key: cord-0072315-4x6dh6cs
authors: Arabshahi, Mona; Wang, Di; Sun, Junbo; Rahnamayiezekavat, Payam; Tang, Weichen; Wang, Yufei; Wang, Xiangyu
title: Review on Sensing Technology Adoption in the Construction Industry
date: 2021-12-12
journal: Sensors (Basel)
DOI: 10.3390/s21248307
sha: 52e6b2a0fd7b1959bce79fee8ebd6c06e3bd679c
doc_id: 72315
cord_uid: 4x6dh6cs

Sensing technologies demonstrate promising potential in providing the construction industry with a safe, productive, and high-quality process. The majority of sensing technologies in the construction research area have been focused on construction automation research in prefabrication, on-site operation, and logistics. However, most of these technologies are either not implemented in real construction projects or are at the very early stages in practice. The corresponding applications are far behind, even in extensively researched aspects such as Radio Frequency Identification, ultra-wideband technology, and Fiber Optic Sensing technology. This review systematically investigates the current status of sensing technologies in construction from 187 articles and explores the reasons responsible for their slow adoption from 69 articles. First, this paper identifies common sensing technologies and investigates their implementation extent. Second, contributions and limitations of sensing technologies are elaborated to understand the current status. Third, key factors influencing the adoption of sensing technologies are extracted from construction stakeholders’ experience. Demand towards sensing technologies, benefits and suitability of them, and barriers to their adoption are reviewed. Lastly, the governance framework is determined as the research tendency facilitating sensing technologies adoption. This paper provides a theoretical basis for the governance framework development. It will promote the sensing technologies adoption and improve construction performance including safety, productivity, and quality.

Data collection is crucial in management owing to the complexity and dynamic nature of construction projects [1, 2] . However, the conventional data collection process cannot meet the increasing requirements of modern construction management due to the defects in automation and cost [3] . Thereby, Automated Data Collection (ADC) methodologies are in great demand, which could reduce human errors and benefit projects on planning, procurement, control, construction, and management [4, 5] . As a base for ADC methodologies, sensing technology is promising in improving data collection and ongoing monitoring [6] . To a large extent, sensing technology can instantly collect and permanently store environment data, revolutionizing data collection, transmission, and analysis in the construction industry. Meanwhile, sensing technology introduces innovative technologies including Information Technology (IT) and digital construction sites, in which sensing technologies promote construction safety and productivity.

Sensing technologies have been academically researched, but their adoption has been challenged by technology-related, adoption process-related, and human-related factors [7, 8] . First, inadequate understanding and neglect of automatic sensing technologies restrict real project adoption, despite great benefits in securing construction safety [9] . Taneja et al. [10] claimed the necessity of educating construction practitioners on sensing technologies. Second, information on in-use sensing technologies such as Real-Time Locating Systems (RTLS) is insufficient [11, 12] . Specifically, the deployment, time, cost, and accuracy of sensing technologies need to be emphasized [13] [14] [15] . Third, perceptions of construction stakeholders toward sensing technologies and decision-making criteria for their adoption are scarce [16] . Odubiyi et al. [7] concluded human-related factors were critical in construction adoption, highlighting the perceptions from construction stakeholders. Fourth, research on the acceptance of sensing technologies by construction workers is insufficient. According to the previous research on ADC, acceptance of sensing technologies by construction workers has been ignored in the human-related factors [4] . Fifth, Sepasgozar et al. [17] reported that a thorough understanding of procedures to introduce new technologies into existing systems is a critical factor to facilitate the adoption of sensing technologies in construction. In summary, the current status of sensing technologies and factors restricting their adoption are not yet clear.

This review investigates the current status of sensing technologies and explores the factors influencing their adoption. Previous research mostly focuses on one single group of technologies. Schall et al. [18] have studied the barriers to the adoption of wearable sensors in the workplace. In addition, Usman et al. [19] have analyzed the information and communication technology innovation for construction site management. However, this paper was dedicated to general sensing technologies rather than specific types of sensors. To begin with, common sensing technologies are classified and reported according to their features on safety, quality, and productivity. Of 187 potential articles on types of sensing technologies and their applications in construction, 127 were selected to classify technologies based on their applications. Additionally, their applications and limitations are carefully studied to understand their application status. Then, factors influencing the adoption of various types of digital technologies are extracted from construction stakeholders' perceptions about the demand, benefits, suitability, and barriers of such technologies. Compared with previous research on ADC, acceptance of sensing technologies by construction workers is added to the review of the human-related factors [4] . Of 69 articles relevant to the adoption of technology, 47 were subsequently analyzed to identify factors affecting the adoption of sensing technologies in construction. Finally, a conclusion is summarized that the governance framework is in great demand for facilitating sensing technology adoption. The governance framework highlights the sensing technology benefits, decision-making considerations, and construction-specific expectations while specifying barriers to deal with. In future research, influential factors uniquely related to sensing technologies and common factors between sensing technologies and other digital technologies need to be separated. This review will facilitate the sensing technologies adoption then improve the construction industry on safety, quality, and productivity.

The method used for the literature review took place in seven sequential steps. These steps are "scope definition and clarification", "a literature search" to find potential relevant resources, "a preliminary literature analysis" and "relevant literature selection" to identify and shortlist relevant literature, "detailed literature analysis" to extract related materials, "classification of the findings" for the sake of easy reporting, and finally, "reporting the results". The process followed for the literature review in this chapter is presented in Figure 1 , which also specifies the number of articles identified and shortlisted for both the current status of sensing technologies in construction and the factors affecting their adoption. Of 187 potential articles on types of sensing technologies and their applications in construction, 127 were selected to classify technologies based on their applications. Of 69 articles relevant to the adoption of technology, 47 were subsequently analyzed to identify factors affecting the adoption of sensing technologies in construction. 

Location-based sensing technologies, also known as Real-Time Locating Systems (RTLS), are based on wireless technologies including Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, Global Positioning System (GPS), Radio Frequency Identification (RFID), and ultra-wideband (UWB) technology. RTLS are effective in construction management on the process, safety, and on-site resource through locating and tracking construction materials [12, 20] . These systems are also effective in situational awareness enhancement [21, 22] , quantitative hazard exposure analysis [23, 24] , and behavior-based safety monitoring [25] . The data collection, information processing, and application framework of RTLS are presented in Figure 2 . However, they still have shortcomings such as weak signal, high cost, and low accuracy [14] . The applications and limitations of the most common technologies are investigated as follows. 

GPS is the most prevalent location-based sensing technology realizing powerful capabilities through satellites [1] . The main components contain the space segment, the control segment, and the user segment. The space segment sets 24 satellites, at least four of which must be visible from a given point on the Earth at any time for most applications. The control segment consists of one master control station, five monitor stations, and four ground antennae to track the satellites and calibrate the clocks. The user segment is made up of the user using a GPS receiver to determine his location based on a received signal. Great improvements resulting from GPS in construction safety are summarized in Table 1 . However, the GPS application is also hampered by data delays in transmission, low performance in congested areas, and signal blockage in indoor environments [6, 27] . Table 1 . GPS technology in construction safety enhancement.

Reference proximity detection of workers on foot and construction equipment [26] unsafe proximity detection identification [28, 29] construction equipment management [30, 31] situational awareness improvement of on-site workers [32] construction resources identification [33] enhancement of tower crane navigation systems [34] construction equipment activity recognition [35, 36] Radio Frequency Identification (RFID) Technology RFID technology identifies objects through radio waves, reading digital data encoded in RFID tags without direct contact or line-of-sight. The advanced technology is more efficient in tracking materials and equipment compared to traditional barcode systems [37] . An RFID system usually consists of a reader transmitting radio waves, radio frequency tags attached to items, and a software system managing collected information [38] . Furthermore, the RFID system obtains versatile tag categories to satisfy construction demands. An active tag equips a built-in power source enabling the tag to transmit data on its own. Passive tags are more popular than active tags as they are smaller and cheaper. RFID technology presents great performance on both outdoor and indoor construction projects, where satellite position information is unavailable [39, 40] . For instance, RFID technology can secure construction safety when the gate crane driver cannot observe the workers at the bottom of the tunnel shaft [41] . The RFID tags on helmets and RFID readers around this area will generate safety warnings for the potential hazard during vertical transportation ( Figure 3) . Then, the nearby workers would be informed to leave this hoisting area. Other utilities of RFID technology in reducing safety risks are summarized in Table 2 . The RFID system has been identified as the most popular sensing technology among all RTLS, although its adoption is still slow [37] . Some limitations restrict the RFID technology application including simultaneous identification of multiple tags and range issues due to metal obstacles. 

Reference risky behavior of workers recognition [41] accidents and collision prevention [42] [43] [44] proximity detection alert systems [45] storage of safety information [46] controls of workers and vehicles to specific positions [47] indoor localization of mobile and stationary construction resources [48, 49] detection of construction workers localization [50] Ultra-Wideband (UWB) Technology UWB technology monitors construction resources and materials by high-bandwidth radio communications. The advanced technology has been used in locating hazard zones, avoiding collision, and increasing situational awareness [51] [52] [53] . Teizer et al. [54] validated the outstanding functions of UWB technology in obstacle avoidance and field personnel tracking. Experiments employing UWB technology in workforce and materials monitoring is demonstrated in Figure 4 . UWB technology exhibits great performance in interior construction sites and harsh environments, even where wooden materials block signals [55] [56] [57] . However, metal blockage reduces the effect of UWB technology [58, 59] . The function of UWB technology is also weakened by range issues over long distances, missing data, possible calibration difficulties, and limited update rates [6] . 

Vision-based sensing technologies range from well-established technology photographs and video recordings to contemporary technology laser scanning, benefit safety management. Photographs and video recordings technology promotes decision making of operations, blind lifts of tower cranes, and communication between project network and work-front operations [60] [61] [62] . Laser scanners capture detailed geometries and environmental conditions through laser signals emitted from a rotating laser photon source [10] . The scanners are used in intensifying situational awareness of crane operators [21] , simulating construction sites [63] , and monitoring the construction activities [11, 64, 65] . The hazardous situation of workers and equipment measured using a 3D laser scanner is demonstrated in Figure 5 . However, laser scanning technology is not suitable for moving objects or providing information about colors, textures, and materials. Other factors also restrict the implementation, including a clear line-of-sight requirement, long data processing time, and high data storage capacity. 

WSN technologies enable wireless communication between sensors and data recording devices. Common sensors applied in WSN to improve construction safety management include temperature sensors, displacement sensors, light sensors, pressure sensors, and Fiber Optic Sensing (FOS) [67] [68] [69] . For instance, FOS technology measures temperature, strain, and pressure by the transmission of light through an optical fiber [70] [71] [72] . It is completely immune to electromagnetic interference and capable of functioning in hostile surroundings [73, 74] . Meanwhile, fiber optic sensors are user-friendly devices with an elevated sensitivity which makes them suitable for detecting crack damage in concrete structures [75] [76] [77] . Fibre Bragg grating (FBG) sensor is one type of FOS which realizes real-time temperature monitoring and displacement measurement, such as tunnel segments [78] [79] [80] . The utilization of WSN technology supports construction safety greatly, which is summarized in Table 3 . 

OHS is a major division of construction safety management in which sensing technologies contribute to remarkable improvements. Articles on sensing and warning technologies have increased exponentially since 2016, indicating that sensing technologies are effective in OHS ( Figure 6 ). OHS is strengthened by vision-based sensing technologies comprising Closed-Circuit Television (CCTV), video cameras, range cameras, and built-in sensors of smartphones [90, 91] . Methods of the above technologies to assess the effects of wearing hard hats are demonstrated in Table 4 . Additionally, RFID technology secures OHS by checking the presence and compliance of personal protective equipment. Moreover, wearable sensors and environmental sensors have been a focus of research in securing OHS [92] . Wearable devices could simply be available devices such as smartwatches and wristbands which integrate various sensors for monitoring of workers' health [93, 94] . Specific devices such as a chest sensor recording heart rate and heart rate variability are also included in wearable sensing technologies. The effects of wearable sensing technologies in promoting OHS are demonstrated as follows. 

Physiological wearable sensing devices benefit OHS through emotional wellbeing monitoring, physical workload and fatigue monitoring, and posture detection [99] . Electroencephalograms (EEGs) monitor stress levels, mental fatigue, emotional states, and attention level [100, 101] by tracking and recording brain wave patterns. EEGs provide a base for investigating and addressing any psychological problems of construction workers and, therefore, avoid unsafe behaviors. In addition, electrocardiograms (ECGs) used in chest sensors monitor heart rate and variability of construction workers [102] . Wristband-type heart rate monitoring devices are also used to capture significant variations in physical demands [94, 103] , estimate energy expenditure [102] , and track heart rate [104, 105] . Furthermore, ECG, EEGs, and infrared temperature sensors are combined for real-time monitoring of physical fatigue in construction workers [106] . Moreover, surface electromyography monitors the spinal biomechanics of a construction workforce by measuring the electrical activities of muscles. It secures OHS of construction workforces exposed to repetitive lifting tasks and tying rebars [107, 108] .

Wearable sensing technologies attached to PPE realize safety risk detection and health monitoring. To begin with, Inertial Measurement Units (IMUs) are the most common motion sensors in PPE to detect awkward postures [109] , gait abnormalities [110] , and fall-risk assessments [111] . IMU-based wearable motion capture system (Perception Neuron) used in acquiring experiment data is exhibited in Figure 7 . Furthermore, pressure sensors and three-axis accelerometers are valid in assessing the PPE wearing effect [112, 113] . Moreover, dust sensors can monitor fine particle concentration and protect workers against excessive respirable dust [114, 115] . Lastly, Adjiski et al. [116] proposed a prototype system, which was an outstanding example of different sensors integrated into a system and attached to PPE. In the system, helmets and safety glasses were equipped with sensors connected with smartphones and smartwatches (Figure 8 ). Sensors used in the system included gas sensors, dust sensors, sound sensors, smoke sensors, temperature sensors, accelerometers, gyroscopes, magnetometers, heart rate sensor measures, and cameras. The prototype system designed to secure OHS during mining operations also meets requirements on other underground construction operations. 

Sensing technology can also improve construction quality management. FBG technology realizes real-time and convenient quality control for asphalt mixture compaction operation during lab experiments (Figure 9 ). An FBG sensor consists of a compression end, sensing part, fixed end, and supporting legs [117, 118] . The compression end is regarded as a load-bearing plate that can make the FBG sensor deform coordinately well with asphalt pavement. The sensing part is made up of a core with gratings and core-protecting materials. Fixed end and supporting legs are used for fixing sensing parts and making the sensor stand stable, respectively. FOS technology is effective in monitoring temperature and stress/strain variation of reinforced concrete structures during construction [119] [120] [121] . Furthermore, RFID technology facilitates construction quality controls by assisting with monitoring of concrete curing progress and material quality assurance [122, 123] . Moreover, temperature sensors measure the internal temperature of in-place concrete in real-time during the early curing stages and assess the strength [124] . Finally, laser scanning technology prevents the failure of precast concrete elements by identifying deviations of prefabricated modules and assessing precast concrete quality [125, 126] . 

Construction productivity benefits from optimizing scheduling, cutting back on construction time and cost, and reducing construction waste. Real-time progress reporting of construction activities can overcome cost overruns and scheduling delays. However, conventional data collection processes are labor-intensive, costly, and error-prone. Remote sensing technologies have been proposed to achieve an automated data acquisition platform to improve construction productivity.

GPS technology obtains multiple potential applications comprising resource localization and materials tracking to increase construction productivity [127] [128] [129] . For instance, GPS technology collects and provides real-time information of a delivery fleet to reduce productivity loss and idleness [59, 130] . Similarly, position tracking of key personnel is also achieved through RFID technology to save cost and time [131, 132] . Fang et al. [48] concluded that the BIM and cloud-enabled RFID indoor localization solution had great potential in asset management and productivity monitoring. The cloud-enabled remote monitoring user interface is demonstrated in Figure 10 . Moreover, GPS and RFID technologies are combined to realize automated tracking of construction resources, which is beneficial in construction productivity monitoring [133] . Applications of RFID technology in increasing construction productivity are demonstrated in Table 5 . (b) cloud-enabled remote monitoring user interface [48] . Table 5 . RFID technology in construction productivity enhancement.

construction waste management and machinery maintenance records [13] identification of construction material and resources [33] recognition of construction staff location [131] automatic progress reports [134, 135] operational cost reduction in precast construction supply chain [136] material localization, monitoring, and tracking [137] [138] [139] active information flow between construction progress and material monitoring staff [140, 141] applications in time and schedule management [142] supply network visibility [143, 144] asset management and supply chain management [145, 146] 

Video cameras can monitor and track construction resources to improve construction productivity [147, 148] . Three-dimensional (3D) laser scanning technology combined with schedule information can result in more effective and efficient tracking of construction progress than manual works [149] . 3D point clouds, project 3D computer-aided design (CAD) model, and schedule information are combined to track construction progress. First, 3D laser scanning data provides current site conditions. Second, the 3D CAD model combined with schedule information (the project 4D model) provides designed spatial characteristics of the facility under construction over time (Figure 11) . A time-stamped 3D CAD model can thus be formed automatically for a given date with such a 4D model. The 3D point clouds and the 4D model must be registered in the same coordinate system to extract useful data for progress tracking. Once registered, as-built objects can be recognized, progress estimated, and the schedule updated all automatically. Moreover, vision-based sensing technologies are also used along with other technologies for a more robust accuracy in material tracking especially in congested and indoor construction sites. Construction productivity is significantly promoted by integrations such as Photogrammetry with GPS [150] or robotic total stations [151] , and the incorporation of video recording with UWB [152, 153] . 

Sensing technologies lack adoption in real construction projects, though they have been academically explored and proven to yield positive potential. Sepasgozar et al. [154] discovered the adoption process influenced emerging technologies promotion. The process was classified as new technologies identification, existing options cognition, and options comparison. Opinions from construction stakeholders are crucial factors in the process. Therefore, perceptions of construction managers and the acceptance of construction workers toward sensing technologies are in great demand. Emerging technologies will benefit from the investigation of factors determining the adoption process.

The decision-making process for adopting new technology is affected by the managers [155] . General awareness about the benefits, capabilities, and effects will contribute to an improved adoption process [156] . Resistance attributes to insufficient understanding and exposure [157] . In contrast, an understanding of market conditions and technology capabilities increases confidence about the adoption. However, sensing technologies have not yet been fully adopted into the construction industry. Perceptions toward other technologies are also worth exploring, such as Information Technology (IT), Information and Communication Technology (ICT), ADC, and Building Information Modeling (BIM) [158, 159] . The scope of the investigation is expanded beyond sensing technologies to extract as much information as possible.

Motivations for the construction industry to adopt digital technologies help discover the factors that can promote sensing technologies in construction. One significant motivation for new IT-based technologies is the competitive advantage in the market [160] . Most new technologies are problem-driven and solution-driven. Digital Twins (DT) create a digital replica of a physical object and synchronize data to achieve monitoring, simulating, and optimizing the physical object [161] . The visualization technology presents dynamic and complex information generated by DT, helping construction managers and on-site workers to make better decisions. New technologies also might be forced by external requirements, such as the request of clients, or compliance with regulations [162, 163] .

Sensing technologies employment can lead to savings both in terms of social costs and health costs. Therefore, future research should cover the relevant contents to contribute to the states and insurance companies to support the technology application. Analysis of the benefits in Table 6 will facilitate the sensing technologies adoption. Table 6 . Benefits of digital technologies according to construction stakeholders.

cost reduction [164] [165] [166] time-saving and improved productivity [167] [168] [169] reduced risk of injury and illness [170] increase employees' wellness and satisfaction [171] better document quality [172, 173] better facilities management [174] process and performance improvement [175, 176] improved leadership and decision support systems [177] mechanical enhancement on concrete printing [178] [179] [180] improved quality of construction project delivery [181] 3.

Barriers have been identified through the perceptions of stakeholders such as operating cost, lack of well-trained staff, and technology immaturity, etc. Odubiyi et al. [7] divided barriers in ICT into three broad categories related to technology, process, and people. Sardroud et al. [4] classified the barriers to ADC technologies into cost-related, processrelated, and technology-related issues. As most barriers are people-related, solutions will be found through an investigation on the factors that construction stakeholders perceive as barriers.

As a major barrier, the capital cost of implementation has been noted repeatedly [166] . Training costs, maintenance costs, and operating costs [164] are also key components in the barriers. Besides cost-related barriers, challenges related to people are also involved, such as a lack of interest and well-trained staff [157, 182] . In addition, technical complications such as lack of integrity, durability, and reliability negatively affect innovative technologies [18, 183] . Meanwhile, changes in the management process and complications in the construction site also influence technology adoption [182, 183] . Analysis of the barriers in Table 7 will promote the adoption of emerging technologies. Table 7 . Barriers to digital technology adoption according to construction stakeholders.

Reference Barriers Reference cost-related people-related operating cost [164] lack of well-trained staff [167] cost of training and employing professionals [177] compliance of employees [166] cost of maintenance [184] legal or ethical concerns [171] implementation cost [185] resistance to change [182] uncertain cost-benefit relation [186] company culture [187] lack of government support [188] technology-related other barriers operational difficulties [19, 189] manufacturing requirements [18] power supply issues [174] change in the process [182] data management issues [177] site-related issues [183] lack of proper IT infrastructure [182] temporary nature of construction [187] technology immaturity [183] 3.

User acceptance and trust-building are the two key components of the Internet of Things (IoT)-based technologies adoption in OHS [171] . Engineers, operating crews, and fitters are also consulted before adopting new technology, though managerial support affects employees' intentions to accept a new system [17] . The acceptance of construction workers has been investigated on IT, mobile computing devices, BIM, and wearable sensing technologies [190, 191] . Previous research studies, especially on wearable technologies, reported that privacy, security, and confidentiality were major concerns held by construction workers [18, 192] . Workers show great willingness to use wearable sensors if data is only collected during working hours [191] . Meanwhile, the top motivation of construction workers to accept wearable sensing technologies is to identify health risks and promote occupational safety [171] . Therefore, perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use are the two concepts dominating the literature on the acceptance of construction workers toward innovative technologies.

Perceived usefulness is the extent users believe that the system will assist them to achieve better performance [193] . It is determined by various factors such as social influence, job relevance, top management support, and benefits at the organizational level [194] . Perceived usefulness has been recognized as a motivation towards using emerging technologies such as BIM [156] , scanner technology [11] , and wearable sensing technologies [192] . Perceived usefulness has been a determining factor for technology adoption in the context of construction research [195] . Perceived ease of use is another important factor, which is the degree to which the user believes that they can use a system effortlessly and free from difficulties [193] . Perceived ease of use is usually measured through training and technological complexity [194] [195] [196] . User satisfaction is more influenced by perceived usefulness than perceived ease of use [166] . As the application of wearable sensors is quite new, it is important to research the acceptance of construction workers. Choi et al. [192] investigated factors influencing the adoption of wearable sensing technologies by construction workers. They discovered that "perceived usefulness", "social influence", "perceived privacy risk", and "perceived ease of use" were the major factors determining workers' acceptance.

The final goal is to develop a governance framework, which could be referred to for easier decision making on the suitability of particular sensing technology. Sensing technologies demonstrate promising potential in construction safety, productivity, and quality enhancement. However, the construction industry lacks an understanding of these advanced technologies. Information about sensing technologies in real projects is scarce. Additionally, the adoption process demonstrates the crucial factors as opinions of stakeholders and workers. This paper embraces a review of factors that affect the adoption and implementation of digital technologies. The future research will identify, extract, supplement, and rank the factors conducted from this review to determine the significant factors in sensing technology adoption. Awareness of the advantages resulting from the sensing technology implementation is crucial to counter the resistance from the construction industry and promote innovative sensing technologies. Therefore, the construction industry needs a governance framework, which contains a core structure depicting the adoption process, from a proposal to its evaluation and approval. Barriers and benefits work in opposite directions during the proposal, while the risk of introducing new devices into the existing systems is also considered. The proposal progresses to detailed evaluation and approval when the totality of benefits, barriers, and all relevant considerations conclude new sensing technology is suitable. During the evaluation, considerations for the suitability of the proposed sensing technology, the whole of life costs, and factors related to people should be justified. The framework will assist with the implementation of sensing technologies during construction processes. In the case study of the governance framework, overall cost-benefit analyses of these technologies in the construction site need to be considered to incentivize their adoption by stakeholders.

Applications of sensing technologies and the rationale behind their slow adoption have been explored in this paper. This literature review, as opposed to previous reviews, is not limited to a specific group of technologies. The focus is on sensing technologies effectively improving construction performance such as safety, productivity, and quality. Eight popular sensing technologies are selected, including GPS, RFID, UWB, FOS, pressure sensing technology, temperature sensing technology, visual sensing technology, and 3D scanning technology. The benefits, shortcomings, and their application in construction have been reviewed. Even the most popular technologies such as GPS and visual sensing technology were not fully adopted. Despite sensing technologies having been academically explored and proven to yield positive potential, they lack adoption in real construction projects. This review is not only limited to the factors affecting the adoption, but also covered factors affecting the acceptance of sensing technologies by construction workers. Meanwhile, this review embraced all relevant factors reported in the literature regarding the adoption of almost all types of innovative digital technologies such as IT and BIM. In future research, influential factors uniquely related to sensing technologies and common factors between sensing technologies and other digital technologies need to be separated. Furthermore, research should cover the points of stakeholders inside and outside of the construction industry. It is concluded that the capital cost of sensing technology implementation is the strongest barrier to its adoption. Technical barriers, safety concerns, and ethical concerns are also involved in the decision-making process. Aside from financial constraints and challenges related to skill acquisition, another barrier is related to decision makers or end-users who are resistant to change and lack awareness of the benefits of the proposed new technology. Such barriers could be diminished by raising awareness of the benefits and effectiveness of the intended sensing technology. These factors form the basis of the governance framework, which could be referred to for easier decision making on the suitability of particular sensing technology. Safety, productivity, and quality performance of construction processes will benefit from sensing technologies adoption, and the governance framework will promote a more straightforward adoption process. 

The data presented in this study are openly available.

The authors declare no conflict of interest.

The role of information technologies to address data handling in construction project management

Ubiquitous location tracking for context-specific information delivery on construction sites

A framework for indoor construction resources tracking by applying wireless sensor networks. Rev. Can. De Génie Civ

Perceptions of automated data collection technology use in the construction industry

Time-domain analysis of tamper displacement during dynamic compaction based on automatic control

Automated Data Acquisition in Construction with Remote Sensing Technologies

Information and communication technology application challenges in the construction industry: A narrative review

Extending automation of building construction-Survey on potential sensor technologies and robotic applications

Sensing and warning-based technology applications to improve occupational health and safety in the construction industry: A literature review

Sensing and Field Data Capture for Construction and Facility Operations

A Scanner Technology Acceptance Model for Construction Projects

Real-time locating systems applications in construction

Scenarios for applying RFID technology in construction project management

Sacks, R. Construction safety and digital design: A review

Critical review of data-driven decision-making in bridge operation and maintenance

Factors influencing the decision of technology adoption in construction

Construction Technology Adoption Cube: An Investigation on Process, Factors, Barriers, Drivers and Decision Makers Using NVivo and AHP

Barriers to the Adoption of Wearable Sensors in the Workplace: A Survey of Occupational Safety and Health Professionals

Said, I. Information and communication technology innovation for construction site management

Real-time locating systems and safety in construction sites: A literature review

Modeling Tower Crane Operator Visibility to Minimize the Risk of Limited Situational Awareness

Numerical modeling of response of CFRP-Concrete interfaces subjected to fatigue loading

Quantifying Hazard Exposure Using Real-Time Location Data of Construction Workforce and Equipment

Experimental study of predamaged columns strengthened by HPFL and BSP under combined load cases

Matching Model of Energy Supply and Demand of the Integrated Energy System in Coastal Areas

Proximity hazard indicator for workers-on-foot near miss interactions with construction equipment and geo-referenced hazard areas

Drought monitoring over Yellow River basin from 2003-2019 using reconstructed MODIS land surface temperature in Google Earth Engine

Low False Alarm Rate Model for Unsafe-Proximity Detection in Construction

Torsion design of CFRP-CFST columns using a data-driven optimization approach

Securing a wireless site network to create a BIM-allied work-front

Privacy-Preserving Localization for Underwater Sensor Networks via Deep Reinforcement Learning

Real-time resource location data collection and visualization technology for construction safety and activity monitoring applications

Influence of RFID technology on automated management of construction materials and components

A BIM-and sensor-based tower crane navigation system for blind lifts

Construction equipment activity recognition for simulation input modeling using mobile sensors and machine learning classifiers

Evolution of RFID applications in construction: A literature review

Research on RFID Applications in Construction Industry

Differential received signal strength based RFID positioning for construction equipment tracking

RFID deployment protocols for indoor construction

Adaptive Neural Network-Based Finite-Time Online Optimal Tracking Control of the Nonlinear System With Dead Zone

Safety barrier warning system for underground construction sites using Internet-of-Things technologies

Design and implementation of an identification system in construction site safety for proactive accident prevention

Application of Sensing Technology in the Prevention of Backing Accidents in Construction Work Zones

Real-time safety early warning system for cross passage construction in Yangtze Riverbed Metro Tunnel based on the internet of things

Method for testing proximity detection and alert technology for safe construction equipment operation

Towards an autonomous real-time tracking system of near-miss accidents on construction sites

An IoT-based autonomous system for workers' safety in construction sites with real-time alarming, monitoring, and positioning strategies

Case Study of BIM and Cloud-Enabled Real-Time RFID Indoor Localization for Construction Management Applications

RFID 3D location sensing algorithms

A real-time location-based construction labor safety management system

Ultra-wide band technology experiments for real-time prevention of tower crane collisions

Crane Pose Estimation Using UWB Real-Time Location System

Angular velocity measurement with improved scale factor based on a wideband-tunable optoelectronic oscillator

Ultrawideband for Automated Real-Time Three-Dimensional Location Sensing for Workforce, Equipment, and Material Positioning and Tracking

Accuracy assessment of Ultra-Wide Band technology in tracking static resources in indoor construction scenarios

Performance evaluation of ultra wideband technology for construction resource location tracking in harsh environments

Ultra Wideband Indoor Positioning Technologies: Analysis and Recent Advances

Deterioration of UWB positioning during construction

Behaviour of concrete filled glass fibre-reinforced polymer tubes under static and flexural fatigue loading

3D range imaging camera sensing for active safety in construction

Performance of short and long range wireless communication technologies in construction

Vision-Based Measurement: Actualities and Developing Trends in Automated Container Terminals

Computer vision techniques in construction: A critical review

A novel differential search algorithm and applications for structure design

One-dimensional compression behavior of calcareous sand and marine clay mixtures

Autonomous pro-active real-time construction worker and equipment operator proximity safety alert system

Applying Sensor-Based Technology to Improve Construction Safety Management

The effect of graphite and slag on electrical and mechanical properties of electrically conductive cementitious composites

Effects of initial SiO 2 /Al 2 O 3 molar ratio and slag on fly ash-based ambient cured geopolymer properties

The Strain Transfer Mechanism of Fiber Bragg Grating Sensor for Extra Large Strain Monitoring

Mechanical and conductive performance of electrically conductive cementitious composite using graphite, steel slag, and GGBS

Mechanical behavior of fiber-reinforced self-compacting rubberized concrete exposed to elevated temperatures

Evaluation of the efficacy of using engineered cementitious composites in RC beamcolumn joints

Experimental investigation of the behavior of concrete-filled high-strength glass fiber-reinforced polymer tubes under static and cyclic axial compression

An In-depth Review: Structural Health Monitoring using Fiber Optic Sensor

Fiber-reinforced lightweight self-compacting concrete incorporating scoria aggregates at elevated temperatures

Debonding development in cracked steel plates strengthened by CFRP laminates under fatigue loading: Experimental and boundary element method analysis. Thin-Walled Struct

Safety Monitoring of Railway Tunnel Construction Using FBG Sensing Technology

Experimental analysis of fiber-reinforced recycled aggregate self-compacting concrete using waste recycled concrete aggregates, polypropylene, and steel fibers

Fatigue design of CFRP strengthened steel members. Thin-Walled Struct

Non-uniform model of relationship between surface strain and rust expansion force of reinforced concrete

The development of a novel analytical model to design composite steel plate shear walls under eccentric shear

Relationship model between surface strain of concrete and expansion force of reinforcement rust

Axial strength of back-to-back cold-formed steel channels with edge-stiffened holes, un-stiffened holes and plain webs

Wireless Sensor Networks Configurations for Applications in Construction

Large-scale experiment of a novel non-domestic building using BPSC systems for energy saving

A monitoring system for real-time interference control on large construction sites

Triaxial Shear Behavior of Basalt Fiber-Reinforced Loess Based on Digital Image Technology

New Insights of Grouting in Coal Mass: From Small-Scale Experiments to Microstructures

Predicting movements of onsite workers and mobile equipment for enhancing construction site safety

Ergonomic analysis of construction worker's body postures using wearable mobile sensors

Wearable technology for personalized construction safety monitoring and trending: Review of applicable devices

The availability of wearable-device-based physical data for the measurement of construction workers' psychological status on site: From the perspective of safety management

Automated Hardhat Detection for Construction Safety Applications

Real-time construction worker posture analysis for ergonomics training

A vision-based motion capture and recognition framework for behavior-based safety management

Human Mobility Data in the COVID-19 Pandemic: Characteristics, Applications, and Challenges

Wearable Sensing Technology Applications in Construction Safety and Health

Monitoring workers' attention and vigilance in construction activities through a wireless and wearable electroencephalography system

Feasibility of Field Measurement of Construction Workers' Valence Using a Wearable EEG Device

Wearable sensors for monitoring on-duty and off-duty worker physiological status and activities in construction

Wristband-type wearable health devices to measure construction workers' physical demands

Development of an early-warning system for site work in hot and humid environments: A case study

Practical algorithm for stochastic optimal control problem about microbial fermentation in batch culture

Monitoring fatigue in construction workers using physiological measurements

Biomechanical analysis of risk factors for work-related musculoskeletal disorders during repetitive lifting task in construction workers

Low-cost ergonomic intervention for mitigating physical and subjective discomfort during manual rebar tying

Construction worker's awkward posture recognition through supervised motion tensor decomposition

Collective sensing of workers' gait patterns to identify fall hazards in construction

Comprehensive Fall-Risk Assessment of Construction Workers Using Inertial Measurement Units: Validation of the Gait-Stability Metric to Assess the Fall Risk of Iron Workers

Building information modeling in combination with real time location systems and sensors for safety performance enhancement

Safety Helmet Wearing Management System for Construction Workers Using Three-Axis Accelerometer Sensor

Preliminary Tests on a Wireless Sensor Network for Pervasive Dust Monitoring in Construction Sites

Respirable Dust Monitoring in Construction Sites and Visualization in Building Information Modeling Using Real-time Sensor Data

System architecture to bring smart personal protective equipment wearables and sensors to transform safety at work in the underground mining industry. Rudarsko-Geolosko-Naftni Zbornik

Quality control of asphalt pavement compaction using fibre Bragg grating sensing technology

Mechanical, chemical and hydrothermal activation for waste glass reinforced cement

Integrated distributed fiber optic sensing technology-based structural monitoring of the pound lock

Fatigue behavior of cracked high-strength steel plates strengthened by CFRP sheets

Upscaling evapotranspiration from the instantaneous to the daily time scale: Assessing six methods including an optimized coefficient based on worldwide eddy covariance flux network

Dynamic quality control of process resource to improve concrete supply chain

Machine-learning-assisted shear strength prediction of reinforced concrete beams with and without stirrups

A formalism for utilization of sensor systems and integrated project models for active construction quality control

A framework for dimensional and surface quality assessment of precast concrete elements using BIM and 3D laser scanning

A conceptual framework of quality-assured fabrication, delivery and installation processes for liquefied natural gas (LNG) plant construction

Using reference RFID tags for calibrating the estimated locations of construction materials

Assessing the impact of materials tracking technologies on construction craft productivity

Machine learning-aided design and prediction of cementitious composites containing graphite and slag powder

Comparative study of GPS-integrated concrete supply management using discrete event simulation

Evaluation of position tracking technologies for user localization in indoor construction environments

Well logging curve reconstruction based on kernel ridge regression

IntelliSensorNet: A Positioning Technique Integrating Wireless Sensor Networks and Artificial Neural Networks for Critical Construction Resource Tracking

A service-oriented integrated information framework for RFID/WSN-based intelligent construction supply chain management

Properties of a double-layer EMW-absorbing structure containing a graded nano-sized absorbent combing extruded and sprayed 3D printing

RFID Enabled Knowledge-Based Precast Construction Supply Chain

Reliability-Based Hybrid Data Fusion Method for Adaptive Location Estimation in Construction

Ubiquitous Sensor Network for Construction Material Monitoring

Review on electromagnetic wave absorbing capacity improvement of cementitious material

RFID-facilitated construction materials management (RFID-CMM)-A case study of water-supply project

Machine-Learning-Aided Prediction of Flexural Strength and ASR Expansion for Waste Glass Cementitious Composite

An adaptive cyber-physical system's approach to construction progress monitoring and control

Improving Construction Supply Network Visibility by Using Automated Materials Locating and Tracking Technology

Electromagnetic wave absorbing performance of 3D printed wave-shape copper solid cementitious element

Developing and evaluating a framework of total constraint management for improving workflow in liquefied natural gas construction

RFID-Aided Tracking System to Improve Work Efficiency of Scaffold Supplier: Stock Management in Australasian Supply Chain

Brilakis, I. Three-Dimensional Tracking of Construction Resources Using an On-Site Camera System

Brilakis, I. Comparative study of vision tracking methods for tracking of construction site resources

Automated progress tracking using 4D schedule and 3D sensing technologies

A Cost Effective Material Tracking and Locating Solution for Material Laydown Yard

Combining photogrammetry and robotic total stations to obtain dimensional measurements of temporary facilities in construction field

UWB RTLS for Construction Equipment Localization: Experimental Performance Analysis and Fusion with Video Data

Analytical approach for crack identification of glass fiber reinforced polymer-sea sand concrete composite structures based on strain dissipations. Struct. Health Monit

Technology Adoption in Construction

Technology Adoption Decisions in Construction Organizations

Factors influencing BIM Adoption in Small and Medium Sized Construction Organizations

Factors for effective BIM governance

A theoretical framework of a BIM-based multi-disciplinary collaboration platform

Generative Design in Building Information Modelling (BIM): Approaches and Requirements. Sensors

The effect of hollow glass microspheres, carbon nanofibers and activated carbon powder on mechanical and dry shrinkage performance of ultra-lightweight engineered cementitious composites

Maximum Probabilistic and Dynamic Traffic Load Effects on Short-to-Medium Span Bridges

Forces Driving Adoption of New Information Technologies

Fatigue reliability evaluation of aging prestressed concrete bridge accounting for stochastic traffic loading and resistance degradation

Model to Predict the Impact of a Technology on Construction Productivity

Rationalizing the Implementation of Web-Based Project Management Systems in Construction Projects Using PLS-SEM

A Concept for Automated Construction Progress Monitoring: Technologies Adoption for Benchmarking Project Performance Control. Arab

Assessment of the Challenges and Benefits of Information Communication Technology (ICT) on Construction Industry in OYO State Njgeria

Fracture behavior of a sustainable material: Recycled concrete with waste crumb rubber subjected to elevated temperatures

The ultimate shear capacity of longitudinally stiffened steel-concrete composite plate girders

Development of an ensemble intelligent model for assessing the strength of cemented paste backfill

IoT-based safety monitoring from the perspective of construction site workers

Digitalisation in construction industry: Construction professionals perspective

Multi-objective optimisation of a graphite-slag conductive composite applying a BAS-SVR based model

Wireless technologies for the construction sector-Requirements, energy and cost efficiencies

Drivers of innovation in construction projects

Development of lightweight rubberized geopolymer concrete by using polystyrene and recycled crumb-rubber aggregates

Challenges and drivers for data mining in the AEC sector

Mechanical enhancement for EMW-absorbing cementitious material using 3D concrete printing

Electromagnetic absorption of copper fiber oriented composite using 3D printing

Fresh and mechanical behaviour of developed fibre-reinforced lightweight engineered cementitious composites for 3D concrete printing containing hollow glass microspheres

The Impact of Information Technology (IT) Adoption on the Quality of Construction Projects: The Case of Jordan

An Investigation on Virtual Information Modeling Acceptance Based on

Barriers to adoption of RPAs on construction projects: A task-technology fit perspective

Descriptive perspective on factors affecting the complete adoption of information technology systems in the construction firms

Barriers to Technology Adoption Among Construction Project Managers in Nigeria

Adopting information and communication technology in construction industry

Adoption and Use of Interorganizational ICT in a Construction Project

Adoption of Building Information Modelling technology (BIM): Perspectives from Malaysian engineering consulting services firms

Broadband cancellation method in an adaptive co-site interference cancellation system

Technology acceptance model for Augmented Reality and Building Information Modeling integration in the construction industry

Physiolytics at the workplace: Affordances and constraints of wearables use from an employee's perspective

What drives construction workers' acceptance of wearable technologies in the workplace?: Indoor localization and wearable health devices for occupational safety and health

Perceived Usefulness, Perceived Ease of Use, and User Acceptance of Information Technology

Toward an understanding of construction professionals' acceptance of mobile computing devices in South Korea: An extension of the technology acceptance model

BIM Acceptance Model in Construction Organizations

Fatigue performance and design of concrete-filled steel tubular joints: A critical review