key: cord-0019572-7gipxxme
authors: Torres, Thiago S.; Coelho, Lara E.; Konda, Kelika A.; Vega-Ramirez, E. Hamid; Elorreaga, Oliver A.; Diaz-Sosa, Dulce; Hoagland, Brenda; Pimenta, Cristina; Benedetti, Marcos; Grinsztejn, Beatriz; Caceres, Carlos F.; Veloso, Valdilea G.
title: Low socioeconomic status is associated with self-reported HIV positive status among young MSM in Brazil and Peru
date: 2021-07-31
journal: BMC Infect Dis
DOI: 10.1186/s12879-021-06455-3
sha: 61abd36b21cc0c5aff5e53500a55e3729faa30ea
doc_id: 19572
cord_uid: 7gipxxme

BACKGROUND: Despite efforts to stop HIV epidemic in Latin America, new HIV cases continue to increase in the region especially among young MSM (YMSM). This study aims to assess if sociodemographic characteristics are associated with self-reported HIV positive status among YMSM from three Latin American countries. METHODS: Cross-sectional web-based survey advertised on dating apps (Grindr and Hornet) and Facebook in Brazil, Mexico and Peru. For this analysis, we included YMSM aged 18–24 years who self-reported their HIV status. We used multivariable logistic regression models for each country separately to verify if sociodemographic characteristics (race, education and income) were associated with HIV self-reported status after adjusting for behavior characteristics (sexual attraction and steady partner). RESULTS: Among 43,687 MSM who initiated the questionnaire, 27,318 (62.5%) reported their HIV status; 7001 (25.6%) of whom were YMSM. Most YMSM (83.4%) reported an HIV test in the past year, and 15.7% reported an HIV positive status in Peru, 8.4% in Mexico and 7.7% in Brazil. In adjusted models, low-income was associated with higher odds of self-reported HIV positive status in Brazil (aOR = 1.33, 95%CI: 1.01–1.75) and Peru (aOR = 1.56, 95%CI: 1.02–2.40), but not in Mexico. Lower education was associated with higher odds of self-reported HIV positive status only in Brazil (aOR = 1.35, 95%CI: 1.05–1.75). CONCLUSIONS: In this large, cross-country study, self-reported HIV positive status among YMSM was high. Lower socioeconomic status was associated with higher odds of self-reported HIV positive status in Brazil and Peru. There is an urgent need for HIV prevention interventions targeting YMSM, and efforts to address low-income YMSM are especially needed in Peru and Brazil. SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12879-021-06455-3.

Latin America is one of the most unequal regions in the world due to historical and structural characteristics of its societies [1] . Brazil, Mexico and Peru represent more than a half of the overall population (~368 million) [2] . These countries also share vast socio-economic disparities. Despite being the 9th largest economy by nominal Gross Domestic Product (GDP = US$ 1.9 trillion), Brazil is the 9th most unequal country in the world and the 2nd in the Americas according to GINI index from The World Bank [1, 3] . Mexico and Peru poverty rate for 2018 were 23% and 22%, respectively, corresponding to the percentage of the population living on less than USD 5.50 a day [4] . Social disparities are related to health outcomes [5] and studies to understand these disparities are of utmost importance in the region.

Globally, 38 million people were living with HIV and 1.7 million people were newly infected in 2019 [6] . In Latin America, the number of new HIV diagnoses has increased from 100,000 in 2018 to 120,000 in 2019 [6] . About 90% of new HIV infections in the region occurred in 10 countries, including Brazil (49%), Mexico (13%), and Peru (4%) [7] . HIV epidemic in the region remains concentrated in vulnerable populations, with 40% of new infections occurring among gay, bisexuals and other men who have sex with men (MSM) in 2018 [8, 9] . HIV prevalence among MSM were estimated at 17% in Brazil [10] and Mexico [11] and 10% in Peru [12] , while it is below 0.5% for the general population in each country [13] [14] [15] .

Data from other regions show that young MSM (YMSM) aged 15-24 are at higher risk of HIV infection [16] [17] [18] [19] due to factors such as lack of access to comprehensive sexual education and preventive strategies, condomless and PrEP-less sex, use of alcohol and drugs during sex, transactional sex, and low perceived HIV risk [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] . In Latin America, previous studies using probability-based sampling method have estimated HIV prevalence among YMSM from 1.2% in Santos, Brazil in 2009 to 32.6% in Colón, Panama in 2012 [25] . In Brazil, national surveillance data showed a three-fold increase in the rate of HIV cases among cisgender men aged 15-19 years and two-fold increase among those aged 20-24 years from 2006 to 2017 [13] . In Mexico, the national HIV incidence among MSM aged 15-24 years-old has increased from 13.6 (2015) to 23.6 per 100,000 habitants (2019) [26] . Recent studies have shown that YMSM from Latin America are less aware, less willing and less adherent to use pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) compared to older MSM [23, [27] [28] [29] .

Data from the U.S. found that socioeconomic disparities were related to age among MSM, with YMSM having less income, less access and use of health care services compared to their older counterparts [30] . In addition, socio demographic characteristics, such as race and education, were more strongly associated with HIV infection than individual risk behavior among YMSM [31] . Most of studies previously conducted among MSM in Latin America have evaluated associations of HIV infection with behavior without specifically considering sociodemographic characteristics; none of them specifically targeting YMSM [32] [33] [34] [35] [36] .

The Implementation PrEP Project (ImPrEP) aims to generate evidence on the feasibility, acceptability, and cost-effectiveness of PrEP among MSM and transgender people specific to the cultural contexts and health systems in Brazil, Mexico, and Peru. Within ImPrEP, we conducted a web-based survey aiming to understand the characteristics of MSM in these countries. Primary analyses of this study have evaluated the factors associated with awareness and willingness to use PrEP among MSM self-reporting HIV negative or unknown status [27, 37] .

In this secondary analysis, we aim to assess sociodemographic and behavioral factors associated with selfreported HIV positive status among YMSM in three Latin American countries.

This was a cross-sectional, web-based survey targeting MSM from Brazil, Mexico, and Peru. Inclusion criteria were cisgender men, ≥18 years, resident of one of the three countries. For this secondary analysis, we included YMSM aged 18-24 years who self-reported their HIV status. Individuals who had never tested for HIV and were sexually attracted only to women were excluded. Details of the study design are described elsewhere [27] . Briefly, the questionnaire was developed in English (Additional file 1) by the researchers of the three countries and then translated to local languages (Portuguese in Brazil and Spanish in Mexico and Peru). Final versions were reviewed by two researchers fluent in Portuguese and Spanish. The questionnaire was programmed on Alchemer® in Brazil and SurveyMonkey® in Mexico and Peru. Then, each survey link was tested by the researchers and by members of MSM community as part of the validation process. The project was advertised on Hornet® and Grindr®, two geosocial networking (GSN) apps used by MSM, and Facebook®. Participants were not asked to refer friends to take the survey, but they could share the survey link if they wish.

The main outcome of interest was self-reported HIV status, which was assessed as follows: "Have you ever had a positive HIV result?", with possible answers "yes" (self-reported HIV positive status) and "no" (self-reported HIV negative status). This question was only asked among individuals who reported a history of HIV testing, and as previously mentioned, individuals who reported never testing for HIV were excluded from the study.

Study recruitment was categorized into: Apps (Grindr and Hornet) and Facebook. Race was collected using the relevant categories for each country. In Brazil and Peru, race was stratified as "White", "Black", "Pardo or Mestizo", "Indigenous" or "Asian". Mexican participants were asked if they were indigenous (yes/no). Education was dichotomized by those who had less than or complete secondary education (≤ secondary education) versus those reporting any post-secondary education (> secondary education). Individuals were asked about their monthly income by the time of survey completion. Income was stratified in "low", "middle" and "high" according to each country definition, which considered the minimum wage value per month in June 2018 (Brazil: 954 BRL or 250 USD; Mexico: 2686 MXN or 141 USD; Peru: 850 PEN or 265 USD). For Brazil, participants were stratified in "low" if the family monthly income was equivalent or inferior to three times the minimum wage (≤ 750 USD); in "middle" if between three and ten times the minimum wage (751-2500 USD); in "high" if superior to ten times the minimum wage (> 2500 USD) [20, 38, 39] . For Mexico, participants were stratified in "low" if individual monthly income was less than three times the minimum wage (< 423 USD); "middle" if between three and five times the minimum wage (423-704 USD); and high if equivalent or superior to five times the minimum wage (750 USD) [27, 40] . For Peru, participants were stratified in "low" if individual monthly income was less than the equivalent of three times the minimum wage (≤ 795 USD); "middle" if between three and five times the minimum wage (796-1060 USD); and "high" if greater than five times the minimum wage (> 1060 USD) [41] . Sexual attraction was dichotomized into those attracted only to men versus those attracted to both men and women. As previously mentioned, respondents reporting being attracted only to women were excluded from this analysis. Individuals were asked if they had a steady partner (yes/no) without further specification (i.e., if this was a long-term casual partner or a formal romantic relationship). They were also asked about their last HIV test with possible options as follows: last 3 months, last 6 months, last year and more than 1 year. As previously mentioned, those who responded that they had never tested for HIV were excluded from the analysis. We dichotomized this question in "≤ 1 year" versus "> 1 year". Individuals were also asked about city of residence (data not shown).

For the logistic regression models, race was dichotomized into "white" vs. "non-white" (Black, Brown, Indigenous and Asian) following previous studies conducted among Brazilian and Peruvian MSM [20, 27, 42, 43] and income was dichotomized into "low" vs. "middle/high".

Participant characteristics were described according to self-reported HIV status (negative or positive) per country (Brazil, Mexico, and Peru). Some survey questions included options such as "I do not want to answer" or "I do not know" for participant comfort, and these answers were considered missing for data analysis. We used logistic regression to assess the factors associated with self-reported HIV positive status separately for each country. Bivariate regression models were fitted for all explanatory variables and then a multivariable model was estimated including all of these variables regardless of statistical significance, based our a priori theoretical/ conceptual model. We wanted to verify if sociodemographic characteristics measured by race, education and income were associated with HIV self-reported status after adjusting for behavior characteristics measured by sexual attraction and steady partner. These factors have been associated with HIV status among MSM from Latin America in previous studies [25] . All analyses were performed using Software R version 4.0.3 [44] .

From March 2018 to June 2018, a total of 43,687 MSM accessed the questionnaire, 11.1% (5610/43,687) did not meet study inclusion criteria and of the eligible individuals 71.7% (27,318/38,077) self-reported their HIV status. Among these, 7001 (25.6%; 7007/27318) were YMSM and were included in this analysis (Fig. 1) In the multivariable models adjusted by behavioral characteristics, being low-income was associated with higher odds of self-reported HIV positive status in Brazil (aOR = 1.33, 95%CI: 1.01-1.75) and Peru (aOR = 1.56, 95%CI: 1.02-2.40) but not in Mexico (Table 2) . Lower education was also associated with higher odds of selfreported HIV positive status in Brazil (aOR = 1.31, 95%CI: 1.01-1.72), but not in Mexico nor in Peru. Race was not associated with self-reported HIV positive status in Brazil or Peru, nor was being indigenous associated with self-reported HIV positive status in Mexico (data not shown).

YMSM from the three countries sexually attracted only to men had at least twice higher odds of selfreported HIV positive status than those attracted to men and women. Peruvian YMSM having a steady partner had higher odds of self-reported HIV positive status than those with no steady partner (aOR = 1.67, 95%CI: 1.10-2.50).

In this cross-country study, self-reported HIV positive status among YMSM within Latin America was high for Brazil, Mexico and Peru. In Peru and Brazil, low socioeconomic status was associated with self-reported HIV positive status. The samples included from each country were distinct, which could explain the disparate model results across countries. High internet access and smartphone availability among all social strata in Brazil [45] could explain the higher inclusion of lower income YMSM compared to the other two countries.

Our results of high self-reported HIV positive status are corroborated by previous studies assessing HIV prevalence in the region during the past 10 years, such as in Lima, Peru (27%), Rio de Janeiro, Brazil (13%), Tijuana, Mexico (12%) and São Paulo, Brazil (11%) [25] . In Brazil, one hypothesis of the increase in HIV prevalence [12] . Lower income and lower education, factors frequently associated with poverty, have shown to be associated with self-reported HIV positive status in this analysis. We could not find other studies exploring sociodemographic factors associated with HIV status specifically for Latin American YMSM. In Brazil, previous studies have shown that low-income YMSM were less adherent to daily oral PrEP than older MSM [29] and lower schooling was associated with worse outcomes among individuals living with HIV, such as being on antiretroviral treatment and virologic suppression [47] . In Mexico, a national representative survey among MSM not stratified by age showed that lower education was associated with a positive HIV test result [11] . Socioeconomic disparities add to other vulnerabilities commonly observed among YMSM such as mental health disorders [30] , low HIV risk perception [28, 38] , riskier sexual practices [28] and lower knowledge of prevention technologies, such as PrEP [23] . YMSM sexual attracted to men had higher odds of self-reported HIV positive status than those preferring both men and women. Other studies conducted in Latin America observed similar association considering sexual orientation. Being gay/homosexual was previously associated with HIV prevalence among MSM from Mexico, Peru and other countries from the region [25] . MSM self-identified as gay had increased odds of HIV risk behavior in a large analysis considering 16,667 HIVuninfected MSM from Brazil [20] . In a longitudinal analysis, type of relationship (casual versus steady) and condomless anal sex (receptive versus insertive) differ according to sexual orientation, as self-identified bisexual men reported more insertive condomless anal sex with casual male partners than self-identified gay men [48] .

Although not statistically significant in the multivariate model, non-white Brazilian YMSM had increased odds of self-reporting HIV positive status compared to white YMSM in bivariate analysis. According to Brazilian surveillance data, the proportion of new HIV cases among non-white males has increased from 48 to 64% between 2007 and 2019 in comparison to white males [49] . MSM populations may face different forms of stigma, including internalized, perceived, experienced and layered stigmas [50] , and Black and Pardo MSM populations additionally face structural racism, which may increase their vulnerability to HIV infection in comparison to white MSM. In a previous study conducted in Brazil, Black individuals had over 50% higher odds of experiencing discrimination than whites, even after controlling for income, education, social status, and health problems [51] . Studies addressing intersectional stigma among non-white YMSM in Brazil are required as well as the inclusion of these populations in the conception and delivery of educational campaigns about HIV prevention and sexual health.

This study has limitations. Web-based studies are not probabilistic sampling strategies, precluding the generalization of the findings to all MSM from Brazil, Mexico and Peru. Moreover, our findings are based on MSM who have access to cellphones and who use GSN apps or social media. Measures of income were adapted to specific countries' definitions, in Brazil official definition uses family income while in Mexico and Peru, individual income is preferred. Thus, comparison of the results regarding income between countries should be made cautiously. Moreover, sex work was not assessed in the study, though it can be both related to HIV status and income. Given the cross-sectional nature of the data, causality and the direction of association may not be inferred. All collected data were self-reported by participants and may be subject to bias, including our main outcome (self-reported HIV status). However, individuals tend to be more open through web-based surveys, thereby reducing the possibility of social desirability bias [52] . There is also a concern about participants taking the survey multiple times. To mitigate this bias, the first question of the survey was, "Are you answering this survey for the first time?" and anyone answering 'no' was excluded.

Self-reported HIV-positive status among YMSM in three Latin American countries was high and low socioeconomic status was associated with higher odds of selfreported HIV positive status in Brazil and Peru. There is an urgent need for HIV prevention interventions targeting YMSM to stop HIV epidemic by 2030, and efforts to address low-income YMSM are especially needed in Peru and Brazil.

United Nations Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean

World Bank estimate

Inequalities in life expectancy in six large Latin American cities from the SALURBAL study: an ecological analysis

Ending AIDS: progress towards the 90-90-90 targets

The HIV epidemic in Latin America: accomplishments and challenges on treatment and prevention

~:text= New%20HIV%20infections%20rising%20in%20Latin%20America%E2%80% 95key%20populations%20particularly%20affected,-14%20October%20201 9&text=HIV%20incidence%2C%20the-, Although%20several%20countries%2 0in%20Latin%20America%20have%20shown%20impressive%20declines

HIV prevalence among men who have sex with men in Brazil: results of the 2nd national survey using respondent-driven sampling

Is the HIV epidemic stable among MSM in Mexico? HIV prevalence and risk behavior results from a nationally representative survey among men who have sex with men

Presentación de los resultados de los estudios de prevalencia de VIH/ITS y vigilancia del comportamiento en población HSH, MTG y población indígena

Boletim epidemiológico HIV/Aids

Accessed 16

Comparison of HIV risks among gay, lesbian, bisexual and heterosexual homeless youth

A review of the epidemiology of HIV infection and prevention responses among MSM in Asia

HIV in young men who have sex with men: a review of epidemiology, risk and protective factors, and interventions

How heterogeneous are MSM from Brazilian cities? An analysis of sexual behavior and perceived risk and a description of trends in awareness and willingness to use preexposure prophylaxis

Depressive symptoms, utilization of mental health care, substance use and sexual risk among young men who have sex with men in explore: implications for age-specific interventions

Sexual behaviors and risks among bisexually-and gay-identified young Latino men

Characteristics of younger MSM and association of age with PrEP awareness and willingness in Brazil, Mexico and Peru. The IAS Conference

Fatores associados ao baixo conhecimento sobre HIV/AIDS entre homens que fazem sexo com homens no Brasil. Cad Saúde Pública (Online)

High prevalence of HIV among young men who have sex with men in Latin America and the Caribbean: a systematic review

Direction of epidemiological surveillance for communicable diseases

Factors associated with willingness to use pre-exposure prophylaxis in Brazil, Mexico, and Peru: web-based survey among men who have sex with men

Factors associated with PrEP awareness according to age and willingness to use HIV prevention technologies: the 2017 online survey among MSM in Brazil

Retention, engagement, and adherence to pre-exposure prophylaxis for men who have sex with men and transgender women in PrEP Brasil: 48 week results of a demonstration study

Determinants of HIV incidence disparities among young and older men who have sex with men in the United States

High HIV incidence and prevalence and associated factors among young MSM

Prevalence and risk factors for HIV infection in a population of homosexual, bisexual, and other men who have sex with men in the metropolitan region of Chile: a re-emerging health problem

High HIV burden in men who have sex with men across Colombia's largest cities: findings from an integrated biological and behavioral surveillance study

A continuing HIV epidemic and differential patterns of HIV-STI risk among MSM in Quito, Ecuador: an urgent need to scale up HIV testing and prevention

Prevalence and correlates of HIV among men who have sex with men in Tijuana

High HIV infection prevalence in a group of men who have sex with men

Are men who have sex with men at higher risk for HIV in Latin America more aware of PrEP? Plos One

High-risk sexual behavior, binge drinking and use of stimulants are key experiences on the pathway to high perceived HIV risk among men who have sex with men in Brazil

Pesquisa de Orçamentos Familiares Tabela 439 -Famílias por classes de recebimento

Results of the National Survey of Occupation and Employment during the Fourth Quarter of 2017

Impact of COVID-19 pandemic on sexual minority populations in Brazil: an analysis of social/racial disparities in maintaining social distancing and a description of sexual behavior

Awareness of prevention strategies and willingness to use Preexposure prophylaxis in Brazilian men who have sex with men using apps for sexual encounters: online cross-sectional study

C2A -USUÁRIOS DE INTERNET -INDICADOR AMPLIADO

Comparing HIV risk-related behaviors between 2 RDS national samples of MSM in Brazil

Sociodemographic determinants of attrition in the HIV continuum of care in Brazil

Differences in HIV risk behaviors between self-identified gay and bisexual young men who are HIV-negative

Measuring stigma affecting sex workers (SW) and men who have sex with men (MSM): a systematic review

Who experiences discrimination in Brazil? Evidence from a large metropolitan region

Mode differences between face-to-face and web surveys: an experimental investigation of data quality and social desirability effects

Publisher's Note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations

Presented in part at the Conference of Retroviruses and Opportunistic Infections (CROI), Abstract Number 857, Boston, March 8-11, 2020. We would like to thanks Gabriel Madeira for programming the questionnaires and Daniel R B Bezerra for social media consulting in Brazil. 

The online version contains supplementary material available at https://doi. org/10.1186/s12879-021-06455-3.

Authors' contributions TST and LEC did the literature search. TST, KAK and EHV-R conceived the questionnaire. TST, KAK, EHV-R, OAE and DDS worked on the advertisement of the questionnaire. TST, KAK and EHV-R performed data cleaning. TST and LEC analyzed the data and generated the tables and figures. KAK reviewed the statistical analyses. TST and LEC interpreted the data and draft the manuscript. KAK, EHV-R, OAE, DDS, BH, CP, MB, BG, CFC and VGV substantively revised the manuscript for important intellectual content. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.

This project was made possible thanks to Unitaid's funding and support. Unitaid accelerates access to innovative health products and lays the foundations for their scale-up by countries and partners. Unitaid is a hosted partnership of WHO. We would like to thank the support of the MoHs of Brazil, Mexico, and Peru. The funding bodies had no role in the design of the study and collection, analysis, and interpretation of data and in writing the manuscript.

The datasets analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.

Ethics and consent to participate An ethical review board in each country approved the study: in Brazil, INI Evandro Chagas-FIOCRUZ institutional review board (#CAAE 82021918.0.0000.5262); in Mexico, the research ethics committee of the National Institute of Psychiatry Ramón de la Fuente Muñiz (#CEI/C/038/2018); and in Peru, Universidad Peruana Cayetano Heredia Ethical Committee for Research with Human Subjects (#101460). All study participants provided their informed consent electronically before initiating the web-based survey, which clearly stated that the survey was targeting MSM. No identification of participants was collected and no incentives were provided for answering the survey.

Not applicable.

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.