key: cord-0689069-9mgvmz9m authors: Şenol Çelik, Sevilay; Atli Özbaş, Azize; Kovancı, Mustafa Sabri; Savaş, Hafize; Çelik, Yusuf title: Experience and views of nurses on nursing services and personal protective equipment in Covid‐19 pandemic the case of Turkey: A cross‐sectional study date: 2022-04-27 journal: J Nurs Manag DOI: 10.1111/jonm.13625 sha: 9753d2bbb1cadec5c588050abddc56aab9ae6ef7 doc_id: 689069 cord_uid: 9mgvmz9m BACKGROUND: During the COVID‐19 pandemic, there were difficulties in planning the nursing workforce and personal protective equipment. AIM: The purpose of this study was to identify the experiences and views of nurses on personal protective equipment use and nursing workforce planning in Turkey. METHODS: This descriptive and cross‐sectional study was conducted between 23 December 2020 and 3 May 2021, among 362 nurses who agreed to participate in this study voluntarily. RESULTS: The findings showed that the satisfaction scores were significantly higher for those nurses who worked in 8‐h shifts, were not assigned to different clinics, were notified by an official letter and 1 week or month in advance before assignment compared with nurses in other categories. CONCLUSIONS: The problems that have arisen in the COVID‐19 pandemic process have made it clear that there is a need for a nursing services management model in the event of an epidemic. IMPLICATIONS FOR NURSING MANAGEMENT: This study reveals the need for the ‘Nursing Services Management Model in the Event of an Epidemic’ by discussing the problems of nurse workforce planning and protective personal equipment management from the perspective of nurses who experienced these problems at first hand. The Coronavirus-disease 2019 , which has resulted in more than 5.5 million deaths worldwide as a global epidemic, has become a major health crisis for countries since the day it began (Cascella et al., 2021; WHO, 2022) . Although rapid management of COVID-19 has been achieved with the advancement of technology and scientific research, preventing the spread of new variants is a major burden on health systems. Most countries are experiencing consecutive epidemic waves due to the emergence of new variants of the virus (Islam et al., 2021; Vasireddy et al., 2021) . The organization efforts of health professionals, who are in an important position in achieving success during the pandemic-namely, reorganization of health professionals in intensive care units and inpatient rooms-have been left to health institutions (Ardebili et al., 2020; Liu et al., 2020; Stucky et al., 2020) . However, proceedings all over the world and in Turkey during the COVID-19 pandemic have shown that there are shortages especially in quality and quantity to meet the increasing demand in the supply of health workers and necessary personal protective equipment (PPE) (Akkus et al., 2021; Cengiz et al., 2021; Kackin et al., 2021) . Nurses have been at the forefront of this struggle during the COVID-19 pandemic process and have been needed at every stage of health care, from family health centers to emergency rooms and intensive care units (Celik et al., 2020; Chen et al., 2020; Stucky et al., 2020) . At the same time, there have been major problems regarding shortage of nursing workforce, insufficient PPE/medical supplies, inadequate management and organization of pandemic processes in Turkey (Celik et al., 2020; Cengiz et al., 2021) . In addition, nurses have witnessed some problems including the fear and anxiety, violence, long working hours with more patients, not having appropriate nurse/patient ratios, taking care of their families and children and other problems regarding personnel rights and compensation, transmitting COVID-19 to loved ones and members of the public. Nurses have continued to do their jobs under difficult and stressful conditions so as to maintain the highest level of safe and quality nursing care despite the insufficient number of nurses and the problems witnessed (Celik et al., 2020; Şenol, 2020) . The difficulties experienced with the nursing workforce and PPE/medical supplies planning in the COVID-19 pandemic have emphasized the need for 'Nursing Services Management for Pandemics' (Galanis et al., 2021; Halcomb et al., 2020) . Obtaining the experiences and views of nurses providing care for patients with the use of PPE and planning of the nursing workforce are essential in order to find solutions for the experienced problems. The purpose of this descriptive and cross-sectional study is to identify the experiences and views of nurses providing care for COVID-19 patients on the management of nursing services and PPE. This study also investigates the relationship between satisfaction levels of nurses with the management of nursing services and PPE and nurses' demographic, work-related characteristics and the practices of health care facilities during COVID-19 pandemic. This is a descriptive and cross-sectional study. The sample of study was composed of 362 nurses who agreed to participate in this study and were the members of national nurse's associations in Turkey. Those nurses whose contact information was available were contacted via e-mail and WhatsApp, and they were asked to fill out the data collection tools. It is an obvious fact that lower level of satisfaction among nurses and lack of PPE are common problems caused by inadequate management of nursing services during the pandemic process. The findings of this study reveal that: • Better management of nursing services plays a significant role in increasing the motivation of nurses that is needed more in providing high-quality patient care during unexpected crises such as COVID-19 • Protecting nurses from infection as forefront warriors during COVID-19 is an essential management duty, and their services should be guaranteed by meeting their essential needs such as PPE and by practicing better management functions. square analysis was used to examine the relationships between categorical independent and dependent variables. Fisher's exact test was used for 2 Â 2 tables to estimate odds ratios (OR) to show the association between the status of being infected/contacted and implementations of hospitals or nursing services. In cases where the compared groups were more than two, the associations were estimated by using Pearson's chi-square value with two-way probability values. Student's t-test and one-way ANOVA analysis were used in order to determine whether the satisfaction levels of nurses with nursing services and PPE management were different by the demographic characteristics of nurses and hospital/nursing services. Levene's test was used to examine whether the variances were homogeneous or not in order to determine appropriate t/F values that should be used in comparisons. Pearson's correlation analysis was used to examine the relationship between normally distributed continuous variables, while the independent predictors of nurses' satisfaction levels with nursing services and PPE management were estimated by using multiple regression analysis. The mean age of the nurses was 31.83 AE 7.54 (range 20-54) years, and their professional experience was 9.83 AE 8.36 (range 1-35) years. Of nurses, 84.5% were women, 69.9% were in hospitals affiliated to the Ministry of Health, 39.0% were in intensive care units and 40.6% were on 24-h duty. In addition, the average number of patients cared for by a nurse in the unit was 12.22 AE 30.63 people and their average weekly working hours were 50.50 AE 11.00 h on average. The data on being infected by COVID-19 according to demographic and workrelated characteristics of nurses were illustrated in Table 1 . The rate of being infected among male nurses (78.6%) was higher than that of female nurses (65.4%), and male nurses were more likely to be infected (OR = 1943) compared with female nurses. The rate of being infected was higher among nurses assigned to COVID-19 intensive care units (74.20%), those who were not trained in PPE (76.80%) and those who had difficulties in accessing disposable gowns/overalls (71.1%) compared with their counterparts. The probability of being infected among nurses assigned to intensive care units (OR = 1.814), nurses who were not trained in PPE (OR = 0.71) and who have difficulties in accessing to disposable gowns/overalls (OR = 1.52) was higher compared with their counterparts. Although it was not expressed with OR, a significant relationship was found between the work schedule and the state of being infected (p < 0.05). It was found that working in hospitals for longer periods of time without resting significantly increased the probability of being infected. The relationship between demographic and work-related characteristics of nurses and their status of contacting a COVID-19 patient T A B L E 1 COVID-19 infection status, by the demographic and job characteristics of nurses All demographic and work-related variables were examined to see if they were significant in terms of being infected, but only those variables that were found to be statistically significant were presented in this table. was presented in Mean satisfaction score with the management of nursing services and PPEs by demographic and work-related characteristics of nurses was compared by using t-test and ANOVA test, and the results were presented in Table 3 . A statistically significant difference was found between the satisfaction with the management of nursing services and the management of PPE and the work schedule, being assigned to different units, the way and the time of the notification before assignment to different units (p < 0.05). The findings showed that the satisfaction scores of the nurses who worked in 8-h shifts, who were not assigned to different clinics, who were notified by an official letter and 1 week or 1 month in advance before assignment were significantly higher than that of the other nurses. A statistically significant difference was also found between the state of having close contact with a COVID-19 patient The rate of having close contact with a COVID-19 patient by demographic and work-related characteristics of nurses All demographic and work-related variables were examined to see if they were significant in terms of being infected, but only those variables that were found to be statistically significant were presented in this table. b Family health center, community mental health center, alcohol and substance treatment center. and satisfaction with the management of nursing services (F = 3.666, p < 0.05). It was observed that the satisfaction level with the management of nursing services was found to be lower among the nurses who were infected and had to go to work compared with those who were not infected and those who were infected but took a leave. There was also a statistically significant difference between the assigned unit and satisfaction with the management of PPE (Table 4) . A weak positive relationship was found between the age of nurses and their satisfaction with the management of nursing services and the management of PPE (r = 0.194; r = 0.211, p < 0.05). This finding indicated that relatively more aged nurses were more satisfied with management of nursing services and PPE. In addition, there was a negative and weak, but statistically significant correlation between weekly working hours and the satisfaction with management of nursing services and PPE (r = À0.143; r = À0.152, p < 0.05). This situation is interpreted as an increase in the weekly working hours decreased in the level of satisfaction level (Table 5) . A multiple regression analysis was conducted to estimate the effects of all demographic and job-related characteristics of the nurses on the satisfaction level with nursing services and PPE management ( As the second year of the COVID-19 pandemic approaches, its burden on health institutions and health professionals has increased. Some of the problems have been solved and but some have become The fact that working longer than 12 h reduces the quality of life of nurses also threatens the safety of patients and employees (Griffiths et al., 2014) . As a matter of fact, it is reported in the literature that nurses who work together with PPE for long periods of time experience physical and emotional burnout (Cengiz et al., 2021; Gao et al., 2020; Liu et al., 2020) . In this study, similar to the literature, it is observed that as nurses' weekly working hours increase, their satisfaction rates with nursing services decrease. In this context, it may be suggested that the number of nurses should be considered when organizing the working hours of nurses, and shifts not exceeding 12 h should be organized for an optimal performance. Kluger et al. have reported that the infection rate of nurses can be reduced with working in 12-h shifts and at least 3 days apart (Kluger et al., 2020) . It has also been reported that staff numbers should be reorganized in accordance with the requirements, and the workforce problem may be solved with transferring nurses from general clinics to intensive care units and working under the supervision of an experienced nurse (Poortaghi et al., 2021) . The limited number of nurses, unavailability of PPE and its proper management and inadequacies of the emergency/disaster plan have led to significant problems in the provision of health services during the pandemic process (Ardebili et al., 2020; González-Gil et al., 2021) . In order to deal with the increasing number of cases, especially in intensive care units, arrangements have been made for nurse workforce planning. In this context, operation room nurses, anaesthesia nurses or inpatient service nurses were assigned to intensive care units (Chen et al., 2020; Crowe et al., 2020; Stucky et al., 2020) . It has been reported that 100 (27.6%) of the nurses in this study sample were assigned to different units rather than the units they worked before the pandemic. Of these, 13 were assigned to different units every week, 78 were assigned to different units every month and 9 were assigned to different units almost every day. It was found that the nurses were mostly notified of these assignments verbally and on the day or a few days before they were going to start working in their new unit. According to Cengiz et al., the nurses who were assigned to different units almost each shift or each month, nurses who had never been trained before and who were assigned to different units where they had no experience with had difficulty adapting to this situation (Cengiz et al., 2021) . Liu et al. reported that nurses from different clinics, although they were assigned on a voluntary basis, had difficulty communicating when working with different teams and with different protocols, which caused chaos and stress in the situation (Liu et al., 2020) . In our study, it was found that nurses assigned to different units had a low satisfaction rate from the management of nursing services. Especially the nurses who were assigned to intensive care units and who had difficulty with accessing PPE had a lower satisfaction rate compared with nurses working in outpatient clinics. This finding is consistent with the literature. It is recommended that the action plans should be prepared in advance, the number and availability of nurse manpower should be considered, the nurses should be assigned based on their experience, adequate amount of PPE and medical supplies should be provided, and physical infrastructure should be re-organized during pandemic or disaster planning. When these arrangements and preparations are made, it is envisaged that rapid health care organization will be ensured and nurses will work without experiencing any negativity such as burnout, stress and dissatisfaction in case of possible emergencies. Age and long working hours were associated with satisfaction with the management of nursing services in this study. The progression of age brings with it work and life experience, an increase in competence and problem-solving skills (Kwak et al., 2017) . In this direction, the possibility of coping with the problems experienced in nursing services increases with the progression of age and therefore increases satisfaction. Having long working hours in pandemic conditions leads to increased exposure to viral infections, burnout, stress, fatigue and impaired psychological well-being (Sagherian et al., 2020) . Therefore, it causes a decrease in satisfaction in nursing services. Nurses who have been fighting devotedly on the front lines since the beginning of the pandemic also need to protect themselves. Despite this, it has been reported that nurses have serious problems in accessing PPE against the risk of becoming infected (Akkus et al., 2021; Cengiz et al., 2021; Fernandez et al., 2020) . In our study, similar to the literature, it was found that institutions were not sufficiently able to provide PPE, and it was determined that almost more than half of the nurses had problems with accessing PPE. This makes nurses feel unprotected against COVID-19 and work with fear (Iheduru-Anderson, 2021). It is known that COVID-19 is transmitted by droplets and close contact (Cascella et al., 2021) , and therefore, the use of medical masks, especially N95 and its derivative masks, is recommended for the prevention of transmission (Herron et al., 2020) . In our study, it was found that there was a lack of provision of PPE, and among them, in particular, there were problems with the supply of medical masks, especially N95 and its derivative masks, and these were among the variables that affected satisfaction with nursing services negatively. This study showed that one of the factors affecting satisfaction with the management of nursing services was gender. Male nurses were more likely to be satisfied with the management of nursing services during the pandemic process. Guzek et al. (2020) have found that women paid more attention to hygiene and pandemic protection methods than men and women were more careful. This finding, which is different from these studies in the literature, may be due to the gender roles in Turkey. The burden of the pandemic might be more on especially women who bear the great burden of house works, caring of children and elderly. In addition to these reasons, the fact that women nurses stay away from their children and loved ones can be considered as factors that reduce satisfaction with nursing management services. In this context, it can be discussed that the problems experienced in pandemic-related nursing services are more severely felt by women, they evaluate the problems more seriously, and their satisfaction is negatively affected as a result. The state of being infected was found to be a significant factor affecting satisfaction with nursing management services. Interestingly, it was found that nurses who were infected had higher satisfaction with the management of nursing services. Since 62.8% of infected nurses use quarantine leave, this positive response may have been caused by the feeling of being cared and protected by the administration of health care facilities. In some studies, it has been stated that nurses who have very busy and long working hours with the fear of being infected consider quarantine leave as a time they can rest (Labrague, 2021; Moreno-Mulet et al., 2021) . Similar to this situation, taking a leave after being infected may have caused a high level of satisfaction with the management of nursing services among nurses. A few limitations were identified in this study. First, this study analyses self-reported problems by nurses, and this may cause response bias. Second, this study collected data from relatively small sample size, so the findings cannot be generalized to all hospitals and nurses in Turkey. The problems and risks highlighted in this study are as follows: problems in accessing PPE in adequate numbers, quality and conformity; the intense, challenging working conditions of nurses; substandard nurse/patient ratios; the high rates of coming into close contact with COVID-19 patients and being infected; and therefore, the nurses' dissatisfaction with management of nursing services. Even though the health legislation in Turkey and the international standards of the nursing profession have given nurses important duties and responsibilities during the pandemic, the neglect of nurses in the management of this process and the lack of standards for the organization of nursing workforce and nursing services, magnify these problems in the fight against the COVID-19 pandemic. This has led to problems in accessing equipment and materials needed to prevent contamination. The problems that have arisen in the COVID-19 pandemic process have made it clear that there is a need for a 'Nursing Services Management Model in the Event of an Epidemic' in Turkey. Planning of Nurses is the key in establishing success in the fight against the pandemic, and it is necessary to consider nurse workforce characteristics at all levels of nursing services as well as considering the health system and available resources in developing this management model. Nurse manpower planning, which is important for employee satisfaction, and the regular supply of PPE, should be among the priorities of nurse managers in extraordinary situations such as pandemics. The necessary permissions from the Ministry of Health, which is required for data collection on COVID-19 and ethical approval from the Non-Interventional Clinical Research Ethics Committee of a university, were obtained. Informed consent was obtained from the nurses via a form added to the online questionnaire. The principles of the Helsinki Declaration were considered when conducting the study. Koc University Ethics Committee, ethical approval number: 2020.307. IRB.114. This study was presented as an e-poster at ICN Congress 2021. The authors declare that there is no conflict of interest. They also declare that they agree with the content of this manuscript. Sevilay Şenol Çelik: conceptualization, data curation, formal analysis, methodology, writing-review and editing, software and writingoriginal draft. Azize Atlı Özbaş: conceptualization, data curation, formal analysis, methodology, writing-review and editing and writingoriginal draft. Mustafa Sabri Kovancı: formal analysis, methodology, writing-review and editing, software and writing-original draft. Hafize Savaş: formal analysis, methodology and writing-review and editing. Yusuf Çelik: formal analysis, methodology, writing-review and editing, software and writing-original draft. Authors do not wish to share the data. Experiences of nurses working with COVID-19 patients: A qualitative study Healthcare providers experience of working during the COVID-19 pandemic: A qualitative study Features, Evaluation, and Treatment of Coronavirus (COVID-19) COVID-19 Pandemic in the international year of nurses: Turkish nurses association studies Behaviors and experiences of nurses during the COVID-19 pandemic in Turkey: A mixed methods study Role of anesthesia nurses in the treatment and management of patients with COVID-19 The effect of COVID-19 pandemic on the mental health of Canadian critical care nurses providing patient care during the early phase pandemic: A mixed method study Implications for COVID-19: A systematic review of nurses' experiences of working in acute care hospital settings during a respiratory pandemic Nurses' burnout and associated risk factors during the COVID-19 pandemic: A systematic review and meta-analysis Nurses' experiences regarding shift patterns in isolation wards during the COVID-19 pandemic in China: A qualitative study Nurses' perceptions and demands regarding COVID-19 care delivery in critical care units and hospital emergency services Nurses' shift length and overtime working in 12 European countries: The association with perceived quality of care and patient safety Analysis of genderdependent personal protective behaviors in a national sample: Polish adolescents' COVID-19 experience (PLACE-19) study The support needs of Australian primary health care nurses during the COVID-19 pandemic Personal protective equipment and Covid 19-a risk to healthcare staff? Reflections on the lived experience of working with limited personal protective equipment during the COVID-19 crisis Protecting nurses from COVID-19 a top priority: A survey of ICN's national nursing associations Emergence of European and North American mutant variants of SARS-CoV-2 in South-East Asia Experiences and psychosocial problems of nurses caring for patients diagnosed with COVID-19 in Turkey: A qualitative study Impact of healthcare worker shift scheduling on workforce preservation during the COVID-19 pandemic Influence of nursing informatics competencies and problem-solving ability on nursing performance ability among clinical nurses Psychological resilience, coping behaviours and social support among health care workers during the COVID-19 pandemic: A systematic review of quantitative studies The experiences of health-care providers during the COVID-19 crisis in China: A qualitative study. The Lancet Global Health The impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on ICU healthcare professionals: A mixed methods study Exploring nursing managers' perceptions of nursing workforce management during the outbreak of COVID-19: A content analysis study Insomnia, fatigue and psychosocial well-being during COVID-19 pandemic: A crosssectional survey of hospital nursing staff in the United States The pandemic in the international year of the nurse and during the nursing now campaign: The example of Turkey COVID-19: Initial perioperative and perianesthesia nursing response in a military medical center Review of COVID-19 variants and COVID-19 vaccine efficacy: What the clinician should know Health and care worker deaths during COVID-19 Experience and views of nurses on nursing services and personal protective equipment in Covid-19 pandemic the case of Turkey: A cross-sectional study