptibility to develop Long-COVID.

Regarding the host factors that might be related to Long-COVID, some demographic characteristics such as age and gender have been appointed as contributing host factors for an increased susceptibility (11, 19, 38) . Before the general vaccination against COVID-19, most patients admitted to the ICU due to a critical form of the disease were usually men over 65 years old (39) . In contrast, most participants in our cohort of Long-COVID were women under 45 years old, which is in accordance with previous studies (18, 40) . Rh blood O + type was also significantly more frequent in the individuals of the Long-COVID group, but we cannot rule out that most Spanish populations present this blood type (41) . Although it has been reported that individuals with Rh − blood type may be at lower risk of SARS-CoV-2 infection and development of severe illness or death by COVID-19 (42, 43) , other studies did not find a significant impact of Rh on COVID-19 severity (44, 45) . In our study, according to the Random Forest analysis, both female gender and Rh blood type were within the less important possible diagnostic factors for Long-COVID. However, clinical signs and symptoms such as persistent lethargy, pleuritic chest pain, and recurrent dermatological injuries showed more relative importance for the prediction of higher susceptibility to Long-COVID. Considering the potential viral factors that might be involved in the development of Long-COVID, one hypothesis that should be taken into account is that SARS-CoV-2 might find mechanisms to persist in the organism after the acute infection. In this case, Long-COVID syndrome would be a consequence of an unresolved SARS-CoV-2 infection (46) . A prolonged SARS-CoV-2 viral shedding in feces has been described several months after the COVID-19 diagnosis (21, 47) . This suggests that SARS-CoV-2 may persist in sanctuaries such as the epithelial cells of the gastrointestinal tract or the tissue macrophages in the gut-associated lymphoid tissue (GALT) (48, 49) , which would explain not only the continuous viral shedding but also the gastrointestinal symptoms developed by individuals with Long-COVID (50) . In fact, alterations in the gut microbiota have been described in individuals with Long-COVID even 6 months after the infection (51) . We cannot rule out this possibility in our cohort, as at least 70% of individuals with Long-COVID had been treated with broad-spectrum antibiotics. However, SARS-CoV-2 could also persist in other anatomical sanctuary organs with immune privilege such as the central nervous system (CNS) (52) or in other organs and cells in which ACE2 receptor is highly expressed such as the intestine, kidneys, cardiac tissue, reproductive system, thyroid, gallbladder, and nasal mucosa (53, 54) , which would also explicate the highly variable signs and symptoms that are associated with Long-COVID (55) . The persistence of SARS-CoV-2 in the organism Total levels of NK cell subpopulation CD56 + CD16 + over CD3 − population or with the degranulation marker CD107a over this population CD3 − CD56 + CD16 + (C) and total levels of NK cell subpopulation CD56 + CD16 − over CD3 − population or with the degranulation marker CD107a over this population CD3 − CD56 + CD16 − (D) were also analyzed by flow cytometry. Analysis by flow cytometry of the total levels of NKT cell subpopulation CD56 + CD16 + over CD3 + population or with the degranulation marker CD107a over this population CD3 + CD56 + CD16 + (E) and total levels of NKT cell subpopulation CD56 + CD16 − over CD3 + population or with the degranulation marker CD107a over this population CD3 + CD56 + CD16 − (F). Each dot in the graphs corresponds to one sample, and lines represent mean ± SEM. Statistical significance was calculated using nonparametric Mann-Whitney test. PBMCs, peripheral blood mononuclear cells. would also correlate with the recurrent peaks of fever reported by the participants from the Long-COVID group, which was significantly increased at 0.5°C in comparison with the individuals from the Recovered group, in which the fever stopped once the infection was resolved. Although more studies will be necessary to determine whether the virus may be found in the feces of these individuals, low SARS-CoV-2 viremia was detected in one participant from the Long-COVID group (Patient ID 26). This participant was a 44-year-old woman, A + , with previous history of asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) who was treated with azithromycin during the first days after COVID-19 diagnosis, had signs and symptoms compatible with Long-COVID at the time of sampling (21.4 weeks post-infection), and did not report a subsequent re-infection after the first exposure to SARS-CoV-2. She informed about persistent neurological symptoms and diarrhea, which would support the possibility of a viral persistence in the CNS or in the GALT, with occasional viremia. The persistence of SARS-CoV-2 or its viral products in the organism would then contribute to the increased antiviral, cytotoxic activity detected in individuals from the Long-COVID group, along with the associated gastrointestinal symptoms, which were likely also due to the presence of activated immune cells in the GALT (56) . Persistent epithelial damage due to a chronic inflammatory response has been appointed as a possible cause of Long-COVID (57) . It is noteworthy that patients with critical COVID-19 who are admitted to the ICU usually present CD4 + cytopenia (4, 58) , which makes it difficult to develop a complete, effective immune response against SARS-CoV-2. However, the individuals from the Long-COVID group in our study showed not only normal levels of CD4 + T cells in peripheral blood but also CD8 + lymphocytosis with an increased proportion of TEMRA cells, which are highly differentiated effector cells essential for CD8 + function (59) . This enhanced terminal differentiation of memory CD8 + T cells pointed at the presence of a potent antiviral immune response that was supported by the presence of increased levels of highly cytotoxic populations of CD8 ± T lymphocytes expressing TCRgd. These cells have been related to a potent antiviral and antineoplastic response, and therefore, they are currently the target of different strategies to reprogram their cytotoxic potential against specific targets such as viruses or cancerous cells (60, 61) . Although the capacity of CD8 + T cells to produce pro-inflammatory cytokines and GZB was not significantly different between individuals with Long-COVID and those who completely recovered, the sustained presence of these cytotoxic cell populations from the adaptive immune system indicated that the participants from the Long-COVID group had developed a potent memory response against SARS-CoV-2 that was still fully active after more than 49 weeks postinfection, whereas this response had waned in the Recovered group once the infection was cleared. The increased expression of exhaustion markers such as PD-1 in CD3 + T lymphocytes from these individuals of the Long-COVID group could be a consequence of the continuous activation of the immune system. The PD-1/PD-L1 axis is upregulated during acute viral infection and after infection with persistent RNA viruses such as HIV and HCV, and it has been related to viral evasion of the immune system and prolonged inflammatory responses (62) . Moreover, the significant increase of Tregs observed in PBMCs from individuals of the Long-COVID group may indicate the failed attempt of the immune system to control this persistent immune response.

The long-term activation of the immune system in response to triggers such as pathogens, vaccines, drugs, or chemicals has been previously related to the development of autoimmune diseases due to the loss of tolerance (63) . The link between the development of autoimmunity and a previous infection is not always clear, as occurs with common autoimmune diseases such as lupus erythematosus, multiple sclerosis, type 1 diabetes mellitus, and rheumatoid arthritis. However, the discovery of autoantibodies in individuals with Long-COVID may link this syndrome not only to a persistent viral infection but also to an immune dysregulation that would lead to a sustained targeting of own cells (26, 64) . The detection of high levels of functional cytotoxic memory cells in peripheral blood of the participants from the Long-COVID group may explain why several signs and symptoms of this syndrome resembled those of an autoimmune disease. Some previous predisposition may be then contributing since the most prevalent comorbidities showed by these individuals were autoimmune diseases, although they were not considered within the most accurate diagnostic biomarkers for Long-COVID in our Random Forest model. However, the hypothesis that a persistent memory cytotoxic response against SARS-CoV-2 could be the cause for the development of Long-COVID was supported in our cohort by the presence not only of high levels of CD8 + TEMRA cells but also of NK cells expressing both memory (CD57) and activation (NKG2C) markers that did not waste and wane after SARS-CoV-2 infection was cleared, despite the presence of high levels of Tregs. Moreover, these immunological factors were considered the most important variables for the prediction of a higher susceptibility to develop Long-COVID in our Random Forest model.

The difference in the median time from the clinical onset to sampling in the Long-COVID group versus the Recovered group could be considered a potential limitation of our study. However, all participants were infected with SARS-CoV-2 during the same period of time that was the first pandemic peak in Spain (March to April 2020), and whereas all signs and symptoms of COVID-19 were completely resolved at the time of sampling (12 weeks postinfection) in all participants of the Recovered group, the individuals of the Long-COVID group still presented recurrent signs and symptoms of the disease more than 49 weeks post-infection. Therefore, all inclusion criteria were met in both groups.

In conclusion, Long-COVID syndrome could be the consequence of a long-lasting memory cytotoxic immune response that had been triggered by SARS-CoV-2, or its viral products are hidden in some anatomical sanctuaries such as the CNS or tissue macrophages in the GALT, where it would be protected from clearance by the immune system. However, we also have to consider that Long-COVID shows characteristics of autoimmune disease and that infected individuals may be more susceptible to developing this syndrome due to the activation of an exacerbated memory immune response that cannot be adequately controlled by homeostatic mechanisms once the infection was cleared. Having a better understanding of the underlying mechanisms of Long-COVID could be helpful to prevent the development of this syndrome and to improve the clinical management of these patients. According to our Random Forest model, 100% of the participants included in the Long-COVID group were correctly assigned to this group using parameters related to long-lasting cytotoxicity, which proved their validity as biomarkers to diagnose the development of this syndrome. 

The original contributions presented in the study are included in the article/Supplementary Material. Further inquiries can be directed to the corresponding authors.

The studies involving human participants were reviewed and approved by the Ethical Committee of Instituto de Salud Carlos III (IRB IORG0006384) (CEI PI 07_2021) and the Central Research Commission from the Health Counseling (Comunidad de Madrid, Spain) (favorable report 20210008). The patients/participants provided their written informed consent to participate in this study.

COVID-19) Dashboard. Available at

Omicron Variant Genome Evolution and Phylogenetics

Epidemiological and Clinical Characteristics of 99 Cases of 2019 Novel Coronavirus Pneumonia in Wuhan, China: A Descriptive Study

Impaired Cytotoxic Response in PBMCs From Patients With

Admitted to the ICU: Biomarkers to Predict Disease Severity

A Review of Persistent Post-COVID Syndrome (PPCS)

Clinical Predictors of Mortality Due to COVID-19 Based on an Analysis of Data of 150 Patients From Wuhan, China

Late Complications of COVID-19; a Systematic Review of Current Evidence

COVID-19 Length of Hospital Stay: A Systematic Review and Data Synthesis

More Than 50 Long-Term Effects of COVID-19: A Systematic Review and Meta

Complication and Sequelae of COVID-19: What Should We Pay Attention to in the Post-Epidemic Era

Attributes and Predictors of Long COVID

COVID-19 Rapid Guideline: Managing the Long-Term Effects of COVID-19

Management of Post-Acute Covid-19 in Primary Care

Covid-19: What do We Know About "Long Covid

World Health Organization RO for E. New Policy Brief Calls on Decision-Makers to Support Patients as 1 in 10 Report Symptoms of "Long COVID

COVID-19 Cardiac Injury: Implications for Long-Term Surveillance and Outcomes in Survivors

Persistent Symptoms After Covid-19: Qualitative Study of 114 "Long Covid" Patients and Draft Quality Principles for Services

Long Covid in Adults Discharged From UK Hospitals After Covid-19: A Prospective, Multicentre Cohort Study Using the ISARIC WHO Clinical Characterisation Protocol

Long COVID Risk -a Signal to Address Sex Hormones and Women's Health

Viral (Hepatitis C Virus, Hepatitis B Virus, HIV) Persistence and Immune Homeostasis

Prolonged Viral Shedding in Feces of Pediatric Patients With Coronavirus Disease

Persistent SARS-CoV-2 Nucleocapsid Protein Presence in the Intestinal Epithelium of a Pediatric Patient 3 Months After Acute Infection

Tissue and Cellular Tropism of the Coronavirus Associated With Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome: An in-Situ Hybridization Study of Fatal Cases

Intestinal Permeability Changes With Bacterial Translocation as Key Events Modulating Systemic Host Immune Response to SARS-CoV-2: A Working Hypothesis

Inflammatory Responses and Inflammation-Associated Diseases in Organs

Diverse Functional Autoantibodies in Patients With COVID-19

Autoantibodies Against Type I IFNs in Patients With Life-Threatening

A Negative COVID-19 Test Does Not Mean Recovery

Detection of 2019 Novel Coronavirus

Diagnostic Testing for SARS-CoV-2. Interim Guidance 2020

A New Strategy Based on Recombinant Viruses as a Tool for Assessing Drug Susceptibility of Human Immunodeficiency Virus Type 1

Characterization of Spike Glycoprotein of SARS-CoV-2 on Virus Entry and its Immune Cross-Reactivity With SARS-CoV

A Founder Effect Led Early SARS-CoV-2 Transmission in Spain

Random Forests

PhenotypeSimulator: A Comprehensive Framework for Simulating Multi-Trait, Multi-Locus Genotype to Phenotype Relationships

Random Forest Algorithm for the Classification of Neuroimaging Data in Alzheimer's Disease: A Systematic Review

The Revival of the Gini Importance?

Female Gender is Associated With Long COVID Syndrome: A Prospective Cohort Study

The Coronavirus is Most Deadly If You are Older and Male -New Data Reveal the Risks

Co-Occurrence, and Evolution of Long-COVID Features: A 6-Month Retrospective Cohort Study of 273,618 Survivors of COVID-19

ABO and Rh Blood Groups in Spain

Association Between ABO and Rh Blood Groups and SARS-CoV-2 Infection or Severe COVID-19 Illness

Associations Between Blood Type and COVID-19 Infection, Intubation, and Death

ABO Phenotype and Death in Critically Ill Patients With COVID-19

Relationship Between Blood Type and Outcomes Following COVID-19 Infection

Long COVID or Post-Acute Sequelae of COVID-19 (PASC): An Overview of Biological Factors That May Contribute to Persistent Symptoms

Detection of SARS-CoV-2 by RT-PCR in Anal From Patients Who Have Recovered From Coronavirus Disease

Little to No Expression of Angiotensin-Converting Enzyme-2 on Most Human Peripheral Blood Immune Cells But Highly Expressed on Tissue Macrophages

Persistent Cytotoxic Response in Long-COVID

SARS-CoV-2 Productively Infects Human Gut Enterocytes

Global Prevalence of Prolonged Gastrointestinal Symptoms in COVID-19 Survivors and Potential Pathogenesis: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Gut Microbiota Dynamics in a Prospective Cohort of Patients With

Olfactory Transmucosal SARS-CoV-2 Invasion as a Port of Central Nervous System Entry in Individuals With COVID-19

Tissue Distribution of ACE2 Protein, the Functional Receptor for SARS Coronavirus. A First Step in Understanding SARS Pathogenesis

Body Localization of ACE-2: On the Trail of the Keyhole of SARS-CoV-2

Signs and Symptoms, and Criteria Adopted for Long COVID-19: A Systematic Review

Human Small Intestinal Infection by SARS-CoV-2 is Characterized by a Mucosal Infiltration With Activated CD8+ T Cells

Long COVID: An Overview

Characteristics of Peripheral Lymphocyte Subset Alteration in COVID-19 Pneumonia

Terminally Differentiated Effector Memory CD8 + T Cells Identify Kidney Transplant Recipients at High Risk of Graft Failure

Cells in Cancer: A Small Population of Lymphocytes With Big Implications

Role of gd T Cells in Controlling Viral Infections With a Focus on Influenza Virus: Implications for Designing Novel Therapeutic Approaches

The PD-1/PD-L1 Axis and Virus Infections: A Delicate Balance

The Long and Latent Road to Autoimmunity

How Pandemics Strengthen Links Between Viruses and Autoimmunity

We greatly appreciate all the participants for their contribution to this study. We also thank the excellent secretarial assistance of Mrs Olga Palao.

The Supplementary Material for this article can be found online at: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fimmu.2022.

Conflict of Interest: The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.