key: cord-0701968-u2mkkw3r
authors: Ames, Jennifer L.; Ferrara, Assiamira; Avalos, Lyndsay A.; Badon, Sylvia E.; Greenberg, Mara B.; Hedderson, Monique M.; Kuzniewicz, Michael W.; Qian, Yinge; Young-Wolff, Kelly C.; Zerbo, Ousseny; Zhu, Yeyi; Croen, Lisa A.
title: COVID-19 prevalence, symptoms, and sociodemographic disparities in infection among insured pregnant women in Northern California
date: 2021-09-03
journal: PLoS One
DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0256891
sha: 3d9415ec13462a8919a57b70d1aa3e6e68b2eef4
doc_id: 701968
cord_uid: u2mkkw3r

BACKGROUND: Research on COVID-19 during pregnancy has mainly focused on women hospitalized for COVID-19 or other reasons during their pregnancy. Little is known about COVID-19 in the general population of pregnant women. OBJECTIVE: To describe the prevalence of COVID-19, symptoms, consequent healthcare use, and possible sources of COVID-19 exposure among a population-based sample of pregnant women residing in Northern California. METHODS: We analyzed data from 19,458 members of Kaiser Permanente Northern California who were pregnant between January 2020 and April 2021 and responded to an online survey about COVID-19 testing, diagnosis, symptoms, and their experiences during the COVID-19 pandemic. Medical diagnosis of COVID-19 during pregnancy was defined separately by self-report and by documentation in electronic health records (EHR). We examined relationships of COVID-19 with sociodemographic factors, underlying comorbidities, and survey measures of COVID-19-like symptoms, consequent healthcare utilization, and possible COVID-19 exposures. RESULTS: Among 19,458 respondents, the crude prevalence of COVID-19 was 2.5% (n = 494) according to self-report and 1.4% (n = 276) according to EHR. After adjustment, the prevalence of self-reported COVID-19 was higher among women aged <25 years compared with women aged ≥35 years (prevalence ratio [PR], 1.75, 95% CI: 1.23, 2.49) and among Hispanic women compared with White women (PR, 1.91, 95% CI: 1.53, 2.37). Prevalence of self-reported COVID-19 was higher among women affected by personal or partner job loss during the pandemic (PR, 1.23, 95% CI: 1.02, 1.47) and among women living in areas of high vs. low neighborhood deprivation (PR, 1.74, 95% CI: 1.33, 2.27). We did not observe differences in self-reported COVID-19 between women with and without underlying comorbidities. Results were similar for EHR-documented COVID-19. Loss of smell or taste was a unique and common symptom reported among women with COVID-19 (42.3% in self-reported; 54.0% in EHR-documented). Among women with symptomatic COVID-19, approximately 2% were hospitalized, 71% had a telehealth visit, and 75% quarantined at home. Over a third of women with COVID-19 reported no known exposure to someone with COVID-19. CONCLUSIONS: Observed COVID-19 prevalence differences by sociodemographic and socioeconomic factors underscore social and health inequities among reproductive-aged women. Women with COVID-19 reported unique symptoms and low frequency of hospitalization. Many were not aware of an exposure to someone with COVID-19.

Pregnant women may be more susceptible to severe COVID-19 illness [1] [2] [3] , in part due to reduced immunity and increased stress during pregnancy. Factors such as chronic stress, underlying inflammatory conditions such as obesity and asthma, belonging to a racial/ethnic minority group, and socioeconomic factors are also known to compound risk of viral infections and exacerbate inflammation during pregnancy [4] [5] [6] . Research also suggests that SARS-CoV-2 infection during pregnancy may increase risk of other adverse women's and neonatal health outcomes [7, 8] . Despite these concerns, research on COVID-19 in pregnant women remains limited. Several studies have presented the clinical characteristics of COVID-19 in pregnant women admitted for delivery [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] or for COVID-19 complications [1, 16] . Fewer studies have characterized symptoms of COVID-19 in a general sample of pregnant women, representative of different stages during pregnancy [17] [18] [19] [20] . Furthermore, prior studies have primarily focused on infection prevalence across relatively short time windows and have not described healthcare utilization or sources of COVID-19 exposure in pregnant women during the pandemic.

At Kaiser Permanente Northern California (KPNC), a large integrated healthcare delivery system, we conducted a survey among all women who were pregnant at any time during January 2020 to April 2021. The survey was designed to evaluate the frequency of self-reported COVID-19 testing, medical diagnosis, symptoms and related health care utilization. The aims of the present analysis were to a) estimate the crude prevalence of diagnosed COVID-19 and testing frequency for COVID-19 among pregnant women overall and by sociodemographic characteristics, neighborhood factors, and underlying comorbidities, and b) describe frequencies of symptoms, consequent health care utilization, and possible COVID-19 exposures between January 2020 and May 2021.

The study setting was KPNC, a large integrated healthcare delivery system serving a membership of 4.5 million people, with approximately 30% of the population residing in the San Francisco Bay Area, Sacramento metropolitan area, and the Central Valley [21] .

The study population included KPNC members who were �18 years old and at any stage of pregnancy between January 1, 2020 and April 28, 2021. At the time the survey was launched (June 22, 2020), eligible women aged 18+ years were either postpartum, having already delivered a liveborn infant between January 1, 2020 and June 22, 2020, or were currently pregnant and at > = 12 weeks of gestation.

At the initial survey launch, all eligible women were contacted via email and invited to complete a brief, web-based 25-item research survey through REDCap. Every two weeks thereafter, all newly eligible pregnant women were emailed a study invitation. Although we typically identified and invited eligible women during their second trimester, we also invited a small number of women whose eligibility we ultimately identified late in pregnancy or early in postpartum. Women who did not respond to the initial email invitation received email reminders 7 and 14 days after the initial emails were sent. Participants who started but did not complete the survey received two email reminders, at 7 and 14 days after starting the survey. Regardless of whether they completed the first survey, women were again invited by email to complete a second survey, identical to the first, towards the end of their pregnancy (>34 weeks of pregnancy).

The present study reports findings from women pregnant between January 2020 and April 2021 who completed the survey between June 22, 2020 and May 10, 2021 and focuses on questions about healthcare provider diagnosis of COVID-19, receipt of COVID-19 diagnostic tests and test results, and experience of symptoms previously reported to be associated with COVID-19 [22] . Women reporting symptoms were additionally asked about healthcare utilization resulting from symptoms, and potential exposures from personal contacts who had or likely had COVID-19 and/or from travel in the 2 weeks before the symptoms started. The survey also collected other information about whether the respondents experienced changes to their or their partner's employment during the pandemic and whether they received nutritional assistance (see S1 Appendix for a copy of the full survey).

Women's information captured in the KPNC EHR before and during pregnancy, including sociodemographic information (e.g., self-reported race/ethnicity), medical diagnoses, delivery date (actual or expected), and COVID-19 diagnostic codes, was linked to the survey data. We examined respondents' underlying diagnoses of several conditions previously shown to be related to heightened risk of severe COVID-19 in adults [23] [24] [25] [26] [27] . These included any diagnoses, ascertained via clinical diagnosis and/or medication use, of allergy, asthma, autoimmune conditions, obesity, diabetes, and hypertension in the two years preceding survey completion. We used current residential address obtained from EHR to link survey responses to data on neighborhood deprivation index (NDI), [28] an indicator of neighborhood-level socioeconomic position that integrates census variables on education, occupation, housing, and income/poverty.

We defined clinically-diagnosed COVID-19 during pregnancy in two ways: according to selfreported diagnosis of COVID-19 made by a healthcare provider or according to documentation in the EHR. Women with a self-reported COVID-19 diagnosis responded "Yes" to the survey question "During your pregnancy, did a healthcare provider ever tell you that you have, or likely have, COVID-19 (Coronavirus)?" Women with EHR-documented diagnosis of COVID-19 had a positive polymerase chain reaction (PCR) test for SARS-CoV-2 and/or a diagnostic ICD-10 code for COVID-19 recorded in their EHR between the date of their last menstrual cycle and the delivery date (for postpartum respondents) or the survey completion date (for currently pregnant respondents). The relevant ICD-10 codes are included in the S2 Appendix. Women who did not meet either of these diagnostic definitions were included in the no-COVID-19 group. Women who did not have SARS-CoV-2 PCR test results but had diagnostic codes in their EHR for suspected COVID-19, exposure to COVID-19, or COVID-19 disease counseling were considered suspected COVID-19 (n = 4035) and were excluded from the EHR-documented COVID-19 and no-COVID-19 groups. Of note, during the period of March-October 2020, KPNC was predominantly only testing people with symptoms or known exposures, in accordance with CDC recommendations.

KPNC's Institutional Review Board approved all study procedures and women indicated informed consent prior to participation in the survey.

Chi-square tests were performed to compare the characteristics between women who did and did not complete the survey. The crude prevalence of COVID-19 during pregnancy (according to self-report and according to EHR documentation) was calculated overall and by age, race/ ethnicity, and NDI; variables reflecting individual and neighborhood socioeconomic status; and several underlying comorbidities. Generalized linear models were used to obtain crude and adjusted prevalence ratios for COVID-19. All multivariable models adjusted the prevalence ratios for maternal age category, maternal race/ethnicity, and NDI quartile. Seven women with missing age were excluded from all models. Women with missing values for NDI (n = 105) were included in the missing category and retained in the models. As a secondary analysis, we summarized the frequencies of self-reported COVID-19 diagnostic testing and test-positivity by sociodemographic characteristics and underlying comorbidities among women who were pregnant at the time they completed the survey.

We described differences in self-reported COVID-19-like symptoms, consequent healthcare use, and potential exposures to COVID-19 between women with COVID-19 (for each case definition) and women in the no-COVID-19 group using chi-square tests, or Fisher exact tests when cell counts were <5. A p-value <0.05 was used to determine statistical significance in all tests performed. All statistical analyses were conducted using SAS version 9.4 (SAS Institute).

Between June 22, 2020 and May 10, 2021, a total of 19,458 of 82,482 eligible women (23.6%) completed the survey, 73.8% while pregnant (of which 92.1% were in their second or third trimester) and 26.2% after delivery (mean [SD]: 10 [7] weeks postpartum). Postpartum respondents were pregnant between March 2019 and April 2021, and the majority (98.3%) gave birth between February 2020, when the first identified cases of COVID-19 were reported in California, and August 2020. The majority of all respondents were in their second trimester (68.9%) and a plurality were 30-34 years old (40.0%), White (47.3%), and living in the lowest quartile of neighborhood deprivation (31.3%) ( Table 1) . In comparison to survey non-respondents, respondents were more likely to be White, �30 years old, and live in neighborhoods with low deprivation. The frequency of any history of EHR-documented COVID-19 diagnosis was similar between respondents and non-respondents (2.3% vs. 2.4%, p = 0.60) (S1 Table) .

A total of 494 respondents (2.5%) reported that a healthcare provider told them that they had or likely had COVID-19 during their pregnancy ( Table 2 ). The crude prevalence of selfreported COVID-19 was highest for women <25 years of age (5.1%), Hispanic (4.4%) and Black women (3.1%), and women living in neighborhoods with the highest deprivation (i.e., 4th quartile of NDI) (4.1%) ( Table 2) . After adjustment for other sociodemographic characteristics, the prevalence of self-reported COVID- 19 . Other socioeconomic indicators such as health insurance payer and receipt of food assistance were not significantly associated with self-reported COVID-19 after adjustment for covariates. While the crude prevalence of EHR-documented COVID-19 was lower than self-reported COVID-19 (1.4% vs 2.5%), prevalence patterns by age, race/ethnicity, and NDI were similar for both definitions ( Table 2 ).

The crude prevalence of self-reported COVID-19 was highest in women with asthma (3.2%), hypertension (3.5%), and obesity (3.1%) and lowest in women with none of these conditions (2.3%) ( Table 2) . After adjustment for age, race/ethnicity, and NDI, the prevalence of self-reported COVID-19 did not significantly differ between women with and without these underlying comorbidities ( 

Women with diagnosed COVID-19 were more likely to report living with someone who had or probably had COVID-19 (49.6% for self-report, 64.1% for EHR-documented), than women in the no-COVID-19 group (3.2%) ( Table 4) . Women with diagnosed COVID-19 according to self-report or EHR documentation were more likely than women in the no-COVID-19 group to experience several different symptoms during pregnancy ( Among women who experienced symptoms during pregnancy, those in the self-reported and EHR-documented COVID-19 groups were significantly more likely than those in the no-COVID-19 group to report having had an overnight hospitalization (2.2% and 1.8%, respectively vs. 0%) or an in-person (16.1% and 14.3%, respectively vs. 6.5%) or telehealth visit with their provider (70.7% and 70.5%, respectively vs. 20.2%), self-isolating as a result of their symptoms (75.3% and 76.8%, respectively vs. 15.7%), and having had contact with someone who tested positive (46.7% and 54.9%, respectively vs. 1.3%) or likely had COVID-19 (both 15.2% vs. 1.9%) ( Table 4) . However, over a third of women with COVID-19 reported not having a known exposure to someone who had or likely had COVID-19.

In a large, diverse population of pregnant women during the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic in Northern California, we found that women who were <25 years of age, Hispanic, living in neighborhoods with high deprivation, and who had experienced personal or a partner's job loss or reduced employment hours had the highest prevalence of diagnosed COVID-19. Over 50% of women with EHR-documented COVID-19 reported loss of smell or taste, although a fifth of women reported feeling no symptoms during their infection. Fewer than 3% of women with diagnosed COVID-19 and symptoms were hospitalized, suggesting that most symptomatic infections were not severe. Over a third of women with diagnosed COVID-19 were not aware of having had exposure to someone who had or likely had COVID-19 in the two weeks before their symptoms started. The prevalence of COVID-19 in our sample of survey responders is lower than the prevalence in pregnant women reported by studies conducted in clinical settings across the US. These studies differed from ours in that they sampled over shorter time periods and from universal testing programs of hospitalized women admitted for delivery [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] or for COVID-19 related symptoms [1, 16] . A prevalence of 15% was reported among women who were admitted for delivery during the early surge of the pandemic in New York City (March 22-April 4, 2020) [15] , when New York's documented prevalence of COVID-19 in the adult population was much higher than in California [29] . During periods of rapid community transmission in the spring of 2020, Texas, Illinois, Massachusetts, and Connecticut observed infection rates of 2.6-8% in pregnant women who were universally screened for COVID-19 at delivery [9, [12] [13] [14] . In April and May, before Southern California witnessed summer surges in COVID-19 transmission, only 1% of pregnant women universally screened at delivery at Kaiser Permanente Southern California tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 [11] . The relatively low prevalence reported in both the Southern and Northern California samples may reflect the early success of local public health mitigation efforts at the beginning of the pandemic. However, in our sample, the low prevalence may also reflect the limited testing availability in the early course of the pandemic when KPNC was following CDC recommendations to test only those with severe symptoms or known exposures. Partway through the study's observation period, KPNC began universal testing for all patients who presented for scheduled cesarean in October 2020 and for all patients in labor and delivery in December 2020. Northern California also experienced a surge in COVID-19 transmission across November 2020-February 2021, reflected in an observable increase in COVID-19 screening and test-positivity among respondents participating in the survey after October 2020.

The prevalence of COVID-19, whether measured by self-report of a diagnosis made by a healthcare provider or a documented diagnosis in the EHR, was generally highest among women <25 years old; Hispanic women; and women who lived in neighborhoods with high deprivation. Analyses of self-reported SARS-CoV-2 testing also indicated sociodemographic disparities in test-positivity rate, despite SARS-CoV-2 testing frequency being relatively similar across sociodemographic groups. A study in the broader KPNC population also found that sociodemographic factors, particularly race/ethnicity, were stronger predictors of SARS-CoV- 2 infection but less predictive of SARS-CoV-2 testing use [30] . In other states, younger age [9, 14] and other sociodemographic indicators, including receipt of government health insurance [12, 14] , were associated with heightened risk of COVID-19 in pregnant women. Earlier studies conducted in different US healthcare systems also consistently demonstrate that pregnant Black and Hispanic women have higher rates of COVID-19 [2, 9, 12, 14, 17, 20, 31] and are more likely to have severe symptoms leading to hospitalization [1, 17] . These COVID-19-related health disparities further highlight the pandemic's interaction with pre-existing social determinants of health, employment in essential high-risk sectors, and systemic racial health inequities in the US [32] [33] [34] . In our sample, women with underlying asthma, hypertension, and obesity had a slightly higher prevalence of COVID-19 than their counterparts without these conditions, though these differences were not statistically significant after adjustment for covariates. Previous studies based on universal COVID-19 testing of pregnant women at delivery have found that several conditions, including diabetes, chronic lung diseases, cardiovascular disease, and obesity, were associated with increased risk of severe COVID-19 illness [1, 3, 9, 10, 14, 35] . While the relationship between allergy and COVID-19 has not been scrutinized in pregnant women prior to this study, studies in general populations present mixed evidence, suggesting that more research is needed to understand how specific conditions, treatments, and their interactions may shape COVID-19 susceptibility [23, 27] . Though very few women were hospitalized for COVID-19 in our sample, other studies suggest that underlying comorbidities may put pregnant women at increased risk of COVID-19 complications requiring hospitalization [2, 16, 31] .

Pregnancy induces several physiological changes, including phases of immunosuppression and altered cardiopulmonary function, that can increase pregnant women's susceptibility to infectious disease [36] as well as increase frequency of fatigue and headaches. Further, the proinflammatory states that naturally occur during the first and third trimesters can exacerbate a woman's COVID-19 illness, inducing a cytokine storm of acute inflammation that can adversely affect the short and long-term health of the woman and fetus [37] . While COVID-19-like symptoms were prevalent in women without diagnosed COVID-19, most symptoms, including COVID-19 hallmarks such as cough, headache, and loss of smell or taste [22] , were markedly more common in women with COVID-19. Previous studies have found that, among hospitalized women with COVID-19, some symptoms, including cough, fever, and myalgia were less common in pregnant than non-pregnant women, in part because universal testing of pregnant women has led to increased detection of mild and asymptomatic cases [2, 3, 38] . Studies in universal testing settings have demonstrated that 65-94% of pregnant women with SARS-CoV-2 infection experience no symptoms [9-13, 15, 18] . In contrast, only 20% of women with recognized SARS-CoV-2 infection were asymptomatic in our sample, likely reflecting the local testing policies in the early months of the pandemic that prioritized those with symptoms and known exposures.

Our study had some notable limitations. Response rates to the survey were relatively low, raising concerns about non-response bias. In addition, sociodemographic factors associated with higher risk of COVID-19 were also found to be associated with survey non-response. Our survey sample was more likely to be aged 30 years or older and more likely to be White relative to the general KPNC population, which is broadly representative of the insured adult population in California [21] . This potential selection bias suggests that the sociodemographic disparities we observed may underestimate disparities in the general population of pregnant women in California and nationally. Though the rates of some co-morbidities such as asthma, preexisting diabetes, and obesity were similar in our sample to estimates in nationally-representative samples of the pregnant population, our sample was on average older with a higher proportion of women with commercial health insurance than in the national population [39] [40] [41] [42] .

The strengths of the present study include the examination of both self-reported and EHRdocumented COVID-19 from a general population of pregnant women, providing additional insight regarding infection risk, symptoms, consequent healthcare use, and possible exposures beyond what has been described in earlier studies of pregnant women, which predominantly included women admitted to the hospital for delivery or for COVID-19 complications [2, [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] . Women who self-reported COVID-19 but who had no documentation of infection in the EHR may have received testing outside of KPNC and not reported their findings to their healthcare provider. Further strengths include the study's large sample size, diversity across sociodemographic characteristics and stages in pregnancy, and large window of observation over the first year of the pandemic.

In conclusion, while COVID-19 was recognized in a relatively small number of women in our sample overall, our study identified several subgroups that may be particularly vulnerable to infection and observed unique infection-related symptoms during pregnancy, low frequency of hospitalization but high frequency of self-isolation and use of telehealth visits, and a sizable proportion of women with no known exposures to infected contacts before the onset of their symptoms. It will be important to follow the health of these women and their children in future studies. 

Characteristics and Maternal and Birth Outcomes of Hospitalized Pregnant Women with Laboratory-Confirmed COVID-19-COVID-NET, 13 States

Characteristics of Women of Reproductive Age with Laboratory-Confirmed SARS-CoV-2 Infection by Pregnancy Status-United States

Clinical manifestations, risk factors, and maternal and perinatal outcomes of coronavirus disease 2019 in pregnancy: living systematic review and meta-analysis

A prospective study of respiratory viral infection in pregnant women with and without asthma

Epstein-Barr virus reactivation during pregnancy and postpartum: effects of race and racial discrimination

Incidence of cytomegalovirus infection among the general population and pregnant women in the United States

Birth and Infant Outcomes Following Laboratory-Confirmed SARS-CoV-2 Infection in Pregnancy-SET-NET, 16 Jurisdictions

Maternal COVID-19 infection, clinical characteristics, pregnancy, and neonatal outcome: A prospective cohort study

Patient characteristics associated with SARS-CoV-2 infection in parturients admitted for labour and delivery in Massachusetts during the spring 2020 surge: A prospective cohort study

Characteristics and Outcomes of 241 Births to Women With Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) Infection at Five New York City Medical Centers

Universal SARS-Cov-2 Screening in Women Admitted for Delivery in a Large Managed Care Organization

Racial-ethnic disparities and pregnancy outcomes in SARS-CoV-2 infection in a universally

Prevalence of SARS-CoV-2 Among Patients Admitted for Childbirth in Southern Connecticut

Risk factors for severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 infection in pregnant women

Universal Screening for SARS-CoV-2 in Women Admitted for Delivery

SARS-CoV-2 Infection Among Hospitalized Pregnant Women: Reasons for Admission and Pregnancy Characteristics-Eight U.S. Health Care Centers

Racial and ethnic disparities in severity of COVID-19 disease in pregnancy in the United States

Association of SARS-CoV-2 Test Status and Pregnancy Outcomes

Clinical Presentation of Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) in Pregnant and Recently Pregnant People

Prevalence and Severity of Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) Illness in Symptomatic Pregnant and Postpartum Women Stratified by Hispanic Ethnicity

The Kaiser Permanente Northern California Adult Member Health Survey

Characteristics of Adult Outpatients and Inpatients with COVID-19-11 Academic Medical Centers

Allergic disorders and susceptibility to and severity of COVID-19: A nationwide cohort study

Evidence used to update the list of underlying medical conditions that increase a person's risk of severe illness from COVID-19

Preexisting Comorbidities Predicting COVID-19 and Mortality in the UK Biobank Community Cohort

Prevalence and clinical outcomes of COVID-19 in patients with autoimmune diseases: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Risk factors for severe and critically ill COVID-19 patients: A review

The development of a standardized neighborhood deprivation index

Geographic Differences in COVID-19 Cases, Deaths, and Incidence-United States

Racial Disparities in COVID-19 Testing and Outcomes: Retrospective Cohort Study in an Integrated Health System

Characteristics and outcomes of pregnant women admitted to hospital with confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infection in UK: national population based cohort study

Economic, and Health Inequality and COVID-19 Infection in the United States. J Racial Ethn Health Disparities

Characteristics Associated With Racial/Ethnic Disparities in COVID-19 Outcomes in an Academic Health Care System

Associations Between Built Environment, Neighborhood Socioeconomic Status, and SARS-CoV-2 Infection Among Pregnant Women in New York City

Clinical course of severe and critical coronavirus disease 2019 in hospitalized pregnancies: a United States cohort study

Pregnancy and susceptibility to infectious diseases

SARS-CoV-2 Infection and COVID-19 During Pregnancy: A Multidisciplinary Review

Clinical Characteristics of Pregnant Women With Coronavirus Disease

Management of Preexisting Diabetes in Pregnancy: A Review

Asthma prevalence among women aged 18 to 44 in the United States: National health and nutrition examination survey 2001-2016

Marked Disparities in Pre-Pregnancy Obesity and Overweight Prevalence among US Women by Race/Ethnicity

Women In The United States Experience High Rates Of Coverage 'Churn' In Months Before And After Childbirth. Health Aff (Millwood)

The authors thank Linda Nkemere, Jenna Ritchie, and Maria Massolo for their contributions to launching and maintaining the survey study.The