key: cord-0050504-tvdbyvkn
authors: Shi, Feng; Zhao, Yang; Sun, Yixiao; Chen, Chuangfu
title: Development and application of a colloidal carbon test strip for the detection of antibodies against Mycoplasma bovis
date: 2020-09-23
journal: World J Microbiol Biotechnol
DOI: 10.1007/s11274-020-02930-2
sha: 2b05994d06427eae014d76b9c7c20284089ec179
doc_id: 50504
cord_uid: tvdbyvkn

Mycoplasma bovis (M. bovis) is an important bovine mycoplasma implicated in economically important clinical diseases, such as respiratory diseases, otitis media, and mastitis. The prevalence of M. bovis-associated mastitis in both cattle and buffaloes has been increasingly recognized as a global problem. High morbidity rates and consequential economic losses have been devastating to the affected cattle and buffalo farms, especially those in developing countries. Therefore, a rapid and accurate method is urgently needed to detect M. bovis. In this study, a rapid and simple lateral flow strip for detecting antibodies against M. bovis was established that used carbon nanoparticles (CNPs) as the labelled materials. The results from the test strip were highly consistent with those from ELISA. The test showed high specificity (100%) and no cross-reaction with other bovine pathogens. The detection sensitivity of the test was also relatively high (97.67%). All the results indicated that the colloidal carbon test strip could serve as a simple, rapid, sensitive, and specific diagnostic method for detecting antibodies against M. bovis at cattle farms.

Mycoplasma bovis, a prokaryotic microorganism that lacks a cell wall, causes severe pneumonia, mastitis, arthritis, otitis media, and reproductive disorders in cattle. It also causes exudative pleuritic tuberculous in humans (Fox et al. 2005; Kay et al. 2015) . M. bovis is mainly transmitted by droplets from the respiratory tract (Foster et al. 2009 ). M. bovis mainly spreads by droplets ejected from the respiratory tract, and secondly by contacts. It often causes acute and chronic diseases in cattle in a direct or indirect way (Ball and Nicholas 2010) . The development of disease severely affects the cattle industry by increasing the cost of feeding and the costs associated with the diagnosis and treatment of disease, including permanent lung injury (Ayling et al. 2014) .

Traditionally, the identification and diagnosis of M. bovis has been performed via microbial culture. Parker et al. 2018; Zhao et al. 2018) . More recently, the use of polymerase chain reaction (PCR) to detect M. bovis species from various bovine samples has increased. PCR has a higher efficiency, specificity, and sensitivity for laboratory diagnosis when compared with conventional culture-based methods (Andersson et al. 2019) . Serological diagnosis can detect anti-mycoplasma antibodies in serum and milk which includes indirect haemagglutination, immunohistochemistry, agar diffusion, growth inhibition, complement binding, and indirect ELISA (I-ELISA) (Caswell and Archambault 2007; Nielsen et al. 2015; Parker et al. 2017) . While each testing method has its strengths and limitations, these methods require professional technicians and test instruments and are not suitable for testing in pastures. Therefore, it is vital to develop a rapid and easy-to-perform method that might be used to effectively eradicate M. bovis from cattle flocks.

Lateral flow testing (LFT) is one of the most commonly used transversal flow immunoassay techniques and is considered an ideal method for detecting and measuring objects Feng Shi and Yang Zhao have contributed equally to this work.

* Feng Shi shifeng2314@yeah.net * Chuangfu Chen ccf-xb@163.com during the analysis of samples (Huang et al. 2016; Jiang et al. 2019; Kim et al. 2019) . CNPs are relatively inexpensive labels compared with other materials, such as gold and polymers. Additionally, the intense black colour of CNPs provides good contrast for visual detection, which has been demonstrated in many sensitive diagnostic tests (Noguera et al. 2011a, b; Suárez-Pantaleón et al. 2013 ).

In the present study, we compared and identified the M. bovis p81 membrane protein, p48 membrane protein, M. bovis whole protein and M. bovis outer membrane protein and screened for specific antigens. A double-antigen sandwich immunochromatography assay utilizing CNP label materials with specifically screened antigens as coating antigens was developed for the detection of antibodies against M. bovis in whole blood. On the lateral flow test line and control line, the specific antigens and polyclonal antibody (pAb) against the specific antigens were coated. Then, samples were added onto the sample pad, and a characteristic black band was subsequently observed in the test zone, indicating the accumulation of CNPs. A black band was also observed in the control zone, which indicated the usability of the test strip. The colour intensity of the test line represented the level of target antibody in the sample and could be observed visually. Furthermore, the quantitative detection of antibodies against M. bovis was also achieved by analysing the colour intensities using commercially available optical readers. We anticipate that this CNP-based test strip could be utilized as a novel, direct, and effective immunological method for the detection of antibodies against M. bovis.

The care and use of the animals were conducted in strict accordance with the recommendations in the Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals of the National Institutes of Health. Procedures involving animals were approved by the Shihezi University Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee.

The p48 proteins and candidate proteins used in this study were listed in 

According to previously described procedures with slight modifications (Li et al. 2016) , the purified recombinant p48 protein and p81 protein produced in the laboratory were diluted to 5 mg/mL and subjected to SDS-PAGE. The separated proteins were transferred to an NC membrane, which was blocked with 5% skim milk. M. bovis-positive serum (1:1000) was used as the primary antibody, and HRP-rabbit anti-cattle IgG was used as the secondary antibody.

I-ELISA of p81, p48, whole protein, and outer membrane protein from M. bovis I-ELISA was used to screen proteins with good affinity and specificity. Different concentrations of whole protein, outer membrane protein, p81 protein and p48 protein were coated on independent microplates, each protein was set with blank pore, negative serum pore and positive serum pore, and each sample pore was made with three biological replicates.

Microplates coated with 100μL of protein of different concentrations (0.5 μg/mL, 2 μg/mL, 5 μg/mL, 10 μg/mL, 20 μg/mL) per well were blocked with 3% BSA for 2 h at 37 °C. After washing three times with PBST, 100 μL of negative and positive serum (1:40) was added to each well and the microplates were incubated for 1 h at 37 °C. After washing three times with PBST, A volume of 100 μL of HRP-Rabbit anti-bovine IgG (1:5000) was added to each well and incubated for 30 min at 37 °C. The plates were washed four times with PBST, and then 100 μL of TMB was added to each well. After incubating for 10 min at 37 °C, 2 M sulfuric acid was added to stop the reaction. The optical densities were read at 450 nm on a microplate reader.

Purified p48 protein was mixed with an equal volume of Freund's complete adjuvant to obtain a final concentration of 300 μg/mL. Subsequently, approximately 500 μg of antigen-adjuvant mixture was injected subcutaneously into New Zealand white rabbits. Immunizations using the antigen-adjuvant mixture were performed at 10-day intervals. An enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) was used to test the rabbit antisera for the presence of antibodies against p48 and was repeated daily until the threshold was reached (1:100,000). Protein A was used for the isolation of IgG antibodies using column chromatography according to the manufacturer's recommendations.

An approximately 1% (w/v) suspension of carbon was prepared in demineralized water by sonication. Then, 100 mL sodium borate buffer containing 5 mg p48 was added dropwise to 500 mL of a fivefold dilution of carbon (0.2%, w/v) in sodium borate buffer. After overnight incubation at 4 °C with gentle stirring, the solution was washed four times with washing solution by centrifugation (13600 g; 15 min). Then, the p48-conjugate was reconstituted in 100 mM sodium borate buffer, pH 8.8, with 1% (w/v) BSA and 0.02% (w/v) NaN 3 at a final carbon concentration of 0.2% and stored at 4 °C. Before performing the experiments, the working dilution of the p48-carbon conjugate was sonicated for 10 s.

The p48-carbon conjugate was dried onto a conjugate pad, which overlapped the NC membrane containing the two capture lines that were visible within the results window. An absorbent pad was laid on top of the membrane to ensure rapid flow up the membrane. The top line was the control line and comprised a polyclonal anti-p48 antibody that was immobilized on the NC membrane to capture the p48-carbon conjugate. This test line confirmed the presence of p48 antibody. Approximately 3-5 drops were placed onto the sample pad, and the results were observed after 10 min. Negative results were observed when only black strips appeared in the quality control line.

The test strip included a sample pad, a conjugate pad, an absorbent pad, an NC membrane. The conjugate pad contained the dried carbon-labelled p48 protein, which produced an easily visible black colour. There were two lines on the NC membrane: the control line and the test line. The test line was coated with p48 protein. The control line was coated with the pAb against p48 (Fig. 1) .

To evaluate the cross reactivity of the CNP test strip, positive serum samples of M. bovis, P. multocida, BVDV, Bovine Brucella, Mycobacterium bovis, E.coli, M.bovigenitalium, M. haemolytica, H. somni and M. ovipneumoniae were added to the sample pad. After 10 min, the results were observed.

The standard positive serum of M. bovis was diluted 10-, 50-, 100-, 200-, 400-, 800-fold with 1 × PBS (pH 7.4). A 100 μL droplet was added to the sample pad under various conditions, and the results were observed after 10 min. 

To identify the composition characteristics of p81 and p48 proteins obtained by gene recombination technology in vitro, Western blot analysis was used. M. bovis-negative and -positive serum samples were subjected to Western blot analysis. Figure 2 shows that the p81 protein reacted with the M. bovis-positive and M. bovis-negative sera, whereas the p48 protein reacted with the M. bovis-positive serum but not with the M. bovis-negative sera. The recombinant proteins p81 and p48 showed good reactivity, but the specificity of the p48 protein was higher than that of p81.

I-ELISA was used to screen proteins with good affinity and specificity. A series of proteins with dilution concentrations ranging from 0.5 to 20.0 µg were prepared and the results are shown in Table 2 . Under the same conditions, p48 protein showed a good positive detection rate, the optimal concentration was 5.0 µg/mL. Interestingly, the whole protein showed a good positive detection rate because it contains p48 protein, but its specificity is not as good as p48 protein, so we chose p48 protein as the specific protein to establish the detection method.

To identify the composition and concentration of the pAbs against p48 protein, SDS-PAGE was used. After the rabbits were immunized five times with the purified p48 protein, the pAb against p48 was purified using a protein A chromatography column. The pAb was observed with SDS-PAGE, and the subunit dissociation resulted in bands corresponding to approximately 55 kDa for the heavy chain and approximately 25 kDa for the light chain; no non-specific bands were observed, indicating that the pAb was pure (Fig. 3a) . The titer of the pAb according to ELISA was 1:204,800. These results revealed that the pAbs could recognize the recombinant p48 protein, which is indicative of high specificity (Fig. 3b) . 

To determine the optimal ratio of p48 protein coating concentration and p48 protein-labeled CNPs, p48 proteinlabeled CNPs were diluted at the ratio of 1:4, 1:6, 1:10, and p48 protein was diluted to 1 mg/mL, 2 mg/mL, 4 mg/mL, and 5 mg/mL, respectively. When the concentration of the p48 protein-labelled CNPs was diluted at a ratio of 1:4, the C line was clearly observed; however, the T line was not observed. With increasing concentrations of p48 proteinlabelled CNPs, the colour of the T line became increasingly darker until the CNPs were diluted at a ratio of 1:10 ( Fig. 4) . When the p48 protein was diluted to a concentration of 4 mg/mL, it was coated in NC membrane, and the colour of the T line increased in intensity; furthermore, the negative and positive serum results were clear. When the p48 protein was diluted to a concentration of 2 mg/mL, the T and C lines were of the same colour, indicating that this was the optimal condition (Table 3) .

To determine the optimal dilution ratio for rabbit anti-p48 pAb, rabbit anti-p48 pAb was diluted at the ratio of 1:50, 1:100, 1:150, 1:200 respectively. When the concentration of the rabbit anti-p48 pAb was high, the colour intensity of the quality control line was markedly higher than that of the detection line. At a 1:100 dilution, the two detection lines were clearly visible, and the colour intensity remained the same. Therefore, the optimal dilution of the rabbit anti-p48 pAb was 1:100. (Table 4 ).

The cross-reactivity of the test strips was evaluated using bovine-susceptible pathogens in serum samples positive for P. multocida, BVDV, Bovine Brucella, M. bovis, E. coli, M. bovigenitalium, M. haemolytica, H. somni and M. ovipneumoniae. While the M. bovis-positive serum sample yielded positive results, all other samples showed negative results (Fig. 5) . These data convincingly demonstrated that the test strip could be used to detect antibodies against M. bovis.

To evaluate the detection limit of the CNP test strip, the standard positive serum was diluted with normal saline to yield different concentration gradients. When the standard M. bovis-positive sample was diluted 800-fold, the CNP test strip was negative. When the standard M. bovis-positive sample was diluted 400-fold, the CNP test strip was positive, but the test line was indistinct, indicating that the detection limit of the CNP test strip was 1:400; as the dilution ratio was increased, the colour of the T-line deepened gradually (Fig. 6 ). Table 5 . The lateral flow strips showed 100% and 97.67% specificity and sensitivity, respectively, compared to ELISA. The lateral flow strips had higher specificity and sensitivity. The results obtained with the lateral flow strips exhibited 99.49% concordance with those of ELISA.

In recent years, because of the rise in socioeconomic status and the quality of life, there has been a higher demand for lamb and wool products, which has led to increases in cattle farming and husbandry for beef production. However, the incidence of M. bovis targeting cattle has concordantly risen, and epidemic outbreaks were reported recently (Wawegama C + + + /T + C + + + /T + C + + + + /T + + C + + + /T + + + 6x C + + /T + C + + /T + C + + /T + C + + /T + + 10x C + /T + C + + /T + + C + /T + C + /T + + Table 4 Colour rendering results for different dilution multiples T < C indicates that the T line was lighter than the C line. T = C indicates that the T line showed the same colour intensity as the C line. T > C indicates that the T line was darker than the C line Dilution ratio of rabbit anti-p48 pAb Chromogenic result 50 + + + + T < C 100 + + + T = C 150 + + T > C 200 + T > C . Therefore, there is a need to establish a rapid, simple, and reliable detection method for M. bovis. In this study, a fast and efficient lateral flow strip method for detecting antibodies against M. bovis was established that used CNPs as labelled materials. The method is simple, does not require any instruments or equipment, and its results are presented visually.

To the best of our knowledge, this is the first time that CNPs have been selected as labeling materials to establish a method for detecting antibodies against M. bovis in serum and describe the results of conjugated proteins and lateral flow test strips achieved with colloidal carbon labeling. The colloidal carbon label appeared useful for the lateral flow strips that were studied. Considering the desired properties for a new label, colloidal carbon has several advantageous characteristics and properties. First, the label is very cheap, and conjugates with proteins are easy to prepare (O'Keeffe et al. 2003) . Second, the colloidal carbon label and the conjugates are very stable. Some conjugates were stored at 4 °C for several months, while others were stored for up to 1 year (Blažková et al. 2009 ). Finally, the black/grey line on a white nitrocellulose background has a very good contrast ratio, as judged by visual examination and by computer image analysis. Based on these characteristics and properties, colloidal carbon suspensions can be applied as labels in lateral flow strips.

To obtain better lateral flow strip results, we systematically optimized the coating and labeling conditions of the test strip. After optimization, the test strip could show an accurate and clear result that was directly visible to the naked eye within 10 min. We further examined the accuracy of the result, including its specificity, sensitivity, and consistency in comparison with the ELISA results. To examine its practicability, the test strip was used for the detection of 197 clinical samples. Among them, the results obtained from the test strip agreed with the ELISA results 99.49% of the time. There was one sample that was identified as positive by ELISA but was identified as negative by the strip. This sample was retested by PCR, and the final data agreed with the result obtained from the strip. This observation may hint at the possibility of false positive results from ELISA, thereby implying that our test strip may show higher efficacy for detecting antibodies against M. bovis in serum. I-ELISA has been widely used to detect antibodies in serum, but it shows false positives in practical applications (Fu et al. 2014 ). The reasons for non-specific reactions include the non-specific colour of non-specific antibodies in the sample, the binding of the clad protein, and the non-specific colour reaction caused by the enzyme marker in the solid carrier. The strip uses a sandwich antigen method, which may help reduce the non-specific adsorption of the sandwich antigen. The double-antigen sandwich method has higher specificity than Table 5 Comparison of the CNP strips with ELISA for the detection of antibodies against M. bovis the indirect method. Therefore, the sandwich method can promote the detection of weakly positive samples. Therefore, this study used the double-antigen sandwich method to establish a test strip for antibody detection. To our knowledge, this is the first screening of specific proteins in four candidate proteins of M. bovis by I-ELISA. The results indicate that the assay has high specificity for p48 recombinant protein. We describe a simple, rapid, and specific strip assay using CNPs as labelled materials for the detection of antibodies against M. bovis. The strip results indicate that the specificity was relatively increased, and no cross-reactions with other bovine pathogens were observed; the detection sensitivity was also increased. This technique is suitable for use in areas with a high incidence of M. bovis because of its simple operation, visual results and low costs.

A European interlaboratory trial to evaluate the performance of three serological methods for diagnosis of Mycoplasma bovis infection in cattle using latent class analysis

Changes in antimicrobial susceptibility of Mycoplasma bovis isolates from Great Britain

Immunochromatographic colloidal carbon-based assay for detection of methiocarb in surface water

Mycoplasma bovis-associated disease: here, there and everywhere

Mycoplasma bovis pneumonia in cattle

Ayling RD (2009) Mycoplasma bovis and otitis in dairy calves in the United Kingdom

Development of a direct competitive ELISA for the detection of Mycoplasma bovis infection based on a monoclonal antibody of p48 protein

Membrane-based lateral flow immunochromatographic strip with nanoparticles as reporters for detection: a review

Isolation of Mycoplasma spp. and serological responses in bulls prior to and following their introduction into Mycoplasma bovis-infected dairy herds

Lateral and vertical flow assays for point-of-care diagnostics

A new point-of-care test for the diagnosis of infectious diseases based on multiplex lateral flow immunoassays

Pleural effusion and fever in an immunocompromised patient

Identification of a linear B-cell epitope on the avian leukosis virus P27 protein using monoclonal antibodies

Latent class analysis of bulk tank milk PCR and ELISA testing for herd level diagnosis of Mycoplasma bovis

Carbon nanoparticles as detection labels in antibody microarrays. Detection of genes encoding virulence factors in shiga toxin-producing Escherichia coli

Carbon nanoparticles in lateral flow methods to detect genes encoding virulence factors of Shiga toxin-producing Escherichia coli

Bulk tank milk antibody ELISA as a biosecurity tool for detecting dairy herds with past exposure to Mycoplasma bovis

A review of mycoplasma diagnostics in cattle

Development of an immunochromatographic assay based on carbon nanoparticles for the determination of the phytoregulator forchlorfenuron

Development of a recombinant protein-based enzymelinked immunosorbent assay for diagnosis of Mycoplasma bovis infection in cattle

7-018-1703-x Publisher's Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations