id sid tid token lemma pos tt44pk04w59 1 1 while while SCONJ tt44pk04w59 1 2 the the DET tt44pk04w59 1 3 language language NOUN tt44pk04w59 1 4 of of ADP tt44pk04w59 1 5 natural natural ADJ tt44pk04w59 1 6 ( ( PUNCT tt44pk04w59 1 7 or or CCONJ tt44pk04w59 1 8 human human ADJ tt44pk04w59 1 9 ) ) PUNCT tt44pk04w59 1 10 rights right NOUN tt44pk04w59 1 11 continues continue VERB tt44pk04w59 1 12 to to PART tt44pk04w59 1 13 proliferate proliferate VERB tt44pk04w59 1 14 in in ADP tt44pk04w59 1 15 contemporary contemporary ADJ tt44pk04w59 1 16 discourse discourse NOUN tt44pk04w59 1 17 , , PUNCT tt44pk04w59 1 18 the the DET tt44pk04w59 1 19 intellectual intellectual ADJ tt44pk04w59 1 20 underpinnings underpinning NOUN tt44pk04w59 1 21 of of ADP tt44pk04w59 1 22 these these DET tt44pk04w59 1 23 rights right NOUN tt44pk04w59 1 24 has have VERB tt44pk04w59 1 25 yet yet ADV tt44pk04w59 1 26 to to PART tt44pk04w59 1 27 progress progress VERB tt44pk04w59 1 28 in in ADP tt44pk04w59 1 29 a a DET tt44pk04w59 1 30 widely widely ADV tt44pk04w59 1 31 accepted accept VERB tt44pk04w59 1 32 manner manner NOUN tt44pk04w59 1 33 from from ADP tt44pk04w59 1 34 the the DET tt44pk04w59 1 35 rawlsian rawlsian ADJ tt44pk04w59 1 36 arguments argument NOUN tt44pk04w59 1 37 that that PRON tt44pk04w59 1 38 precipitated precipitate VERB tt44pk04w59 1 39 the the DET tt44pk04w59 1 40 most most ADV tt44pk04w59 1 41 recent recent ADJ tt44pk04w59 1 42 state state NOUN tt44pk04w59 1 43 of of ADP tt44pk04w59 1 44 crisis crisis NOUN tt44pk04w59 1 45 in in ADP tt44pk04w59 1 46 liberal liberal ADJ tt44pk04w59 1 47 thought thought NOUN tt44pk04w59 1 48 . . PUNCT tt44pk04w59 2 1 from from ADP tt44pk04w59 2 2 the the DET tt44pk04w59 2 3 perspective perspective NOUN tt44pk04w59 2 4 of of ADP tt44pk04w59 2 5 contemporary contemporary ADJ tt44pk04w59 2 6 natural natural ADJ tt44pk04w59 2 7 law law NOUN tt44pk04w59 2 8 theory theory NOUN tt44pk04w59 2 9 , , PUNCT tt44pk04w59 2 10 rights right NOUN tt44pk04w59 2 11 are be AUX tt44pk04w59 2 12 indeed indeed ADV tt44pk04w59 2 13 grounded ground VERB tt44pk04w59 2 14 and and CCONJ tt44pk04w59 2 15 justified justify VERB tt44pk04w59 2 16 as as ADP tt44pk04w59 2 17 expressions expression NOUN tt44pk04w59 2 18 of of ADP tt44pk04w59 2 19 a a DET tt44pk04w59 2 20 subjective subjective ADJ tt44pk04w59 2 21 perspective perspective NOUN tt44pk04w59 2 22 regarding regard VERB tt44pk04w59 2 23 the the DET tt44pk04w59 2 24 requirements requirement NOUN tt44pk04w59 2 25 of of ADP tt44pk04w59 2 26 the the DET tt44pk04w59 2 27 natural natural ADJ tt44pk04w59 2 28 law law NOUN tt44pk04w59 2 29 or or CCONJ tt44pk04w59 2 30 the the DET tt44pk04w59 2 31 demands demand NOUN tt44pk04w59 2 32 of of ADP tt44pk04w59 2 33 justice justice NOUN tt44pk04w59 2 34 . . PUNCT tt44pk04w59 3 1 while while SCONJ tt44pk04w59 3 2 many many ADJ tt44pk04w59 3 3 rights right NOUN tt44pk04w59 3 4 may may AUX tt44pk04w59 3 5 derive derive VERB tt44pk04w59 3 6 their their PRON tt44pk04w59 3 7 justification justification NOUN tt44pk04w59 3 8 solely solely ADV tt44pk04w59 3 9 from from ADP tt44pk04w59 3 10 the the DET tt44pk04w59 3 11 requirements requirement NOUN tt44pk04w59 3 12 of of ADP tt44pk04w59 3 13 a a DET tt44pk04w59 3 14 prior prior ADJ tt44pk04w59 3 15 natural natural ADJ tt44pk04w59 3 16 morality morality NOUN tt44pk04w59 3 17 in in ADP tt44pk04w59 3 18 this this DET tt44pk04w59 3 19 way way NOUN tt44pk04w59 3 20 , , PUNCT tt44pk04w59 3 21 the the DET tt44pk04w59 3 22 partial partial ADJ tt44pk04w59 3 23 detachment detachment NOUN tt44pk04w59 3 24 of of ADP tt44pk04w59 3 25 subjective subjective ADJ tt44pk04w59 3 26 rights right NOUN tt44pk04w59 3 27 from from ADP tt44pk04w59 3 28 a a DET tt44pk04w59 3 29 prior prior ADJ tt44pk04w59 3 30 moral moral ADJ tt44pk04w59 3 31 structure structure NOUN tt44pk04w59 3 32 effected effect VERB tt44pk04w59 3 33 by by ADP tt44pk04w59 3 34 early early ADJ tt44pk04w59 3 35 liberal liberal ADJ tt44pk04w59 3 36 thinkers thinker NOUN tt44pk04w59 3 37 such such ADJ tt44pk04w59 3 38 as as SCONJ tt44pk04w59 3 39 john john PROPN tt44pk04w59 3 40 locke locke PROPN tt44pk04w59 3 41 contains contain VERB tt44pk04w59 3 42 an an DET tt44pk04w59 3 43 important important ADJ tt44pk04w59 3 44 element element NOUN tt44pk04w59 3 45 of of ADP tt44pk04w59 3 46 truth truth NOUN tt44pk04w59 3 47 . . PUNCT tt44pk04w59 4 1 natural natural ADJ tt44pk04w59 4 2 rights right NOUN tt44pk04w59 4 3 , , PUNCT tt44pk04w59 4 4 such such ADJ tt44pk04w59 4 5 as as ADP tt44pk04w59 4 6 the the DET tt44pk04w59 4 7 rights right NOUN tt44pk04w59 4 8 to to ADP tt44pk04w59 4 9 one one NOUN tt44pk04w59 4 10 's 's PART tt44pk04w59 4 11 life life NOUN tt44pk04w59 4 12 , , PUNCT tt44pk04w59 4 13 liberty liberty NOUN tt44pk04w59 4 14 , , PUNCT tt44pk04w59 4 15 and and CCONJ tt44pk04w59 4 16 external external ADJ tt44pk04w59 4 17 property property NOUN tt44pk04w59 4 18 , , PUNCT tt44pk04w59 4 19 are be AUX tt44pk04w59 4 20 primarily primarily ADV tt44pk04w59 4 21 justified justify VERB tt44pk04w59 4 22 by by ADP tt44pk04w59 4 23 human human ADJ tt44pk04w59 4 24 beings being NOUN tt44pk04w59 4 25 ' ' PART tt44pk04w59 4 26 self self NOUN tt44pk04w59 4 27 - - PUNCT tt44pk04w59 4 28 ownership ownership NOUN tt44pk04w59 4 29 through through ADP tt44pk04w59 4 30 self self NOUN tt44pk04w59 4 31 - - PUNCT tt44pk04w59 4 32 consciousness consciousness NOUN tt44pk04w59 4 33 . . PUNCT tt44pk04w59 5 1 this this DET tt44pk04w59 5 2 notion notion NOUN tt44pk04w59 5 3 is be AUX tt44pk04w59 5 4 expressed express VERB tt44pk04w59 5 5 , , PUNCT tt44pk04w59 5 6 in in ADP tt44pk04w59 5 7 an an DET tt44pk04w59 5 8 implicit implicit ADJ tt44pk04w59 5 9 and and CCONJ tt44pk04w59 5 10 undeveloped undeveloped ADJ tt44pk04w59 5 11 manner manner NOUN tt44pk04w59 5 12 , , PUNCT tt44pk04w59 5 13 by by ADP tt44pk04w59 5 14 locke locke NOUN tt44pk04w59 5 15 in in ADP tt44pk04w59 5 16 his his PRON tt44pk04w59 5 17 essay essay NOUN tt44pk04w59 5 18 concerning concern VERB tt44pk04w59 5 19 human human ADJ tt44pk04w59 5 20 understanding understanding NOUN tt44pk04w59 5 21 and and CCONJ tt44pk04w59 5 22 his his PRON tt44pk04w59 5 23 two two NUM tt44pk04w59 5 24 treatises treatise NOUN tt44pk04w59 5 25 of of ADP tt44pk04w59 5 26 government government NOUN tt44pk04w59 5 27 . . PUNCT tt44pk04w59 6 1 self self NOUN tt44pk04w59 6 2 - - PUNCT tt44pk04w59 6 3 ownership ownership NOUN tt44pk04w59 6 4 , , PUNCT tt44pk04w59 6 5 rightly rightly ADV tt44pk04w59 6 6 understood understand VERB tt44pk04w59 6 7 , , PUNCT tt44pk04w59 6 8 both both PRON tt44pk04w59 6 9 underpins underpin NOUN tt44pk04w59 6 10 and and CCONJ tt44pk04w59 6 11 justifies justify VERB tt44pk04w59 6 12 certain certain ADJ tt44pk04w59 6 13 natural natural ADJ tt44pk04w59 6 14 rights right NOUN tt44pk04w59 6 15 independently independently ADV tt44pk04w59 6 16 of of ADP tt44pk04w59 6 17 a a DET tt44pk04w59 6 18 prior prior ADJ tt44pk04w59 6 19 natural natural ADJ tt44pk04w59 6 20 morality morality NOUN tt44pk04w59 6 21 , , PUNCT tt44pk04w59 6 22 and and CCONJ tt44pk04w59 6 23 serves serve VERB tt44pk04w59 6 24 as as ADP tt44pk04w59 6 25 the the DET tt44pk04w59 6 26 basis basis NOUN tt44pk04w59 6 27 for for ADP tt44pk04w59 6 28 responsibility responsibility NOUN tt44pk04w59 6 29 within within ADP tt44pk04w59 6 30 a a DET tt44pk04w59 6 31 natural natural ADJ tt44pk04w59 6 32 moral moral ADJ tt44pk04w59 6 33 structure structure NOUN tt44pk04w59 6 34 . . PUNCT tt44pk04w59 7 1 indeed indeed ADV tt44pk04w59 7 2 , , PUNCT tt44pk04w59 7 3 a a DET tt44pk04w59 7 4 persuasive persuasive ADJ tt44pk04w59 7 5 theory theory NOUN tt44pk04w59 7 6 of of ADP tt44pk04w59 7 7 the the DET tt44pk04w59 7 8 natural natural ADJ tt44pk04w59 7 9 law law NOUN tt44pk04w59 7 10 is be AUX tt44pk04w59 7 11 implied imply VERB tt44pk04w59 7 12 by by ADP tt44pk04w59 7 13 a a DET tt44pk04w59 7 14 proper proper ADJ tt44pk04w59 7 15 understanding understanding NOUN tt44pk04w59 7 16 of of ADP tt44pk04w59 7 17 the the DET tt44pk04w59 7 18 same same ADJ tt44pk04w59 7 19 self self NOUN tt44pk04w59 7 20 - - PUNCT tt44pk04w59 7 21 ownership ownership NOUN tt44pk04w59 7 22 that that PRON tt44pk04w59 7 23 engenders engender VERB tt44pk04w59 7 24 natural natural ADJ tt44pk04w59 7 25 rights right NOUN tt44pk04w59 7 26 . . PUNCT tt44pk04w59 8 1 in in ADP tt44pk04w59 8 2 this this DET tt44pk04w59 8 3 way way NOUN tt44pk04w59 8 4 , , PUNCT tt44pk04w59 8 5 a a DET tt44pk04w59 8 6 properly properly ADV tt44pk04w59 8 7 articulated articulated ADJ tt44pk04w59 8 8 understanding understanding NOUN tt44pk04w59 8 9 of of ADP tt44pk04w59 8 10 self self NOUN tt44pk04w59 8 11 - - PUNCT tt44pk04w59 8 12 ownership ownership NOUN tt44pk04w59 8 13 simultaneously simultaneously ADV tt44pk04w59 8 14 justifies justify VERB tt44pk04w59 8 15 and and CCONJ tt44pk04w59 8 16 explains explain VERB tt44pk04w59 8 17 liberalism liberalism PROPN tt44pk04w59 8 18 's 's PART tt44pk04w59 8 19 rights right NOUN tt44pk04w59 8 20 - - PUNCT tt44pk04w59 8 21 based base VERB tt44pk04w59 8 22 orientation orientation NOUN tt44pk04w59 8 23 , , PUNCT tt44pk04w59 8 24 and and CCONJ tt44pk04w59 8 25 provides provide VERB tt44pk04w59 8 26 a a DET tt44pk04w59 8 27 persuasive persuasive ADJ tt44pk04w59 8 28 basis basis NOUN tt44pk04w59 8 29 for for ADP tt44pk04w59 8 30 supplementing supplement VERB tt44pk04w59 8 31 natural natural ADJ tt44pk04w59 8 32 rights right NOUN tt44pk04w59 8 33 - - PUNCT tt44pk04w59 8 34 based base VERB tt44pk04w59 8 35 morality morality NOUN tt44pk04w59 8 36 with with ADP tt44pk04w59 8 37 a a DET tt44pk04w59 8 38 natural natural ADJ tt44pk04w59 8 39 law law NOUN tt44pk04w59 8 40 morality morality NOUN tt44pk04w59 8 41 . . PUNCT tt44pk04w59 9 1 natural natural ADJ tt44pk04w59 9 2 justice justice NOUN tt44pk04w59 9 3 , , PUNCT tt44pk04w59 9 4 of of ADP tt44pk04w59 9 5 the the DET tt44pk04w59 9 6 sort sort NOUN tt44pk04w59 9 7 that that PRON tt44pk04w59 9 8 justifies justify VERB tt44pk04w59 9 9 and and CCONJ tt44pk04w59 9 10 limits limit VERB tt44pk04w59 9 11 the the DET tt44pk04w59 9 12 actions action NOUN tt44pk04w59 9 13 of of ADP tt44pk04w59 9 14 human human ADJ tt44pk04w59 9 15 governments government NOUN tt44pk04w59 9 16 and and CCONJ tt44pk04w59 9 17 guides guide VERB tt44pk04w59 9 18 the the DET tt44pk04w59 9 19 activity activity NOUN tt44pk04w59 9 20 of of ADP tt44pk04w59 9 21 individuals individual NOUN tt44pk04w59 9 22 , , PUNCT tt44pk04w59 9 23 finds find VERB tt44pk04w59 9 24 complementary complementary ADJ tt44pk04w59 9 25 bases basis NOUN tt44pk04w59 9 26 in in ADP tt44pk04w59 9 27 both both CCONJ tt44pk04w59 9 28 the the DET tt44pk04w59 9 29 individual individual ADJ tt44pk04w59 9 30 human human ADJ tt44pk04w59 9 31 being being NOUN tt44pk04w59 9 32 and and CCONJ tt44pk04w59 9 33 in in ADP tt44pk04w59 9 34 the the DET tt44pk04w59 9 35 common common ADJ tt44pk04w59 9 36 characteristics characteristic NOUN tt44pk04w59 9 37 of of ADP tt44pk04w59 9 38 humanity humanity NOUN tt44pk04w59 9 39 . . PUNCT tt44pk04w59 10 1 natural natural ADJ tt44pk04w59 10 2 rights right NOUN tt44pk04w59 10 3 and and CCONJ tt44pk04w59 10 4 natural natural ADJ tt44pk04w59 10 5 law law NOUN tt44pk04w59 10 6 , , PUNCT tt44pk04w59 10 7 or or CCONJ tt44pk04w59 10 8 modern modern ADJ tt44pk04w59 10 9 and and CCONJ tt44pk04w59 10 10 pre pre ADJ tt44pk04w59 10 11 - - ADJ tt44pk04w59 10 12 modern modern ADJ tt44pk04w59 10 13 orientations orientation NOUN tt44pk04w59 10 14 in in ADP tt44pk04w59 10 15 moral moral ADJ tt44pk04w59 10 16 and and CCONJ tt44pk04w59 10 17 political political ADJ tt44pk04w59 10 18 philosophy philosophy NOUN tt44pk04w59 10 19 more more ADV tt44pk04w59 10 20 broadly broadly ADV tt44pk04w59 10 21 , , PUNCT tt44pk04w59 10 22 need need AUX tt44pk04w59 10 23 not not PART tt44pk04w59 10 24 be be AUX tt44pk04w59 10 25 characterized characterize VERB tt44pk04w59 10 26 in in ADP tt44pk04w59 10 27 terms term NOUN tt44pk04w59 10 28 of of ADP tt44pk04w59 10 29 opposition opposition NOUN tt44pk04w59 10 30 or or CCONJ tt44pk04w59 10 31 even even ADV tt44pk04w59 10 32 an an DET tt44pk04w59 10 33 order order NOUN tt44pk04w59 10 34 of of ADP tt44pk04w59 10 35 priority priority NOUN tt44pk04w59 10 36 ; ; PUNCT tt44pk04w59 10 37 they they PRON tt44pk04w59 10 38 are be AUX tt44pk04w59 10 39 , , PUNCT tt44pk04w59 10 40 rather rather ADV tt44pk04w59 10 41 , , PUNCT tt44pk04w59 10 42 complementary complementary ADJ tt44pk04w59 10 43 elements element NOUN tt44pk04w59 10 44 that that PRON tt44pk04w59 10 45 join join VERB tt44pk04w59 10 46 to to PART tt44pk04w59 10 47 form form VERB tt44pk04w59 10 48 a a DET tt44pk04w59 10 49 true true ADJ tt44pk04w59 10 50 conception conception NOUN tt44pk04w59 10 51 of of ADP tt44pk04w59 10 52 natural natural ADJ tt44pk04w59 10 53 justice justice NOUN tt44pk04w59 10 54 . . PUNCT