key: cord-0010036-7qyvnm2o authors: DERRICK, E. H. title: CHILDHOOD ASTHMA IN BRISBANE: EPIDEMIOLOGICAL OBSERVATIONS date: 2008-03-10 journal: J Paediatr Child Health DOI: 10.1111/j.1440-1754.1973.tb01867.x sha: d4fbd3cc78a697bf824d3117289cd03e5e58f9e3 doc_id: 10036 cord_uid: 7qyvnm2o Analysis of hospital admissions for 20 years suggests that there has been an increase in childhood asthma in Brisbane. The characteristic seasonal pattern of asthma with waves in autumn and spring is evident from the second year of age and continues into adult life. It has not been explained, although respiratory infections, allergens and cold changes probably contribute to it. Unlike adults, children shown an increase in asthma in February‐March, ascribed to infections spread at school. Maximal asthma is associated with a mean temperature of 20–21°C. This may be optimal for the production of allergens. Further viral studies of asthmatic attacks are desirable. The aim of this paper is to study epidemiological features of asthma based on admissions to the Royal Children's Hospital, Brisbane, and from them to endeavour to draw conclusions about the etiology. The conclusions may be compared with those of a similar study of asthma at ages 12 years and over (Derrick, 1972) . In the 20 years July 1949 to June 1969, there were 3,645 admissions to the Royal Children's Hospital, Brisbane, for asthma and asthmatic bronchitis (Table I) . These comprised 2.37% of the total admissions for the period. Cases in which the diagnosis indicated inflammation in the bronchi or lungs as well as asthma, were included with asthmatic bronchitis. Asthma and Asthmatic Bronchitis. In infancy the distinction between asthma and bronchitis or bronchiolitis may be difficult. At this age infection and wheezing are frequently associated. It is common for the earliest episodes in a patient to be designated asthmatic bronchitis, and after repeated recurrences the diagnosis of asthma becomes definite. This sequence is exemplified in the present series by Leanne, who was admitted 15 times between the ages of 2 and 5 years. At the first 7 admissions and 2 of the next 4, the diagnosis was asthmatic bronchitis; with the other 6 it was asthma. Over the whole period the proportion of "asthmatic bronchitis" to "asthma" admissions was 1:2. In individual years it varied considerably. Age. Admissions for "asthmatic bronchitis" were most numirous in infancy (Figure 1) and at this age exceeded those for "asthma"'. With increasing age they steadily declined. "Asthma" admissions, relatively few in infancy, showed one peak at 4 years of age and another at 8-10 years. When the 2 conditions were added, the greatist number of admissions was at 3-4 years. The second peak, both in the "asthma" and combined curves, was due to multiple admissions of a number of severe cases, and the peak disappears when each individual is counted not more than once in any year. It is likely that the lower curve in Figure 1C approximates more closely than the upper to the age distribution of the disease. Multiple admissions of particular patients, more frequent since 1965, did not necessarily indicate a series of relapses of their asthma. Some chronic sufferers were from time to time discharged to their homes for week-ends and then readmitted. This potential distortion of 19% 1955 Figure 2 . Annual a d d d o n s for asthma (includhg asthmatic broochitis) accodng to age-groups, to quarterly totals (ages 1-11 years) and to the perrentage of dl admissions to the hospital (ages 0-11 years). In these graphs no patient has been counted more than Once in any quarter. the index of prevalence has been reduced by not counting any patient more than once in annual, quarterly, monthly or weekly totals. Sex. Male admissions exceeded female at each age, but the difference became quite small at ages 10 and 11 years ( Figure 1 ). Similar sex ratios applied to both "asthmatic bronchitis" and "asthma", except that in infancy the male proportion of "asthmatic bronchitis" was above the average. Onset. An analysis of 50 cases showed that 41 were admitted within 2 days of the onset of wheezing. The median interval between onset and admission was one day. 18 had a cough or cold for one or more days before wheezing started. The annual admissions for asthma (including asthmatic bronchitis) varied considerably-from 101 to 279, and the curve is undulating (Figure 2 ). In general, admissions increased until 1958-59, decreased until 1961-62, and then increased again. On the whole there was a highly significant increase over the 20 years of the study, both in the number of admissions and in their proportion of total admissions to the hospital. As is apparent in Figure 2 and Table 11 , the increase involved mainly older children. The increase in the 6-1 1 years group was highly significant (P < 0.001); the slight increase in the 1-5 years group was not significant ( P > 0.1). Both sexes and all seasons participated in the increase. The annual admissions to the hospital for all disorders varied from 7,730 in 1949-50 to 8,856 in 1955-56 . The significant increase in the proportion of these admissions which were for asthma shows that the increase cannot be ascribed to differing availability of beds in different years. The overall increase in admissions of the older children since 1949 may therefore be accepted as definite. It suggests strongly that there has been an increase, in Brisbane, in the number of severe cases of asthma in this age-group. Cases which are admitted are, of course, drawn from those with the more severe grades of asthma in the community. , percentage of all admissions 0.74*** 'The measure of time used for determining the coefficients of correlation with the admissions for the corresponding year was 1 for 1949-50, 2 for 1950-51 and so on. No child was counted more than once in any quarter. **P < 0.01 ***P < 0.001 The annual variation in Brisbane may be compared with that in two overseas reports. In the Los Angeles Children's Hospital Richards et al. (1967) concluded that there had not been a statistically significant increase in the proportion of total admissions due to asthma over the 35 years 1937 to 1964. It varied from 0.66 to 2.21% with an average of 1.13%. Although it had been high in the last 4 years of the study, it had also been high from 1940 to 1943. In a survey of school children in Birmingham, England, Smith et al. (1971) found that the prevalence of definitely diagnosed asthma increased from 1.8% in 1956-57 to 2.3% in 1968-69. Many factors probably contributed to the annual variation. The significant increase in admissions over the 20 years suggesting an increase in severity has been mentioned above. Otherwise little evidence of the factors has emerged. One to be considered is the advance in therapy in recent years. This would be expected to reduce the number of admissions. Corticosteroids have been used increasingly since about 1952 and aerosol bronchodilators since 1958, with a considerable increase since 1963. However, it is difficult to relate these to the undulations in Figure 2 . Sodium cromoglycate, introduced in 1967, did not come into general use in Queensland It is noted below that infection, like asthmatic bronchitis, is more frequent in younger children. The increase in the number of admissions from 1954-55 to 1958-59 was more evident in younger children (Figure 2 ) and included a higher proportion of "asthmatic bronchitis". This suggests that infection made a greater contribution than usual in those years. It seems likely, from the studies of seasonal variation described below, that some of the annual variations depicted in Figure 2 were related to the weather, but no significant correlation of them with weather elements could be demonstrated: in time to influence-the graphs. years. Of URTI cases 76% were 0-5 years, of bronchitis 77%. Also admissions for asthma to Royal Brisbane Hospital, ages 12 years and over. In Figures 5 and 6 the curves have been smoothed by plottting a running total of three weeks. February 29 and August 31 have been omitted so that snccessive seven-day periods fall on the same dates each year. The curves were similar for males and females and also for those diagnosed as "asthma" and as "asthmatic bronchitis". The latter similarity and the sequence of the diagnoses in such cases as Leanne noted above, is in accord with the conclusion of Williams and McNicol (1969) that cases of "asthma" and "wheezy bronchitis" belong to a single population with the same defect. The two diagnostic groups, as well as the two sexes, have therefore been combined for further analyses. Spring and autumn waves were present in each year of age except the first (Figure 4) . Those under one year showed only one wave, which was in winter and peaked in June; this type of curve reflects the close association noted above between asthma and respiratory infection in the first year. The high admissions in March for children 2 and 3 years old are noteworthy. There was considerable variation from year to year in the seasonal pattern. Asthma was very prevalent in December, 1958 ( Figure 5 ) . This month had the highest number of admissions for any month in the 20 years, even surpassing any autumn month. 1960-61 ( Figure 6 ) was notable for a series of minor attendances for asthma at the Casualty Department at the Royal Brisbane Hospital (RBH) (Derrick, 1972) . A comparable study of C 0 childhood asthma has been made over the same 10 years, 1959-1968. Figure 7 shows that the seasonal distribution of admissions at ages 1-5 and 6-1 1 yearsthat is, of pre-school and school childrenwas similar throughout the average year except for occasional weeks. There was also a general similarity to the R B H attendances, except much more asthma in the children. Figure 7 shows also the two-fold relation of asthma to temperature. Asthma is minimal both when the temperature is high in summer and low in winter, and maximal when it is was therefore divided, according to prevailing temperature, into 2 equal sections for correlation studies. The age-groups 1-5 years and 6-1 1 years were dealt with separately. Certain relationships to the weather have been reported in the seasonal variation of night Other weather elements analysed are included in Tables 111 and IV. The dew point, a measure of absolute humidity, shows little diurnal variation. Its curve is almost parallel to that of the temperature. The relative humidity at 3 p.m. is close to the daily minimum. The rainfall varied consideraly, and in the average year it was greater than the weekly mean of 2.2 cpl in most weeks from November to March, and less than the mean in most. weeks from April to October. The weekly totals were adapted for calculation as in Derrick (1972) . Soil moisture was estimated as in Derrick ( 1966) . 'These columns show the lag at which Y was highest and, in brackets, the range for which P < 0.001 ( r at least 0.61). ?P < 0.01. 2. Warm humid weather may be a factor in promoting asthma after a short lag. There were highly significant correlations ( P < 0.001 ) bEtween the weekly prevalence of asthma in the children and the temperature, dew point and relative humidity a few weeks earlier (Table 111 ). There were also highly significant correlations with rainfall and soil moisture some months earlier; their relevance is more remote. As there was very little difference in the weather relations of the 2 children's age-groups, they were combined in the table. 3. Factors unrelated to weather may contribute more to asthma in childhood than in adults. The weather correlations with the children showed in general a similar pattern to those for the adults, but with somewhat lower coefficients. With temperature and dew point, the coefficients were significantly lower. 4. Asthma is maximal a few weeks after the mean temperature is about 20-21°C and decreases as the temperature varies either up or down. In the children the highest prevalence of asthma in autumn was in the 7 weeks, April 2 3 to June 10. For this period the average temperature was 18.3"C. In spring the highest prevalence was in the 8 weeks, September 25 to November 19, when the average temperature was 21.3"C. As the temperature is falling in autumn and rising in spring, the mean temperature would have been 20°C about 2.5 weeks before the midpoint of each period. With the RBH attendances, the weeks of highest prevalence were not quite the same as with the children, and a similar calculation gave 21°C as the mean temperature 2.5 weeks before the midpoints. As noted above, the highest correlation of asthma with temperature was with a lag of some weeks. The dew point that corresponds to maximal esthma is about 12.5-13.5"C. Asihma in the 26 Warmer Weeks. This period (October 2 3 to April 22) includes February and March when, as shown in Figure 7 , there was much more asthma in children than in adults. The main conclusions were: 1. The seasonal pattern was similar in the 2 children's age-groups; for the weekly admissions, r = 0.45 ( P < 0.05). The 2 agegroups were combined for further studies; separately they gave closely similar results. with the children's admissions was greater, but not significantly so, when the 8 weeks, February 5 to April 1, were omitted (r = 0.77, P < 0.001) than over the whole 26 weeks (r = 0.43, P < 0.05). In the warmer and wetter half of the year, both child and adult asthma decreased significantly, with no lag, as warmth and wetness increased (Table IV) . The higher prevalence of asthma in children than in adults in February and March was not apparently related to the weather. Over the 26 weeks, the correlations with temperature, dew point, relative humidity and rainfall were lower with children than with adults; with the first 2 the differences were significant. When the 8 weeks were omitted the differences mostly disappeared. The two-fold relation of asthma to temperature, based on the correlations in the cooler and warmer weeks, is illustrated in Figure 8 . The Significance of 23°C. The ending of the spring wave and the beginning of the autumn wave occurred at times when the mean temperature was approximately 23°C. This relationship is shown in Figures 7, 9 and 10 . In the autumn it is partly obscured by the February-March asthma in the children, but is clearly defined in the RBH attendances. Some of the asthma increases in the warmer months corresponded with a temporary fall in the mean temperature below 23°C; an example is the increase in mid-March 1961 shown in Figure 6 . Other increases did not correspond Figure 9 . Weekly asthma admissions in relation to mean temperature and rainfall, 1956-57. It is noteworthy that a. The spring wave appears unrelated to rainfall: there was no substantial rain for months before it, during or immediately after it. b. Its abrupt ending early in November coincided with a sham and sustxined rise in mean temperature above 23°C. c. In this respect the "school-opening" wave of asthma in February-March was different; this occurred while the temperature remained above 23°C. d. In eeneral the autumn wave occurred after the temperature fell below 23°C. e. The high asthma in May coincided with a sharp fall in temperature. Figure 9 ) the temperature did not rise above 23" until near the end of December; the spring asthma wave was correspondingly prolonged. b. Also in contrast with 1956, the spring wave occurred during a period of ample rain. c. In 1964 there was little "school-opening" asthma and the autumn wave began in March at about the time when the temperature fell below 23". d. From late December until February when grass pollens in the air were maximal, asthma was minimal (Pollen counts by courtesy of Miss Janice Moss). -those in December 1958 ( Figure 5 ) and in February 1961 February , 1965 February and 1968 (Figure 6 ) . It is conceivable that sensitivity to a temperature above about 23°C limits the production of some important allergen; this could be a clue to its recognition. The 23°C level does not sharply divide two distinctive temperature regions. They merge gradually. On a day when the mean temperature is 23"C, the temperature would be lower than this for 12 hours and higher for 12. Even in an average midsummer day the temperature would be below 23" for eight hours. One would therefore expect the influence, if any, of a rising temperature on the prevalence of asthma to be manifest gradually. As a rule the ending of the spring wave is gradual. Only . in' the occasional year, when the temperature rises sharply and the high le