id sid tid token lemma pos pc289g57935 1 1 to to PART pc289g57935 1 2 paraphrase paraphrase VERB pc289g57935 1 3 a a DET pc289g57935 1 4 claim claim NOUN pc289g57935 1 5 is be AUX pc289g57935 1 6 to to PART pc289g57935 1 7 provide provide VERB pc289g57935 1 8 an an DET pc289g57935 1 9 alternative alternative ADJ pc289g57935 1 10 formulation formulation NOUN pc289g57935 1 11 of of ADP pc289g57935 1 12 it it PRON pc289g57935 1 13 . . PUNCT pc289g57935 2 1 but but CCONJ pc289g57935 2 2 what what PRON pc289g57935 2 3 are be AUX pc289g57935 2 4 the the DET pc289g57935 2 5 adequacy adequacy NOUN pc289g57935 2 6 conditions condition NOUN pc289g57935 2 7 on on ADP pc289g57935 2 8 such such ADJ pc289g57935 2 9 reformulations reformulation NOUN pc289g57935 2 10 ? ? PUNCT pc289g57935 3 1 kant kant NOUN pc289g57935 3 2 , , PUNCT pc289g57935 3 3 for for ADP pc289g57935 3 4 example example NOUN pc289g57935 3 5 , , PUNCT pc289g57935 3 6 claimed claim VERB pc289g57935 3 7 that that SCONJ pc289g57935 3 8 the the DET pc289g57935 3 9 different different ADJ pc289g57935 3 10 formulations formulation NOUN pc289g57935 3 11 of of ADP pc289g57935 3 12 the the DET pc289g57935 3 13 categorical categorical ADJ pc289g57935 3 14 imperative imperative NOUN pc289g57935 3 15 are be AUX pc289g57935 3 16 different different ADJ pc289g57935 3 17 formulations formulation NOUN pc289g57935 3 18 of of ADP pc289g57935 3 19 one one NUM pc289g57935 3 20 and and CCONJ pc289g57935 3 21 the the DET pc289g57935 3 22 same same ADJ pc289g57935 3 23 law law NOUN pc289g57935 3 24 . . PUNCT pc289g57935 4 1 but but CCONJ pc289g57935 4 2 was be AUX pc289g57935 4 3 he he PRON pc289g57935 4 4 right right ADJ pc289g57935 4 5 about about ADP pc289g57935 4 6 this this PRON pc289g57935 4 7 ? ? PUNCT pc289g57935 5 1 how how SCONJ pc289g57935 5 2 are be AUX pc289g57935 5 3 we we PRON pc289g57935 5 4 to to PART pc289g57935 5 5 know know VERB pc289g57935 5 6 ? ? PUNCT pc289g57935 6 1 the the DET pc289g57935 6 2 problem problem NOUN pc289g57935 6 3 is be AUX pc289g57935 6 4 widespread widespread ADJ pc289g57935 6 5 . . PUNCT pc289g57935 7 1 moore moore NOUN pc289g57935 7 2 argued argue VERB pc289g57935 7 3 that that SCONJ pc289g57935 7 4 moral moral ADJ pc289g57935 7 5 claims claim NOUN pc289g57935 7 6 can can AUX pc289g57935 7 7 not not PART pc289g57935 7 8 be be AUX pc289g57935 7 9 expressed express VERB pc289g57935 7 10 using use VERB pc289g57935 7 11 sentences sentence NOUN pc289g57935 7 12 containing contain VERB pc289g57935 7 13 only only ADJ pc289g57935 7 14 naturalistic naturalistic ADJ pc289g57935 7 15 language language NOUN pc289g57935 7 16 ; ; PUNCT pc289g57935 7 17 platonists platonist NOUN pc289g57935 7 18 argue argue VERB pc289g57935 7 19 that that SCONJ pc289g57935 7 20 reality reality NOUN pc289g57935 7 21 can can AUX pc289g57935 7 22 not not PART pc289g57935 7 23 be be AUX pc289g57935 7 24 adequately adequately ADV pc289g57935 7 25 characterized characterize VERB pc289g57935 7 26 without without ADP pc289g57935 7 27 using use VERB pc289g57935 7 28 sentences sentence NOUN pc289g57935 7 29 that that PRON pc289g57935 7 30 refer refer VERB pc289g57935 7 31 to to ADP pc289g57935 7 32 abstract abstract ADJ pc289g57935 7 33 objects object NOUN pc289g57935 7 34 ; ; PUNCT pc289g57935 7 35 ' ' PUNCT pc289g57935 7 36 tensers tenser NOUN pc289g57935 7 37 ' ' PART pc289g57935 7 38 in in ADP pc289g57935 7 39 the the DET pc289g57935 7 40 philosophy philosophy NOUN pc289g57935 7 41 of of ADP pc289g57935 7 42 time time NOUN pc289g57935 7 43 argue argue VERB pc289g57935 7 44 that that SCONJ pc289g57935 7 45 tensed tense VERB pc289g57935 7 46 sentences sentence NOUN pc289g57935 7 47 can can AUX pc289g57935 7 48 not not PART pc289g57935 7 49 be be AUX pc289g57935 7 50 adequately adequately ADV pc289g57935 7 51 paraphrased paraphrase VERB pc289g57935 7 52 by by ADP pc289g57935 7 53 tenseless tenseless NOUN pc289g57935 7 54 sentences sentence NOUN pc289g57935 7 55 ; ; PUNCT pc289g57935 7 56 and and CCONJ pc289g57935 7 57 dualists dualist NOUN pc289g57935 7 58 such such ADJ pc289g57935 7 59 as as ADP pc289g57935 7 60 david david PROPN pc289g57935 7 61 chalmers chalmer NOUN pc289g57935 7 62 argue argue VERB pc289g57935 7 63 that that SCONJ pc289g57935 7 64 certain certain ADJ pc289g57935 7 65 facts fact NOUN pc289g57935 7 66 about about ADP pc289g57935 7 67 consciousness consciousness NOUN pc289g57935 7 68 can can AUX pc289g57935 7 69 not not PART pc289g57935 7 70 be be AUX pc289g57935 7 71 expressed express VERB pc289g57935 7 72 using use VERB pc289g57935 7 73 sentences sentence NOUN pc289g57935 7 74 containing contain VERB pc289g57935 7 75 only only ADV pc289g57935 7 76 vocabulary vocabulary ADJ pc289g57935 7 77 amenable amenable NOUN pc289g57935 7 78 to to ADP pc289g57935 7 79 reductive reductive ADJ pc289g57935 7 80 physicalism physicalism NOUN pc289g57935 7 81 . . PUNCT pc289g57935 8 1 whether whether SCONJ pc289g57935 8 2 these these DET pc289g57935 8 3 claims claim NOUN pc289g57935 8 4 are be AUX pc289g57935 8 5 correct correct ADJ pc289g57935 8 6 makes make VERB pc289g57935 8 7 a a DET pc289g57935 8 8 considerable considerable ADJ pc289g57935 8 9 difference difference NOUN pc289g57935 8 10 to to ADP pc289g57935 8 11 the the DET pc289g57935 8 12 way way NOUN pc289g57935 8 13 we we PRON pc289g57935 8 14 should should AUX pc289g57935 8 15 conceive conceive VERB pc289g57935 8 16 of of ADP pc289g57935 8 17 the the DET pc289g57935 8 18 world world NOUN pc289g57935 8 19 and and CCONJ pc289g57935 8 20 our our PRON pc289g57935 8 21 place place NOUN pc289g57935 8 22 within within ADP pc289g57935 8 23 it it PRON pc289g57935 8 24 . . PUNCT pc289g57935 9 1 but but CCONJ pc289g57935 9 2 how how SCONJ pc289g57935 9 3 are be AUX pc289g57935 9 4 we we PRON pc289g57935 9 5 to to PART pc289g57935 9 6 determine determine VERB pc289g57935 9 7 whether whether SCONJ pc289g57935 9 8 they they PRON pc289g57935 9 9 are be AUX pc289g57935 9 10 correct correct ADJ pc289g57935 9 11 ? ? PUNCT pc289g57935 10 1 despite despite SCONJ pc289g57935 10 2 the the DET pc289g57935 10 3 importance importance NOUN pc289g57935 10 4 of of ADP pc289g57935 10 5 developing develop VERB pc289g57935 10 6 an an DET pc289g57935 10 7 adequate adequate ADJ pc289g57935 10 8 understanding understanding NOUN pc289g57935 10 9 of of ADP pc289g57935 10 10 paraphrase paraphrase NOUN pc289g57935 10 11 , , PUNCT pc289g57935 10 12 surprisingly surprisingly ADV pc289g57935 10 13 little little ADJ pc289g57935 10 14 work work NOUN pc289g57935 10 15 has have AUX pc289g57935 10 16 been be AUX pc289g57935 10 17 done do VERB pc289g57935 10 18 on on ADP pc289g57935 10 19 the the DET pc289g57935 10 20 topic topic NOUN pc289g57935 10 21 . . PUNCT pc289g57935 11 1 the the DET pc289g57935 11 2 present present ADJ pc289g57935 11 3 dissertation dissertation NOUN pc289g57935 11 4 addresses address VERB pc289g57935 11 5 this this DET pc289g57935 11 6 deficiency deficiency NOUN pc289g57935 11 7 . . PUNCT pc289g57935 12 1 it it PRON pc289g57935 12 2 exposes expose VERB pc289g57935 12 3 a a DET pc289g57935 12 4 widespread widespread ADJ pc289g57935 12 5 misconception misconception NOUN pc289g57935 12 6 about about ADP pc289g57935 12 7 johnchristopher johnchristopher PROPN pc289g57935 12 8 adorno adorno PROPN pc289g57935 12 9 keller keller PROPN pc289g57935 12 10 the the DET pc289g57935 12 11 function function NOUN pc289g57935 12 12 of of ADP pc289g57935 12 13 paraphrase paraphrase NOUN pc289g57935 12 14 : : PUNCT pc289g57935 12 15 that that SCONJ pc289g57935 12 16 its its PRON pc289g57935 12 17 purpose purpose NOUN pc289g57935 12 18 is be AUX pc289g57935 12 19 to to PART pc289g57935 12 20 remove remove VERB pc289g57935 12 21 unwanted unwanted ADJ pc289g57935 12 22 commitments commitment NOUN pc289g57935 12 23 . . PUNCT pc289g57935 13 1 i i PRON pc289g57935 13 2 argue argue VERB pc289g57935 13 3 that that SCONJ pc289g57935 13 4 the the DET pc289g57935 13 5 proper proper ADJ pc289g57935 13 6 way way NOUN pc289g57935 13 7 to to PART pc289g57935 13 8 understand understand VERB pc289g57935 13 9 paraphrase paraphrase NOUN pc289g57935 13 10 is be AUX pc289g57935 13 11 as as ADP pc289g57935 13 12 revealing reveal VERB pc289g57935 13 13 the the DET pc289g57935 13 14 commitments commitment NOUN pc289g57935 13 15 of of ADP pc289g57935 13 16 our our PRON pc289g57935 13 17 discourse discourse NOUN pc289g57935 13 18 . . PUNCT pc289g57935 14 1 paraphrase paraphrase NOUN pc289g57935 14 2 is be AUX pc289g57935 14 3 important important ADJ pc289g57935 14 4 precisely precisely ADV pc289g57935 14 5 because because SCONJ pc289g57935 14 6 we we PRON pc289g57935 14 7 do do AUX pc289g57935 14 8 not not PART pc289g57935 14 9 in in ADP pc289g57935 14 10 general general ADJ pc289g57935 14 11 know know VERB pc289g57935 14 12 what what PRON pc289g57935 14 13 the the DET pc289g57935 14 14 entailments entailment NOUN pc289g57935 14 15 of of ADP pc289g57935 14 16 our our PRON pc289g57935 14 17 theories theory NOUN pc289g57935 14 18 are be AUX pc289g57935 14 19 . . PUNCT pc289g57935 15 1 the the DET pc289g57935 15 2 entailment entailment NOUN pc289g57935 15 3 relations relation NOUN pc289g57935 15 4 our our PRON pc289g57935 15 5 theories theory NOUN pc289g57935 15 6 stand stand VERB pc289g57935 15 7 in in ADP pc289g57935 15 8 , , PUNCT pc289g57935 15 9 being be AUX pc289g57935 15 10 truths truth NOUN pc289g57935 15 11 of of ADP pc289g57935 15 12 logic logic NOUN pc289g57935 15 13 and and CCONJ pc289g57935 15 14 hence hence ADV pc289g57935 15 15 necessary necessary ADJ pc289g57935 15 16 , , PUNCT pc289g57935 15 17 can can AUX pc289g57935 15 18 not not PART pc289g57935 15 19 be be AUX pc289g57935 15 20 removedì¢ removedì¢ PROPN pc289g57935 15 21 ââ ââ NOUN pc289g57935 15 22 ' ' PUNCT pc289g57935 15 23 the the DET pc289g57935 15 24 only only ADJ pc289g57935 15 25 commitments commitment NOUN pc289g57935 15 26 paraphrase paraphrase NOUN pc289g57935 15 27 is be AUX pc289g57935 15 28 able able ADJ pc289g57935 15 29 to to PART pc289g57935 15 30 ' ' PUNCT pc289g57935 15 31 remove remove VERB pc289g57935 15 32 ' ' PUNCT pc289g57935 15 33 are be AUX pc289g57935 15 34 commitments commitment NOUN pc289g57935 15 35 that that PRON pc289g57935 15 36 were be AUX pc289g57935 15 37 not not PART pc289g57935 15 38 really really ADV pc289g57935 15 39 there there ADV pc289g57935 15 40 in in ADP pc289g57935 15 41 the the DET pc289g57935 15 42 first first ADJ pc289g57935 15 43 place place NOUN pc289g57935 15 44 : : PUNCT pc289g57935 15 45 merely merely ADV pc289g57935 15 46 apparent apparent ADJ pc289g57935 15 47 commitments commitment NOUN pc289g57935 15 48 . . PUNCT pc289g57935 16 1 an an DET pc289g57935 16 2 important important ADJ pc289g57935 16 3 part part NOUN pc289g57935 16 4 of of ADP pc289g57935 16 5 the the DET pc289g57935 16 6 argument argument NOUN pc289g57935 16 7 for for ADP pc289g57935 16 8 the the DET pc289g57935 16 9 revealing reveal VERB pc289g57935 16 10 conception conception NOUN pc289g57935 16 11 of of ADP pc289g57935 16 12 paraphrase paraphrase NOUN pc289g57935 16 13 lies lie VERB pc289g57935 16 14 in in ADP pc289g57935 16 15 showing show VERB pc289g57935 16 16 that that SCONJ pc289g57935 16 17 two two NUM pc289g57935 16 18 presuppositions presupposition NOUN pc289g57935 16 19 of of ADP pc289g57935 16 20 the the DET pc289g57935 16 21 removing removing NOUN pc289g57935 16 22 conception conception NOUN pc289g57935 16 23 are be AUX pc289g57935 16 24 false false ADJ pc289g57935 16 25 . . PUNCT pc289g57935 17 1 these these PRON pc289g57935 17 2 are be AUX pc289g57935 17 3 , , PUNCT pc289g57935 17 4 first first ADV pc289g57935 17 5 , , PUNCT pc289g57935 17 6 that that SCONJ pc289g57935 17 7 the the DET pc289g57935 17 8 ' ' PUNCT pc289g57935 17 9 logical logical ADJ pc289g57935 17 10 forms form NOUN pc289g57935 17 11 ' ' PUNCT pc289g57935 17 12 of of ADP pc289g57935 17 13 claims claim NOUN pc289g57935 17 14 we we PRON pc289g57935 17 15 accept accept VERB pc289g57935 17 16 are be AUX pc289g57935 17 17 transparent transparent ADJ pc289g57935 17 18 to to ADP pc289g57935 17 19 us we PRON pc289g57935 17 20 ; ; PUNCT pc289g57935 17 21 and and CCONJ pc289g57935 17 22 , , PUNCT pc289g57935 17 23 second second ADV pc289g57935 17 24 , , PUNCT pc289g57935 17 25 that that SCONJ pc289g57935 17 26 when when SCONJ pc289g57935 17 27 being be AUX pc289g57935 17 28 truthful truthful ADJ pc289g57935 17 29 we we PRON pc289g57935 17 30 typically typically ADV pc289g57935 17 31 believe believe VERB pc289g57935 17 32 what what PRON pc289g57935 17 33 we we PRON pc289g57935 17 34 say say VERB pc289g57935 17 35 . . PUNCT pc289g57935 18 1 the the DET pc289g57935 18 2 first first ADJ pc289g57935 18 3 presupposition presupposition NOUN pc289g57935 18 4 , , PUNCT pc289g57935 18 5 despite despite SCONJ pc289g57935 18 6 the the DET pc289g57935 18 7 ubiquity ubiquity NOUN pc289g57935 18 8 with with ADP pc289g57935 18 9 which which PRON pc289g57935 18 10 it it PRON pc289g57935 18 11 is be AUX pc289g57935 18 12 accepted accept VERB pc289g57935 18 13 , , PUNCT pc289g57935 18 14 simply simply ADV pc289g57935 18 15 does do AUX pc289g57935 18 16 not not PART pc289g57935 18 17 stand stand VERB pc289g57935 18 18 up up ADP pc289g57935 18 19 to to ADP pc289g57935 18 20 critical critical ADJ pc289g57935 18 21 scrutinyì¢ scrutinyì¢ NOUN pc289g57935 18 22 ââ ââ NOUN pc289g57935 18 23 ' ' PUNCT pc289g57935 18 24 if if SCONJ pc289g57935 18 25 it it PRON pc289g57935 18 26 were be AUX pc289g57935 18 27 true true ADJ pc289g57935 18 28 , , PUNCT pc289g57935 18 29 it it PRON pc289g57935 18 30 would would AUX pc289g57935 18 31 be be AUX pc289g57935 18 32 trivial trivial ADJ pc289g57935 18 33 to to PART pc289g57935 18 34 find find VERB pc289g57935 18 35 adequate adequate ADJ pc289g57935 18 36 formulations formulation NOUN pc289g57935 18 37 of of ADP pc289g57935 18 38 our our PRON pc289g57935 18 39 thoughts thought NOUN pc289g57935 18 40 in in ADP pc289g57935 18 41 logical logical ADJ pc289g57935 18 42 languages language NOUN pc289g57935 18 43 . . PUNCT pc289g57935 19 1 the the DET pc289g57935 19 2 problem problem NOUN pc289g57935 19 3 with with ADP pc289g57935 19 4 the the DET pc289g57935 19 5 second second ADJ pc289g57935 19 6 presupposition presupposition NOUN pc289g57935 19 7 is be AUX pc289g57935 19 8 less less ADV pc289g57935 19 9 obvious obvious ADJ pc289g57935 19 10 . . PUNCT pc289g57935 20 1 my my PRON pc289g57935 20 2 argument argument NOUN pc289g57935 20 3 draws draw VERB pc289g57935 20 4 on on ADP pc289g57935 20 5 recent recent ADJ pc289g57935 20 6 work work NOUN pc289g57935 20 7 in in ADP pc289g57935 20 8 the the DET pc289g57935 20 9 philosophy philosophy NOUN pc289g57935 20 10 of of ADP pc289g57935 20 11 language language NOUN pc289g57935 20 12 by by ADP pc289g57935 20 13 kent kent PROPN pc289g57935 20 14 bach bach PROPN pc289g57935 20 15 and and CCONJ pc289g57935 20 16 others other NOUN pc289g57935 20 17 , , PUNCT pc289g57935 20 18 which which PRON pc289g57935 20 19 shows show VERB pc289g57935 20 20 that that SCONJ pc289g57935 20 21 the the DET pc289g57935 20 22 proposition proposition NOUN pc289g57935 20 23 we we PRON pc289g57935 20 24 communicate communicate VERB pc289g57935 20 25 is be AUX pc289g57935 20 26 rarely rarely ADV pc289g57935 20 27 the the DET pc289g57935 20 28 semantic semantic ADJ pc289g57935 20 29 content content NOUN pc289g57935 20 30 of of ADP pc289g57935 20 31 the the DET pc289g57935 20 32 sentence sentence NOUN pc289g57935 20 33 we we PRON pc289g57935 20 34 use use VERB pc289g57935 20 35 to to PART pc289g57935 20 36 communicate communicate VERB pc289g57935 20 37 it it PRON pc289g57935 20 38 . . PUNCT pc289g57935 21 1 it it PRON pc289g57935 21 2 follows follow VERB pc289g57935 21 3 that that SCONJ pc289g57935 21 4 semantic semantic ADJ pc289g57935 21 5 analysis analysis NOUN pc289g57935 21 6 of of ADP pc289g57935 21 7 the the DET pc289g57935 21 8 sentences sentence NOUN pc289g57935 21 9 we we PRON pc289g57935 21 10 utter utter VERB pc289g57935 21 11 is be AUX pc289g57935 21 12 an an DET pc289g57935 21 13 unreliable unreliable ADJ pc289g57935 21 14 method method NOUN pc289g57935 21 15 for for ADP pc289g57935 21 16 determining determine VERB pc289g57935 21 17 what what PRON pc289g57935 21 18 we we PRON pc289g57935 21 19 believe believe VERB pc289g57935 21 20 . . PUNCT pc289g57935 22 1 the the DET pc289g57935 22 2 final final ADJ pc289g57935 22 3 chapter chapter NOUN pc289g57935 22 4 of of ADP pc289g57935 22 5 the the DET pc289g57935 22 6 dissertation dissertation NOUN pc289g57935 22 7 shows show VERB pc289g57935 22 8 that that SCONJ pc289g57935 22 9 an an DET pc289g57935 22 10 influential influential ADJ pc289g57935 22 11 objection objection NOUN pc289g57935 22 12 to to PART pc289g57935 22 13 quinean quinean VERB pc289g57935 22 14 meta meta NOUN pc289g57935 22 15 - - NOUN pc289g57935 22 16 ontology ontology NOUN pc289g57935 22 17 is be AUX pc289g57935 22 18 based base VERB pc289g57935 22 19 on on ADP pc289g57935 22 20 a a DET pc289g57935 22 21 misunderstanding misunderstanding NOUN pc289g57935 22 22 of of ADP pc289g57935 22 23 the the DET pc289g57935 22 24 function function NOUN pc289g57935 22 25 of of ADP pc289g57935 22 26 paraphrase paraphrase NOUN pc289g57935 22 27 , , PUNCT pc289g57935 22 28 and and CCONJ pc289g57935 22 29 spells spell VERB pc289g57935 22 30 out out ADP pc289g57935 22 31 the the DET pc289g57935 22 32 dire dire ADJ pc289g57935 22 33 consequences consequence NOUN pc289g57935 22 34 of of ADP pc289g57935 22 35 the the DET pc289g57935 22 36 position position NOUN pc289g57935 22 37 adopted adopt VERB pc289g57935 22 38 as as ADP pc289g57935 22 39 a a DET pc289g57935 22 40 result result NOUN pc289g57935 22 41 of of ADP pc289g57935 22 42 that that DET pc289g57935 22 43 misunderstanding misunderstanding NOUN pc289g57935 22 44 . . PUNCT