key: cord-0030626-8w4m1iu4
authors: Mahittikorn, Aongart; Masangkay, Frederick Ramirez; De Jesus Milanez, Giovanni; Kuraeiad, Saruda; Kotepui, Manas
title: Prevalence and effect of Plasmodium spp. and hookworm co-infection on malaria parasite density and haemoglobin level: a meta-analysis
date: 2022-04-27
journal: Sci Rep
DOI: 10.1038/s41598-022-10569-2
sha: 88ef0f6e75ed7ac93b9c9b8e68811fd2f7b2f660
doc_id: 30626
cord_uid: 8w4m1iu4

The dual effects of co-infection of Plasmodium spp. and hookworm on malaria remain under debate. This study investigated prevalence, prevalence odds ratio (POR) of co-infection and impact of co-infection on malaria parasite density and haemoglobin levels in comparison to Plasmodium mono-infection. The protocol for this systematic review and meta-analysis is registered at PROPERO under ID: CRD42020202156. Relevant literatures were obtained from PubMed, ISI Web of Science, and Scopus on 25 December 2020. Mean difference (MD) and confidence interval (CI) of malaria parasite density and haemoglobin were compared using a random effect model. Heterogeneity was assessed using Cochrane Q and I(2) statistics. Publication bias was determined by visualising funnel plot asymmetry. Of 1756 articles examined, 22,191 malaria cases across 37 studies included 6096 cases of co-infection of Plasmodium spp. and hookworm. The pooled prevalence was 20% (95% CI 15–26%, I(2) 99.6%, 37 studies) and was varied in terms of geographical region. Co-infection occurred by chance (OR 0.97, p 0.97, 95% CI 0.73–1.27, I(2) 95%, 30 studies). The mean malaria parasite density for co-infection (478 cases) was similar to Plasmodium mono-infection (920 cases) (p 0.24, MD 0.86, 95% CI − 0.58–2.29, I(2) 100%, 7 studies). The mean haemoglobin level for co-infection (90 cases) was similar to Plasmodium mono-infection (415 cases) (p 0.15, MD − 0.63, 95% CI − 1.49–0.23, I(2) 98%, 4 studies). Co-infection was common and occurred by chance but varied by geographic region. Further studies are required to investigate the mechanism of hookworm infection on malaria severity. Additionally, detection of hookworm infections among patients with malaria in endemic areas of both diseases is recommended to prevent severe malaria.

Study selection and data extraction. Two independent authors (AM, MK) selected the potentially relevant studies based on eligibility criteria. Any discrepancy between the two reviewers was resolved by discussion or request of the second author (FM) for the conclusion. Data extraction was performed by the same authors. The following data were extracted for the pilot standardised datasheet: the name of the first author, publication year, study location, year that the study was conducted, study design, characteristics and number of participants, number of malaria cases, number of hookworm cases, number of co-infection, number of single infections, malaria parasite density and haemoglobin level.

Quality of included studies. The quality of the included studies was assessed using the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (NOS) for assessing the quality of nonrandomised studies in meta-analyses (Supplementary Table S2 ). NOS provided a star system for judging the included studies based on the selected study groups, comparability of the groups and ascertainment of either exposure or outcome of interest 22 . The comparability criteria that are not applicable to most study types were defined as "not applicable" since no data from control groups were unavailable. For this study, any included study rated more than 6 out of 7 stars indicated a high-quality study. Any included study rated 4-5 stars indicated moderate quality, whereas any study rated below 3 stars indicated poor quality.

Outcomes. The outcomes of the study were (i) magnitudes of co-infection, (ii) magnitude of parasitaemia, (iii) magnitude of malaria severity (anaemia).

Search results. The searches retrieved 522, 769 and 465 articles from PubMed, Scopus and ISI Web of Science, respectively. Of the 1756 studies screened, 712 were duplicates and were removed. Of the 1044 articles screened for titles and abstracts, 796 articles were excluded due to irrelevant articles. Of the 248 articles examined for full texts, 211 articles were excluded for the following reasons: 55 showed no report on co-infection, 42 were review articles, 22 showed co-infection but the data could not be extracted, 18 were in vitro, 16 were intervention studies/randomised control trials, 13 were published in local languages, 12 were not full-text, 6 were not malarial case, 5 were in vivo, 4 were co-infection with other nematodes, 4 were model prediction, 4 were case-control studies, 3 were books, 3 were studies on the same group of participants, 2 were case reports/case series, 1 was protocol and 1 was a questionnaire. Finally, 37 studies met the inclusion criteria and were included in the analysis (Fig. 1 ).

Characteristics of the included studies are shown in Table 1 .

Most of the included studies were cross-sectional studies (35/37, 94 .6%). Most of the included studies reported Plasmodium spp. and hookworm co-infection in Africa (34/37, 91 .9%) [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] 20, while the remaining studies were from Asia (1 Thai-Burmese border, 1 Indonesia) 51, 52 or South America (Brazil) 53 . Most of the included studies conducted in Africa were in Nigeria (8/34, 23.5%) 11, 24, 28, 32, 33, 45, 46, 50 , followed by Ethiopia (6/34, 17.6%) 8, 9, 12, 13, 31, 42 , Tanzania (4/34, 11.8%) [38] [39] [40] 49 , Uganda (4/34, 11.8%) 34, 36, 44, 47 , Coˆted'Ivoire (3/34, 8 .8%) 10, 41, 48 , Ghana (3/34, 8 .8%) 26, 27, 35 , Kenya (2/34, 5.88%) 30, 37 , Gabon (2/34, 5.88%) 20, 25 and Cameroon. One study covered three countries, including Kenya, Ethiopia and Uganda 29 .

Most of the included studies were conducted in school-age children (19/37, 51 .4%) 9, 20, 24, 29, 30, [35] [36] [37] [38] [39] [40] [41] [42] [43] [44] [45] 49, 52, 53 , pregnant women (7/37, 18 .9%) 25, 28, [32] [33] [34] 46, 51 , residents in the community (6/37, 16.2%) 10, 11, 26, 27, 47, 48 , and acute febrile patients (4/37, 10.8%) 8, 12, 13, 31 , while 1 study was conducted in voluntary donors 50 . Of the 37 studies included in the present analysis, 22,191 participants were confirmed to have malaria infection. Among those malarial patients, 6096 cases were patients with Plasmodium spp. and hookworm co-infection.

Prevalence of Plasmodium spp. and hookworm co-infection. The pooled prevalence of Plasmodium spp. and hookworm co-infection was estimated from 37 studies. The result demonstrated the pooled prevalence of Plasmodium spp., and hookworm co-infection was 20% (95% CI 15-26%, I 2 99.6%). The meta-regression analysis was performed to identify the source (s) of heterogeneity of the prevalence. The meta-regression analysis using participant types as covariates showed that differences in participant type were not the source of heterogeneity of the pooled prevalence of Plasmodium spp. and hookworm co-infection (p > 0.05). A subgroup analysis of participants demonstrated that the pooled prevalence of co-infection was highest in residents in the community (37%, 95% CI 10-64%, I 2 99.9%), acute febrile patients (21%, 95% CI 6-37%, I 2 98.9%), pregnant women (20%, 95% CI 9-31%, I 2 97.5%) and school-age children (14%, 95% CI 10-18%, I 2 98.8%). One study conducted on voluntary donors demonstrated 45% (95% CI 40-50) co-infection 50 11 , respectively (Fig. 2) .

The meta-regression analysis using countries as covariates showed that differences in participant type were a source of heterogeneity of the pooled prevalence of Plasmodium spp. and hookworm co-infection (p < 0.05). Further subgroup analysis of countries yielded the following results: Nigeria (20%, 95% CI 9-30%, I 2 97.9%), Gabon (2%, 95% CI 1-2%, I 2 99.7%), Ghana (35%, 95% CI 2-69%, I 2 99.1%), Kenya (20%, 95% CI 19-22%, I 2 99.5%), Ethiopia (18%, 95% CI 8-28%, I 2 98.1%), Uganda (27%, 95% CI 9-45% I 2 99.7%), Coˆted'Ivoire (26%, 95% CI 0-72%, I 2 99.9%), Tanzania (8%, 95% CI 4-12%, I 2 77.2%) (Fig. 3 ).

Quality of the included studies. Ten studies 8, 9, 11, 13, 24, 28, 38, 40, 50, 53 were rated as high-quality studies, since they reported the outcomes of interest, whereas the rest of the studies were rated as moderate quality, since they www.nature.com/scientificreports/ than in Plasmodium mono-infection, whereas one study 38 demonstrated a higher mean haemoglobin level in coinfection than in Plasmodium mono-infection (Fig. 6 ). The pooled MD of haemoglobin between patients with co-infection (79 cases) and without any infection (645 cases) was estimated from three studies 8, 9, 38 . The results demonstrated no difference in the mean haemoglobin level between patients with co-infection and without any infection when a random effects model was used (p 0.062, MD − 1.4, 95% CI − 2.87 to 0.07, I 2 98.8%) (Fig. 7) .

Publication bias. Publication bias was assessed using the funnel plot demonstrating the effect size (pooled OR) and selogES from 30 studies (Fig. 8) . Egger's test demonstrated that no small-study effect was found (p 0.128, coefficiency 6.77, standard error 4.31). Visualisation of the funnel plot and the result of Egger's test demonstrated asymmetrical distribution of the funnel plot, and no small-study effect was found among the included studies, respectively. 51 . A possible explanation for the high rate of co-infection in these participants may be attributed to the impairment of immunity during pregnancy 63 . A study demonstrated that that pregnant women are more susceptible to Plasmodium spp. and hookworm infections in their first pregnancy, which might cause nutrient deficiency in subjects, which would lead to poor pregnancy outcomes 33 .

The co-infection of Plasmodium spp. and hookworm might occur by chance. The pooled analysis of this study suggested that underlying infection by hookworms may not increase the chance of being infected with malaria. Nevertheless, the meta-analysis for each subgroup of participants demonstrated that hookworm infections of people within communities increased the risk of malaria infection. Previous studies showed that rural communities are associated with poverty, poor sanitation and personal hygiene, and in turn, are related to , previous studies demonstrated that co-infection was more common among boys, less common with increasing age and highest among children from poor households 29, 48, 68, 69 . Therefore, the risk of Plasmodium spp. and hookworm might be associated with access to sanitation and clean water, recent deworming and living in urban settings 69 , as in these areas, children are exposed to open defecation grounds, which is a major source of hookworm transmission infection 70 .

The present meta-analysis demonstrated that there was no difference in malaria parasite density among patients with co-infection when compared to patients with Plasmodium spp. mono-infection. Only two studies demonstrated that a higher hookworm intensity was positively correlated with higher malaria parasite density 13, 50 . Previous studies demonstrated that a higher hookworm intensity was positively correlated with a higher malaria parasite density, whereas it was negatively correlated with a lower malaria parasite density when malaria was co-infected with A. lumbricoides 12, 13 . The possible association of hookworm with protection from severe malaria was that infection of helminth modulates inflammatory factors and immunoglobulin E-induced nitric oxide (NO) production and is related to reduced parasite sequestration, which protects against severe malaria 71, 72 . In addition, helminth may decrease cytophilic IgG1 and IgG3 antibodies, which protect the host from malaria disease. Moreover, helminth infection can increase the non-cytophilic IgG2, IgG4 and IgM antibodies, thereby accelerating the severity of malaria 73 .

Anaemia caused by malaria and hookworm is attributable to a combination of chronic blood loss, haemolysis, and haemopoietic suppression 52 . In addition, children with asymptomatic Plasmodium infection demonstrated impaired intestinal iron absorption, which may play an important role in the development of anaemia 74 . Previous studies demonstrated that hookworm infection is more prevalent in older children than in young children, and is associated with chronic intestinal blood loss 62, 75 . In areas where co-infection was low, co-infection was related to anaemia and its effect on the child's health and development 62 . The mechanisms by which Plasmodium spp. causes anaemia involve decreased red blood cell production by bone marrow suppression and increased red blood cell destruction through rupturing, phagocytosis and hypersplenism 76, 77 , while hookworm infection contributes to anaemia through chronic blood loss in the intestine 78 . The present study found no association between co-infection and malaria parasite density or haemoglobin level among the included studies. A possible explanation is that the impact of co-infection on these parameters might be due to an increase in the number of intestinal helminths species than only hookworm co-infection 12, 71 . In addition, when compared to other intestinal helminth infections, the mean Plasmodium density in co-infected individuals with hookworm was lower than in malarial patients co-infected with A. lumbricoides alone, S. mansoni alone or T. trichiura alone 31 . Another explanation for the difference in contradicting reports about parasite density among co-infected patients is the variation among the included studies, such as the difference in participants, study design, methodology, level of parasite endemicity and local climate. These variations impact the differences in Plasmodium spp. and hookworm interactions and influence the heterogeneity among the includes studies. Another explanation suggested by a previous study was that hookworm infection was not associated with anaemia if low infection intensities were detected in the studied population 38, 79 . The non-impact of Plasmodium spp. and hookworm co-infection www.nature.com/scientificreports/ on anaemia in the present study suggested that the anaemia was most likely due to dietary deficiency. Therefore, more studies are needed to explore the impact of co-infection on anaemia. This study has several limitations. First, several important sources of databases, such as ScienceDirect and OVID, were not included in the search. Therefore, some relevant studies may have been missed from the search. Second, the source of heterogeneity across the included studies in the pooled prevalence analysis cannot be explored due to the limited data on the included studies. Therefore, a pooled analysis needed to be interpreted with caution. Third, the number of included studies that reported the mean or median haemoglobin and mean malarial parasite density was limited, which caused imprecision in the estimate for a pooled analysis of the mean haemoglobin and mean parasite density between patients with Plasmodium spp. and hookworm infection. Third, only studies published in English were included. For this reason, studies in Latin America are absent in this review, although this region has high malaria and hookworm endemicity.

In conclusion, co-infection of Plasmodium spp. and hookworm was common and it most likely occurred by chance. The meta-analysis demonstrated no difference in the malaria parasite density and haemoglobin level in patients with co-infection compared to Plasmodium monoinfection. However, these results were based on the limited number of studies included for meta-analysis. Therefore, for a more comprehensive review, further meta-analysis studies should include non-English literature or case-control studies. Additionally, further studies are needed to investigate the mechanism of hookworm infection on malaria severity. Finally, the detection of hookworm infections among patients with malaria in endemic areas of both diseases is recommended to prevent severe malaria.

All data supporting the findings of this study are available within the article and its supplementary files. 

Epidemiology and clinical features of soil-transmitted helminths

Prevalence, intensity and associated risk factors of soil transmitted helminth infections: A comparison between Negritos (indigenous) in inland jungle and those in resettlement at town peripheries

Soil-transmitted helminth infection and intestinal inflammation among the Shuar of Amazonian Ecuador

Soil-transmitted helminths and associated risk factors among elementary school pupils in Dadin Kowa

Trends in prevalence of soil-transmitted helminth and major intestinal protozoan infections among school-aged children in Nepal

Assessment of public health implication of malaria-geohelminth co-infection with an emphasis on hookworm-malaria anemia among suspected malaria patients in asendabo, southwest Ethiopia

Synergetic effects of Plasmodium, hookworm, and Schistosoma mansoni infections on hemoglobin level among febrile school age children in Jawe Worda, Northwest Ethiopia

Antagonistic effects of Plasmodium-helminth co-infections on malaria pathology in different population groups in Cote d'Ivoire

High prevalence of Plasmodium falciparum and soil-transmitted helminth co-infections in a periurban community in Kwara State

Malaria severity status in patients with soil-transmitted helminth infections

Malaria Parasitemia in febrile patients mono-and coinfected with soiltransmitted helminthiasis attending Sanja Hospital, Northwest Ethiopia

Hookworm infection

Epidemiology of helminth infections and their relationship to clinical malaria in southwest Uganda

Cytokine and chemokine profile of the innate and adaptive immune response of Schistosoma haematobium and Plasmodium falciparum single and co-infected school-aged children from an endemic area of Lambarene, Gabon

Associations between helminth infections, Plasmodium falciparum parasite carriage and antibody responses to sexual and asexual stage malarial antigens

Schistosomiasis coinfection in children influences acquired immune response against Plasmodium falciparum malaria antigens

Reduced antibody responses against Plasmodium falciparum vaccine candidate antigens in the presence of Trichuris trichiura

Schistosoma haematobium effects on Plasmodium falciparum infection modified by soil-transmitted helminths in school-age children living in rural areas of Gabon

Worms and malaria: Noisy nuisances and silent benefits

The Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (NOS) for assessing the quality of nonrandomised studies in meta-analyses

Estimating the mean and variance from the median, range, and the size of a sample

Co-endemicity of Plasmodium falciparum and intestinal helminths infection in school age children in rural communities of Kwara State Nigeria

Epidemiology of parasitic co-infections during pregnancy in Lambaréné

Epidemiology of soil transmitted helminth infections in the middle-belt of Ghana

Levels of serum eosinophil cationic protein are associated with hookworm infection and intensity in endemic communities in Ghana

Pattern of Plasmodium-intestinal helminth co-infection among pregnant women in a high transmission zone of malaria in Nigeria

Plasmodium-helminth coinfection and its sources of heterogeneity across East Africa

Impact of polyparasitic infections on anemia and undernutrition among Kenyan children living in a Schistosoma haematobium-endemic area

Malaria and related outcomes in patients with intestinal helminths: A cross-sectional study

Plasmodium/intestinal helminth co-infections among pregnant Nigerian women

Malaria and hookworm co-infection among pregnant and non-pregnant women in a semi-urban area in Anambra state

Plasmodium falciparum and helminth coinfection in a semi urban population of pregnant women in Uganda

Hookworm infection among school age children in Kintampo north municipality, Ghana: Nutritional risk factors and response to albendazole treatment

Integrated prevalence mapping of schistosomiasis, soil-transmitted helminthiasis and malaria in lakeside and island communities in Lake Victoria

Epidemiology of coinfection with soil transmitted helminths and Plasmodium falciparum among school children in Bumula District in western Kenya

Malaria and helminth co-infections in school and preschool children: A cross-sectional study in Magu district, north-western Tanzania

Co-infections with Plasmodium falciparum, Schistosoma mansoni and intestinal helminths among schoolchildren in endemic areas of northwestern Tanzania

Plasmodium falciparum and helminth coinfections among schoolchildren in relation to agro-ecosystems in Mvomero District

Effect of schistosomiasis and soil-transmitted helminth infections on physical fitness of school children in côte d'ivoire

Epidemiological and clinical correlates of malaria-helminth co-infections in Southern Ethiopia

Malaria and helminth co-infection in children living in a malaria endemic setting of mount Cameroon and predictors of anemia

Prevalence and clinical outcomes of Plasmodium falciparum and intestinal parasitic infections among children in Kiryandongo refugee camp, mid-Western Uganda: A cross sectional study

Asymptomatic falciparum malaria and intestinal helminths co-infection among school children in Osogbo

Prevalence and associated factors of Plasmodium falciparum and soil transmitted helminth infections among pregnant women in Osun state

Heterogeneities and consequences of Plasmodium species and hookworm coinfection: A population based study in Uganda

Interactions and potential implications of Plasmodium falciparum-hookworm coinfection in different age groups in south-central Côte d'Ivoire

Distribution and risk factors for Plasmodium and helminth co-infections: A cross-sectional survey among children in Bagamoyo district, coastal region of Tanzania

Overlapping distribution of Plasmodium falciparum and soil transmitted helminths in a malaria hyperendemic region

Complex interactions between soil-transmitted helminths and malaria in pregnant women on the Thai-Burmese border

Asymptomatic vivax and falciparum parasitaemia with helminth co-infection: Major risk factors for anemia in early life

Concurrent helminthic infection protects schoolchildren with Plasmodium vivax from anemia

Prevalence and outcomes of malaria as co-infection among patients with human African trypanosomiasis: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Prevalence, probability, and outcomes of typhoidal/non-typhoidal Salmonella and malaria co-infection among febrile patients: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Prevalence and characteristics of malaria co-infection among individuals with visceral leishmaniasis in Africa and Asia: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Prevalence and characteristics of malaria among COVID-19 individuals: A systematic review, meta-analysis, and analysis of case reports

A meta-analysis on the prevalence and characteristics of severe malaria in patients with Plasmodium spp. and HIV co-infection

Malaria and helminth co-infections in outpatients of Alaba Kulito Health Center, southern Ethiopia: A cross sectional study

Prevalence of hookworm infection and hemoglobin status among rural elementary school children in Southern Ethiopia

Effectiveness of albendazole for hookworm varies widely by community and correlates with nutritional factors: A cross-sectional study of school-age children in Ghana

Malaria and helminth interactions in humans: An epidemiological viewpoint

Responses to malarial antigens are altered in helminth-infected children

Prevalence of asymptomatic malaria and intestinal helminthiasis co-infection among children living in selected rural communities in Ibadan Nigeria

Asymptomatic malaria and intestinal helminth co-infection among children in a rural community in Southwest Nigeria

Water, sanitation and hygiene related risk factors for soil-transmitted helminth and Giardia duodenalis infections in rural communities in Timor-Leste

The role of residential location in apparent helminth and malaria associations

Cross-sectional study of the burden of vector-borne and soil-transmitted polyparasitism in rural communities of Coast Province

Infection and co-infection with helminths and Plasmodium among school children in Côte d'Ivoire: Results from a national cross-sectional survey

Effects of hygiene and defecation behavior on helminths and intestinal protozoa infections in Taabo

Intestinal helminth infections are associated with increased incidence of Plasmodium falciparum malaria in Thailand

A new NOS2 promoter polymorphism associated with increased nitric oxide production and protection from severe malaria in Tanzanian and Kenyan children

Worms can worsen malaria: Towards a new means to roll back malaria

Increased serum hepcidin and alterations in blood iron parameters associated with asymptomatic P. falciparum and P. vivax malaria

Soil-transmitted helminth infections: Ascariasis, trichuriasis, and hookworm

Factors contributing to anemia after uncomplicated falciparum malaria

Hematopoiesis in human malaria

Hookworm infection caused acute intestinal bleeding diagnosed by capsule: A case report and literature review

Hemoquant determination of hookworm-related blood loss and its role in iron deficiency in African children

This research was supported by the New Strategic Research (P2P) Project Fiscal Year 2022, Walailak University, Thailand.

M.K., A.M., G.D.M., F.R.M., and S.K. participated in the study design, data analysis, and writing of the paper. Allauthors have read and approved the final paper.

The authors declare no competing interests.

Supplementary Information The online version contains supplementary material available at https:// doi. org/ 10. 1038/ s41598-022-10569-2.Correspondence and requests for materials should be addressed to M.K.

Publisher's note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http:// creat iveco mmons. org/ licen ses/ by/4. 0/.