key: cord-0078788-7ol4qd1l authors: Gioseffi, Janaína Rosenburg; Batista, Ramaiene; Brignol, Sandra Mara title: Tuberculosis, vulnerabilities, and HIV in homeless persons: a systematic review date: 2022-05-18 journal: Rev Saude Publica DOI: 10.11606/s1518-8787.2022056003964 sha: 682175bc3aed232e95d883189ec9c0cfcd8d451c doc_id: 78788 cord_uid: 7ol4qd1l OBJECTIVE: Analyze, systematize, and compile social, individual, and programmatic vulnerability factors associated with tuberculosis and HIV in homeless persons. METHODS: This is a systematic literature review assessing quantitative studies, published between 2014 and 2020, on the prevalence of tuberculosis in homeless persons. Our review grouped studies according to vulnerabilities, followed the PRISMA recommendation guide, and used the Joanna Briggs Institute Critical Appraisal tool for bias analysis. RESULTS: Of the 372 publications found, 16 were selected according to our eligibility criteria. In total, 10 studies assessed tuberculosis and HIV. The most commonly described factors for individual, social, and programmatic vulnerability were drug use, HIV coinfection, and tuberculosis treatment failure, respectively. The literature also claims that average homelessness length related to a higher frequency of tuberculosis and latent tuberculosis infection. CONCLUSION: All reviewed studies described how homeless persons suffer with stigma and dehumanization, which are important barriers to their access to health services. Homelessness enhances the risks of chronic and infectious diseases and prioritizes issues which are more pragmatic for the maintenance of life, such as safety and food, to the detriment of health. The results can be used to support hypotheses for future research and to reinforce and direct existing public health and social policies to cope with tuberculosis and HIV in homeless persons. Tuberculosis is a respiratory disease caused by the agent Mycobacterium tuberculosis. It is currently among the 10 most lethal diseases in the world and the first, among infectious diseases 1 . Its transmission occurs by inhalation of aerosols leading to a granulomatous infection in the lower respiratory tract 2 . Its occurrence is associated with socioeconomic factors since, according to the UN, 95% of cases occur in low-and middle-income countries 3 . Africa and the Americas 1 are at the top of the ranking of estimated cases and deaths for the disease. The global estimate of tuberculosis infection was 10 million cases in 2020, with an estimated incidence of 132/100,000 inhabitants, and 1.2 million deaths, of which 208,000 among people who are HIV+ 1 . The END TB strategy, proposed by the World Health Organization, aims to reduce the incidence of tuberculosis to less than 10/100,000 inhabitants and decrease the number of deaths by at least 95% so tuberculosis could no longer be considered a global public health problem 4 . In Brazil, tuberculosis is an important health problem, with a death rate of 2.2/100,000 and an incidence of 31.6/100,000 inhabitants 5 . The Sistema Único de Saúde (SUS -Brazilian Unified Health System) promotes specific programs to combat it, such as the Programa Nacional de Controle da Tuberculose (National Tuberculosis Control Program) and the establishment of treatment directly managed by the basic health network 6 . However, patient adherence is low 7 , and treatment abandonment and wrong or intermittent medication administration cause the number of deaths to remain high and the emergence of drug-resistant strands 7 . Homeless persons (HP) are constantly exposed to different types of vulnerable and degrading living conditions, increasing the challenge for health care and requiring specific interventions for these people 4, 8 . As a result of this exposure and the precarization of their lives, tuberculosis in HP is very frequent. This population is 56 times more likely to be affected by this disease in Brazil. This vulnerabilization has three dimensions 9 : 1) Individual -determined by individuals' access to information; their ability to put it into practice; and material, cultural, cognitive, and moral aspects -among many others participating in the construction of the human "being"; 2) Social -guided by social and cultural contexts and 3) programmatic -scenarios concerning social institutions (especially health, education, culture, and social assistance) which enable unfavorable contexts to increase these social conditions. Treating tuberculosis in HP is more expensive and complex than in the rest of the population due to their lower treatment adherence, according to the Evidence Informed Policy Network of the Brazilian Ministry of Health 4 . Moreover, issues such as safety, food, and rest, compete in importance with health care. In addition to tuberculosis, HIV/Aids, dermatological diseases (including leprosy), and hypertension are the main diseases in this population. Psychosocial treatment due to drug and alcohol abuse is also prominent 10 . Homeless persons live marginalized and distant from public policies and lack the effective exercise of their basic rights, including access to medical primary care in SUS 11 . Worldwide, tuberculosis is the leading cause of death in HIV-positive individuals, accounting for one third of their deaths 12 . People with HIV are 28 times more likely to become infected with tuberculosis 13 , a coinfection responsible for almost 29% of deaths from tuberculosis in Brazil 14 . In 2018, he incidence of tuberculosis in HIV-positive patients was 5.2/100,000 inhabitants in Brazil. In the same year, of the new cases of tuberculosis, 75.5% were tested for HIV and, among the affected, only 47.4% underwent antiretroviral treatment concomitantly with tuberculosis treatment 15 . Due to the technological advances in tuberculosis and HIV/Aids treatment and the commitments made by World Health Organization member countries, this scenario is Bias in the evaluated studies was assessed in pairs, using the Joanna Briggs Institute Critical Appraisal (JBI -Systematic Reviews tools). JBI is composed of questions assessing the methodological quality of a study according to its design. Cross-sectional studies were evaluated with the JBI Critical Appraisal Checklist for Analytical Cross Sectional Studies with the following questions: (i) clearly defined inclusion and exclusion criteria; (ii) theme and method described in detail; (iii) appropriately measured exposures; (iv) objective and standardized definition criteria to determine the condition studied; (v) confounding factor identification; (vi) strategies to deal with confounding factors; (vii) adequately measured outcomes; and (viii) appropriate statistical analyses 18 . To analyze cohort studies, 11 questions of the JBI Critical Appraisal Checklist for Analytical Cohort Studies were used: (i) both groups recruited from the same population; (ii) exposures similarly measured to identify exposed and unexposed groups; (iii) appropriately measured exposures; (iv) confounding factor identification; (v) strategies for dealing with confounding factors; (vi) participants free of outcomes at baseline; (vii) appropriately measured outcomes; (viii) sufficient time to study outcome occurrence; (ix) complete follow-ups/if not, described and explored reasons for it; (x) strategies to deal with incomplete follow-ups; and (xi) appropriate statistical analyses 19 . inclusion and exclusion criteria; (iii) theme and method described in detail; (iv) objective and standardized definition criteria to determine the condition studied; (v) appropriately measured exposures; (vi) confounding factor identification; (vii) strategies to deal with confounding factors; (viii) appropriately measured outcomes; (ix) efforts to reduce the possibility of bias; (x) appropriate statistical analyses; (xi) strategies to deal with incomplete follow-ups; and (xii) highlighted limitations 18, 20 . We found 374 studies in the researched platforms, selecting 103 published within the study period and excluding two since they were official government documents for public policies, 23 for being duplicates, and nine because they were not indexed for full reading. Finally, 71 studies remained for analysis. We read their abstracts and browsed the entire articles, selecting 16 according to our eligibility criteria. Most studies were conducted in Europe (6/16), followed by Asia (3/16), North America (4/16), South America (2/16) -of which one was Brazilian, and Africa (1/16) (Figure) . In total, seven were cross-sectional studies; eight, cohort; and one, ecological. To this, we added the average of 2.7 studies published annually in the years analyzed, with a minimum of one and a maximum of four papers published each year. We collected our sample between June 2019 and April 2021 and all data were entered into a Microsoft Excel spreadsheet containing the authors, study population, year of publication, country of publication, and study design. Among the selected articles, we found the following vulnerability factors for their outcomes: alcohol use 21-28 ; smoking 21, 22, 25, 28, 29 ; use of illicit drugs 21, 24, [26] [27] [28] [29] [30] [31] , such as injectable ones 21,27-29 -which may have caused needle sharing 29,30 -and methamphetamine 29 ; history of incarceration 21, 29 ; immigration 26, 32, 33 ; psychological disorders 24, 28, 30 ; prostitution 29 , including among men who have sex with men; illiteracy 22, 29 ; malnutrition 22 ; HIV coinfection 21, 22, [24] [25] [26] [27] [28] [29] 34 ; and other chronic diseases, such as diabetes 27,28 , chronic renal failure 27,28 , and hepatitis B and C 21,28,29 . 23 In all analyzed studies, most patients with tuberculosis were Black or mixed-race men 24, 28, 30, 32 , with a mean age of 49.8 years (SD ± 5.2). The literature shows that average homelessness length related to a higher occurrence of tuberculosis and latent tuberculosis infection 21, 22, 29 . Table 3 shows the outcomes related to the occurrence of tuberculosis and latent tuberculosis infection: incomplete treatment 22, 24, 25, 27, 28, 30, 31, 34, 35 or its failure 2,24,26 , death 22, 24, 25, 27, 30, 31, 34 , development of treatment-resistance 22, [25] [26] [27] [28] [29] , and occurrence of extrapulmonary tuberculosis 22, 26, 27 . The main diagnostic tools were sputum cytology 22, 24, 26, 27, 29, 31 , thoracic X-rays 24, 27, 33 , culture 27,29-31 , molecular examination 27 , and clinical diagnosis 27 . Among the 16 publications analyzed, 10 described the association between tuberculosis comorbidities and HIV. In Semunigus et al. 22 , the proportion of coinfection reached 55.5%. According to Dias et al. 26 , HIV-positive people were 2.1 times more likely to have an unfavorable outcome. Moreover, 32.6% of participants showed some comorbidity. In Ranzani et al. 24 , 17.3% of homeless persons were HIV positive. According to Agarwal et al. 27 , 16% of participants with tuberculosis were HIV positive and the chance ratio for mortality in these individuals was 3.57 higher than for those who were HIV negative. In Hwang et al. 25 , 5.7% showed tuberculosis+HIV coinfections. In Amiri et al. 29 , 1.2% of HP were HIV positive and had a latent tuberculosis infection, a similar proportion (1.8%) to the one in Nwana et al. 28 Gomez et al. 31 found that 20.6% of HP had comorbidities. Vieira et al. 23 report that a 100-case increase of HIV+tuberculosis coinfection in the general population raises the incidence of tuberculosis among homeless persons to 14 cases per 100,000 inhabitants. The only HIV+ patient in Dolla et al. 34 died. Regarding biases, most studies showed dissimilar recruited groups 24, 25, 36 , confounding factor identification 26, 27, 29, 30, [33] [34] [35] [36] , strategies to deal with these factors 26, 27, 29, 30, [32] [33] [34] [35] [36] or incomplete participant follow-ups 25, 26, 36 . Few studies indicated their limitations 24, 26, 28, 29, 31, 34 and those that did showed flaws in how they described their methodology and results 29, 30, 32, 36 . We can observe a recurrence between alcohol, tobacco, and illicit drug consumption results -factors of individual susceptibility and social vulnerability (due to the stigma associated with addiction) -whether to escape the reality of suffering or to seek an improvement in general well-being 37, 38 . Thus, this vulnerability overlap may increase exposure to tuberculosis and HIV in the study population. Gender, age, coinfection by other communicable diseases, and history of incarceration are also factors which arouse discrimination in our society, albeit at different levels. Since it is a very important global public health problem (even listed among the Sustainable Development Goals), some methodological flaws in these studies draw our attention, such as their small sample size, weakening their results and conclusions; lack of direct access to tuberculosis-positive patients 29 ; underestimation of the actual number of homeless persons 24, 26 and of the incidence and prevalence of tuberculosis in this population 26, 34 ; and a sample composed only of people with tuberculosis 24 , excluding extrapulmonary forms of the illness. Constant drug use can lead to the development of mental disorders, as stated in the last World Drug Report in 2020 from the United Nations Office of Drugs and Crime (UNODC). In total, two publications 24,30 described the variable "mental disorder," evincing its constant occurrence in the study samples. The break with family members either due to maladaptation to their structural model, a history of violence and harassment or unacceptance of reprehensible forms of sustenance and their own addiction, expose these people to social and individual vulnerability since they are unable to count on their families at a difficult time 39, 40 . https://doi.org/10.11606/s1518-8787.2022056003964 The State attempts to reduce social vulnerability by implementing income transfer programs to decrease the number of people below the poverty line and give them better feeding conditions 41 . This important measure is considered programmatic and affects social vulnerability and should be expanded as it can reduce the vulnerability of people below the poverty line. Since vulnerability dimensions may overlap or intersect, this helps to broaden the epidemiological view on the ways of getting sick and alert managers to health issues, resulting in a more qualified confrontation of these problems in HP. Producing vulnerable and non-integrable lives forces HP to continuously live with access barriers to education, work, and health care and services, among others, in addition to their invisibility, which can lead some of them to engage in activities such as prostitution, association with trafficking, theft, and labor analogous to slavery. Social vulnerability also involves characteristics marked by lower social classes, residence, and Black ethnicity, among others. Studies showed a 63.6% proportion of Black and mixed-race people among their results. The average age of participants is 49.8 years (SD ± 5.2), probably due to their greater spatial mobility, when compared to women or people of different age groups such as older adults, who move less through the streets, exposing themselves less in their journeys 42 . History of incarceration was frequent among the reviewed studies. The prison system, tasked with rehabilitating and reinserting convicts into society, fails to do so due to the stigma inmates carry after their sentences are fulfilled either by society in general or by absent family support or unemployment. Thus, many lack the monetary resources to continue their lives, resorting to homelessness and sometimes engaging in illegal activities, which are incapable of breaking the recidivism cycle 43 . According to a ranking conducted by the World Prison Brief (2021) 44 , Brazil has the third largest prison population in the world, a fact intrinsically linked to structural racism and, consequently, to the systematic marginalization of Black and mixed-race people, who comprise 61.7% of inmates 45 . Thus, we can observe that these vulnerability factors related to social, racial, and economic impacts are perpetuated in the most vulnerable populations. This dimension, related to access to State public and institutional equipment, proved to be an important dimension to analyze vulnerable populations' susceptibilities to tuberculosis and HIV in epidemiological studies 46 , as it evinces the precariousness and fragility of these resources. Incomplete treatment and the development of resistance to medication are included in this dimension, as they show the failure of the health system to provide adequate therapy, information, and structure to treat these patients 47 . Among its consequences is coinfection with other diseases since homelessness and environmental exposure enhance the risks for some chronic and infectious diseases 38 once priority issues for the maintenance of life, such as safety and food, are more urgent than health care. Due to access barriers, health care is relegated to the background or received only when opportune 38, 48 . According to the Institute of Applied Economic Research, Brazil had more than 100,000 homeless persons in 2016 49 . Due to the Brazilian socioeconomic perspective, including the covid-19 pandemic allied to the current economic and political scenario, Brazil witnessed an increase in poverty and the number of HP 50 . Among its consequences, we can observe, in the short term, an increase of tuberculosis in HP and other vulnerable populations, such as lowincome families, favela dwellers or residents of precarious housing 51 since Brazil already has experienced an increase in poverty and misery, as have other Latin American countries 50, 52 . Our perspective of the concept of vulnerability allowed us to assess that the results found in the analyzed publications evinced the social and programmatic factors associated with tuberculosis and HIV in HP, highlighting the different dimensions of life and healthcare precarization. Thus, this concept was a fundamental support to classify and understand the different susceptibilities permeating HP's life and hindering the treatment of tuberculosis and HIV, as well as treatment failures due to discontinuity and, consequently, the appearance of drug-resistant strains. Even with established protocols, guidelines, ordinances, and technical standards to prevent and treat HP's health, we noticed that the execution of the action plans outlined by government strategies shows important flaws, evincing weaknesses in the health system and public policies aimed at HP, and the stigma and social prejudices health services reproduce. Thus, some lives are more exposed to vulnerability situations and consequently show less access to prevention and protection and are more susceptible to violence from the State and society than others. This is due to various crossings marking these lives as more vulnerable and often unrecognized and invisible. Based on the results of this review, we recommend greater attention and investment in improving prevention actions and interventions for tuberculosis and tuberculosis+HIV in HP since primary care to routinely assess homeless persons' vulnerabilities. We also suggest that managers and technicians evaluate the need to change and adjust primary care protocols for HP and integrally distribute resources to the demands which are already known and shown in this study. Political effort and commitment are also necessary to distribute resources destined to health, social policies, and HP assistance. Systematizing vulnerability factors can support hypotheses for future research and subsidize public health and social policies to cope with tuberculosis and HIV in HP. Our findings, when compared to other systematic reviews, seem to advance the literature by its discussion from a perspective of the concept of vulnerability, unprecedented in national publications, for homeless persons and the prevalence of tuberculosis and tuberculosis+HIV. World Health Organization. Global tuberculosis report 2020: executive summary. Geneva (CH): WHO Microbiologia veterinária e doenças infecciosas ONU quer acabar com epidemia de tuberculose até 2030. ONU News Adesão ao tratamento de tuberculose pela população em situação de rua Secretaria de Vigilância em Saúde Casa Civil, Subchefia para Assuntos Jurídicos. Emenda Constitucional Nº 95, de 15 de dezembro de 2016. Altera o Ato das Disposições Constitucionais Transitórias, para instituir o Novo Regime Fiscal, e dá outras providências Tratamento da tuberculose O conceito de vulnerabilidade e seus sentidos para as políticas públicas de saúde e assistência social Vulnerability human rights, and comprehensive health care needs of young people living with HIV/AIDS Política Nacional para Inclusão Social da População em Situação de Rua Rua: aprendendo a contar. Pesquisa Nacional sobre População em Situação de Rua Globais sobre HIV 2020 Brasil Livre da Tuberculose: evolução dos cenários epidemiológicos e operacionais da doença Factors associated with underreporting of tuberculosis based on data from Sinan Aids and Sinan TB Panorama epidemiológico da coinfecção TB-HIV no Brasil Tuberculose: pesquisas e melhorias no tratamento intensificam o combate à doença Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA satement Systematic reviews of etiology and risk Systematic reviews of etiology and risk The quality of modern cross-sectional ecologic studies: a bibliometric review High prevalence of latent tuberculosis and bloodborne virus infection in a homeless population Smear positive pulmonary tuberculosis and associated factors among homeless individuals in Dessie and Debre Birhan towns Tuberculosis incidence rate among the homeless population: the impact of socio-demographic and health-related variables The impact of being homeless on the unsuccessful outcome of treatment of pulmonary TB in São Paulo State, Brazil Epidemiology and clinical outcomes of tuberculosis among homeless persons visiting emergency department in public hospital Tuberculosis among the homeless: should we change the strategy? Homelessness and mortality among persons with tuberculosis in Texas Treatment of latent Mycobacterium tuberculosis infection with 12 once weekly directly-observed doses of isoniazid and rifapentine among persons experiencing homelessness Vulnerability of homeless people in Tehran, Iran, to HIV, tuberculosis and viral hepatitis Outbreak of drugresistant Mycobacterium tuberculosis among homeless people in Homelessness and HIV: a combination predictive of poor tuberculosis treatment outcomes and in need of innovative strategies to improve treatment completion Analysis of risk factors for tuberculous infection following exposure at a homeless shelter Prevalence of latent tuberculosis in homeless persons: a single-centre cross-sectional study Tuberculosis among the homeless in Chennai city, South India Siemion-Szcześniak I. Tuberculosis in homeless persons in Poland Tuberculosis among the homeless and inmates kept in custody and in penitentiary institutions in the Silesia region Itinerário terapêutico de doentes com tuberculose vivendo em situação de rua no Rio de Janeiro Pessoas que vivenciam situação de rua sob o olhar da saúde Dando uma moral": moralidades, prazeres e poderes no caminho da cura da tuberculose na população em situação de rua no município de São Paulo Práticas de saúde em contextos de vulnerabilização e negligência de doenças, sujeitos e territórios: potencialidades e contradições na atenção à saúde de pessoas em situação de rua História natural e apresentação clínica Tuberculose e indicadores socioeconômicos: Revisão sistemática da literatura Estigma e reinserção do preso na sociedade World Prison Brief Sistema carcerário brasileiro: negros e pobres na prisão. Brasília, DF: CDHM Pode o conceito de vulnerabilidade apoiar a construção do conhecimento em Saúde Coletiva? Cienc Saude Coletiva Vulnerabilidade e direitos humanos: prevenção e promoção da saúde. Livro I: Da doença à cidadania Tuberculosis control from the perspective of health professionals working in street clinics Estimativa da população em situação de rua no Brasil. Brasília, DF: IPEA Para 43% dos brasileiros, número de moradores de rua aumentou. Folha de São Paulo Spatial distribution and socioeconomic context of tuberculosis in Rio de Janeiro Comisión Económica para América Latina y el Caribe. El COVID-19 y la crisis socioeconómica em América Latina y Caribe Funding: Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior (Capes -Demanda Social grant for JRG This study has limitations since, even if its two researchers conducted a wide search of the published studies, a number of texts may yet be digitally unavailable on the surveyed platforms; due to the quick dynamic of publishing, some studies may have escaped search and data collection.