id sid tid token lemma pos kh04dn42689 1 1 this this DET kh04dn42689 1 2 dissertation dissertation NOUN kh04dn42689 1 3 takes take VERB kh04dn42689 1 4 up up ADP kh04dn42689 1 5 the the DET kh04dn42689 1 6 project project NOUN kh04dn42689 1 7 of of ADP kh04dn42689 1 8 analyzing analyze VERB kh04dn42689 1 9 and and CCONJ kh04dn42689 1 10 evaluating evaluate VERB kh04dn42689 1 11 contemporary contemporary ADJ kh04dn42689 1 12 moral moral ADJ kh04dn42689 1 13 particularism particularism NOUN kh04dn42689 1 14 . . PUNCT kh04dn42689 2 1 moral moral ADJ kh04dn42689 2 2 particularism particularism NOUN kh04dn42689 2 3 is be AUX kh04dn42689 2 4 a a DET kh04dn42689 2 5 family family NOUN kh04dn42689 2 6 of of ADP kh04dn42689 2 7 views view NOUN kh04dn42689 2 8 --- --- PUNCT kh04dn42689 2 9 a a DET kh04dn42689 2 10 family family NOUN kh04dn42689 2 11 unified unify VERB kh04dn42689 2 12 by by ADP kh04dn42689 2 13 its its PRON kh04dn42689 2 14 rejection rejection NOUN kh04dn42689 2 15 of of ADP kh04dn42689 2 16 moral moral ADJ kh04dn42689 2 17 principles principle NOUN kh04dn42689 2 18 --- --- PUNCT kh04dn42689 2 19 in in ADP kh04dn42689 2 20 moral moral ADJ kh04dn42689 2 21 metaphysics metaphysics NOUN kh04dn42689 2 22 and and CCONJ kh04dn42689 2 23 moral moral ADJ kh04dn42689 2 24 epistemology epistemology NOUN kh04dn42689 2 25 . . PUNCT kh04dn42689 3 1 some some DET kh04dn42689 3 2 versions version NOUN kh04dn42689 3 3 of of ADP kh04dn42689 3 4 particularism particularism NOUN kh04dn42689 3 5 claim claim VERB kh04dn42689 3 6 that that SCONJ kh04dn42689 3 7 there there PRON kh04dn42689 3 8 are be VERB kh04dn42689 3 9 no no DET kh04dn42689 3 10 true true ADJ kh04dn42689 3 11 moral moral ADJ kh04dn42689 3 12 principles principle NOUN kh04dn42689 3 13 , , PUNCT kh04dn42689 3 14 while while SCONJ kh04dn42689 3 15 others other NOUN kh04dn42689 3 16 claim claim VERB kh04dn42689 3 17 that that SCONJ kh04dn42689 3 18 we we PRON kh04dn42689 3 19 should should AUX kh04dn42689 3 20 n't not PART kh04dn42689 3 21 use use VERB kh04dn42689 3 22 moral moral ADJ kh04dn42689 3 23 principles principle NOUN kh04dn42689 3 24 in in ADP kh04dn42689 3 25 moral moral ADJ kh04dn42689 3 26 deliberation deliberation NOUN kh04dn42689 3 27 ; ; PUNCT kh04dn42689 3 28 i i PRON kh04dn42689 3 29 call call VERB kh04dn42689 3 30 the the DET kh04dn42689 3 31 former former ADJ kh04dn42689 3 32 view view NOUN kh04dn42689 3 33 ' ' PUNCT kh04dn42689 3 34 eliminativism eliminativism NOUN kh04dn42689 3 35 ' ' PUNCT kh04dn42689 3 36 and and CCONJ kh04dn42689 3 37 the the DET kh04dn42689 3 38 latter latter ADJ kh04dn42689 3 39 view view NOUN kh04dn42689 3 40 ' ' PUNCT kh04dn42689 3 41 abstinence abstinence NOUN kh04dn42689 3 42 . . PUNCT kh04dn42689 3 43 ' ' PUNCT kh04dn42689 4 1 chapters chapter NOUN kh04dn42689 4 2 1 1 NUM kh04dn42689 4 3 - - SYM kh04dn42689 4 4 3 3 NUM kh04dn42689 4 5 concern concern NOUN kh04dn42689 4 6 eliminativism eliminativism NOUN kh04dn42689 4 7 . . PUNCT kh04dn42689 5 1 i i PRON kh04dn42689 5 2 argue argue VERB kh04dn42689 5 3 that that SCONJ kh04dn42689 5 4 contemporary contemporary ADJ kh04dn42689 5 5 presentations presentation NOUN kh04dn42689 5 6 of of ADP kh04dn42689 5 7 eliminativism eliminativism NOUN kh04dn42689 5 8 are be AUX kh04dn42689 5 9 inadequate inadequate ADJ kh04dn42689 5 10 on on ADP kh04dn42689 5 11 the the DET kh04dn42689 5 12 grounds ground NOUN kh04dn42689 5 13 that that SCONJ kh04dn42689 5 14 they they PRON kh04dn42689 5 15 do do AUX kh04dn42689 5 16 not not PART kh04dn42689 5 17 make make VERB kh04dn42689 5 18 clear clear ADJ kh04dn42689 5 19 how how SCONJ kh04dn42689 5 20 eliminativism eliminativism NOUN kh04dn42689 5 21 is be AUX kh04dn42689 5 22 compatible compatible ADJ kh04dn42689 5 23 with with ADP kh04dn42689 5 24 the the DET kh04dn42689 5 25 supervenience supervenience NOUN kh04dn42689 5 26 of of ADP kh04dn42689 5 27 moral moral ADJ kh04dn42689 5 28 on on ADP kh04dn42689 5 29 descriptive descriptive ADJ kh04dn42689 5 30 properties property NOUN kh04dn42689 5 31 . . PUNCT kh04dn42689 6 1 however however ADV kh04dn42689 6 2 , , PUNCT kh04dn42689 6 3 i i PRON kh04dn42689 6 4 also also ADV kh04dn42689 6 5 present present VERB kh04dn42689 6 6 an an DET kh04dn42689 6 7 overlooked overlook VERB kh04dn42689 6 8 version version NOUN kh04dn42689 6 9 of of ADP kh04dn42689 6 10 eliminativism eliminativism NOUN kh04dn42689 6 11 --- --- PUNCT kh04dn42689 6 12 a a DET kh04dn42689 6 13 version version NOUN kh04dn42689 6 14 i i PRON kh04dn42689 6 15 call call VERB kh04dn42689 6 16 ' ' PUNCT kh04dn42689 6 17 incompactness incompactness NOUN kh04dn42689 6 18 eliminativism'---that eliminativism'---that PRON kh04dn42689 6 19 avoids avoid VERB kh04dn42689 6 20 the the DET kh04dn42689 6 21 problems problem NOUN kh04dn42689 6 22 faced face VERB kh04dn42689 6 23 by by ADP kh04dn42689 6 24 other other ADJ kh04dn42689 6 25 versions version NOUN kh04dn42689 6 26 . . PUNCT kh04dn42689 7 1 i i PRON kh04dn42689 7 2 examine examine VERB kh04dn42689 7 3 how how SCONJ kh04dn42689 7 4 an an DET kh04dn42689 7 5 incompactness incompactness ADJ kh04dn42689 7 6 eliminativist eliminativist NOUN kh04dn42689 7 7 can can AUX kh04dn42689 7 8 respond respond VERB kh04dn42689 7 9 to to ADP kh04dn42689 7 10 typical typical ADJ kh04dn42689 7 11 objections objection NOUN kh04dn42689 7 12 posed pose VERB kh04dn42689 7 13 to to ADP kh04dn42689 7 14 particularism particularism NOUN kh04dn42689 7 15 , , PUNCT kh04dn42689 7 16 and and CCONJ kh04dn42689 7 17 i i PRON kh04dn42689 7 18 thereby thereby ADV kh04dn42689 7 19 show show VERB kh04dn42689 7 20 that that SCONJ kh04dn42689 7 21 incompactness incompactness ADJ kh04dn42689 7 22 eliminativism eliminativism NOUN kh04dn42689 7 23 is be AUX kh04dn42689 7 24 both both PRON kh04dn42689 7 25 coherent coherent ADJ kh04dn42689 7 26 and and CCONJ kh04dn42689 7 27 defensible defensible ADJ kh04dn42689 7 28 . . PUNCT kh04dn42689 8 1 i i PRON kh04dn42689 8 2 also also ADV kh04dn42689 8 3 explore explore VERB kh04dn42689 8 4 how how SCONJ kh04dn42689 8 5 an an DET kh04dn42689 8 6 incompactness incompactness ADJ kh04dn42689 8 7 eliminativist eliminativist NOUN kh04dn42689 8 8 can can AUX kh04dn42689 8 9 provide provide VERB kh04dn42689 8 10 positive positive ADJ kh04dn42689 8 11 motivation motivation NOUN kh04dn42689 8 12 for for ADP kh04dn42689 8 13 her her PRON kh04dn42689 8 14 view view NOUN kh04dn42689 8 15 . . PUNCT kh04dn42689 9 1 i i PRON kh04dn42689 9 2 show show VERB kh04dn42689 9 3 that that SCONJ kh04dn42689 9 4 one one NUM kh04dn42689 9 5 promising promising ADJ kh04dn42689 9 6 strategy strategy NOUN kh04dn42689 9 7 is be AUX kh04dn42689 9 8 to to PART kh04dn42689 9 9 use use VERB kh04dn42689 9 10 an an DET kh04dn42689 9 11 argument argument NOUN kh04dn42689 9 12 from from ADP kh04dn42689 9 13 ' ' PUNCT kh04dn42689 9 14 radical radical ADJ kh04dn42689 9 15 holism holism NOUN kh04dn42689 9 16 ' ' PUNCT kh04dn42689 9 17 and and CCONJ kh04dn42689 9 18 develop develop VERB kh04dn42689 9 19 a a DET kh04dn42689 9 20 normative normative ADJ kh04dn42689 9 21 theory theory NOUN kh04dn42689 9 22 ( ( PUNCT kh04dn42689 9 23 of of ADP kh04dn42689 9 24 a a DET kh04dn42689 9 25 certain certain ADJ kh04dn42689 9 26 structure structure NOUN kh04dn42689 9 27 ) ) PUNCT kh04dn42689 9 28 in in ADP kh04dn42689 9 29 order order NOUN kh04dn42689 9 30 to to PART kh04dn42689 9 31 support support VERB kh04dn42689 9 32 the the DET kh04dn42689 9 33 premises premise NOUN kh04dn42689 9 34 of of ADP kh04dn42689 9 35 that that DET kh04dn42689 9 36 argument argument NOUN kh04dn42689 9 37 . . PUNCT kh04dn42689 10 1 thus thus ADV kh04dn42689 10 2 , , PUNCT kh04dn42689 10 3 it it PRON kh04dn42689 10 4 turns turn VERB kh04dn42689 10 5 out out ADP kh04dn42689 10 6 that that SCONJ kh04dn42689 10 7 although although SCONJ kh04dn42689 10 8 eliminativism eliminativism NOUN kh04dn42689 10 9 places place VERB kh04dn42689 10 10 some some DET kh04dn42689 10 11 constraints constraint NOUN kh04dn42689 10 12 on on ADP kh04dn42689 10 13 what what PRON kh04dn42689 10 14 kind kind NOUN kh04dn42689 10 15 of of ADP kh04dn42689 10 16 normative normative ADJ kh04dn42689 10 17 theory theory NOUN kh04dn42689 10 18 one one PRON kh04dn42689 10 19 can can AUX kh04dn42689 10 20 accept accept VERB kh04dn42689 10 21 , , PUNCT kh04dn42689 10 22 one one PRON kh04dn42689 10 23 must must AUX kh04dn42689 10 24 at at ADP kh04dn42689 10 25 least least ADJ kh04dn42689 10 26 partially partially ADV kh04dn42689 10 27 develop develop VERB kh04dn42689 10 28 a a DET kh04dn42689 10 29 normative normative ADJ kh04dn42689 10 30 theory theory NOUN kh04dn42689 10 31 in in ADP kh04dn42689 10 32 order order NOUN kh04dn42689 10 33 to to PART kh04dn42689 10 34 motivate motivate VERB kh04dn42689 10 35 eliminativism eliminativism NOUN kh04dn42689 10 36 in in ADP kh04dn42689 10 37 the the DET kh04dn42689 10 38 first first ADJ kh04dn42689 10 39 place place NOUN kh04dn42689 10 40 . . PUNCT kh04dn42689 11 1 the the DET kh04dn42689 11 2 fourth fourth ADJ kh04dn42689 11 3 and and CCONJ kh04dn42689 11 4 final final ADJ kh04dn42689 11 5 chapter chapter NOUN kh04dn42689 11 6 addresses address NOUN kh04dn42689 11 7 abstinence abstinence NOUN kh04dn42689 11 8 . . PUNCT kh04dn42689 12 1 i i PRON kh04dn42689 12 2 argue argue VERB kh04dn42689 12 3 that that SCONJ kh04dn42689 12 4 those those PRON kh04dn42689 12 5 who who PRON kh04dn42689 12 6 accept accept VERB kh04dn42689 12 7 incompactness incompactness ADJ kh04dn42689 12 8 eliminativism eliminativism NOUN kh04dn42689 12 9 should should AUX kh04dn42689 12 10 not not PART kh04dn42689 12 11 accept accept VERB kh04dn42689 12 12 abstinence abstinence NOUN kh04dn42689 12 13 . . PUNCT kh04dn42689 13 1 i i PRON kh04dn42689 13 2 do do VERB kh04dn42689 13 3 this this PRON kh04dn42689 13 4 by by ADP kh04dn42689 13 5 showing show VERB kh04dn42689 13 6 that that SCONJ kh04dn42689 13 7 abstinence abstinence NOUN kh04dn42689 13 8 entails entail VERB kh04dn42689 13 9 a a DET kh04dn42689 13 10 commitment commitment NOUN kh04dn42689 13 11 to to ADP kh04dn42689 13 12 a a DET kh04dn42689 13 13 strong strong ADJ kh04dn42689 13 14 form form NOUN kh04dn42689 13 15 of of ADP kh04dn42689 13 16 intuitionism intuitionism NOUN kh04dn42689 13 17 , , PUNCT kh04dn42689 13 18 and and CCONJ kh04dn42689 13 19 that that SCONJ kh04dn42689 13 20 extant extant ADJ kh04dn42689 13 21 attempts attempt VERB kh04dn42689 13 22 to to PART kh04dn42689 13 23 defend defend VERB kh04dn42689 13 24 the the DET kh04dn42689 13 25 plausibility plausibility NOUN kh04dn42689 13 26 of of ADP kh04dn42689 13 27 such such DET kh04dn42689 13 28 an an DET kh04dn42689 13 29 intuitionism intuitionism NOUN kh04dn42689 13 30 require require VERB kh04dn42689 13 31 models model NOUN kh04dn42689 13 32 of of ADP kh04dn42689 13 33 moral moral ADJ kh04dn42689 13 34 reasoning reasoning NOUN kh04dn42689 13 35 that that PRON kh04dn42689 13 36 are be AUX kh04dn42689 13 37 incompatible incompatible ADJ kh04dn42689 13 38 with with ADP kh04dn42689 13 39 incompactness incompactness ADJ kh04dn42689 13 40 eliminativism eliminativism NOUN kh04dn42689 13 41 . . PUNCT kh04dn42689 14 1 however however ADV kh04dn42689 14 2 , , PUNCT kh04dn42689 14 3 i i PRON kh04dn42689 14 4 develop develop VERB kh04dn42689 14 5 another another DET kh04dn42689 14 6 model model NOUN kh04dn42689 14 7 of of ADP kh04dn42689 14 8 praiseworthy praiseworthy ADJ kh04dn42689 14 9 moral moral ADJ kh04dn42689 14 10 deliberation deliberation NOUN kh04dn42689 14 11 that that PRON kh04dn42689 14 12 the the DET kh04dn42689 14 13 eliminativist eliminativist NOUN kh04dn42689 14 14 can can AUX kh04dn42689 14 15 accept accept VERB kh04dn42689 14 16 , , PUNCT kh04dn42689 14 17 one one NUM kh04dn42689 14 18 according accord VERB kh04dn42689 14 19 to to ADP kh04dn42689 14 20 which which PRON kh04dn42689 14 21 good good ADJ kh04dn42689 14 22 moral moral ADJ kh04dn42689 14 23 deliberation deliberation NOUN kh04dn42689 14 24 can can AUX kh04dn42689 14 25 involve involve VERB kh04dn42689 14 26 the the DET kh04dn42689 14 27 responsible responsible ADJ kh04dn42689 14 28 use use NOUN kh04dn42689 14 29 of of ADP kh04dn42689 14 30 ' ' PUNCT kh04dn42689 14 31 rules rule NOUN kh04dn42689 14 32 of of ADP kh04dn42689 14 33 thumb thumb NOUN kh04dn42689 14 34 . . PUNCT kh04dn42689 14 35 ' ' PUNCT