id sid tid token lemma pos gm80ht27413 1 1 in in ADP gm80ht27413 1 2 this this DET gm80ht27413 1 3 dissertation dissertation NOUN gm80ht27413 1 4 we we PRON gm80ht27413 1 5 will will AUX gm80ht27413 1 6 examine examine VERB gm80ht27413 1 7 the the DET gm80ht27413 1 8 philosophical philosophical ADJ gm80ht27413 1 9 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 1 10 theological theological ADJ gm80ht27413 1 11 projects project NOUN gm80ht27413 1 12 of of ADP gm80ht27413 1 13 emmanuel emmanuel PROPN gm80ht27413 1 14 lì lì PROPN gm80ht27413 1 15 © © PROPN gm80ht27413 1 16 vinas vina NOUN gm80ht27413 1 17 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 1 18 johann johann PROPN gm80ht27413 1 19 baptist baptist NOUN gm80ht27413 1 20 metz metz VERB gm80ht27413 1 21 as as ADP gm80ht27413 1 22 discourses discourse NOUN gm80ht27413 1 23 involved involve VERB gm80ht27413 1 24 in in ADP gm80ht27413 1 25 the the DET gm80ht27413 1 26 remembrance remembrance NOUN gm80ht27413 1 27 of of ADP gm80ht27413 1 28 the the DET gm80ht27413 1 29 prophetic prophetic ADJ gm80ht27413 1 30 jewish jewish ADJ gm80ht27413 1 31 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 1 32 christian christian ADJ gm80ht27413 1 33 roots root NOUN gm80ht27413 1 34 of of ADP gm80ht27413 1 35 western western ADJ gm80ht27413 1 36 thought thought NOUN gm80ht27413 1 37 in in ADP gm80ht27413 1 38 response response NOUN gm80ht27413 1 39 to to ADP gm80ht27413 1 40 the the DET gm80ht27413 1 41 persecution persecution NOUN gm80ht27413 1 42 of of ADP gm80ht27413 1 43 the the DET gm80ht27413 1 44 jewish jewish ADJ gm80ht27413 1 45 people people NOUN gm80ht27413 1 46 during during ADP gm80ht27413 1 47 the the DET gm80ht27413 1 48 shoah shoah NOUN gm80ht27413 1 49 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 1 50 more more ADV gm80ht27413 1 51 broadly broadly ADV gm80ht27413 1 52 to to ADP gm80ht27413 1 53 any any DET gm80ht27413 1 54 persecution persecution NOUN gm80ht27413 1 55 or or CCONJ gm80ht27413 1 56 oppression oppression NOUN gm80ht27413 1 57 of of ADP gm80ht27413 1 58 the the DET gm80ht27413 1 59 other other ADJ gm80ht27413 1 60 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 2 1 as as ADP gm80ht27413 2 2 a a DET gm80ht27413 2 3 consequence consequence NOUN gm80ht27413 2 4 of of ADP gm80ht27413 2 5 this this DET gm80ht27413 2 6 focus focus NOUN gm80ht27413 2 7 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 2 8 lì lì X gm80ht27413 2 9 © © X gm80ht27413 2 10 vinas vina NOUN gm80ht27413 2 11 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 2 12 metz metz PROPN gm80ht27413 2 13 are be AUX gm80ht27413 2 14 particularly particularly ADV gm80ht27413 2 15 concerned concerned ADJ gm80ht27413 2 16 to to PART gm80ht27413 2 17 prioritize prioritize VERB gm80ht27413 2 18 the the DET gm80ht27413 2 19 ethical ethical ADJ gm80ht27413 2 20 response response NOUN gm80ht27413 2 21 to to ADP gm80ht27413 2 22 the the DET gm80ht27413 2 23 suffering suffering NOUN gm80ht27413 2 24 of of ADP gm80ht27413 2 25 others other NOUN gm80ht27413 2 26 as as ADP gm80ht27413 2 27 the the DET gm80ht27413 2 28 most most ADV gm80ht27413 2 29 basic basic ADJ gm80ht27413 2 30 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 2 31 important important ADJ gm80ht27413 2 32 commitment commitment NOUN gm80ht27413 2 33 of of ADP gm80ht27413 2 34 philosophy philosophy NOUN gm80ht27413 2 35 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 2 36 theology theology NOUN gm80ht27413 2 37 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 3 1 this this DET gm80ht27413 3 2 movement movement NOUN gm80ht27413 3 3 toward toward ADP gm80ht27413 3 4 the the DET gm80ht27413 3 5 prioritization prioritization NOUN gm80ht27413 3 6 of of ADP gm80ht27413 3 7 ethics ethic NOUN gm80ht27413 3 8 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 3 9 praxis praxis NOUN gm80ht27413 3 10 is be AUX gm80ht27413 3 11 intimately intimately ADV gm80ht27413 3 12 linked link VERB gm80ht27413 3 13 to to ADP gm80ht27413 3 14 the the DET gm80ht27413 3 15 task task NOUN gm80ht27413 3 16 of of ADP gm80ht27413 3 17 contesting contest VERB gm80ht27413 3 18 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 3 19 criticizing criticize VERB gm80ht27413 3 20 alternative alternative ADJ gm80ht27413 3 21 approaches approach NOUN gm80ht27413 3 22 to to ADP gm80ht27413 3 23 philosophy philosophy NOUN gm80ht27413 3 24 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 3 25 theology theology NOUN gm80ht27413 3 26 which which PRON gm80ht27413 3 27 fail fail VERB gm80ht27413 3 28 to to PART gm80ht27413 3 29 acknowledge acknowledge VERB gm80ht27413 3 30 this this DET gm80ht27413 3 31 prioritization prioritization NOUN gm80ht27413 3 32 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 4 1 thus thus ADV gm80ht27413 4 2 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 4 3 the the DET gm80ht27413 4 4 projects project NOUN gm80ht27413 4 5 of of ADP gm80ht27413 4 6 lì lì X gm80ht27413 4 7 © © X gm80ht27413 4 8 vinas vina NOUN gm80ht27413 4 9 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 4 10 metz metz ADJ gm80ht27413 4 11 stand stand NOUN gm80ht27413 4 12 in in ADP gm80ht27413 4 13 contrast contrast NOUN gm80ht27413 4 14 with with ADP gm80ht27413 4 15 alternative alternative ADJ gm80ht27413 4 16 first first ADJ gm80ht27413 4 17 philosophies philosophy NOUN gm80ht27413 4 18 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 4 19 theologies theology NOUN gm80ht27413 4 20 based base VERB gm80ht27413 4 21 on on ADP gm80ht27413 4 22 a a DET gm80ht27413 4 23 commitment commitment NOUN gm80ht27413 4 24 to to ADP gm80ht27413 4 25 metaphysics metaphysics NOUN gm80ht27413 4 26 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 4 27 ontology ontology NOUN gm80ht27413 4 28 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 4 29 or or CCONJ gm80ht27413 4 30 even even ADV gm80ht27413 4 31 doxology doxology NOUN gm80ht27413 4 32 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 4 33 mysticism mysticism NOUN gm80ht27413 4 34 as as ADP gm80ht27413 4 35 the the DET gm80ht27413 4 36 fundamental fundamental ADJ gm80ht27413 4 37 starting starting NOUN gm80ht27413 4 38 point point NOUN gm80ht27413 4 39 of of ADP gm80ht27413 4 40 philosophy philosophy NOUN gm80ht27413 4 41 or or CCONJ gm80ht27413 4 42 theology theology NOUN gm80ht27413 4 43 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 5 1 although although SCONJ gm80ht27413 5 2 they they PRON gm80ht27413 5 3 share share VERB gm80ht27413 5 4 this this DET gm80ht27413 5 5 prophetic prophetic ADJ gm80ht27413 5 6 focus focus NOUN gm80ht27413 5 7 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 5 8 lì lì X gm80ht27413 5 9 © © X gm80ht27413 5 10 vinas vina NOUN gm80ht27413 5 11 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 5 12 metz metz VERB gm80ht27413 5 13 adhere adhere ADV gm80ht27413 5 14 to to ADP gm80ht27413 5 15 different different ADJ gm80ht27413 5 16 methodological methodological ADJ gm80ht27413 5 17 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 5 18 disciplinary disciplinary ADJ gm80ht27413 5 19 protocols protocol NOUN gm80ht27413 5 20 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 5 21 as as ADP gm80ht27413 5 22 a a DET gm80ht27413 5 23 consequence consequence NOUN gm80ht27413 5 24 the the DET gm80ht27413 5 25 style style NOUN gm80ht27413 5 26 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 5 27 ultimately ultimately ADV gm80ht27413 5 28 the the DET gm80ht27413 5 29 content content NOUN gm80ht27413 5 30 of of ADP gm80ht27413 5 31 their their PRON gm80ht27413 5 32 prophetic prophetic ADJ gm80ht27413 5 33 retrievals retrieval NOUN gm80ht27413 5 34 remain remain VERB gm80ht27413 5 35 distinctive distinctive ADJ gm80ht27413 5 36 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 6 1 as as SCONJ gm80ht27413 6 2 will will AUX gm80ht27413 6 3 become become VERB gm80ht27413 6 4 evident evident ADJ gm80ht27413 6 5 over over ADP gm80ht27413 6 6 the the DET gm80ht27413 6 7 course course NOUN gm80ht27413 6 8 of of ADP gm80ht27413 6 9 the the DET gm80ht27413 6 10 dissertation dissertation NOUN gm80ht27413 6 11 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 6 12 lì lì X gm80ht27413 6 13 © © X gm80ht27413 6 14 vinas vina NOUN gm80ht27413 6 15 is be AUX gm80ht27413 6 16 engaged engage VERB gm80ht27413 6 17 in in ADP gm80ht27413 6 18 a a DET gm80ht27413 6 19 philosophical philosophical ADJ gm80ht27413 6 20 redescription redescription NOUN gm80ht27413 6 21 of of ADP gm80ht27413 6 22 central central ADJ gm80ht27413 6 23 prophetic prophetic ADJ gm80ht27413 6 24 themes theme NOUN gm80ht27413 6 25 from from ADP gm80ht27413 6 26 the the DET gm80ht27413 6 27 hebrew hebrew ADJ gm80ht27413 6 28 bible bible NOUN gm80ht27413 6 29 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 6 30 as as ADP gm80ht27413 6 31 a a DET gm80ht27413 6 32 consequence consequence NOUN gm80ht27413 6 33 generalizes generalize VERB gm80ht27413 6 34 prophetic prophetic ADJ gm80ht27413 6 35 commitments commitment NOUN gm80ht27413 6 36 in in ADP gm80ht27413 6 37 the the DET gm80ht27413 6 38 direction direction NOUN gm80ht27413 6 39 of of ADP gm80ht27413 6 40 a a DET gm80ht27413 6 41 radical radical ADJ gm80ht27413 6 42 ethics ethic NOUN gm80ht27413 6 43 of of ADP gm80ht27413 6 44 responsibility responsibility NOUN gm80ht27413 6 45 for for ADP gm80ht27413 6 46 the the DET gm80ht27413 6 47 other other ADJ gm80ht27413 6 48 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 6 49 particularly particularly ADV gm80ht27413 6 50 those those PRON gm80ht27413 6 51 who who PRON gm80ht27413 6 52 suffer suffer VERB gm80ht27413 6 53 unjustly unjustly ADV gm80ht27413 6 54 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 6 55 experience experience VERB gm80ht27413 6 56 persecution persecution NOUN gm80ht27413 6 57 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 6 58 oppression oppression NOUN gm80ht27413 6 59 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 7 1 metz metz ADJ gm80ht27413 7 2 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 7 3 on on ADP gm80ht27413 7 4 the the DET gm80ht27413 7 5 other other ADJ gm80ht27413 7 6 hand hand NOUN gm80ht27413 7 7 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 7 8 while while SCONJ gm80ht27413 7 9 concerned concerned ADJ gm80ht27413 7 10 to to PART gm80ht27413 7 11 defend defend VERB gm80ht27413 7 12 responsibility responsibility NOUN gm80ht27413 7 13 for for ADP gm80ht27413 7 14 the the DET gm80ht27413 7 15 other other ADJ gm80ht27413 7 16 as as ADP gm80ht27413 7 17 something something PRON gm80ht27413 7 18 of of ADP gm80ht27413 7 19 an an DET gm80ht27413 7 20 ontological ontological ADJ gm80ht27413 7 21 faktum faktum NOUN gm80ht27413 7 22 of of ADP gm80ht27413 7 23 the the DET gm80ht27413 7 24 human human ADJ gm80ht27413 7 25 condition condition NOUN gm80ht27413 7 26 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 7 27 nevertheless nevertheless ADV gm80ht27413 7 28 prosecutes prosecute VERB gm80ht27413 7 29 his his PRON gm80ht27413 7 30 defense defense NOUN gm80ht27413 7 31 of of ADP gm80ht27413 7 32 prophetic prophetic ADJ gm80ht27413 7 33 discourse discourse NOUN gm80ht27413 7 34 in in ADP gm80ht27413 7 35 terms term NOUN gm80ht27413 7 36 of of ADP gm80ht27413 7 37 an an DET gm80ht27413 7 38 explicit explicit ADJ gm80ht27413 7 39 retrieval retrieval NOUN gm80ht27413 7 40 of of ADP gm80ht27413 7 41 the the DET gm80ht27413 7 42 prophetic prophetic ADJ gm80ht27413 7 43 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 7 44 apocalyptic apocalyptic ADJ gm80ht27413 7 45 contours contour NOUN gm80ht27413 7 46 of of ADP gm80ht27413 7 47 the the DET gm80ht27413 7 48 hebrew hebrew ADJ gm80ht27413 7 49 bible bible NOUN gm80ht27413 7 50 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 7 51 the the DET gm80ht27413 7 52 new new ADJ gm80ht27413 7 53 testament testament NOUN gm80ht27413 7 54 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 8 1 metz metz PROPN gm80ht27413 8 2 's 's PART gm80ht27413 8 3 theology theology NOUN gm80ht27413 8 4 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 8 5 furthermore furthermore ADV gm80ht27413 8 6 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 8 7 as as ADP gm80ht27413 8 8 an an DET gm80ht27413 8 9 apocalyptic apocalyptic ADJ gm80ht27413 8 10 theology theology NOUN gm80ht27413 8 11 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 8 12 represents represent VERB gm80ht27413 8 13 an an DET gm80ht27413 8 14 intensification intensification NOUN gm80ht27413 8 15 of of ADP gm80ht27413 8 16 prophetic prophetic ADJ gm80ht27413 8 17 discourse discourse NOUN gm80ht27413 8 18 which which PRON gm80ht27413 8 19 differs differ VERB gm80ht27413 8 20 from from ADP gm80ht27413 8 21 the the DET gm80ht27413 8 22 generalizing generalize VERB gm80ht27413 8 23 tendencies tendency NOUN gm80ht27413 8 24 of of ADP gm80ht27413 8 25 lì lì X gm80ht27413 8 26 © © X gm80ht27413 8 27 vinas vina NOUN gm80ht27413 8 28 's 's PART gm80ht27413 8 29 philosophy philosophy NOUN gm80ht27413 8 30 ( ( PUNCT gm80ht27413 8 31 we we PRON gm80ht27413 8 32 will will AUX gm80ht27413 8 33 return return VERB gm80ht27413 8 34 to to ADP gm80ht27413 8 35 these these DET gm80ht27413 8 36 points point NOUN gm80ht27413 8 37 in in ADP gm80ht27413 8 38 the the DET gm80ht27413 8 39 introduction introduction NOUN gm80ht27413 8 40 to to ADP gm80ht27413 8 41 chapters chapter NOUN gm80ht27413 8 42 two two NUM gm80ht27413 8 43 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 8 44 three three NUM gm80ht27413 8 45 ) ) PUNCT gm80ht27413 8 46 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 9 1 while while SCONJ gm80ht27413 9 2 these these DET gm80ht27413 9 3 different different ADJ gm80ht27413 9 4 inflections inflection NOUN gm80ht27413 9 5 of of ADP gm80ht27413 9 6 prophetic prophetic ADJ gm80ht27413 9 7 discourse discourse NOUN gm80ht27413 9 8 account account NOUN gm80ht27413 9 9 for for ADP gm80ht27413 9 10 notable notable ADJ gm80ht27413 9 11 differences difference NOUN gm80ht27413 9 12 in in ADP gm80ht27413 9 13 their their PRON gm80ht27413 9 14 projects project NOUN gm80ht27413 9 15 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 9 16 lì lì X gm80ht27413 9 17 © © X gm80ht27413 9 18 vinas vina NOUN gm80ht27413 9 19 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 9 20 metz metz ADJ gm80ht27413 9 21 share share NOUN gm80ht27413 9 22 a a DET gm80ht27413 9 23 focus focus NOUN gm80ht27413 9 24 on on ADP gm80ht27413 9 25 subjectivity subjectivity NOUN gm80ht27413 9 26 as as ADP gm80ht27413 9 27 responsibility responsibility NOUN gm80ht27413 9 28 for for ADP gm80ht27413 9 29 the the DET gm80ht27413 9 30 other other ADJ gm80ht27413 9 31 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 9 32 the the DET gm80ht27413 9 33 centrality centrality NOUN gm80ht27413 9 34 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 9 35 irresolvability irresolvability NOUN gm80ht27413 9 36 of of ADP gm80ht27413 9 37 the the DET gm80ht27413 9 38 problem problem NOUN gm80ht27413 9 39 of of ADP gm80ht27413 9 40 theodicy theodicy NOUN gm80ht27413 9 41 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 9 42 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 9 43 eschatology eschatology NOUN gm80ht27413 9 44 as as ADP gm80ht27413 9 45 an an DET gm80ht27413 9 46 approach approach NOUN gm80ht27413 9 47 to to ADP gm80ht27413 9 48 philosophy philosophy NOUN gm80ht27413 9 49 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 9 50 theology theology NOUN gm80ht27413 9 51 which which PRON gm80ht27413 9 52 focuses focus VERB gm80ht27413 9 53 on on ADP gm80ht27413 9 54 the the DET gm80ht27413 9 55 unfinished unfinished ADJ gm80ht27413 9 56 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 9 57 unreconciled unreconciled ADJ gm80ht27413 9 58 character character NOUN gm80ht27413 9 59 of of ADP gm80ht27413 9 60 history history NOUN gm80ht27413 9 61 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 9 62 prioritizes prioritize VERB gm80ht27413 9 63 the the DET gm80ht27413 9 64 ethical ethical ADJ gm80ht27413 9 65 interruption interruption NOUN gm80ht27413 9 66 of of ADP gm80ht27413 9 67 the the DET gm80ht27413 9 68 status status NOUN gm80ht27413 9 69 quo quo PROPN gm80ht27413 9 70 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 10 1 in in ADP gm80ht27413 10 2 order order NOUN gm80ht27413 10 3 to to PART gm80ht27413 10 4 describe describe VERB gm80ht27413 10 5 these these DET gm80ht27413 10 6 prophetic prophetic ADJ gm80ht27413 10 7 retrievals retrieval NOUN gm80ht27413 10 8 in in ADP gm80ht27413 10 9 the the DET gm80ht27413 10 10 projects project NOUN gm80ht27413 10 11 of of ADP gm80ht27413 10 12 lì lì X gm80ht27413 10 13 © © X gm80ht27413 10 14 vinas vina NOUN gm80ht27413 10 15 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 10 16 metz metz VERB gm80ht27413 10 17 this this DET gm80ht27413 10 18 dissertation dissertation NOUN gm80ht27413 10 19 will will AUX gm80ht27413 10 20 unfold unfold VERB gm80ht27413 10 21 in in ADP gm80ht27413 10 22 five five NUM gm80ht27413 10 23 chapters chapter NOUN gm80ht27413 10 24 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 10 25 each each DET gm80ht27413 10 26 chapter chapter NOUN gm80ht27413 10 27 exploring explore VERB gm80ht27413 10 28 different different ADJ gm80ht27413 10 29 contours contour NOUN gm80ht27413 10 30 of of ADP gm80ht27413 10 31 their their PRON gm80ht27413 10 32 engagement engagement NOUN gm80ht27413 10 33 with with ADP gm80ht27413 10 34 prophetic prophetic ADJ gm80ht27413 10 35 discourse discourse NOUN gm80ht27413 10 36 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 11 1 in in ADP gm80ht27413 11 2 the the DET gm80ht27413 11 3 first first ADJ gm80ht27413 11 4 chapter chapter NOUN gm80ht27413 11 5 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 11 6 we we PRON gm80ht27413 11 7 will will AUX gm80ht27413 11 8 examine examine VERB gm80ht27413 11 9 the the DET gm80ht27413 11 10 intellectual intellectual ADJ gm80ht27413 11 11 biographies biography NOUN gm80ht27413 11 12 of of ADP gm80ht27413 11 13 lì lì X gm80ht27413 11 14 © © X gm80ht27413 11 15 vinas vina NOUN gm80ht27413 11 16 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 11 17 metz metz VERB gm80ht27413 11 18 with with ADP gm80ht27413 11 19 specific specific ADJ gm80ht27413 11 20 attention attention NOUN gm80ht27413 11 21 to to ADP gm80ht27413 11 22 the the DET gm80ht27413 11 23 ways way NOUN gm80ht27413 11 24 in in ADP gm80ht27413 11 25 which which PRON gm80ht27413 11 26 the the DET gm80ht27413 11 27 shoah shoah NOUN gm80ht27413 11 28 constitutes constitute VERB gm80ht27413 11 29 a a DET gm80ht27413 11 30 rupture rupture NOUN gm80ht27413 11 31 in in ADP gm80ht27413 11 32 their their PRON gm80ht27413 11 33 biographies biography NOUN gm80ht27413 11 34 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 11 35 more more ADV gm80ht27413 11 36 broadly broadly ADV gm80ht27413 11 37 in in ADP gm80ht27413 11 38 their their PRON gm80ht27413 11 39 philosophical philosophical ADJ gm80ht27413 11 40 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 11 41 theological theological ADJ gm80ht27413 11 42 development development NOUN gm80ht27413 11 43 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 12 1 while while SCONJ gm80ht27413 12 2 the the DET gm80ht27413 12 3 exact exact ADJ gm80ht27413 12 4 terms term NOUN gm80ht27413 12 5 in in ADP gm80ht27413 12 6 which which PRON gm80ht27413 12 7 lì lì NOUN gm80ht27413 12 8 © © ADJ gm80ht27413 12 9 vinas vina NOUN gm80ht27413 12 10 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 12 11 metz metz PROPN gm80ht27413 12 12 reorient reorient VERB gm80ht27413 12 13 their their PRON gm80ht27413 12 14 thought thought NOUN gm80ht27413 12 15 in in ADP gm80ht27413 12 16 response response NOUN gm80ht27413 12 17 to to ADP gm80ht27413 12 18 the the DET gm80ht27413 12 19 shoah shoah NOUN gm80ht27413 12 20 remains remains AUX gm80ht27413 12 21 debated debate VERB gm80ht27413 12 22 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 12 23 it it PRON gm80ht27413 12 24 is be AUX gm80ht27413 12 25 clearly clearly ADV gm80ht27413 12 26 the the DET gm80ht27413 12 27 case case NOUN gm80ht27413 12 28 that that SCONJ gm80ht27413 12 29 the the DET gm80ht27413 12 30 projects project NOUN gm80ht27413 12 31 of of ADP gm80ht27413 12 32 both both DET gm80ht27413 12 33 thinkers thinker NOUN gm80ht27413 12 34 constitute constitute VERB gm80ht27413 12 35 direct direct ADJ gm80ht27413 12 36 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 12 37 sustained sustained ADJ gm80ht27413 12 38 responses response NOUN gm80ht27413 12 39 to to ADP gm80ht27413 12 40 the the DET gm80ht27413 12 41 incomprehensible incomprehensible ADJ gm80ht27413 12 42 tremendum tremendum PROPN gm80ht27413 12 43 at at ADP gm80ht27413 12 44 auschwitz auschwitz PROPN gm80ht27413 12 45 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 13 1 after after ADP gm80ht27413 13 2 examining examine VERB gm80ht27413 13 3 the the DET gm80ht27413 13 4 development development NOUN gm80ht27413 13 5 of of ADP gm80ht27413 13 6 lì lì X gm80ht27413 13 7 © © X gm80ht27413 13 8 vinas vina NOUN gm80ht27413 13 9 's 's PART gm80ht27413 13 10 philosophy philosophy NOUN gm80ht27413 13 11 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 13 12 metz metz PROPN gm80ht27413 13 13 's 's PART gm80ht27413 13 14 theology theology NOUN gm80ht27413 13 15 in in ADP gm80ht27413 13 16 response response NOUN gm80ht27413 13 17 to to ADP gm80ht27413 13 18 the the DET gm80ht27413 13 19 shoah shoah NOUN gm80ht27413 13 20 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 13 21 in in ADP gm80ht27413 13 22 conclusion conclusion NOUN gm80ht27413 13 23 to to ADP gm80ht27413 13 24 the the DET gm80ht27413 13 25 first first ADJ gm80ht27413 13 26 chapter chapter NOUN gm80ht27413 13 27 we we PRON gm80ht27413 13 28 will will AUX gm80ht27413 13 29 briefly briefly ADV gm80ht27413 13 30 describe describe VERB gm80ht27413 13 31 their their PRON gm80ht27413 13 32 projects project NOUN gm80ht27413 13 33 as as ADP gm80ht27413 13 34 discourses discourse NOUN gm80ht27413 13 35 of of ADP gm80ht27413 13 36 mourning mourning NOUN gm80ht27413 13 37 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 14 1 because because SCONJ gm80ht27413 14 2 lì lì X gm80ht27413 14 3 © © X gm80ht27413 14 4 vinas vina NOUN gm80ht27413 14 5 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 14 6 metz metz VERB gm80ht27413 14 7 refuse refuse VERB gm80ht27413 14 8 to to PART gm80ht27413 14 9 integrate integrate VERB gm80ht27413 14 10 unjust unjust ADJ gm80ht27413 14 11 suffering suffering NOUN gm80ht27413 14 12 into into ADP gm80ht27413 14 13 the the DET gm80ht27413 14 14 order order NOUN gm80ht27413 14 15 of of ADP gm80ht27413 14 16 the the DET gm80ht27413 14 17 meaningful meaningful ADJ gm80ht27413 14 18 their their PRON gm80ht27413 14 19 projects project NOUN gm80ht27413 14 20 are be AUX gm80ht27413 14 21 characterized characterize VERB gm80ht27413 14 22 by by ADP gm80ht27413 14 23 a a DET gm80ht27413 14 24 constant constant ADJ gm80ht27413 14 25 critique critique NOUN gm80ht27413 14 26 of of ADP gm80ht27413 14 27 those those DET gm80ht27413 14 28 forms form NOUN gm80ht27413 14 29 of of ADP gm80ht27413 14 30 philosophy philosophy NOUN gm80ht27413 14 31 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 14 32 theology theology NOUN gm80ht27413 14 33 which which DET gm80ht27413 14 34 accent accent ADJ gm80ht27413 14 35 reconciliation reconciliation NOUN gm80ht27413 14 36 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 15 1 this this DET gm80ht27413 15 2 mournful mournful ADJ gm80ht27413 15 3 contestation contestation NOUN gm80ht27413 15 4 of of ADP gm80ht27413 15 5 idealist idealist ADJ gm80ht27413 15 6 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 15 7 aesthetic aesthetic ADJ gm80ht27413 15 8 discourses discourse NOUN gm80ht27413 15 9 of of ADP gm80ht27413 15 10 reconciliation reconciliation NOUN gm80ht27413 15 11 leads lead VERB gm80ht27413 15 12 to to ADP gm80ht27413 15 13 the the DET gm80ht27413 15 14 prioritization prioritization NOUN gm80ht27413 15 15 of of ADP gm80ht27413 15 16 a a DET gm80ht27413 15 17 radical radical ADJ gm80ht27413 15 18 ethics ethic NOUN gm80ht27413 15 19 of of ADP gm80ht27413 15 20 responsibility responsibility NOUN gm80ht27413 15 21 that that PRON gm80ht27413 15 22 attempts attempt VERB gm80ht27413 15 23 to to PART gm80ht27413 15 24 respond respond VERB gm80ht27413 15 25 to to ADP gm80ht27413 15 26 the the DET gm80ht27413 15 27 suffering suffering NOUN gm80ht27413 15 28 of of ADP gm80ht27413 15 29 the the DET gm80ht27413 15 30 victims victim NOUN gm80ht27413 15 31 in in ADP gm80ht27413 15 32 a a DET gm80ht27413 15 33 world world NOUN gm80ht27413 15 34 which which PRON gm80ht27413 15 35 remains remain VERB gm80ht27413 15 36 tragically tragically ADV gm80ht27413 15 37 unreconciled unreconciled ADJ gm80ht27413 15 38 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 16 1 in in ADP gm80ht27413 16 2 the the DET gm80ht27413 16 3 second second ADJ gm80ht27413 16 4 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 16 5 third third ADJ gm80ht27413 16 6 chapters chapter NOUN gm80ht27413 16 7 we we PRON gm80ht27413 16 8 will will AUX gm80ht27413 16 9 focus focus VERB gm80ht27413 16 10 on on ADP gm80ht27413 16 11 the the DET gm80ht27413 16 12 way way NOUN gm80ht27413 16 13 in in ADP gm80ht27413 16 14 which which PRON gm80ht27413 16 15 lì lì NOUN gm80ht27413 16 16 © © ADJ gm80ht27413 16 17 vinas vina NOUN gm80ht27413 16 18 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 16 19 metz metz VERB gm80ht27413 16 20 prophetically prophetically ADV gm80ht27413 16 21 transform transform VERB gm80ht27413 16 22 philosophical philosophical ADJ gm80ht27413 16 23 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 16 24 theological theological ADJ gm80ht27413 16 25 discourse discourse NOUN gm80ht27413 16 26 by by ADP gm80ht27413 16 27 focusing focus VERB gm80ht27413 16 28 on on ADP gm80ht27413 16 29 the the DET gm80ht27413 16 30 priority priority NOUN gm80ht27413 16 31 of of ADP gm80ht27413 16 32 ethics ethic NOUN gm80ht27413 16 33 or or CCONJ gm80ht27413 16 34 praxis praxis NOUN gm80ht27413 16 35 in in ADP gm80ht27413 16 36 response response NOUN gm80ht27413 16 37 to to ADP gm80ht27413 16 38 the the DET gm80ht27413 16 39 suffering suffering NOUN gm80ht27413 16 40 of of ADP gm80ht27413 16 41 others other NOUN gm80ht27413 16 42 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 17 1 in in ADP gm80ht27413 17 2 an an DET gm80ht27413 17 3 introduction introduction NOUN gm80ht27413 17 4 to to ADP gm80ht27413 17 5 chapters chapter NOUN gm80ht27413 17 6 two two NUM gm80ht27413 17 7 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 17 8 three three NUM gm80ht27413 17 9 i i PRON gm80ht27413 17 10 will will AUX gm80ht27413 17 11 introduce introduce VERB gm80ht27413 17 12 the the DET gm80ht27413 17 13 prophetic prophetic ADJ gm80ht27413 17 14 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 17 15 apocalyptic apocalyptic ADJ gm80ht27413 17 16 movements movement NOUN gm80ht27413 17 17 of of ADP gm80ht27413 17 18 lì lì X gm80ht27413 17 19 © © X gm80ht27413 17 20 vinas vina NOUN gm80ht27413 17 21 's 's PART gm80ht27413 17 22 philosophy philosophy NOUN gm80ht27413 17 23 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 17 24 metz metz PROPN gm80ht27413 17 25 's 's PART gm80ht27413 17 26 theology theology NOUN gm80ht27413 17 27 by by ADP gm80ht27413 17 28 first first ADV gm80ht27413 17 29 examining examine VERB gm80ht27413 17 30 their their PRON gm80ht27413 17 31 projects project NOUN gm80ht27413 17 32 more more ADV gm80ht27413 17 33 broadly broadly ADV gm80ht27413 17 34 in in ADP gm80ht27413 17 35 terms term NOUN gm80ht27413 17 36 of of ADP gm80ht27413 17 37 their their PRON gm80ht27413 17 38 remembrance remembrance NOUN gm80ht27413 17 39 of of ADP gm80ht27413 17 40 the the DET gm80ht27413 17 41 jewish jewish ADJ gm80ht27413 17 42 roots root NOUN gm80ht27413 17 43 of of ADP gm80ht27413 17 44 the the DET gm80ht27413 17 45 west west PROPN gm80ht27413 17 46 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 18 1 in in ADP gm80ht27413 18 2 chapter chapter NOUN gm80ht27413 18 3 two two NUM gm80ht27413 18 4 we we PRON gm80ht27413 18 5 will will AUX gm80ht27413 18 6 explore explore VERB gm80ht27413 18 7 lì lì X gm80ht27413 18 8 © © X gm80ht27413 18 9 vinas vina NOUN gm80ht27413 18 10 's 's PART gm80ht27413 18 11 specific specific ADJ gm80ht27413 18 12 criticisms criticism NOUN gm80ht27413 18 13 of of ADP gm80ht27413 18 14 ontological ontological ADJ gm80ht27413 18 15 forms form NOUN gm80ht27413 18 16 of of ADP gm80ht27413 18 17 philosophy philosophy NOUN gm80ht27413 18 18 ( ( PUNCT gm80ht27413 18 19 husserl husserl PROPN gm80ht27413 18 20 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 18 21 heidegger heidegger NOUN gm80ht27413 18 22 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 18 23 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 18 24 parmenides parmenide NOUN gm80ht27413 18 25 ) ) PUNCT gm80ht27413 18 26 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 18 27 his his PRON gm80ht27413 18 28 return return NOUN gm80ht27413 18 29 to to ADP gm80ht27413 18 30 a a DET gm80ht27413 18 31 prophetic prophetic ADJ gm80ht27413 18 32 form form NOUN gm80ht27413 18 33 of of ADP gm80ht27413 18 34 philosophy philosophy NOUN gm80ht27413 18 35 that that PRON gm80ht27413 18 36 focuses focus VERB gm80ht27413 18 37 on on ADP gm80ht27413 18 38 the the DET gm80ht27413 18 39 encounter encounter NOUN gm80ht27413 18 40 with with ADP gm80ht27413 18 41 the the DET gm80ht27413 18 42 face face NOUN gm80ht27413 18 43 of of ADP gm80ht27413 18 44 the the DET gm80ht27413 18 45 other other ADJ gm80ht27413 18 46 as as ADP gm80ht27413 18 47 the the DET gm80ht27413 18 48 interruption interruption NOUN gm80ht27413 18 49 of of ADP gm80ht27413 18 50 self self NOUN gm80ht27413 18 51 - - PUNCT gm80ht27413 18 52 concern concern NOUN gm80ht27413 18 53 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 18 54 self self NOUN gm80ht27413 18 55 - - PUNCT gm80ht27413 18 56 interest interest NOUN gm80ht27413 18 57 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 19 1 in in ADP gm80ht27413 19 2 chapter chapter NOUN gm80ht27413 19 3 three three NUM gm80ht27413 19 4 we we PRON gm80ht27413 19 5 will will AUX gm80ht27413 19 6 examine examine VERB gm80ht27413 19 7 metz metz PROPN gm80ht27413 19 8 's 's PART gm80ht27413 19 9 own own ADJ gm80ht27413 19 10 contestation contestation NOUN gm80ht27413 19 11 of of ADP gm80ht27413 19 12 idealist idealist ADJ gm80ht27413 19 13 forms form NOUN gm80ht27413 19 14 of of ADP gm80ht27413 19 15 philosophy philosophy NOUN gm80ht27413 19 16 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 19 17 theology theology NOUN gm80ht27413 19 18 as as ADV gm80ht27413 19 19 well well ADV gm80ht27413 19 20 as as ADP gm80ht27413 19 21 his his PRON gm80ht27413 19 22 criticisms criticism NOUN gm80ht27413 19 23 of of ADP gm80ht27413 19 24 the the DET gm80ht27413 19 25 postmodern postmodern ADJ gm80ht27413 19 26 aesthetic aesthetic ADJ gm80ht27413 19 27 projects project NOUN gm80ht27413 19 28 of of ADP gm80ht27413 19 29 nietzsche nietzsche NOUN gm80ht27413 19 30 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 19 31 heidegger heidegger NOUN gm80ht27413 19 32 by by ADP gm80ht27413 19 33 returning return VERB gm80ht27413 19 34 to to ADP gm80ht27413 19 35 an an DET gm80ht27413 19 36 apocalyptic apocalyptic ADJ gm80ht27413 19 37 form form NOUN gm80ht27413 19 38 of of ADP gm80ht27413 19 39 theology theology NOUN gm80ht27413 19 40 that that PRON gm80ht27413 19 41 disrupts disrupt VERB gm80ht27413 19 42 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 19 43 disturbs disturb VERB gm80ht27413 19 44 the the DET gm80ht27413 19 45 march march NOUN gm80ht27413 19 46 of of ADP gm80ht27413 19 47 the the DET gm80ht27413 19 48 victors victor NOUN gm80ht27413 19 49 by by ADP gm80ht27413 19 50 remembering remember VERB gm80ht27413 19 51 the the DET gm80ht27413 19 52 nameless nameless ADJ gm80ht27413 19 53 victims victim NOUN gm80ht27413 19 54 of of ADP gm80ht27413 19 55 history history NOUN gm80ht27413 19 56 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 20 1 in in ADP gm80ht27413 20 2 the the DET gm80ht27413 20 3 fourth fourth ADJ gm80ht27413 20 4 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 20 5 fifth fifth ADJ gm80ht27413 20 6 chapters chapter NOUN gm80ht27413 20 7 we we PRON gm80ht27413 20 8 turn turn VERB gm80ht27413 20 9 to to ADP gm80ht27413 20 10 the the DET gm80ht27413 20 11 two two NUM gm80ht27413 20 12 central central ADJ gm80ht27413 20 13 concerns concern NOUN gm80ht27413 20 14 of of ADP gm80ht27413 20 15 the the DET gm80ht27413 20 16 projects project NOUN gm80ht27413 20 17 of of ADP gm80ht27413 20 18 lì lì X gm80ht27413 20 19 © © X gm80ht27413 20 20 vinas vina NOUN gm80ht27413 20 21 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 20 22 metz metz PROPN gm80ht27413 20 23 : : PUNCT gm80ht27413 20 24 the the DET gm80ht27413 20 25 defense defense NOUN gm80ht27413 20 26 of of ADP gm80ht27413 20 27 the the DET gm80ht27413 20 28 subject subject NOUN gm80ht27413 20 29 as as ADP gm80ht27413 20 30 unconditionally unconditionally ADV gm80ht27413 20 31 responsible responsible ADJ gm80ht27413 20 32 for for ADP gm80ht27413 20 33 the the DET gm80ht27413 20 34 suffering suffering NOUN gm80ht27413 20 35 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 20 36 death death NOUN gm80ht27413 20 37 of of ADP gm80ht27413 20 38 the the DET gm80ht27413 20 39 other other ADJ gm80ht27413 20 40 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 20 41 the the DET gm80ht27413 20 42 critique critique NOUN gm80ht27413 20 43 of of ADP gm80ht27413 20 44 theoretical theoretical ADJ gm80ht27413 20 45 forms form NOUN gm80ht27413 20 46 of of ADP gm80ht27413 20 47 theodicy theodicy NOUN gm80ht27413 20 48 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 20 49 the the DET gm80ht27413 20 50 discourses discourse NOUN gm80ht27413 20 51 on on ADP gm80ht27413 20 52 god god PROPN gm80ht27413 20 53 which which PRON gm80ht27413 20 54 issues issue NOUN gm80ht27413 20 55 from from ADP gm80ht27413 20 56 these these DET gm80ht27413 20 57 reconciling reconcile VERB gm80ht27413 20 58 theodicies theodicy NOUN gm80ht27413 20 59 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 21 1 both both DET gm80ht27413 21 2 lì lì X gm80ht27413 21 3 © © PROPN gm80ht27413 21 4 vinas vinas PROPN gm80ht27413 21 5 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 21 6 metz metz PROPN gm80ht27413 21 7 explicitly explicitly ADV gm80ht27413 21 8 define define VERB gm80ht27413 21 9 their their PRON gm80ht27413 21 10 projects project NOUN gm80ht27413 21 11 as as ADP gm80ht27413 21 12 defenses defense NOUN gm80ht27413 21 13 of of ADP gm80ht27413 21 14 the the DET gm80ht27413 21 15 subject subject NOUN gm80ht27413 21 16 against against ADP gm80ht27413 21 17 the the DET gm80ht27413 21 18 postmodern postmodern ADJ gm80ht27413 21 19 critique critique NOUN gm80ht27413 21 20 of of ADP gm80ht27413 21 21 the the DET gm80ht27413 21 22 subject subject NOUN gm80ht27413 21 23 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 22 1 but but CCONJ gm80ht27413 22 2 in in ADP gm80ht27413 22 3 their their PRON gm80ht27413 22 4 defense defense NOUN gm80ht27413 22 5 of of ADP gm80ht27413 22 6 the the DET gm80ht27413 22 7 subject subject NOUN gm80ht27413 22 8 they they PRON gm80ht27413 22 9 resist resist VERB gm80ht27413 22 10 returning return VERB gm80ht27413 22 11 to to ADP gm80ht27413 22 12 modern modern ADJ gm80ht27413 22 13 forms form NOUN gm80ht27413 22 14 of of ADP gm80ht27413 22 15 subjectivity subjectivity NOUN gm80ht27413 22 16 predicted predict VERB gm80ht27413 22 17 on on ADP gm80ht27413 22 18 self self NOUN gm80ht27413 22 19 - - PUNCT gm80ht27413 22 20 consciousness consciousness NOUN gm80ht27413 22 21 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 22 22 instead instead ADV gm80ht27413 22 23 maintain maintain VERB gm80ht27413 22 24 that that SCONJ gm80ht27413 22 25 the the DET gm80ht27413 22 26 identity identity NOUN gm80ht27413 22 27 of of ADP gm80ht27413 22 28 the the DET gm80ht27413 22 29 subject subject NOUN gm80ht27413 22 30 is be AUX gm80ht27413 22 31 located locate VERB gm80ht27413 22 32 in in ADP gm80ht27413 22 33 its its PRON gm80ht27413 22 34 asymmetrical asymmetrical ADJ gm80ht27413 22 35 responsibility responsibility NOUN gm80ht27413 22 36 for for ADP gm80ht27413 22 37 the the DET gm80ht27413 22 38 other other ADJ gm80ht27413 22 39 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 23 1 this this DET gm80ht27413 23 2 defense defense NOUN gm80ht27413 23 3 of of ADP gm80ht27413 23 4 the the DET gm80ht27413 23 5 subject subject NOUN gm80ht27413 23 6 culminates culminate NOUN gm80ht27413 23 7 in in ADP gm80ht27413 23 8 their their PRON gm80ht27413 23 9 criticisms criticism NOUN gm80ht27413 23 10 of of ADP gm80ht27413 23 11 heidegger heidegger PROPN gm80ht27413 23 12 's 's PART gm80ht27413 23 13 approach approach NOUN gm80ht27413 23 14 to to ADP gm80ht27413 23 15 death death NOUN gm80ht27413 23 16 which which PRON gm80ht27413 23 17 points point VERB gm80ht27413 23 18 toward toward ADP gm80ht27413 23 19 the the DET gm80ht27413 23 20 death death NOUN gm80ht27413 23 21 of of ADP gm80ht27413 23 22 the the DET gm80ht27413 23 23 self self NOUN gm80ht27413 23 24 as as ADP gm80ht27413 23 25 the the DET gm80ht27413 23 26 limit limit NOUN gm80ht27413 23 27 experience experience NOUN gm80ht27413 23 28 which which PRON gm80ht27413 23 29 discloses disclose VERB gm80ht27413 23 30 the the DET gm80ht27413 23 31 authenticity authenticity NOUN gm80ht27413 23 32 or or CCONJ gm80ht27413 23 33 inauthenticity inauthenticity NOUN gm80ht27413 23 34 of of ADP gm80ht27413 23 35 dasein dasein PROPN gm80ht27413 23 36 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 24 1 for for ADP gm80ht27413 24 2 both both DET gm80ht27413 24 3 lì lì X gm80ht27413 24 4 © © ADJ gm80ht27413 24 5 vinas vina NOUN gm80ht27413 24 6 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 24 7 metz metz PROPN gm80ht27413 24 8 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 24 9 heidegger heidegger NOUN gm80ht27413 24 10 is be AUX gm80ht27413 24 11 right right ADJ gm80ht27413 24 12 to to PART gm80ht27413 24 13 focus focus VERB gm80ht27413 24 14 on on ADP gm80ht27413 24 15 death death NOUN gm80ht27413 24 16 as as ADP gm80ht27413 24 17 a a DET gm80ht27413 24 18 central central ADJ gm80ht27413 24 19 event event NOUN gm80ht27413 24 20 in in ADP gm80ht27413 24 21 the the DET gm80ht27413 24 22 life life NOUN gm80ht27413 24 23 of of ADP gm80ht27413 24 24 the the DET gm80ht27413 24 25 subject subject NOUN gm80ht27413 24 26 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 24 27 but but CCONJ gm80ht27413 24 28 heidegger heidegger NOUN gm80ht27413 24 29 misinterpreted misinterpret VERB gm80ht27413 24 30 its its PRON gm80ht27413 24 31 significance significance NOUN gm80ht27413 24 32 by by ADP gm80ht27413 24 33 failing fail VERB gm80ht27413 24 34 to to PART gm80ht27413 24 35 see see VERB gm80ht27413 24 36 that that SCONJ gm80ht27413 24 37 it it PRON gm80ht27413 24 38 is be AUX gm80ht27413 24 39 the the DET gm80ht27413 24 40 death death NOUN gm80ht27413 24 41 of of ADP gm80ht27413 24 42 the the DET gm80ht27413 24 43 other other ADJ gm80ht27413 24 44 which which PRON gm80ht27413 24 45 is be AUX gm80ht27413 24 46 central central ADJ gm80ht27413 24 47 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 24 48 not not PART gm80ht27413 24 49 the the DET gm80ht27413 24 50 death death NOUN gm80ht27413 24 51 of of ADP gm80ht27413 24 52 the the DET gm80ht27413 24 53 self self NOUN gm80ht27413 24 54 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 25 1 in in ADP gm80ht27413 25 2 the the DET gm80ht27413 25 3 fifth fifth ADJ gm80ht27413 25 4 chapter chapter NOUN gm80ht27413 25 5 we we PRON gm80ht27413 25 6 will will AUX gm80ht27413 25 7 extend extend VERB gm80ht27413 25 8 our our PRON gm80ht27413 25 9 discussion discussion NOUN gm80ht27413 25 10 of of ADP gm80ht27413 25 11 the the DET gm80ht27413 25 12 unjust unjust ADJ gm80ht27413 25 13 suffering suffering NOUN gm80ht27413 25 14 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 25 15 death death NOUN gm80ht27413 25 16 of of ADP gm80ht27413 25 17 the the DET gm80ht27413 25 18 other other ADJ gm80ht27413 25 19 by by ADP gm80ht27413 25 20 examining examine VERB gm80ht27413 25 21 the the DET gm80ht27413 25 22 thoroughgoing thoroughgoing ADJ gm80ht27413 25 23 criticisms criticism NOUN gm80ht27413 25 24 of of ADP gm80ht27413 25 25 the the DET gm80ht27413 25 26 project project NOUN gm80ht27413 25 27 of of ADP gm80ht27413 25 28 theodicy theodicy NOUN gm80ht27413 25 29 in in ADP gm80ht27413 25 30 western western ADJ gm80ht27413 25 31 philosophy philosophy NOUN gm80ht27413 25 32 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 25 33 theology theology NOUN gm80ht27413 25 34 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 26 1 the the DET gm80ht27413 26 2 criticism criticism NOUN gm80ht27413 26 3 of of ADP gm80ht27413 26 4 western western ADJ gm80ht27413 26 5 ontologies ontology NOUN gm80ht27413 26 6 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 26 7 idealisms idealism NOUN gm80ht27413 26 8 ( ( PUNCT gm80ht27413 26 9 as as ADV gm80ht27413 26 10 well well ADV gm80ht27413 26 11 as as ADP gm80ht27413 26 12 aesthetics aesthetic NOUN gm80ht27413 26 13 ) ) PUNCT gm80ht27413 26 14 that that SCONJ gm80ht27413 26 15 we we PRON gm80ht27413 26 16 traced trace VERB gm80ht27413 26 17 in in ADP gm80ht27413 26 18 chapters chapter NOUN gm80ht27413 26 19 two two NUM gm80ht27413 26 20 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 26 21 three three NUM gm80ht27413 26 22 are be AUX gm80ht27413 26 23 intimately intimately ADV gm80ht27413 26 24 connected connect VERB gm80ht27413 26 25 to to ADP gm80ht27413 26 26 their their PRON gm80ht27413 26 27 retrieval retrieval NOUN gm80ht27413 26 28 of of ADP gm80ht27413 26 29 prophetic prophetic ADJ gm80ht27413 26 30 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 26 31 apocalyptic apocalyptic ADJ gm80ht27413 26 32 discourses discourse NOUN gm80ht27413 26 33 which which PRON gm80ht27413 26 34 focus focus VERB gm80ht27413 26 35 on on ADP gm80ht27413 26 36 the the DET gm80ht27413 26 37 problem problem NOUN gm80ht27413 26 38 of of ADP gm80ht27413 26 39 suffering suffer VERB gm80ht27413 26 40 rather rather ADV gm80ht27413 26 41 than than ADP gm80ht27413 26 42 the the DET gm80ht27413 26 43 acquisition acquisition NOUN gm80ht27413 26 44 of of ADP gm80ht27413 26 45 knowledge knowledge NOUN gm80ht27413 26 46 or or CCONJ gm80ht27413 26 47 the the DET gm80ht27413 26 48 experience experience NOUN gm80ht27413 26 49 of of ADP gm80ht27413 26 50 beauty beauty NOUN gm80ht27413 26 51 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 27 1 specifically specifically ADV gm80ht27413 27 2 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 27 3 both both DET gm80ht27413 27 4 thinkers thinker NOUN gm80ht27413 27 5 are be AUX gm80ht27413 27 6 concerned concerned ADJ gm80ht27413 27 7 to to ADP gm80ht27413 27 8 the the DET gm80ht27413 27 9 assault assault NOUN gm80ht27413 27 10 the the DET gm80ht27413 27 11 totalizing totalizing ADJ gm80ht27413 27 12 nature nature NOUN gm80ht27413 27 13 of of ADP gm80ht27413 27 14 these these DET gm80ht27413 27 15 ontologies ontology NOUN gm80ht27413 27 16 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 27 17 idealisms idealism NOUN gm80ht27413 27 18 which which PRON gm80ht27413 27 19 engage engage VERB gm80ht27413 27 20 in in ADP gm80ht27413 27 21 projects project NOUN gm80ht27413 27 22 which which PRON gm80ht27413 27 23 justify justify VERB gm80ht27413 27 24 meaningless meaningless ADJ gm80ht27413 27 25 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 27 26 useless useless ADJ gm80ht27413 27 27 suffering suffering NOUN gm80ht27413 27 28 by by ADP gm80ht27413 27 29 comprehending comprehend VERB gm80ht27413 27 30 this this DET gm80ht27413 27 31 suffering suffering NOUN gm80ht27413 27 32 in in ADP gm80ht27413 27 33 terms term NOUN gm80ht27413 27 34 of of ADP gm80ht27413 27 35 knowledge knowledge NOUN gm80ht27413 27 36 ( ( PUNCT gm80ht27413 27 37 gnosis gnosis NOUN gm80ht27413 27 38 ) ) PUNCT gm80ht27413 27 39 or or CCONJ gm80ht27413 27 40 by by ADP gm80ht27413 27 41 referring refer VERB gm80ht27413 27 42 this this DET gm80ht27413 27 43 suffering suffering NOUN gm80ht27413 27 44 to to ADP gm80ht27413 27 45 some some DET gm80ht27413 27 46 harmonious harmonious ADJ gm80ht27413 27 47 whole whole ADJ gm80ht27413 27 48 ( ( PUNCT gm80ht27413 27 49 aesthetic aesthetic ADJ gm80ht27413 27 50 ) ) PUNCT gm80ht27413 27 51 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 28 1 in in ADP gm80ht27413 28 2 either either DET gm80ht27413 28 3 case case NOUN gm80ht27413 28 4 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 28 5 suffering suffering NOUN gm80ht27413 28 6 is be AUX gm80ht27413 28 7 explained explain VERB gm80ht27413 28 8 away away ADP gm80ht27413 28 9 or or CCONJ gm80ht27413 28 10 aestheticized aestheticize VERB gm80ht27413 28 11 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 28 12 thereby thereby ADV gm80ht27413 28 13 made make VERB gm80ht27413 28 14 bearable bearable ADJ gm80ht27413 28 15 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 29 1 writing write VERB gm80ht27413 29 2 in in ADP gm80ht27413 29 3 the the DET gm80ht27413 29 4 shadow shadow NOUN gm80ht27413 29 5 of of ADP gm80ht27413 29 6 auschwitz auschwitz PROPN gm80ht27413 29 7 any any DET gm80ht27413 29 8 practice practice NOUN gm80ht27413 29 9 of of ADP gm80ht27413 29 10 justification justification NOUN gm80ht27413 29 11 of of ADP gm80ht27413 29 12 the the DET gm80ht27413 29 13 suffering suffering NOUN gm80ht27413 29 14 of of ADP gm80ht27413 29 15 the the DET gm80ht27413 29 16 other other ADJ gm80ht27413 29 17 is be AUX gm80ht27413 29 18 not not PART gm80ht27413 29 19 only only ADV gm80ht27413 29 20 resisted resist VERB gm80ht27413 29 21 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 29 22 but but CCONJ gm80ht27413 29 23 interpreted interpret VERB gm80ht27413 29 24 as as ADP gm80ht27413 29 25 scandalous scandalous ADJ gm80ht27413 29 26 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 29 27 unethical unethical ADJ gm80ht27413 29 28 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 30 1 we we PRON gm80ht27413 30 2 will will AUX gm80ht27413 30 3 conclude conclude VERB gm80ht27413 30 4 the the DET gm80ht27413 30 5 dissertation dissertation NOUN gm80ht27413 30 6 by by ADP gm80ht27413 30 7 reflecting reflect VERB gm80ht27413 30 8 on on ADP gm80ht27413 30 9 the the DET gm80ht27413 30 10 significance significance NOUN gm80ht27413 30 11 of of ADP gm80ht27413 30 12 the the DET gm80ht27413 30 13 prophetic prophetic ADJ gm80ht27413 30 14 projects project NOUN gm80ht27413 30 15 of of ADP gm80ht27413 30 16 lì lì X gm80ht27413 30 17 © © X gm80ht27413 30 18 vinas vina NOUN gm80ht27413 30 19 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 30 20 metz metz VERB gm80ht27413 30 21 for for ADP gm80ht27413 30 22 contemporary contemporary ADJ gm80ht27413 30 23 theology theology NOUN gm80ht27413 30 24 by by ADP gm80ht27413 30 25 returning return VERB gm80ht27413 30 26 to to ADP gm80ht27413 30 27 the the DET gm80ht27413 30 28 juxtaposition juxtaposition NOUN gm80ht27413 30 29 that that PRON gm80ht27413 30 30 we we PRON gm80ht27413 30 31 pointed point VERB gm80ht27413 30 32 to to ADP gm80ht27413 30 33 in in ADP gm80ht27413 30 34 the the DET gm80ht27413 30 35 introduction introduction NOUN gm80ht27413 30 36 to to ADP gm80ht27413 30 37 chapters chapter NOUN gm80ht27413 30 38 two two NUM gm80ht27413 30 39 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 30 40 three three NUM gm80ht27413 30 41 between between ADP gm80ht27413 30 42 ethics ethic NOUN gm80ht27413 30 43 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 30 44 aesthetics aesthetic NOUN gm80ht27413 30 45 as as ADP gm80ht27413 30 46 the the DET gm80ht27413 30 47 privileged privileged ADJ gm80ht27413 30 48 post post ADJ gm80ht27413 30 49 - - ADJ gm80ht27413 30 50 metaphysical metaphysical ADJ gm80ht27413 30 51 discourses discourse NOUN gm80ht27413 30 52 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 31 1 in in ADP gm80ht27413 31 2 particular particular ADJ gm80ht27413 31 3 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 31 4 i i PRON gm80ht27413 31 5 want want VERB gm80ht27413 31 6 to to PART gm80ht27413 31 7 sharpen sharpen VERB gm80ht27413 31 8 the the DET gm80ht27413 31 9 terms term NOUN gm80ht27413 31 10 of of ADP gm80ht27413 31 11 the the DET gm80ht27413 31 12 debate debate NOUN gm80ht27413 31 13 between between ADP gm80ht27413 31 14 ethical ethical ADJ gm80ht27413 31 15 - - PUNCT gm80ht27413 31 16 prophetic prophetic ADJ gm80ht27413 31 17 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 31 18 aesthetic aesthetic ADJ gm80ht27413 31 19 - - PUNCT gm80ht27413 31 20 mystical mystical ADJ gm80ht27413 31 21 forms form NOUN gm80ht27413 31 22 of of ADP gm80ht27413 31 23 theology theology NOUN gm80ht27413 31 24 by by ADP gm80ht27413 31 25 placing place VERB gm80ht27413 31 26 the the DET gm80ht27413 31 27 projects project NOUN gm80ht27413 31 28 of of ADP gm80ht27413 31 29 lì lì X gm80ht27413 31 30 © © X gm80ht27413 31 31 vinas vina NOUN gm80ht27413 31 32 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 31 33 metz metz VERB gm80ht27413 31 34 in in ADP gm80ht27413 31 35 dialogue dialogue NOUN gm80ht27413 31 36 with with ADP gm80ht27413 31 37 the the DET gm80ht27413 31 38 aesthetic aesthetic ADJ gm80ht27413 31 39 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 31 40 mystical mystical ADJ gm80ht27413 31 41 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 31 42 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 31 43 sacramental sacramental ADJ gm80ht27413 31 44 retrievals retrieval NOUN gm80ht27413 31 45 found find VERB gm80ht27413 31 46 in in ADP gm80ht27413 31 47 the the DET gm80ht27413 31 48 theology theology NOUN gm80ht27413 31 49 of of ADP gm80ht27413 31 50 hans hans PROPN gm80ht27413 31 51 urs urs PROPN gm80ht27413 31 52 von von PROPN gm80ht27413 31 53 balthasar balthasar PROPN gm80ht27413 31 54 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 31 55 the the DET gm80ht27413 31 56 phenomenology phenomenology NOUN gm80ht27413 31 57 / / SYM gm80ht27413 31 58 theology theology NOUN gm80ht27413 31 59 of of ADP gm80ht27413 31 60 jean jean PROPN gm80ht27413 31 61 - - PUNCT gm80ht27413 31 62 luc luc PROPN gm80ht27413 31 63 marion marion NOUN gm80ht27413 31 64 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 32 1 while while SCONJ gm80ht27413 32 2 i i PRON gm80ht27413 32 3 ultimately ultimately ADV gm80ht27413 32 4 think think VERB gm80ht27413 32 5 that that SCONJ gm80ht27413 32 6 what what PRON gm80ht27413 32 7 is be AUX gm80ht27413 32 8 urgently urgently ADV gm80ht27413 32 9 needed need VERB gm80ht27413 32 10 in in ADP gm80ht27413 32 11 contemporary contemporary ADJ gm80ht27413 32 12 theology theology NOUN gm80ht27413 32 13 is be AUX gm80ht27413 32 14 a a DET gm80ht27413 32 15 renewed renew VERB gm80ht27413 32 16 mystical mystical ADJ gm80ht27413 32 17 - - PUNCT gm80ht27413 32 18 prophetic prophetic ADJ gm80ht27413 32 19 theology theology NOUN gm80ht27413 32 20 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 32 21 for for ADP gm80ht27413 32 22 our our PRON gm80ht27413 32 23 purposes purpose NOUN gm80ht27413 32 24 this this DET gm80ht27413 32 25 juxtaposition juxtaposition NOUN gm80ht27413 32 26 will will AUX gm80ht27413 32 27 serve serve VERB gm80ht27413 32 28 to to PART gm80ht27413 32 29 accent accent VERB gm80ht27413 32 30 the the DET gm80ht27413 32 31 distinctiveness distinctiveness NOUN gm80ht27413 32 32 of of ADP gm80ht27413 32 33 the the DET gm80ht27413 32 34 projects project NOUN gm80ht27413 32 35 of of ADP gm80ht27413 32 36 lì lì X gm80ht27413 32 37 © © X gm80ht27413 32 38 vinas vina NOUN gm80ht27413 32 39 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 32 40 metz metz VERB gm80ht27413 32 41 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 32 42 point point VERB gm80ht27413 32 43 to to ADP gm80ht27413 32 44 the the DET gm80ht27413 32 45 important important ADJ gm80ht27413 32 46 contribution contribution NOUN gm80ht27413 32 47 that that SCONJ gm80ht27413 32 48 prophetic prophetic ADJ gm80ht27413 32 49 theology theology NOUN gm80ht27413 32 50 offers offer VERB gm80ht27413 32 51 to to ADP gm80ht27413 32 52 debates debate NOUN gm80ht27413 32 53 in in ADP gm80ht27413 32 54 contemporary contemporary ADJ gm80ht27413 32 55 theology theology NOUN gm80ht27413 32 56 . . PUNCT gm80ht27413 33 1 after after ADP gm80ht27413 33 2 juxtaposing juxtapose VERB gm80ht27413 33 3 these these DET gm80ht27413 33 4 trajectories trajectory NOUN gm80ht27413 33 5 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 33 6 briefly briefly ADV gm80ht27413 33 7 analyzing analyze VERB gm80ht27413 33 8 what what PRON gm80ht27413 33 9 is be AUX gm80ht27413 33 10 at at ADP gm80ht27413 33 11 stake stake NOUN gm80ht27413 33 12 in in ADP gm80ht27413 33 13 their their PRON gm80ht27413 33 14 different different ADJ gm80ht27413 33 15 starting starting NOUN gm80ht27413 33 16 points point NOUN gm80ht27413 33 17 , , PUNCT gm80ht27413 33 18 i i PRON gm80ht27413 33 19 will will AUX gm80ht27413 33 20 then then ADV gm80ht27413 33 21 move move VERB gm80ht27413 33 22 to to PART gm80ht27413 33 23 offer offer VERB gm80ht27413 33 24 a a DET gm80ht27413 33 25 constructive constructive ADJ gm80ht27413 33 26 analysis analysis NOUN gm80ht27413 33 27 of of ADP gm80ht27413 33 28 the the DET gm80ht27413 33 29 focal focal ADJ gm80ht27413 33 30 points point NOUN gm80ht27413 33 31 of of ADP gm80ht27413 33 32 a a DET gm80ht27413 33 33 prophetic prophetic ADJ gm80ht27413 33 34 starting starting NOUN gm80ht27413 33 35 point point NOUN gm80ht27413 33 36 in in ADP gm80ht27413 33 37 theology theology NOUN gm80ht27413 33 38 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 33 39 conclude conclude VERB gm80ht27413 33 40 by by ADP gm80ht27413 33 41 bringing bring VERB gm80ht27413 33 42 lì lì ADV gm80ht27413 33 43 © © X gm80ht27413 33 44 vinas vina NOUN gm80ht27413 33 45 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 33 46 metz metz VERB gm80ht27413 33 47 into into ADP gm80ht27413 33 48 critical critical ADJ gm80ht27413 33 49 conversation conversation NOUN gm80ht27413 33 50 on on ADP gm80ht27413 33 51 the the DET gm80ht27413 33 52 issues issue NOUN gm80ht27413 33 53 an an DET gm80ht27413 33 54 ethics ethic NOUN gm80ht27413 33 55 of of ADP gm80ht27413 33 56 the the DET gm80ht27413 33 57 flesh flesh NOUN gm80ht27413 33 58 and and CCONJ gm80ht27413 33 59 the the DET gm80ht27413 33 60 ethical ethical ADJ gm80ht27413 33 61 status status NOUN gm80ht27413 33 62 of of ADP gm80ht27413 33 63 memory memory NOUN gm80ht27413 33 64 . . PUNCT