key: cord-0685616-hqv9wi5u
authors: Power, Tamara; Wilson, Denise; Best, Odette; Brockie, Teresa; Bourque Bearskin, Lisa; Millender, Eugenia; Lowe, John
title: COVID‐19 and Indigenous Peoples: An imperative for action
date: 2020-05-29
journal: J Clin Nurs
DOI: 10.1111/jocn.15320
sha: 626cbbb4e3b5e96e19d64bb110683f29b3964bc0
doc_id: 685616
cord_uid: hqv9wi5u

Every person on Earth has been affected in some way by the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic. However, there is a marked inequity in the impact and threat of the disease for the 370 million Indigenous Peoples worldwide. While honouring diversity in peoples and cultures, this editorial (written by a collaborative of Indigenous nurses from Australia, Aotearoa (New Zealand), Canada, the United States of America and Central America), explores contemporary issues raised for Indigenous communities by this latest public health emergency. Please note, while we may describe a situation about a specific Indigenous group, readers can be assured that the issues we raise are endemic across colonised Indigenous communities globally.

Indigenous Peoples experience a more significant burden of noncommunicable and infectious diseases generally, and this is related to social and health inequities stemming from invasion and subsequent colonisation. Colonisation's legacy for Indigenous Peoples includes intergenerational and concentrated poverty, poor physical and mental health, transport and housing issues, increased rates of domestic and family violence, shorter life expectancy and inadequate access to culturally safe care (Allan & Smylie, 2015; Braveman et al., 2011) . Colonisation is known to have a negative effect on the social determinants of health (Greenwood, de Leeuw, & Lindsay, 2018; Sherwood, 2018) and cultural determinants of health (Salmon et al., 2019) . In Canada, Australia, New Zealand and the Americas, invasion and subsequent colonisation have brought about disproportionate inequities that detrimentally affect Indigenous Peoples compared with other groups in their respective countries.

Indigenous Peoples in colonised nations share similar histories of invasion, displacement from traditional lands and relocation onto missions or reservations, stolen generations, forced assimilation, genocide, decimation from introduced infectious diseases and the attempted erasure of culture through the banning of languages and cultural practices (Sherwood, 2018) . In Central American countries like Guatemala and Panama, Indigenous Peoples have endured centuries of war, internal violence, exile, marginalisation, genocide and other trauma. The existence of imposed trauma and decimation began when Spaniards invaded Panama in the early 16th century (Central Intelligence Agency, 2020). Despite the world class, universal healthcare systems available in Canada and Australia, Indigenous populations continue to experience much poorer health outcomes due to the legacies and intersections of colonialism and racism (Allan & Smylie, 2015) .

Indigenous People's increased vulnerability to disease is unquestionable, evident not only in shorter life expectancies but also in the lower age we become more vulnerable. In Australia, the Health Department advice is for Australians aged 70 years or over, or those aged 65 years or over with chronic medical conditions to stay at home and avoid all contact with other people. However, for Indigenous Peoples, this recommendation is for those aged over 50 years (Department of Health, 2020b Historical data have demonstrated that poor health and poverty positively correlate with pandemic severity (Clay, Lewis, & Severnini, 2019) . Poverty impacts Indigenous Peoples' capacity to respond to COVID-19 on multiple levels. In this current crisis, health outcomes are determined by levels of secure housing, employment, comorbidities, functional literacy, health insurance, food security, access to running water, access to health care and technology. A one-size-fits-all response to COVID-19 ignores the roles of privilege, affluence and racism in perpetuating inequities, and therefore the ability to provide culturally safe care (Best, 2018) . Globally, many Indigenous Peoples live on missions and reserves. Many of these missions and reserves are geographically rural or remote. Among the 574 tribes in the USA, the Navajo Nation is the third highest population in the nation for per capita infections after New York and New Jersey. As of 22nd May 2020, the Navajo Nation had over 4,253 positive cases and 146 deaths from COVID-19 (Navajo Department of Health, 2020a). Older age, multigenerational housing, lack of running water, communal wells, (Maclean & Elphick, 2020) . On the 26th March 2020, the Minister invoked biosecurity travel restrictions for remote areas. People wishing to enter remote communities must self-isolate for 14 days prior to entry (National Indigenous Australians Agency (NIAA), 2020). Assurances that "Governments will support people who do not have appropriate alternate arrangements to self-isolate" are not trusted (NIAA, 2020). Some communities are hundreds of kilometres and many hours away from regional centres, and where people would be accommodated is not clear. Furthermore, this support has not been evident for other Aboriginal people, with media reports of rough sleepers having camps broken up by police, and possessions thrown into garbage trucks (Hirini, 2020) .

A central tension exists between food security and affordability and the closing of missions, reservations, and communities to keep Indigenous Peoples safe from the virus. Prepandemic, one in three adult Aboriginal people who lived remotely in Australia reported running out of food and being unable to afford more (Rogers, Ferguson, Ritchie, Van Den Boogaard, & Brimblecombe, 2018) . In many remote communities, there is only one store to buy food from, and prices are exorbitant due to transport and access issues (Rogers et al., 2018) . In some cases, price-gouging is evident (Central Land Council, 2020) . Because of food costing up to sixty per cent more in remote communities, many Aboriginal people prefer to travel to regional towns to do their shopping (Central Land Council, 2020).

With biosecurity lockdowns in effect, this is no longer possible. Compounding the sudden increase in violence during a pandemic is the intersecting forms of stressors stemming from a sudden rise in economic, emotional and physical pressures; enforced proximity from lockdowns; and, reduced access to support systems, health care and first responders (Peterman et al., 2020) . Pre-existing trauma and stress are triggered during disasters, so there will also be a corresponding rise in harmful alcohol and substance abuse (Macauley, 2020) . Families faced with the stressors associated with COVID-19 may see violence occurring for the first time. These factors all culminate in Indigenous women and children affected by violence, no longer being able to enact the strategies they could take to keep themselves and their children safe. It will also be very difficult to seek help outside of their homes.

The COVID-19 crisis has seen unprecedented disruption to cultural practices and the normal relational and collective practices of Indigenous Peoples. This is detrimental as it has been empirically proven that the cultural determinants of health have an overwhelmingly positive impact on the health of Indigenous Peoples (Bourke et al., 2018) . Many Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people in Australia travel frequently between communities to attend to Sorry Business (funerals and grieving; Department of Health, 2020a).

In the current environment of lockdowns and social distancing, Indigenous people are having difficulties reconciling coronavirus restrictions with their relationally based cultural obligations, with mourning taking precedence (Wainwright, 2020) . Māori in Aotearoa have also been forced to reconsider how they undertake the cultural practices involved to farewell someone who passed away and how they support older people and those with high needs. Traditional greetings of hongi (pressing noses when greeting) and harirū (shaking hands) have a rāhui (temporary prohibition) suspending such practices that breach social distancing regulations (New Zealand Government, 2020a).

Prepandemic, governments were already failing in their efforts to reduce the inequities in social determinants and health outcomes between Indigenous and nonindigenous citizens, and Indigenous Peoples are generally under-resourced for responding to the current crisis. A 2019 report on health security across 195 countries found that the majority of countries were ill-equipped to prevent, detect and respond to health emergencies (Nalabandian et al., 2019) . For instance, it is estimated that there are only 100 ventilators available from Guatemala to Haiti (Burki, 2020) . Iwi (tribal nations) are distributing food parcels to older people who cannot leave their homes and whanau (Family) rather than expecting people to make their way to a food bank. In some more remote areas, Iwi are monitoring who comes and goes out of their rohe (Iwi region) with roadblocks. In Canada, First Nation populations are gathering their bundles for medicine, food, birthing and death, while developing innovative ways to protect themselves such as making their own protective facemasks (Wright, 2020) . Although we and some allied media are reporting on these initiatives, information on strategies Indigenous Peoples have implemented during pandemics is not routinely collected or acknowledged (Zavaleta, 2020) .

To this date, despite known vulnerability and high mortality rates, little information related to the rates of COVID-19 in Indigenous Peoples is obtainable. Even where testing is available, data are rarely disaggregated by ethnicity (United Nations, 2020) .

Yet data will be essential to understand the true impact of COVID-19 on our communities, justify the demand for resources like food and personal protection equipment (PPE) and allow service access and delivery to ensure already existing inequities do not worsen further (Phelan, 2020) . Indigenous communities across Canada are urging provincial and federal health leaders to disclose COVID statistics to their nations, reporting that these numbers will help nations prepare and respond appropriately to potential outbreaks. In Central America, statistical transparency among Indigenous groups related to previous pandemics and other health outcomes is lacking, further perpetuating the lack of Indigenous voice and increasing the health disparity gap (Babyar, 2019) . Failure to recognise the differences in morbidity and mortality among Indigenous Peoples contributes to inequities. There is not only a lack of information sharing but the delay in funding to support nations, and the growing jurisdictional disputes over who will provide these services has once again been intensified in the response to COVID pandemic planning. If ever there was a time to acknowledge the need to collect accurate ethnicity data and disseminate adequate resources to address health disparities among Indigenous people globally, now is that time. The needs of Indigenous Peoples must be made visible and not subsumed instead, in generalised universal response strategies.

In this editorial, we have drawn attention to the existing health and social justice inequities stemming from colonisation. We have discussed the devastating effects pandemics have on our health and capacity to practice culture which is our medicine. We have asked the reader to consider the desperate situation our Peoples face, but recognise the Indigenous-led solutions that are being enacted.

We demand our governments recognise that the harm and hurt and drastically increased morbidity and mortality in our communities during this pandemic are their legacies of failing to address historical and ongoing inequities. The cultural determinants of health must be recognised as the remedy and be built into health policy, practice and research. Going forward, data need to meticulously document the damage, naming us by our countries, our communities, our clans and our tribes. So that the next time disease sweeps our planet, we know our weaknesses, we know our strengths, and if more informed and empowered, we will prevail against the next neo colonial wave. 

First Peoples, second class treatment: the role of racism in the health and well-being of INdigenous peoples in Canada

Indigenous women face particularly high risks in this crisis

Mission and reserve records

In search of Pan-American indigenous health and harmony

The cultural safety journey: An Aboriginal Australian nursing and midwifery context

The impact of influenza on the Canadian First Nations

Evidence review of Indigenous culture for health and wellbeing

Health disparities and health equity: The issue is justice

COVID-19 in Latin America. The Lancet Infectious Diseases

Deaths related to 2009 pandemic influenza A (H1N1) among American Indian/Alaska Natives -12 states

Aborigines may defy orders, come to Alice for food: CLC

What explains cross-city variation in mortality during the 1918 influenza pandemic? Evidence from 438 U.S. cities

Australian health sector emergency response plan for novel coronavirus (COVID-19): Management plan for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander populations. Operational plan for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander populations

Closing the water access gap in the United States: A national action plan

Challenges in health equity for Indigenous peoples in Canada

Homeless Aboriginal people in Perth given move on notices by WA police

British Columbia First Nations and the influenza pandemic of 1918-1919

The importance of culture in addressing domestic violence for First Nation's women

Why should we care about substance use amid a pandemic

COVID-19 Human biosecurity emergency declaration explainer

Indians, Southerners, and Americans: Race, tribe, and nation during

The Lumbee tribe of North Carolina

Criminal Victimization

H1N1 in retrospect: A review of risk factors and policy recommendations

Travel restrictions for remote communities -COVID-19

Reclaiming Power and Place: The Final Report of the National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls

Public Health Order

Vulnerable people: Guidelines for people at higher risk of COVID-19

Pandemics and violence against women and children

We need to be seen' -why data is vital in the fight against COVID-19

Coronavirus disease (COVID-19): vulnerable populations and COVID-19

Strengthening food systems with remote Indigenous Australians: Stakeholders' perspectives

Defining the indefinable: Descriptors of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples' cultures and their links to health and wellbeing

Historical and current perspectives on the health of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people

New Zealand's experience of the 1918-19 influenza pandemic: A systematic review after 100 years

COVID-19 and Indigenous peoples

Why Indigenous funerals are bypassing coronavirus social distancing rules

Wāhine Māori keeping safe in unsafe relationships

Leaders detail concerns about COVID-19 impacts on Indigenous populations

COVID-19: Review Indigenous peoples' data