id sid tid token lemma pos 9593tt46s16 1 1 i i PRON 9593tt46s16 1 2 present present VERB 9593tt46s16 1 3 a a DET 9593tt46s16 1 4 systematic systematic ADJ 9593tt46s16 1 5 case case NOUN 9593tt46s16 1 6 for for ADP 9593tt46s16 1 7 all all DET 9593tt46s16 1 8 - - PUNCT 9593tt46s16 1 9 falsism falsism NOUN 9593tt46s16 1 10 – – PUNCT 9593tt46s16 1 11 the the DET 9593tt46s16 1 12 view view NOUN 9593tt46s16 1 13 that that SCONJ 9593tt46s16 1 14 all all DET 9593tt46s16 1 15 undetermined undetermined ADJ 9593tt46s16 1 16 future future ADJ 9593tt46s16 1 17 contingent contingent ADJ 9593tt46s16 1 18 propositions proposition NOUN 9593tt46s16 1 19 are be AUX 9593tt46s16 1 20 false false ADJ 9593tt46s16 1 21 . . PUNCT 9593tt46s16 2 1 i i PRON 9593tt46s16 2 2 show show VERB 9593tt46s16 2 3 that that SCONJ 9593tt46s16 2 4 all all DET 9593tt46s16 2 5 - - PUNCT 9593tt46s16 2 6 falsism falsism NOUN 9593tt46s16 2 7 is be AUX 9593tt46s16 2 8 not not PART 9593tt46s16 2 9 only only ADV 9593tt46s16 2 10 defensible defensible ADJ 9593tt46s16 2 11 , , PUNCT 9593tt46s16 2 12 but but CCONJ 9593tt46s16 2 13 attractive attractive ADJ 9593tt46s16 2 14 . . PUNCT 9593tt46s16 3 1 it it PRON 9593tt46s16 3 2 allows allow VERB 9593tt46s16 3 3 one one NUM 9593tt46s16 3 4 to to PART 9593tt46s16 3 5 keep keep VERB 9593tt46s16 3 6 a a DET 9593tt46s16 3 7 wide wide ADJ 9593tt46s16 3 8 range range NOUN 9593tt46s16 3 9 of of ADP 9593tt46s16 3 10 philosophical philosophical ADJ 9593tt46s16 3 11 intuitions intuition NOUN 9593tt46s16 3 12 and and CCONJ 9593tt46s16 3 13 views view NOUN 9593tt46s16 3 14 , , PUNCT 9593tt46s16 3 15 including include VERB 9593tt46s16 3 16 bivalence bivalence NOUN 9593tt46s16 3 17 , , PUNCT 9593tt46s16 3 18 classical classical ADJ 9593tt46s16 3 19 logic logic NOUN 9593tt46s16 3 20 , , PUNCT 9593tt46s16 3 21 libertarianism libertarianism NOUN 9593tt46s16 3 22 about about ADP 9593tt46s16 3 23 free free ADJ 9593tt46s16 3 24 will will NOUN 9593tt46s16 3 25 , , PUNCT 9593tt46s16 3 26 the the DET 9593tt46s16 3 27 fixity fixity NOUN 9593tt46s16 3 28 of of ADP 9593tt46s16 3 29 the the DET 9593tt46s16 3 30 past past NOUN 9593tt46s16 3 31 , , PUNCT 9593tt46s16 3 32 the the DET 9593tt46s16 3 33 openness openness NOUN 9593tt46s16 3 34 of of ADP 9593tt46s16 3 35 the the DET 9593tt46s16 3 36 future future NOUN 9593tt46s16 3 37 , , PUNCT 9593tt46s16 3 38 non non ADJ 9593tt46s16 3 39 - - NOUN 9593tt46s16 3 40 existentialism existentialism NOUN 9593tt46s16 3 41 about about ADP 9593tt46s16 3 42 propositions proposition NOUN 9593tt46s16 3 43 , , PUNCT 9593tt46s16 3 44 grounding ground VERB 9593tt46s16 3 45 for for ADP 9593tt46s16 3 46 truth truth NOUN 9593tt46s16 3 47 of of ADP 9593tt46s16 3 48 propositions proposition NOUN 9593tt46s16 3 49 about about ADP 9593tt46s16 3 50 the the DET 9593tt46s16 3 51 past past NOUN 9593tt46s16 3 52 , , PUNCT 9593tt46s16 3 53 truth truth NOUN 9593tt46s16 3 54 supervenes supervene VERB 9593tt46s16 3 55 on on ADP 9593tt46s16 3 56 being be AUX 9593tt46s16 3 57 , , PUNCT 9593tt46s16 3 58 and and CCONJ 9593tt46s16 3 59 modal modal NOUN 9593tt46s16 3 60 realism realism NOUN 9593tt46s16 3 61 , , PUNCT 9593tt46s16 3 62 all all PRON 9593tt46s16 3 63 while while SCONJ 9593tt46s16 3 64 being be AUX 9593tt46s16 3 65 a a DET 9593tt46s16 3 66 presentist presentist ADJ 9593tt46s16 3 67 par par NOUN 9593tt46s16 3 68 excellence excellence PROPN 9593tt46s16 3 69 . . PUNCT 9593tt46s16 4 1 presentism presentism NOUN 9593tt46s16 4 2 , , PUNCT 9593tt46s16 4 3 the the DET 9593tt46s16 4 4 view view NOUN 9593tt46s16 4 5 that that SCONJ 9593tt46s16 4 6 there there PRON 9593tt46s16 4 7 are be VERB 9593tt46s16 4 8 no no DET 9593tt46s16 4 9 non non ADJ 9593tt46s16 4 10 - - ADJ 9593tt46s16 4 11 present present ADJ 9593tt46s16 4 12 objects object NOUN 9593tt46s16 4 13 , , PUNCT 9593tt46s16 4 14 is be AUX 9593tt46s16 4 15 objected object VERB 9593tt46s16 4 16 to to ADP 9593tt46s16 4 17 in in ADP 9593tt46s16 4 18 part part NOUN 9593tt46s16 4 19 because because SCONJ 9593tt46s16 4 20 detractors detractor NOUN 9593tt46s16 4 21 think think VERB 9593tt46s16 4 22 presentism presentism NOUN 9593tt46s16 4 23 requires require VERB 9593tt46s16 4 24 one one PRON 9593tt46s16 4 25 to to PART 9593tt46s16 4 26 give give VERB 9593tt46s16 4 27 up up ADP 9593tt46s16 4 28 at at ADV 9593tt46s16 4 29 least least ADJ 9593tt46s16 4 30 one one NUM 9593tt46s16 4 31 of of ADP 9593tt46s16 4 32 the the DET 9593tt46s16 4 33 previously previously ADV 9593tt46s16 4 34 listed list VERB 9593tt46s16 4 35 intuitive intuitive ADJ 9593tt46s16 4 36 positions position NOUN 9593tt46s16 4 37 . . PUNCT 9593tt46s16 5 1 these these DET 9593tt46s16 5 2 objections objection NOUN 9593tt46s16 5 3 assume assume VERB 9593tt46s16 5 4 that that SCONJ 9593tt46s16 5 5 some some DET 9593tt46s16 5 6 undetermined undetermined ADJ 9593tt46s16 5 7 future future ADJ 9593tt46s16 5 8 contingents contingent NOUN 9593tt46s16 5 9 must must AUX 9593tt46s16 5 10 be be AUX 9593tt46s16 5 11 true true ADJ 9593tt46s16 5 12 . . PUNCT 9593tt46s16 6 1 in in ADP 9593tt46s16 6 2 chapter chapter NOUN 9593tt46s16 6 3 one one NUM 9593tt46s16 6 4 , , PUNCT 9593tt46s16 6 5 i i PRON 9593tt46s16 6 6 show show VERB 9593tt46s16 6 7 this this DET 9593tt46s16 6 8 assumption assumption NOUN 9593tt46s16 6 9 must must AUX 9593tt46s16 6 10 go go VERB 9593tt46s16 6 11 – – PUNCT 9593tt46s16 6 12 all all DET 9593tt46s16 6 13 - - PUNCT 9593tt46s16 6 14 falsism falsism NOUN 9593tt46s16 6 15 is be AUX 9593tt46s16 6 16 an an DET 9593tt46s16 6 17 option option NOUN 9593tt46s16 6 18 . . PUNCT 9593tt46s16 7 1 the the DET 9593tt46s16 7 2 common common ADJ 9593tt46s16 7 3 objection objection NOUN 9593tt46s16 7 4 that that SCONJ 9593tt46s16 7 5 all all DET 9593tt46s16 7 6 - - PUNCT 9593tt46s16 7 7 falsism falsism NOUN 9593tt46s16 7 8 is be AUX 9593tt46s16 7 9 a a DET 9593tt46s16 7 10 contradictory contradictory ADJ 9593tt46s16 7 11 position position NOUN 9593tt46s16 7 12 fails fail VERB 9593tt46s16 7 13 . . PUNCT 9593tt46s16 8 1 the the DET 9593tt46s16 8 2 all all DET 9593tt46s16 8 3 - - PUNCT 9593tt46s16 8 4 falsist falsist NOUN 9593tt46s16 8 5 maintains maintain VERB 9593tt46s16 8 6 that that SCONJ 9593tt46s16 8 7 propositions proposition NOUN 9593tt46s16 8 8 about about ADP 9593tt46s16 8 9 the the DET 9593tt46s16 8 10 future future NOUN 9593tt46s16 8 11 – – PUNCT 9593tt46s16 8 12 will will AUX 9593tt46s16 8 13 propositions proposition NOUN 9593tt46s16 8 14 – – PUNCT 9593tt46s16 8 15 behave behave VERB 9593tt46s16 8 16 like like ADP 9593tt46s16 8 17 modals modal NOUN 9593tt46s16 8 18 . . PUNCT 9593tt46s16 9 1 ' ' PUNCT 9593tt46s16 9 2 will will AUX 9593tt46s16 9 3 ' ' PUNCT 9593tt46s16 9 4 is be AUX 9593tt46s16 9 5 a a DET 9593tt46s16 9 6 kind kind NOUN 9593tt46s16 9 7 of of ADP 9593tt46s16 9 8 necessity necessity NOUN 9593tt46s16 9 9 operator operator NOUN 9593tt46s16 9 10 . . PUNCT 9593tt46s16 10 1 in in ADP 9593tt46s16 10 2 chapter chapter NOUN 9593tt46s16 10 3 two two NUM 9593tt46s16 10 4 , , PUNCT 9593tt46s16 10 5 after after ADP 9593tt46s16 10 6 showing show VERB 9593tt46s16 10 7 that that SCONJ 9593tt46s16 10 8 the the DET 9593tt46s16 10 9 all all PRON 9593tt46s16 10 10 - - PUNCT 9593tt46s16 10 11 falsist falsist NOUN 9593tt46s16 10 12 can can AUX 9593tt46s16 10 13 account account VERB 9593tt46s16 10 14 for for ADP 9593tt46s16 10 15 truths truth NOUN 9593tt46s16 10 16 about about ADP 9593tt46s16 10 17 the the DET 9593tt46s16 10 18 past past NOUN 9593tt46s16 10 19 , , PUNCT 9593tt46s16 10 20 i i PRON 9593tt46s16 10 21 argue argue VERB 9593tt46s16 10 22 that that SCONJ 9593tt46s16 10 23 if if SCONJ 9593tt46s16 10 24 one one PRON 9593tt46s16 10 25 thinks think VERB 9593tt46s16 10 26 ' ' PUNCT 9593tt46s16 10 27 will will AUX 9593tt46s16 10 28 ' ' PUNCT 9593tt46s16 10 29 a a DET 9593tt46s16 10 30 kind kind NOUN 9593tt46s16 10 31 of of ADP 9593tt46s16 10 32 necessity necessity NOUN 9593tt46s16 10 33 operator operator NOUN 9593tt46s16 10 34 , , PUNCT 9593tt46s16 10 35 one one PRON 9593tt46s16 10 36 should should AUX 9593tt46s16 10 37 reduce reduce VERB 9593tt46s16 10 38 times time NOUN 9593tt46s16 10 39 to to ADP 9593tt46s16 10 40 possible possible ADJ 9593tt46s16 10 41 worlds world NOUN 9593tt46s16 10 42 . . PUNCT 9593tt46s16 11 1 i i PRON 9593tt46s16 11 2 demonstrate demonstrate VERB 9593tt46s16 11 3 this this DET 9593tt46s16 11 4 reduction reduction NOUN 9593tt46s16 11 5 and and CCONJ 9593tt46s16 11 6 show show VERB 9593tt46s16 11 7 that that SCONJ 9593tt46s16 11 8 it it PRON 9593tt46s16 11 9 nicely nicely ADV 9593tt46s16 11 10 accounts account VERB 9593tt46s16 11 11 for for ADP 9593tt46s16 11 12 similarities similarity NOUN 9593tt46s16 11 13 between between ADP 9593tt46s16 11 14 times time NOUN 9593tt46s16 11 15 and and CCONJ 9593tt46s16 11 16 possible possible ADJ 9593tt46s16 11 17 worlds world NOUN 9593tt46s16 11 18 . . PUNCT 9593tt46s16 12 1 this this DET 9593tt46s16 12 2 reduction reduction NOUN 9593tt46s16 12 3 allows allow VERB 9593tt46s16 12 4 the the DET 9593tt46s16 12 5 all all ADV 9593tt46s16 12 6 - - PUNCT 9593tt46s16 12 7 falsist falsist NOUN 9593tt46s16 12 8 , , PUNCT 9593tt46s16 12 9 unlike unlike ADP 9593tt46s16 12 10 other other ADJ 9593tt46s16 12 11 open open ADJ 9593tt46s16 12 12 future future ADJ 9593tt46s16 12 13 theorists theorist NOUN 9593tt46s16 12 14 , , PUNCT 9593tt46s16 12 15 to to PART 9593tt46s16 12 16 be be AUX 9593tt46s16 12 17 a a DET 9593tt46s16 12 18 modal modal ADJ 9593tt46s16 12 19 realist.all realist.all SPACE 9593tt46s16 12 20 - - PUNCT 9593tt46s16 12 21 falsism falsism NOUN 9593tt46s16 12 22 proves prove VERB 9593tt46s16 12 23 not not PART 9593tt46s16 12 24 only only ADV 9593tt46s16 12 25 advantageous advantageous ADJ 9593tt46s16 12 26 to to ADP 9593tt46s16 12 27 presentists presentist NOUN 9593tt46s16 12 28 , , PUNCT 9593tt46s16 12 29 but but CCONJ 9593tt46s16 12 30 turns turn VERB 9593tt46s16 12 31 out out ADP 9593tt46s16 12 32 to to PART 9593tt46s16 12 33 be be AUX 9593tt46s16 12 34 the the DET 9593tt46s16 12 35 best well ADV 9593tt46s16 12 36 open open ADJ 9593tt46s16 12 37 future future ADJ 9593tt46s16 12 38 view view NOUN 9593tt46s16 12 39 ( ( PUNCT 9593tt46s16 12 40 ofv ofv PROPN 9593tt46s16 12 41 ) ) PUNCT 9593tt46s16 12 42 . . PUNCT 9593tt46s16 13 1 there there PRON 9593tt46s16 13 2 is be VERB 9593tt46s16 13 3 currently currently ADV 9593tt46s16 13 4 widespread widespread ADJ 9593tt46s16 13 5 disagreement disagreement NOUN 9593tt46s16 13 6 regarding regard VERB 9593tt46s16 13 7 requirements requirement NOUN 9593tt46s16 13 8 for for ADP 9593tt46s16 13 9 ofvs ofvs NOUN 9593tt46s16 13 10 . . PUNCT 9593tt46s16 14 1 in in ADP 9593tt46s16 14 2 chapter chapter NOUN 9593tt46s16 14 3 three three NUM 9593tt46s16 14 4 , , PUNCT 9593tt46s16 14 5 i i PRON 9593tt46s16 14 6 settle settle VERB 9593tt46s16 14 7 the the DET 9593tt46s16 14 8 dispute dispute NOUN 9593tt46s16 14 9 . . PUNCT 9593tt46s16 15 1 ofvs ofvs PROPN 9593tt46s16 15 2 deny deny VERB 9593tt46s16 15 3 the the DET 9593tt46s16 15 4 tense tense ADJ 9593tt46s16 15 5 logic logic NOUN 9593tt46s16 15 6 axiom axiom NOUN 9593tt46s16 15 7 ( ( PUNCT 9593tt46s16 15 8 k k X 9593tt46s16 15 9 ): ): PUNCT 9593tt46s16 15 10 p p PROPN 9593tt46s16 15 11 → → SYM 9593tt46s16 15 12 hfp hfp PROPN 9593tt46s16 15 13 ( ( PUNCT 9593tt46s16 15 14 if if SCONJ 9593tt46s16 15 15 p p PROPN 9593tt46s16 15 16 , , PUNCT 9593tt46s16 15 17 then then ADV 9593tt46s16 15 18 it it PRON 9593tt46s16 15 19 has have AUX 9593tt46s16 15 20 always always ADV 9593tt46s16 15 21 been be AUX 9593tt46s16 15 22 the the DET 9593tt46s16 15 23 case case NOUN 9593tt46s16 15 24 that that SCONJ 9593tt46s16 15 25 it it PRON 9593tt46s16 15 26 will will AUX 9593tt46s16 15 27 be be AUX 9593tt46s16 15 28 that that DET 9593tt46s16 15 29 p p NOUN 9593tt46s16 15 30 ) ) PUNCT 9593tt46s16 15 31 . . PUNCT 9593tt46s16 16 1 with with ADP 9593tt46s16 16 2 this this DET 9593tt46s16 16 3 requirement requirement NOUN 9593tt46s16 16 4 in in ADP 9593tt46s16 16 5 hand hand NOUN 9593tt46s16 16 6 , , PUNCT 9593tt46s16 16 7 i i PRON 9593tt46s16 16 8 show show VERB 9593tt46s16 16 9 all all PRON 9593tt46s16 16 10 - - PUNCT 9593tt46s16 16 11 falsism falsism NOUN 9593tt46s16 16 12 superior superior NOUN 9593tt46s16 16 13 to to ADP 9593tt46s16 16 14 all all PRON 9593tt46s16 16 15 rivals.in rivals.in NUM 9593tt46s16 16 16 chapter chapter NOUN 9593tt46s16 16 17 four four NUM 9593tt46s16 16 18 , , PUNCT 9593tt46s16 16 19 i i PRON 9593tt46s16 16 20 answer answer VERB 9593tt46s16 16 21 epistemological epistemological ADJ 9593tt46s16 16 22 and and CCONJ 9593tt46s16 16 23 pragmatic pragmatic ADJ 9593tt46s16 16 24 objections objection NOUN 9593tt46s16 16 25 . . PUNCT 9593tt46s16 17 1 i i PRON 9593tt46s16 17 2 present present VERB 9593tt46s16 17 3 the the DET 9593tt46s16 17 4 beginnings beginning NOUN 9593tt46s16 17 5 of of ADP 9593tt46s16 17 6 semantics semantic NOUN 9593tt46s16 17 7 which which PRON 9593tt46s16 17 8 answers answer VERB 9593tt46s16 17 9 the the DET 9593tt46s16 17 10 objections objection NOUN 9593tt46s16 17 11 . . PUNCT 9593tt46s16 18 1 the the DET 9593tt46s16 18 2 all all PRON 9593tt46s16 18 3 - - PUNCT 9593tt46s16 18 4 falsist falsist NOUN 9593tt46s16 18 5 can can AUX 9593tt46s16 18 6 account account VERB 9593tt46s16 18 7 for for ADP 9593tt46s16 18 8 assertions assertion NOUN 9593tt46s16 18 9 people people NOUN 9593tt46s16 18 10 commonly commonly ADV 9593tt46s16 18 11 make make VERB 9593tt46s16 18 12 . . PUNCT 9593tt46s16 19 1 in in ADP 9593tt46s16 19 2 addition addition NOUN 9593tt46s16 19 3 , , PUNCT 9593tt46s16 19 4 i i PRON 9593tt46s16 19 5 show show VERB 9593tt46s16 19 6 that that SCONJ 9593tt46s16 19 7 all all DET 9593tt46s16 19 8 - - PUNCT 9593tt46s16 19 9 falsism falsism NOUN 9593tt46s16 19 10 provides provide VERB 9593tt46s16 19 11 a a DET 9593tt46s16 19 12 useful useful ADJ 9593tt46s16 19 13 explanation explanation NOUN 9593tt46s16 19 14 of of ADP 9593tt46s16 19 15 our our PRON 9593tt46s16 19 16 behavior behavior NOUN 9593tt46s16 19 17 in in ADP 9593tt46s16 19 18 lottery lottery NOUN 9593tt46s16 19 19 cases case NOUN 9593tt46s16 19 20 and and CCONJ 9593tt46s16 19 21 the the DET 9593tt46s16 19 22 beginnings beginning NOUN 9593tt46s16 19 23 of of ADP 9593tt46s16 19 24 a a DET 9593tt46s16 19 25 middle middle ADJ 9593tt46s16 19 26 - - PUNCT 9593tt46s16 19 27 ground ground NOUN 9593tt46s16 19 28 position position NOUN 9593tt46s16 19 29 between between ADP 9593tt46s16 19 30 contextualism contextualism NOUN 9593tt46s16 19 31 and and CCONJ 9593tt46s16 19 32 traditional traditional ADJ 9593tt46s16 19 33 epistemology epistemology NOUN 9593tt46s16 19 34 . . PUNCT