id sid tid token lemma pos dz010p11b69 1 1 what what PRON dz010p11b69 1 2 is be AUX dz010p11b69 1 3 there there ADV dz010p11b69 1 4 ? ? PUNCT dz010p11b69 2 1 this this PRON dz010p11b69 2 2 is be AUX dz010p11b69 2 3 the the DET dz010p11b69 2 4 ontological ontological ADJ dz010p11b69 2 5 question question NOUN dz010p11b69 2 6 . . PUNCT dz010p11b69 3 1 to to PART dz010p11b69 3 2 ask ask VERB dz010p11b69 3 3 the the DET dz010p11b69 3 4 ontological ontological ADJ dz010p11b69 3 5 question question NOUN dz010p11b69 3 6 is be AUX dz010p11b69 3 7 to to PART dz010p11b69 3 8 engage engage VERB dz010p11b69 3 9 in in ADP dz010p11b69 3 10 ontology ontology NOUN dz010p11b69 3 11 . . PUNCT dz010p11b69 4 1 one one PRON dz010p11b69 4 2 's 's PART dz010p11b69 4 3 views view NOUN dz010p11b69 4 4 about about ADP dz010p11b69 4 5 what what PRON dz010p11b69 4 6 the the DET dz010p11b69 4 7 question question NOUN dz010p11b69 4 8 means mean VERB dz010p11b69 4 9 and and CCONJ dz010p11b69 4 10 how how SCONJ dz010p11b69 4 11 to to PART dz010p11b69 4 12 go go VERB dz010p11b69 4 13 about about ADP dz010p11b69 4 14 answering answer VERB dz010p11b69 4 15 it it PRON dz010p11b69 4 16 is be AUX dz010p11b69 4 17 one one PRON dz010p11b69 4 18 's 's PART dz010p11b69 4 19 meta meta NOUN dz010p11b69 4 20 - - NOUN dz010p11b69 4 21 ontology ontology NOUN dz010p11b69 4 22 . . PUNCT dz010p11b69 5 1 in in ADP dz010p11b69 5 2 this this DET dz010p11b69 5 3 dissertation dissertation NOUN dz010p11b69 5 4 a a PRON dz010p11b69 5 5 particular particular ADJ dz010p11b69 5 6 meta meta NOUN dz010p11b69 5 7 - - NOUN dz010p11b69 5 8 ontology ontology NOUN dz010p11b69 5 9 will will AUX dz010p11b69 5 10 be be AUX dz010p11b69 5 11 in in ADP dz010p11b69 5 12 view view NOUN dz010p11b69 5 13 : : PUNCT dz010p11b69 5 14 quine quine PROPN dz010p11b69 5 15 's 's PART dz010p11b69 5 16 . . PUNCT dz010p11b69 6 1 call call VERB dz010p11b69 6 2 it it PRON dz010p11b69 6 3 ` ` PUNCT dz010p11b69 6 4 quinean quinean ADJ dz010p11b69 6 5 meta meta NOUN dz010p11b69 6 6 - - NOUN dz010p11b69 6 7 ontology ontology NOUN dz010p11b69 6 8 . . PUNCT dz010p11b69 6 9 ' ' PUNCT dz010p11b69 7 1 but but CCONJ dz010p11b69 7 2 there there PRON dz010p11b69 7 3 is be VERB dz010p11b69 7 4 confusion confusion NOUN dz010p11b69 7 5 over over ADP dz010p11b69 7 6 how how SCONJ dz010p11b69 7 7 quine quine ADJ dz010p11b69 7 8 intended intend VERB dz010p11b69 7 9 ontology ontology NOUN dz010p11b69 7 10 to to PART dz010p11b69 7 11 be be AUX dz010p11b69 7 12 done do VERB dz010p11b69 7 13 , , PUNCT dz010p11b69 7 14 enough enough ADJ dz010p11b69 7 15 confusion confusion NOUN dz010p11b69 7 16 to to PART dz010p11b69 7 17 warrant warrant VERB dz010p11b69 7 18 a a DET dz010p11b69 7 19 very very ADV dz010p11b69 7 20 close close ADJ dz010p11b69 7 21 look look NOUN dz010p11b69 7 22 at at ADP dz010p11b69 7 23 his his PRON dz010p11b69 7 24 meta meta NOUN dz010p11b69 7 25 - - NOUN dz010p11b69 7 26 ontology ontology NOUN dz010p11b69 7 27 . . PUNCT dz010p11b69 8 1 one one NUM dz010p11b69 8 2 of of ADP dz010p11b69 8 3 the the DET dz010p11b69 8 4 primary primary ADJ dz010p11b69 8 5 goals goal NOUN dz010p11b69 8 6 of of ADP dz010p11b69 8 7 this this DET dz010p11b69 8 8 dissertation dissertation NOUN dz010p11b69 8 9 then then ADV dz010p11b69 8 10 is be AUX dz010p11b69 8 11 to to PART dz010p11b69 8 12 clearly clearly ADV dz010p11b69 8 13 present present VERB dz010p11b69 8 14 quinean quinean ADJ dz010p11b69 8 15 meta meta NOUN dz010p11b69 8 16 - - NOUN dz010p11b69 8 17 ontology ontology NOUN dz010p11b69 8 18 , , PUNCT dz010p11b69 8 19 showing show VERB dz010p11b69 8 20 just just ADV dz010p11b69 8 21 what what PRON dz010p11b69 8 22 it it PRON dz010p11b69 8 23 is be AUX dz010p11b69 8 24 --- --- PUNCT dz010p11b69 8 25 and and CCONJ dz010p11b69 8 26 is be AUX dz010p11b69 8 27 n't not PART dz010p11b69 8 28 . . PUNCT dz010p11b69 9 1 another another DET dz010p11b69 9 2 goal goal NOUN dz010p11b69 9 3 is be AUX dz010p11b69 9 4 to to PART dz010p11b69 9 5 show show VERB dz010p11b69 9 6 how how SCONJ dz010p11b69 9 7 quinean quinean ADJ dz010p11b69 9 8 meta meta NOUN dz010p11b69 9 9 - - NOUN dz010p11b69 9 10 ontology ontology NOUN dz010p11b69 9 11 is be AUX dz010p11b69 9 12 used use VERB dz010p11b69 9 13 , , PUNCT dz010p11b69 9 14 particularly particularly ADV dz010p11b69 9 15 in in ADP dz010p11b69 9 16 arguments argument NOUN dz010p11b69 9 17 for for ADP dz010p11b69 9 18 the the DET dz010p11b69 9 19 existence existence NOUN dz010p11b69 9 20 of of ADP dz010p11b69 9 21 abstract abstract ADJ dz010p11b69 9 22 objects object NOUN dz010p11b69 9 23 . . PUNCT dz010p11b69 10 1 so so ADV dz010p11b69 10 2 after after ADP dz010p11b69 10 3 carefully carefully ADV dz010p11b69 10 4 presenting present VERB dz010p11b69 10 5 quinean quinean ADJ dz010p11b69 10 6 meta meta NOUN dz010p11b69 10 7 - - NOUN dz010p11b69 10 8 ontology ontology NOUN dz010p11b69 10 9 in in ADP dz010p11b69 10 10 a a DET dz010p11b69 10 11 way way NOUN dz010p11b69 10 12 that that PRON dz010p11b69 10 13 shows show VERB dz010p11b69 10 14 it it PRON dz010p11b69 10 15 's be AUX dz010p11b69 10 16 key key ADJ dz010p11b69 10 17 features feature NOUN dz010p11b69 10 18 as as ADV dz010p11b69 10 19 well well ADV dz010p11b69 10 20 as as ADP dz010p11b69 10 21 merely merely ADV dz010p11b69 10 22 putative putative ADJ dz010p11b69 10 23 features feature NOUN dz010p11b69 10 24 , , PUNCT dz010p11b69 10 25 i i PRON dz010p11b69 10 26 provide provide VERB dz010p11b69 10 27 evidence evidence NOUN dz010p11b69 10 28 that that SCONJ dz010p11b69 10 29 the the DET dz010p11b69 10 30 arguments argument NOUN dz010p11b69 10 31 for for ADP dz010p11b69 10 32 platonism platonism NOUN dz010p11b69 10 33 which which PRON dz010p11b69 10 34 use use VERB dz010p11b69 10 35 quinean quinean ADJ dz010p11b69 10 36 meta meta NOUN dz010p11b69 10 37 - - NOUN dz010p11b69 10 38 ontology ontology NOUN dz010p11b69 10 39 are be AUX dz010p11b69 10 40 really really ADV dz010p11b69 10 41 indispensability indispensability NOUN dz010p11b69 10 42 - - PUNCT dz010p11b69 10 43 style style NOUN dz010p11b69 10 44 arguments argument NOUN dz010p11b69 10 45 . . PUNCT dz010p11b69 11 1 i i PRON dz010p11b69 11 2 do do VERB dz010p11b69 11 3 this this PRON dz010p11b69 11 4 by by ADP dz010p11b69 11 5 showing show VERB dz010p11b69 11 6 how how SCONJ dz010p11b69 11 7 both both CCONJ dz010p11b69 11 8 peter peter PROPN dz010p11b69 11 9 van van PROPN dz010p11b69 11 10 inwagen inwagen PROPN dz010p11b69 11 11 's 's PART dz010p11b69 11 12 argument argument NOUN dz010p11b69 11 13 for for ADP dz010p11b69 11 14 properties property NOUN dz010p11b69 11 15 and and CCONJ dz010p11b69 11 16 hilary hilary ADJ dz010p11b69 11 17 putnam putnam NOUN dz010p11b69 11 18 's 's PART dz010p11b69 11 19 argument argument NOUN dz010p11b69 11 20 for for ADP dz010p11b69 11 21 mathematical mathematical ADJ dz010p11b69 11 22 objects object NOUN dz010p11b69 11 23 are be AUX dz010p11b69 11 24 species specie NOUN dz010p11b69 11 25 of of ADP dz010p11b69 11 26 the the DET dz010p11b69 11 27 same same ADJ dz010p11b69 11 28 genus.once genus.once NOUN dz010p11b69 11 29 this this PRON dz010p11b69 11 30 is be AUX dz010p11b69 11 31 done do VERB dz010p11b69 11 32 , , PUNCT dz010p11b69 11 33 the the DET dz010p11b69 11 34 philosophical philosophical ADJ dz010p11b69 11 35 geography geography NOUN dz010p11b69 11 36 surrounding surround VERB dz010p11b69 11 37 quinean quinean ADJ dz010p11b69 11 38 meta meta NOUN dz010p11b69 11 39 - - NOUN dz010p11b69 11 40 ontology ontology NOUN dz010p11b69 11 41 ( ( PUNCT dz010p11b69 11 42 the the DET dz010p11b69 11 43 meta meta NOUN dz010p11b69 11 44 - - NOUN dz010p11b69 11 45 ontology ontology NOUN dz010p11b69 11 46 proper proper ADJ dz010p11b69 11 47 as as ADV dz010p11b69 11 48 well well ADV dz010p11b69 11 49 as as ADP dz010p11b69 11 50 its its PRON dz010p11b69 11 51 use use NOUN dz010p11b69 11 52 in in ADP dz010p11b69 11 53 arguments argument NOUN dz010p11b69 11 54 for for ADP dz010p11b69 11 55 platonism platonism NOUN dz010p11b69 11 56 ) ) PUNCT dz010p11b69 11 57 should should AUX dz010p11b69 11 58 be be AUX dz010p11b69 11 59 apparent apparent ADJ dz010p11b69 11 60 . . PUNCT dz010p11b69 12 1 given give VERB dz010p11b69 12 2 this this DET dz010p11b69 12 3 better well ADJ dz010p11b69 12 4 view view NOUN dz010p11b69 12 5 , , PUNCT dz010p11b69 12 6 i i PRON dz010p11b69 12 7 will will AUX dz010p11b69 12 8 then then ADV dz010p11b69 12 9 address address VERB dz010p11b69 12 10 four four NUM dz010p11b69 12 11 important important ADJ dz010p11b69 12 12 objections objection NOUN dz010p11b69 12 13 to to ADP dz010p11b69 12 14 both both PRON dz010p11b69 12 15 quinean quinean ADJ dz010p11b69 12 16 meta meta NOUN dz010p11b69 12 17 - - NOUN dz010p11b69 12 18 ontology ontology NOUN dz010p11b69 12 19 and and CCONJ dz010p11b69 12 20 the the DET dz010p11b69 12 21 indispensability indispensability NOUN dz010p11b69 12 22 - - PUNCT dz010p11b69 12 23 style style NOUN dz010p11b69 12 24 argument argument NOUN dz010p11b69 12 25 for for ADP dz010p11b69 12 26 abstracta abstracta NOUN dz010p11b69 12 27 . . PUNCT dz010p11b69 13 1 most most ADJ dz010p11b69 13 2 of of ADP dz010p11b69 13 3 these these DET dz010p11b69 13 4 objections objection NOUN dz010p11b69 13 5 , , PUNCT dz010p11b69 13 6 it it PRON dz010p11b69 13 7 turns turn VERB dz010p11b69 13 8 out out ADP dz010p11b69 13 9 , , PUNCT dz010p11b69 13 10 focus focus VERB dz010p11b69 13 11 on on ADP dz010p11b69 13 12 the the DET dz010p11b69 13 13 uniquely uniquely ADV dz010p11b69 13 14 quinean quinean ADJ dz010p11b69 13 15 views view NOUN dz010p11b69 13 16 of of ADP dz010p11b69 13 17 existence existence NOUN dz010p11b69 13 18 and and CCONJ dz010p11b69 13 19 quantification quantification NOUN dz010p11b69 13 20 . . PUNCT dz010p11b69 14 1 and and CCONJ dz010p11b69 14 2 all all PRON dz010p11b69 14 3 of of ADP dz010p11b69 14 4 them they PRON dz010p11b69 14 5 focus focus VERB dz010p11b69 14 6 on on ADP dz010p11b69 14 7 particularly particularly ADV dz010p11b69 14 8 subtle subtle ADJ dz010p11b69 14 9 aspects aspect NOUN dz010p11b69 14 10 of of ADP dz010p11b69 14 11 language language NOUN dz010p11b69 14 12 and and CCONJ dz010p11b69 14 13 so so ADV dz010p11b69 14 14 suggest suggest VERB dz010p11b69 14 15 that that SCONJ dz010p11b69 14 16 quinean quinean ADJ dz010p11b69 14 17 meta meta NOUN dz010p11b69 14 18 - - NOUN dz010p11b69 14 19 ontology ontology NOUN dz010p11b69 14 20 may may AUX dz010p11b69 14 21 just just ADV dz010p11b69 14 22 be be AUX dz010p11b69 14 23 too too ADV dz010p11b69 14 24 heavy heavy ADV dz010p11b69 14 25 - - PUNCT dz010p11b69 14 26 handed handed ADJ dz010p11b69 14 27 when when SCONJ dz010p11b69 14 28 it it PRON dz010p11b69 14 29 comes come VERB dz010p11b69 14 30 to to ADP dz010p11b69 14 31 interpreting interpret VERB dz010p11b69 14 32 our our PRON dz010p11b69 14 33 sentences sentence NOUN dz010p11b69 14 34 . . PUNCT dz010p11b69 15 1 in in ADP dz010p11b69 15 2 the the DET dz010p11b69 15 3 last last ADJ dz010p11b69 15 4 chapter chapter NOUN dz010p11b69 15 5 , , PUNCT dz010p11b69 15 6 i i PRON dz010p11b69 15 7 make make VERB dz010p11b69 15 8 a a DET dz010p11b69 15 9 proposal proposal NOUN dz010p11b69 15 10 for for ADP dz010p11b69 15 11 future future ADJ dz010p11b69 15 12 work work NOUN dz010p11b69 15 13 , , PUNCT dz010p11b69 15 14 work work VERB dz010p11b69 15 15 for for ADP dz010p11b69 15 16 a a DET dz010p11b69 15 17 nominalism nominalism NOUN dz010p11b69 15 18 that that PRON dz010p11b69 15 19 takes take VERB dz010p11b69 15 20 the the DET dz010p11b69 15 21 subtleties subtlety NOUN dz010p11b69 15 22 of of ADP dz010p11b69 15 23 natural natural ADJ dz010p11b69 15 24 language language NOUN dz010p11b69 15 25 quite quite ADV dz010p11b69 15 26 seriously seriously ADV dz010p11b69 15 27 . . PUNCT dz010p11b69 16 1 i i PRON dz010p11b69 16 2 propose propose VERB dz010p11b69 16 3 that that SCONJ dz010p11b69 16 4 a a DET dz010p11b69 16 5 type type NOUN dz010p11b69 16 6 of of ADP dz010p11b69 16 7 fictionalism fictionalism NOUN dz010p11b69 16 8 might might AUX dz010p11b69 16 9 be be AUX dz010p11b69 16 10 the the DET dz010p11b69 16 11 answer answer NOUN dz010p11b69 16 12 . . PUNCT dz010p11b69 17 1 such such DET dz010p11b69 17 2 a a DET dz010p11b69 17 3 view view NOUN dz010p11b69 17 4 needs need VERB dz010p11b69 17 5 a a DET dz010p11b69 17 6 lot lot NOUN dz010p11b69 17 7 of of ADP dz010p11b69 17 8 attention attention NOUN dz010p11b69 17 9 though though ADV dz010p11b69 17 10 and and CCONJ dz010p11b69 17 11 so so ADV dz010p11b69 17 12 i i PRON dz010p11b69 17 13 point point VERB dz010p11b69 17 14 out out ADP dz010p11b69 17 15 four four NUM dz010p11b69 17 16 of of ADP dz010p11b69 17 17 the the DET dz010p11b69 17 18 most most ADV dz010p11b69 17 19 salient salient ADJ dz010p11b69 17 20 problems problem NOUN dz010p11b69 17 21 for for ADP dz010p11b69 17 22 fictionalism fictionalism NOUN dz010p11b69 17 23 , , PUNCT dz010p11b69 17 24 also also ADV dz010p11b69 17 25 alluding allude VERB dz010p11b69 17 26 to to ADP dz010p11b69 17 27 where where SCONJ dz010p11b69 17 28 the the DET dz010p11b69 17 29 solutions solution NOUN dz010p11b69 17 30 to to ADP dz010p11b69 17 31 these these DET dz010p11b69 17 32 problems problem NOUN dz010p11b69 17 33 lay lay VERB dz010p11b69 17 34 . . PUNCT