id sid tid token lemma pos pr76f190d4g 1 1 this this DET pr76f190d4g 1 2 dissertation dissertation NOUN pr76f190d4g 1 3 updates update VERB pr76f190d4g 1 4 the the DET pr76f190d4g 1 5 debate debate NOUN pr76f190d4g 1 6 over over ADP pr76f190d4g 1 7 the the DET pr76f190d4g 1 8 nontriviality nontriviality NOUN pr76f190d4g 1 9 of of ADP pr76f190d4g 1 10 general general ADJ pr76f190d4g 1 11 covariance covariance NOUN pr76f190d4g 1 12 for for ADP pr76f190d4g 1 13 einstein einstein PROPN pr76f190d4g 1 14 's 's PART pr76f190d4g 1 15 general general ADJ pr76f190d4g 1 16 theory theory NOUN pr76f190d4g 1 17 of of ADP pr76f190d4g 1 18 relativity relativity NOUN pr76f190d4g 1 19 ( ( PUNCT pr76f190d4g 1 20 gtr gtr NOUN pr76f190d4g 1 21 ) ) PUNCT pr76f190d4g 1 22 and and CCONJ pr76f190d4g 1 23 considers consider VERB pr76f190d4g 1 24 particle particle NOUN pr76f190d4g 1 25 physics physics NOUN pr76f190d4g 1 26 in in ADP pr76f190d4g 1 27 the the DET pr76f190d4g 1 28 debate debate NOUN pr76f190d4g 1 29 over over ADP pr76f190d4g 1 30 underdetermination underdetermination NOUN pr76f190d4g 1 31 and and CCONJ pr76f190d4g 1 32 empirical empirical ADJ pr76f190d4g 1 33 equivalence equivalence NOUN pr76f190d4g 1 34 . . PUNCT pr76f190d4g 2 1 both both DET pr76f190d4g 2 2 tasks task NOUN pr76f190d4g 2 3 are be AUX pr76f190d4g 2 4 tied tie VERB pr76f190d4g 2 5 to to ADP pr76f190d4g 2 6 the the DET pr76f190d4g 2 7 unexplored unexplored ADJ pr76f190d4g 2 8 issue issue NOUN pr76f190d4g 2 9 of of ADP pr76f190d4g 2 10 artificial artificial ADJ pr76f190d4g 2 11 gauge gauge NOUN pr76f190d4g 2 12 freedom freedom NOUN pr76f190d4g 2 13 , , PUNCT pr76f190d4g 2 14 a a DET pr76f190d4g 2 15 valuable valuable ADJ pr76f190d4g 2 16 form form NOUN pr76f190d4g 2 17 of of ADP pr76f190d4g 2 18 descriptive descriptive ADJ pr76f190d4g 2 19 redundancy redundancy NOUN pr76f190d4g 2 20 . . PUNCT pr76f190d4g 3 1 whereas whereas SCONJ pr76f190d4g 3 2 einstein einstein PROPN pr76f190d4g 3 3 took take VERB pr76f190d4g 3 4 general general ADJ pr76f190d4g 3 5 covariance covariance NOUN pr76f190d4g 3 6 to to PART pr76f190d4g 3 7 characterize characterize VERB pr76f190d4g 3 8 gtr gtr NOUN pr76f190d4g 3 9 , , PUNCT pr76f190d4g 3 10 kretschmann kretschmann PROPN pr76f190d4g 3 11 thought think VERB pr76f190d4g 3 12 it it PRON pr76f190d4g 3 13 merely merely ADV pr76f190d4g 3 14 a a DET pr76f190d4g 3 15 formal formal ADJ pr76f190d4g 3 16 feature feature NOUN pr76f190d4g 3 17 that that SCONJ pr76f190d4g 3 18 any any DET pr76f190d4g 3 19 theory theory NOUN pr76f190d4g 3 20 could could AUX pr76f190d4g 3 21 have have AUX pr76f190d4g 3 22 . . PUNCT pr76f190d4g 4 1 anderson anderson PROPN pr76f190d4g 4 2 and and CCONJ pr76f190d4g 4 3 friedman friedman PROPN pr76f190d4g 4 4 analyzed analyze VERB pr76f190d4g 4 5 substantive substantive ADJ pr76f190d4g 4 6 general general ADJ pr76f190d4g 4 7 covariance covariance NOUN pr76f190d4g 4 8 as as ADP pr76f190d4g 4 9 the the DET pr76f190d4g 4 10 lack lack NOUN pr76f190d4g 4 11 of of ADP pr76f190d4g 4 12 absolute absolute ADJ pr76f190d4g 4 13 objects object NOUN pr76f190d4g 4 14 , , PUNCT pr76f190d4g 4 15 fields field VERB pr76f190d4g 4 16 the the DET pr76f190d4g 4 17 same same ADJ pr76f190d4g 4 18 in in ADP pr76f190d4g 4 19 all all DET pr76f190d4g 4 20 models model NOUN pr76f190d4g 4 21 . . PUNCT pr76f190d4g 5 1 some some DET pr76f190d4g 5 2 extant extant ADJ pr76f190d4g 5 3 counterexamples counterexample NOUN pr76f190d4g 5 4 and and CCONJ pr76f190d4g 5 5 a a DET pr76f190d4g 5 6 new new ADJ pr76f190d4g 5 7 one one NUM pr76f190d4g 5 8 involving involve VERB pr76f190d4g 5 9 the the DET pr76f190d4g 5 10 electron electron NOUN pr76f190d4g 5 11 spinor spinor NOUN pr76f190d4g 5 12 field field NOUN pr76f190d4g 5 13 are be AUX pr76f190d4g 5 14 resolved resolve VERB pr76f190d4g 5 15 . . PUNCT pr76f190d4g 6 1 however however ADV pr76f190d4g 6 2 , , PUNCT pr76f190d4g 6 3 geroch geroch PROPN pr76f190d4g 6 4 and and CCONJ pr76f190d4g 6 5 giulini giulini PROPN pr76f190d4g 6 6 diagnose diagnose VERB pr76f190d4g 6 7 an an DET pr76f190d4g 6 8 absolute absolute ADJ pr76f190d4g 6 9 object object NOUN pr76f190d4g 6 10 in in ADP pr76f190d4g 6 11 gtr gtr PROPN pr76f190d4g 6 12 itself itself PRON pr76f190d4g 6 13 in in ADP pr76f190d4g 6 14 the the DET pr76f190d4g 6 15 metric metric NOUN pr76f190d4g 6 16 's 's PART pr76f190d4g 6 17 volume volume NOUN pr76f190d4g 6 18 element element NOUN pr76f190d4g 6 19 . . PUNCT pr76f190d4g 7 1 one one PRON pr76f190d4g 7 2 might might AUX pr76f190d4g 7 3 instead instead ADV pr76f190d4g 7 4 analyze analyze VERB pr76f190d4g 7 5 substantive substantive ADJ pr76f190d4g 7 6 general general ADJ pr76f190d4g 7 7 covariance covariance NOUN pr76f190d4g 7 8 as as ADP pr76f190d4g 7 9 formal formal ADJ pr76f190d4g 7 10 general general ADJ pr76f190d4g 7 11 covariance covariance NOUN pr76f190d4g 7 12 achieved achieve VERB pr76f190d4g 7 13 without without ADP pr76f190d4g 7 14 hiding hide VERB pr76f190d4g 7 15 preferred preferred ADJ pr76f190d4g 7 16 coordinates coordinate NOUN pr76f190d4g 7 17 as as ADP pr76f190d4g 7 18 scalar scalar ADJ pr76f190d4g 7 19 ' ' PUNCT pr76f190d4g 7 20 clock clock NOUN pr76f190d4g 7 21 fields field NOUN pr76f190d4g 7 22 , , PUNCT pr76f190d4g 7 23 ' ' PUNCT pr76f190d4g 7 24 recalling recall VERB pr76f190d4g 7 25 einstein einstein PROPN pr76f190d4g 7 26 's 's PART pr76f190d4g 7 27 early early ADJ pr76f190d4g 7 28 views view NOUN pr76f190d4g 7 29 . . PUNCT pr76f190d4g 8 1 theories theory NOUN pr76f190d4g 8 2 with with ADP pr76f190d4g 8 3 no no DET pr76f190d4g 8 4 metric metric ADJ pr76f190d4g 8 5 or or CCONJ pr76f190d4g 8 6 multiple multiple ADJ pr76f190d4g 8 7 metrics metric NOUN pr76f190d4g 8 8 make make VERB pr76f190d4g 8 9 the the DET pr76f190d4g 8 10 age age NOUN pr76f190d4g 8 11 of of ADP pr76f190d4g 8 12 the the DET pr76f190d4g 8 13 universe universe ADJ pr76f190d4g 8 14 meaningless meaningless ADJ pr76f190d4g 8 15 or or CCONJ pr76f190d4g 8 16 ambiguous ambiguous ADJ pr76f190d4g 8 17 , , PUNCT pr76f190d4g 8 18 respectively respectively ADV pr76f190d4g 8 19 , , PUNCT pr76f190d4g 8 20 so so ADV pr76f190d4g 8 21 the the DET pr76f190d4g 8 22 ancient ancient ADJ pr76f190d4g 8 23 and and CCONJ pr76f190d4g 8 24 medieval medieval ADJ pr76f190d4g 8 25 debate debate NOUN pr76f190d4g 8 26 over over ADP pr76f190d4g 8 27 the the DET pr76f190d4g 8 28 eternity eternity NOUN pr76f190d4g 8 29 of of ADP pr76f190d4g 8 30 the the DET pr76f190d4g 8 31 world world NOUN pr76f190d4g 8 32 should should AUX pr76f190d4g 8 33 be be AUX pr76f190d4g 8 34 recast recast VERB pr76f190d4g 8 35 . . PUNCT pr76f190d4g 9 1 particle particle NOUN pr76f190d4g 9 2 physics physics NOUN pr76f190d4g 9 3 provides provide VERB pr76f190d4g 9 4 case case NOUN pr76f190d4g 9 5 studies study NOUN pr76f190d4g 9 6 for for ADP pr76f190d4g 9 7 empirical empirical ADJ pr76f190d4g 9 8 equivalence equivalence NOUN pr76f190d4g 9 9 . . PUNCT pr76f190d4g 10 1 proca proca PROPN pr76f190d4g 10 2 's 's PART pr76f190d4g 10 3 electromagnetism electromagnetism NOUN pr76f190d4g 10 4 with with ADP pr76f190d4g 10 5 some some DET pr76f190d4g 10 6 nonzero nonzero NOUN pr76f190d4g 10 7 photon photon NOUN pr76f190d4g 10 8 mass mass NOUN pr76f190d4g 10 9 constitutes constitute VERB pr76f190d4g 10 10 a a DET pr76f190d4g 10 11 family family NOUN pr76f190d4g 10 12 of of ADP pr76f190d4g 10 13 rivals rival NOUN pr76f190d4g 10 14 to to ADP pr76f190d4g 10 15 maxwell maxwell PROPN pr76f190d4g 10 16 's 's PART pr76f190d4g 10 17 theory theory NOUN pr76f190d4g 10 18 . . PUNCT pr76f190d4g 11 1 whereas whereas SCONJ pr76f190d4g 11 2 any any DET pr76f190d4g 11 3 proca proca PROPN pr76f190d4g 11 4 theory theory NOUN pr76f190d4g 11 5 can can AUX pr76f190d4g 11 6 be be AUX pr76f190d4g 11 7 distinguished distinguish VERB pr76f190d4g 11 8 empirically empirically ADV pr76f190d4g 11 9 from from ADP pr76f190d4g 11 10 maxwell maxwell PROPN pr76f190d4g 11 11 's 's PART pr76f190d4g 11 12 , , PUNCT pr76f190d4g 11 13 the the DET pr76f190d4g 11 14 proca proca PROPN pr76f190d4g 11 15 family family NOUN pr76f190d4g 11 16 approaches approach VERB pr76f190d4g 11 17 maxwell maxwell PROPN pr76f190d4g 11 18 's 's PART pr76f190d4g 11 19 for for ADP pr76f190d4g 11 20 small small ADJ pr76f190d4g 11 21 masses masse NOUN pr76f190d4g 11 22 , , PUNCT pr76f190d4g 11 23 yielding yield VERB pr76f190d4g 11 24 permanent permanent ADJ pr76f190d4g 11 25 underdetermination underdetermination NOUN pr76f190d4g 11 26 with with ADP pr76f190d4g 11 27 only only ADV pr76f190d4g 11 28 approximate approximate ADJ pr76f190d4g 11 29 empirical empirical ADJ pr76f190d4g 11 30 equivalence equivalence NOUN pr76f190d4g 11 31 . . PUNCT pr76f190d4g 12 1 the the DET pr76f190d4g 12 2 weak weak ADJ pr76f190d4g 12 3 nuclear nuclear ADJ pr76f190d4g 12 4 force force NOUN pr76f190d4g 12 5 also also ADV pr76f190d4g 12 6 displays display VERB pr76f190d4g 12 7 a a DET pr76f190d4g 12 8 smooth smooth ADJ pr76f190d4g 12 9 massless massless NOUN pr76f190d4g 12 10 limit limit NOUN pr76f190d4g 12 11 classically classically ADV pr76f190d4g 12 12 , , PUNCT pr76f190d4g 12 13 but but CCONJ pr76f190d4g 12 14 not not PART pr76f190d4g 12 15 after after ADP pr76f190d4g 12 16 quantization quantization NOUN pr76f190d4g 12 17 , , PUNCT pr76f190d4g 12 18 recalling recall VERB pr76f190d4g 12 19 the the DET pr76f190d4g 12 20 instability instability NOUN pr76f190d4g 12 21 of of ADP pr76f190d4g 12 22 empirical empirical ADJ pr76f190d4g 12 23 equivalence equivalence NOUN pr76f190d4g 12 24 under under ADP pr76f190d4g 12 25 change change NOUN pr76f190d4g 12 26 of of ADP pr76f190d4g 12 27 auxiliary auxiliary ADJ pr76f190d4g 12 28 hypotheses hypothesis NOUN pr76f190d4g 12 29 . . PUNCT pr76f190d4g 13 1 the the DET pr76f190d4g 13 2 standard standard ADJ pr76f190d4g 13 3 electroweak electroweak NOUN pr76f190d4g 13 4 theory theory NOUN pr76f190d4g 13 5 apparently apparently ADV pr76f190d4g 13 6 permits permit VERB pr76f190d4g 13 7 a a DET pr76f190d4g 13 8 photon photon NOUN pr76f190d4g 13 9 mass mass NOUN pr76f190d4g 13 10 term term NOUN pr76f190d4g 13 11 and and CCONJ pr76f190d4g 13 12 hence hence ADV pr76f190d4g 13 13 underdetermination underdetermination ADJ pr76f190d4g 13 14 , , PUNCT pr76f190d4g 13 15 but but CCONJ pr76f190d4g 13 16 possible possible ADJ pr76f190d4g 13 17 further further ADJ pr76f190d4g 13 18 unification unification NOUN pr76f190d4g 13 19 might might AUX pr76f190d4g 13 20 not not PART pr76f190d4g 13 21 . . PUNCT pr76f190d4g 14 1 the the DET pr76f190d4g 14 2 question question NOUN pr76f190d4g 14 3 of of ADP pr76f190d4g 14 4 underdetermination underdetermination NOUN pr76f190d4g 14 5 regarding regard VERB pr76f190d4g 14 6 massive massive ADJ pr76f190d4g 14 7 gravity gravity NOUN pr76f190d4g 14 8 is be AUX pr76f190d4g 14 9 unresolved unresolved ADJ pr76f190d4g 14 10 . . PUNCT pr76f190d4g 15 1 physicists physicist NOUN pr76f190d4g 15 2 often often ADV pr76f190d4g 15 3 reformulate reformulate VERB pr76f190d4g 15 4 a a DET pr76f190d4g 15 5 theory theory NOUN pr76f190d4g 15 6 to to PART pr76f190d4g 15 7 install install VERB pr76f190d4g 15 8 additional additional ADJ pr76f190d4g 15 9 fields field NOUN pr76f190d4g 15 10 and and CCONJ pr76f190d4g 15 11 new new ADJ pr76f190d4g 15 12 gauge gauge NOUN pr76f190d4g 15 13 symmetries symmetry NOUN pr76f190d4g 15 14 preserving preserve VERB pr76f190d4g 15 15 empirical empirical ADJ pr76f190d4g 15 16 content content NOUN pr76f190d4g 15 17 . . PUNCT pr76f190d4g 16 1 post post ADJ pr76f190d4g 16 2 - - ADJ pr76f190d4g 16 3 positivist positivist ADJ pr76f190d4g 16 4 philosophers philosopher NOUN pr76f190d4g 16 5 might might AUX pr76f190d4g 16 6 judge judge VERB pr76f190d4g 16 7 the the DET pr76f190d4g 16 8 result result NOUN pr76f190d4g 16 9 a a DET pr76f190d4g 16 10 distinct distinct ADJ pr76f190d4g 16 11 and and CCONJ pr76f190d4g 16 12 inferior inferior ADJ pr76f190d4g 16 13 theory theory NOUN pr76f190d4g 16 14 , , PUNCT pr76f190d4g 16 15 but but CCONJ pr76f190d4g 16 16 physicists physicist NOUN pr76f190d4g 16 17 consider consider VERB pr76f190d4g 16 18 it it PRON pr76f190d4g 16 19 a a DET pr76f190d4g 16 20 perhaps perhaps ADV pr76f190d4g 16 21 superior superior ADJ pr76f190d4g 16 22 formulation formulation NOUN pr76f190d4g 16 23 of of ADP pr76f190d4g 16 24 the the DET pr76f190d4g 16 25 same same ADJ pr76f190d4g 16 26 theory theory NOUN pr76f190d4g 16 27 . . PUNCT pr76f190d4g 17 1 evidently evidently ADV pr76f190d4g 17 2 a a DET pr76f190d4g 17 3 step step NOUN pr76f190d4g 17 4 back back ADV pr76f190d4g 17 5 from from ADP pr76f190d4g 17 6 naïve naïve PROPN pr76f190d4g 17 7 realism realism NOUN pr76f190d4g 17 8 towards towards ADP pr76f190d4g 17 9 mathematical mathematical ADJ pr76f190d4g 17 10 - - PUNCT pr76f190d4g 17 11 empirical empirical ADJ pr76f190d4g 17 12 equivalence equivalence NOUN pr76f190d4g 17 13 is be AUX pr76f190d4g 17 14 appropriate appropriate ADJ pr76f190d4g 17 15 for for ADP pr76f190d4g 17 16 physical physical ADJ pr76f190d4g 17 17 ontology ontology NOUN pr76f190d4g 17 18 and and CCONJ pr76f190d4g 17 19 theory theory NOUN pr76f190d4g 17 20 individuation individuation NOUN pr76f190d4g 17 21 . . PUNCT pr76f190d4g 18 1 artificial artificial ADJ pr76f190d4g 18 2 gauge gauge NOUN pr76f190d4g 18 3 freedom freedom NOUN pr76f190d4g 18 4 licenses license VERB pr76f190d4g 18 5 a a DET pr76f190d4g 18 6 generalized generalized ADJ pr76f190d4g 18 7 kretschmann kretschmann PROPN pr76f190d4g 18 8 objection objection NOUN pr76f190d4g 18 9 , , PUNCT pr76f190d4g 18 10 but but CCONJ pr76f190d4g 18 11 the the DET pr76f190d4g 18 12 clock clock NOUN pr76f190d4g 18 13 field field NOUN pr76f190d4g 18 14 case case NOUN pr76f190d4g 18 15 suggests suggest VERB pr76f190d4g 18 16 a a DET pr76f190d4g 18 17 resolution resolution NOUN pr76f190d4g 18 18 . . PUNCT