id sid tid token lemma pos mk61rf58818 1 1 the the DET mk61rf58818 1 2 view view NOUN mk61rf58818 1 3 that that SCONJ mk61rf58818 1 4 happiness happiness NOUN mk61rf58818 1 5 consists consist VERB mk61rf58818 1 6 in in ADP mk61rf58818 1 7 virtuous virtuous ADJ mk61rf58818 1 8 action action NOUN mk61rf58818 1 9 is be AUX mk61rf58818 1 10 an an DET mk61rf58818 1 11 attractive attractive ADJ mk61rf58818 1 12 view view NOUN mk61rf58818 1 13 . . PUNCT mk61rf58818 2 1 a a DET mk61rf58818 2 2 relationship relationship NOUN mk61rf58818 2 3 to to ADP mk61rf58818 2 4 happiness happiness NOUN mk61rf58818 2 5 may may AUX mk61rf58818 2 6 help help VERB mk61rf58818 2 7 explain explain VERB mk61rf58818 2 8 , , PUNCT mk61rf58818 2 9 define define VERB mk61rf58818 2 10 and and CCONJ mk61rf58818 2 11 give give VERB mk61rf58818 2 12 distinctively distinctively ADV mk61rf58818 2 13 human human ADJ mk61rf58818 2 14 content content NOUN mk61rf58818 2 15 to to ADP mk61rf58818 2 16 the the DET mk61rf58818 2 17 virtues virtue NOUN mk61rf58818 2 18 , , PUNCT mk61rf58818 2 19 and and CCONJ mk61rf58818 2 20 may may AUX mk61rf58818 2 21 encourage encourage VERB mk61rf58818 2 22 us we PRON mk61rf58818 2 23 to to PART mk61rf58818 2 24 cultivate cultivate VERB mk61rf58818 2 25 virtue virtue NOUN mk61rf58818 2 26 . . PUNCT mk61rf58818 3 1 yet yet ADV mk61rf58818 3 2 many many ADJ mk61rf58818 3 3 virtue virtue ADJ mk61rf58818 3 4 theorists theorist NOUN mk61rf58818 3 5 today today NOUN mk61rf58818 3 6 are be AUX mk61rf58818 3 7 wary wary ADJ mk61rf58818 3 8 of of ADP mk61rf58818 3 9 this this DET mk61rf58818 3 10 view view NOUN mk61rf58818 3 11 . . PUNCT mk61rf58818 4 1 there there PRON mk61rf58818 4 2 is be VERB mk61rf58818 4 3 tension tension NOUN mk61rf58818 4 4 between between ADP mk61rf58818 4 5 ordinary ordinary ADJ mk61rf58818 4 6 notions notion NOUN mk61rf58818 4 7 of of ADP mk61rf58818 4 8 happiness happiness NOUN mk61rf58818 4 9 and and CCONJ mk61rf58818 4 10 virtue virtue NOUN mk61rf58818 4 11 . . PUNCT mk61rf58818 5 1 there there PRON mk61rf58818 5 2 is be VERB mk61rf58818 5 3 also also ADV mk61rf58818 5 4 concern concern NOUN mk61rf58818 5 5 that that SCONJ mk61rf58818 5 6 choosing choose VERB mk61rf58818 5 7 virtue virtue NOUN mk61rf58818 5 8 for for ADP mk61rf58818 5 9 the the DET mk61rf58818 5 10 sake sake NOUN mk61rf58818 5 11 of of ADP mk61rf58818 5 12 happiness happiness NOUN mk61rf58818 5 13 is be AUX mk61rf58818 5 14 inappropriate inappropriate ADJ mk61rf58818 5 15 . . PUNCT mk61rf58818 6 1 however however ADV mk61rf58818 6 2 , , PUNCT mk61rf58818 6 3 i i PRON mk61rf58818 6 4 defend defend VERB mk61rf58818 6 5 a a DET mk61rf58818 6 6 version version NOUN mk61rf58818 6 7 of of ADP mk61rf58818 6 8 the the DET mk61rf58818 6 9 claim claim NOUN mk61rf58818 6 10 that that SCONJ mk61rf58818 6 11 happiness happiness NOUN mk61rf58818 6 12 consists consist VERB mk61rf58818 6 13 in in ADP mk61rf58818 6 14 virtuous virtuous ADJ mk61rf58818 6 15 action action NOUN mk61rf58818 6 16 , , PUNCT mk61rf58818 6 17 and and CCONJ mk61rf58818 6 18 i i PRON mk61rf58818 6 19 show show VERB mk61rf58818 6 20 that that SCONJ mk61rf58818 6 21 when when SCONJ mk61rf58818 6 22 properly properly ADV mk61rf58818 6 23 understood understand VERB mk61rf58818 6 24 , , PUNCT mk61rf58818 6 25 happiness happiness NOUN mk61rf58818 6 26 is be AUX mk61rf58818 6 27 an an DET mk61rf58818 6 28 appropriate appropriate ADJ mk61rf58818 6 29 motive motive NOUN mk61rf58818 6 30 for for ADP mk61rf58818 6 31 virtuous virtuous ADJ mk61rf58818 6 32 action action NOUN mk61rf58818 6 33 . . PUNCT mk61rf58818 7 1 key key NOUN mk61rf58818 7 2 to to ADP mk61rf58818 7 3 my my PRON mk61rf58818 7 4 view view NOUN mk61rf58818 7 5 is be AUX mk61rf58818 7 6 an an DET mk61rf58818 7 7 account account NOUN mk61rf58818 7 8 of of ADP mk61rf58818 7 9 friendship friendship NOUN mk61rf58818 7 10 whereby whereby SCONJ mk61rf58818 7 11 actions action NOUN mk61rf58818 7 12 and and CCONJ mk61rf58818 7 13 the the DET mk61rf58818 7 14 happiness happiness NOUN mk61rf58818 7 15 they they PRON mk61rf58818 7 16 constitute constitute VERB mk61rf58818 7 17 are be AUX mk61rf58818 7 18 routinely routinely ADV mk61rf58818 7 19 shared share VERB mk61rf58818 7 20 . . PUNCT mk61rf58818 8 1 i i PRON mk61rf58818 8 2 analyze analyze VERB mk61rf58818 8 3 four four NUM mk61rf58818 8 4 competing compete VERB mk61rf58818 8 5 views view NOUN mk61rf58818 8 6 of of ADP mk61rf58818 8 7 the the DET mk61rf58818 8 8 relationship relationship NOUN mk61rf58818 8 9 between between ADP mk61rf58818 8 10 virtue virtue NOUN mk61rf58818 8 11 and and CCONJ mk61rf58818 8 12 happiness happiness NOUN mk61rf58818 8 13 . . PUNCT mk61rf58818 9 1 john john PROPN mk61rf58818 9 2 mcdowell mcdowell PROPN mk61rf58818 9 3 holds hold VERB mk61rf58818 9 4 that that SCONJ mk61rf58818 9 5 happiness happiness NOUN mk61rf58818 9 6 consists consist VERB mk61rf58818 9 7 in in ADP mk61rf58818 9 8 virtuous virtuous ADJ mk61rf58818 9 9 action action NOUN mk61rf58818 9 10 , , PUNCT mk61rf58818 9 11 performed perform VERB mk61rf58818 9 12 for for ADP mk61rf58818 9 13 its its PRON mk61rf58818 9 14 own own ADJ mk61rf58818 9 15 sake sake NOUN mk61rf58818 9 16 , , PUNCT mk61rf58818 9 17 and and CCONJ mk61rf58818 9 18 hence hence ADV mk61rf58818 9 19 is be AUX mk61rf58818 9 20 independent independent ADJ mk61rf58818 9 21 of of ADP mk61rf58818 9 22 goods good NOUN mk61rf58818 9 23 of of ADP mk61rf58818 9 24 fortune fortune NOUN mk61rf58818 9 25 , , PUNCT mk61rf58818 9 26 but but CCONJ mk61rf58818 9 27 this this DET mk61rf58818 9 28 view view NOUN mk61rf58818 9 29 is be AUX mk61rf58818 9 30 unrealistic unrealistic ADJ mk61rf58818 9 31 and and CCONJ mk61rf58818 9 32 encourages encourage VERB mk61rf58818 9 33 self self NOUN mk61rf58818 9 34 - - PUNCT mk61rf58818 9 35 absorption absorption NOUN mk61rf58818 9 36 . . PUNCT mk61rf58818 10 1 rosalind rosalind NOUN mk61rf58818 10 2 hursthouse hursthouse NOUN mk61rf58818 10 3 maintains maintain VERB mk61rf58818 10 4 that that SCONJ mk61rf58818 10 5 the the DET mk61rf58818 10 6 virtues virtue NOUN mk61rf58818 10 7 are be AUX mk61rf58818 10 8 conducive conducive ADJ mk61rf58818 10 9 to to ADP mk61rf58818 10 10 happiness happiness NOUN mk61rf58818 10 11 , , PUNCT mk61rf58818 10 12 but but CCONJ mk61rf58818 10 13 neither neither CCONJ mk61rf58818 10 14 necessary necessary ADJ mk61rf58818 10 15 nor nor CCONJ mk61rf58818 10 16 sufficient sufficient ADJ mk61rf58818 10 17 : : PUNCT mk61rf58818 10 18 happiness happiness NOUN mk61rf58818 10 19 consists consist VERB mk61rf58818 10 20 in in ADP mk61rf58818 10 21 goods good NOUN mk61rf58818 10 22 of of ADP mk61rf58818 10 23 fortune fortune NOUN mk61rf58818 10 24 . . PUNCT mk61rf58818 11 1 i i PRON mk61rf58818 11 2 argue argue VERB mk61rf58818 11 3 that that SCONJ mk61rf58818 11 4 tensions tension NOUN mk61rf58818 11 5 in in ADP mk61rf58818 11 6 hursthouse hursthouse NOUN mk61rf58818 11 7 's 's PART mk61rf58818 11 8 text text NOUN mk61rf58818 11 9 are be AUX mk61rf58818 11 10 better well ADV mk61rf58818 11 11 resolved resolve VERB mk61rf58818 11 12 by by ADP mk61rf58818 11 13 the the DET mk61rf58818 11 14 bicameral bicameral ADJ mk61rf58818 11 15 view view NOUN mk61rf58818 11 16 : : PUNCT mk61rf58818 11 17 happiness happiness NOUN mk61rf58818 11 18 consists consist VERB mk61rf58818 11 19 in in ADP mk61rf58818 11 20 virtuous virtuous ADJ mk61rf58818 11 21 action action NOUN mk61rf58818 11 22 , , PUNCT mk61rf58818 11 23 but but CCONJ mk61rf58818 11 24 one one PRON mk61rf58818 11 25 's 's PART mk61rf58818 11 26 ability ability NOUN mk61rf58818 11 27 to to PART mk61rf58818 11 28 act act VERB mk61rf58818 11 29 depends depend VERB mk61rf58818 11 30 on on ADP mk61rf58818 11 31 goods good NOUN mk61rf58818 11 32 of of ADP mk61rf58818 11 33 fortune fortune NOUN mk61rf58818 11 34 . . PUNCT mk61rf58818 12 1 richard richard PROPN mk61rf58818 12 2 kraut kraut PROPN mk61rf58818 12 3 's 's PART mk61rf58818 12 4 reading reading NOUN mk61rf58818 12 5 of of ADP mk61rf58818 12 6 aristotle aristotle PROPN mk61rf58818 12 7 yields yield VERB mk61rf58818 12 8 a a DET mk61rf58818 12 9 bicameral bicameral ADJ mk61rf58818 12 10 view view NOUN mk61rf58818 12 11 centered center VERB mk61rf58818 12 12 on on ADP mk61rf58818 12 13 contemplation contemplation NOUN mk61rf58818 12 14 , , PUNCT mk61rf58818 12 15 but but CCONJ mk61rf58818 12 16 this this PRON mk61rf58818 12 17 is be AUX mk61rf58818 12 18 overly overly ADV mk61rf58818 12 19 narrow narrow ADJ mk61rf58818 12 20 . . PUNCT mk61rf58818 13 1 the the DET mk61rf58818 13 2 perfectionist perfectionist ADJ mk61rf58818 13 3 view view NOUN mk61rf58818 13 4 , , PUNCT mk61rf58818 13 5 including include VERB mk61rf58818 13 6 ethically ethically ADV mk61rf58818 13 7 virtuous virtuous ADJ mk61rf58818 13 8 action action NOUN mk61rf58818 13 9 in in ADP mk61rf58818 13 10 happiness happiness NOUN mk61rf58818 13 11 , , PUNCT mk61rf58818 13 12 mitigates mitigate VERB mk61rf58818 13 13 the the DET mk61rf58818 13 14 self self NOUN mk61rf58818 13 15 - - PUNCT mk61rf58818 13 16 absorption absorption NOUN mk61rf58818 13 17 of of ADP mk61rf58818 13 18 mcdowell mcdowell PROPN mk61rf58818 13 19 's 's PART mk61rf58818 13 20 view view NOUN mk61rf58818 13 21 at at ADP mk61rf58818 13 22 the the DET mk61rf58818 13 23 cost cost NOUN mk61rf58818 13 24 of of ADP mk61rf58818 13 25 introducing introduce VERB mk61rf58818 13 26 unsavory unsavory ADJ mk61rf58818 13 27 competition competition NOUN mk61rf58818 13 28 for for ADP mk61rf58818 13 29 opportunities opportunity NOUN mk61rf58818 13 30 to to PART mk61rf58818 13 31 act act VERB mk61rf58818 13 32 . . PUNCT mk61rf58818 14 1 the the DET mk61rf58818 14 2 four four NUM mk61rf58818 14 3 preceding precede VERB mk61rf58818 14 4 views view NOUN mk61rf58818 14 5 construe construe VERB mk61rf58818 14 6 happiness happiness NOUN mk61rf58818 14 7 individualistically individualistically ADV mk61rf58818 14 8 . . PUNCT mk61rf58818 15 1 however however ADV mk61rf58818 15 2 , , PUNCT mk61rf58818 15 3 the the DET mk61rf58818 15 4 best good ADJ mk61rf58818 15 5 human human ADJ mk61rf58818 15 6 actions action NOUN mk61rf58818 15 7 can can AUX mk61rf58818 15 8 only only ADV mk61rf58818 15 9 be be AUX mk61rf58818 15 10 performed perform VERB mk61rf58818 15 11 in in ADP mk61rf58818 15 12 cooperation cooperation NOUN mk61rf58818 15 13 . . PUNCT mk61rf58818 16 1 actions action NOUN mk61rf58818 16 2 are be AUX mk61rf58818 16 3 shared share VERB mk61rf58818 16 4 through through ADP mk61rf58818 16 5 cooperation cooperation NOUN mk61rf58818 16 6 and and CCONJ mk61rf58818 16 7 , , PUNCT mk61rf58818 16 8 more more ADV mk61rf58818 16 9 importantly importantly ADV mk61rf58818 16 10 , , PUNCT mk61rf58818 16 11 shared share VERB mk61rf58818 16 12 choice choice NOUN mk61rf58818 16 13 . . PUNCT mk61rf58818 17 1 since since SCONJ mk61rf58818 17 2 happiness happiness NOUN mk61rf58818 17 3 consists consist VERB mk61rf58818 17 4 in in ADP mk61rf58818 17 5 actions action NOUN mk61rf58818 17 6 , , PUNCT mk61rf58818 17 7 happiness happiness NOUN mk61rf58818 17 8 too too ADV mk61rf58818 17 9 is be AUX mk61rf58818 17 10 often often ADV mk61rf58818 17 11 shared share VERB mk61rf58818 17 12 . . PUNCT mk61rf58818 18 1 shared share VERB mk61rf58818 18 2 action action NOUN mk61rf58818 18 3 overcomes overcome VERB mk61rf58818 18 4 the the DET mk61rf58818 18 5 self self NOUN mk61rf58818 18 6 - - PUNCT mk61rf58818 18 7 absorption absorption NOUN mk61rf58818 18 8 of of ADP mk61rf58818 18 9 mcdowell mcdowell PROPN mk61rf58818 18 10 's 's PART mk61rf58818 18 11 view view NOUN mk61rf58818 18 12 and and CCONJ mk61rf58818 18 13 the the DET mk61rf58818 18 14 competition competition NOUN mk61rf58818 18 15 of of ADP mk61rf58818 18 16 the the DET mk61rf58818 18 17 perfectionist perfectionist ADJ mk61rf58818 18 18 view view NOUN mk61rf58818 18 19 . . PUNCT mk61rf58818 19 1 in in ADP mk61rf58818 19 2 helping help VERB mk61rf58818 19 3 another another PRON mk61rf58818 19 4 to to PART mk61rf58818 19 5 act act VERB mk61rf58818 19 6 well well ADV mk61rf58818 19 7 , , PUNCT mk61rf58818 19 8 one one PRON mk61rf58818 19 9 participates participate VERB mk61rf58818 19 10 in in ADP mk61rf58818 19 11 her her PRON mk61rf58818 19 12 action action NOUN mk61rf58818 19 13 , , PUNCT mk61rf58818 19 14 rendering render VERB mk61rf58818 19 15 her her PRON mk61rf58818 19 16 action action NOUN mk61rf58818 19 17 constitutive constitutive ADJ mk61rf58818 19 18 of of ADP mk61rf58818 19 19 one one NOUN mk61rf58818 19 20 's 's PART mk61rf58818 19 21 own own ADJ mk61rf58818 19 22 happiness happiness NOUN mk61rf58818 19 23 as as ADV mk61rf58818 19 24 well well ADV mk61rf58818 19 25 as as ADP mk61rf58818 19 26 hers hers PRON mk61rf58818 19 27 . . PUNCT mk61rf58818 20 1 where where SCONJ mk61rf58818 20 2 one one PRON mk61rf58818 20 3 finds find VERB mk61rf58818 20 4 happiness happiness NOUN mk61rf58818 20 5 precisely precisely ADV mk61rf58818 20 6 in in ADP mk61rf58818 20 7 the the DET mk61rf58818 20 8 happiness happiness NOUN mk61rf58818 20 9 of of ADP mk61rf58818 20 10 another another PRON mk61rf58818 20 11 , , PUNCT mk61rf58818 20 12 one one PRON mk61rf58818 20 13 's 's PART mk61rf58818 20 14 happiness happiness NOUN mk61rf58818 20 15 is be AUX mk61rf58818 20 16 an an DET mk61rf58818 20 17 appropriate appropriate ADJ mk61rf58818 20 18 motive motive NOUN mk61rf58818 20 19 to to ADP mk61rf58818 20 20 virtue virtue NOUN mk61rf58818 20 21 . . PUNCT