id sid tid token lemma pos 8p58pc30b46 1 1 this this DET 8p58pc30b46 1 2 thesis thesis NOUN 8p58pc30b46 1 3 is be AUX 8p58pc30b46 1 4 a a DET 8p58pc30b46 1 5 critical critical ADJ 8p58pc30b46 1 6 examination examination NOUN 8p58pc30b46 1 7 of of ADP 8p58pc30b46 1 8 structured structured ADJ 8p58pc30b46 1 9 propositionalism propositionalism NOUN 8p58pc30b46 1 10 ( ( PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 1 11 sp sp NOUN 8p58pc30b46 1 12 ) ) PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 1 13 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 1 14 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 1 15 view view NOUN 8p58pc30b46 1 16 that that SCONJ 8p58pc30b46 1 17 propositions proposition NOUN 8p58pc30b46 1 18 are be AUX 8p58pc30b46 1 19 complex complex ADJ 8p58pc30b46 1 20 entities entity NOUN 8p58pc30b46 1 21 composed compose VERB 8p58pc30b46 1 22 of of ADP 8p58pc30b46 1 23 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 1 24 semantic semantic ADJ 8p58pc30b46 1 25 values value NOUN 8p58pc30b46 1 26 of of ADP 8p58pc30b46 1 27 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 1 28 ( ( PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 1 29 meaningful meaningful ADJ 8p58pc30b46 1 30 ) ) PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 1 31 parts part NOUN 8p58pc30b46 1 32 of of ADP 8p58pc30b46 1 33 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 1 34 sentences sentence NOUN 8p58pc30b46 1 35 that that PRON 8p58pc30b46 1 36 express express VERB 8p58pc30b46 1 37 them they PRON 8p58pc30b46 1 38 . . PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 2 1 according accord VERB 8p58pc30b46 2 2 to to ADP 8p58pc30b46 2 3 sp sp NOUN 8p58pc30b46 2 4 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 2 5 propositions proposition NOUN 8p58pc30b46 2 6 have have VERB 8p58pc30b46 2 7 constituents constituent NOUN 8p58pc30b46 2 8 and and CCONJ 8p58pc30b46 2 9 are be AUX 8p58pc30b46 2 10 individuated individuate VERB 8p58pc30b46 2 11 by by ADP 8p58pc30b46 2 12 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 2 13 identity identity NOUN 8p58pc30b46 2 14 and and CCONJ 8p58pc30b46 2 15 arrangement arrangement NOUN 8p58pc30b46 2 16 of of ADP 8p58pc30b46 2 17 their their PRON 8p58pc30b46 2 18 constituents constituent NOUN 8p58pc30b46 2 19 . . PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 3 1 two two NUM 8p58pc30b46 3 2 questions question NOUN 8p58pc30b46 3 3 face face VERB 8p58pc30b46 3 4 advocates advocate NOUN 8p58pc30b46 3 5 of of ADP 8p58pc30b46 3 6 structured structured ADJ 8p58pc30b46 3 7 propositionalism propositionalism NOUN 8p58pc30b46 3 8 . . PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 4 1 first first ADV 8p58pc30b46 4 2 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 4 3 what what PRON 8p58pc30b46 4 4 does do AUX 8p58pc30b46 4 5 it it PRON 8p58pc30b46 4 6 mean mean VERB 8p58pc30b46 4 7 to to PART 8p58pc30b46 4 8 say say VERB 8p58pc30b46 4 9 that that SCONJ 8p58pc30b46 4 10 propositions proposition NOUN 8p58pc30b46 4 11 are be AUX 8p58pc30b46 4 12 structured structure VERB 8p58pc30b46 4 13 and and CCONJ 8p58pc30b46 4 14 have have VERB 8p58pc30b46 4 15 constituents constituent NOUN 8p58pc30b46 4 16 ? ? PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 5 1 and and CCONJ 8p58pc30b46 5 2 second second ADV 8p58pc30b46 5 3 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 5 4 why why SCONJ 8p58pc30b46 5 5 think think VERB 8p58pc30b46 5 6 that that SCONJ 8p58pc30b46 5 7 propositions proposition NOUN 8p58pc30b46 5 8 have have VERB 8p58pc30b46 5 9 these these DET 8p58pc30b46 5 10 properties property NOUN 8p58pc30b46 5 11 ? ? PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 6 1 these these PRON 8p58pc30b46 6 2 are be AUX 8p58pc30b46 6 3 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 6 4 primary primary ADJ 8p58pc30b46 6 5 questions question NOUN 8p58pc30b46 6 6 i i PRON 8p58pc30b46 6 7 address address VERB 8p58pc30b46 6 8 in in ADP 8p58pc30b46 6 9 this this DET 8p58pc30b46 6 10 thesis thesis NOUN 8p58pc30b46 6 11 . . PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 7 1 given give VERB 8p58pc30b46 7 2 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 7 3 deficiency deficiency NOUN 8p58pc30b46 7 4 of of ADP 8p58pc30b46 7 5 contemporary contemporary ADJ 8p58pc30b46 7 6 attempts attempt NOUN 8p58pc30b46 7 7 to to PART 8p58pc30b46 7 8 answer answer VERB 8p58pc30b46 7 9 these these DET 8p58pc30b46 7 10 questions question NOUN 8p58pc30b46 7 11 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 7 12 three three NUM 8p58pc30b46 7 13 chapters chapter NOUN 8p58pc30b46 7 14 are be AUX 8p58pc30b46 7 15 spent spend VERB 8p58pc30b46 7 16 examining examine VERB 8p58pc30b46 7 17 historical historical ADJ 8p58pc30b46 7 18 accounts account NOUN 8p58pc30b46 7 19 of of ADP 8p58pc30b46 7 20 structured structured ADJ 8p58pc30b46 7 21 truth truth NOUN 8p58pc30b46 7 22 - - PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 7 23 bearers bearer NOUN 8p58pc30b46 7 24 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 7 25 going go VERB 8p58pc30b46 7 26 back back ADV 8p58pc30b46 7 27 to to ADP 8p58pc30b46 7 28 plato plato NOUN 8p58pc30b46 7 29 's 's PART 8p58pc30b46 7 30 theaetetus theaetetus NOUN 8p58pc30b46 7 31 and and CCONJ 8p58pc30b46 7 32 sophist sophist ADJ 8p58pc30b46 7 33 . . PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 8 1 i i PRON 8p58pc30b46 8 2 argue argue VERB 8p58pc30b46 8 3 that that SCONJ 8p58pc30b46 8 4 an an DET 8p58pc30b46 8 5 important important ADJ 8p58pc30b46 8 6 reason reason NOUN 8p58pc30b46 8 7 for for ADP 8p58pc30b46 8 8 sp sp NOUN 8p58pc30b46 8 9 's 's PART 8p58pc30b46 8 10 wide wide ADJ 8p58pc30b46 8 11 acceptance acceptance NOUN 8p58pc30b46 8 12 is be AUX 8p58pc30b46 8 13 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 8 14 historical historical ADJ 8p58pc30b46 8 15 ubiquity ubiquity NOUN 8p58pc30b46 8 16 of of ADP 8p58pc30b46 8 17 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 8 18 view view NOUN 8p58pc30b46 8 19 that that SCONJ 8p58pc30b46 8 20 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 8 21 fundamental fundamental ADJ 8p58pc30b46 8 22 truth truth NOUN 8p58pc30b46 8 23 - - PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 8 24 bearers bearer NOUN 8p58pc30b46 8 25 are be AUX 8p58pc30b46 8 26 sentential sentential ADJ 8p58pc30b46 8 27 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 8 28 and and CCONJ 8p58pc30b46 8 29 thus thus ADV 8p58pc30b46 8 30 obviously obviously ADV 8p58pc30b46 8 31 structured structure VERB 8p58pc30b46 8 32 . . PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 9 1 after after ADP 8p58pc30b46 9 2 presenting present VERB 8p58pc30b46 9 3 historical historical ADJ 8p58pc30b46 9 4 accounts account NOUN 8p58pc30b46 9 5 of of ADP 8p58pc30b46 9 6 structured structured ADJ 8p58pc30b46 9 7 truth truth NOUN 8p58pc30b46 9 8 - - PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 9 9 bearers bearer NOUN 8p58pc30b46 9 10 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 9 11 with with ADP 8p58pc30b46 9 12 a a DET 8p58pc30b46 9 13 focus focus NOUN 8p58pc30b46 9 14 on on ADP 8p58pc30b46 9 15 frege frege NOUN 8p58pc30b46 9 16 's 's PART 8p58pc30b46 9 17 and and CCONJ 8p58pc30b46 9 18 russell russell PROPN 8p58pc30b46 9 19 's 's PART 8p58pc30b46 9 20 influential influential ADJ 8p58pc30b46 9 21 versions version NOUN 8p58pc30b46 9 22 of of ADP 8p58pc30b46 9 23 sp sp NOUN 8p58pc30b46 9 24 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 9 25 i i PRON 8p58pc30b46 9 26 present present VERB 8p58pc30b46 9 27 some some DET 8p58pc30b46 9 28 objections objection NOUN 8p58pc30b46 9 29 to to ADP 8p58pc30b46 9 30 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 9 31 application application NOUN 8p58pc30b46 9 32 of of ADP 8p58pc30b46 9 33 mereological mereological ADJ 8p58pc30b46 9 34 notions notion NOUN 8p58pc30b46 9 35 to to PART 8p58pc30b46 9 36 abstracta abstracta VERB 8p58pc30b46 9 37 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 9 38 with with ADP 8p58pc30b46 9 39 an an DET 8p58pc30b46 9 40 emphasis emphasis NOUN 8p58pc30b46 9 41 on on ADP 8p58pc30b46 9 42 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 9 43 difficulties difficulty NOUN 8p58pc30b46 9 44 for for ADP 8p58pc30b46 9 45 providing provide VERB 8p58pc30b46 9 46 a a DET 8p58pc30b46 9 47 metaphysics metaphysics NOUN 8p58pc30b46 9 48 of of ADP 8p58pc30b46 9 49 propositional propositional ADJ 8p58pc30b46 9 50 constituency constituency NOUN 8p58pc30b46 9 51 . . PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 10 1 i i PRON 8p58pc30b46 10 2 discuss discuss VERB 8p58pc30b46 10 3 five five NUM 8p58pc30b46 10 4 approaches approach NOUN 8p58pc30b46 10 5 and and CCONJ 8p58pc30b46 10 6 show show VERB 8p58pc30b46 10 7 that that SCONJ 8p58pc30b46 10 8 all all PRON 8p58pc30b46 10 9 of of ADP 8p58pc30b46 10 10 them they PRON 8p58pc30b46 10 11 face face VERB 8p58pc30b46 10 12 serious serious ADJ 8p58pc30b46 10 13 problems problem NOUN 8p58pc30b46 10 14 . . PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 11 1 these these DET 8p58pc30b46 11 2 problems problem NOUN 8p58pc30b46 11 3 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 11 4 while while SCONJ 8p58pc30b46 11 5 perhaps perhaps ADV 8p58pc30b46 11 6 not not PART 8p58pc30b46 11 7 insurmountable insurmountable ADJ 8p58pc30b46 11 8 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 11 9 shift shift VERB 8p58pc30b46 11 10 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 11 11 burden burden NOUN 8p58pc30b46 11 12 of of ADP 8p58pc30b46 11 13 argument argument NOUN 8p58pc30b46 11 14 to to ADP 8p58pc30b46 11 15 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 11 16 proponents proponent NOUN 8p58pc30b46 11 17 of of ADP 8p58pc30b46 11 18 sp sp PROPN 8p58pc30b46 11 19 . . PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 12 1 i i PRON 8p58pc30b46 12 2 then then ADV 8p58pc30b46 12 3 argue argue VERB 8p58pc30b46 12 4 that that SCONJ 8p58pc30b46 12 5 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 12 6 required require VERB 8p58pc30b46 12 7 arguments argument NOUN 8p58pc30b46 12 8 have have AUX 8p58pc30b46 12 9 not not PART 8p58pc30b46 12 10 been be AUX 8p58pc30b46 12 11 given give VERB 8p58pc30b46 12 12 . . PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 13 1 in in ADP 8p58pc30b46 13 2 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 13 3 penultimate penultimate ADJ 8p58pc30b46 13 4 chapter chapter NOUN 8p58pc30b46 13 5 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 13 6 i i PRON 8p58pc30b46 13 7 evaluate evaluate VERB 8p58pc30b46 13 8 six six NUM 8p58pc30b46 13 9 arguments argument NOUN 8p58pc30b46 13 10 for for ADP 8p58pc30b46 13 11 sp sp NOUN 8p58pc30b46 13 12 : : PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 13 13 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 13 14 compositionality compositionality NOUN 8p58pc30b46 13 15 argument argument NOUN 8p58pc30b46 13 16 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 13 17 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 13 18 logical logical ADJ 8p58pc30b46 13 19 form form NOUN 8p58pc30b46 13 20 argument argument NOUN 8p58pc30b46 13 21 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 13 22 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 13 23 argument argument NOUN 8p58pc30b46 13 24 from from ADP 8p58pc30b46 13 25 analyticity analyticity NOUN 8p58pc30b46 13 26 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 13 27 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 13 28 similarity similarity NOUN 8p58pc30b46 13 29 argument argument NOUN 8p58pc30b46 13 30 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 13 31 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 13 32 direct direct ADJ 8p58pc30b46 13 33 reference reference NOUN 8p58pc30b46 13 34 argument argument NOUN 8p58pc30b46 13 35 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 13 36 and and CCONJ 8p58pc30b46 13 37 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 13 38 language language NOUN 8p58pc30b46 13 39 - - PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 13 40 based base VERB 8p58pc30b46 13 41 argument argument NOUN 8p58pc30b46 13 42 . . PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 14 1 these these DET 8p58pc30b46 14 2 arguments argument NOUN 8p58pc30b46 14 3 are be AUX 8p58pc30b46 14 4 based base VERB 8p58pc30b46 14 5 on on ADP 8p58pc30b46 14 6 suggestions suggestion NOUN 8p58pc30b46 14 7 in in ADP 8p58pc30b46 14 8 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 14 9 historical historical ADJ 8p58pc30b46 14 10 literature literature NOUN 8p58pc30b46 14 11 ' ' PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 14 12 primarily primarily ADV 8p58pc30b46 14 13 from from ADP 8p58pc30b46 14 14 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 14 15 early early ADJ 8p58pc30b46 14 16 analytic analytic ADJ 8p58pc30b46 14 17 philosophers philosopher NOUN 8p58pc30b46 14 18 ' ' PART 8p58pc30b46 14 19 and and CCONJ 8p58pc30b46 14 20 enthymemes enthymeme NOUN 8p58pc30b46 14 21 in in ADP 8p58pc30b46 14 22 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 14 23 contemporary contemporary ADJ 8p58pc30b46 14 24 literature literature NOUN 8p58pc30b46 14 25 . . PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 15 1 i i PRON 8p58pc30b46 15 2 conclude conclude VERB 8p58pc30b46 15 3 that that SCONJ 8p58pc30b46 15 4 none none NOUN 8p58pc30b46 15 5 of of ADP 8p58pc30b46 15 6 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 15 7 arguments argument NOUN 8p58pc30b46 15 8 makes make VERB 8p58pc30b46 15 9 a a DET 8p58pc30b46 15 10 compelling compelling ADJ 8p58pc30b46 15 11 case case NOUN 8p58pc30b46 15 12 for for ADP 8p58pc30b46 15 13 sp sp NOUN 8p58pc30b46 15 14 . . PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 16 1 in in ADP 8p58pc30b46 16 2 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 16 3 final final ADJ 8p58pc30b46 16 4 chapter chapter NOUN 8p58pc30b46 16 5 i i PRON 8p58pc30b46 16 6 examine examine VERB 8p58pc30b46 16 7 two two NUM 8p58pc30b46 16 8 versions version NOUN 8p58pc30b46 16 9 of of ADP 8p58pc30b46 16 10 sp sp NOUN 8p58pc30b46 16 11 recently recently ADV 8p58pc30b46 16 12 advocated advocate VERB 8p58pc30b46 16 13 by by ADP 8p58pc30b46 16 14 scott scott PROPN 8p58pc30b46 16 15 soames soame NOUN 8p58pc30b46 16 16 and and CCONJ 8p58pc30b46 16 17 jeffrey jeffrey PROPN 8p58pc30b46 16 18 king king PROPN 8p58pc30b46 16 19 . . PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 17 1 i i PRON 8p58pc30b46 17 2 argue argue VERB 8p58pc30b46 17 3 that that SCONJ 8p58pc30b46 17 4 ' ' PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 17 5 propositions proposition NOUN 8p58pc30b46 17 6 ' ' PUNCT 8p58pc30b46 17 7 of of ADP 8p58pc30b46 17 8 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 17 9 kind kind NOUN 8p58pc30b46 17 10 postulated postulate VERB 8p58pc30b46 17 11 by by ADP 8p58pc30b46 17 12 these these DET 8p58pc30b46 17 13 theories theory NOUN 8p58pc30b46 17 14 are be AUX 8p58pc30b46 17 15 unable unable ADJ 8p58pc30b46 17 16 to to PART 8p58pc30b46 17 17 play play VERB 8p58pc30b46 17 18 some some PRON 8p58pc30b46 17 19 of of ADP 8p58pc30b46 17 20 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 17 21 fundamental fundamental ADJ 8p58pc30b46 17 22 roles role NOUN 8p58pc30b46 17 23 that that PRON 8p58pc30b46 17 24 motivate motivate VERB 8p58pc30b46 17 25 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 17 26 postulation postulation NOUN 8p58pc30b46 17 27 of of ADP 8p58pc30b46 17 28 propositions proposition NOUN 8p58pc30b46 17 29 in in ADP 8p58pc30b46 17 30 the the DET 8p58pc30b46 17 31 first first ADJ 8p58pc30b46 17 32 place place NOUN 8p58pc30b46 17 33 . . PUNCT