id sid tid token lemma pos mp48sb41m1q 1 1 this this DET mp48sb41m1q 1 2 dissertation dissertation NOUN mp48sb41m1q 1 3 is be AUX mp48sb41m1q 1 4 a a DET mp48sb41m1q 1 5 defense defense NOUN mp48sb41m1q 1 6 of of ADP mp48sb41m1q 1 7 mereological mereological ADJ mp48sb41m1q 1 8 nihilism nihilism NOUN mp48sb41m1q 1 9 , , PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 1 10 the the DET mp48sb41m1q 1 11 view view NOUN mp48sb41m1q 1 12 that that SCONJ mp48sb41m1q 1 13 composition composition NOUN mp48sb41m1q 1 14 never never ADV mp48sb41m1q 1 15 occurs occur VERB mp48sb41m1q 1 16 . . PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 2 1 so so ADV mp48sb41m1q 2 2 , , PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 2 3 according accord VERB mp48sb41m1q 2 4 to to ADP mp48sb41m1q 2 5 nihilism nihilism NOUN mp48sb41m1q 2 6 things thing NOUN mp48sb41m1q 2 7 with with ADP mp48sb41m1q 2 8 proper proper ADJ mp48sb41m1q 2 9 parts part NOUN mp48sb41m1q 2 10 ( ( PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 2 11 including include VERB mp48sb41m1q 2 12 dogs dog NOUN mp48sb41m1q 2 13 , , PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 2 14 tables table NOUN mp48sb41m1q 2 15 , , PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 2 16 and and CCONJ mp48sb41m1q 2 17 rocks rock NOUN mp48sb41m1q 2 18 ) ) PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 2 19 do do AUX mp48sb41m1q 2 20 n't not PART mp48sb41m1q 2 21 exist exist VERB mp48sb41m1q 2 22 . . PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 3 1 i i PRON mp48sb41m1q 3 2 give give VERB mp48sb41m1q 3 3 two two NUM mp48sb41m1q 3 4 arguments argument NOUN mp48sb41m1q 3 5 in in ADP mp48sb41m1q 3 6 favor favor NOUN mp48sb41m1q 3 7 of of ADP mp48sb41m1q 3 8 nihilism nihilism NOUN mp48sb41m1q 3 9 , , PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 3 10 both both PRON mp48sb41m1q 3 11 of of ADP mp48sb41m1q 3 12 which which PRON mp48sb41m1q 3 13 are be AUX mp48sb41m1q 3 14 from from ADP mp48sb41m1q 3 15 the the DET mp48sb41m1q 3 16 theoretical theoretical ADJ mp48sb41m1q 3 17 simplicity simplicity NOUN mp48sb41m1q 3 18 enjoyed enjoy VERB mp48sb41m1q 3 19 by by ADP mp48sb41m1q 3 20 nihilism nihilism NOUN mp48sb41m1q 3 21 . . PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 4 1 the the DET mp48sb41m1q 4 2 first first ADJ mp48sb41m1q 4 3 argument argument NOUN mp48sb41m1q 4 4 is be AUX mp48sb41m1q 4 5 from from ADP mp48sb41m1q 4 6 nihilism nihilism NOUN mp48sb41m1q 4 7 's 's PART mp48sb41m1q 4 8 ideological ideological ADJ mp48sb41m1q 4 9 simplicity simplicity NOUN mp48sb41m1q 4 10 , , PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 4 11 the the DET mp48sb41m1q 4 12 fact fact NOUN mp48sb41m1q 4 13 that that SCONJ mp48sb41m1q 4 14 nihilism nihilism NOUN mp48sb41m1q 4 15 allows allow VERB mp48sb41m1q 4 16 us we PRON mp48sb41m1q 4 17 to to PART mp48sb41m1q 4 18 do do VERB mp48sb41m1q 4 19 without without ADP mp48sb41m1q 4 20 mereological mereological ADJ mp48sb41m1q 4 21 primitives primitive NOUN mp48sb41m1q 4 22 like like ADP mp48sb41m1q 4 23 " " PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 4 24 part part NOUN mp48sb41m1q 4 25 . . PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 4 26 " " PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 5 1 the the DET mp48sb41m1q 5 2 second second ADJ mp48sb41m1q 5 3 argument argument NOUN mp48sb41m1q 5 4 is be AUX mp48sb41m1q 5 5 from from ADP mp48sb41m1q 5 6 the the DET mp48sb41m1q 5 7 theoretical theoretical ADJ mp48sb41m1q 5 8 unification unification NOUN mp48sb41m1q 5 9 conferred confer VERB mp48sb41m1q 5 10 by by ADP mp48sb41m1q 5 11 nihilism nihilism NOUN mp48sb41m1q 5 12 . . PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 6 1 the the DET mp48sb41m1q 6 2 remainder remainder NOUN mp48sb41m1q 6 3 of of ADP mp48sb41m1q 6 4 the the DET mp48sb41m1q 6 5 dissertation dissertation NOUN mp48sb41m1q 6 6 is be AUX mp48sb41m1q 6 7 directed direct VERB mp48sb41m1q 6 8 toward toward ADP mp48sb41m1q 6 9 defending defend VERB mp48sb41m1q 6 10 nihilism nihilism NOUN mp48sb41m1q 6 11 against against ADP mp48sb41m1q 6 12 objections objection NOUN mp48sb41m1q 6 13 . . PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 7 1 two two NUM mp48sb41m1q 7 2 of of ADP mp48sb41m1q 7 3 the the DET mp48sb41m1q 7 4 objections objection NOUN mp48sb41m1q 7 5 i i PRON mp48sb41m1q 7 6 consider consider VERB mp48sb41m1q 7 7 are be AUX mp48sb41m1q 7 8 deflationary deflationary ADJ mp48sb41m1q 7 9 , , PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 7 10 in in ADP mp48sb41m1q 7 11 the the DET mp48sb41m1q 7 12 sense sense NOUN mp48sb41m1q 7 13 that that SCONJ mp48sb41m1q 7 14 they they PRON mp48sb41m1q 7 15 contend contend VERB mp48sb41m1q 7 16 that that SCONJ mp48sb41m1q 7 17 the the DET mp48sb41m1q 7 18 debate debate NOUN mp48sb41m1q 7 19 over over ADP mp48sb41m1q 7 20 the the DET mp48sb41m1q 7 21 existence existence NOUN mp48sb41m1q 7 22 of of ADP mp48sb41m1q 7 23 composite composite ADJ mp48sb41m1q 7 24 objects object NOUN mp48sb41m1q 7 25 is be AUX mp48sb41m1q 7 26 merely merely ADV mp48sb41m1q 7 27 verbal verbal ADJ mp48sb41m1q 7 28 , , PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 7 29 or or CCONJ mp48sb41m1q 7 30 trivially trivially ADV mp48sb41m1q 7 31 easy easy ADJ mp48sb41m1q 7 32 to to PART mp48sb41m1q 7 33 settle settle VERB mp48sb41m1q 7 34 via via ADP mp48sb41m1q 7 35 conceptual conceptual ADJ mp48sb41m1q 7 36 analysis analysis NOUN mp48sb41m1q 7 37 in in ADP mp48sb41m1q 7 38 conjunction conjunction NOUN mp48sb41m1q 7 39 with with ADP mp48sb41m1q 7 40 basic basic ADJ mp48sb41m1q 7 41 empirical empirical ADJ mp48sb41m1q 7 42 investigation investigation NOUN mp48sb41m1q 7 43 . . PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 8 1 other other ADJ mp48sb41m1q 8 2 objections objection NOUN mp48sb41m1q 8 3 to to ADP mp48sb41m1q 8 4 nihilism nihilism NOUN mp48sb41m1q 8 5 which which PRON mp48sb41m1q 8 6 i i PRON mp48sb41m1q 8 7 address address VERB mp48sb41m1q 8 8 focus focus NOUN mp48sb41m1q 8 9 on on ADP mp48sb41m1q 8 10 claims claim NOUN mp48sb41m1q 8 11 which which PRON mp48sb41m1q 8 12 the the DET mp48sb41m1q 8 13 nihilist nihilist NOUN mp48sb41m1q 8 14 endorses endorse VERB mp48sb41m1q 8 15 to to ADP mp48sb41m1q 8 16 the the DET mp48sb41m1q 8 17 effect effect NOUN mp48sb41m1q 8 18 that that SCONJ mp48sb41m1q 8 19 , , PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 8 20 while while SCONJ mp48sb41m1q 8 21 there there PRON mp48sb41m1q 8 22 are be VERB mp48sb41m1q 8 23 no no DET mp48sb41m1q 8 24 composite composite ADJ mp48sb41m1q 8 25 objects object NOUN mp48sb41m1q 8 26 , , PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 8 27 there there PRON mp48sb41m1q 8 28 are be VERB mp48sb41m1q 8 29 " " PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 8 30 simples simples ADJ mp48sb41m1q 8 31 arranged arrange VERB mp48sb41m1q 8 32 composite composite ADJ mp48sb41m1q 8 33 object object NOUN mp48sb41m1q 8 34 - - PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 8 35 wise wise ADJ mp48sb41m1q 8 36 . . PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 8 37 " " PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 9 1 these these DET mp48sb41m1q 9 2 objections objection NOUN mp48sb41m1q 9 3 contend contend VERB mp48sb41m1q 9 4 that that SCONJ mp48sb41m1q 9 5 the the DET mp48sb41m1q 9 6 " " PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 9 7 simples simples ADJ mp48sb41m1q 9 8 arranged arrange VERB mp48sb41m1q 9 9 f f PROPN mp48sb41m1q 9 10 - - ADJ mp48sb41m1q 9 11 wise wise ADJ mp48sb41m1q 9 12 " " PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 9 13 locution locution NOUN mp48sb41m1q 9 14 is be AUX mp48sb41m1q 9 15 objectionable objectionable ADJ mp48sb41m1q 9 16 . . PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 10 1 i i PRON mp48sb41m1q 10 2 go go VERB mp48sb41m1q 10 3 on on ADP mp48sb41m1q 10 4 to to PART mp48sb41m1q 10 5 consider consider VERB mp48sb41m1q 10 6 whether whether SCONJ mp48sb41m1q 10 7 science science NOUN mp48sb41m1q 10 8 gives give VERB mp48sb41m1q 10 9 us we PRON mp48sb41m1q 10 10 compelling compelling ADJ mp48sb41m1q 10 11 reasons reason NOUN mp48sb41m1q 10 12 to to PART mp48sb41m1q 10 13 believe believe VERB mp48sb41m1q 10 14 in in ADP mp48sb41m1q 10 15 composite composite ADJ mp48sb41m1q 10 16 objects object NOUN mp48sb41m1q 10 17 . . PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 11 1 while while SCONJ mp48sb41m1q 11 2 scientific scientific ADJ mp48sb41m1q 11 3 theories theory NOUN mp48sb41m1q 11 4 are be AUX mp48sb41m1q 11 5 frequently frequently ADV mp48sb41m1q 11 6 framed frame VERB mp48sb41m1q 11 7 in in ADP mp48sb41m1q 11 8 terms term NOUN mp48sb41m1q 11 9 which which PRON mp48sb41m1q 11 10 make make VERB mp48sb41m1q 11 11 reference reference NOUN mp48sb41m1q 11 12 to to ADP mp48sb41m1q 11 13 composite composite ADJ mp48sb41m1q 11 14 objects object NOUN mp48sb41m1q 11 15 , , PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 11 16 i i PRON mp48sb41m1q 11 17 argue argue VERB mp48sb41m1q 11 18 that that SCONJ mp48sb41m1q 11 19 these these DET mp48sb41m1q 11 20 references reference NOUN mp48sb41m1q 11 21 to to ADP mp48sb41m1q 11 22 composite composite ADJ mp48sb41m1q 11 23 objects object NOUN mp48sb41m1q 11 24 are be AUX mp48sb41m1q 11 25 eliminable eliminable ADJ mp48sb41m1q 11 26 . . PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 12 1 what what PRON mp48sb41m1q 12 2 's be AUX mp48sb41m1q 12 3 more more ADJ mp48sb41m1q 12 4 , , PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 12 5 specific specific ADJ mp48sb41m1q 12 6 scientific scientific ADJ mp48sb41m1q 12 7 contexts context NOUN mp48sb41m1q 12 8 which which PRON mp48sb41m1q 12 9 have have AUX mp48sb41m1q 12 10 sometimes sometimes ADV mp48sb41m1q 12 11 been be AUX mp48sb41m1q 12 12 thought think VERB mp48sb41m1q 12 13 to to PART mp48sb41m1q 12 14 contain contain VERB mp48sb41m1q 12 15 particularly particularly ADV mp48sb41m1q 12 16 intractable intractable ADJ mp48sb41m1q 12 17 references reference NOUN mp48sb41m1q 12 18 to to ADP mp48sb41m1q 12 19 composition composition NOUN mp48sb41m1q 12 20 ( ( PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 12 21 quantum quantum PROPN mp48sb41m1q 12 22 entanglement entanglement NOUN mp48sb41m1q 12 23 and and CCONJ mp48sb41m1q 12 24 natural natural ADJ mp48sb41m1q 12 25 selection selection NOUN mp48sb41m1q 12 26 ) ) PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 12 27 can can AUX mp48sb41m1q 12 28 all all PRON mp48sb41m1q 12 29 be be AUX mp48sb41m1q 12 30 interpreted interpret VERB mp48sb41m1q 12 31 in in ADP mp48sb41m1q 12 32 a a DET mp48sb41m1q 12 33 nihilist nihilist NOUN mp48sb41m1q 12 34 friendly friendly ADJ mp48sb41m1q 12 35 manner manner NOUN mp48sb41m1q 12 36 . . PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 13 1 finally finally ADV mp48sb41m1q 13 2 , , PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 13 3 i i PRON mp48sb41m1q 13 4 address address VERB mp48sb41m1q 13 5 the the DET mp48sb41m1q 13 6 objection objection NOUN mp48sb41m1q 13 7 that that SCONJ mp48sb41m1q 13 8 nihilists nihilist NOUN mp48sb41m1q 13 9 are be AUX mp48sb41m1q 13 10 committed commit VERB mp48sb41m1q 13 11 to to ADP mp48sb41m1q 13 12 the the DET mp48sb41m1q 13 13 implausible implausible ADJ mp48sb41m1q 13 14 view view NOUN mp48sb41m1q 13 15 that that SCONJ mp48sb41m1q 13 16 we we PRON mp48sb41m1q 13 17 ( ( PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 13 18 you you PRON mp48sb41m1q 13 19 , , PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 13 20 me i PRON mp48sb41m1q 13 21 ) ) PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 13 22 do do AUX mp48sb41m1q 13 23 n't not PART mp48sb41m1q 13 24 exist exist VERB mp48sb41m1q 13 25 . . PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 14 1 i i PRON mp48sb41m1q 14 2 note note VERB mp48sb41m1q 14 3 that that SCONJ mp48sb41m1q 14 4 substance substance NOUN mp48sb41m1q 14 5 dualism dualism NOUN mp48sb41m1q 14 6 gets get VERB mp48sb41m1q 14 7 the the DET mp48sb41m1q 14 8 nihilist nihilist NOUN mp48sb41m1q 14 9 out out ADP mp48sb41m1q 14 10 of of ADP mp48sb41m1q 14 11 the the DET mp48sb41m1q 14 12 difficulty difficulty NOUN mp48sb41m1q 14 13 . . PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 15 1 while while SCONJ mp48sb41m1q 15 2 i i PRON mp48sb41m1q 15 3 am be AUX mp48sb41m1q 15 4 aware aware ADJ mp48sb41m1q 15 5 of of ADP mp48sb41m1q 15 6 no no DET mp48sb41m1q 15 7 good good ADJ mp48sb41m1q 15 8 arguments argument NOUN mp48sb41m1q 15 9 for for ADP mp48sb41m1q 15 10 substance substance NOUN mp48sb41m1q 15 11 dualism dualism NOUN mp48sb41m1q 15 12 , , PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 15 13 i i PRON mp48sb41m1q 15 14 note note VERB mp48sb41m1q 15 15 that that SCONJ mp48sb41m1q 15 16 every every DET mp48sb41m1q 15 17 popular popular ADJ mp48sb41m1q 15 18 argument argument NOUN mp48sb41m1q 15 19 against against ADP mp48sb41m1q 15 20 substance substance NOUN mp48sb41m1q 15 21 dualism dualism NOUN mp48sb41m1q 15 22 has have VERB mp48sb41m1q 15 23 a a DET mp48sb41m1q 15 24 parallel parallel ADJ mp48sb41m1q 15 25 argument argument NOUN mp48sb41m1q 15 26 against against ADP mp48sb41m1q 15 27 composition composition NOUN mp48sb41m1q 15 28 . . PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 16 1 accordingly accordingly ADV mp48sb41m1q 16 2 , , PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 16 3 you you PRON mp48sb41m1q 16 4 should should AUX mp48sb41m1q 16 5 not not PART mp48sb41m1q 16 6 reject reject VERB mp48sb41m1q 16 7 nihilism nihilism NOUN mp48sb41m1q 16 8 because because SCONJ mp48sb41m1q 16 9 you you PRON mp48sb41m1q 16 10 reject reject VERB mp48sb41m1q 16 11 substance substance NOUN mp48sb41m1q 16 12 dualism dualism NOUN mp48sb41m1q 16 13 . . PUNCT mp48sb41m1q 17 1 i i PRON mp48sb41m1q 17 2 end end VERB mp48sb41m1q 17 3 with with ADP mp48sb41m1q 17 4 an an DET mp48sb41m1q 17 5 appendix appendix ADJ mp48sb41m1q 17 6 defending defend VERB mp48sb41m1q 17 7 simplicity simplicity NOUN mp48sb41m1q 17 8 as as ADP mp48sb41m1q 17 9 a a DET mp48sb41m1q 17 10 criterion criterion NOUN mp48sb41m1q 17 11 of of ADP mp48sb41m1q 17 12 theory theory NOUN mp48sb41m1q 17 13 choice choice NOUN mp48sb41m1q 17 14 in in ADP mp48sb41m1q 17 15 metaphysics metaphysics NOUN mp48sb41m1q 17 16 . . PUNCT