key: cord-0014513-obrrkvxj
authors: Zhao, Qinfeng; Wang, Jian; Nicholas, Stephen; Maitland, Elizabeth; Sun, Jingjie; Jiao, Chen; Xu, Lizheng; Leng, Anli
title: Health-Related Quality of Life and Health Service Use among Multimorbid Middle-Aged and Older-Aged Adults in China: A Cross-Sectional Study in Shandong Province
date: 2020-12-11
journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health
DOI: 10.3390/ijerph17249261
sha: d683f8e07000aaa434f9413a13a1246d6c7326a5
doc_id: 14513
cord_uid: obrrkvxj

(1) Background: The management of multiple chronic diseases challenges China’s health system, but current research has neglected how multimorbidity is associated with poor health-related quality of life (HRQOL) and high health service demands by middle-aged and older adults. (2) Methods: A cross-sectional study was conducted in Shandong province, China in 2018 across three age groups: Middle-aged (45 to 59 years), young-old (60 to 74 years), and old-old (75 or above years). The information about socio-economic, health-related behaviors, HRQOL, and health service utilization was collected via face-to-face structured questionnaires. The EQ-5D-3L instrument, comprising a health description system and a visual analog scale (VAS), was used to measure participants’ HRQOL, and χ(2) tests and the one-way ANOVA test were used to analyze differences in socio-demographic factors and HRQOL among the different age groups. Logistic regression models estimated the associations between lifestyle factors, health service utilization, and multimorbidity across age groups. (3) Results: There were 17,867 adults aged 45 or above in our sample, with 9259 (51.82%) female and 65.60% living in rural areas. Compared with the middle-aged adults, the young-old and old-old were more likely to be single and to have a lower level of education and income, with the old-old having lower levels than the young-old (P < 0.001). We found that 2465 (13.80%) suffered multimorbidities of whom 75.21% were older persons (aged 60 or above). As age increased, both the mean values of EQ-5D utility and the VAS scale decreased, displaying an inverse trend to the increase in the number of chronic diseases (P < 0.05). Ex-smokers and physical check-ups for middle or young-old respondents and overweight/obesity for all participants (P < 0.05) were positively correlated with multimorbidity. Drinking within the past month for all participants (P < 0.001), and daily tooth-brushing for middle (P < 0.05) and young-old participants (P < 0.001), were negatively associated with multimorbidity. Multimorbidities increased service utilization including outpatient and inpatient visits and taking self-medicine; and the probability of health utilization was the lowest for the old-old multimorbid patients (P < 0.001). (4) Conclusions: The prevalence and decline in HRQOL of multimorbid middle-aged and older-aged people were severe in Shandong province. Old patients also faced limited access to health services. We recommend early prevention and intervention to address the prevalence of middle-aged and old-aged multimorbidity. Further, the government should set-up special treatment channels for multiple chronic disease sufferers, improve medical insurance policies for the older-aged groups, and set-up multiple chronic disease insurance to effectively alleviate the costs of medical utilization caused by economic pressure for outpatients and inpatients with chronic diseases.

Chronic diseases challenge public health systems and individual well-being around the world. In China, chronic diseases accounted for 89% of all deaths and 70% of disability-adjusted life-years lost, with devastating impacts on individuals, the public health system, and the social economy [1] [2] [3] [4] . With population ageing, and lifestyle changes driving health risk factors, the prevalence of multimorbidity, or two or more chronic conditions, is intensifying, and multimorbidity is a major concern for chronic diseases management [5] . Multimorbidity prevalence around the world varies by age, ranging from 2.6% to over 95%, and data from China estimate that multimorbidity ranges from 6.4% to 76.5% among people aged over 60 years old [1, 6] . Multimorbidity leads to higher mortality [7] and poorer quality of life, including constraining daily activities, discomfort and pain, decreasing happiness, and the loss of independence [8, 9] . Multimorbidity also increases the frequency of hospitalization, outpatient visits, and use of medicine, and imposes health-related financial stress, including catastrophic health expenditure by individuals and families [10] [11] [12] . Overall, whether for individuals, households, the health system, or society, the multimorbidity presents severe challenges.

Numerous studies have explored the age, gender, place of residence, education, income level, and occupation as factors associated with multimorbidity [12] [13] [14] . Lifestyle factors, such as obesity, tobacco use, drinking and physical inactivity, and unhealthy diets, have also been identified as multimorbidity risk factors [1, [15] [16] [17] [18] . Most of these studies have focused on older adults, given the susceptibility of older people to multimorbidity [10, 15, 19, 20] , with global multimorbidity rates as high as 98% among older adults [15] . Current research has tended to neglect how multimorbidity is significantly associated with a poor health-related quality of life (HRQOL) and high health service demands by older adults [9, 21] . However, multimorbidity is not only an old person problem. The prevalence of multimorbidity across working-age adults is widespread, impacting the HRQOL of middle-aged adults and imposing high health service demands on the health system [10, 22] . For example, the World Health Organization (WHO) estimated that a quarter of chronic disease deaths occur among adults under 45 years old [8] . A Scottish study indicated that 30% of people aged 45 to 64 years suffer from more than one chronic disease [5] , and a survey of the general Alberta Canada population reported that 70% of people with multimorbidity were less than 65 years old [6] .

To address these lacunae, we assess multimorbidity among both middle-aged and old-aged people in China. Considering the increase in the average life span, we further subdivided the older group into young-old (60 years to 74 years old) and old-old (75 years old and above) according to the WHO age criteria. Using 2018 cross-sectional data from Shandong province, we estimate the health status of multimorbid middle-aged, young-old, and old-old. Second, we retrospectively explored the association between physical multimorbidity and lifestyle factors to discover the reasons for multimorbidity. Third, we explored health-care service use by multimorbid middle-aged and old-aged persons in Shandong.

Located in eastern China, Shandong province is the second-most populated province and one of China's rapidly developing industrial provinces [23] . Our data came from the Sixth Health Service Survey of Shandong, which was a part of the 2018 Chinese National Health Service Survey [24] . The Sixth Health Service Survey was conducted by the Health Committee of Shandong Province using a three-stage stratified cluster sampling method. First, 20 counties were randomly selected from 137 counties throughout eastern, central, and western areas in Shandong province as the primary sampling units (PSUs). Second, five townships were randomly selected from each PSU yielding 100 townships comprising 50 urban and 50 rural secondary sampling units (SSUs). Third, two villages were randomly selected from each SSU, providing 200 villages in total. After informed consent, face-to-face interviews using a structured questionnaire were conducted with all members in every selected household, with 35,264 individuals in 12,938 households completing the survey. The inclusion criteria in our study were respondents aged over 45 years old, without cognitive impairments, and we excluded some questionnaires that were uncompleted. In the end, a total of 17,867 subjects were eligible for our study.

Socio-demographic variables included age groups (45-59, 60-74, 75+), sex, marital status (single, married, or partnered), education (no education, primary school, secondary school, high school, and above), residence (rural-urban), and income quintiles level (quintile 1: RMB0-10,000; quintile 2: RMB10,001-20,000; quintile 3: RMB20,001-40,000; quintile 4: RMB40,001-60,000; quintile 5: RMB60,001-1,000,000).

Multimorbidity-related conditions were solicited by a range of self-answered disease questions: "Have you been diagnosed with hypertension or diabetes?" "Have you been diagnosed with any chronic diseases except hypertension and diabetes?" and "What chronic diseases do you suffer from?" Each answer was scientifically assessed by investigators separately. Respondents with two or more diseases were classified as multimorbid.

Tested for China, the EQ-5D-3L instrument was used to measure participants' HRQOL. EQ-5D-3L consists of a health description system and a visual analog scale (VAS). The health description system has five dimensions ("Mobility," "Self-Care," "Usual Activities," "Pain/Discomfort," and "Anxiety/Depression"), with each dimension described by a single item divided into three levels: No problem, moderate problems, and severe problems. We described 243 health states, where each state was assigned a utility weight between −0.149 and 1, using a utility scoring function derived from the Chinese general population [25] . VAS recorded the respondents' overall health status ranging from 0 to 100, with higher VAS values representing higher HRQOL [25] .

Lifestyle characteristics were assessed by the following responses: "Never-smoker, ex-smoker, current smoker"; "drank within last 30 days, drank more than 30 days ago, never-drank"; "exercise times ≤1 or ≥2 weekly"; The classifications of BMI were underweight (BMI<18.50 kg/m 2 ), normal weight (BMI 18.50-24.99 kg/m 2 ), overweight (BMI 25.00-29.99 kg/m 2 ), and obese (BMI ≥ 30.00 kg/m 2 ); physical examination in the past year (yes-no); and brushing teeth daily (yes-no).

Health service utilization was assessed through yes-no responses to the following questions: "Have you visited the doctors because of discomfort within two weeks?"; "Have you taken self-medicine because of discomfort within the past two weeks?"; "Have you hospitalized because of discomfort within the past year?"

Participants were divided into three categories: The middle-aged (45 to 59 years), young-old (60 to 74 years), and old-old (75 and above years). The basic variables were described using counts (percentages) and tested using chi-square tests. One-way ANOVA tests were used to compare differences in HRQOL between different numbers of chronic diseases among the three age groups. The associations between lifestyle factors, health service utilization, and multimorbidity across different age groups were estimated by a logistic regression model controlling for socio-economic variables including sex, urban-rural residence, marital status, education, and income levels. The outcomes were expressed as odds ratios (ORs) and 95% confidence intervals (CIs), where P < 0.05 denoted statistically significant differences. All data were analyzed using STATA 14.0. Table 1 presents the characteristics of the 17,867 respondents stratified by age group, with 49.63% aged 45 to 59 years, 40.58% aged 60 to 74 years, and 9.79% aged over 75 years; 9259 (51.82%) were female and 65.60% participants lived in rural areas. The number of single respondents increased with age (P < 0.001). Compared with the middle-aged adults, the young-old and the old-old had a lower level of education and income, with the old-old having lower education and income than the young-old (P < 0.001). About 70% of respondents never smoked or drank, and few people chose to quit smoking; and middle-aged participants were more likely to be smokers (23.12%) and drinkers (29.60%) than the young-old (smokers 20.43% and drinkers 20.90%) and the old-old (smokers 16.17% and drinkers 18.51%) (P < 0.001). About half (52.39%) of young-old exercised twice or more per week compared to 45.79% of middle-aged and 48.46 of old-old respondents, (P < 0.001). In terms of BMI, 24.23% of the old-old were overweight and 4.06% obese, while 38.19% of the middle-aged were overweight and 6.64% obese (P < 0.001). About 79% of older people completed health check-ups in the past year, which was significantly higher than the middle-aged (36%) (P < 0.001). The proportion of respondents brushing their teeth every day decreased with age (P < 0.001). 

As shown in Figure 1 , the average occurrence of multimorbidity was 13.80% for all 17,867 participants; 6.89% of those aged 45 to 59 years; 19.43% of young-old; and 25.43% of old-old respondents. Further, 70.73% of middle-aged adults had no chronic diseases, and 22.38% suffered from one chronic disease condition. Figure 1 shows that the percent of people with chronic diseases increased with age until 80 years old when it decreased. Among all age groups, the occurrence of multimorbidity was highest (28.71%) in the 80 to 85 aged group. Table 2 reveals statistically significant differences in both mean EQ-5D utility values and VAS scores between different numbers of noncommunicable diseases (NCDs) categories (P < 0.001) by the three age groups. As age increased, both the mean EQ-5D utility values and VAS scores decreased, and the trend to higher numbers of NCDs categories saw lower EQ-5D utility values and VAS scores. The difference between EQ-5D utility values of multimorbid patients (0.84 ± 0.19) and the mean utility value of total persons (0.92 ± 0.10) in the middle age group was the largest in all age groups, and the VAS scores were also like this in Table 2 . Table 3 shows the results of the logistic regression models to separately identify the association of lifestyle factors with multimorbidity for each age group after controlling for residence, sex, marital status, education, and income level variables. The middle-aged (OR 2.62, 95%CI 1.77 to 3.87) and young-old (OR 1.49, 95%CI 1.17 to 1.89) respondents who were ex-smokers had a higher likelihood of multimorbidity than nonsmokers. People who drank alcohol within the last 30 days in the middleaged (OR 0.57, 95%CI 0.44 to 0.73), young-old (OR 0.57 95%CI 0.47 to 0.68), and old-old (OR 0.52, 95%CI 0.36 to 0.75) groups had a negative association with multimorbidity compared to nondrinkers. When BMI exceeded the recommended healthy standard, participants were prone to multimorbidity (P < 0.01), and being underweight protected old-old respondents from multimorbidity (OR 0.61, Table 2 reveals statistically significant differences in both mean EQ-5D utility values and VAS scores between different numbers of noncommunicable diseases (NCDs) categories (P < 0.001) by the three age groups. As age increased, both the mean EQ-5D utility values and VAS scores decreased, and the trend to higher numbers of NCDs categories saw lower EQ-5D utility values and VAS scores. The difference between EQ-5D utility values of multimorbid patients (0.84 ± 0.19) and the mean utility value of total persons (0.92 ± 0.10) in the middle age group was the largest in all age groups, and the VAS scores were also like this in Table 2 . Table 3 shows the results of the logistic regression models to separately identify the association of lifestyle factors with multimorbidity for each age group after controlling for residence, sex, marital status, education, and income level variables. The middle-aged (OR 2.62, 95%CI 1.77 to 3.87) and young-old (OR 1.49, 95%CI 1.17 to 1.89) respondents who were ex-smokers had a higher likelihood of multimorbidity than nonsmokers. People who drank alcohol within the last 30 days in the middle-aged (OR 0.57, 95%CI 0.44 to 0.73), young-old (OR 0.57 95%CI 0.47 to 0.68), and old-old (OR 0.52, 95%CI 0.36 to 0.75) groups had a negative association with multimorbidity compared to nondrinkers. When BMI exceeded the recommended healthy standard, participants were prone to multimorbidity (P < 0.01), and being underweight protected old-old respondents from multimorbidity (OR 0.61, 95%CI 0.41 to 0.93). Tooth-brushing had a negative association with the prevalence of multimorbidity among the middle-aged group (OR 0.67, 95%CI 0.52 to 0.88) and young-old group (OR 0.79, 95%CI 0.68 to 0.91). A physical check-up in the past year had a positive impact on the occurrence of multimorbidity among middle-aged (OR 1.64, 95%CI 1.38 to 1.96) and the young-old (OR 1.64, 95%CI 1.43 to 1.89) participants. Table 3 . The association of lifestyle factors with multimorbidity by age groups (odds ratio (OR), 95% confidence interval (CI)).

Young-Old Old-Old * P < 0.05, *** P < 0.01. Table 4 presents the logistic regression model coefficient for the association between outpatient visits, inpatient hospital visits, taking self-medicine, and multimorbidity across the three age groups. There were significant differences in outpatient and inpatient visits and taking self-medicine between multimorbid and nonmultimorbid participants, with multimorbidity increasing the likelihood of service utilization compared with people without multimorbidities (P < 0.001). Table 4 also shows that multimorbid younger participants had a higher probability of health service utilization than multimorbid older respondents. The odds ratio of taking self-medicine was higher than that of outpatient visits and inpatient visits. With regard to middle-aged participants, the odds ratio of taking self-medicine was 9.78, which was more than 2.8 times higher than the odds ratio of outpatient visits and 2.09 times higher than the odds ratio of inpatient visits. Income level was also negatively correlated with the utilization of health services in general, and the higher income group had less healthcare utilization. 

To our knowledge, this is the first study to examine multimorbidity, HRQOL, health-related behaviors, and health service use across three age groups: Middle-aged adults (45 to 59 years), young-old adults (60 to 74 years), old-old adults (75 and above years) in China. We found that the overall prevalence of multimorbidity was 13.80% for all participants, 6.89% for middle-aged participants, and 20.60% for old-aged participants aged 60 years and above. Multimorbidity among Shandong older-aged persons (20.60%) was higher than rural older-aged people in Yunnan province in 2017 (16.10%) [2] , but relatively low compared to another Shandong study in 2017 (35.20%) [20] and a China-wide study (from 6.4 to 76.5%) [1] . These variations in prevalence of older-aged multimorbidity was due to different data sources, sample sizes, differences in type of chronic conditions, different age compositions, and varied definitions of multimorbidity. We found that the likelihood of multimorbidity increased with age, which is consistent with studies from Finland, Poland, Spain, China, Ghana, India, Mexico, and Russia [26] . However, multimorbid prevalence culminated in the 80 to 84 years old group and then fell in our study. Those over 85 years old may be underrepresented in our sample and those without multimorbidity were relatively healthy and lived longer.

The highest mean value of EQ-5D utility and VAS was achieved by middle-aged participants without chronic diseases. HRQOL declined with increasing multimorbidity and age, which is consistent with other studies [27] [28] [29] [30] . However, multimorbidity in middle-aged respondents saw their HRQOL fall relative to the older-aged group. While the older-aged were the most vulnerable to multimorbidity, especially the old-old group and those 80-84 years old, multimorbidity impacted middle-aged participants' HRQOL more significantly than the older-aged group. This suggests the need to pay more attention not only to the physical, but also the psychological, health of multimorbid middle-aged persons, including actively providing psychological counseling and rehabilitation.

After controlling for basic socio-economic factors, our study found that various lifestyle factors were associated with the prevalence of multimorbidity. Ex-smoker status, obesity, and overweight were positively associated with the probability of multimorbidity, which aligns with previous reports [15, 20, [31] [32] [33] . Physical check-ups were more likely to unearth multimorbidity in middle-aged and young-old participants, which suggests that younger people should take regular physical examinations. As demonstrated in numerous studies [16] [17] [18] , exercise was a protective factor to avoid multimorbidity, but the effect was only significant for those over aged 75 in our study. A new finding is that daily teeth brushing could effectively attenuate multimorbidity for middle aged and young-old participants. As periodontal diseases have been proved to be risk factors for cardiovascular diseases, diabetes, rheumatoid arthritis, cancer, and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease [34] , it is necessary to develop correct oral cleaning habits from childhood. Drinking within the last 30 days had a negative association with the occurrence of multimorbidity, which contrasts with other studies that reported both current drinking and ex-drinking status were important multimorbid risk factors [15] . Future studies should collect more detailed information about drinking status, such as frequency and amount. Shandong has a unique drinking custom that was different from other Chinese provinces [35] , so future studies should collect data on drinking habits in other provinces.

Multimorbidity was positively associated with health service utilization including outpatient and inpatient hospital visits, and taking self-medicine. This aligns with the previous studies conducted in China and high-income countries, which showed that multimorbidity was positively associated with substantially increased use of health care [36] [37] [38] [39] . We also found that health service utilization decreased with the age of participants with multimorbidity, due to older respondents having more limited access to health care, including outpatient and inpatient hospital visits and a greater reliance on self-medicine, compared to younger respondents. In China, older-aged persons tended to have more limited economic capacity and lived away from health facilities. We recommend that the government provide better health service access for the older population, especially older people with a chronic disease or multimorbidity; improve access to health services generally; and provide high-quality health care in order to serve vulnerable people.

There were two major limitations to our study. First, our cross-sectional design meant that causality could not be inferred. Second, the prevalence of chronic disease could be under-reported because we relied on self-reported disease status by subjects who may not be fully aware of their health status. Despite these limitations, our data provided evidence on HRQOL and health service utilization from a comprehensive survey on multimorbidity among the middle-aged and older-aged population in the second-most populated province in China.

The prevalence and decline in HRQOL of multimorbid middle-aged and older-aged people were severe in Shandong province. Although older-aged people were more susceptible to multimorbidity, multimorbidity caused middle-aged respondents to experience a lower HRQOL. The association between lifestyle factors and multimorbidity was different among the middle-aged, young-old, and old-old participants. We recommend early prevention and intervention to address the prevalence of middle-aged and older-aged multimorbidity, which requires government to improve the diagnostics of chronic diseases, management of multimorbidity, prevention of chronic disease, and health literacy from a young age. Older-aged participants also had limited access to health services. Government should pay close attention to older-aged patients' access to health services, set-up special treatment channels for sufferers from multiple chronic diseases, improve medical insurance policies for older-aged groups, and set-up multiple chronic disease insurances to effectively alleviate the costs of medical utilization caused by economic pressure for outpatients and inpatients with chronic diseases. 

Status of prevalence study on multimorbidity of chronic disease in China: Systematic review

Association of socioeconomic and lifestyle factors with chronic non-communicable diseases and multimorbidity among the elderly in rural southwest

Physical multimorbidity, health service use, and catastrophic health expenditure by socioeconomic groups in China: An analysis of population-based panel data

Associations between taste preferences and chronic diseases: A population-based exploratory study in China. Public Health Nutr

Epidemiology of multimorbidity and implications for health care, research, and medical education: A cross-sectional study

Multimorbidity prevalence and patterns across socioeconomic determinants: A cross-sectional survey

Multimorbidity and mortality in older adults: A systematic review and meta-analysis

The association between multimorbidity and health-related quality of life: A cross-sectional survey among community middle-aged and elderly residents in southern China

Comparing the self-perceived quality of life of multimorbid patients and the general population using the EQ-5D-3L

Aging with multimorbidity: A systematic review of the literature

correlates and implications of non-communicable disease multimorbidity among older adults in selected Indian states: A cross-sectional study

Prevalence, Correlates, and Outcomes of Multimorbidity Among Patients Attending Primary Care in Odisha

Chronic diseases among the elderly in a rural Vietnam: Prevalence, associated socio-demographic factors and healthcare expenditures

Multimorbidity prevalence and pattern in Indonesian adults: An exploratory study using national survey data

Multimorbidity and health seeking behaviours among older people in Myanmar: A community survey

The contribution of risk factors to socioeconomic inequalities in multimorbidity across the lifecourse: A longitudinal analysis of the Twenty-07 cohort

Prevalence and distribution of risk factors for non-communicable chronic diseases among adults from Lages city, south of Brazil

Association between socioeconomic status and prevalence of non-communicable diseases risk factors and comorbidities in Bangladesh: Findings from a nationwide cross-sectional survey

Era of geriatric medical challenges: Multimorbidity among older patients

Association between obesity-related anthropometric indices and multimorbidity among older adults in Shandong, China: A cross-sectional study

Multimorbidity among middle-aged and older persons in urban China: Prevalence, characteristics and health service utilization

Global, regional, and national incidence, prevalence, and years lived with disability for 301 acute and chronic diseases and injuries in 188 countries, 1990-2013: A systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study

Treatment of coronavirus disease 2019 in Shandong, China: A cost and affordability analysis

Gender differences in the association between body mass index and health-related quality of life among adults:a cross-sectional study in Shandong, China

Chinese Time Trade-Off Values for EQ-5D Health States. Value Health

Global Multimorbidity Patterns: A Cross-Sectional, Population-Based, Multi-Country Study

General Population Reference Values for the French Version of the EuroQol EQ-5D Health Utility Instrument. Value Health

How do common chronic conditions affect health-related quality of life?

Patterns of multimorbidity and their association with health outcomes within Yorkshire, England: Baseline results from the Yorkshire Health Study

Health-related quality of life in residents aged 18 years and older with and without disease: Findings from the First Provincial Health Services Survey of Hunan, China

Multimorbidity prevalence in the general population: The role of obesity in chronic disease clustering

Association between body mass index and prevalence of multimorbidity: A cross-sectional study

Association Between Body Mass index and Prevalence of Multimorbidity in Low-and Middle-income Countries: A Cross-Sectional Study

Periodontal Pathogens as Risk Factors of Cardiovascular Diseases, Diabetes, Rheumatoid Arthritis, Cancer, and Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease-Is There Cause for Consideration? Microorganisms

Cross-sectional survey on drinking among residents aged 18 and older in Shandong Province during 2013

Epidemiology of multimorbidity in China and implications for the healthcare system: Cross-sectional survey among 162,464 community household residents in southern China

Impact of Noncommunicable Disease Multimorbidity on Healthcare Utilisation and Out-Of-Pocket Expenditures in Middle-Income Countries: Cross Sectional Analysis

Associations between multimorbidity, healthcare utilisation and health status: Evidence from 16 European countries

Association between non-communicable disease multimorbidity and health care utilization in a middle-income country: Population-based study

The authors would like to thank all the participants for their cooperation. This study was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (grant numbers 72004117 and 71703081); Shandong University Center for Health Economics Experiment and Public Policy Research; and the NHC Key Laboratory of Health Economics and Policy Research (Shandong University). L.X. was supported by the Australian Government Research Training Program Scholarship. The authors thank three reviewers for their supportive comments.

The authors declare no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.Ethics Approval and Consent to Participate: The project was approved by the Public Health Ethics Committee at Shandong University School of Public Health (Grant No. 20190406). Written informed consent was obtained from all participants prior to research.