id sid tid token lemma pos k0698625s1d 1 1 this this DET k0698625s1d 1 2 dissertation dissertation NOUN k0698625s1d 1 3 explores explore VERB k0698625s1d 1 4 the the DET k0698625s1d 1 5 existence existence NOUN k0698625s1d 1 6 and and CCONJ k0698625s1d 1 7 extent extent NOUN k0698625s1d 1 8 of of ADP k0698625s1d 1 9 political political ADJ k0698625s1d 1 10 equality equality NOUN k0698625s1d 1 11 by by ADP k0698625s1d 1 12 race race NOUN k0698625s1d 1 13 , , PUNCT k0698625s1d 1 14 gender gender NOUN k0698625s1d 1 15 , , PUNCT k0698625s1d 1 16 and and CCONJ k0698625s1d 1 17 education education NOUN k0698625s1d 1 18 within within ADP k0698625s1d 1 19 democratic democratic ADJ k0698625s1d 1 20 deliberation deliberation NOUN k0698625s1d 1 21 . . PUNCT k0698625s1d 2 1 though though SCONJ k0698625s1d 2 2 deliberation deliberation NOUN k0698625s1d 2 3 has have AUX k0698625s1d 2 4 rapidly rapidly ADV k0698625s1d 2 5 grown grow VERB k0698625s1d 2 6 to to ADP k0698625s1d 2 7 prominence prominence NOUN k0698625s1d 2 8 in in ADP k0698625s1d 2 9 academic academic ADJ k0698625s1d 2 10 political political ADJ k0698625s1d 2 11 science science NOUN k0698625s1d 2 12 and and CCONJ k0698625s1d 2 13 practical practical ADJ k0698625s1d 2 14 politics politic NOUN k0698625s1d 2 15 over over ADP k0698625s1d 2 16 the the DET k0698625s1d 2 17 last last ADJ k0698625s1d 2 18 few few ADJ k0698625s1d 2 19 decades decade NOUN k0698625s1d 2 20 , , PUNCT k0698625s1d 2 21 critics critic NOUN k0698625s1d 2 22 have have AUX k0698625s1d 2 23 charged charge VERB k0698625s1d 2 24 that that SCONJ k0698625s1d 2 25 members member NOUN k0698625s1d 2 26 of of ADP k0698625s1d 2 27 traditionally traditionally ADV k0698625s1d 2 28 disempowered disempowered ADJ k0698625s1d 2 29 groups group NOUN k0698625s1d 2 30 are be AUX k0698625s1d 2 31 likely likely ADJ k0698625s1d 2 32 to to PART k0698625s1d 2 33 be be AUX k0698625s1d 2 34 marginalized marginalize VERB k0698625s1d 2 35 within within ADP k0698625s1d 2 36 deliberation deliberation NOUN k0698625s1d 2 37 . . PUNCT k0698625s1d 3 1 yet yet ADV k0698625s1d 3 2 , , PUNCT k0698625s1d 3 3 little little ADJ k0698625s1d 3 4 empirical empirical ADJ k0698625s1d 3 5 analysis analysis NOUN k0698625s1d 3 6 has have AUX k0698625s1d 3 7 tackled tackle VERB k0698625s1d 3 8 the the DET k0698625s1d 3 9 important important ADJ k0698625s1d 3 10 task task NOUN k0698625s1d 3 11 of of ADP k0698625s1d 3 12 judging judge VERB k0698625s1d 3 13 this this DET k0698625s1d 3 14 critique critique NOUN k0698625s1d 3 15 . . PUNCT k0698625s1d 4 1 i i PRON k0698625s1d 4 2 argue argue VERB k0698625s1d 4 3 that that SCONJ k0698625s1d 4 4 providing provide VERB k0698625s1d 4 5 a a DET k0698625s1d 4 6 fuller fuller ADJ k0698625s1d 4 7 empirical empirical ADJ k0698625s1d 4 8 evaluation evaluation NOUN k0698625s1d 4 9 of of ADP k0698625s1d 4 10 political political ADJ k0698625s1d 4 11 equality equality NOUN k0698625s1d 4 12 on on ADP k0698625s1d 4 13 demographic demographic ADJ k0698625s1d 4 14 dimensions dimension NOUN k0698625s1d 4 15 is be AUX k0698625s1d 4 16 a a DET k0698625s1d 4 17 crucial crucial ADJ k0698625s1d 4 18 step step NOUN k0698625s1d 4 19 in in ADP k0698625s1d 4 20 developing develop VERB k0698625s1d 4 21 our our PRON k0698625s1d 4 22 understanding understanding NOUN k0698625s1d 4 23 of of ADP k0698625s1d 4 24 democratic democratic ADJ k0698625s1d 4 25 deliberation deliberation NOUN k0698625s1d 4 26 . . PUNCT k0698625s1d 5 1 i i PRON k0698625s1d 5 2 evaluate evaluate VERB k0698625s1d 5 3 political political ADJ k0698625s1d 5 4 equality equality NOUN k0698625s1d 5 5 within within ADP k0698625s1d 5 6 deliberation deliberation NOUN k0698625s1d 5 7 by by ADP k0698625s1d 5 8 analyzing analyze VERB k0698625s1d 5 9 participants participant NOUN k0698625s1d 5 10 ' ' PART k0698625s1d 5 11 attitudes attitude NOUN k0698625s1d 5 12 about about ADP k0698625s1d 5 13 the the DET k0698625s1d 5 14 process process NOUN k0698625s1d 5 15 of of ADP k0698625s1d 5 16 the the DET k0698625s1d 5 17 deliberation deliberation NOUN k0698625s1d 5 18 itself itself PRON k0698625s1d 5 19 and and CCONJ k0698625s1d 5 20 their their PRON k0698625s1d 5 21 opinion opinion NOUN k0698625s1d 5 22 change change NOUN k0698625s1d 5 23 over over ADP k0698625s1d 5 24 the the DET k0698625s1d 5 25 course course NOUN k0698625s1d 5 26 of of ADP k0698625s1d 5 27 the the DET k0698625s1d 5 28 deliberation deliberation NOUN k0698625s1d 5 29 in in ADP k0698625s1d 5 30 two two NUM k0698625s1d 5 31 deliberative deliberative ADJ k0698625s1d 5 32 poll poll NOUN k0698625s1d 5 33 datasets dataset NOUN k0698625s1d 5 34 from from ADP k0698625s1d 5 35 2004 2004 NUM k0698625s1d 5 36 . . PUNCT k0698625s1d 6 1 in in ADP k0698625s1d 6 2 particular particular ADJ k0698625s1d 6 3 , , PUNCT k0698625s1d 6 4 i i PRON k0698625s1d 6 5 test test VERB k0698625s1d 6 6 whether whether SCONJ k0698625s1d 6 7 women woman NOUN k0698625s1d 6 8 , , PUNCT k0698625s1d 6 9 african african ADJ k0698625s1d 6 10 americans americans PROPN k0698625s1d 6 11 , , PUNCT k0698625s1d 6 12 and and CCONJ k0698625s1d 6 13 the the DET k0698625s1d 6 14 less less ADV k0698625s1d 6 15 educated educate VERB k0698625s1d 6 16 find find VERB k0698625s1d 6 17 the the DET k0698625s1d 6 18 deliberative deliberative ADJ k0698625s1d 6 19 process process NOUN k0698625s1d 6 20 more more ADV k0698625s1d 6 21 useful useful ADJ k0698625s1d 6 22 , , PUNCT k0698625s1d 6 23 feel feel VERB k0698625s1d 6 24 less less ADV k0698625s1d 6 25 respected respected ADJ k0698625s1d 6 26 and and CCONJ k0698625s1d 6 27 efficacious efficacious ADJ k0698625s1d 6 28 , , PUNCT k0698625s1d 6 29 and and CCONJ k0698625s1d 6 30 are be AUX k0698625s1d 6 31 more more ADV k0698625s1d 6 32 likely likely ADJ k0698625s1d 6 33 to to PART k0698625s1d 6 34 be be AUX k0698625s1d 6 35 influenced influence VERB k0698625s1d 6 36 by by ADP k0698625s1d 6 37 the the DET k0698625s1d 6 38 presence presence NOUN k0698625s1d 6 39 and and CCONJ k0698625s1d 6 40 opinion opinion NOUN k0698625s1d 6 41 of of ADP k0698625s1d 6 42 others other NOUN k0698625s1d 6 43 . . PUNCT k0698625s1d 7 1 i i PRON k0698625s1d 7 2 find find VERB k0698625s1d 7 3 that that SCONJ k0698625s1d 7 4 members member NOUN k0698625s1d 7 5 of of ADP k0698625s1d 7 6 these these DET k0698625s1d 7 7 groups group NOUN k0698625s1d 7 8 are be AUX k0698625s1d 7 9 more more ADV k0698625s1d 7 10 likely likely ADJ k0698625s1d 7 11 to to PART k0698625s1d 7 12 find find VERB k0698625s1d 7 13 deliberation deliberation NOUN k0698625s1d 7 14 useful useful ADJ k0698625s1d 7 15 in in ADP k0698625s1d 7 16 helping help VERB k0698625s1d 7 17 them they PRON k0698625s1d 7 18 clarify clarify VERB k0698625s1d 7 19 issue issue NOUN k0698625s1d 7 20 attitudes attitude NOUN k0698625s1d 7 21 , , PUNCT k0698625s1d 7 22 and and CCONJ k0698625s1d 7 23 that that SCONJ k0698625s1d 7 24 african african ADJ k0698625s1d 7 25 americans americans PROPN k0698625s1d 7 26 are be AUX k0698625s1d 7 27 more more ADV k0698625s1d 7 28 likely likely ADJ k0698625s1d 7 29 than than ADP k0698625s1d 7 30 other other ADJ k0698625s1d 7 31 racial racial ADJ k0698625s1d 7 32 groups group NOUN k0698625s1d 7 33 to to PART k0698625s1d 7 34 feel feel VERB k0698625s1d 7 35 efficacious efficacious ADJ k0698625s1d 7 36 within within ADP k0698625s1d 7 37 small small ADJ k0698625s1d 7 38 groups group NOUN k0698625s1d 7 39 . . PUNCT k0698625s1d 8 1 there there PRON k0698625s1d 8 2 is be VERB k0698625s1d 8 3 some some DET k0698625s1d 8 4 evidence evidence NOUN k0698625s1d 8 5 that that SCONJ k0698625s1d 8 6 women woman NOUN k0698625s1d 8 7 feel feel VERB k0698625s1d 8 8 less less ADV k0698625s1d 8 9 efficacious efficacious ADJ k0698625s1d 8 10 and and CCONJ k0698625s1d 8 11 non non ADJ k0698625s1d 8 12 - - ADJ k0698625s1d 8 13 college college ADJ k0698625s1d 8 14 graduates graduate NOUN k0698625s1d 8 15 less less ADV k0698625s1d 8 16 respected respect VERB k0698625s1d 8 17 , , PUNCT k0698625s1d 8 18 but but CCONJ k0698625s1d 8 19 these these DET k0698625s1d 8 20 attitudes attitude NOUN k0698625s1d 8 21 do do AUX k0698625s1d 8 22 not not PART k0698625s1d 8 23 appear appear VERB k0698625s1d 8 24 to to PART k0698625s1d 8 25 affect affect VERB k0698625s1d 8 26 participantsì¢ participantsì¢ NOUN k0698625s1d 8 27 ââ ââ NOUN k0698625s1d 8 28 ü ü NOUN k0698625s1d 8 29 judgments judgment NOUN k0698625s1d 8 30 of of ADP k0698625s1d 8 31 the the DET k0698625s1d 8 32 usefulness usefulness NOUN k0698625s1d 8 33 of of ADP k0698625s1d 8 34 deliberation deliberation NOUN k0698625s1d 8 35 . . PUNCT k0698625s1d 9 1 contrary contrary ADJ k0698625s1d 9 2 to to ADP k0698625s1d 9 3 expectations expectation NOUN k0698625s1d 9 4 drawn draw VERB k0698625s1d 9 5 from from ADP k0698625s1d 9 6 a a DET k0698625s1d 9 7 body body NOUN k0698625s1d 9 8 of of ADP k0698625s1d 9 9 research research NOUN k0698625s1d 9 10 on on ADP k0698625s1d 9 11 small small ADJ k0698625s1d 9 12 group group NOUN k0698625s1d 9 13 settings setting NOUN k0698625s1d 9 14 , , PUNCT k0698625s1d 9 15 there there PRON k0698625s1d 9 16 is be VERB k0698625s1d 9 17 little little ADJ k0698625s1d 9 18 evidence evidence NOUN k0698625s1d 9 19 of of ADP k0698625s1d 9 20 an an DET k0698625s1d 9 21 effect effect NOUN k0698625s1d 9 22 of of ADP k0698625s1d 9 23 group group NOUN k0698625s1d 9 24 composition composition NOUN k0698625s1d 9 25 on on ADP k0698625s1d 9 26 attitude attitude NOUN k0698625s1d 9 27 change change VERB k0698625s1d 9 28 during during ADP k0698625s1d 9 29 the the DET k0698625s1d 9 30 deliberation deliberation NOUN k0698625s1d 9 31 . . PUNCT k0698625s1d 10 1 these these DET k0698625s1d 10 2 results result NOUN k0698625s1d 10 3 provide provide VERB k0698625s1d 10 4 one one NUM k0698625s1d 10 5 of of ADP k0698625s1d 10 6 the the DET k0698625s1d 10 7 first first ADJ k0698625s1d 10 8 extensive extensive ADJ k0698625s1d 10 9 empirical empirical ADJ k0698625s1d 10 10 evaluations evaluation NOUN k0698625s1d 10 11 of of ADP k0698625s1d 10 12 political political ADJ k0698625s1d 10 13 equality equality NOUN k0698625s1d 10 14 along along ADP k0698625s1d 10 15 demographic demographic ADJ k0698625s1d 10 16 dimensions dimension NOUN k0698625s1d 10 17 within within ADP k0698625s1d 10 18 deliberation deliberation NOUN k0698625s1d 10 19 . . PUNCT k0698625s1d 11 1 they they PRON k0698625s1d 11 2 reveal reveal VERB k0698625s1d 11 3 that that SCONJ k0698625s1d 11 4 ì¢ ì¢ NUM k0698625s1d 11 5 ââ ââ NOUN k0698625s1d 11 6 ' ' PUNCT k0698625s1d 11 7 within within ADP k0698625s1d 11 8 the the DET k0698625s1d 11 9 deliberative deliberative ADJ k0698625s1d 11 10 polls poll NOUN k0698625s1d 11 11 ì¢ ì¢ VERB k0698625s1d 11 12 ââ ââ NOUN k0698625s1d 11 13 ' ' PUNCT k0698625s1d 11 14 criticsì¢ criticsì¢ NUM k0698625s1d 11 15 ââ ââ NOUN k0698625s1d 11 16 ü ü PROPN k0698625s1d 11 17 fears fear VERB k0698625s1d 11 18 about about ADP k0698625s1d 11 19 marginalization marginalization NOUN k0698625s1d 11 20 do do AUX k0698625s1d 11 21 not not PART k0698625s1d 11 22 appear appear VERB k0698625s1d 11 23 to to PART k0698625s1d 11 24 be be AUX k0698625s1d 11 25 borne bear VERB k0698625s1d 11 26 out out ADP k0698625s1d 11 27 . . PUNCT k0698625s1d 12 1 i i PRON k0698625s1d 12 2 argue argue VERB k0698625s1d 12 3 that that SCONJ k0698625s1d 12 4 these these DET k0698625s1d 12 5 results result NOUN k0698625s1d 12 6 should should AUX k0698625s1d 12 7 guide guide VERB k0698625s1d 12 8 further further ADJ k0698625s1d 12 9 empirical empirical ADJ k0698625s1d 12 10 analysis analysis NOUN k0698625s1d 12 11 of of ADP k0698625s1d 12 12 political political ADJ k0698625s1d 12 13 equality equality NOUN k0698625s1d 12 14 within within ADP k0698625s1d 12 15 deliberation deliberation NOUN k0698625s1d 12 16 , , PUNCT k0698625s1d 12 17 can can AUX k0698625s1d 12 18 advise advise VERB k0698625s1d 12 19 practitioners practitioner NOUN k0698625s1d 12 20 in in ADP k0698625s1d 12 21 constructing construct VERB k0698625s1d 12 22 deliberative deliberative ADJ k0698625s1d 12 23 bodies body NOUN k0698625s1d 12 24 , , PUNCT k0698625s1d 12 25 and and CCONJ k0698625s1d 12 26 suggest suggest VERB k0698625s1d 12 27 that that SCONJ k0698625s1d 12 28 traditionally traditionally ADV k0698625s1d 12 29 disempowered disempowered ADJ k0698625s1d 12 30 groups group NOUN k0698625s1d 12 31 can can AUX k0698625s1d 12 32 be be AUX k0698625s1d 12 33 successfully successfully ADV k0698625s1d 12 34 integrated integrate VERB k0698625s1d 12 35 into into ADP k0698625s1d 12 36 democratic democratic ADJ k0698625s1d 12 37 deliberation deliberation NOUN k0698625s1d 12 38 without without ADP k0698625s1d 12 39 the the DET k0698625s1d 12 40 aid aid NOUN k0698625s1d 12 41 of of ADP k0698625s1d 12 42 ' ' PUNCT k0698625s1d 12 43 enclaves enclave NOUN k0698625s1d 12 44 . . PUNCT k0698625s1d 12 45 ' ' PUNCT