id sid tid token lemma pos w9504x5421k 1 1 this this DET w9504x5421k 1 2 dissertation dissertation NOUN w9504x5421k 1 3 explores explore VERB w9504x5421k 1 4 the the DET w9504x5421k 1 5 sources source NOUN w9504x5421k 1 6 that that SCONJ w9504x5421k 1 7 the the DET w9504x5421k 1 8 author author NOUN w9504x5421k 1 9 of of ADP w9504x5421k 1 10 the the DET w9504x5421k 1 11 apocalypse apocalypse NOUN w9504x5421k 1 12 used use VERB w9504x5421k 1 13 to to PART w9504x5421k 1 14 create create VERB w9504x5421k 1 15 his his PRON w9504x5421k 1 16 description description NOUN w9504x5421k 1 17 of of ADP w9504x5421k 1 18 the the DET w9504x5421k 1 19 heavenly heavenly ADJ w9504x5421k 1 20 liturgy liturgy NOUN w9504x5421k 1 21 . . PUNCT w9504x5421k 2 1 many many ADJ w9504x5421k 2 2 previous previous ADJ w9504x5421k 2 3 treatments treatment NOUN w9504x5421k 2 4 of of ADP w9504x5421k 2 5 this this DET w9504x5421k 2 6 subject subject NOUN w9504x5421k 2 7 have have AUX w9504x5421k 2 8 overstated overstate VERB w9504x5421k 2 9 the the DET w9504x5421k 2 10 conclusions conclusion NOUN w9504x5421k 2 11 that that PRON w9504x5421k 2 12 can can AUX w9504x5421k 2 13 be be AUX w9504x5421k 2 14 drawn draw VERB w9504x5421k 2 15 from from ADP w9504x5421k 2 16 our our PRON w9504x5421k 2 17 evidence evidence NOUN w9504x5421k 2 18 for for ADP w9504x5421k 2 19 christian christian ADJ w9504x5421k 2 20 liturgical liturgical ADJ w9504x5421k 2 21 practice practice NOUN w9504x5421k 2 22 in in ADP w9504x5421k 2 23 the the DET w9504x5421k 2 24 late late ADJ w9504x5421k 2 25 - - PUNCT w9504x5421k 2 26 first first ADJ w9504x5421k 2 27 century century NOUN w9504x5421k 2 28 ce ce PROPN w9504x5421k 2 29 . . PUNCT w9504x5421k 3 1 in in ADP w9504x5421k 3 2 order order NOUN w9504x5421k 3 3 to to PART w9504x5421k 3 4 determine determine VERB w9504x5421k 3 5 which which PRON w9504x5421k 3 6 of of ADP w9504x5421k 3 7 the the DET w9504x5421k 3 8 elements element NOUN w9504x5421k 3 9 found find VERB w9504x5421k 3 10 in in ADP w9504x5421k 3 11 rev rev ADJ w9504x5421k 3 12 4 4 NUM w9504x5421k 3 13 - - SYM w9504x5421k 3 14 5 5 NUM w9504x5421k 3 15 might might AUX w9504x5421k 3 16 have have AUX w9504x5421k 3 17 been be AUX w9504x5421k 3 18 taken take VERB w9504x5421k 3 19 from from ADP w9504x5421k 3 20 an an DET w9504x5421k 3 21 early early ADJ w9504x5421k 3 22 christian christian ADJ w9504x5421k 3 23 service service NOUN w9504x5421k 3 24 of of ADP w9504x5421k 3 25 worship worship NOUN w9504x5421k 3 26 , , PUNCT w9504x5421k 3 27 the the DET w9504x5421k 3 28 available available ADJ w9504x5421k 3 29 liturgical liturgical ADJ w9504x5421k 3 30 evidence evidence NOUN w9504x5421k 3 31 is be AUX w9504x5421k 3 32 examined examine VERB w9504x5421k 3 33 to to PART w9504x5421k 3 34 ascertain ascertain VERB w9504x5421k 3 35 what what PRON w9504x5421k 3 36 we we PRON w9504x5421k 3 37 can can AUX w9504x5421k 3 38 say say VERB w9504x5421k 3 39 that that SCONJ w9504x5421k 3 40 we we PRON w9504x5421k 3 41 know know VERB w9504x5421k 3 42 about about ADP w9504x5421k 3 43 christian christian ADJ w9504x5421k 3 44 worship worship NOUN w9504x5421k 3 45 at at ADP w9504x5421k 3 46 the the DET w9504x5421k 3 47 end end NOUN w9504x5421k 3 48 of of ADP w9504x5421k 3 49 the the DET w9504x5421k 3 50 first first ADJ w9504x5421k 3 51 century century NOUN w9504x5421k 3 52 ce ce PROPN w9504x5421k 3 53 , , PUNCT w9504x5421k 3 54 and and CCONJ w9504x5421k 3 55 to to PART w9504x5421k 3 56 correct correct VERB w9504x5421k 3 57 some some DET w9504x5421k 3 58 mistaken mistaken ADJ w9504x5421k 3 59 conclusions conclusion NOUN w9504x5421k 3 60 that that PRON w9504x5421k 3 61 have have AUX w9504x5421k 3 62 appeared appear VERB w9504x5421k 3 63 in in ADP w9504x5421k 3 64 earlier early ADJ w9504x5421k 3 65 scholarship scholarship NOUN w9504x5421k 3 66 . . PUNCT w9504x5421k 4 1 this this DET w9504x5421k 4 2 examination examination NOUN w9504x5421k 4 3 includes include VERB w9504x5421k 4 4 the the DET w9504x5421k 4 5 first first ADJ w9504x5421k 4 6 - - PUNCT w9504x5421k 4 7 century century NOUN w9504x5421k 4 8 evidence evidence NOUN w9504x5421k 4 9 for for ADP w9504x5421k 4 10 the the DET w9504x5421k 4 11 use use NOUN w9504x5421k 4 12 of of ADP w9504x5421k 4 13 the the DET w9504x5421k 4 14 sanctus sanctus NOUN w9504x5421k 4 15 , , PUNCT w9504x5421k 4 16 hymns hymn NOUN w9504x5421k 4 17 , , PUNCT w9504x5421k 4 18 doxologies doxology NOUN w9504x5421k 4 19 , , PUNCT w9504x5421k 4 20 the the DET w9504x5421k 4 21 use use NOUN w9504x5421k 4 22 of of ADP w9504x5421k 4 23 incense incense NOUN w9504x5421k 4 24 , , PUNCT w9504x5421k 4 25 the the DET w9504x5421k 4 26 amen amen NOUN w9504x5421k 4 27 , , PUNCT w9504x5421k 4 28 and and CCONJ w9504x5421k 4 29 the the DET w9504x5421k 4 30 alleluia alleluia NOUN w9504x5421k 4 31 . . PUNCT w9504x5421k 5 1 the the DET w9504x5421k 5 2 results result NOUN w9504x5421k 5 3 of of ADP w9504x5421k 5 4 this this DET w9504x5421k 5 5 survey survey NOUN w9504x5421k 5 6 are be AUX w9504x5421k 5 7 disappointing disappointing ADJ w9504x5421k 5 8 , , PUNCT w9504x5421k 5 9 as as SCONJ w9504x5421k 5 10 the the DET w9504x5421k 5 11 pieces piece NOUN w9504x5421k 5 12 that that PRON w9504x5421k 5 13 we we PRON w9504x5421k 5 14 need need VERB w9504x5421k 5 15 to to PART w9504x5421k 5 16 be be AUX w9504x5421k 5 17 able able ADJ w9504x5421k 5 18 to to PART w9504x5421k 5 19 reconstruct reconstruct VERB w9504x5421k 5 20 the the DET w9504x5421k 5 21 ways way NOUN w9504x5421k 5 22 in in ADP w9504x5421k 5 23 which which PRON w9504x5421k 5 24 christians christians PROPN w9504x5421k 5 25 worshipped worship VERB w9504x5421k 5 26 in in ADP w9504x5421k 5 27 the the DET w9504x5421k 5 28 first first ADJ w9504x5421k 5 29 century century NOUN w9504x5421k 5 30 are be AUX w9504x5421k 5 31 largely largely ADV w9504x5421k 5 32 lacking lacking ADJ w9504x5421k 5 33 , , PUNCT w9504x5421k 5 34 and and CCONJ w9504x5421k 5 35 many many ADJ w9504x5421k 5 36 of of ADP w9504x5421k 5 37 these these DET w9504x5421k 5 38 prayers prayer NOUN w9504x5421k 5 39 and and CCONJ w9504x5421k 5 40 practices practice NOUN w9504x5421k 5 41 remain remain VERB w9504x5421k 5 42 beyond beyond ADP w9504x5421k 5 43 our our PRON w9504x5421k 5 44 reach reach NOUN w9504x5421k 5 45 . . PUNCT w9504x5421k 6 1 turning turn VERB w9504x5421k 6 2 to to ADP w9504x5421k 6 3 the the DET w9504x5421k 6 4 texts text NOUN w9504x5421k 6 5 of of ADP w9504x5421k 6 6 rev rev ADJ w9504x5421k 6 7 4 4 NUM w9504x5421k 6 8 - - SYM w9504x5421k 6 9 5 5 NUM w9504x5421k 6 10 themselves themselves PRON w9504x5421k 6 11 , , PUNCT w9504x5421k 6 12 the the DET w9504x5421k 6 13 dissertation dissertation NOUN w9504x5421k 6 14 tries try VERB w9504x5421k 6 15 to to PART w9504x5421k 6 16 identify identify VERB w9504x5421k 6 17 the the DET w9504x5421k 6 18 sources source NOUN w9504x5421k 6 19 of of ADP w9504x5421k 6 20 the the DET w9504x5421k 6 21 author author NOUN w9504x5421k 6 22 's 's PART w9504x5421k 6 23 imagery imagery NOUN w9504x5421k 6 24 for for ADP w9504x5421k 6 25 his his PRON w9504x5421k 6 26 picture picture NOUN w9504x5421k 6 27 of of ADP w9504x5421k 6 28 what what PRON w9504x5421k 6 29 the the DET w9504x5421k 6 30 heavenly heavenly ADJ w9504x5421k 6 31 worship worship NOUN w9504x5421k 6 32 of of ADP w9504x5421k 6 33 god god PROPN w9504x5421k 6 34 looked look VERB w9504x5421k 6 35 like like ADP w9504x5421k 6 36 , , PUNCT w9504x5421k 6 37 focusing focus VERB w9504x5421k 6 38 on on ADP w9504x5421k 6 39 what what PRON w9504x5421k 6 40 may may AUX w9504x5421k 6 41 have have AUX w9504x5421k 6 42 been be AUX w9504x5421k 6 43 derived derive VERB w9504x5421k 6 44 from from ADP w9504x5421k 6 45 a a DET w9504x5421k 6 46 service service NOUN w9504x5421k 6 47 of of ADP w9504x5421k 6 48 christian christian ADJ w9504x5421k 6 49 worship worship NOUN w9504x5421k 6 50 . . PUNCT w9504x5421k 7 1 contemporary contemporary ADJ w9504x5421k 7 2 jewish jewish ADJ w9504x5421k 7 3 and and CCONJ w9504x5421k 7 4 christian christian ADJ w9504x5421k 7 5 liturgical liturgical ADJ w9504x5421k 7 6 practices practice NOUN w9504x5421k 7 7 were be AUX w9504x5421k 7 8 likely likely ADJ w9504x5421k 7 9 to to PART w9504x5421k 7 10 have have AUX w9504x5421k 7 11 been be AUX w9504x5421k 7 12 one one NUM w9504x5421k 7 13 source source NOUN w9504x5421k 7 14 of of ADP w9504x5421k 7 15 this this DET w9504x5421k 7 16 imagery imagery NOUN w9504x5421k 7 17 , , PUNCT w9504x5421k 7 18 along along ADP w9504x5421k 7 19 with with ADP w9504x5421k 7 20 the the DET w9504x5421k 7 21 ot ot NOUN w9504x5421k 7 22 and and CCONJ w9504x5421k 7 23 jewish jewish ADJ w9504x5421k 7 24 apocalyptic apocalyptic ADJ w9504x5421k 7 25 literature literature NOUN w9504x5421k 7 26 , , PUNCT w9504x5421k 7 27 elements element NOUN w9504x5421k 7 28 of of ADP w9504x5421k 7 29 ancient ancient ADJ w9504x5421k 7 30 near near ADP w9504x5421k 7 31 eastern eastern ADJ w9504x5421k 7 32 throne throne NOUN w9504x5421k 7 33 room room NOUN w9504x5421k 7 34 scenes scene NOUN w9504x5421k 7 35 , , PUNCT w9504x5421k 7 36 roman roman ADJ w9504x5421k 7 37 imperial imperial ADJ w9504x5421k 7 38 court court NOUN w9504x5421k 7 39 ceremonial ceremonial NOUN w9504x5421k 7 40 , , PUNCT w9504x5421k 7 41 and and CCONJ w9504x5421k 7 42 his his PRON w9504x5421k 7 43 own own ADJ w9504x5421k 7 44 imagination imagination NOUN w9504x5421k 7 45 . . PUNCT w9504x5421k 8 1 another another DET w9504x5421k 8 2 concern concern NOUN w9504x5421k 8 3 of of ADP w9504x5421k 8 4 the the DET w9504x5421k 8 5 dissertation dissertation NOUN w9504x5421k 8 6 asks ask VERB w9504x5421k 8 7 whether whether SCONJ w9504x5421k 8 8 the the DET w9504x5421k 8 9 apocalypse apocalypse NOUN w9504x5421k 8 10 was be AUX w9504x5421k 8 11 read read VERB w9504x5421k 8 12 at at ADP w9504x5421k 8 13 a a DET w9504x5421k 8 14 liturgy liturgy NOUN w9504x5421k 8 15 , , PUNCT w9504x5421k 8 16 focusing focus VERB w9504x5421k 8 17 on on ADP w9504x5421k 8 18 the the DET w9504x5421k 8 19 introductory introductory ADJ w9504x5421k 8 20 and and CCONJ w9504x5421k 8 21 concluding conclude VERB w9504x5421k 8 22 passages passage NOUN w9504x5421k 8 23 of of ADP w9504x5421k 8 24 the the DET w9504x5421k 8 25 text text NOUN w9504x5421k 8 26 ( ( PUNCT w9504x5421k 8 27 rev rev VERB w9504x5421k 8 28 1:4 1:4 NUM w9504x5421k 8 29 - - SYM w9504x5421k 8 30 8 8 NUM w9504x5421k 8 31 and and CCONJ w9504x5421k 8 32 22:6 22:6 NUM w9504x5421k 8 33 - - SYM w9504x5421k 8 34 21 21 NUM w9504x5421k 8 35 ) ) PUNCT w9504x5421k 8 36 , , PUNCT w9504x5421k 8 37 which which PRON w9504x5421k 8 38 some some PRON w9504x5421k 8 39 have have AUX w9504x5421k 8 40 argued argue VERB w9504x5421k 8 41 take take VERB w9504x5421k 8 42 the the DET w9504x5421k 8 43 form form NOUN w9504x5421k 8 44 of of ADP w9504x5421k 8 45 a a DET w9504x5421k 8 46 liturgical liturgical ADJ w9504x5421k 8 47 dialogue dialogue NOUN w9504x5421k 8 48 between between ADP w9504x5421k 8 49 the the DET w9504x5421k 8 50 lector lector NOUN w9504x5421k 8 51 and and CCONJ w9504x5421k 8 52 assembly assembly NOUN w9504x5421k 8 53 . . PUNCT w9504x5421k 9 1 this this DET w9504x5421k 9 2 theory theory NOUN w9504x5421k 9 3 helps help VERB w9504x5421k 9 4 to to PART w9504x5421k 9 5 explain explain VERB w9504x5421k 9 6 some some DET w9504x5421k 9 7 parts part NOUN w9504x5421k 9 8 of of ADP w9504x5421k 9 9 these these DET w9504x5421k 9 10 passages passage NOUN w9504x5421k 9 11 better well ADV w9504x5421k 9 12 then then ADV w9504x5421k 9 13 others other NOUN w9504x5421k 9 14 , , PUNCT w9504x5421k 9 15 but but CCONJ w9504x5421k 9 16 most most ADJ w9504x5421k 9 17 problematic problematic ADJ w9504x5421k 9 18 is be AUX w9504x5421k 9 19 the the DET w9504x5421k 9 20 fact fact NOUN w9504x5421k 9 21 that that SCONJ w9504x5421k 9 22 our our PRON w9504x5421k 9 23 evidence evidence NOUN w9504x5421k 9 24 for for ADP w9504x5421k 9 25 worship worship NOUN w9504x5421k 9 26 practices practice NOUN w9504x5421k 9 27 in in ADP w9504x5421k 9 28 the the DET w9504x5421k 9 29 first first ADJ w9504x5421k 9 30 centuries century NOUN w9504x5421k 9 31 remains remain VERB w9504x5421k 9 32 incomplete incomplete ADJ w9504x5421k 9 33 , , PUNCT w9504x5421k 9 34 and and CCONJ w9504x5421k 9 35 we we PRON w9504x5421k 9 36 can can AUX w9504x5421k 9 37 not not PART w9504x5421k 9 38 be be AUX w9504x5421k 9 39 sure sure ADJ w9504x5421k 9 40 that that SCONJ w9504x5421k 9 41 liturgical liturgical ADJ w9504x5421k 9 42 dialogues dialogue NOUN w9504x5421k 9 43 were be AUX w9504x5421k 9 44 a a DET w9504x5421k 9 45 part part NOUN w9504x5421k 9 46 of of ADP w9504x5421k 9 47 christian christian ADJ w9504x5421k 9 48 liturgy liturgy NOUN w9504x5421k 9 49 at at ADP w9504x5421k 9 50 this this DET w9504x5421k 9 51 early early ADJ w9504x5421k 9 52 date date NOUN w9504x5421k 9 53 . . PUNCT